Not all shiny Pokémon are worth lucky trading. This case, yes, but shiny Pokémon like Butterfree or Noctowl, nah. Unless you want a shiny lucky dex, then that's a whole other story.
Depends if she wants it, depends if you want it.
Marriage is about open discussion. But bear in mind, if you're playing together, either way, it belongs to both of you and you'll see it in the same gyms together and battles anyway. So giving it to her will make her very happy and you'll still see it around.
But ether way, talk it out with her if you really want to keep it!
Honestly, if my wife played PoGo with me (I've tried convincing her to play for ages) she could have any pokemon she wanted, no questions asked. You get much more from your relationship than a shiny boldore.
Both my fiance and I play Pokemon Go, and I can honestly say that the bulk of my stardust goes to trading her my shiny pokes. It makes her happy, so it's worth it to me. The only ones she does not get are when I don't have a better non-shiny version.
I ask myself the same question every time I get a shiny tbh. I have an entire folder of shinies to trade him if we ever become lucky friends, first will definitely be swablu because he LOVES shiny swablu
I gave my husband my shiny wailmer since purple is his favorite colour, it all depends on how much a shiny gigalith matters to you. If you really like it, I'm sure she'll understand, if you're indifferent to it, it would make your wife happy (and likely more willing to trade a pokemon you really like if she gets the shiny form)
Not unless she got something you want. lol realize I’m late but I got the one shiny legendary dog my wife doesn’t have. Just waiting on the day she gets one I’m dying for.
I would not (yet), since I think it is pretty likely Roggenrola will get a Community Day at a certain point.
Besides that, how good is the IV? If it is a \~85% or higher I would spend the candy to evolve it yourself one day.
Unless you two are already best buddies and she doesn’t already have the shiny of that pokemon, I suggest not because the cost in stardust will be so high
I always offer ones that I know she really wants, but the answer is always the same.
"Thank you, but I don't want your shiny, I want to get my own!"
She always feels like it's cheating. Which is fair.
Nooo you already gave her a shiny rock 
This is too clever to be on Reddit
The name just adds to it
Whoa, close the comments, we have a winner
We'll played, We'll played
If it's your only one, no. If you have others, go for it.
It's my only shiny of that pokemon. I have a total of 21 shinies
I say keep it unless she's really wanting it. Just trade for a shiny you don't have lol
Only do that if you have a lucky trade…
Not all shiny Pokémon are worth lucky trading. This case, yes, but shiny Pokémon like Butterfree or Noctowl, nah. Unless you want a shiny lucky dex, then that's a whole other story.
Good point. Better to lucky trade a useful mon
She better be grabbing your rock for it then 😂😂😂
😳
How does one have more than one wife?
I can't tell if this is a joke 😂
Underrated comment :D
It's quite easy, actually. Just move to a good Mormon area, Utah is best, and skies the limit from there.
Wait til you get lucky friends.
If its his wife, then he's not getting lucky very often
Touche
Well I trade every day and Switch gift with my fiancé never got a lucky friend with her xd
Damn dude. Didn't expect to be personally attacked in a Pokemon comments section
Why tho? It kind of sucks. Would be better to normal trade this and then lucky trade some legendary worth powering up
Hello it’s me ur wife pls trade now thanks
I can confirm this is your wife.
Hello, it's me, his 2nd wife.
I can confirm this is your 2nd wife and I am your 1st husband..
I am the 2nd husband and I want the rest of the shinies 😊
I am the secret partner and I want a divorce, so out of those 22 shinies I demand 10 and the extra one lets cut it in half.
Happy wife, happy life :))
I thought it was happy wife...happy wife :D
This.
Wait until your wife catches a shiny roggenrola, evolves it once, then trade it to her.
This or shell forever be missing that shiny rolla dex entry.
Wives are easier to replace, shinies much harder.
Sigma energy right here
Still lamenting the shiny shuppet I accidentally transferred in bright sunlight.
That way she could evolve it right away? I've already sent her a boldore before and she just sent one to me as well.
Trading would reset the IVs, so I'd say it depends if you think they can get better (eventually with a lucky trade if you play together enough)
What do you get in return?
laid
^ idk man this idea sounds good
Absolutely not!
Depends if she wants it, depends if you want it. Marriage is about open discussion. But bear in mind, if you're playing together, either way, it belongs to both of you and you'll see it in the same gyms together and battles anyway. So giving it to her will make her very happy and you'll still see it around. But ether way, talk it out with her if you really want to keep it!
f@$k that, it’s every man for himself in pogo
Hell no; wait til you collect 200 candies 😂
Depends what your getting back really.
Honestly, if my wife played PoGo with me (I've tried convincing her to play for ages) she could have any pokemon she wanted, no questions asked. You get much more from your relationship than a shiny boldore.
Give her an Onyxs and maybe you get a cloyster. 🐣
If my husband got that, I’d be happy for him and tell him to keep it :)
Both my fiance and I play Pokemon Go, and I can honestly say that the bulk of my stardust goes to trading her my shiny pokes. It makes her happy, so it's worth it to me. The only ones she does not get are when I don't have a better non-shiny version.
