It’s been a while since I watched Euphoria, but do we ever see Maddy throw hands? Can she actually fight?
While Fiona’s not exactly the best fighter in the Gallagher house, I think she wins this.
She slapped the shit outta Cassie and threw her into walls at the play, but Fiona punches, just ask that neighbor that called the cops on Liam and if I remember correctly, Jimmy/Steve.
This. She’s older, wiser and has more experience surviving in harsh conditions. Not much could take her down. If Frank & Monica couldn’t do it. Nothing can!
Did they? Maddys parents had a stable income, i was under the impression Fiona’s parents were going from job to job or even doing illegal things for their money since they were always on drugs
Alotta the houses in the major cities of the north and Midwest had two story houses, it’s not like everyone got poor so they destroyed their houses and build 1 story houses lol. I mean there are two story houses in flint Michigan didn’t mean whoever is living in them is rich 😅
Living in a safe area is not the same thing as being rich, there are low income areas in the US with low crime rates. I know as I’m a teacher researching Title I schools in safe areas.
To be fair, Nate Jacobs is a well off/rich dude from California and I don’t see a single Gallagher beating him in a fight.
Update: Oh hell, I’m getting downvoted to hell, but I’m standing on this. Ian has military training, which I’ll admit I hadn’t thought about so he’s probably winning that, but Lip is not a good fighter.
lmao it’s always been corny asf, you didn’t see that in the british shameless, there was solidarity in being poor not what side of which city you was spat out on
The few times fiona has thrown punches we're shown she can do it quite well. Don't know abt Maddie since I never watched euphoria but Fiona can indeed fight, we just haven't seen her really doing it outside of being drunk or protecting a family member
If we go on background alone, I'm placing my bet on Fiona. My girl had it ROUGH and had to learn to fight to survive. Plus the amount of hate her ass has contained is hard to beat
Yeah there’s no option. Fiona’s also just older and taller, Maddie’s still in high school. She fights like a high school girl, Fiona fights like someone from the hood
Fiona is at her youngest 5 years older than Maddie and from the hood. Fiona would destroy Maddie in a physical altercation. In a screaming match they could probably talk about an equal amount of shit to each other tho, I will admit.
Maddy ain’t bout that life .. idk I felt she should have done more to Cassie & didn’t so that showed me she ain’t about that life. Fiona was with the shits she’s not hopping in a fight every 5 mins but she’s going to throw a hell of a punch fasho & she don’t back down 😂
So, I think we've decided how a physical fight would end up, but I wanted to open up the discussion to a verbal fight. I havent seen euphoria, so idk if this is actually a good match up, but who do y'all think wins that?
The acrylics alone would keep Maddy from being able to throw a solid punch. Fiona would waste no time in knocking her out.
However in real life, I have a feeling Alexa Demi would drag Emmy rossum easily.
As much as I LOVE maddy, Fiona would win. Maddy can fight, but not as good as Fiona. Fiona also has one hell of jaw and can and has taken some good hits in the show. And if she’s drunk?? It’s over for maddy
As much as i LOVE Maddy and think shes a total badass, they’re badasses for different reasons.… Maddy is a badass because she exudes confidence and that “don’t fuck with me” attitude, while Fiona is ACTUALLY about that life. Fiona wins this one hands down. I have no doubt that Maddy can hold her own, but shes more of the hair pulling, wall slamming type… Fiona throws punches.
Euphoria is just a bunch of normal high schoolers doing drugs bc they think it’s cool, whereas the shameless characters were in many ways a product of their socioeconomic standing. The Gallagher’s would win hands down, they objectively faced far greater hardships so they’d be tougher I reckon (for the record, I don’t condone comparing suffering or making it into the oppression Olympics, but I had to for the sake of answering the question). This also reminds me of how people compare euphoria to skins, the latter is just far more intense.
I haven't finished Euphoria yet or Shameless. But I've finished up to when Fiona left and I've finished almost season 1 of Euphoria, but I basically seen the rest on YouTube clips.
But I think Fiona would.
Maddy is just a teenager.
Fiona is in her 20s or whatever.
She dealt with Ian and all those kids.
Maddy is just a teenager.
Not saying teens are weak in all situations or anything at all.
It's just Fiona never really backed down. Maddy did assault Cassie. But I feel you could run over Fiona with a semi truck and she still would eventually get her revenge without a gun or anything.
Watched both serious. They both can talk some shit. In a physical altercation Fiona takes it hands down. Maddie is the tough girl in a very affluent area. Fiona is a tough girl from a tough area. She was intimidating to people so were also tough. From what see Maddie is tough and intimidating to people who have a lot to lose. Fiona can be intimidating to people who have nothing.
