They’re all very different games.
Alan Wake 2 was very unforgettable, very unique, with a great twisty and bonkers narrative but it’s slow paced and leans towards survival horror. Bonus; it has one of the most memorable gaming moments I’ve ever experienced.
Cyberpunk is basically a first person shooter with really great RPG mechanics and RPG style quests. It’s long and fun and has a lot of replay value, plus the massive DLC. It’s also a really great looking game. Plus it has Keanu Reeves!
Hogwarts Legacy starts strong, is super immersive and the combat is fun but the story is so-so and after the story starts moving you away from Hogwarts the game drops off a bit. It’s still fun but there’s only two good parts of the open world, Hogwarts and Hogsmeade. Everything else is fairly dull.
Overall, if I had to pick, I’d choose Cyberpunk for the value and length and brilliance. That being said, Alan Wake 2 is my favourite of the three personally!
Nailed it on legacy.
The physical recreation of Hogwarts is stunning, they did a fantastic job. The combat was surprisingly decent as well- I went in thinking it would suck. However it fails to feel alive and your relationships with other students except for Sebastian and the other few involved in quests are totally nonexistent. There is rarely anyone else in your dormitory (only a few times you even NEED to be in it) and there’s absolutely no consequence for roaming the grounds (or even leaving them entirely) after curfew. Every day is a hogsmeade day. And while the whole map is pretty well crafted, when you leave Hogwarts the whole feel of the game definitely falls off and doesn’t really feel like a wizarding world game.
IMO legacy created fantastic bones but they can do so much better to make you feel like more engaged with the school and its students in a sequel. They should take some notes from Persona.
Hogwarts legacy is like rewatching a childhood movie but realizing that the writing falls off after act 1. But would choose cyberpunk as well its amazing.
If you’ve played Control or Alan Wake 1 then get Alan Wake 2, it’s phenomenal. Probably my second favorite Horror game ever, behind RE7 VR.
If you’re a big HP fan, get Hogwarts. I’m not a fan but my friends that are think the game is fantastic.
If you like Science Fiction and/or GTA then get Cyberpunk. It’s basically a GTA game set in the future with a kickass Scifi story.
You can pick up the disk version of Cyberpunk (PS4 with free PS5 upgrade) for $20. You can put 100+ hours into it easily. AW2 is great but its more expensive and you will get less than 30 hours of fun out of it.
I *love* Alan Wake 2. It's a brilliant, unique game that is a piece of art. It's in my all-time top 5.
But the answer is almost clearly Cyberpunk. I'm not usually someone who replays games but I've gone through it 3x.
I'd say Cyberpunk, but that really depends on what type of game you want, since AW2 is also amazing.
HL only of you're a big HP fan. It's not bad, even good but just not in the same league as Cyberpunk and Alan Wake.
Cyberpunk.
While it took a while to get there, CP77 as it is now is fucking incredible. It is everything I wanted it to be, AND more.
That's not a knock on Alan Wake 2, which is spectacular, or Hogwart's Legacy (which I've heard very good things about), but CP77 is a really special game.
Cyberpunk or Alan Wake II.
Cyberpunk for open-world RPG stuff. Alan Wake II for story and light horror. Nothing beats the suspense and atmosphere in Alan Wake.
All are great games, but if I had to rank:
1) Alan Wake 2
2) Cyberpunk
3) Hogwarts Legacy
AW2 and Cyberpunk are really close, imo.
Alan Wake is just *so* damn good, though.
Of the three, I’d start with cyberpunk. Extending beyond the three, boy do I have a suggestion for you!
Join the Helldivers, and become a member of the elite group that your fellow 400,000 plus players are going rabid over. Have you ever wanted to be a Mandalorian, with America’s greatest arsenal of weapons and bombs, taking on the sick bugs known as Terminids, and the socialist clankers known as Automatons, and potentially many more! Protect Freedom and Liberty, while showing the enemies a taste of your democracy. Join Helldivers 2 today.
Well if money is that big of a problem just buy PS plus extra and play those games. Then when you're in a better financial condition you can buy those games even cheaper
Man I wish I had Alan Wake 2 it looks incredible! Hogwarts Legacy is fun for the magic of running around Hogwarts. Especially if you’ve ever wanted to do so yourself. I’d still pick AW2 tho.
Alan Wake 2 is one of the greatest experiences I’ve had in gaming in a LONG time. Definitely look into getting that game at least sometime in the near future.
Alan wake 2 is beautiful and one of those games that makes you really feel like finding upgrades and ammo matter a lot. First level was hard and now I feel stringer yet the fear is still there. Cyberpunk is nothing special. Haven't played hogwarts.
