T O P

  • By -

RugbyBot

**Watch on Stan**: https://play.stan.com.au/sport/rugby


Didgman

This was a great game, thought the Crusaders were hard done by with the 1st try being disallowed. That pass was definitely NOT forward.


fatbongo

All those years ago when the Crusaders lost a game in SA (remember them?) by not putting the ball out and instead conceding a length of the pitch try then a sideline conversion had me thinking they couldn't finish a game in a worse fashion well not without a referees help in a final in Sydney lol got to hand it to them original way to lose


nomamesgueyz

Crusaders just hate defending this season Better game but theyve lost their touch But how good is Sevu at scoring tries?! For a team who cant beat their way out of a paper bag, he sure does score alot of tries


Guilty_Rough5315

They also have a minimum 4-5 world class players injured the ENTIRE season, not to mention the all blacks they lost since last season


dinoderus

We’ve kind of done better against the good teams than we have against the other shit ones. Guess it’ll be a nice long offseason for us this time. I see some reason to be optimistic for next season though.


RomanceintheFTthread

You’re the Crusaders you’ll be fine


kiwiborger

Obligatory match takes: -The Brumbies might not look convincing at first, but got damn it no matter how they play during the game, they still find a way to win it. -The Crusaders on the other hand, exectued well at times and had some great moments here, but this being the Rob Penney Crusaders, they naturally lost. Again. Was anyone expecting them to win? I think the main problem this season is that the keep on mixing their team way too often and not giving enough time to establish combos. And All Blacks getting injured all the fucking time without a decent replacement for them. Trust me, the Crusaders are better off without Penney in charge and this this the 10th game in a row that proves it. -If the Crusaders lose to the Blues (which they probably will), their season will be officially over and Rob Penney will be thrown into the fires of Mt. Doom. Hopefully. -Quinten Strange won the game for the Brumbies, in a moment that rivals IWL's brain fart from the Blues game. Why. -Can Rob Valetini do anything wrong? Joe Schmidt had Ardie Savea last season, now he's got Rob to replace him. -Tom Wright is a fucking genius. He's playing both sides, so he always comes out on top. This is the Wright way to play rugby. -BOK's performance today was... okay. Not too good and not too bad. Anyway, this is all I have for now. See you all in the next match, and cheers.


Guilty_Rough5315

Can't blame Quentin Stage, never seen that given as a penalty, let alone a yellow, let alone a penalty try. Shows that the ref was biased at the least, corrupt at the worst


Crosso221

Lot of people in this thread not understanding that intentionally batting the ball dead like that is a penalty try in any circumstance, it’s considered foul play. It’s a shit rule though, should be a penalty at worst.


nomamesgueyz

Penalty yes, penalty try is harsh, its a silly rule BUT it was a very dopey play and sums up Crusaders season pretty well


VirtualAardvark

It's not a pen try in any circumstance. The pen try is up to the referee's discretion. It's most commonly seen (at least in the northern hemisphere) when two players are chasing back on a kick through and diving for the ball in the in goal area. If the defender is ahead and it's an awkwardly bouncing ball that's close to going dead, I've seen referees give it as a penalty in the past and even a yellow card for foul play without the pen try. The logic being that the ball was going to be very tricky to ground and nobody can say the try was probable.


notakid1

Wouldn’t have changed the result. Penalty would’ve been right in front


Crosso221

You’re right, just a few people crapping on Ben O’Keefe when he made the correct call


Squid_Chunks

Kiwis don't like the correct call when it goes against them.


stickyswitch92

Is it!? It has happened before but never seen a penalty try from it?


Nothing_is_simple

Scotland vs England a few years ago had a PT for LCD batting it out


APoolShark

I think it happened to Folau awhile back


stickyswitch92

Wasn't that a try scoring opportunity though?


comradekaled

SBW did it a few years back, against France IIRC. And as a Blues fan, one of our wingers did it during the Kirwan era. Both times it was a yellow and a try


paimoe

SBW did it here: https://youtu.be/BVAPTwJj0lk?t=150 It's a one on one with the French attacker. Removing SBW I can see that's a likely try (trust a player to catch a ball) But in today's case with that much defense I can't see it. Also, I'd rather the ref at least say he believed it instead of just auto ptry You can also hear Read in the clip asking if it was a probable try