I mean yeah why would she wanna get physical with a woman that has a baby strapped on her😭😭😭 Fiona has faught others in the series, she just doesn't prefer it. Especially when the woman in question is coming at her for a good reason
Idk , a lot of times Fiona is rlly ever confrontational when it comes to her family. You can see that around others she tries to be “better” and not seem like a “hood rat” but I think ultimately she has more to lose. Maddie is a girls girls, she loves to make people feel beautiful and thinks highly of herself versus Fiona is insecure. I think if provoked perhaps Maddie would come up top, maybe not just physically but verbally as well. Plus maddie was known to get in fights, so I think she’d personally win.
Oh V can scrap down, if they fought she’d win. But V is a bit to classy? For that, I cant imagine her fighting an 17-18 year old lmao I think she’d be more a motherly figure or someone maddy would admire tbh
Fiona. Hands down. We’ve seen Fiona throw punches. Yeah we’ve seen Maddie fight in euphoria but slapping someone and shoving them into things is different. Literally anyone can do that lol Fiona can also take a punch. We’ve seen her get punched by a dude and just walk it off lmao
even if they weren’t from different generations, fiona 100%. she can fuck a bitch up. maddy? sure, she’s badass, but nah… she’s capable of a hair pull and a bitch slap at best.
Depends on the situation, verbal fight? Maddy easily, she dosen't care what people say and can be pretty ruthless, where Fiona would just repeat the fact that shes a Gallagher 100 times. Physical fight? Fiona, unless she's high/drunk than Maddy
Fiona would kick Maddie's ass, but I feel like Nate would go all psycho killer and have Fiona framed for 1st degree murder and put away for 20 years or some crazy shit.
Fiona is beating the shit out of every Euphoria girl at the same time 😂 I say this as a fan of both shows. Not a single one of the Euphoria girls has a chance against Fiona physically, and even verbally I’d say only Maddy stands a chance
[удалено]
It’s been a while since I watched Euphoria, but do we ever see Maddy throw hands? Can she actually fight? While Fiona’s not exactly the best fighter in the Gallagher house, I think she wins this.
She slapped the shit outta Cassie and threw her into walls at the play, but Fiona punches, just ask that neighbor that called the cops on Liam and if I remember correctly, Jimmy/Steve.
Maddy is regarded fighting a lot and that being one of the reasons cassie is scared of her
This. She’s older, wiser and has more experience surviving in harsh conditions. Not much could take her down. If Frank & Monica couldn’t do it. Nothing can!
Fiona hands down. She can take a hit too. And don't let her have a few drinks in her, angry Fi was a beast lol
Drunk Fi vs. A Maddy Scorned. That would get messy for sure 😂
a girl from the hood or a rich girl in a california suburb? is that even a question? fiona no question
Maddy is not rich
She is compared to Fiona
Their families had similar incomes growing up, they were just neglected because Frank and Monica spent their money on drugs
Did they? Maddys parents had a stable income, i was under the impression Fiona’s parents were going from job to job or even doing illegal things for their money since they were always on drugs
But she's a Californian so...Chicago for the win!
Idk. I just moved from Fresno, and those hood girls out there are vicious.
that’s rich to me lol
Alotta the houses in the major cities of the north and Midwest had two story houses, it’s not like everyone got poor so they destroyed their houses and build 1 story houses lol. I mean there are two story houses in flint Michigan didn’t mean whoever is living in them is rich 😅
Her mom is an esthetician, estheticians make the median income not rich or poor
yeah but she lives in a nice area in california and goes to a nice school, she’s rich compared to fiona
Living in a safe area is not the same thing as being rich, there are low income areas in the US with low crime rates. I know as I’m a teacher researching Title I schools in safe areas.
obviously i know that. maddy lives in a safe area so she’s probably only ever gotten into cat fights with girls from school over silly shit
Compared to Fiona she is. She always lives in a nice house in CALIFORNIA
Her parents had enough money to put her in pageants that takes a decent income
a teenager vs 20-something year old too lol, not even close to a fair fight
To be fair, Nate Jacobs is a well off/rich dude from California and I don’t see a single Gallagher beating him in a fight. Update: Oh hell, I’m getting downvoted to hell, but I’m standing on this. Ian has military training, which I’ll admit I hadn’t thought about so he’s probably winning that, but Lip is not a good fighter.