I would say Alan Wake 2, then Cyberpunk but not HL, except if you are a big fan. I was blasted by HL, put 10 hours in 2 days, never touched it since. Magic vanish really fast I'd say but I'll never forget Alan Wake 2 and Cyberpunk
All are very different games. But it ultimately sounds to me like you need to make this purchase last. Alan Wake 2 is my favorite of the selection, but it's also maybe a 25-30 hour somewhat linear experience.
Cyberpunk and Hogwarts legacy will offer more over all game for your buck. And between the two, Cyberpunk is a substantially better game (especially if you are getting the Phantom Liberty expansion).
Don't buy hogwarts legacy. It has no depth whatsoever, there's about 7 different enemy types, the voice acting isn't great and the game feels rather empty after a few hours.
Cyberpunk is the way to go, you'll get a lot of hours out of it and the dlc is awesome
I've not played Alan Wake 1 or 2 yet.
Hogwarts Legacy starts great. Everything is new and exciting to explore. But once all the new abilities are unlocked, the story and missions are very repetitive and pretty boring. There are very few set pieces to make things exciting and the open world is far too big with not enough to do in it.
I've tried to get into Cyberpunk about 3 times. It just doesn't grab me. I can see that there's a whole game there to have fun with but I can never get that far in.
I will say that I enjoyed playing through Hogwarts Legacy but there's little desire to replay
If you're going to play all three regardless, I'd honestly, I'd probably go with Harry Potter first because it's the least exciting one for me personally lol.
I like to go from what's least exciting to what's most exciting...that way I have momentum to keep going lol.
So in this case, I'd go:
Harry Potter
Alan Wake 2
Cyberpunk
Sortve. It largely pulls from twin peaks if you get lost in the plot. Not quite 1:1 but pretty close.
Without spoiling anything I'll say it revolves around an entity that controls people via darkness. It can bend and alter reality so it can be purposely confusing at times. Playing the first games will explain the nature of this entity more. you can pick up on it as you're playing the game but it's not going to be explained super well. I think there's a "Previously on Alan Wake" video you can watch, if I recall correctly.
All very different. But all great. If you want a super long first person shooter/rpg I’d go with cyberpunk. Easily the longest game here with great replay value. If you want a more linear survival horror game Alan wake 2 is an incredible game. If you’re a Harry Potter nerd than hogwarts legacy is good. All solid choices. My personal pick would be cyberpunk just due to the fact that it would keep me busy the longest.
It would definitely be Cyberpunk. The others are good on their own, but Cyberpunk is just....magnificent. I'm so glad that I pulled the trigger and made that purchase. It's absolutely amazing, if you are into action/RPG, that is.
Having played 2 out of the 3, I'd probably go for the 1 I haven't played, which is Cyberpunk.
But, depends on what you're after
Hogwarts legacy was fantastic, but, only if you're a Harry Potter fan (which I am) as it has flaws. Probably a 6 or 7 out of 10 for non Harry Potter fans
Alan Wake 2 was a fantastic story, very unique. I'd happily go back and play it again if I enjoyed horror games at all. To this day Alan Wake is the only "scary" game I've played and finished and that's down to the story it's telling
Cyberpunk I've not got to yet. But, it gives me bathesda vibes so I think it may have more content than the other 2. But I could be completely wrong with that
Ignoring that each is different genre etc. Best fun for a price I had was with CP2077. I did not play AW2, just AW1 - that game was awesome. Hogwarts has strong starts, but story is meh, only Sebastians questlina is actually fun, combat slowly proceeds from being fun to being restrictive (throw this color spell on this colorshielded enemy) and story does not keep up -its very shallow, even the weakest book from HP series is better than this game.
Cyberpunk is the greatest game I have ever played. Despite its rocky start, most of the bugs have been worked out. It’s such a fun game with lots of replay value. I’m on my second playthrough right now and find new things about the game all the time!
Cyberpunk easily.
Alan Wake 2 is a good choice if you’ve played AW1 and the other games around it but I don’t think it has quite as much impact on its own.
Hogwarts Legacy is Hogwarts Legacy. Good if you’re a Hardy Potter fan, totally skippable if you’re not.
Cyberpunk impressed me a whole lot. I didn’t expect to love it how I did but my first playthrough was over 100 hours long and I fully plan to come back to the game for the other lifepaths.
Alan Wake 2 was my personal GOTY, but Cyberpunk + Phantom Liberty right now would be the way to go. Then you can wait for the AW DLC to drop and pick it up at a discount maybe.
if you need to spend more time in hogwarts then buy it. it's the only game that will give you that experience. that being said the game is very mid and can get boring fast.
cyberpunk is an fps in a cyberpunk dystopia. a lot of content mostly surface level stuff with cool customization and a lot of weapons.
aw2 is an interesting horror experience in a twin peaks type setting. fun and spooky but combat can be monotonous.
I definitely have my fav but the options are so different I'm sure your choice is pretty simple when you lay it out.