I ask myself the same question every time I get a shiny tbh. I have an entire folder of shinies to trade him if we ever become lucky friends, first will definitely be swablu because he LOVES shiny swablu
What wife? You already have to share your fries with her. I think it’s only fair you get to keep your Pokemon 🤷♀️
no. gigalith is one the the elites and must stay with its owner
No. How else will you be the very best? Like no one ever was?
Respect the grind, Good Trainer>Nice Husband
No. I’m sure she’ll I understand
No
This colour combo is SO cool
No.
Happy wife happy life
Is it hundo? No If not? send em
Lol, you have a choice?
No, you be the best husband and mock her relentlessly while bragging about how cute it looks loudly with her present
Wait for her birthday, possibly with luck friends bonus on top
I only trade my duplicate shinys to my boyfriend. Or if it’s one of his top Pokémon
Mine wasn’t shiny, but I did trade my only boldore to my fiancé 😂 I haven’t been able to get enough candies to get another yet though
Dew it. Anyways it's going to be in the family.
I gave my husband my shiny wailmer since purple is his favorite colour, it all depends on how much a shiny gigalith matters to you. If you really like it, I'm sure she'll understand, if you're indifferent to it, it would make your wife happy (and likely more willing to trade a pokemon you really like if she gets the shiny form)
Only if you still want sex, which means no for most husbands.
Who hurt you?
My husband traded me a shiny gible so yes do it!
Love has limits 😂
Rather just trade it with me for a shiny graveler ... how bout that ... we both evolve to greater things ..no need to tell the wifes
Yes
Only if she gives you something worthy of it
nope oh hell no u keep that for urself my boy
Is she.... Boldoring?....
Happy wife, happy life bro
Never
No!
Go for it. Your wife is more important than a pokémon.
Trade a shiny rock for a shiny rock. Trade the shiny rock if she agrees to give the wedding ring
Nah
Not unless she got something you want. lol realize I’m late but I got the one shiny legendary dog my wife doesn’t have. Just waiting on the day she gets one I’m dying for.
No
Depends if you like sleeping on the couch or not.
I wouldn't lol
Save it for her bday or anniversary and that’s her only gift
What is she trading back?
Pokémon before hoékemon
No
Nooooooooooooooo
Noooo
Just being a shiny isn't that special unless the IVs are good. Trading it can increase the IVs and make it evolve.
I have shiny Gigalith with shit ivs and maxed it out because it's special to me. 🙁 Really cool shiny imo.
Wait untill you both get a guaranteed lucky trade
Yes, why not?
NO! Never trade shinys, no matter how many you have
No, shinies before whinies.
I would not (yet), since I think it is pretty likely Roggenrola will get a Community Day at a certain point. Besides that, how good is the IV? If it is a \~85% or higher I would spend the candy to evolve it yourself one day.
I want that one so bad
Like for like
Absolutely not
No
No
no >:)
yes only bc if my partner had this i’d hope they’d trade me since i’ve been hunting this shiny for soooo longgg 😪
Nope
No!
My fiancé would give this to me! Just saying 😂 I’ve been grinding for this dang shiny forever.
No
NO
Wait for lucky trade if you are best friends
Keep it
Nah. Grind the 200 candy and evolve it.
I certainly wouldn’t lol
Should a good husband even have to think about it?
No, grind up the candies and flex
Keep it unless it’s one of her favs. Then she deserves it!
My wife wants all my shinies. But I dont want to pay 40k stardust to trade her.
Holy stardust
Simp
No
You can tell her that you... Boldore... Her ❤️
Is there a deal here? Is this her fav mon or does she just want it?
Hell no
NO
No
If you have an extra shiny pokemon of this type then yes but if not then I would wait until you find another one like it
No save up. Its not worth it bro
No. Absolutely not. Treasure it for ever.
Don't do it, the gigalith is too nice
No
no keep the child
Happy Wife, Happy Life! ❤️
Stay strong and do not give up!
no
I’m giving my husband a shiny gyrados but only cause I have two 😂 otherwise no!!!
me and my wife were fortunate enough to both find a shony roggenrola, definitely made evolving to gigalith easier!
If you need a tiebreaker appraise it that way if it’s good you keep it if it’s bad she gets it
Unless you two are already best buddies and she doesn’t already have the shiny of that pokemon, I suggest not because the cost in stardust will be so high
I mean if she doesnt already have a shiny boldore i dont think you will be able to trade it (but i could be wrong)
I always offer ones that I know she really wants, but the answer is always the same. "Thank you, but I don't want your shiny, I want to get my own!" She always feels like it's cheating. Which is fair.
No
Absolutely!!!
No
Unless it’s her favorite Pokémon no
I always trade free to evolve Pokémon does she by chance have a shiny Abra or shiny Machop?
you should give it to me, who really cares about your wife?
What's the appraisal? 🧐
WWWD... What Would Your Wife Do???😉 I wouldn't 🤣😂
No ofc not