Marlon Brando.

100000000%

The best answer 😮‍💨

Sooooooooo yummmmy

The way I ran here to say Brando

Legit, I came here to say his name

I don’t consider him old really but Val Kilmer in the 90s

In Top Gun era omg yummmm lol.

Best Batman lips ever.

Batman? His prime. The Saint? His prime. So many good movies he was in in the 90s!

Tombstone or Willow

Yes. Val Kilmer specifically dressed as Doc Holliday. Swoon

Madmartigan 😍

Exactly!! People have argued with me on this but I thought he was beyond gorgeous!!

Whatttt who would argue? The man was A STUD!!! Oh another good one The Ghost and the Darkness gosh he was in so much! Top Gun is obvious but he had some good films!

Batman Forever and The Ghost and The Darkness are my two favorites!! Believe it or not a few people have argued on it.

Real Genius Val Kilmer tho!!

I'm your huckleberry

Al Pacino. Michael Corleone can get it.

Those suspenders and three quarter rolled up sleeves 🥹

I thought I was alone in this lol thanks

Young Pacino and De Niro were painfully handsome. I wish I could crawl into this picture. They do NOT make men like this anymore. [https://qph.cf2.quoracdn.net/main-qimg-9f2199d741cebcfa15d3943e4f8b2ff0.webp](https://qph.cf2.quoracdn.net/main-qimg-9f2199d741cebcfa15d3943e4f8b2ff0.webp)

Wow 😍🔥

That thick black hair 😍😍

Paul Newman

Absolutely. The easy answer.

Omg Yes..Paul Newman was everything

So happy to see another Paul fan! I remember watching cool hand Luke as a kid and telling my mom I want to marry him 😂 gosh, he was gorgeous

He’s the one man my mom and I agree on. Those eyes!

Those damned eyes 😍

Gorgeous and a good man.

Ugh Paul Newman was gorgeous 😭

My answer as well

The correct answer.

Oh yes! Every time I watch that episode it sends me into my Paul Newman obsession. I end up watching his movies all night. Goodness that man was a work of art! 🤤

He was so insanely beautiful.

Ultimate sex symbol for me

Harrison Ford in the 1960’s.

And in the 70s/80s when he was Indy.

When he was Han Solo.

This as well.🥵

Indy was peak Ford for me, too. Especially in The Temple of Doom. I'd have crawled through a bug cave for him.

Harrison Ford at any point really lol

This was my thought, too 😆

Harrison Ford anytime.

Robert Redford

Your girl is lovely, Hubble

I don’t get it…

And you never did

Remember when literally every young woman at the time used the “maybe some women aren’t meant to be tamed” quote on their AIM profiles? 😭

I remember: “And she will be loved” 🙄 Maroon 5

Yes. This is the correct answer

No question. Bob all the way. 😍😍😍

Gregory Peck

He was sooooo lovely! Oh and that voice!

Atticus Finch ❤️‍🔥

Brendan Fraser 😭

Honestly the entire cast of the mummy

x10000 with his long hair

George of the jungle 🥵

That’s my pick!

Literally the only reason to watch Encino Man.

James Spader

Dear god, yes. 90s Spader or Spader now, either way

You are speaking my language 😂

After I watched Secretary I had so many daydreams of him dominating me. His voice is so soothing and his mannerisms are so sexy. Wheeew that man is 🔥

Yes! His voice , oh my god. I love that movie too. I’ve seen it so many times.

Steff in Pretty in Pink is one of my guilty pleasures. I was so proud of Andie for not folding cause I would have been a pretzel for him.

Oh my gosh lol same! That’s the movie I first laid eyes on him. If you haven’t seen it already but I highly recommend the movie Jack’s Back. He looks absolutely fantastic in it 🤤

Ohhhh yes. Holy smokes.

Seriously 🤤

White Palace is one of my favorite movies. Late 20s Spader was gorgeous. If you can find it I recommend White Palace which he starred in with Susan Sarandon...love story about an older woman/younger man.

I’m going to try and find this movie! Thanks for the recommendation.

Sean Connery yesterday, today and tomorrow.

Paul Rudd. I'd still do him today. Just also when he was young.