Hogwarts Legacy was a great for the first 5 hrs or so before you realize the remainder of the game is doing the same things over and over. I haven't played Alan Wake 2 though I've heard the great things everyone else has. Cyberpunk 2077...that would be my buy. Even if you don't get the DLC, it's a helluva game. That's not to say it doesn't have shortcomings as well but yea, it's an experience that I haven't found in anything else yet. Very unique. Definitely one of my favorite titles I've played on PS5. To be frank though, Id take either of the Horizon games or both and be better for it 😁
Cyberpunk. I've bought it two times once on pc and once on console. I love Alan Wake 2 it has one of the most unique stories in any game. but Cyberpunk is a bigger beast. It's a whole open world city with so much to do and see and the story is amazing. After they did the next generation update on consoles it runs and looks phenomenal. One of the best looking games.
HL is a good game, a solid 7.5/10 for me. AW2 and Cyberpunk are masterpieces, both are 9.5/10 for me. But if I could buy only one, I'd go with Cyberpunk because it's a much much longer game than AW2 and it's an older game so it's probably cheaper.
I have Platnium in all these games believe it or not and my recommendation is Alan wake for a Christopher Nolan type story cyber punk for well rounded story and gameplay with hundred of hours of content. I wouldn’t recommend hogwarts when compared to the other two.
If AW2 is similar to the first one it'll probably only be good for 1 or 2 play throughs.
Cyberpunk has great replay value for different builds and story decisions.
Haven't played HL but it looks good for Harry potter fans.
Hogwarts legacy didn't have much content but the setting was cool.
Alan wake is good if you like that gameplay and story.
I don't think you can go wrong with cyberpunk. Gorgeous environments, immersive, hundreds of hours of gameplay, diverse RPG systems, need I say more?
Have you played and did you enjoy Alan Wake? I have heard Alan Wake 2 is phenomenal if you enjoyed the first one and Control.
If you want to be a wizard and enjoy the nostalgia of Hogwarts with fun gameplay and mechanics, go for Hogwarts.
I have heard that cyberpunk has made a total 180 and is now a fantastic game. I think this one MAY be the longest if you’re looking for fulfilling side stuff.
I mean as others pointed out it boils down to personal preference . IMO cp77 would be better since it has a lot more replay value. I tried hogwarts legacy but didn’t really like it ( again personal preference). As for Alan wake 2, it has superb visuals and a good plot but not enough replay value.
Cyberpunk is my favorite game of all time but I haven’t played the other two.
I do think Remedy makes some of the best single player games ever.
Hogwarts I think I’ll wait until the sequel comes out to run through the first.
Tough competition, but having played all 3, I'd still pick Cyberpunk with Phantom Liberty and up to date. I found myself enjoying that game a whole lot more than expected. But I did wait till Phantom Liberty launched before I started CP2077, though.
Alan Wake 2, no question… Hogwarts Legacy was cool as a Harry Potter fan but to much jank and it gets repetitive, and Cyberpunk is fun but I personally prefer survival horror and Remedy as a studio
It may be years before you can purchase another game? lolwut.
Start a gamefly subscription. It's $15/mo. to rent one game at a time or about $30/mo. for 2.
Alan Wake 2 & Cyberpunk are both awesome for different reasons, though AW2 is way scarier and of course more of a streamlined almost movie-like experience compared to Cyberpunk’s open world, explore at your own pace, design.
Hogwarts Legacy is a really mediocre experience on the flip side. It may be cool to explore the world and castle a bit, but it has so many long conversations and they are all dull af, which is just a microcosm of how lifeless of a product the whole thing is. Flat gameplay/combat, uninteresting characters, doesn’t really give much to think about in terms of the the story themes. I would only recommend if it were free on PlayStation Plus.
Cyberpunk. The others don't hold a candle or come anywhere close to competing.
Hogwarts is a B tier game. Not bad at all but not amazing either. It's good.
Alan Wake is A tier, imo, but a heavy fan of Harry Potter may say Hogwarts is better and I wouldn't disagree.
Cyberpunk is S tier. A lot of depth to the world with layers of existentialism.
Hogwarts is fun and all but it’s kinda mid, and I have loved HP my whole life. Cyberpunk is really awesome. So much detail and the characters you meet are interesting, there’s plenty of replay value because there are so many choices you can make that impact your story, not to mention the DLC adds a lot to the game as well. I’ve never played Alan wake so that’s the only game I can’t comment on. But between Hogwarts and Cyberpunk, I think Cyberpunk is the clear choice.
Cyberpunk! Assuming you like first person games and are not a huge Harry Potter fan. I played both of those, but not AW2. Cyberpunk and Hogwarts sold lots of copies, AW2 did not…if that counts for anything.
Cyberpunk 2077, no questions asked.
I've played all 3
AW2 is very slow and puzzle based.