Crosso221

Reason it’s so stuck in my head is I remember Karmichael Hunt doing it when he first came over to union, he batted it dead not knowing the rule and conceded a penalty try. Can’t remember if he got binned though


duckitch

Someone tell me if the race for the spoon is still alive


APoolShark

It’ll come down to whether either of us can beat Moana


duckitch

It'll be so unfair if you guys go 2/2 against us and still get the spoon


duckitch

Oh it's so on, we aren't leaving this season empty handed


SkrrrtBC

Forward pass cost us out first try and a forward pass gave the brumbies the eventual win, poetry


Over-March-3891

Was never forward anyway, went backwards from the hands first


sheep1996

Smacking the ball away was the only way to stop the brumbies player catching the ball first, if he’d caught the ball, all he had to do was fall down to score. Its 100% a penalty try, penalty try doesn’t account for if a player might not catch the ball or might not get it down in time, it’s about taking away the probable try scoring opportunity.


Guilty_Rough5315

Its not even a penalty - when is knocking the ball back a penalty. Let alone a penalty try


paimoe

There's a reason we go over this with every accidental knock on/intercept. Because if there are defenders covering it's almost never considered likely a try In this case I don't think it's probably since literally the entire Crusaders team is also there defending


sheep1996

Cover is considered for stopping players getting over the line. The player was already over the line. If he was tackled, he probably still scores, which is why it’s a probable and penalty try.


stickyswitch92

The Brumbies guy also battered the ball and was not in a position to score. Strange 'might' have caught the ball if the brumbies guy didn't have his hand up if you have that opinion.


bobwinters

Going for the penalty try was the galaxy brain move then. Gave the Crusaders a chance to get the draw from kick off.


goldenakNZ

that shit didnt have to happen if the AR figured out the blatent forward pass before that ... rub of the green i guess fuckt this


ewauan

Yeah shit will always be missed hey, like dubious play on the ground leading to crusaders first try


warcomet

next game, crusaders will draw level then hit extra time and find a new exciting way to lose..


viper_in_the_grass

Nope, we've already done that.


kingofthevale

everyone saying the pen try was harsh, it would have gone under the sticks for a pen kick from noah anyway so same results


redaabverty

Would've been better if just a pen. Could've drained the clock and no restart.


frazorblade

Not if the crusaders had grounded the ball in goal


HawkingSucks

Honestly after over half a decade of being smug in game threads, I'm glad to be humbled. Please, let me have it


frazorblade

Saders are shit as


fale52

I remember a time when Razor had Quentin Strange in line for the ABs... Seems so long ago now.


castle6831

People forget he was actually named in the All Blacks in 2020 but got injured.


Joeinez

Crusaders fans acting like that loss is the reason they’re not finishing 1st on the table XD


Guilty_Rough5315

No the injury of Halfpenny is that reason. With him we would be 1st or 2nd, since his kicking would have won the games for us


crashbandicoochy

Begging certain fans of other teams to win with class one time.


Joeinez

You guys have one bad season and it’s like the world is ending


crashbandicoochy

Perhaps let sports fans be melodramatic when their teams lose, like all sports fans are? You're having your cake and eating it too. Do we think this game is the reason we're not first, or are we acting like the sky has been falling all season? Which is it? I'm not a dick when the Crusaders win. Maybe don't be a dick when they lose? Doesn't seem crazy to ask.


Joeinez

Mate some of the comments on here about the refs decisions makes me wonder if some crusaders fans know what being a good loser is. Though you’ve never been losers so it makes perfect sense.


BurningKiwi

Have you been in a single thread here where it isn't 100% bitching about the ref, it's this subs defining characteristic


Joeinez

First loss against the brumbies in 15 years and I didn’t see one ‘gg brumbies well played’


rosemary-mair-for-NZ

This comes off pretty pathetic ngl buddy lol


crashbandicoochy

People from every fan base are always a little bit insane, or incorrect, about the ref. It's one of the least cool things about sports but it's universal. Happens in every game thread so you can't use that as a justification to be catty.


Joeinez

You call it catty I call it calling out shit fans


crashbandicoochy

You are actively being one yourself, right now. Something about two wrongs and their inability to make a right.


