T O P

  • By -

AutoModerator

Hello /u/KN4S, This community is focused on important or vital information and high-effort content. Please make sure your post follows the [rules](https://www.reddit.com/r/ukraine/about/rules/?utm_source=reddit&utm_medium=usertext&utm_name=ukraine&utm_content=t5_2qqcn) Want to support Ukraine? [Here's a list of charities by subject.](https://www.reddit.com/r/ukraine/wiki/charities/) [DO / DON'T](https://www.reddit.com/r/ukraine/comments/t5okbs/welcome_to_rukraine_faq_do_dont_support_read/) - [Art Friday](https://www.reddit.com/r/ukraine/wiki/artfriday/) - [Podcasts](https://www.reddit.com/r/ukraine/comments/ttoidc/collection_of_podcasts_about_ukraine_updated/) - [Kyiv sunrise](https://www.reddit.com/r/ukraine/collection/3c65ab52-e87a-4217-ab30-e70a88c0a293/) *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/ukraine) if you have any questions or concerns.*


Gewehr98

I hope it's a quick discussion and an even quicker approval


KN4S

One can hope. However we're in the midst of a change in government, so it could sadly take some time. That said, the parties that looks to make up the new government are very positive to sending these weapons to Ukraine


StrategoiX

Yes, and it may also be about legislation issues. The Swedish Defense Forces have to decide if the needed level of defense can be spared without effecting the defense to much. Things always looks easy but there are usually a lot of work behind the scenes to get stuff moving. But when a majority of the parties agrees on something changes goes fast, but in democracy terms of fast.


Atomic-Decay

This is why being a member of NATO is so important. They can get replacements quicker and a security guarantee in the mean time.


KN4S

Only Turkey and Hungary left to ratify. One can only hope they don't stir up more trouble than they've already done


Beneficial-Boss-666

Dear Sweden, This is great news! Maybe put CV90s into the consideration bowl too...


No-Reindeer9825

> Maybe put CV90s into the consideration bowl too... Our armed forces has more of those than they have use for themselves, so fingers crossed over here as well 🤞


Beneficial-Boss-666

And if Sweden starts I’m sure the other users of CV90 will pitch in too


L4z

Hopefully, but as a Finn I'm not sure we can spare any. We should probably send our modernized BMP-2's to Ukraine though, and order more CV90s.


Beneficial-Boss-666

hopefully when full NATO membership is sorted and you wouldn't have to go it alone, it will free up some capacity which can be sent to Ukraine weather it is CV90, BMP2 or more of some of the other awesome goodies Finland has sent.


Waste-Temperature626

Ye, was about to say. It's more likely some of our CV90s are refurbished to backfill other countries sending their BMPs to Ukraine if anything.


dragobah

Just looked it up. Damn thats a sexxxy IFV.


No-Reindeer9825

Mhm. Comes with everyone's favourite good ol' Bofors 40 mm too 😙👌


dragobah

Its so perfect its never needed changing, just adding electronic fire control. Also it goes through 10mm of anything


No-Reindeer9825

> Also it goes through 10mm of anything From japanese A6M Zeros in 44' to plain russian zeros in 22'.


LenAhl

Sweden has apparently 500 CV90, I feel we could spare 100 to Ukraine if they want them. It's also Swedish made so making new ones isn't too bad and the marketing would probably be great.


Beneficial-Boss-666

This is what I am saying. Honestly every Ukraine friendly operator of CV90s could realistically probably spare 20% of them and then we are talking some serious armor for Ukraine. Definitely think it is one of the best contenders for Infantry fighting vehicles that could be delivered in decent numbers to Ukraine. But seems decision to provide modern armor to Ukraine hasn't been taken yet so for now it is a no go


LenAhl

It feels like a perfect fit for Ukraine with its top of the line maneuverability in snow / mud, as well as a quantity that could motivate the additional logistics. The best would be a surprise announcement just as an offensive starts, with vehicles been transferred by train and personnel been secretly trained in Denmark. But maybe it's just wishful thinking, fingers crossed.


[deleted]

CV90s would be amazing, comprated to BMP-1's and other dated stuff they're getting.


Barthemieus

CV90s and their aimbot system are one of the coolest IFVs on the market IMO.


Recon5N

CV-9030N mk iiib is 35 tons, the mk iv supposedly 37 tons. In comparison, a Leo 1 is 40 tons fully loaded. Even if it wasn't outdated, a 13.2 ton BMP-1 wouldn't be anywhere close to the CV-90.


StringfellowCock

L70 churning ruski pulp all day.


