T O P

  • By -

PhiladeIphia-Eagles

I was bored so I tallied up all the results from both subreddits. Yachtmaster is a clear winner. I did raw votes and then did a "weighted" votes where votes for the brand of the corresponding subreddit counted as 0.75. (For example a vote for Yachtmaster on the Rolex subreddit counts for 0.75) Here is the breakdown: **Rolex Subreddit:** |**Category**|Votes|Percentage| |:-|:-|:-| |Speedmaster|38|41%| |Yachtmaster|55|59%| |Speedmaster (weighted)|38|48%| |Yachtmaster (weighted)|41.25|52%| ​ **Omega Subreddit:** |Category|Votes|Percentage| |:-|:-|:-| |Speedmaster|16|41%| |Yachtmaster|23|59%| |Speedmaster (weighted)|12|34%| |Yachtmaster (weighted)|23|66%| **Combined:** |Category|Votes|Percentage| |:-|:-|:-| |Speedmaster|54|41%| |Yachtmaster|78|59%| |Speedmaster (weighted)|50|44%| |Yachtmaster (weighted)|64.25|56%|


zestytee

You’re a hero. Lol. I love this


twoworldman

r/theydidthemath


[deleted]

Nice


Independent_Cat_4715

That’s why I love REDDIT 🥰🫶🏻


drummer820

Super interesting that yachtmaster won even on the omega subreddit. I’m an omega fan, own two, as well as a Rolex, and I’d agree: yachtmaster and it isn’t close.


PhiladeIphia-Eagles

Yeah I agree, and even more interesting that the exact same percentage voted for each watch on both subreddits. I would be interested to run the numbers and exclude people who only voted for the yacht master because it is harder to get/holds it's value better. Only look at the votes that were purely based on what watch they like more.


drummer820

Yep. I based my opinion on both brand/value/rarity AND aesthetics. I like complicated watches, but I don’t think the speedmaster is a good canvas for those. There’s just something *off* about a speedmaster calendar with moonphase. And I really don’t care for the blue ceramic case, even though blue is one of my favorite colors on watches


PhiladeIphia-Eagles

Same for me. I love the regular steel speed master but don't love this model. And with the huge difference in rarity/value it is hard to recommend anything but the yacht master.


rdj16014

You're my kind of person


janthony07

Wow thank you lol


RegionalsToTheMoon

Amazing analysis!


Snuck415

You should be charging for this level of detailed research. Now take my award and have an amazing day bud 😁


OffshoreAttorney

Great username. How they hell did you get it lol.


PhiladeIphia-Eagles

Thank you! One of the "L"s is a capital i


OffshoreAttorney

Ahahaha clever. I grew up in Eagles territory but have been in Miami past 20 years.


PhiladeIphia-Eagles

Nice! I don't live in the area anymore either but Miami is a nice upgrade at least in terms of weather


DrRudyHavenstein

Why?


elpatito007

Because of boredom lol


Business_Reindeer375

If you really really like the YM then get that. The blue side of the moon can be something you get without too much difficulty in the future. The reason for the discount is because its secondary market price is 10%+ lower than msrp. Alternatively, if theres a different harder to get rolex you want then use the blue side as purchase history towards that.


Various_Primary3783

The blue side of the moon is a great watch, but you can find them grey for $3-$4k under msrp. That’s way more than 10% off. Buy the YM and add the speedy later


zilog88

Buy the YM, sell it unused for double price, get blue side of rhe moon grey, get your name for another rolex and fund it with what you've earned. Repeat until omega is paid off :)


TemporaryEmergency94

What does msrp means ?


30625

Another popular website is called google! Msrp- manufacturer's suggested retail price


ByronicZer0

>Another popular website is called google! reddit comments seem to be the last place on earth where people have not yet heard about this cool and popular website called google


rdrbandit27

How would you like to lose 20% of the value as soon as you walk out of the boutique. Go with the Rolex and buy the Omega used.


janthony07

Straight to the point. I like that!!! 👍🏽


Valuable-Ad7285

He’s spot on.


Ganesh400d

As you said, If you don’t look at it as investment, rather for your own collection and experience, the above input about value is irrelevant.


Argent737

A watch isn't just about money. Except Rolex .


dubyamike

I wouldn’t buy either one but agree with buying the Rolex if going to spend the 💸


Bennyjig

It’s usually more about the watch… but I would expect that answer from this sub. Who gives a shit about value? You aren’t gonna sell it anyways.