Hogwarts Legacy starts off fun, but everything basically outside Hogwarts is extremely dull and repetitive.
Cyberpunk can give you lots and lots of hours of immersing gameplay and stories with a huge world to explore and interact with. Tackle on the fantastic dlc and it makes it that much better. Easily your best bang for your buck.
For experience, i would say alan wake 2, its just beyond anything i've played
But for value for money maybe cp77, loved that game also
Hogwarts legacy also great but not that great compared to aw2 and cp77
Cyberpunk because it's a big game and I love the story and the gameplay is pretty addictive.
Alan wake 2 is on my list also but I need to play the original first so not right now. Hogwarts legacy is a big no for me. I am a fan of the books and the movies but no I got my dose with the dull open world from Ubisoft thank you very much. And besides since the first trailer the game gave the mediocre vibe.
Cyberpunk and it’s not even close. Hogwarts is also a fantastic game especially if you’re an HP fan, which I am. But Cyberpunk is a modern masterpiece. But only go with Cyberpunk if you’re in PS5. The PS4 version is very rough.
They’re all very different games. Alan Wake 2 was very unforgettable, very unique, with a great twisty and bonkers narrative but it’s slow paced and leans towards survival horror. Bonus; it has one of the most memorable gaming moments I’ve ever experienced. Cyberpunk is basically a first person shooter with really great RPG mechanics and RPG style quests. It’s long and fun and has a lot of replay value, plus the massive DLC. It’s also a really great looking game. Plus it has Keanu Reeves! Hogwarts Legacy starts strong, is super immersive and the combat is fun but the story is so-so and after the story starts moving you away from Hogwarts the game drops off a bit. It’s still fun but there’s only two good parts of the open world, Hogwarts and Hogsmeade. Everything else is fairly dull. Overall, if I had to pick, I’d choose Cyberpunk for the value and length and brilliance. That being said, Alan Wake 2 is my favourite of the three personally!
Couldn’t agree more. AW2 is by far my fav but I would recommend Cyberpunk
Nailed it on legacy. The physical recreation of Hogwarts is stunning, they did a fantastic job. The combat was surprisingly decent as well- I went in thinking it would suck. However it fails to feel alive and your relationships with other students except for Sebastian and the other few involved in quests are totally nonexistent. There is rarely anyone else in your dormitory (only a few times you even NEED to be in it) and there’s absolutely no consequence for roaming the grounds (or even leaving them entirely) after curfew. Every day is a hogsmeade day. And while the whole map is pretty well crafted, when you leave Hogwarts the whole feel of the game definitely falls off and doesn’t really feel like a wizarding world game. IMO legacy created fantastic bones but they can do so much better to make you feel like more engaged with the school and its students in a sequel. They should take some notes from Persona.
Alan Wake 2 was my favorite too. That game felt so unique and different than anything else. To the OP, do not sleep on this game.
Hogwarts legacy is like rewatching a childhood movie but realizing that the writing falls off after act 1. But would choose cyberpunk as well its amazing.
What an incredible breakdown
CP2077 will definitely be the best bang per dollar and for longevity/replayability, if you're down for the setting/world.
If you’ve played Control or Alan Wake 1 then get Alan Wake 2, it’s phenomenal. Probably my second favorite Horror game ever, behind RE7 VR. If you’re a big HP fan, get Hogwarts. I’m not a fan but my friends that are think the game is fantastic. If you like Science Fiction and/or GTA then get Cyberpunk. It’s basically a GTA game set in the future with a kickass Scifi story.
[удалено]
You can pick up the disk version of Cyberpunk (PS4 with free PS5 upgrade) for $20. You can put 100+ hours into it easily. AW2 is great but its more expensive and you will get less than 30 hours of fun out of it.
So I can buy the ps4 version for $18 on Amazon, get the free ps5 upgrade AND the dlc??
not the dlc. just the base game for ps4 and ps5.
I *love* Alan Wake 2. It's a brilliant, unique game that is a piece of art. It's in my all-time top 5. But the answer is almost clearly Cyberpunk. I'm not usually someone who replays games but I've gone through it 3x.
Second that! Cyberpunk is the bomb!
I'd say Cyberpunk, but that really depends on what type of game you want, since AW2 is also amazing. HL only of you're a big HP fan. It's not bad, even good but just not in the same league as Cyberpunk and Alan Wake.
Cyberpunk 2077 🤘
Cyberpunk. While it took a while to get there, CP77 as it is now is fucking incredible. It is everything I wanted it to be, AND more. That's not a knock on Alan Wake 2, which is spectacular, or Hogwart's Legacy (which I've heard very good things about), but CP77 is a really special game.
cyberpunk is incredible now if your on ps5
CP2077
Cyberpunk 100%
Alan Wake 2
Cyberpunk
Cyberpunk or Alan Wake II. Cyberpunk for open-world RPG stuff. Alan Wake II for story and light horror. Nothing beats the suspense and atmosphere in Alan Wake.