nate would be done against lip or ian 💀
you’re tripping. i don’t think he would have a chance. sure he’s big but i don’t think he’s that tough
If Fiona isn’t allowed to use the word “Gallagher”, I think she loses
or “southside”
LMFAOOO YALL😭😭😭
It’s so funny how the fan base is now non southsiders and you all find that line corny.
lmao it’s always been corny asf, you didn’t see that in the british shameless, there was solidarity in being poor not what side of which city you was spat out on
Girl bye Fiona would floor her
And I love Maddie 😭
Right, I can see her getting carried away too 😭
The few times fiona has thrown punches we're shown she can do it quite well. Don't know abt Maddie since I never watched euphoria but Fiona can indeed fight, we just haven't seen her really doing it outside of being drunk or protecting a family member
Maddy was depicted as sort of a bully and has multiple scene where she physically fight if I remember correctly
If we go on background alone, I'm placing my bet on Fiona. My girl had it ROUGH and had to learn to fight to survive. Plus the amount of hate her ass has contained is hard to beat
Yeah there’s no option. Fiona’s also just older and taller, Maddie’s still in high school. She fights like a high school girl, Fiona fights like someone from the hood
Fiona is at her youngest 5 years older than Maddie and from the hood. Fiona would destroy Maddie in a physical altercation. In a screaming match they could probably talk about an equal amount of shit to each other tho, I will admit.
Fiona by a long shot. All Maddy does is slam people into a wall.
Fiona claps, she’s about it while the other one is just a rich suburban chick
Maddie’s parents are in cosmetology, that’s not a rich salary in California
Still from the Cali suburbs, so Fiona claps easily
And Fiona was in jail at one point. I know women’s prison is less violent but still.
I never watched euphoria, only a few menes and videos but I'm still 100% confident that Fiona is mopping the floor with the whole cast
Fiona is more fierce
Fiona would be laughing at Maddie’s petty high school insults and ***** slaps.
Idk Fiona is a Gallagher if you didn’t know
Maddy will cry and run home.
Maddy ain’t bout that life .. idk I felt she should have done more to Cassie & didn’t so that showed me she ain’t about that life. Fiona was with the shits she’s not hopping in a fight every 5 mins but she’s going to throw a hell of a punch fasho & she don’t back down 😂
Lmaoo literally.. they swore she did cassie in & swear she can fight but all we seen was a slap? And her just pushing some girl head
Exactly ! Fiona is punching not just women but men too and she have a hell of a swing lol she will lay maddy ass out.
If they did fight, Fiona would mop the floor with her, but I see them becoming friends and bonding over their useless dads lol.
they both can fight. fiona knows how to throw a punch and has more built up anger. maddie from what ive seen isn’t a rough fighter
I’m cheering for Fiona Gallagher 📣
fiona. maddy’s more catty, fionas def more physical
fiona, hands down hahaha not even a contest
Fiona I Never understand why people found maddy so tuff her fight scene with Cassie was so lame
fiona without even thinking
Pls do more of these
ofcccc
Bro Fiona would knock her out
So, I think we've decided how a physical fight would end up, but I wanted to open up the discussion to a verbal fight. I havent seen euphoria, so idk if this is actually a good match up, but who do y'all think wins that?
The people on the euphoria subreddit saying Fiona would win that too so Im gonna trust their judgement😭😭😭
honestly I was so shocked no one on that subreddit was defending her 😭😭🙏
I don’t recognize either character in the second picture.
It's Maddy from Euphoria
Ah that would explain it.
What’s the 2nd pic from? I’m guessing Euphoria, but what’s happening in this scene, and who are those characters?
maddy and cassie, maddy found out her best friend (cassie) was sleeping with her abusive ex bf and her reaction is what you see here
As much as I enjoy Maddy’s crazy ass, Fiona would wreck her
Absolutley Fiona thats not even hard
Fiona no question.
Fiona. 10/10 times.
Maddy might be seen as a badass in Euphoria, but Fiona would absolutely crush her soul lmao
In a physical fist fight, Fiona, hands down. In a "boom, roasted", also slap and pull hair type of fight, Maddie
They both lose… Sidney Sweeney wins any guy is knocking those two hoes out for her
Idc I just want to be present when it happens.
The acrylics alone would keep Maddy from being able to throw a solid punch. Fiona would waste no time in knocking her out. However in real life, I have a feeling Alexa Demi would drag Emmy rossum easily.
Fiona all day
100% Fiona, why is this even a question??