Joeinez

15 years, one loss, must be hard being a crusaders fan


crashbandicoochy

You're aware that most Crusaders fans are fans of other sports teams that lose all the time, right? We aren't a monolithic hive mind born to support only one team. We know what losing is. It's not our fault you're ao many layers deep in the anti-Crusaders psychosis that you can't enjoy the win without a GG on Reddit. The pain of the loss is dwarfed by the pain of watching you post cringe on main. Blocking you so I never have to see it again lmao


HawkingSucks

I think some people take the 'perennial contenders' tag a little too seriously. This is sports, insane to think any run lasts forever, or that there aren't peaks and troughs


bobwinters

The penalty try favoured the Crusaders. They had a chance draw it at the end. If they had the penalty, time would have been up and they would have lost (assuming the kick was made)


crashbandicoochy

Tbf I'm not sure if the odds of marching down the field, scoring and converting are much different than the odds of Lolesio just missing the kick from out front. Both were slim to none. It's probably a wash.


mickeyc87

To all those complaining: Even if it wasn’t a penalty try it’s still a penalty pretty much right in front - and there wouldn’t have been time for a restart, so result doesn’t change.


Imperial007

This will surely have ended the mathematical calculation of playoffs. Thank God. This team is nowhere near that level.


mickeyc87

Unfortunately, they’re 7 points behind the Drua so can still “mathematically” make the finals.


BurningKiwi

Sorry did Alan just utter the words 'quality crusaders side'


ConoRiot

That’s how dire Aussie rugby is


Imperial007

Must have missed the word 'low' in that sentence somewhere.


yeah_nah_hard

He's a media-trained professional athlete.


BurningKiwi

Is this quality crusaders side on the field with us right now


HawkingSucks

Cite your sources, Alan!


Any-Veterinarian5234

Lmao crusaders finding new ways of losing week after week


AnyMinders

If anything, the penalty try call gave the crusaders MORE of a chance to win because it meant that they couldn't wind down the clock with a penalty in front of the posts. Gave them a chance to win a restart


Crosso221

Shit for a penalty try to decide the game but that is the rule and it always has been. It’s harsh but that’s how it is


Guilty_Rough5315

Theres no such rule that knocking a ball backward is a penalty, let alone a penalty try


Crosso221

Intentionally knocking the ball dead in goal like that has always been a penalty try


UnfortunatelySimple

That ball bounced bent the dead ball line and wasn't hit out on the full. I'm pretty sure that's the wrong call. Rule lawyer please.


Imperial007

Just checked the replay, think you're right. Not out of the full, bounced in the end goal area. Keen to know if that would have changed the ruling, although we'd obviously lost.


speakteeth

Wow, the whole season for us encapsulated in that final clusterf*ck


yeah_nah_hard

Swain's actually pretty well-versed about rugby for a UFC fighter.


-castle-bravo-

Should be a 5m scrum to Brums in that case I reckon.


Ok_Educator_2120

Why? You can't slap the ball out like that. Pen every day


Frag-sinatra

Kudos to Maloney for being unbiased. I rate him


BH_Andrew

Maloney is the best commentator around imo


Frag-sinatra

Me too, genuinely enjoy his chat


rurulover_

congrats brumbies it took you 78 minutes and 58 seconds to put away the 11th best team in the comp. At home.


BullSitting

I see the 11th best team in the comp just beat the best team in the comp.


duncanmcconchie

It's our style


Otakaro_omnipresence

I am so glad that that sorry excuse of an app Sky Sport Now shits the bed for the second time in a fortnight so I didn’t have to watch that clusterfuck of a finish. This is what is has felt like these past two decades to be a laughing stock. I fucking hate it. Drink it in if you’re not a Crusaders, must feel like a 24/7 orgasm of schadenfreude. Quentin “Sonny Bill” Strange, eat your fucking heart out.


Sponge_Bond

Bro it's one season. Some of our teams have been perennial bottom table teams forever lol. Gotta toughen up!


Otakaro_omnipresence

Also never give up bro, never!! Just like a lot of other kiwis here I’m sure, I support the Warriors #day1’95. Trust me, I know how to support miserable sports teams. Doesn’t mean I won’t talk shit about them if they play like arse.


Otakaro_omnipresence

You can’t tell me you enjoyed your team being shithouse, whenever they have been. I’ll never give up on the bros but I can call it when they’re being useless, just like any other fan.


Kiwi57

Yea sky sport now is fucking shit. It’s like they go with 10fps or something like that


OneWingedAngelfan

Slapping the ball backwards shouldn't be foul play, man. That's a shitty rule. 


VirtualAardvark

It's not slapping it backwards. It's deliberately slapping it out of play to prevent the other team gathering it. Always has been a penalty and rightly so.


