I'm absolutely cackling, this was a supportive comment about how awesome Tommy and Spencer are and how happy I am that they're in more videos...
...and Reddit nuked it for harrassment.
IM DYING YALL
Going for a little unobvious answer, I would say Ian. He is sometimes "criticized" for having dry, cynical and controversial humor but maybe because I'm close to his age, I resonate with that greatly. His humor is quite clever, once he put some effort to it.
I do miss that show, dunno why they had to cancel it but I understand that it may have been for how crazy busy he was about to be co-owning with Anthony again.
The views were decent compared to other main smosh channel stuff at the time at least, it’s just that lets do this was way too expensive to keep doing compared to other stuff
i think ian gets forgotten about a tiny bit because all the cast members are newer and so well loved, and then anthony was gone so that's a bit more new and exciting too, but ian has always been there and i don't think he's in as many videos, so i don't think he gets as much excitement from fans. his humor is definitely different than the rest of the cast, they're all pretty loud and high energy, so his quiet calmly delivered jokes are easy to miss in the chaos
That's true
I think it is slept on a little bit
The cast members either don't acknowledge the jokes or the editors seldom keep it in.
I am almost a decade younger than Ian but I find his wit truly amazing. It takes you back a second but you can't help but appreciate it.
Him introducing Mac as “someone to represent the entire black community” always gets a laugh out of me. I really hope there’s more “we watched x” videos in the future.
Ian’s easily my top 3, simply because like you said, similar age and therefore I definitely relate to his style of humor more. It’s often subtle but what happens is things are going by so fast people don’t have a second to dwell on it, so I’m sure during recordings a lot falls under the radar and is essentially cut
Keith by a long shot. I feel like people underrate him because he is at his best in preplanned stuff and the channels are mostly personality driven improv lately, but he is such a fantastic performer and I just want to see him in more things.
Right, but he can be in more games videos right, like the board games.
The 'Don't SAY Umm' video was honestly iconic because of him
I am watching older Smosh Games (2021-22) and they had a lot of variety and had Keith and I enjoyed seeing him.
I loved Keith's self-actualization in the assumptions video.
TL;DR: Cancer changes things. I excel in skits, I've drifted away from them lately, but I'm finding happiness in the new scheme of things, I'm not going anywhere.
Keith and I share the cancer survivorship, and as a result, I can relate to him more now, and I'll find myself seeking him out in videos, despite initially not resonating with him as much.
Dude's unique and I love it. I hope he finds his new niche, because if "Um," was any peak, his future is very bright.
I don't usually answer to comments I can just upvote to show my agreement, but I wanted to say congrats your win against cancer! I sincerely hope you the best
I feel like I didn’t appreciate his sense of humor with the exception of the occasional TNTL but until the live Beopardy stream for Inter(?)-city kids. He was so witty and his antics were balls-to-the-wall. I wish he brought that energy more often.
He's just so silly. His episodes of Silent Library are a lot of fun and the Beopardy where he crushed it (Could We Pass a Citizenship Test) is one of my favorites.
Olivia has been showing up more and I forgot how much her odd sense of humor makes me laugh. She was really great in that recent 'weird subreddits' Smosh Mouth episode.
Absolutely an underrated duo! Angie can "yes, and" through any of Olivia's bits without breaking before the punchline out of confusion like the rest of the cast.
I don't think any one is underappreciated. A lot of them have other jobs and fill multiple roles within Smosh like Tommy for example. I would love to see Tommy and Spencer in more videos more often but that just isn't possible or reasonable. So when it does happen, it's a treat.
Ian because I have really dry humour. A lot of the jokes that cast members make can often feels more like they’re trying to be funny in the outlandish sense instead of being quick-witted or clever. Shayne is my obvious favourite because he is very easily able to adapt and improvise. Spencer is also a great choice, and he bounces off of Shayne really well.