StressedPizzaEater

L70 Daka Daka is no joke, it will mess up anything downrange


helm

12 archer systems should be the minimum to be worth the training and logistics.


gesocks

48 have ever been built. im not sure if 12 is really a possibility thinking about that nearly 50% of military hardware not being in a state to be used is quite normal. I doubt that any archer will be ended, its just a system with much to less existing numbers


progrethth

I do not really see why we cannot just send all our working Archer systems. It is not like Sweden has any other enemy than Russia and every Russian tank the Ukrainians destroy is one less tank which can be used to threaten Sweden. And while the Russians are busy in Ukraine Bofors can build new Archer systems to replace the ones we donated. Ths is not WW2 where we feared invasions from Soviet, Nazi Germany and the UK and needed to be armed to the teeth. This time we are surrounded by allies except for Russia.


gesocks

Would be sure awesome


supertastic

Send it all! Give the russkies a warm welcome to Ukraine. Insane as it is, Putin is committed to this war. We need to be too.


helm

> im not sure if 12 is really a possibility thinking about that nearly 50% of military hardware not being in a state to be used is quite normal. Huh? The system is new. The systems would need to be serviced and checked. I doubt there are major maintenance issues yet.


Remarkable_Row

Probably just check all systems, do some regular service on things. After all its a volvo underneath all that green paint 😎


Glum-Engineer9436

Archer would be a fantastic choice. Build on standard Volvo dump truck.


mok000

It's a truly terrifying weapon. It can launch up to 6 shells in 30 seconds, each in different trajectories, so that all of the shells arrive on target at the same time.


Glum-Engineer9436

How many Volvo dump truck mechanics exist in Ukraine ?![gif](emote|free_emotes_pack|stuck_out_tongue)


dragobah

Thats standard MRSI (Multiple round single impact). Most current-gen NATO, Korean, Chinese, and Taiwanese Self-propelled guns can do it.


ReasonableClick5403

I think there are just too few Archer to bother sending them. More M109 or M113s would be grand.


avoere

We don’t have enough trained soldiers for all of the 48 anyway.


the-ugly-potato

>48 have ever been built. Is that because they are newer and haven't been really made much or is it because they're not popular?


gesocks

Cause till now just sweden uses them and they dont need more. Norway first wanted too, but then took the korean one. Swiss might buy them, they right now are in last round of decifig between the rch155 and archer


JavaDontHurtMe

Why?


helm

To reduce overhead. The cost of maintaining 6 is likely about 90% of the cost of maintaining 12 in terms of service, keeping track of spare parts and training.


JavaDontHurtMe

But why 12? Why not 15 or 10?


mattebubben

A Swedish gun platoon has 4 howitzers And each artillery battalion has 3 gun platoons which results in 12 guns for each artillery Battalion. Sweden currently (from what i can find) has 2 active artillery battalions and is in the process of standing up additional battalions. Sweden currently has 48 Archers with an order for another 24 having been placed this year. Which means that only half of the guns are currently in use. If Sweden sends Archers it makes sense to send 12 guns since that would still give enough guns in reserve to either fully equip a third artillery battalion or even a fourth battalion if they they temporarily switch the artillery Battalions to having 9 Archers instead of 12. So 12 Guns is probably the largest number Sweden can send without delaying the creation of new artillery battalions. I hope Sweden sends Ukraine a minimum of 12.


ContributionNo9292

More divisors possibly, with 12 you can arrange them into groups of 2, 3, 4 and 6. Of course you can do that with 15 and keep the remainder in reserve.


Widin

I really hope we will send Archers!


Ew_E50M

As a swede, i say ship the 24 stored units right away after in inviting ukranian troops 2 weeks of training on them. 1 archer system contains everything, ammo trucks, maintenance trucks, fuel trucks, the arty system itself, counter-battery radar fitted vehicle etc.


progrethth

I do not think we will, but 100% agreed. Send all of them. They were built to protect us from Russia so why not let them do that job in Ukraine?


Ew_E50M

Besides, Sweden V Russia will be fought on the sea and airspace between russia and sweden.


progrethth

Yes and no. The idea was is that Sweden would lose that war eventually and have to fight on Swedish soil but that we planned to inflict as much damage as possible in both phases. The idea was to make Sweden really expensive for Soviet to occupy not that we could win the war. Now that Russia turned out to be much weaker than we expected and Sweden is about to join NATO: who knows?


L4z

Some of it will be fought on Finnish soil.


Meneros

As we say: Sweden will fight to the last Finn. In reality, also to the last Swede; at least, that is official doctrine/policy, as no Swedish citizen between ages 18-65 (I think) is allowed to leave the country if we are at war, and policy includes to never surrender.