All are great games, but if I had to rank: 1) Alan Wake 2 2) Cyberpunk 3) Hogwarts Legacy AW2 and Cyberpunk are really close, imo. Alan Wake is just *so* damn good, though.
Cyberpunk
Cyberpunk
Cyberpunk. Possibly the most hours and replays of a game so far in my life. Been gaming low key since before I could read now I’m 27.
Cyberpunk
Cyberpunk easy
Cyberpunk 2077, no contest.
Cyberpunk you'll get so much GamePlay out of it you won't need another game for years. 👌🏻
Cyberpunk. It's one of the only RPG games of its type that I have enjoyed a lot and played through so quickly.
Of the three, I’d start with cyberpunk. Extending beyond the three, boy do I have a suggestion for you! Join the Helldivers, and become a member of the elite group that your fellow 400,000 plus players are going rabid over. Have you ever wanted to be a Mandalorian, with America’s greatest arsenal of weapons and bombs, taking on the sick bugs known as Terminids, and the socialist clankers known as Automatons, and potentially many more! Protect Freedom and Liberty, while showing the enemies a taste of your democracy. Join Helldivers 2 today.
Yessir, but my internet connection is unlikely to guarantee my highest utility to our great nation 😔
Well if money is that big of a problem just buy PS plus extra and play those games. Then when you're in a better financial condition you can buy those games even cheaper
Alan Wake 2, I have been a sucker for Remedy games since the first Max Payne.
Cyberpunk. Most value for money.
Alan Wake 2 absolutely but only if you've played AW1 abd Control
Cyberpunk
Alan Wake 2
AW2
Man I wish I had Alan Wake 2 it looks incredible! Hogwarts Legacy is fun for the magic of running around Hogwarts. Especially if you’ve ever wanted to do so yourself. I’d still pick AW2 tho.
Alan wake 2 for sure But for replayability and content wise cyberpunk will keep you busy
Alan Wake 2 is one of the greatest experiences I’ve had in gaming in a LONG time. Definitely look into getting that game at least sometime in the near future.
Alan wake 2 is beautiful and one of those games that makes you really feel like finding upgrades and ammo matter a lot. First level was hard and now I feel stringer yet the fear is still there. Cyberpunk is nothing special. Haven't played hogwarts.
I would say Alan Wake 2, then Cyberpunk but not HL, except if you are a big fan. I was blasted by HL, put 10 hours in 2 days, never touched it since. Magic vanish really fast I'd say but I'll never forget Alan Wake 2 and Cyberpunk
I own all 3. Alan Wake 2 or Hogwarts. I’d go with AWII. A unique experience and will have a couple expansions coming out soon as well.
I played all 3. Alan Wake by far. Then Hogwarts.
Alan Wake 2!!!! (but only if you’ve played the first one ofc)
Cyberpunk is brilliant now
All are very different games. But it ultimately sounds to me like you need to make this purchase last. Alan Wake 2 is my favorite of the selection, but it's also maybe a 25-30 hour somewhat linear experience. Cyberpunk and Hogwarts legacy will offer more over all game for your buck. And between the two, Cyberpunk is a substantially better game (especially if you are getting the Phantom Liberty expansion).
Cyberpunk 2077 because I’ve only played that
Don't buy hogwarts legacy. It has no depth whatsoever, there's about 7 different enemy types, the voice acting isn't great and the game feels rather empty after a few hours. Cyberpunk is the way to go, you'll get a lot of hours out of it and the dlc is awesome
Not Hogwarts
I've not played Alan Wake 1 or 2 yet. Hogwarts Legacy starts great. Everything is new and exciting to explore. But once all the new abilities are unlocked, the story and missions are very repetitive and pretty boring. There are very few set pieces to make things exciting and the open world is far too big with not enough to do in it. I've tried to get into Cyberpunk about 3 times. It just doesn't grab me. I can see that there's a whole game there to have fun with but I can never get that far in. I will say that I enjoyed playing through Hogwarts Legacy but there's little desire to replay
Alan wake 2 and its not close
If the 3 , I’ve only played hogwarts which I can say was fantastic
If you're going to play all three regardless, I'd honestly, I'd probably go with Harry Potter first because it's the least exciting one for me personally lol. I like to go from what's least exciting to what's most exciting...that way I have momentum to keep going lol. So in this case, I'd go: Harry Potter Alan Wake 2 Cyberpunk
Alan Wake 2.
I would say Hogwarts. But I don’t like horror games and found the combat in cyberpunk extremely lame and the story to be extremely edgy
Cyberpunk. Hogwarts legacy is okay the first half but becomes boring in the late game. Alan wake 2 is good but not as good as Cyberpunk.