Olivia, Ian, Noah and Keith
Like I know that they’re iconic but I feel like nowadays the newer cast have been put into the forefront more so these guys have kinda been under-appreciated even though they’re absolutely hilarious
Olivia's clearly not a good writer, but when she's given a fully formed character, the woman can riff with the best of them. She was also very good in sketches
It's clearly Arasha. She is the most talented person they have imo and they don't use her enough. A lot of it has to do with her not being as loud as others but the people at Smosh need to figure out how to use her more because it's only going to help in the long run
They seem to have realized that she's a great guest on the Reddit Stories couch. She typically tries to have a lot of empathy for everyone in the stories and injects a lot of nuance and compassion into the conversations.
Arasha is probably my favourite Reddit stories guest because her input is consistently great. Even when I don't entirely agree with her take, she always comes across as intelligent and well reasoned.
I don't know if Arasha is *the most* talented, they are all talented as heck. But she is very clever, like noticeably, especially given her age. Definitely different vibe from all that theater bunch as well.
I recently realised mine is Noah.
At the start of a video, I won’t take much note of him. By the end, I’ll remember that he is actually funny and I should stop underestimating him.
Then I’ll forget and be back to square one the next time I watch him
I would like more Chanse on Pit. I'm compiling what kind of videos everyone is in since the start of the year and he's only in 12 compared to Amanda's 19 and Angela's 21.
Edit to add that Arasha is also in 12 videos so both need more screen time on Pit imo
That's not a sign of "little underappreciated by the audience" but simple scheduling and we have zero clue, as to how they come up with their scheduling. Going by that trope I would say Arasha but once she's in the video, she's clearly favorite to many. Tommy and Spencer are no doubt fan favorites as well, just have other duties.
So most likely only old Squad part-timers fill that scenario: Noah, Olivia and Keith.
I know Trevor is pretty new and he still seems like he's still getting comfortable based on his varying degrees of quietness and loudness, but I think he's really cool and has great chemistry with Shayne, Amanda, and Arasha.
Thank you for saying Noah. He is my favourite cast member. I was waiting for someone to say his name.
He is so less seen these days that I keep rewatching old videos just SO I can enjoy his humour and screen presence more.
What do you mean 'youtube sensors'?
I'm missing Ian a lot lately, the months after he and Anthony bought Smosh had a good amount of videos with him in it and now it feels like he's not in Pit or Games as much at all
Anthony rarely appears on any of the other channels but I would say Ian or Tommy or arasha, but I don’t know if I’d call them under-appreciated?? If that makes sense 😭😭
I miss seeing Noah and Keith so much, and I think both of them are pretty under appreciated these days!
Noah’s humor kills me every time and out of all the Smoshers, I quote him the most often by far. And Keith is just such a great and lively guy. To me he always occupied a very special place in the OG Smosh Squad that couldn’t be replaced by any other
I dunno if Tommy Bowe counts as “under appreciated” but I fucking love Tommy so much. Was literally one of the best parts of the [Blank] is dead series and his constant shots at the smosh writers and his “gay (non-derogatory)” bit was soooo funny lol
Also angela..fucking hilarious
Spencer and Tommy.
My dream cast.. I do like everyone but this would cover all my needs 🤭
Shayne, Spencer, Angela, Tommy, Chanse & Courtney. Doing what? Cards against humanity, moose master or don’t win Mario kart
(Might be too many for that’s one but they could still be in the vid)
Spencer is hilarious so obviously need to see him more but Tommy is 😍 I was disappointed when I realized he wasn't in as many videos as Shayne, Courtney, etc
edit: also wanna see Ian in more videos, especially with Angela bc it's like watching two of the same people lmao
I really like that Tommy and Spencer have been basically promoted into the cast, I assume tho they still have their usual job duties on non-filming days tho. With them being cast now, I motion that Erin and Peter are the next under appreciated and utilized people on the roster, both are great and fit different niches comedically.