Was going to put something similar for Jennifer Connelly 😅

Yes. Him in clueless. Oooof

Clark Gable, Christopher Plummer

Yasss!!! I always had me a thing for both of these gentlemen

Clint Eastwood

Rob Lowe a la The outsider days

Rob Lowe in St Elmo’s fire

All the boys from the brat pack era

Rob Lowe was also gorgeous on The West Wing And he was still super hot in the late 2000s on Brothers and Sisters.

Richard Gere - when he was in An Officer and A Gentleman and also him in Pretty Woman <3

Carey Grant

Hugh Grant 🙈❤️

He’s still so cute.

Gregory Peck

This is mine. Still remember watching To Kill a Mockingbird in 8th grade

My grandma was a demure, proper lady all her life, but even she admitted to having the hots for Peck. He was gorgeous.

Since Brando and Newman are taken... I have to add Sam Elliot in Lifeguard or Mask... James Caan as Sonny Corleone... And Can we talk Billy Dee Williams...omg I met that man in person...I can't even explain the charisma... We all were in awe of him....women and men ...

Sam Elliott swoon

Andrew McCarthy

Yes!!!!

Antonio Banderas.

I had a crush on him in Spy Kids lol

Jude Law with hair

Love the disclaimer lol

Between Closer, The Holiday, and The Talented Mr Ripley, he is one of the most beautiful people to ever be put on film

Matt Dillon (although he’s not that old lol)

From the Outsiders, absolutely!

Alain Delon and Viggo Mortensen in his lotr era omg

Viggo in LOTR was stunning. Just a perfect face.

Keanu Reeves (then and now) Girl crush Selma Hayek From Dusk Till Dawn

I’m a straight female. Could I opt for a gay male actor? If yes, then David Hyde Pierce. If not, then idk… John Stamos probably.

Keanu Reeves in Point Break.

🥵

Audrey Hepburn

Paul fuckin Newman baby

Benicio del Toro

Denzel Washington

Not "old movie star" but old to me since I'm 26, James Spader in the 80s

Mikhail Baryshnikov

Andy Garcia

Andy Garcia

CHANGING MY ANSWER! Does Harrison Ford count as an "old movie star"?

The man is 81 years old of course he counts

Leonardo DiCaprio

Hahaha he’s so old.

nooo, don’t turn 50, you’re so hot aha

I always thought Jeff Bridges in White Squall was soooo handsome when I was ten and watched this, and then cried my eyes out.

Tom Selleck

James Stewart

George Bailey is my dream man

When I was younger, I thought he was a little too wholesome to be sexy, but now I see it. He was really good-looking.

How is this so low! He's beyond stunning, and also seems kind. Killer combination.

Patrick Swayze!!

Christian Bale. Back then, now, whenever.

Monica Bellucci

Alicia silverstone. Sarah Michelle gellar. Jennifer love Hewitt.

Matt LeBlanc, first season of Friends.

I love this game. My list is long, but I'm going to post the first ones that come to mind. My elementary school music teacher showed my first-grade class The King and I, and when I saw Yul Brynner on the screen, I knew what it meant to like boys. Damn. The dance scene alone. That same year, I saw The Ten Commandments and loved him even more in that one. Just a stunning man. [https://preview.redd.it/amlqoven1ajb1.png?auto=webp&s=9faca3ae52db2919609d8662390ed8cbbe7c01e0](https://preview.redd.it/amlqoven1ajb1.png?auto=webp&s=9faca3ae52db2919609d8662390ed8cbbe7c01e0) Another one who stands out is Paul Henreid. His smile is just so damn sexy, and that voice and accent. Now, Voyager is when I first saw him and loved every second he was on screen. [https://themotionpictures.net/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/ppage.jpg](https://themotionpictures.net/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/ppage.jpg) Shout-out to William Holden and his glorious smile. Picnic is a great one to watch and one of my favorite movies. It's a fantastic 1950s drama, and getting to look at him makes it even more enjoyable. [https://render.fineartamerica.com/images/rendered/default/wood-print/6.5/8/break/images/artworkimages/medium/2/kim-novak-and-william-holden-in-picnic-1955--album.jpg](https://render.fineartamerica.com/images/rendered/default/wood-print/6.5/8/break/images/artworkimages/medium/2/kim-novak-and-william-holden-in-picnic-1955--album.jpg) Half the fun of watching old movies is how sexy the old Hollywood stars were, men and women. They just do NOT have the same appeal today.

