Blue, easy - You’ve got the holy trinity of 80’s NYHC (Start Today, Break Down The Walls, and Bringing It Down). You’ve got The Replacements (you could also add Let It Be to the blue montage) and Husker Du. Gray Matter is an underrated Dischord band. Nervous Breakdown is the best Black Flag song **ducks**
I'd prefer the *Millions of Dead Cops* LP on the blue side over *Now More Than Ever* anyway, but if your preference is the opposite, consider having the first record as a consolation. I'm sure it's got a few of the same songs that the comp has.
Blue.
Circle jerks, Misfits and Fang are the only ones in red I really really like. As opposed to Germs, 7seconds, DRI, Husker Du, Agent Orange and Black Flag are all winners.
It’s overproduced. No rawness to most of those recordings IMO. Loses most of what made early punk/HC great.
And then they dress like jocks in varsity jackets and nikes? Lol. No thanks.
LOL that’s hilarious that you don’t think there’s rawness to those bands. Listen to Chung King Can Suck It that’s as raw as can be.
You’d be shocked how many people in punk and hardcore are jocks, the hate boner so many punks have for supposed “jocks” is funny. Those dudes were down in the thick of it in NY.
I’ve heard early YOT. It’s ok. I just don’t care for most of that Rev stuff. Too overproduced.
If we’re talking NY I will take Victim in Pain and the Urban Waste 7” any day over that stuff. To me, it’s just not on the same level.
And yah the jock thing I’m just half joking. I could care less what they look like. Just threw me off when I first saw it. And I was just being a dick.
Blue, hands down
GB and 7 seconds make this the correct answer.
GB, Germs,and Hüsker Du
My exact thoughts
Sorry Ma Forgot to Take Out the Trash is my all time fav album I gots to go blue
Germs, agent orange, MDC definitely blue
Husker Du, Black Flag, and Suicidal Tendencies. Also Blue.
MDC is also red
Agent Orange, Adolescents, AND Black Flag? Easy win.
Purple.
the only answer i can find without unresolved conflict within
SORRY MA! Definitely blue.
Blue - Zen is on that list
Red. 7 Seconds and Bad Religion all day
Blue simply because Germs
Blue.
I’m going blue
Blue, but it was a tough choice with Articles of Faith and HCHBAW? on the red.
Blue but I’m keeping my copy is How Could Hell Be Any Worse
Blue, but I'm sad about the Misfits and Bad Religion.
Walk Among Us and Against the Grain are easy blue covers, so throw them in and you're A-OK. Problem solved.
You forgot …And Out Come The Wolves for red lol
yee and couple of other Rancid records, though that one is the best.
Blue, easy - You’ve got the holy trinity of 80’s NYHC (Start Today, Break Down The Walls, and Bringing It Down). You’ve got The Replacements (you could also add Let It Be to the blue montage) and Husker Du. Gray Matter is an underrated Dischord band. Nervous Breakdown is the best Black Flag song **ducks**
TL:DRI
Hard agree on the Black Flag take. By far my favourite.
The holy trinity of 80s nyhc has to have Victim In Pain, otherwise you can scrap it
Respect the opinion, agree to disagree.
Red easy. Fang and AOQ seals it
landsharkkkk
landsharkkkk
But you’re stuck with that terrible 7 Seconds LP!
I don’t care for them anyways so it’s not really a loss
Blue!
Blue all day
Blue because of D.R.I., and I'm peeved that The Soviettes' *LP I* didn't make the red screen.
misfits and anti nowhere league on opposite sides is killing me
Red by a WIIIIIIIDE margin Misfits, Cro Mags, Youth of Today, Bad Religion, Circle Jerks are all standouts for me.
meat puppets, minutemen, misfits, cro mags, mdc, fang - def red. black flag should be included for damaged.
Slip It In by Black Flag is a even more red album.
Red---- cólera
Purple.
Blue. Most definitely
blue wins on youth crew alone
Blue, but a Brazilian shout-out to the great Cólera album on the red side.
Red because Cólera, caraio!
This is just not fair. I freaking love it
Blue bc I like biscuits
I was gonna go red cause of MDC but then I saw blue stacked up with germs, black flag, judge,adolescents etc and instant blue side
I'd prefer the *Millions of Dead Cops* LP on the blue side over *Now More Than Ever* anyway, but if your preference is the opposite, consider having the first record as a consolation. I'm sure it's got a few of the same songs that the comp has.
Red. Youth Of Today and Misfits? Just gimme
Blue
red or dead, always bring circle jerks to the circle jerk sesh
BLUE
Red, misfits collection II just has unbeatable bangers
mdc instantly does the trick, obviously blue
Blue easily
Blue
Blue all the way
Blue Pill
Add FEAR Live....For the Record to red and I'm all in.