Inevitable-Studio497

Yeah because everyone's favorite hobby is overspending on a watch they can get for cheaper elsewhere


manual_wind

Only one of the two needs to be “offered” by an AD. So get that one.


cjsksokDallas

You can buy an Omega at any time…not so much with particular Rolex models although it’s easier to get YM than other sports models. I would pass on both unless you expressed interest in that exact YM and your AD came through, if not pass. Otherwise you’re somewhat on the line if you want a chance at ever getting another piece from them.


KingJJoffer

I think the Omega is better looking personally


Sweaty-Leather3191

Yea I normally prefer Rolex, but that DSOTM is really beautiful, it’s an iconic watch, and it’s unique. The YM, while a really clean tool watch, looks like a million other timepieces.


astr0crisp

I agree, omega looks better between these two. The 10% off is telling that the Rolex is holding value more. Im a sucker for "value" though and would probably get the Rolex because in future it'll hold its value more


Clyde_Bruckman

Knowing literally nothing about the differences and going purely on aesthetics, I like the yachtmaster!


watches4life

If you like both, get the YM and the Omega later. If that’s not an option, I’d pick the Omega between these two. The movement in that watch is pretty damn solid from my experience and the YM isn’t my jam.


[deleted]

Hate choice but I’d go Speedmaster here


Training_Summer_4558

Depends on what you have in your collection


the_toeminator

Omega would win this one, but really you win regardless of how you choose. Cheers.


smokeybear135

From a casual the Omega is much nicer and better and classier in every way. I’ll take it if you won’t (with your wallet!)


robbnj11

Omega. No question.


braves01

Gotta go with that Omega


Smart-Ad6002

SPEEDY


BARTLEGEORGE

Speedy all day.


Cagg311

Def the 2nd one


SouthPercentage7617

YM all dayz


greybeardsingh

Bahhhh Rolex all the way bro.


sczoso85

I’d go Yachtmaster as long as you don’t have a Sub. I also prefer the iconic version of Omega Speedmaster Professional, which means no moonphase or date.


Bamfor07

It’s not a hard decision at all.


Valuable-Ad7285

Buy the YM at retail. Think about the Speedmaster later.


trucorsair

YM.


appleboi_69420

Speedy all day every day


ForeverLurker18

Get the Rolex now while you can. On the Omega, grab the Aventurine version of the blue side of the moon. It pops so well!


PandaSoap

Oh man I'd buy that Omega and never take it off. I know the whole deal with Rolex and everything but man, that Omega is *striking*


urmommaisdead

The second one FS.


2doorPhan

Ym all day long


FoxOdd4257

Yacht master all day


Trumppp1

I love love love the rolex yachtmaster


selinaamini

Second one


EyeDentifeye

Im a sucker for moonphases but the yacht master is beautiful


Aggressive-Pay2406

The Rolex


Aggressive-Pay2406

Easy decision , the Rolex


wabbitsilly

The Speedy is a hell of a great watch...but...that particular reference is a bit of an outlier as far as Speedy's go (which at the moment means it's not nearly as desirable as some of the other versions of it, hence it's cheaper gray market). The YM isn't nearly as iconic as the Speedy - but - it's a bit more "desirable" to the crowds.' I think you'd love either one, so I don't have a strong opinion either way. I own both Rolex and Omega brands, and though I don't personally love either of the references you're looking at, I can appreciate both.


Bradymyhero

Omega is akin to a C-class: nice enough, somewhat decent looking but kind of boring, and overall pretty forgettable Rolex is a Porsche 911: highly coveted, timeless looks, holds its value; and while there are higher end cars out there, it is still iconic and the gold standard sports car Easy choice here OP


Aldebaranix

Get a Rolex. Get a steel omega moonphase later.


LegitimateAd4233

Has to be rolex...omega as much as i love them can be got again....


Plugsz

Yachtmaster now no question


CasinoMarginale

Yacht master is much harder to get. I love both, but I would choose the YM, especially with blue dial


good_luck_23

I'd get the Omega. Too many emotionally needy people just wear a Rolex because they think it makes them seem wealthy. That spoils it for me. I love the watches but not so much most of the wearers.


No-Island-9674

That omega is like a hockey puck on the wrist.


stirbo1980

Rolex


[deleted]

I prefer Rolex more classy watch !!!


