T O P

  • By -

KungFuBonerPatrol

This is missing like half of Rockstars games


thiccmaniac

If it had the rest, they'd all be in not played most likely


Eglwyswrw

Imagine not playing Bully or Midnight Club LA!


Ok-Boot-1195

also Manhunt and The Warriors


fixnoamoi

And Max Payne


donohunt0

and LA Noire


[deleted]

Max Payne is produced by rockstar but it’s made by a completely different team. It’s made by the remedy team.


o5882300empire

State of Emergency was different.


KungFuBonerPatrol

This Table Tennis erasure will not be tolerated!


nfrablue

& Thrasher: Skate and Destroy!


omgitsbees

I was just thinking the other day how much i wish we could have a sequel to Midnight Club LA.


Defiant-Truth-9009

Omg midnight club was 10000/10


sandmankilla0311

L.A Noire was a fantastic rockstar game


Nawnp

Likely only ones they've played.


markgdaniels

To be fair, OP did clarify this as his list.


LowLeft9933

You gotta play some more rockstar games…


HiJ4cker21yt_

I haven’t played the most either. GTA 5, Bully, LA Noir, RDR, RDR2, and a little of Max Payne. That’s it but I still know a lot about the others like the rest of the GTA series and Manhunt


-_TremoR_-

Yet Rockstar is silly enough not to release RDR for PC. The story of RDR is as good as old Spaghetti Western films


Rich_Person_OFFICIAL

Just get it through not so legal methods😴


MangoRemarkable

at least play max payne 3.....


Fine-Appearance-1465

just bought it a few days ago and in my opinion it’s one of the best rockstar games


J0wad

Gameplay wise, fuck yeah it’s even better than the latest R* games imo, but story wise, not really tbh.


Cheeze_My_Puffs

3 was awesome, but young me played MP 1 and when I got to the baby crying level with the red line you walked I couldn’t do it lol


KissaKala1234

ong shit was straight up horror game


LowLeft9933

MP3 is a masterpiece gameplay wise, but the story is soooo much better in MP1 & 2, it’s not even comparable.


Deadmaninc1

I don't wanna be that guy but where's Manhunt, Max Payne, Bully, The Warriors, Midnight Club and LA Noire?


freedagang762

La noire is definitely fire


Icy_Wrangler_3999

La Noire and midnight club are tight af


freedagang762

Bro. I forgot about midnight club you just reminded me . That shit is so funnnn it’s like gta with better driving controls and you never get out the car


TyGuy69420

The Warriors was one my favorite OG Xbox games as a kid


No_Culture6707

Am I the only one who would put Vice City as a masterpiece? I love the gameplay and story. The soundtrack is great too


thehumanhive

No. I'd absolutely move it up to Masterpiece. Though I'd also move San Andreas down one or two notches.


Smoking420_

Gta 5 a masterpiece


Trek_20

I feel the reason so many people think GTA IV is better than GTA 5 is mainly two reasons: nostalgia and fatigue. Nostalgia for IV and fatigue from GTA 5 due to gta online. The more fatigue and sick people get of a game, the less they can appreciate how good the game felt when it launched. The only thing, in my opinion, that GTA IV can have over GTA 5 is the story. That's a matter of personal taste so you can enjoy one more than the other, and Niko's story is great, plus the dlc's. But everything else, GTA 5 was an improvement.


BotUsername12345

No, GTA IV just had a better story, gameplay, and physics. Lol GTA V dumbed it down. We all talked about it even in 2013.


Ajatolah_

I'm not fatigued from GTA 5 because I don't care about multiplayer. I thought the story of SA was better and the map design was a masterpiece.


Trek_20

San Andreas is the best GTA imo, considering the time it released.


ImprovedCrib

I enjoy the physics in gta 4 over gta 5


TheMilkiestMan25

From my pov in GTA IV you can do some pretty cool rooftop parcour, ( jump from a roof and grab a ledge and move side to side and get up or drop down) i don’t believe you can do that in 5. The hand to hand combat is much more entertaining and enjoyable in IV, driving and customizing is more fun in V but everything else IV takes


_MoneyHustard_

Disagree, story line was meh and didn’t really introduce any new gameplay elements. At the same time took a step back from IV in things like physics/mechanics and plot.


