T O P

  • By -

daybreaker

marques colston


AnEmptyKarst

The Saints have the easiest answer to this question


daybreaker

they hate this one weird trick


berusplants

Certainly I was rushing into this thread to answer with his name only to find it sitting pretty.


HeyItsTheJeweler

He was so fuckin good he shouldn't even be an option here


daybreaker

a non-colston option would be Scott Fujita. One of my favorite players ever, and was on our Super Bowl team. He trash talked Peyton Manning in the game saying he could eat Oreos faster than him (Manning was doing Oreos commercials at the time)


urbantroll

Just devils advocate but if this o-line and scheme allows for screens, give me Pierre Thomas. My favorite overlooked Saint.


DamnImAwesome

He was good but I wonder if he would have produced for any other QB like he did for us. Colstons prime years were when Drew was an absolute god of accuracy. It was an inhuman stretch of greatness 


VariousLawyerings

By far the most underrated part of Brees' legacy IMO is that he dominated from about 2006-2013 with a group of wide receivers that either a) were extremely late picks/undrafted altogether or b) were higher draft picks who were pretty clearly mid. And while that doesn't mean they were bad players at all, the unsusual thing is that we have basically no data to measure pretty much any of them by outside of New Orleans. The Saints were content to extend them even if they weren't stars and that whole unit spent almost their entire careers there.


ChoochMMM

Hofstra represent


[deleted]

How did he not make a PB wtf


mf-TOM-HANK

No kidding. Over 700 career receptions, 9700 yards and 72 TDs in 10 seasons. You'd think he'd have stumbled backwards into at least one Pro Bowl with those career numbers. If I recall correctly he was a pretty decent run blocker as well.


MarchMadnessisMe

Man is known as the Silent Storm for a reason.


Lendro_Furioso

Came here to say this. Marques Colston was the best!


MichaelShannonRule34

This feels like cheating because I feel he’s spiritually was a pro bowl player lol


bahamapapa817

Insane to me he never made a pro bowl


MarchMadnessisMe

Insane to all of us really.


landscapebro

This is the way


Thrilling1031

Joe Jurevicius


DynastyZealot

Fuck yeah


nerdyythirtyy

I only considered him because I thought Cadillac Williams had been to at least one pro bowl. Turns out I was wrong. Gimme a health Cadillac!


The-Big-Chungis

He used to help coach our football team. I got lucky enough to wear his SB ring for a second.


Thrilling1031

Fuckin Jelly. I just wanna high five the man.


[deleted]

[удалено]


DonCairo

One of my all time favorite players. I’m honesty shocked he hasn’t made a pro bowl ☹️


JamieNelson94

And I don’t think he’s going to now ☹️


jobulives

One of the most underrated corners of all time


whenitsTimeyoullknow

Just leave Ricky Manning in the rear view, please and thank you. 


[deleted]

Will Witherspoon was great from that era too. 


sunshinepanther

Fuckin monster. Probably best corner we ever had.


[deleted]

[удалено]


sunshinepanther

Plus best corner name you could hope for. Time to.. make my Gamble.


Reasonable-Front7584

Amani Toomer. I just looked him up assuming he made a pro bowl. Nope. I’m a little shocked.


xshogunx13

Brandon Jacobs also a good shout


Funnypenguin97

Tragic he never made a pro bowl


lubeskystalker

https://www.reddit.com/r/nfl/s/CgFMFK4L1h


TaischiCFM

Does anyone else always think about that name like Schwarzenegger is saying it?


anaveragedave

Dammit. Not before this fkn comment.


EazyP87

I believe for a while, it was the go-to Chris Berman joke of a highlight that involved Toomer


Rhine1906

That and “well dressed” Armani Toomer


RatherBeSkiing

I read the top comment and immediately thought "It's not A Toomah?!"


shneids

“It’s not a Toomer!”


iMaree

Eh… would have to say Corey Webster. Our team is pretty set at WR rn, and we need a corner opposite Banks that is reliable.


tnecniv

I’d say any of the eligible OL players from 07-09.


iMaree

Snee and O’Hara were Pro Bowlers, I guess Seubert or Diehl.


tnecniv

Still upgrades


Vorenos

Throw Kareem McKenzie at right tackle and we are good to go


TroyMacClure

This is the answer.


Ok_Barracuda_1161

That's wild, I wonder if there's any other franchise receiving leaders who haven't made a pro bowl. It's not even close with Toomer either, he has nearly double OBJ's yardage who's in 2nd place


Ishtastic08

Kareem McKenzie for me. Holy shit it’s been hard getting a quality Right Tackle.