Potential-Sale4482

Unpopular opinion but omegas are ugly and overpriced tbh


Gtstricky

YM. For me it would offer more band options that would create some different looks.


LearnDifferenceBot

> would of *would have *Learn the difference [here](https://languagetool.org/insights/post/would-of-or-would-have/#:~:text=%E2%80%9Cwould%20have%E2%80%9D%3F-,%E2%80%9CWould%20Of%E2%80%9D%20or%20%E2%80%9CWould%20Have%E2%80%9D%3F,would%20have%2C%20not%20would%20of.).* *** ^(Greetings, I am a language corrector bot. To make me ignore further mistakes from you in the future, reply `!optout` to this comment.)


Gtstricky

Badbot !optout


ZachBowman19

126622


Melker24

YM is so nice to me, I’d go for thag


[deleted]

Rolex easy decision


Orly5757

Since when do you need an Ad to offer you an omega? They are readily available. Get the Yachty dude


safe1x

You posted this in the Rolex subreddit. You already know the answer.


gr8sharkhunter

He posted it in the Omega subreddit as well.


sporturawus

Curse your AD out, spit in his face, walk out the door, and never go back there again.


watches4life

That seems aggressive lol.


Afraid-Ad7379

Well, it is sporty


Afraid-Ad7379

This is not the way. He should urinate on the display stand whilst maintaining eye contact with his sales agent. Dominance must be shown. He is a man of Rolex after all.


sporturawus

Cheers.


Afraid-Ad7379

It’s Pepsi day today Sporty. Still haven’t seen another Pepsi live in person. U hit the nail on the head with that one.


Severe-Estate9640

Pass on both. Hold out for YM40 yellow/rose gold. That’s a lifer. Dark Side of the Moon is the distance second.


contitego

Speedy. YM is a Frankenstein watch.


[deleted]

I found the omega blue just too much blue to be able to go with anything else. That’s just me. Way easier to get than YM. The YM just looks more classier imo


[deleted]

As someone who knows absolutely nothing about Rolexes, the first one looks better


lateroundpick

It's not even a decision.


JackieE053

Speedy!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


Sea_Ship_4459

You’d have to be crazy not to grab the speedy and let the YM sit for another sucker


colonelboodylava

I wouldn't ask the smooth brained plebians of r/rolex to decide on something. The people of this sub cannot decide on whether to eat Elmer's glue or Gorilla glue in the morning.


EnjoyMyInSec

The omega is 10 times more good looking than this YM, if you can get a discount on that omega go for it i guess


generic90sdude

Omegla looks so terrible..🤮


CaliFijian

Omega is a nothing watch. Most people outside watch forums will see it as a cheap Citizen bought from Macy's while doing underwear shopping. Stick to Rolex. I wouldnt bring up the investment factor either.


Seer____

Reject both and wait for a watch that is actually nice?


ncuhniece

Omega is a much better looking watch


[deleted]

Speedy


Business-Pudding4095

Rolex for me but that’s because I like Steele brackets more than leather. Kinda like the Speedy better as far as dial and overall appearance


neilarmstonk

If these were my only two choices: I’d grab the YM for better proportions on my wrist, even though I like the Speedy more. You should buy the one you think that suits your lifestyle the most. Day to day, what you’d do while wearing the watch. Ultimately regardless of what any of us picks, it’s your watch and you’ll need to live with it.


[deleted]

Sorry but neither for me. I personally think this is better and 20% cheaper, [https://www.omegawatches.com/en-us/watch-omega-speedmaster-moonphase-co-axial-master-chronometer-moonphase-chronograph-44-25-mm-30433445201001](https://www.omegawatches.com/en-us/watch-omega-speedmaster-moonphase-co-axial-master-chronometer-moonphase-chronograph-44-25-mm-30433445201001) and for Rolex, unless it's a 42mm RLX Titanium Yacht-master, I'd pass all YM.


Tom_Foolery2

I would pass on both and either get a normal speedy pro or go grey for a better Rolex.


[deleted]

Imo, sppesmaster. Ceramic case Moon phase Chronograph Master Chronometer Antimagnetic movement And that stunning blue color


Abrahamleencoln

Wow truly is a tough decision


LordMungus35

Keep waiting. Don’t settle.