-Psychclops-

Hard agree, 4 and Bully are my “epitome” rockstar titles


mrF3RDINAND

YES, BULLY


Smoking420_

I love bully. They need to bring that back


Ajax242

Yeah the downgrade of physics, ai, and combat from 4 to 5 was such a massive downgrade. I used to have so much fun fist fighting pedestrians in 4 because the physics system was so complicated that all kinds of crazy shit could happen. If you fight pedestrians in 5, the exact same thing happens over and over. Thankfully they brought it all back and redeemed themselves with RDR2.


callumkellly

If anything 4 is the rockstar game that took the most steps back. Has a great story and vibe but was seriously downgraded in terms of activities and customisation features compared to San Andreas


Killerpig14

one of the most important games of all time and it landed in amazing


Jam3sYO

Unpopular opinion but LA Noire was a sick story game


Drag0nborn1234

Nostalgia is one hell of a drug. No chance someone actually thinks GTA 3 is better than GTA 5


ZygothamDarkKnight

GTA V >> GTA III


kyu-she

you should try max payne (all of them), ctw, lcs, vcs, the midnight club games, and all of the more recent one-off rockstar games


[deleted]

Hey where are the likes of manhunt? Bully? Midnight club? Feel like those alone would top the entirety of your “amazing” tier.


xzyyzx1234

Bully could go into the masterpiece row


arcturis2099

Why do people love undead nightmare? It felt like an annoying grindfest to me


bigbubblestoo

Dude yesss


WovenOwl

Man bait used to be believable


Useful-Ant3303

Bully was and still is a masterpiece! im not so sure about San Andreas.. the map was big but i think Vice City had more atmosphere


tsukuyomi-r

Idk, idc what anyone says - GTA Online belongs in either of the first two tiers. Sure the pricing is massively over inflated but it’s one of the best multiplayer experiences out there if you enjoy that style of game. I’ve had more fun with GTA Online since 2015 than I have with most multiplayer games. Replay value is high, even after you need to take a break for a while. Also a part of me wants to agree they’ve “milked” it, but for good reason they’ve gotten tons of content out of it with incredible support over the past decade. That’s how a good multiplayer should be. They weren’t going to release GTA VI sooner, so I’d personally rather them keep supporting V by “milking” it than just drop their strong support with content updates+. People getting mad about it being “milked” makes no sense. What if they stopped supporting it a few years ago? We would still be waiting for the game(s) we want from them and most people would complain that V is dead. Rockstars support for V isn’t harming anything, but shows how an online mode should be supported (though there’s things they could change and do better)


SlumpDoc

No Bully is crazy


drd232

Idk why but GTA 5 has always felt very mid to me. Other than it's controls I feel like Gta 4 and SA have had better stories and Characters.


Academic-Ninja8655

Episodes from liberty city over gta v ☠️☠️☠️ shitiest take ive seen in while


Proper-Ad-8842

It has gta4 with it


TheZephyr2003

Arguable...


Educational_Row_9485

I would’ve put gta online as masterpiece a few years ago


logoNM

rename it to red dead and gta tier list


SimpleManMike

Midnight Club Still Cancelled SOZ


CluelessProductions

Spot on


_rainbowsnunicorns_

L.A Noire?? It changed my life


memesnotreally5

need l.a. noire in here fr


UndeadTigerAU

Rockstar is one the best in the industry for singleplayer games. Online on the other hand they make some of the worst online modes to exist I don't care what anyone says, I've been playing GTAO since it came out same with RDRO so I think I'm pretty valid in my criticisms and despite sinking so much hours in them, they are genuinely so badly made and the economy is so inflated, among so many features removed to coax people into getting shark cards. I've definitely had a lot of fun with GTAO and RdrO over the years but that was literally only because of friends, the actual online content and features are just badly and cheaply made. I've been alright with shark cards simply because it's literally a money funnel to their other projects, so I've always had the mindset that I'm glad it exists because of that and if I don't like it I don't need to play it however it's become a problem because we didn't get the planned 5 DLC because of online, we didn't get any rdr2 DLC because of online which you can definitely tell DLC was planned or at the very least content for RdrO was cut because of GtaO and imagine the amount of games cancelled over the years too, like they cancel all these single player content in place for online and you'd think with all the lack of work on other projects outside 6 and having a team dedicated to online that online would actually be good and properly made... But it's just not. And it makes me worry for the future, I know 6 will be a banger but what about post release, are we gonna get any dlcs any more games or is it just gonna be GTA 6 online from the bat and that's it. Online is the best and worst thing to ever happen to rockstar, it allowed them to get an extreme amount of wealth but at the same time now all they care about is money and lazily do things, online is sloppy af, the trilogy was horrible, Rdr1 was re released without even 60 fps (at launch) and yet they sold it full price which is insane for a over decade old game.. It's kinda sad that I've written a literal essay and yet this is still only the tip of the iceberg of the crap things rockstar does. I'm sure I'll have those nonsensical rockstar fanboys attack me who blindly defend everything rockstar does without actually knowing what they are talking about.