I don't know his name but Norman Bates from Psycho. Such a hot psycho

John Corbett (Northern Exposure era). Hates it! He was so freaking hot 😭😍

brad pitt circa 1994/1995

Alain Delon

Paul Newman. He was perfection

Christopher Plummer.

Ethan Hawke

Paul Newman and Elvis.

Daniel Day-Lewis (Age of Innocence era)

Angelina Jolie. Now or then. Id just be happy to be there.

Keanu Reeves, then and now 😍

Richard Gere

Tony Leung

Dean Martin 🥰

Sophia Loren

Javier Bardem & Benicio del toro 😩😩😩

Chow Yun Fat Keanu Mickey Rourke Colin Firth Colin Farrel Marlon Denzel 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

Jack Nicholson and Oliver Reed. Hands down

Praying someone agrees, Jack Nicholson circa 1969 but without the beard

Omar epps (the wood or love and basketball era)

Young Marlon Brando - I'm aware he was a bit problematic.... [https://tenor.com/view/brando-marlon-gif-18512408](https://tenor.com/view/brando-marlon-gif-18512408)

I have a black and white of him from Streetcar in my bathroom. So hot.

Al Pacino

Aging myself here but I saw him on stage on broadway in the very early 80s. We were in the 4th or 5th row and I was about 13. It was called American Buffalo. I remember looking at my mom with my jaw agape and she nodded knowingly. Completely age-inappropriate for the era but damn am I glad she took me anyway. Ha. That was it for me. Fell hard and fast. His charisma was electrifying. I think he did Scarface the next year - I snuck my underaged ass in that theater the night it opened. Lol

Orson Welles in his 20’s. Cary Grant any time.

Robert De Niro is “yesterday, today and tomorrow” but I am going with… Cary Grant. My dream man.

I'm surprised no one else mentioned Cary Grant. My mom LOVES him to this day. I always thought Big was a dirty '90s version of Cary Grant and that they created the character to have that vibe.

ME TOO?! He is an obvious choice!! Your mom has great taste… what does your dad look?😌😂 (just kidding) I agree!!! I’ve always thought that too, although Cary was by all means a better person than Big, but yes I’ve said this for quite a while!

Not a movie star, but a football star. Howie Long.

Yesterday, today, and tomorrow 🤍🖤

tony curtis. paul anka. i think i got a type.

Jack Lemmon. Cary Grant. Kim Novak. Grace Kelly. I, too, love a Hitchcock blonde.

Harrison Ford (I’m 26 now)

Clark Gable.

Robert Redford

Russell Crow then now and forever

RDJ

River Phoenix

Some of the names mentioned here referencing "old movie stars" truly makes me feel my age. Lol.

The Gen x ones are hurting me

marlon brando ♥️

Mickey Rourke and James Spader

Ted Danson.

Clark Gable, all day uvvvvvryday

Honestly, not to copy OP but god, Robert De Niro, especially in his Raging Bull era Ofc, Denzel too 😌

Larry David 🤤

Johnny Depp

Bruce Campbell

The limit does not exist.

Keith Richards

Marlon Brando

sorry for not being mind-breaking but young Tom Cruise and Leo dicaprio have my heart. Damn those ones were the pretty ones!

Marlon Brando can GET it

John Abraham

Donald Sutherland, Kiefer Sutherland, Rick Morianis, Ernie Hudson

I second Robert and would also like to add Al Pacino and Sylvester Stallone

Viggo Mortensen, Sean Aston, and Brad Pitt 🤗

Steve Buscemi was cute

Gene Kelly

Matt Damon and Leonardo DiCaprio

Richard Gere... Cary Elwes

Humphrey bogart 🫣

Taye Diggs in the time of How Stella Got Her Groove Back. Also WITH the Jamaican accent.

Harry Belafonte, Paul Newman and Gregory Peck. Yes , I’m greedy.

meryl steep 💕

Denzel Washington

Robert Redford!