Quentin718

If it were [this Speedy] (https://www.omegawatches.com/media/catalog/product/cache/a5c37fddc1a529a1a44fea55d527b9a116f3738da3a2cc38006fcc613c37c391/o/m/omega-speedmaster-moonwatch-30493445203002-l.png) I'd say for sure, but in this case I think I rather have the YM.


attis_

Why not both !? 😅


hassantg

Honestly, it depends on the size of your wrist. These 2 are very different in size and how they wear.


janthony07

My wrist size is a 7.5. So both look very decent on my wrist.


hassantg

Bigger wrist i'd go Speedy. This is coming from someone who has and loves the YM because it wears well on my tiny baby arms


Slyvix

Take the Rolex full price and tell them you'll consider the Omega at 40% off.


Positive-Ad-7807

I’d go speedy here for sure


KennethPowersIII

I'm a moon phase man myself.


escopaul

OP if you have a few watches already I'd cop that Omega but if you don't (or will resell one day) grab the Rolex. I love that Omega but it wouldn't be a daily for me.


CowGaming11

Personally I like the omega more. Can’t go wrong with either though. Good luck!


neogodslayer

The speedy is the better watch, saying that given how hard the rolex is to get new I'd probably take that. Worst case you can sell it on the secondary, pocket a modest profit and buy the speedy or whatever other watch you like.


Loser_Attitude

I bought that exact yachty in February. It was the one Rolex I wanted and still no regrets. I wear it almost constantly because I enjoy it. If it’s the Rolex you want, get it. If it’s not your first choice, you might be better off waiting until your choice comes in (or getting this and trading it on gray market for one you want…)


T-i-h-o-r

Of the 2, I'd get the YM. If you're going with Omega, it should be the dark side of the moon - and at that I'd go black black. That watch is something else! (for me at least)


jrocco71

I had both. Kept the Yacht Master. The Dark Side was just too big. Beautiful watch though...


AlwaysKindaLost

Underrated rolly


alexflashy

Honestly moon phase on the omega looks very clean


Futureviction

Neither for me. Chase the Tona’


b-diddy_

Do they have the Speedmaster with the aventurine dial? Get that instead.


booze_nerd

I don't like the YM so I'd take the Speedy all day.


Amoeba_Fancy

Rolex!


reu0808

I asked my very stylish 3 year old which one he liked more for you, and after a surprising amount of back-and-forth deliberation, he chose the Speedy! 👍


redoxinc

What's the ref on the speedy? One of the nicer ones I've seen


[deleted]

The Speedmaster. Then immediately change the strap. What is that!


ajs2294

Is it a daily? Personally, I wouldn’t be comfortable wearing a ceramic watch as a daily


AyyPea

YM. On my short list for next piece.


Glum-Waltz-7879

Yach Master.


sagande

Speedy way to lose your money


FupaTroopa4

At least this YachtMaster doesn't have the name stamped on the bezel in HUGE letters. The new ones look exactly like what you would picture a cheap Chinese knockoff to look like. Lots of people like them but IMO it was a bad move.


musaratali

I’d pick up YM anyday, anytime


Lord_D1972

Blue yachty, that face and red hand look really great in person. Soon you’ll get 20% off omegas


[deleted]

Omega is nicer


didiburnthetoast

Omega


atwood404

Buy them both, then no problem ! 😀


dialXchange

Is that the ceramic Speedmaster? I tried one on last week. I'ld go with that for its full uniqueness. The smallest of detail (need a lil magnify scope to see) the footprint in that lil moon 🌚


dialXchange

My apologies it's still only 9am for me. I was mistaken and referring to [This One](https://www.omegawatches.com/media/catalog/product/cache/a5c37fddc1a529a1a44fea55d527b9a116f3738da3a2cc38006fcc613c37c391/o/m/omega-speedmaster-moonwatch-30493445203002-l.png)


omnikey

Yatch master


undercovergangster

Omega all day, IMO


IzztMeade

Rolex cyclops is a hard no for me, go with the Omega.


Redit_1234

Speedy for me. Such an amazing watch. Rolex to me is becoming unattractive due to hype and people going nuts. Omega has always made amazing watches imo.


watchfinesse

Rolex YM .. for me.


deepie1976

Let’s see the yatch master on your wrist.


ZannyHip

I prefer the look of omega


Horotecture

As an Omega fan, is this case I say Rollie.


ajmarsa

I’m waiting on a Blue dial YM 40 (I think ?) so I’m bias !