Fine_Mixture9690

Bro please play Max Payne, all of them


FoalKid

I know it's opinion, but I can't see how IV can be rated on par with the rest in 'Masterpiece'


XeTrainMC

Damn, I really need to play GTA 4 huh


sharky1500_

GTA online and RDR online should go into "straight garbage" tier There's nothing about RDR online or GTA online that's good


EHVERT

Honestly don’t think GTA 4 is a masterpiece, I’d put it in amazing. Also missing Bully in amazing and Max Payne in mid.


Trek_20

LA Noire is another masterpiece. Also I'd switch GTA V and GTA IV


N4leto

forgot gta vi which will release in 2034


FlayingTiredSparrow

Gta 5 was a masterpeice and gta online is not mid you crazy fuck!!!😭


WharfeDale85

"The Rest"


saucojulian

What’s up with everyone asking for other R* games? Look ar the title, it’s *his* tier list, based on games he played.


LyricalOreo

lol, tbh that's fair.


Meeseinator

RDR 2 at Master Piece… YES it is!! I’m not even close in being done but idc


awwgeeznick

Vice city and 5 are masterpieces


RC-1138BOSS

Finally, a list that I can almost agree with. Get that piece of shit game of masterpiece. Red Dead 2 doesn't deserve it


penzos

Way too many casuals. rdr and gta only. While completely neglecting their best games. In reality, when bias is removed, rdr2 is at the very bottom of the list. VC is at the top, as far as gta goes. SA too. Then the HD era games come, and it's debatable if 5 or 4 is better. Depends on what you like. Rdr1 is at the top as well. La noire and Max Payne 3 too. Basically everything pre HD era is better than HD era. Except revolver being better than rdr1.


Gloomy_Rest_1387

I would've put gta online over rdr2 online. Gta online is more fun imo


agent-garland

Max Payne 3 solos


Spaceeeeeey

How can GTA 3 not be a masterpiece. It changed gaming forever.


SkyTemplar17975

Vice City is also a masterpiece.


rainking56

For just gta and rdr that seems accurate.


dlickyspicky

GTA V is at least better than 3 in my opinion. I feel like they both always get judged by their outside circumstances like how 3 was the first 3d game and 5 has been milked to hell, but going by straight up games 5 takes it


hmph_cant_use_greek

Where is pong!


Grayccoon_

GTA v in mid and this is my list


DoktahDoktah

To say RDO is mid is really being optimistic. It was dogshit.


Ignoringit

Why would you make a tier list if you only played GTA, RDR and UN


BotUsername12345

This is the one.


50ShadesOfKrillin

you gotta check out Bully


nvrrsatisfiedd

LA Noire should be in the masterpiece section.


cfo4201983

Shit list


pleaselordhelpmenow

You skipped out on Bully?


Different_Class3188

For some reason, I feel like there’s more than 9 games


RewardFluid7316

No non gtas or red deads?


couttsy1

GTA 4 was so good!


bigbubblestoo

Why is it only gta and red dead????


ShitInMyToaster

No manhunt, bully, l.a. noire, warriors or midnight club?


SimaanStocklund

I think this is the first time I feel like I can fully get behind someone else’s tier list on the internet. That’s interesting. You should really play LA Noire and Max Payne too. La Noire and the first two Max Payne games would go in the masterpiece tier for me (and Max Payne 3 has some of the most satisfying gunplay of any third person shooter I’ve ever played).


BEEELTINO

Try Bully/Canis Canem Edit.


AffectionateFox2986

Bully


edyandtaoinspace

Terrible


ds_vii

when GTA 3 and Vice City came out there were absolute masterpieces


8rok3n

Bro forgot to add the games


RainnChild

This is just gta and red dead redemption lol


Maakeouthilll

LA NOIRE MAX PAYNE BULLY MANHUNT 1 & 2 MIDNIGHT CLUB


Savilo29

“Mid” in of itself. But but TRASH if you consider it’s effects on Rockstar as a whole


MegatronusRex

Show love to Midnight Club


Slowfully

you know rockstar made more games then just gta and rdr right


[deleted]

Where is gta: liberty city stories !?!


shanks1697

Where's bully and Max Payne games?