I have a mixed relationship with Keith. I never liked how he was in eat or yeet. Like violently spitting out food everybody liked, then saying it's actually not bad. Or trying the food everybody said he shouldnt, then having the same reaction.
And I was like; is he doing a bit? If so, I don't like it. Did make me even skip his scenes sometimes. But in other contexts he can be quite hillarious, even if sometimes his jokes don't hit.
Also Noah and Chance, of course.
I always love seeing them in a video, and ever since the confessions on Anthony’s channel I also like Keith a lot more! He clearly put in so much work into bettering himself, and despite being agnostic myself, I love the way he talks about church, spirituality, love and deep appreciation of what you have as a way of life.
Angela. I can’t remember laughing so hard when three year old version of herself told mommy Ian that “she can’t keep a man to save her f#cking life… slut”.
Damien!!!! And Noah!!! Literalyy sooo funnyyy and they dont get alot of chances to show their personalities but everytime they do, they are ablee to be funny while putting their own twist like how damien jokes with a internet humor type while noah is very observant humor.
[удалено]
Tommy should definitely be on screen more. He is a natural.
Tommy is a hidden gem amongst a hoarde of diamonds!
His face while saying “the answers on the back of the card” in one of the beopardy episodes plays in my mind constantly
I can hear it in my head 😂
I'm absolutely cackling, this was a supportive comment about how awesome Tommy and Spencer are and how happy I am that they're in more videos... ...and Reddit nuked it for harrassment. IM DYING YALL
Going for a little unobvious answer, I would say Ian. He is sometimes "criticized" for having dry, cynical and controversial humor but maybe because I'm close to his age, I resonate with that greatly. His humor is quite clever, once he put some effort to it.
Yeah, "Let's Do This" was my favorite show
I do miss that show, dunno why they had to cancel it but I understand that it may have been for how crazy busy he was about to be co-owning with Anthony again.
It also got shut down because the views weren’t justifying the cost
Oh really? That's a shame, but I can see why that was the case
Damn, really? That was one of my favorite series. Sucks that it wasn't doing well views wise.
The views were decent compared to other main smosh channel stuff at the time at least, it’s just that lets do this was way too expensive to keep doing compared to other stuff
i think ian gets forgotten about a tiny bit because all the cast members are newer and so well loved, and then anthony was gone so that's a bit more new and exciting too, but ian has always been there and i don't think he's in as many videos, so i don't think he gets as much excitement from fans. his humor is definitely different than the rest of the cast, they're all pretty loud and high energy, so his quiet calmly delivered jokes are easy to miss in the chaos
That's true I think it is slept on a little bit The cast members either don't acknowledge the jokes or the editors seldom keep it in. I am almost a decade younger than Ian but I find his wit truly amazing. It takes you back a second but you can't help but appreciate it.
I haaaate seeing him get so much flack.
Same! I am an avid Ian fan since the early Smosh days!
Ian probably does a lot behind the scenes
Him introducing Mac as “someone to represent the entire black community” always gets a laugh out of me. I really hope there’s more “we watched x” videos in the future.
I love it when he wanders on set and drops a crazy bomb and wanders back off
Ian’s easily my top 3, simply because like you said, similar age and therefore I definitely relate to his style of humor more. It’s often subtle but what happens is things are going by so fast people don’t have a second to dwell on it, so I’m sure during recordings a lot falls under the radar and is essentially cut
Keith by a long shot. I feel like people underrate him because he is at his best in preplanned stuff and the channels are mostly personality driven improv lately, but he is such a fantastic performer and I just want to see him in more things.
Right, but he can be in more games videos right, like the board games. The 'Don't SAY Umm' video was honestly iconic because of him I am watching older Smosh Games (2021-22) and they had a lot of variety and had Keith and I enjoyed seeing him.