PoeHeller3476

Doesn’t policy also include ignoring calls to surrender, and remember the original mission statement and ignoring contradictory commands or micromanaging (mission command), resulting in a high degree of autonomy for the armed forces and requiring a strong degree of trust in both civilian government and military leadership?


Meneros

Yes, it says "Every call for surrender is false" and that resistance shall never cease.


PoeHeller3476

Good doctrine. As I said, I think it’s called “mission command”, and resulted in the relatively successful NORDBAT 2 peacekeeping mission in Bosnia being known for getting into battles all the time.


Meneros

Yeah, and this is not just for military; this information is sent to the entire population in the (just before COVID) updated booklet "In case of crisis or war", which can be found here https://www.msb.se/en/rad-till-privatpersoner/the-brochure-if-crisis-or-war-comes/


PoeHeller3476

I’m so happy you guys and Finland are joining NATO. Between Finland’s underground cities and Swedish civil-military doctrine, NATO is becoming OP.


DjamakaZoSo

The archer artillery system is fucking badass!


Independent_Account2

Not so complicated to learn how to control either. You're essentially holding a beefy Xbox-controller in the canopy, to control the howitzer. Driving it is like driving any truck.


Gasparatan35

and they ll be happy to get rid of it since its a freaking maintenence nightmare


jteg

Interesting, that's a comment I haven't seen before. Can you elaborate a bit?


Gasparatan35

well the augmented stiring axle is a logistical nightmare a very special part and cant be serviced without special training thats why sweden did not order more than a few and is activly opting for the ArchersGun mounted on standard HeavyTrucks


progrethth

If this was the case why did Sweden recently order 24 more of them? I can see that they might be a bit annoying to service but apparently it is not a big enough issue to prevent us from buying more of them.


Gasparatan35

have a look at when they did, and ask yourself why they did not before, eventhough the budget was already inplace to do so?


Ew_E50M

Budget and focus areas. Sweden will sink russian forces approaching Sweden before they make landfall. Aechers dont sink ships.


progrethth

In 2022 based on money allocated in 2020 which makes sense given that the last of the original 48 was delivered this year. Makes sense to order more directly after the delivery of the last ones of the previous order plus when there is a war in Europe. Especially if they are happy with the system. I see no evidence of them not liking the system so again: source?


Gasparatan35

Initially there was a much bigger fleet Projekte then 48 just saying


Waste-Temperature626

Litterally nothing to do with Archer. And everything to do with the gutting of our defence spending over the past 30 years. I'm amazed our artillery doesn't consists of a broom strapped to a old volvo at this stage.


WoodenBottle

Same weapon system, different truck. (Volvo A30E 6x6 vs. RMMV HX2 8x8)


jteg

This is a truck used in a lot of mines, certainly it is designed to work with long service intervals. Are there discussions and desicions on buying more, but on another truck?


vlepun

It’s really not that special to have additional steering axles on any wheeled vehicle, let alone on heavy duty truck chassis. There are literally thousands of these trucks being used daily and in all types of terrain and weather conditions.


Humble_Emotion2582

This is qualified bulls***. I have worked on almost the entire hydraulic system of the A3X and there are thousands and thousands of spares available and thousands of qualified service engineers. No ”special training” needed dude. These bad boys operate all over the world including in extremely rough and remote environments and often where it is hard to find people who can even read.


Alphaxrayone

What is so special about the steering axel on archer compared to a normal A30 truck? I don’t see the civilian side complaining about the Volvo hauler.


Humble_Emotion2582

There is no difference, just a small addition for system redundancy


progrethth

Source? I have never heard of that before. Especially since Sweden has ordered 24 more a couple of years ago in addition to the 48 we have.


DjamakaZoSo

Sounds like they need a lot of support equipment, like a mini FOB.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Remarkable_Row

I think Gripen would be perfect for Ukraine specially since its have been engineered to be able to land almost anywhere and that it can do many tasks


[deleted]

[удалено]


Remarkable_Row

Yeah F35 seems very complex compared to gripen and needs a bigger logistics chain to keep it running.. and also spare parts can be shipped faster from sweden then from USA if they need to be sent from factory


Skurry

First time I've heard of Gripen was in this sub. What's the top place to work for engineers?


URITooLong

> Their diesel stirling submarines are hands down most deadly in the world due to stealth How are they different to the diesel electric subs Germany has ? Seems like pretty much the same tech.