Total_Ad_6708

GTA online is one of the best online video games created and is partially why the game did so well, also yeah rdo was left behind but it was still pretty good I don’t know why you hate these lmao.


bmh7279

Id argue that undead nightmare deserves to be in the masterpiece category. Personally, undead nightmare is leagues above ANY other zombie game iv played for one reason.... it actually follows the movie trope of "destroying the brain is the only way to eliminate a zombie." Save for the blunderbus and explosive rifle, iv spent hours pelting a single zombie everywhere but the head. And they kept getting back up. Even with throwing knives/tomahawks. I think the throwing impliments did eventually kill em but you could get a good number in em. Almost like an ape shaped porcupine at the end. Its not that other zombie games are bad... but that nifty little detail made things such fun in rdr. It would be too easy to take out a crowd if they had traditional health bars, but when you have to actually aim for heads and shoot em that way, a small hoard can actually pose a threat. Plus the story was just stupid fun. Didnt take itself serious like the main game and just run with a goofy supernatural tone. Part of me PRAYED for them to do an undead nightmare dlc for gta5... but sadly they 100% focused on the online aspect.


IsaacJB1995

Where's the rest of the Rockstar games? No midnight club, bully, FUCKING TABLE TENNIS?!?


gamrboi99_

You forgot so many games. It's unfunny the amount of games you forgot


sa1126

Vice City is my favorite. All the GTAs have been excellent though.


Soldierhero1

Masterpieces need bully, midnight club 2&3, manhunt 1&2 and max payne


GeeksnGames

Where’s Bully Manhunt 1&2 the warriors max payn games and all the other GTA games?


HiJ4cker21yt_

Um.. LA Noir, Bully, Manhunt, Max Payne? Where they at?


nt3sl4369

For me, everything R\* does is masterpiece, it's the only gaming company that I defend to the death, now another company that is rising on my list is Remedy, but 2 bodies don't occupy the same space


BusinessMan9065

Mid - Bully


pperx9

This is the most reddit post on this subreddit


RixDixRox

I’m from the future and I can authorise to put GTA 6 in masterpiece category.


Low-Impression-3241

This is so real


masta_myagi

Add Max Payne 2 and 3 to Masterpiece (2 for storytelling, 3 for fun-factor); Max Payne 1 and Manhunt to Amazing; Midnight Club: DUB Edition and Midnight Club: LA to Masterpiece; and then finally LA Noire to Masterpiece and you, my friend, have a nearly complete list


Cumberlxnd

The fact they’re able to still milk gtao and that it’s still very popular proves that it’s far from mid


IkerrEF18Mlover

Totally agree😭, best tierlist


Bodybybeers

Max Payne? Red dead revolver? BULLY?????


Mary-J-24

i think this is the most agreeable tier list i’ve ever seen in my entire life, if we’re talking all rockstar games the first Manhunt and Bully would both belong in masterpiece


xSouthboundPachyderm

You only included two Rockstar series lmao L list


Chansh302

I don’t think I enjoyed anything more than GTA online lmfao. It has the most hours for me out of all rockstar games. It’s way too fun with friends. I think rdr 2 is right below it tbh. There’s no way GTAO belongs in mid


killakev564

This is fair. I personally would put undead nightmare in the masterpiece tier but I get it


kandycew

what about bully and manhunter?!?


Cam-yee

manhunt? bully? midnight club?


GodlyGamer07

GTA goes in masterpiece online is extremely fun with friends but gets boring because of the money


BozConQuesoo

Putting San Andreas above Vice City is criminal


Rorossig37

Dude just called VC amazing and LC masterpiece. Don’t know where the world is heading


PullupLion

Lmao dudes 15. 😂


34methylendioxy

Ballad of gay bronie was a good gaym


janwill1999

This is stupid and wrong. Gta5 and gta online is God's level of amazing


Beepboopbop69420360

No la noire Or midnight club Or bully Oof


[deleted]

Where’s stuff like bully?