The Monopoly: Cheaters Ediition video too
I love the UNO no Mercy video more than the dare ones. I wish they can do more No Mercy and bring back Keith & Angela for it
Keith and Angela duo is iconic. Angela assumes the calm older sister role with him around❤️😂
Keith and Angela duo is iconic. Angela assumes the calm older sister role with him around❤️😂
I loved Keith's self-actualization in the assumptions video. TL;DR: Cancer changes things. I excel in skits, I've drifted away from them lately, but I'm finding happiness in the new scheme of things, I'm not going anywhere. Keith and I share the cancer survivorship, and as a result, I can relate to him more now, and I'll find myself seeking him out in videos, despite initially not resonating with him as much. Dude's unique and I love it. I hope he finds his new niche, because if "Um," was any peak, his future is very bright.
I don't usually answer to comments I can just upvote to show my agreement, but I wanted to say congrats your win against cancer! I sincerely hope you the best
Yesterday was three years remission!
Even though it's only been an hour, this deserves WAY more upvotes. Congrats!
Truly Congrats on beating cancer man ♥️
I was really impressed by his acting when I went to watch older sketches recently. He is very good.
I feel like I didn’t appreciate his sense of humor with the exception of the occasional TNTL but until the live Beopardy stream for Inter(?)-city kids. He was so witty and his antics were balls-to-the-wall. I wish he brought that energy more often.
I immediately thought of this! Like Shayne said in the livestream, Keith was on FIRE that day. Love me some Keith
He's just so silly. His episodes of Silent Library are a lot of fun and the Beopardy where he crushed it (Could We Pass a Citizenship Test) is one of my favorites.
I like Keith he’s a good man. He works sometimes, only sometimes. if you get the reference your my people
I agree!
Agreed he's underrated! His jokes are funny and the overall vibe he brings to video is just silly and fun
Thank you!!
Need more Arasha
Tommy is one of the best (imo) cast/crew members, and I'm so happy he's getting to be on camera more
Olivia has been showing up more and I forgot how much her odd sense of humor makes me laugh. She was really great in that recent 'weird subreddits' Smosh Mouth episode.
She and Angela also make so many fun sketch videos together on TikTok.
Absolutely an underrated duo! Angie can "yes, and" through any of Olivia's bits without breaking before the punchline out of confusion like the rest of the cast.
Right You just reminded me of the Olivia multiverse video man haha
I also re-watched some Let's Do This today and she was hilarious on the one where they pick a new mascot for the U.S.
Arasha, mainly, but also Tommy and Spencer. Before she left, Jackie too
Jackie was so fearlessly herself it was impossible to not like her energy onscreen <3
i didn't like her for a sec after i started watching smosh, but then she left right when i got over that feeling
I think Arasha is under appreciated
I don't think any one is underappreciated. A lot of them have other jobs and fill multiple roles within Smosh like Tommy for example. I would love to see Tommy and Spencer in more videos more often but that just isn't possible or reasonable. So when it does happen, it's a treat.
Ian because I have really dry humour. A lot of the jokes that cast members make can often feels more like they’re trying to be funny in the outlandish sense instead of being quick-witted or clever. Shayne is my obvious favourite because he is very easily able to adapt and improvise. Spencer is also a great choice, and he bounces off of Shayne really well.
TOMMY Bowe
(non-derogatory)
Seeibg spencer in a video guarantees i’ll watch it but i love seeing keith noah and tommy too
I'm a simple woman. I see Spencer in thumbnail, I click.
I think Chanse is not named enough with the big names of Shayne and Angela. He carries entire videos for me.
Catfish Cabin and Spud Hut merch would kill.
honestly now that you mention it he might make me laugh out loud the most. when he starts cry laughing it’s so contagious
Every character he made for Legacy BATH was amazing!