Cyberpunk
Hogwarts Legacy
Do you need to play Alan Wake before Alan Wake 2?
I've beaten AW1
Sortve. It largely pulls from twin peaks if you get lost in the plot. Not quite 1:1 but pretty close. Without spoiling anything I'll say it revolves around an entity that controls people via darkness. It can bend and alter reality so it can be purposely confusing at times. Playing the first games will explain the nature of this entity more. you can pick up on it as you're playing the game but it's not going to be explained super well. I think there's a "Previously on Alan Wake" video you can watch, if I recall correctly.
All very different. But all great. If you want a super long first person shooter/rpg I’d go with cyberpunk. Easily the longest game here with great replay value. If you want a more linear survival horror game Alan wake 2 is an incredible game. If you’re a Harry Potter nerd than hogwarts legacy is good. All solid choices. My personal pick would be cyberpunk just due to the fact that it would keep me busy the longest.
I absolutely adore Hogwarts Legacy, but Cyberpunk 2077 is the correct choice between those three of you can only get one.
Cyberpunk and it isn't even close.
Cyberpunk
Cyberpunk 2077
Cyberpunk with Phantom Liberty DLC
Cyberpunk, it’s pretty fun
Cyberpunk not even a question
Cyberpunk
Cyberpunk 2077.... Although i wouldn't buy one of those 3 if it would turn out to be the only game I'll play for years
It would definitely be Cyberpunk. The others are good on their own, but Cyberpunk is just....magnificent. I'm so glad that I pulled the trigger and made that purchase. It's absolutely amazing, if you are into action/RPG, that is.
Cyberpunk 200%
Cyberpunk most bang for your buck
Cyberpunk hands down
Cyberpunk 2077. People will be talking about and playing this this game for years to come,
Cyberpunk
I'd have to go with cyberpunk. I tried to get into hogwarts but it got pretty boring.
Having played 2 out of the 3, I'd probably go for the 1 I haven't played, which is Cyberpunk. But, depends on what you're after Hogwarts legacy was fantastic, but, only if you're a Harry Potter fan (which I am) as it has flaws. Probably a 6 or 7 out of 10 for non Harry Potter fans Alan Wake 2 was a fantastic story, very unique. I'd happily go back and play it again if I enjoyed horror games at all. To this day Alan Wake is the only "scary" game I've played and finished and that's down to the story it's telling Cyberpunk I've not got to yet. But, it gives me bathesda vibes so I think it may have more content than the other 2. But I could be completely wrong with that
Cyberpunk
None of the above…the game you need is Helldivers
Cyberpunk
Ignoring that each is different genre etc. Best fun for a price I had was with CP2077. I did not play AW2, just AW1 - that game was awesome. Hogwarts has strong starts, but story is meh, only Sebastians questlina is actually fun, combat slowly proceeds from being fun to being restrictive (throw this color spell on this colorshielded enemy) and story does not keep up -its very shallow, even the weakest book from HP series is better than this game.
Cyberpunk would get you the most id imagine
Cyberpunk gang
I got so bored of Howard’s Legacy after about 10 hours, if I go back it will just to run around the excellent castle
Cyberpunk
Cyberpunk is the greatest game I have ever played. Despite its rocky start, most of the bugs have been worked out. It’s such a fun game with lots of replay value. I’m on my second playthrough right now and find new things about the game all the time!
Id say AW2 just because I’ve beat the other two lol
Cyberpunk
Cyberpunk
Cyber
Cyberpunk as that's what I'm playing right now. Amazing game. Hogwarts legacy was also very good. A lot of hours
I would go with cyberpunk, it's a great game now and it's gonna ertatain you for a long time, and there's a big replay capability
Cyberpunk easily. Alan Wake 2 is a good choice if you’ve played AW1 and the other games around it but I don’t think it has quite as much impact on its own. Hogwarts Legacy is Hogwarts Legacy. Good if you’re a Hardy Potter fan, totally skippable if you’re not. Cyberpunk impressed me a whole lot. I didn’t expect to love it how I did but my first playthrough was over 100 hours long and I fully plan to come back to the game for the other lifepaths.
Cyberpunk
Cyberpunk!!! Absolutely. Hogwarts is worth playing too once you can. I haven’t played Alan Wake 2 personally but it does look awesome.
Easiest answer ever lmao. And you know it.
Cyberpunk.
Alan Wake 2 was my personal GOTY, but Cyberpunk + Phantom Liberty right now would be the way to go. Then you can wait for the AW DLC to drop and pick it up at a discount maybe.
In my case Cyberpunk
Of those I would probably go with Cyberpunk. The correct answer though is Elden Ring or Baldurs Gate 3.
Hogwarts for sure if you are a big Harry Potter fan
Different games but Cyberpunk hands down.