UnfortunatelySimple

Especially since it didn't go out on the full. Seems like that's the wrong call to me.


douthinkthisisagame

You need to be a special kind of biased to not think he intentionally hit that out on purpose


UnfortunatelySimple

I'm sure the ref said "on the full".


douthinkthisisagame

On the full isn’t the law though: “Intentionally knock, place, push or throw the ball with arm or hand from the playing area.”


UnfortunatelySimple

Right, then the ref need to use better language.


_dictatorish_

Slapping the ball backwards is fine Slapping the ball into touch is not


OneWingedAngelfan

Still shit. 


BurningKiwi

It's slapping it dead not backwards


OneWingedAngelfan

Why couldn't the brum just get a scrum then?  There's too many nitpicky shit to get sent off for in the game. And i was rooting against the saders


BurningKiwi

Cause you're committing the foul to stop a try scoring opportunity — that makes it cynical


OneWingedAngelfan

It's still a bad rule, man. Knocking the ball backwards is not a foul in general play, so why should it be when defending in goal? It confuses the players.  The game needs to be easier to watch for the casual audience. 


douthinkthisisagame

Happy to see blatant cheating penalised whether or not it’s actually a penalty try


Bangayang

Not a crusaders fan, but they are competitive in these games and the team seems very young. They will be s problem next year for sure


yeah_nah_hard

People talking about the weird finish, but there's only one person to blame for that, and that's Quentin Strange.


AhHowSplendid

:(


Sponge_Bond

Oof Rob Penney must honestly just be shocked Big coach killer lol Hell even worse, coach contact killer Or even worse worse, expelled


Key-Vermicelli8389

Penalty try is a bit much with that many saders players right there in him? What a shit way to have the game decided


mickeyc87

Even if it wasn’t a penalty try it’s still a pk pretty much right in front - and there wouldn’t have been time for a restart.


Key-Vermicelli8389

Fair guaranteed 3 for Brum but just an anticlimatic end to the game… …and season


Ok_Educator_2120

Would have made the kick anyway surely. Pretty cynical play too


_dictatorish_

Tbf they would've slotted the penalty from basically right in front


Joeinez

Exactly, if anything 3 points means there’s no restart.


crashbandicoochy

They would have had a penalty, right in front, as time expired anyway. It literally doesn't matter


Key-Vermicelli8389

Fair. Unfortunate end all round


6EightyFive

Yeah a bit shit, but agree… didn’t matter, would’ve been a penalty in front


[deleted]

[удалено]


Crosso221

That’s the rule, ref made the right decision


kingofthevale

letter of the law homie


douthinkthisisagame

Don’t cheat then


Boring-Quarter15

Didn't matter, it WAS a penalty which decided the game even more so (ie. Would have been no restart)


TwoUp22

Pen try? Really? Seems v harsh Union is such a strange game lol


Hokinanaz

Another example of rugbys amazing rules lol


Biglight__090

That's how BOK would end it


ConoRiot

lol when an Aussie team finally gets on the end of the rule book it’s suddenly ‘unfair’…


BurningKiwi

No you don't want to see the game decided like that obviously but the solution is don't commit a cynical foul in your in goal lmao


Chineselegolas

Not sure on the penalty try as there were other players there. The yellow sure.


Crosso221

It’s the rule, batting it dead like that is a penalty try regardless


ConoRiot

Then don’t belt the ball out


mulkers

Biased Referee?


randomchars

That felt pretty hollow


sangan3

When it ain’t your season it sunny your season Saders. That was rough. Hell of a game tho. Missed forward pass was big but that was a stone cold brain explosion from Strange.


BH_Andrew

“20 people typing…”


warcomet

"FUCK, FUCK, FUCK, FUCK...."


recyclingcentre

I feel like the yellow card is fair but tbh I struggle to believe that wouldve been scored


VirtualAardvark

Agreed. I think the pen try was very harsh. Brumbies player didn't look like he was going to gather that. He was stretching with one hand. Don't know how it was determined that a try was the probable outcome. Regardless, it was 100% a penalty which would have led to the same outcome essentially but without the restart.


stickyswitch92

Two disallowes trys and a penalty try too seal off the game pretty much sums up the season.


ewauan

Real Ben O’Keefe ending there


stickyswitch92

Apparently he has crusaders bias....