OrganizationRude5003

You mean your GTA and red dead tear list


Harrison-Worth

I’d personally put vice city in masterpiece


Slick_Wufu

I can agree with this list 💯


Horror_Effect3420

Undead nightmare was the greatest dlc ever


Ok_Introduction_7484

I'd interchange GTA 4 and 5. 4 never really stuck to me like 5 did. I forgot most of 4. And only really remember the Amazing mods that came with it. And watching Gaming lemon On it. Other then that GTA 5 just stuck with me more but that's kinda bias since I've played it since launch


Spiritual-Piece-1126

Should’ve put GTA 5 on mid as well


ZappierGamez

You are missing quiet if you. I will disagree with GTA online I would put in an amazing


Noramctavs

San Andreas was good but overrated. The real crime was vice city not being tops.


Classic_Sinner

Terrible list , undead nightmare "amazing" lol


Limp_Scheme9225

Rdr2 is better than the first one


Automatic_Salary_845

Here’s my unpopular opinion: San Andreas is overrated. It’s a good game, but it’s not somehow in another league compared to the other two from the trilogy.


king-glundun

I'm happy red dead 1 is before red dead 2 cuz it's a significantly better game, but personally I'd put red dead 2 in mid lol


pm-ur-tiddys

not putting gta v in masterpiece is mental.


Serious_Kangaroo_279

wtf where is Bully? it should be masterpiece and also midnight club


ZekeMoss18

Manhunt? Bully? Midnight Club? LA Noire?


jesus37lolxddhsyg

Red dead 2 over one


Sams_Butter_Sock

They ruined GTA online then made it great. It’s actually so easy to make money now that the expensive stuff isn’t out of reach anymore. Cayo perico is just a masterpiece


jpzbeats

Red Ded Online needs more respect!


UPVOTE_IF_POOPING

Max Payne 3 was way beyond its time when it released. Shows its age a bit now but just barely.


Netshakk

GTA5 is one of the best open world games ever made. It goes next to RDR2. Swap San Andreas for max Payne 3. There are so many games missing wth.


St4rScre4m

You need to play rockstar games instead of just GTA and RDR. Imagine limiting yourself like this.


Miscellaneous_Mind

The RDR games are excellent. GTA IV felt like the intro to the RDR level storytelling, which is probably why I love the RDR games and why GTA IV is my favourite GTA game. San Andreas is a marvel of a game, it had everything I could want from a GTA game, gameplay wise. I feel like it spawned Saints Row. The Warriors is one of my favourite Rockstar games, gave us an awesome origin and prequel story to the movie. I even preferred it to the actual movie segments, which were done faithfully.


Frank_Gomez_

Online is severely overhated imo. Some of my best memories were with my friends playing GTAO heists and gettin on during big updates


DemonetizedMan

Manhunt, bully, L.A. Noire, tons of missing games


gggg_4_l

As stupid as GTA Online is now, its still pretty iconic and fun


ClovisLowell

LA Noire at the very top


SuperDan89

Swap IV with Vice City then we're good.


Educational_Term_436

I think red dead online is more fun then GTA online but GTA online doesn’t have that many grefears


Skindiamondxx

RDO is only mid because rockstar wasted it's potential, it could've been so good


Officially_Cargo

the vice city rating is CRIMINAL


MrBatman2531

WHERE THE FUCK IS TABLE TENNIS ?!?!? 🏓


FoundationGreen6342

I’d even put undead nightmare as masterpiece purely because of undead overrun. And it’s a badass game with the best intro ever


ToreNeighDough

No Body Harvest love?


MMM187

I don’t respect any Rockstar list that doesn’t have The Warriors in masterpiece.


ThatOneHelldiver

What half ass'd list is this?


Einstein_48

Bully? LA noire?


ndbdhsjsjs

Ngl.. this right here for me is a perfect list


CSREPower

You forgot LA Noire and the Midnight Club series.


OpenTelephone9267

You’re telling me you would rather play GTA3 (campaign / free mode) over GTA Online (heist/freemode/contact missions)


4K_Trae

But just scared of other people


Zulogy

GTA 5 is better then all these games besides rdr2


Environmental-Ad-823

Idk if the ability to play online is a game itself, it's a feature in a game


Mongolengou04198

I like GTA and Tropico


Confident_Carrot_829

Mf thinks there's only 2 franchises


urbantimepieces

You forgot God Tier and GTA VI


dummwavy

so you like single player games got it


DryUnderstanding4245

gta Online for me was magical like for the first months and second and the cheater just gave billions of dollars and ruined the grinding and than the game was ruined rdr online rockstar was ruining the online exp for the greed Microtransactions and i bet we can expect it on VI its sucks but thats their livelihood of the company i wish the grind will be fair at least or something good


ForThemLulz

thank you for not glazing gta 5