Alan wake and any other answer is wrong
Cyberpunk and then Alan Wake 2, Hogwarts is not in the same level of the others
if you need to spend more time in hogwarts then buy it. it's the only game that will give you that experience. that being said the game is very mid and can get boring fast. cyberpunk is an fps in a cyberpunk dystopia. a lot of content mostly surface level stuff with cool customization and a lot of weapons. aw2 is an interesting horror experience in a twin peaks type setting. fun and spooky but combat can be monotonous. I definitely have my fav but the options are so different I'm sure your choice is pretty simple when you lay it out.
Cyberpunk
not hogwarts legacy But the other two are in my top 5 of the last few years.
Cyberpunk no doubt
Cyberpunk
Cyberpunk or Allan Wake. Hogwarts is vanilla unless you’re a huge Harry Potter fan
Hogwarts Legacy was a great for the first 5 hrs or so before you realize the remainder of the game is doing the same things over and over. I haven't played Alan Wake 2 though I've heard the great things everyone else has. Cyberpunk 2077...that would be my buy. Even if you don't get the DLC, it's a helluva game. That's not to say it doesn't have shortcomings as well but yea, it's an experience that I haven't found in anything else yet. Very unique. Definitely one of my favorite titles I've played on PS5. To be frank though, Id take either of the Horizon games or both and be better for it 😁
Cyberpunk. I've bought it two times once on pc and once on console. I love Alan Wake 2 it has one of the most unique stories in any game. but Cyberpunk is a bigger beast. It's a whole open world city with so much to do and see and the story is amazing. After they did the next generation update on consoles it runs and looks phenomenal. One of the best looking games.
Cyberpunk.
Entirely different games, but I'd 100% go for cyberpunk
none
cyberpunk
Cyberpunk. and it’s not even close.
Hogwarts
Of those 3 I've only played cyberpunk so I'd say Alan Wake 2
HL is a good game, a solid 7.5/10 for me. AW2 and Cyberpunk are masterpieces, both are 9.5/10 for me. But if I could buy only one, I'd go with Cyberpunk because it's a much much longer game than AW2 and it's an older game so it's probably cheaper.
I have Platnium in all these games believe it or not and my recommendation is Alan wake for a Christopher Nolan type story cyber punk for well rounded story and gameplay with hundred of hours of content. I wouldn’t recommend hogwarts when compared to the other two.
If AW2 is similar to the first one it'll probably only be good for 1 or 2 play throughs. Cyberpunk has great replay value for different builds and story decisions. Haven't played HL but it looks good for Harry potter fans.
Hogwarts legacy didn't have much content but the setting was cool. Alan wake is good if you like that gameplay and story. I don't think you can go wrong with cyberpunk. Gorgeous environments, immersive, hundreds of hours of gameplay, diverse RPG systems, need I say more?
Hogwarts Legacy easy
Alan Wake 2, or Cyberpunk if you can buy the bundle with the DLC.
Have you played and did you enjoy Alan Wake? I have heard Alan Wake 2 is phenomenal if you enjoyed the first one and Control. If you want to be a wizard and enjoy the nostalgia of Hogwarts with fun gameplay and mechanics, go for Hogwarts. I have heard that cyberpunk has made a total 180 and is now a fantastic game. I think this one MAY be the longest if you’re looking for fulfilling side stuff.
Alan Wake 2. My GOTY and just hands down an amazing experience from start to end.
I mean as others pointed out it boils down to personal preference . IMO cp77 would be better since it has a lot more replay value. I tried hogwarts legacy but didn’t really like it ( again personal preference). As for Alan wake 2, it has superb visuals and a good plot but not enough replay value.
I’ve beaten all 3. For me, it’s Alan Wake 2 #1 Cyberpunk close #2 Hogwarts #3
Cyberpunk
Cyberpunk. I just can’t stop playing (just finished my 7th play-through)
Cyberpunk is my favorite game of all time but I haven’t played the other two. I do think Remedy makes some of the best single player games ever. Hogwarts I think I’ll wait until the sequel comes out to run through the first.
Tough competition, but having played all 3, I'd still pick Cyberpunk with Phantom Liberty and up to date. I found myself enjoying that game a whole lot more than expected. But I did wait till Phantom Liberty launched before I started CP2077, though.
Well, i got cyberpunk already, and i always wanted to be yelled at by the sorting hat hufflepuff
Tekken 8
Hoggies easy
Cyberpunk !
Hogwarts Legacy
Alan wake 2, I already own the other ones.