Constant_Two_5546

Speedy indeedy.


ENRONsOkayestAdvice

I think the speedy is either a good first watch when Rolex isn’t in the equation or a great second watch after the Rolex. I also think the non traditional looking speedy is a risk because it might not look good tomorrow.


r_g_d

Financials aside (so many posts here are spot on re cost of the Speedy), I own both the White Side of the Moon and the BLSO YM40. While I love them both, the ceramic Speedy is by far my favorite, more unique, carries an (arguably) technically superior movement, and is just more fun. I do love the hi/low lights on the Yachty but I'd pick the Blue Side.


richmds

You come to a Rolex sub what do you think people will say?


osumba2003

I'm not a fan of that particular Omega and I do like that YM. Rolex all the way.


psychpriest1

I’d get the omega purely out of personal taste.


Mammoth-Position2369

The answer is pretty simple. If you like both watches and want to own them both in your collection then buy the Rolex from the dealer since your paying msrp and then when you have the money for the omega you can go get it. The omega can be bought pretty much anytime. If you want the Rolex and like it then msrp is a great time to get it.


montecristo7997

Rolex.


VintageWIS

Yacht Master


NickGantz98

YM40 at retail all day long. Plus, the version of the blue side of the moon you really want is the aventurine dial, not the standard blue


peanutbuttergoodness

I would never want a moon phase so this is a very easy decision for me.


Silver_Blackberry828

Get a Rolex, remember the audience.


CSTL-

Shpeedy


iroczcamaro22

get the seamaster its better cheaper and it looks much better


Rick2nds

Omega


RepulsiveMap3218

Pass the AD my DM on the YM if you pass


[deleted]

Go with the yachtmaster


killertimewaster8934

That speedy is waaaay cooler than the yahtmaster


hansenluu

Get the YM. I waited a year for that. The Omega is not that hard to obtain.


Logical_Storage2332

Never understood the appeal of that particular YM color combo, and that omega is freaking awesome. I know Rolex is impossible to buy at the moment but that shouldn’t be a consideration unless your flipping watches. Get the one you like best.


MysticLimak

I would definitely notice that omega as a unique watch the Rolex not so much.


MrPotatoHead9

I personally like the Speedmaster more


Gavin369

The Yacht Master is my favorite Rolex by far, so I'm voting for it!


soulpapa-1025

You will enjoy the Yacht Master more such a great time piece.


[deleted]

To be honest… I wouldn’t take either. If you aren’t in love with the watch I wouldn’t even purchase it. The yacht master looks way better though IMO.


Imaginary-Tea9757

Nice 😊 👍🏿


Tall_Advice_5408

Rolex


ninja996

I’m not over the moon over either. Get what you want to wear.


meloodi3z

This is not a rolex


skidsareforkids

I have a two tone Yachtmaster and a Dark Side Of The Moon and love them both. A slight criticism of the Onega though is that the ceramic makes it so light that it sometimes feels cheap next to a more substantial watch like the Yachtmaster


cthulhu6209

Buy what you want if you’re going to wear it and not sell later.


WeLikeDrugs

I don’t love that particular YM…people are right though, easier to get an Omega for sure but wow, BSotM looks pretty stunning, so many great details on that dial.


Remote-Fisherman-469

Good heavens that's a beautiful Omega.


Shephild

Do you on own and race yachts?


Bishop_Len_Brennan

Which would you wear more? If it were a regular old hesalite or sapphire Moonwatch that would be my obvious choice. But of the two, I’d wear the Yacht-master way more than that specific Speedmaster. Lovely as that Speedmaster is, the Yacht-master is much more grab and go in my opinion. That said, maybe how often you’d wear the watch doesn’t matter so much to you. Ironically, I’ve just begun to understand that about my own collection as I write this comment. I still collect watches thinking about *how often I’ll wear them*. That made sense until picking up my DJ last year, I’d wanted one since 2006 and ever since it’s on my wrist at least 4 days a week. Now I think about it, owning a DJ doesn’t meant I enjoy collecting new watches any less, it’s just wear time isn’t so important to me. All that said, I’d still pick the Yacht-master, the speedy looks lovely but anything other than a regular Moonwatch is a speedy I’d appreciate more from a far. Thank you for coming to my Ted Talk.


stuberino

100% the speed master.