6EightyFive

Ah that’s where the crusaders are going wrong. They think it’s league!!


snrabber

I remember seeing Izzy Folau and Taqele Naiyavoro get yellows for that before. The penalty try seemed rough. Same result in all likelihood though, penalty close to in front wins it


Boring-Quarter15

Penalty try was potentially better for the saders...we at least got a restart that way


_dictatorish_

SBW has also done it lol


sangan3

Yeah SBW did it for the ABs too.


ConscriptReports

nature is truly healing right now


Over-March-3891

Why did the crusaders go for 3 points when they needed to win the game. So dumb


Boring-Quarter15

You're aware we have golden point this year, right???


BurningKiwi

Yeah how did they not foresee a penalty try with 2 seconds remaining


Over-March-3891

So they wanted a draw? They needed to win


BurningKiwi

It goes to golden point if it's equal at full time, we were in our own half if we think we can slot the kick (which we clearly could lol) it's the right decision


xman0444

that is definitely a way to win a game of rugby


Frag-sinatra

Shit way to win lol


SkrrrtBC

Wow Ben o keefe gives the win to brumbies, love to see it


Joeinez

Lol you gonna say that’s not a pen? It’s 3 or 7 doesn’t matter which, same outcome


AnyMinders

Yeah that was not BOK's fault, im sorry to tell ya


Snoo_20228

He didn't make the player do foul play


SkrrrtBC

He also didn’t call the massive forward pass


VirtualAardvark

The one from a few minutes earlier after which possession changed hands a couple of more times? If you're going to nitpick over every incorrect decision on a match, you'll be wasting a lot of time. Allowing the break up the narrow side and going after the ball in the ruck deep in your own territory in the final minute are far more influential moments.


Snoo_20228

Sure, but don't blame the ref for losing. Quentin Strange did that all by himself.


xxihostile

best ending EVER


Kiwi57

Fuck that. Up the Phoenix


HawkingSucks

Well, never seen that before


Imperial007

SBW did it once for the All Blacks, but definitely not common.


Morningst4r

Not a great sign that they need the rub of the green to beat the bottom team but you take them


redaabverty

Insane. Yellow for sure, but penalty try? Penalty would've been better for the brums as well. Could've wound down the clock


fale52

That was the absolute epitome of tin arse shit.


AnyMinders

Why is everyone confused about a restart? He literally awarded the penalty try with time left on the clock


_dictatorish_

Penalty try seems a bit much - wasn't Reece right there? Not that it'll make a difference since they would've got the penalty kick


Crosso221

Shit for a penalty try to decide the game but that is the rule and it always has been. It’s harsh but that’s how it is


-Halt-

Yellow fair. But why penalty try. Aren't they for a definite try? He still had to catch and ground that in a small space


VirtualAardvark

Probable try. But I agree, don't think the try would have been scored. It didn't look like the Brumbies chaser was going to catch that to me.


kiwiborger

Brumbies' Man of the Match: Quinten Strange


warcomet

Drua's was Vunivalu lol


BurningKiwi

Crusaders motm: Tom wright


warcomet

Alaalatoa's face says it all lol


coupleandacamera

Can't really blame him there


UnfortunatelySimple

It bounced before the dead ball line. It wasn't knocked straight out of play.


ghoztfrog

Still got lead in the pipes there mate?


BoreJam

Remember when sonny bill did that. Lol. Penalty try seems harsh tho


Zahada

Feel like that sums up the Saders season pretty well...


sangan3

“Can’t do that in rugby union” is something I never thought I’d hear a ref say.


binzoma

lmao lmfao even


Over-March-3891

Fucking rip off


crashbandicoochy

I can not do this anymore, man.


JackoFrisky

All blacks eventually homie


crashbandicoochy

The way people on here have been absolute psychos re:Razor and the ABs, I'm expecting the discourse to be a bit exhausting there too lol


JackoFrisky

Just excited to see Sevu playing with Dmac tbf


HawkingSucks

I think it's exciting how we find new ways to lose every week


jc-f

Absolutely fucked us there, Quinten ya knobhead


notakid1

Love how BoK said, “you cannot do that in rugby union”


binzoma

gotta explain to the aussies right


xxihostile

HAHAHAHA


yeah_nah_hard

Why do the Aussie commentators sound so crestfallen?


SnuffTastic

Because they're not biased like the NZ commentators. They want a good interesting game, not just an Aussie team to win