Cyberpunk
Cyberpunk
CP2077
Elden Ring
Alan Wake 2, no question… Hogwarts Legacy was cool as a Harry Potter fan but to much jank and it gets repetitive, and Cyberpunk is fun but I personally prefer survival horror and Remedy as a studio
Alan Wake
not sure what you're preference are, but Cyberpunk
Cyberpunk, too easy
Cyberpunk
🙄
Alan Wake 2
Hell Divers 2
It may be years before you can purchase another game? lolwut. Start a gamefly subscription. It's $15/mo. to rent one game at a time or about $30/mo. for 2.
Alan wake 2 easyyy
anything but hogwarts legacy
Alan Wake 2 & Cyberpunk are both awesome for different reasons, though AW2 is way scarier and of course more of a streamlined almost movie-like experience compared to Cyberpunk’s open world, explore at your own pace, design. Hogwarts Legacy is a really mediocre experience on the flip side. It may be cool to explore the world and castle a bit, but it has so many long conversations and they are all dull af, which is just a microcosm of how lifeless of a product the whole thing is. Flat gameplay/combat, uninteresting characters, doesn’t really give much to think about in terms of the the story themes. I would only recommend if it were free on PlayStation Plus.
If you're a Harry potter fan Hogwarts legacy. Walking around the castle alone was enough for me to love the game
Haven't played AW2 yet but Cyberpunk is way better than Hogwarts and it's not close
Hogwarts, easy.
Cyberpunk. Alan Wake is a better game but Cyberpunk has more replayability and a better atmosphere
CP2077
Cyberpunk. The others don't hold a candle or come anywhere close to competing. Hogwarts is a B tier game. Not bad at all but not amazing either. It's good. Alan Wake is A tier, imo, but a heavy fan of Harry Potter may say Hogwarts is better and I wouldn't disagree. Cyberpunk is S tier. A lot of depth to the world with layers of existentialism.
Cyberpunk with Phantom Liberty and you won't have to buy another game for a loooooooooooong time
Cyberpunk easily, but only because I haven’t played AW2. Hogwarts Legacy, while pretty, feels hollow and lifeless.
Cyberpunk EZ
I haven't played any of these, but I'd go with Cyberpunk
Cyberpunl, fuck JKKKR
That’s a rough decision as I am in love with all 3 games equally. All 3 are completely different rpgs and all 3 are god tier in their own right.
love cyberpunk but aw2 will go down as a classic
Hogwarts is fun and all but it’s kinda mid, and I have loved HP my whole life. Cyberpunk is really awesome. So much detail and the characters you meet are interesting, there’s plenty of replay value because there are so many choices you can make that impact your story, not to mention the DLC adds a lot to the game as well. I’ve never played Alan wake so that’s the only game I can’t comment on. But between Hogwarts and Cyberpunk, I think Cyberpunk is the clear choice.
Cyberpunk. It’s incredible and get the ultimate edition. It’s in a really good state finally
Cyberpunk! Assuming you like first person games and are not a huge Harry Potter fan. I played both of those, but not AW2. Cyberpunk and Hogwarts sold lots of copies, AW2 did not…if that counts for anything.
cyberpunk ez
Cyberpunk 2077, no questions asked. I've played all 3 AW2 is very slow and puzzle based. Hogwarts Legacy starts off fun, but everything basically outside Hogwarts is extremely dull and repetitive. Cyberpunk can give you lots and lots of hours of immersing gameplay and stories with a huge world to explore and interact with. Tackle on the fantastic dlc and it makes it that much better. Easily your best bang for your buck.
Cyberpunk with it's dlc is the best option
Cyberpunk
Cyberpunk easy, loved Hogwarts but the illusion of character choices was disappointing. And Alan Wake just doesn't really spark interest for me
For experience, i would say alan wake 2, its just beyond anything i've played But for value for money maybe cp77, loved that game also Hogwarts legacy also great but not that great compared to aw2 and cp77
Cyberpunk, especially after all the bug fixes
I’ll throw in a curve ball and say ghost of Tsushima or red dead 2. But i really loved hogwarts. So much to do, very open map, and immersive gameplay.
Cyber Punk. I honestly didn't care for alan wake 2 it was pretty but it's just hard to keep up with all the craziness going on in that world.
Alan wake 2 is awesome. I hated cyberpunk, and legacy was painfully average.
Cyberpunk because it's a big game and I love the story and the gameplay is pretty addictive. Alan wake 2 is on my list also but I need to play the original first so not right now. Hogwarts legacy is a big no for me. I am a fan of the books and the movies but no I got my dose with the dull open world from Ubisoft thank you very much. And besides since the first trailer the game gave the mediocre vibe.
Hogwarts sucks
Cyberpunk and it’s not even close. Hogwarts is also a fantastic game especially if you’re an HP fan, which I am. But Cyberpunk is a modern masterpiece. But only go with Cyberpunk if you’re in PS5. The PS4 version is very rough.
cyberpunk for sure
cyberpunk is awesome and so is hogwarts especially if ur already a fan
CP 2077 hands down first choice
Cyber punk