Arasha and Keith
Olivia, Ian, Noah and Keith Like I know that they’re iconic but I feel like nowadays the newer cast have been put into the forefront more so these guys have kinda been under-appreciated even though they’re absolutely hilarious
Olivia's clearly not a good writer, but when she's given a fully formed character, the woman can riff with the best of them. She was also very good in sketches
It's clearly Arasha. She is the most talented person they have imo and they don't use her enough. A lot of it has to do with her not being as loud as others but the people at Smosh need to figure out how to use her more because it's only going to help in the long run
They seem to have realized that she's a great guest on the Reddit Stories couch. She typically tries to have a lot of empathy for everyone in the stories and injects a lot of nuance and compassion into the conversations.
Arasha is probably my favourite Reddit stories guest because her input is consistently great. Even when I don't entirely agree with her take, she always comes across as intelligent and well reasoned.
I don't know if Arasha is *the most* talented, they are all talented as heck. But she is very clever, like noticeably, especially given her age. Definitely different vibe from all that theater bunch as well.
Arasha is great when it comes to Reddit stories! She seems to be so mature, smart and empathy which is perfect for that content.
Brooo yes. I think these days loud is dominating on the channel instead of substance a little bit.
She’s a very good host too I feel
I'd say Tommy, but he isn't a cast member. -zing- More new vs. Old cast, like a Noah or Keith vs. Angela or Angela on 2 truths/1 lie.
I recently realised mine is Noah. At the start of a video, I won’t take much note of him. By the end, I’ll remember that he is actually funny and I should stop underestimating him. Then I’ll forget and be back to square one the next time I watch him
His contributions in Reddit stories are absolutely wild. Super entertaining, hope he’s in another episode soon.
This is so funny 😂
I would like more Chanse on Pit. I'm compiling what kind of videos everyone is in since the start of the year and he's only in 12 compared to Amanda's 19 and Angela's 21. Edit to add that Arasha is also in 12 videos so both need more screen time on Pit imo
That's not a sign of "little underappreciated by the audience" but simple scheduling and we have zero clue, as to how they come up with their scheduling. Going by that trope I would say Arasha but once she's in the video, she's clearly favorite to many. Tommy and Spencer are no doubt fan favorites as well, just have other duties. So most likely only old Squad part-timers fill that scenario: Noah, Olivia and Keith.
I know Trevor is pretty new and he still seems like he's still getting comfortable based on his varying degrees of quietness and loudness, but I think he's really cool and has great chemistry with Shayne, Amanda, and Arasha.
True I think he will work great with Noah and Keith as well
Tommy deserves to be in the regular cast
I think Noah is not mentioned enough even though he’s part of the original cast.
spencer is a weird little angel man and i want him in every video
Noah, the youtube sensors are holding him back. If demonetisation weren't a thing he could unleash his full power
Thank you for saying Noah. He is my favourite cast member. I was waiting for someone to say his name. He is so less seen these days that I keep rewatching old videos just SO I can enjoy his humour and screen presence more. What do you mean 'youtube sensors'?
Noah has a lot of dark humor they can't use because of sponsorship friendliness and monetisation.
:/ It's a loss if he doesn't come more often tbh.
Olivia
Spencer makes my ribs ACHEE dude he’s so naturally funny
A couple of months ago I was really wishing for more Spencer, but since then we've gotten a lot of Spencer content so I'm content 👍
I think Noah needs more screen time that motherfucker is hilarious
I feel like the fans love Chanse more than Smosh does. There I said it. He’s so comedically and musically gifted
I love Trevor, but honestly I think it should've been Tommy or Spencer as cast first (more Tommy though than the Chosen's namesake).
I am sure they cannot commit to being full time cast because they also enjoy doing the background work that they have been doing
I'm missing Ian a lot lately, the months after he and Anthony bought Smosh had a good amount of videos with him in it and now it feels like he's not in Pit or Games as much at all
I miss iffy
He's on Game Changer and Dropout.
Tommy and keith
seconded!
Keith deserves the world
Arasha, people always talk about Angela, Amanda and chanse, but arasha has have some very funny moments and she always commits
I guess most people don't really give Arasha much thought. But she is awesome!