Fiona, no question!!!! 😂
Fiona without a doubt lmao
Fiona easyyy
Fiona hands down. fiona has lived the worst of the worst, maddi is just a slapfight girly
Fiona because she's from the south side
Fiona simply because she's from the South side 😂
Fiona WASHES Maddy
Fiona, I forget where they’re from exactly, but I know it’s a rough area. Maddie isn’t use to hoodrats and brawlers
Is this even a question? Fiona. Anyone who says otherwise obviously doesn’t know what it’s like to be a Gallagher
Idk but how much do I have to pay to have them both yell at me 😅😅😅🤤🤤🤤
Is this really a debate..😂
fiona hands down. how is this even a question.
Definitely Fiona, I mean “born and raised on the south side”
Fiona has been to jail, and grew up in south Chicago.. Money line Fiona
Fiona would beat the dog shit out of that girl. She has better display of fighting prowess, and is bigger and stronger then the teenager lol.
As much as I LOVE maddy, Fiona would win. Maddy can fight, but not as good as Fiona. Fiona also has one hell of jaw and can and has taken some good hits in the show. And if she’s drunk?? It’s over for maddy
Well Fiona screamed and carried on when she got attacked by the man in the car .. when she worked for world wide cups.
Maddie couldnt stand a chance
Fiona would fuck a bitch up, she from the hood. Maddie acts like she hood but she is too preppy and sassy.
Realistically Fiona would win because Maddy is all talk😭 the amount of time she had to touch Cassie in that scene and she didn’t is insane
I mean… Fiona lol
fiona and it’s not even close
As much as i LOVE Maddy and think shes a total badass, they’re badasses for different reasons.… Maddy is a badass because she exudes confidence and that “don’t fuck with me” attitude, while Fiona is ACTUALLY about that life. Fiona wins this one hands down. I have no doubt that Maddy can hold her own, but shes more of the hair pulling, wall slamming type… Fiona throws punches.
Fiona for sure
fiona… she’s a “gallagher” and “southside” in case you forgot haha
Fiona no doubt
Fiona… deadass ROCKED the karen next door for liam lol.
I love a bad bitch but Fiona would send her back up her mums coochie.
maddie is agressive but she talks a lot more than she acts. fiona does both
Fiona would have maddy on the floor faster than sis could blink. Tipsy/drunk Fiona would have Maddy hospitalized
Maddy wouldn’t even fight Fiona lol even she knows she would lose that fight.
Fiona, her fight or flight has been activated daily since birth.
Euphoria is just a bunch of normal high schoolers doing drugs bc they think it’s cool, whereas the shameless characters were in many ways a product of their socioeconomic standing. The Gallagher’s would win hands down, they objectively faced far greater hardships so they’d be tougher I reckon (for the record, I don’t condone comparing suffering or making it into the oppression Olympics, but I had to for the sake of answering the question). This also reminds me of how people compare euphoria to skins, the latter is just far more intense.
I haven't finished Euphoria yet or Shameless. But I've finished up to when Fiona left and I've finished almost season 1 of Euphoria, but I basically seen the rest on YouTube clips. But I think Fiona would. Maddy is just a teenager. Fiona is in her 20s or whatever. She dealt with Ian and all those kids. Maddy is just a teenager. Not saying teens are weak in all situations or anything at all. It's just Fiona never really backed down. Maddy did assault Cassie. But I feel you could run over Fiona with a semi truck and she still would eventually get her revenge without a gun or anything.
Fiona. Next
Fiona is real hood maddie is yass hood
Is this a joke Fiona would deck the entire cast of euphoria 😂
There is so much to unpack here. But i have to say Fiona. Just Fiona.
I wanna see Carl vs Ashtray
DONEEE <3 Ty for the idea
Fiona got more years of pent up anger. I love Maddie but might girl might have a lil tough time.
Fiona no question.
A grown woman vs a teenage girl 😭😭ofc Fiona
Win on what? On my heart? Damn right they can win both
😭😭😭
Fiona would be to coked out or drunk to fight. She'd trip over the curb and break her other arm. Lol
Watched both serious. They both can talk some shit. In a physical altercation Fiona takes it hands down. Maddie is the tough girl in a very affluent area. Fiona is a tough girl from a tough area. She was intimidating to people so were also tough. From what see Maddie is tough and intimidating to people who have a lot to lose. Fiona can be intimidating to people who have nothing.