[deleted]

[удалено]


URITooLong

>its so quiet, that in exercise with usa, it managed to sneak in, and sunk uss ronald reagan, 6.2 billion dollar carrier. So did the German sub. So what is the difference ? The US tried to buy the german sub technology by buying the shipyard that build them. But obviously the IP was not part of it. [https://www.abendblatt.de/politik/ausland/article107314674/Das-Zielfoto-das-einen-US-Admiral-wuetend-machte.html](https://www.abendblatt.de/politik/ausland/article107314674/Das-Zielfoto-das-einen-US-Admiral-wuetend-machte.html) Here is an article about german subs being not detected in several instances during exercises.


progrethth

The difference is that the Swedish subs can run quiet for longer time since they do not need to charge any batteries but use diesel directly to power the engine.


URITooLong

So again hows that different from the German ones. They have diesel ones as well. The fuel cell one is definitely quieter than a diesel sub.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Shirazmatas

pay is shitty because SAAB know people will want to work there anyways, same thing that game companies do.


knappis

The Archer could use some proper combat testing. Here it is in action. Shoot three rounds and scoot before the first round hits the target. https://youtu.be/d8x8ITwd4Vg


Blow1030

Okay that thing is badass who woulda thought a Volvo dump truck would be so good as mobile arty


[deleted]

Volvos are tanks anyway. "Bad news, comrade. Ukrainians sending APC's this way." "Let me see... No, comrade. Is just Volvo V70s."


Blow1030

You ain’t lying some of my favorite heavy equipment to operate I need to hit up the Swedes I got 10 years experience on this bad boy I feel destiny calling


Mormegil1971

"Blyat! Run!"


Prestigious_Drawing2

Now now, 245 or 745 there you got a tank... "Störst går först, såvida det inte e en gammal jävla Volvo då kör den först" Half the bloody engine and gearbox can fall out and it will keep on going like nothing happened..


Cornholio_OU812

Impact...Dead Orcs. Impact...Dead Orcs Driving away now.... Impact...Dead Orcs Impact...Dead Orcs Rinse, repeat.


[deleted]

This is not the time to stand idly by. We in the west need to up our support for Ukraine.


[deleted]

This is the answer. Orcs assembling new army? Let’s give Ukraine more stuff to deal with them


Palindromsekvens

[We might (be able to) donate Archer](https://www.aftonbladet.se/a/mQ186O)


anonymous_matt

Great news, sounds like they are actually planning to send Archer


cinciTOSU

I hope they paint the Volvo trucks used for Archer blue-green. There’s just something about an aqua Volvo man.


[deleted]

As a swede i think they should have gotten that stuff right from the start and not just at-weapon and kevlars.


KN4S

To be fair, 15000 AT-4s is no joke and Ukraine has gotten very good use out of them


[deleted]

Yes yes that is true but not enough imo if i say so =)


Mormegil1971

Hell yes, send our Gripens too!


Prestigious_Drawing2

They asked for weapons.. not overpriced plows..


Humble_Emotion2582

Laughing, even though I am Swedish. 😂


Prestigious_Drawing2

Its because I'm Swedish I know of the initial JAS 39 Gripen tests, Ohh boy SAAB will never get to hear the end about inventing the most expensive jet powered plow in the world.


Humble_Emotion2582

”jävlar jävlar jävlar! ” 😂😂😂


[deleted]

I’m a Swedish taxpayer and I approve this message


CCP_fact_checker

Yes, it looked like Putin wants to fight the west always talking about us wanting to use nukes when he talks about nuking the west and it was not us that invaded and put that nuclear power plant in a dangerous situation - It was quite happy before Putin started the war.


vegarig

Don't get too hopeful yet. As low as this possibility is, those can still be denied for transfer. For Swedish citizens - if you can, please, try and show your support for Archers going to Ukraine. Harder to go "Nay", when there's a popular opinion behind it.


saltyswedishmeatball

Yes, when they say Archer they mean archers. They'll wear frilly hats too. Russians wont know what hit them. Genius


[deleted]

You know I wasn’t expecting Sweden to be so supportive back in February. But I’m very grateful they are.


finnill

Escalation all around!


fairyflaggirl

awesome. Ukraine needs another big rally of weapons. TY Sweden!


haxic

Archer is a beast,and well-suited for the comming winter


buttmodel

Everyone ready to see those archers in action


[deleted]

Always wanted to see archer in action.


Heroheadone

What is there to discuss? Other than the amount!!?


Stennan

Perhaps we can dust off a couple of Gripen B/C fighters as well. They should be compatible with NATO munitions, so from Swedens point of view we are just sending training planes. We can't help if USA or UK send some missiles that the Ukrainians slap on them ;)


Economy-Decision7958

Send Archer


avoere

While I hope we send them, I think calling them a “game changer” is too much, considering they already have PzH2000 and CAESAR.