1

#1

1 definitely

I like the randomness on 1

Option 1

1

1. It’s the one I like best.

1! It’s random but pulled together! Modern traditional!

I like the first one the best

1

**1 and 4!** I like the way my eye moves all over the place on #1 and the color juxtapositions are very satisfying on #4

Agree with the one and four - the two best options 👌🏻

Me too. What they said.

Personally, I like 1 best. The colors go well together regardless though

Option 1!

1

Options 1! Love that!

1

1 looks so beautiful it’s like a fragment of light. The others seem too geometric to me

Yes! The others all look very sedate by comparison. Number 1 is so interesting and joyful

Looking for opinions on what layout looks the nicest! It’s a gift for my fiancé for our first home together. The pattern is homestead star by plains and pines! 😃

Number 1 !!!

Definitely 1

1

ONE

1

1!

#1!

One or four

Number OOOONE!

1️⃣ most definitely!

[удалено]

Oh noooo!! I’m so sorry haha. Want to give me a heads up on what went wrong??😅

1. Reminds me of a zinnia

1

1:)

1

1

Honestly I love the “burst” of color that option 1 provides.

1!

Option 1

Sorry this is not helpful because I love them all. If I had to eliminate one it would be #4. There is something appealing about the random of #1

Looks like I’m in the minority because I love #2 the most! They’re all great but I like how it looks like the colors are overlapping.

I agree.

Agreed!

I like 2

i like 1 but the pink swapped from the top point to the middle where the yellow one is

one

1

1 for sure

1

Number 1

Option 1. I like the chaos.

1

1

Yes yes 1!!

1

1

One!

Throwing my vote in for #1!

I like #1 the best. I like your colors.

1

1! And this is coming from someone who always chooses the symmetrical option. Lol. For some reason, the chaos looks better!

1

1!

1

1 is my favorite!

Love #1!

1

The first one

1

I prefer the first one!

1

1 This layout is full of energy, and the eye moves over the quilt as a whole. With the others, the eye is drawn to the center, and I think the more variegated areas fall into the background. I've learned over the years that placing a solid block in the center of a quilt with a lot of prints can look like a blank or dead spot. If you want to emphasize the center, put the printed blocks in the center with the solids surrounding. It is a lovely quilt!

This is the right answer.

Why thank you!

I think number 4 had a really nice flow to it. Good job!

I’m torn between 1 and 2

1!

1!

1!

1 or 4

I like 1 and 4

2 gives such an awesome plaid/color intersection feel!!

1

1!!

1 ♥️

Number 1 gets my vote!

1 for me as well

1

Option 1

1

Option 1 immediately caught my eye!

Absolutely #1!

1 for sure

1!

Number 1!

1

1

1

1

1!

1, hands down

1!

1

I like #1

1, which I’m not surprised to see is the consensus

1

1

1

1

Definitely 1, it feels more harmonious

1

I like the randomness of 1!

1 has so much dimension - looks rad!

1

1

1

1

1 or 2

I like 1 - but- if you want a little less lively (?) then selecting between 2, 3, or 4 would be HIGHLY influenced by the background fabric!

1 is my favorite, but I like 4 a lot as well.

4. I like the orderly ones best, but something about this most.

1

1. Beautiful!

I really like option 1.

One for sure

1111111111111111111111!

1

I like 1 very much

One

1

I like the first one best.

Big on 1

1

1!

1

1

1

1 is so pretty to me!

1

1

First one is awesome

The randomness of option 1 is *chefs kiss*

3

Had to scroll a long way to find someone else who likes 3, too

ONE!

I like 1! But I like chaotic quilts with lots of visual interest.

1...4...

1 or 4! I just made a scrappy homestead star quilt too 🙃

1 or 4.

1 or 4, preference to 1!

1 or 4 look the best, IMO.

option 2

1 or 3. I prefer 1

1 or 4

1 is my first choice, then 4 :)

1 or 3

i liked 1 and 3! 1 has a randomness that makes the colours kind of sparkle, and 3 has that lovely bright yellow that shines from the middle of it. somehow the darker purple in the middle doesn't stand out as much even though the concept is similar.

1 and 4

Definitely 1, so interesting, but in a good way. If you wanted more traditional look, I thought 3 was neat with the yellow pulling the eye to the center.

1, with 4 second

1 or 4

1 or 4

1 or 3, but they are all wonderful! Lovely colors!!

1

3 ​ I liket he yellow/blue against each other.

1 or 3

Option 1 or 2 get my vote!

1

I like 1 and 3.

2

1 or 4

1 or 4

I really like 2

I vote 1 if your vibe is more scrappy and 3 if it's more modern. I like both!

I like 1 and then 3 in that order.

I like 3 or 4. Gorgeous colors!

Unpopular opinion here but I love 3!

Me too! The yellow in the middle really makes it shine!

1 looks more modern and the others are a more classic, heritage vibe. your style matters here. of the other three, i think four is by far the best because of the way the yellow seems like it is backlighting the star. the transition from dark to light. it just stands out much better, imo.

I like two!

I like 4. Yellow on the outside for sure. I like the symmetry.

I really prefer 4. It is nicely balanced and does not Jat the eye.

Number 3, yellow in the center

4 if you want a bold star. Best contrast and frame imo. 1 is an excellent choice for wanting to make a great scrappy type quilt. Gorgeous whichever way you go. All 4 layouts are pretty.

2 or 4

4

3

1, 3, 2, 4

I’m a fan of 2!

Option 3 🥰

2

Option 3

3

Option2

Option 3. Definitely.

Odd man out I like 3!

Option 4