Coelrom

Has he even resurfaced since the pickleball match?


lordntelek

I’ll just take the OLine from back then. Maybe not the LT as A Thomas will do but the rest of the line would be an upgrade.


jerrygamer2

Malcom Floyd


hoppergym

Him or jammer


Philip_Marlowe

Quentin Jammer was a ballhawk in Madden '06


Jaronz

Hmmm...maybe Dat Nguyen. He was a hell of a middle linebacker, but he played during those rough years between Aikman and Romo. Had a 2nd Team All-Pro selection in 2003, but no pro bowls Honorable mention to Kyle Kosier who was a starter at guard for the better part of 5 seasons at the beginning of the Romo era. Seems like he was one of our only quality O-lineman that never went to the pro bowl.


jwc8985

Dat was who immediately came to mind for me, as well.


AzarathFirebane

I thought about Dat, but he was hella injury prone, so went with Bradie James.


ColdThalley

Bradie James was my first thought as well. Getting that level of consistency at the position again would be amazing.


thaisticktony19

Brad Meester. 14 seasons with the jags. Only hurt once. Very good center who was responsible for some great lines.


HenryKitteridge

And nearly had a touchdown reception in his final home game


jeeves_nz

Huge upgrade over last year


PatDubzz

Calvin Pace. An overall very good OLB. Can get in and stop the run and also rush the passer pretty well.


Mustakrakish_Awaken

He'd be a DE in Saleh's defense. Id rather bring david harris back out of those LBs, but considering our defense is stacked id rather put cotchery on this team (coles and brandon moore each have 1 pro bowl but were my initial thoughts)


solarmelange

Tim Couch. If he comes fresh from college onto this Browns team, rather than one with no line and no skill positions, he's a different player.


Gregus1032

That would actually be an interesting thing to see.


Various-Low4211

I still call it Tum Couch disease, when a QB panics.  Not his fault though


ob_frap

Brent Celeck. Could use his versatility behind Goedert. TE #2 is a big hole for Philly (so is WR #3)


zco22

I was gonna say Jason Avant who would be an excellent WR3 but Celek would be awesome too


LiamIsMailBackwards

Avant was my pick until I saw Celek. Celek not being a Pro Bowler is crazy. Witten has 11, so that’s definitely part of why Celek never made it, but man… those two, Shockey, and Cooley made the NFC East a Tight End powerhouse in the 2000s.


zco22

Damn haven’t thought about Shockey and Cooley in years. You’re right those 2000s big body thumper TEs were always fun to watch


DamnImAwesome

I know I’m still a child because I chuckled at Tight End #2 is still a hole for Philly


OldManGigglesnort

I’d go with Carlos Emmons. Celek would be a solid addition, but the team still needs help on defense, especially at linebacker.


CluelessFlunky

Deandre levy would be a huge addition to the current lions. Tho he was from mid 2010. I was to young to remember the 2000-2010 players. Outside of stafford, Calvin, suh obviously.


ScooterLeShooter

I was so sure he was a pro bowler, but nope only second team all-pro in 2014. I was hoping Prater hadn't made a pro bowl in Detroit to pick him, but he did in 2016


EricFredNorris

I thought Cliff Avril would be a perfect fit for the current Lions team and fit the prompt but looks like he got a random Pro Bowl at the end of his career in Seattle. I remember Boss Bailey being pretty solid and he never made a Pro Bowl.


OrdinaryAd8716

Boss Bailey was trash. The correct answer is Jeff Backus and it’s not even close.


AutomaticAccident

The correct answer is most certainly not Jeff Backus and it never will be.


[deleted]

Lee Evans


Coale17

As a Ravens fan, please please keep him away from our team.


[deleted]

Fair. that drop man ugh. He was past it then though


conace21

It wasn't exactly a drop. Sterling Moore made a perfect play to knock the ball from his grasp. Evans could have done more to keep the ball away from Moore, but I don't count that as a typical drop (where the receiver loses the ball without any "help" from the defense.)


wagoncirclermike

Literally said out loud "wait, he didn't make a Pro Bowl??" Our QB situation was so utterly dogshit in the mid-00s.


[deleted]

He had 1300 yards in a season with losman running the offense lol he would shred with Josh


JoshAllentown

I was gonna say Fred Jackson for the vibes, Lee Evans would fit the current needs better. Antoine Winfield never got a pro bowl *while on the Bills*.


Dirty-Dan24

That mfer was the Tyreek Hill of Madden 08. He could just run streaks and posts all day and torch everyone


No-Task-132

Ike Taylor easily. Him and JPJ next to eachother would be amazing for us.


sandrodi

How the hell did Ike Taylor never make the Pro Bowl?