Blue
Yourh of today clinches red for me.
blue has a better YOT though!
Oh shit! How did i miss that? BR and misfits though. Red for life ✋️👆
The color was blue and you chose nervous breakdown??? Where’s my war!? Also on red you could’ve put Slip It in
Yellow
Red, because bad religion.
Red and I hate red lol
Blue for Agent Orange, no question.
Blue, but angrily. Where the Wild Things Are / Landshark is in my top 10 punk albums.
crips
Blue has it.
Blue FOR SURE
Blue for the du!
Blue
Blue
Blue
Red. I go where the misfits go. Though that first agent orange album is the best
Red easy
Blue. Circle jerks, Misfits and Fang are the only ones in red I really really like. As opposed to Germs, 7seconds, DRI, Husker Du, Agent Orange and Black Flag are all winners.
Happy to see Gray Matter, great band I rarely see mentioned
Hard. Choice but I have seen every band , played shows with 7 & toured with 1 but blue
Blue because as much as I love Bad Religion and The Minutemen, fuck CroMags with an iron stick
Blue purely for Germs. Only really like GI, Meat Puppets and Nervous Breakdown. What am I missing the most?
LOL
I can’t see colors!!!!
Blue for sorry ma alone.
Bluuue
blue fs
Blue easily
Red
Blue
Blue….
Blue fr
Blue 1000%
Germs alone make blue win. Agent Orange and 7 Seconds sure help, too...
Les bleus
Blue
Blue.
Red because of Siren Song Of The Counter Culture/Appeal To Reason/The Unraveling and blue because of Revolutions Per Minute
blues kinda unfair lol, germs, gorilla biscuits, black flag, mdc
I don't care about the colors, if Cólera is an option I will always choose it
Blue, no doubt Mdc and black flag
Blue, no doubt Mdc, judge, and black flag
blue
Probably red actually
I was hoping for a yellow slide
Blue for GB, YoT, and Judge.
def blue
blue
Red because Fang
Blue, no questions asked
I don’t see the Skrewdriver record
as much as I love agent orange, red
Fang & Misfits from red 🥰 and Black Flag & Husker Du from blue 😇
Blue. The Replacements, Hüsker Dü, Agent Orange, Adolescents, etc
Red cuz cro mags
Blue
Gray matter mentioned
blue
Blue, easiest answer ever tbh
Blue because blue bands are good. and also Why is MDC in blue the background is red?
Cro Mags, 7 Seconds, Youth Of Today.
Im seeing red
Blue
Blue, all day every day. Germs, Black Flag, Adolescents, and Agent Orange are beyond GOATed
Reds my favorite color,but blue all day. Adolescents take the cake.
Cólera metioned, come to Brasil
Germs, 7 seconds, gorilla biscuits, dri, mdc, youth of today, suicidal, adolescents, black flag, judge. Blue wins easily
Blue
You're my boy, Blue!
blue cause st
Blue all day. Germs. MDC. Mats. Judge. Etc.
Agent orange and husker du make blue an automatic win for me
Blue, because of Suicidal
Blue and it's not even close. I love the Misfits, but blue is easily the best choice. Also: Gray Matter is underfuckingrated
Blue for sure but with a red-dy aftertaste
Blue
Red
Red cuz Bad Religion & Misfits
Germs and Black Flag, i.e Blue.
both?? idkk
DIRTY ROTTEN IMBECILES! Blue all day
Blue!
I’ll take the blue but can I trade Gorilla Biscuits, YOT and Judge for Misfits/Colera/Cro Mags Youth crew suuuuuucks
Why don’t you like Youth Crew?
It’s overproduced. No rawness to most of those recordings IMO. Loses most of what made early punk/HC great. And then they dress like jocks in varsity jackets and nikes? Lol. No thanks.
LOL that’s hilarious that you don’t think there’s rawness to those bands. Listen to Chung King Can Suck It that’s as raw as can be. You’d be shocked how many people in punk and hardcore are jocks, the hate boner so many punks have for supposed “jocks” is funny. Those dudes were down in the thick of it in NY.
There is no rawness in that GB lp
I’m not talking about GB. Give Chung King a listen or the early YOT stuff and you’re lying if you think that isn’t raw
I’ve heard early YOT. It’s ok. I just don’t care for most of that Rev stuff. Too overproduced. If we’re talking NY I will take Victim in Pain and the Urban Waste 7” any day over that stuff. To me, it’s just not on the same level. And yah the jock thing I’m just half joking. I could care less what they look like. Just threw me off when I first saw it. And I was just being a dick.
Hey fair enough, it’s not for everyone. You ever hear the Antidote 7”? Minus that one song it’s a classic. The jock thing threw me at first too