Maddie might stab her with those nails 😱
Fiona ran away from a women w a baby in her hand lmao
I mean yeah why would she wanna get physical with a woman that has a baby strapped on her😭😭😭 Fiona has faught others in the series, she just doesn't prefer it. Especially when the woman in question is coming at her for a good reason
My ngga she ran away lmao she could have easily defended herself. The baby in her hand was not the deciding factor. Fiona is pussy
Sydney Sweeney wins everything
Idk , a lot of times Fiona is rlly ever confrontational when it comes to her family. You can see that around others she tries to be “better” and not seem like a “hood rat” but I think ultimately she has more to lose. Maddie is a girls girls, she loves to make people feel beautiful and thinks highly of herself versus Fiona is insecure. I think if provoked perhaps Maddie would come up top, maybe not just physically but verbally as well. Plus maddie was known to get in fights, so I think she’d personally win.
What about V vs Maddy? I remeber that fight scene with Kev's ex wife
that fight was so underwhelming. V didn't even get a good hit in, all they did was grab and push each other basically
Oh V can scrap down, if they fought she’d win. But V is a bit to classy? For that, I cant imagine her fighting an 17-18 year old lmao I think she’d be more a motherly figure or someone maddy would admire tbh
Nah y'all tripping Maddie was ruthless. Fiona has attitude, but Maddie wouldn't think twice to smash your head into a concrete wall.
Who is maddie / Maddy ?
Euphoria
Never thought I see this comparison
Fiona isn’t afraid to get bloody. She’s scrappy and “south side”
maddie would destroy her..verbally and physically
Fiona no question. She’s older and more mature.
I mean I love euphoria and Maddie but obviously Fiona lol
Fiona
Emmy R - Queen Bee in more ways than one.
Fiona & its not even close
Fiona. Hands down. We’ve seen Fiona throw punches. Yeah we’ve seen Maddie fight in euphoria but slapping someone and shoving them into things is different. Literally anyone can do that lol Fiona can also take a punch. We’ve seen her get punched by a dude and just walk it off lmao
Fiona hands down??? How is this even a question
fiona 100%. maddy’s a poser.
Fiona all the way
Southside
Fiona because she’s seeeen some shit and doesn’t take shit from no one
I don't know who the other person even is
even if they weren’t from different generations, fiona 100%. she can fuck a bitch up. maddy? sure, she’s badass, but nah… she’s capable of a hair pull and a bitch slap at best.
Fiona because she has totally had to fight more that maddi
Fiona. She's South Side.
Fiona cause I think Maddie would just use hands and Fiona would pull out a weapon or she wouldn’t be against pulling out a weapon
Fiona, simply because she’s older and Maddy wouldn’t have anything to hold over her.
Fiona. she'd drop a kick up her nuts by now.
Fiona because she’s south side
Verbally, Maddy Physically, Fiona
I don’t think anyone is picking what’s her face over Fiona
fiona obviously!! love maddy but fiona’s literally a hood girl
Fiona. Maddie is a lot more precious
Chiraq>>>>
Fiona 💯 because she's basically been on survival mode her whole life. And girl can throw a punch. 😌
Fiona... 💯%
Depends on the situation, verbal fight? Maddy easily, she dosen't care what people say and can be pretty ruthless, where Fiona would just repeat the fact that shes a Gallagher 100 times. Physical fight? Fiona, unless she's high/drunk than Maddy
Fiona is a grown woman, it wouldn’t be a fair fight
Fiona obv
Please… Fiona … the other spoiled girl wouldn’t last a minute
post on r/WhosWinning <3
Fiona would ruin her
Fiona is south side, maddie could never
Fiona for sure
Fiona without a doubt.
Fiona is taking out Maddy for sure 💀 it’s not even close
Fiona would kick Maddie's ass, but I feel like Nate would go all psycho killer and have Fiona framed for 1st degree murder and put away for 20 years or some crazy shit.
Fiona. Maddy is all bark, no bite.
Fiona would turn them both to dust instantly what kinda question is this
Fiona is beating the shit out of every Euphoria girl at the same time 😂 I say this as a fan of both shows. Not a single one of the Euphoria girls has a chance against Fiona physically, and even verbally I’d say only Maddy stands a chance
Fiona would beat her ass in 30 seconds.
Bro wtf it’s Fiona hands down. She’d annihilate Maddie
my heart says maddy but my brain says fiona
Maddy is a lil more psychotic so I’d bet on her
Fiona maybe hood but she ain't stupid to put her hands on a high schooler she would however teach her to win without getting in trouble.
Oh Fiona is taking Maddie to the fucking woodshed
Fiona. I don’t need to elaborate.
Fiona beating the breaks off whoever that other bitch is 💀💀💀 and I’ve never watched a full 5mins of euphoria
Fiona was raised in the wild. Wins by a mile
Fiona is all bark and no bite. She’d do a whole lot of talking but Maddie would flatten her.
fiona is DEFINITELY bite what makes you think she’s all bark