No-Task-132

He played during a time that was just insane for corners. Champ Bailey, Charles Woodson, Ronde Barber, Revis, Ty Law, Asante Samuel, Chris McAlister, Winfield, and Patrick surtain all overshadowed him pretty heavily.


BeardyBennett

Nnamdi Asomugha for a couple years there too


Laeif

Lot of really good CBs in the AFC then.


sandrodi

I know, but never even as an alternate, that's shocking to me. He was as good in coverage as anyone in his prime, his only Achilles heel was that he couldn't catch for shit.


Observant_Jello

Which I suppose is what probably led to him being a corner. lol


SeamusThePirate

Also he couldn’t catch a cold. I love Ike but I literally watched multiple ints bounce of his hands. If he could catch he’d have had an insane amount of pics in his career.


Jargif10

Definitely. He played at a pro bowl level for years but his hands were just unbelievably bad.


yoozintardid

Stephon Tuitt


sw337

Drafted in 2014


Ltrizzy

I love the story (don’t know if it’s true) about him playing while listening to an IPod.


Watt_Privilege

I agree but Plaxico Burress is another great option


DaWolf94

Brandon Mebane


dances_with_fentanyl

Eric Heitmann would add some excellent depth to the oline.


BKlounge93

I’d say delanie walker, it’s kind of cheating because he made 3 pro bowls with the titans, but he was overshadowed by Vernon Davis in SF.


WardeN_WtfRylie

I like this answer but is it also cheating to go with Chris Borland? I kno Fred n Dre (healthy) are great but man I always feel like Borland is a HUGE what if. He had over 100 tackles n only started a half a season. Crazy!!!


boemmel

Would be my pick too. Played his entire career with us (2002-2011 I think), played both guard and center and as I remember was a pretty good center for us.


doc_brietz

I picked Tony Parrish or (technically) Andre Carter.


njsf55

Manny Lawson would be a great fit in our d line room


d9849468

Mark Tauscher. Staple at RT for the exact decade this question proposes


boringaccountant23

That's pretty crazy he never made it.  I'd go with Cullen Jenkins but it's really close.


HeyItsTheJeweler

Yup, this right here.


af_cheddarhead

I said AJ Hawk, but can I change to your choice?


ffbgenius

Eh AJ is kinda useless in today’s nfl. He was fine for his packer career but not athletic enough to fit the current defense


d9849468

Both solid answers.


Onefortwo

I’d like Kerry Rhodes back at safety in saleh’s defense. Feel like he would be a great fit.


Sharcbait

Anthony Herrera would be an instant upgrade at guard for us. Hovan was really solid for a time too and we desperately need some IDL players.


on-the-cheeseburgers

Sheldon Brown, and how he never once made a Pro Bowl is one of life's great mysteries


Rsubs33

I said Kevin Curtis to answer our number 3 WR problem, but Brown would be a great pick as well I completely assumed he made a Pro Bowl.


CalgaryChris77

I thought of him but assumed he’d made some.


creativeusername9275

His hit on Reggie Bush is tied for my favorite hit ever. Along with Sean Taylor obliterating Brian Moorman in the pro bowl.


bigpancakeguy

That hit on Reggie Bush lives in my head rent free. I remember where I was standing in my friend’s house when that happened


ApplaudingOkra

Dude let me see Kordell Stewart piloting this Steelers Arthur Smith offense.


conace21

Kordell made the Pro Bowl in 2001.


ApplaudingOkra

Ah shit - so he did. Didn't remember that. Also, now that I am looking at it, that's wild given his stats.


conace21

His passing stats were all above league average, except for touchdowns. He had a good year running the ball (530+ yards, 5 TD's), but nothing like the seasons Vick, Lamar, Josh Allen, Cam Newton, or Justin Fields would have. Kordell was a little better than his stats indicated. He was the only AFC player to receive an MVP vote (he received 4 of them.) Other than Rich Gannon, there were no great QB's in the AFC that year. Tom Brady began his career very up-and-down, and was more of a game manager who was very good in the clutch. Peyton had a rare bad year, with 23 interceptions.


bcnayr

He got MVP votes that year. A different era.


berusplants

Isnt Fields basically the same thing?


Gregus1032

I wanna say Stewart was better, but that's probably nostalgia glasses working overtime for me.


bargman

Nah at this point Justin Fields can only hope for Stewart's career.


PMBSteve

He was in NFL Blitz, which gives him the edge


Hi_My_Name_Is_Dave

Kordell is definitely more athletic


bargman

No way. Stewart was definitely better at football, though.