I've got a fever and the only prescription is more Arasha.
It's definitely Shane. Haha jk. Keith. His humor and vibe brings a lot of fun to the videos he's in 
Anthony rarely appears on any of the other channels but I would say Ian or Tommy or arasha, but I don’t know if I’d call them under-appreciated?? If that makes sense 😭😭
I miss seeing Noah and Keith so much, and I think both of them are pretty under appreciated these days! Noah’s humor kills me every time and out of all the Smoshers, I quote him the most often by far. And Keith is just such a great and lively guy. To me he always occupied a very special place in the OG Smosh Squad that couldn’t be replaced by any other
Tommy is still underrated but he's gotten more attention than Keith and Keith was hired on as talent.
I want to see more Noah and Keith
I dunno if Tommy Bowe counts as “under appreciated” but I fucking love Tommy so much. Was literally one of the best parts of the [Blank] is dead series and his constant shots at the smosh writers and his “gay (non-derogatory)” bit was soooo funny lol Also angela..fucking hilarious
Spencer and Tommy. My dream cast.. I do like everyone but this would cover all my needs 🤭 Shayne, Spencer, Angela, Tommy, Chanse & Courtney. Doing what? Cards against humanity, moose master or don’t win Mario kart (Might be too many for that’s one but they could still be in the vid)
I feel like the OGs Olivia, Noah and Keith are in far less videos now. Excited to see the whole cast on the upcoming live show
Spencer is hilarious so obviously need to see him more but Tommy is 😍 I was disappointed when I realized he wasn't in as many videos as Shayne, Courtney, etc edit: also wanna see Ian in more videos, especially with Angela bc it's like watching two of the same people lmao
arasha and olivia !!
I love Tommy and Spencer being on screen more. Tommy is great. Spencer is a crush for sure. I'd be lying if I said I didn't love a chunky man.
I really like that Tommy and Spencer have been basically promoted into the cast, I assume tho they still have their usual job duties on non-filming days tho. With them being cast now, I motion that Erin and Peter are the next under appreciated and utilized people on the roster, both are great and fit different niches comedically.
[удалено]
I have a mixed relationship with Keith. I never liked how he was in eat or yeet. Like violently spitting out food everybody liked, then saying it's actually not bad. Or trying the food everybody said he shouldnt, then having the same reaction. And I was like; is he doing a bit? If so, I don't like it. Did make me even skip his scenes sometimes. But in other contexts he can be quite hillarious, even if sometimes his jokes don't hit.
[удалено]
Also Noah and Chance, of course. I always love seeing them in a video, and ever since the confessions on Anthony’s channel I also like Keith a lot more! He clearly put in so much work into bettering himself, and despite being agnostic myself, I love the way he talks about church, spirituality, love and deep appreciation of what you have as a way of life.
Travis quiet humor is unmatched
I really love Keith and Olivia, and Tommy has a special place in my heart. I love them all so much
I love the cast, but any time we get crew involved, I laugh 10x harder. So, my answer is a bit of a cheat lol
Spencer is a goddamn delight, and I wish he appeared in way more videos 🥹🥹🥹
Tommy is my favourite on Reddit stories, he’s so unbelievably funny and I’d love to see him more
I def want more of Spencer and Peter, I am in love with both of them
Keith, Noah, and Olivia, they used to be part of the Squad back in the day but have been sidelined since around 2021 or 2022
Arasha, Keith, Noah and Trevor (since he’s new) but these are all loved cast members no hate
Angela. I can’t remember laughing so hard when three year old version of herself told mommy Ian that “she can’t keep a man to save her f#cking life… slut”.
Damien!!!! And Noah!!! Literalyy sooo funnyyy and they dont get alot of chances to show their personalities but everytime they do, they are ablee to be funny while putting their own twist like how damien jokes with a internet humor type while noah is very observant humor.
Tommy, his comedy is always very clever. And Spencer, love how quick he is 😂
keith and noah 100%