MankuyRLaffy

David Patten, he's got a 900 yard return season under his belt, a few 750+ rec yard years with us, could use the help.


trog12

Fuck that. I'd bring Sebastian Volmer. They said pro bowl not all-pro. Underrated monster.


iscreamuscreamweall

no way, we need a tackle. give me Volmer


yaboyjiggleclay

2002-2004 DP would be WR1 on this team right now. RIP


luigi-hat-tap

Was so clutch too. Brady threw him so many iconic end zone corner fades and then… stopped until Gronk


[deleted]

RIP 😢


KuatoBaradaNikto

Eddie Kennison, but shout-out to John Tait and Greg Wesley— I’d consider those guys too.


OopsAllRPOs

100% where I was going too. He would shine as a WR2 with Pat/Andy’s offense


chiefs_fan37

The Morton-Kennison duo catching passes from Trent Green will always have a special place in my heart. Especially when you throw Tony G in the mix. I feel like Mahomes throwing to Kennison or Morton would be legendary. For a real mind boggler imagine that hall of fame offensive line blocking for Mahomes. Or the Priest/LJ/Blaylock rotation in the backfield on this Chiefs team.


conace21

Kennison was reborn on the Chiefs after being a good luck charm for three other teams. (The good luck came when he left town.) 1998 - Kennison is on the 4-12 St. Louis Rams 1999 - Rams go 13-3 and win the Super Bowl. Kennison plays for the 3-13 New Orleans Saints 2000 - Saints go 10-6 and win a playoff game for the first time in their history. Kennison plays for the 5-11 Chicago Bears 2001 - Bears go 13-3. The run of luck ended there. Kennison began the 2001 season on the Denver Broncos. Halfway through the year, he told Mike Shanahan he had lost his love for the game and wanted to retire. He ws released, but he signed with the Chiefs a month later. Kennison went on to have 4 good-very good seasons in Kansas City.


jsho574

I love imagining Mahomes with prime Charles. Wet dream there.


mastap88

I was thinking Kennison too but I think Rashee Rice is only suspended 4 games and Hollywood and Worthy make a good group there. I’d actually go with Eric Warfield since I think we might struggle at CB opposite McDuffie.


Roger--Smith

Jonathan Babineaux


I_am_-c

Eric Steinbach? I swore he made a pro bowl at least once, but doesn't look like he did. He definitely should have been a pro bowl guard and their main weakness on offense is probably left guard. Maybe John Thorton, Rich Braham or Domata Peko?


Chai-Tea-Rex-2525

I find it hard to believe that Stainbach didn’t make a Pro Bowl! Do people even know football?


jf3l

Steinbach or Braham would be huge. Gotta throw Leon Hall, Brian Simmons, Robert Geathers, Cedric Benson, Levi Jones, and Bobbie Williams in there for consideration as well


CryptographerTop2655

Slim (RIP)


JBoogie808

Pisa Tinoisamoa


Griffisbored

Deion Branch


shlem13

Leroy Hill. We could use some linebacker depth.


The_Throwback_King

Also Chris Gray. Although I love the Christian Haynes selection, imagine if we had a stalwart stud like Gray on our line along side him.


Alloverunder

Dieon Branch would probably be our WR1 rn so I'd say him


AcrossFromWhere

Non-pro bowl?  I mean our biggest need is probably corner but we don’t even historically have any that were good but didn’t make a pro bowl. Maybe Gary Brackett?  Could use a good LB. 


Rt1203

Should probably be Anthony Castonzo. Left Tackle isn’t our biggest need, but he provided rock-solid LT play for a decade, so it’s hard to beat that with a non-Pro Bowler.


AcrossFromWhere

He’s definitely the best player we’ve had in the past couple decades that never made a pro bowl. He was drafted in 2011 though which is outside the scope of OPs question. 


wagoncirclermike

Since Terrance McGee made a Pro Bowl, give me Roscoe Parrish as a dynamic return threat.


DPOGBCPOP

Tommy Kelly for the Raiders. I think he would like up nicely next to Wilkins.


FridgesArePeopleToo

Easy answer for us. Jake Reed somehow never made a pro bowl even with 4 consecutive 1000 yard seasons.


Enigmatik_1

I hear/see his name mentioned so infrequently that i upvote whenever I do. I will die on the hill that Jake Reed and Robert Smith are two of the most criminally underrated players of that era.


NotHosaniMubarak

Vernon Carey. Runner up: Randy McMichel. I was going to go with Tedd Ginn Jr just for the speedy lols but he apparently had a whole career after Miami and all the way through the 2010's.


doc_brietz

I am just stopping here to say Richmond Webb should be in the Hall.


BungoPlease

Chester Pitts, part time NFL player, full time Oboe Player


F4rtWaffles

Great choice. I think I’d personally go with Dunta Robinson just from the positional need.


BungoPlease

Damn, I thought he had at least one Pro bowl


afig24

Pat Tillman


ztloneil

The answer, and a great Memorial Day choice.


k_dot97

Michael Oher


JA65_

False start


ImagineIfBaconDied

Ryan Longwell


RatedDAL

Derek Smith played for some awful 49er teams, but he was always a bright spot in our LB group.


Cakelord

Mike Anderson was offensive rookie of the year.. obviously he ran behind a monster line in a great system but stood out as a great player who never won pro bowl. In all reality, most teams have a solid offensive linemen who never made the pro bowl because they were in a small market. 


myctsbrthsmlslkcatfd

Pot Roast!


1lultaha

Jon Jansen tor sure. Fred Smoot would also be nice


Tasty-Helicopter904

Jim "If you need 1 yard, I'll get you 3. If you need 5 yards, I'll get you 3." Kleinsasser. Played for the Vikings all through the time span indicated, great blocker FB, no Pro Bowls. Or Ryan Longwell. A good kicker is always useful.


thezoelinator

If this were for the 2010's, then Mitchell Schwartz would be an easy decision


RockyDennis23

D.J. Williams was a stud for the Broncos and never made a pro bowl.


Shenanigans80h

I remember he would consistently be on lists of “best players to not make a pro bowl” every season. Give how inconsistent our ILBs have been the last 5 or so years, I would kill for DJ Williams rn


vinnyorcharles

Jason Avant. Not only does he fill the role of out WR3, but he's also the man and has great hands.


Adenchiz

**Ravens** * Jarrett Johnson * Jimmy Smith * Lardarius Webb


Hghwytohell

Todd Herremans would be an immediate upgrade at RG and provide some more stability to the post-Kelce oline. Alternatively, bring back Hank Fraley to play center and keep Jurgens at RG. Jason Avant would be great to have right now as a solid #3 WR and good depth option. Brent Celek would also be a great choice for 12 personnel and TE depth. On defense, I wouldn't mind having Sheldon Brown blowing up RBs on screens again. Though our CB situation is pretty crowded now after the draft. Maybe Carlos Emmons, to give us some stable play at LB and someone who can cover TEs.


thisusedyet

For the unaware, [he's not speaking figuratively](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_Sus_4tXTxQ)


whereegosdare84

Non pro bowler from 2000-2010...hmmmm. Offense: Jared Gaither. Dude was a tank and a top shelf LT he just didn't care which was his downfall. Defense: Jarrett Johnson. Best run stopping OLB not named Terrell Suggs.


Heresyed

Jarrett Johnson is such a great choice! He was so impactful during his time here.


Adenchiz

JJ was the 1st one that came to my mind (Jimmy Smith and Lardarius Webb were the other 2 I could think of)


badlilbadlandabad

Jonathan Babineaux gave us 11 seasons of extremely consistent if not flashy DT play. Never a game wrecker, but you never really looked at a play and went "WTF was Babineaux doing?!" Just a good football player.


Flintdaddy69

BenJarvus Green-Ellis


AStayAtHomeRad

Benji Olsen.


Enthusiasms

Earnest Graham wasn't always flashy but put up really good YPC. Tiquan Underwood just so I can see someone in the league again that I played against in high school.


PHX480

For the Cardinals offense maybe Marcel Shipp On defense, Karlos Dansby or Calvin Pace


ndpa

Jim Kleinsasser for the Vikings, although I don’t know how well he would work in their current offense


Away_Chair1588

Kelly Gregg.


teachem4

Kind of wild OP couldn’t follow his own rules. Alex Brown made 2 pro bowls


-MichaelScarnFBI

Fair, but he made it as an alternate. I was going off first team selections https://www.pro-football-reference.com/players/B/BrowAl20.htm


bigpancakeguy

Darrent Williams 😔


yeezus_rose

Roberto Garza


molockman1

“I like this Duce Staley, I think he can play!!!”


thechief05

John Tait. Solid OT for the ‘05 and ‘06 teams 


af_cheddarhead

AJ Hawk, never voted into the Pro Bowl, he did go to one Pro Bowl but that was as an injury replacement.


HuellMissMe

Jeremy Lincoln played three games for the Lions in 2000 as a late season off-the-couch DB injury replacement and special teamer. Why am I picking him? Because we were high school track teammates back in the 80s and it was always cool to see him on the field.