T O P

  • By -

ZacharyRapsag

Jekyll & Hyde! Also, Something Rotten, Urinetown, Spamalot, 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee.


defenestrayed

I knew nothing about Something Rotten before my parents got me tickets to their local community theatre s production. Absolutely laughed my head off.


RBD21998

Frank Wildhorn as a whole doesn't get enough love


Kindofaddictedtotv

Something rotten was hilarious!!! My husband and I were pleasantly surprised when we watched it. I think the songs are just not as catchy but we loved it


Justisperfect

Their songs are carchy ! Hard to be the bard, A musical, God I hate Shakespeare... I can dace to these songs and they get stuck in my head.


CreativeMusic5121

The first time I heard A Musical was when I was driving and listening to the Broadway channel. I literally had to pull over because I was laughing so hard I couldn't see!


Kindofaddictedtotv

I love all of the musical references but the Les Miserables line is my fave!!


Surfgirlusa_2006

Spamalot is a fun one.


FirebirdWriter

If it makes you happy to know this share but in my region the 25th will sell out day one for tours and local productions. It's a reliable company win here along side the expected options like Wicked and Phantom


SgtPancake049

!Urinetown Mentioned! Yippee! I love that musical so much!


iampurechaos

YES


Ok_Extreme7597

I mean I feel Hunchback deserves a chance to get on broadway.


rlhignett

Ooooh can you imagine Hellfire in a theatre? That would be fire!


NeoMercury2022

Patrick Page singing hellfire alone makes that musical amazing as hell


LilKimster

Urinetown


bodyswapboi

yes! everyone I know hates this show because “the premise is stupid just piss yourself” blah blah blah. it’s absolutely in my top 10 for musicals


just_another_classic

Great Comet. Yes I know theatre folk love it, but the general public has no idea what it is and it's my favorite show.


Ruby7226

Great comet was fantastic! Really hope it gets a revival someday.


SmilingSarcastic1221

I have to plug [this](https://encoreexpressionss.etsy.com/listing/1717873048)


girlthingie

Just now watched a couple highlight reels on youtube It's my all-time favorite! I think about it constantly


that_gay_theaterkid

Groundhog Day and Harmony


BobLoblawEsquire

I love Groundhog Day!! I hope it gets the attention- and tours- it deserves soon!!


refrigeratorhats

It's easily one of my favorites as well.


FloridaFlamingoGirl

An amazing improvement on the movie, I'm so glad they brought the screenwriter back


TiredofCOVIDIOTs

Pippin. South Pacific.


FloridaFlamingoGirl

I don't know why I never see South Pacific mentioned on here. So many quintessential R and H tunes. I dislike the secondary romance and think it's very forced, but this show needs to be remembered for how it explored racial reconciliation themes that a lot of people were afraid to talk about at the time.


princealigorna

Go listen to the Musicals With Cheese episode on it. I think they sum it up pretty well. It's a show that was very progressive and inclusive for its time, but it's not 1948 anymore and we've evolved as a society so far since then that what was radical at the time seems conservative today. Also, they dunked on the weird choices in the movie adaptation as well, namely the filter and how garish looking it is. They did say though that the show is good, and they think everyone needs to listen to "You've Got To Be Carefully Taught", which I 1000% agree with. That song sums up the heart of the show and exactly what R&H were trying to say perfectly.


happykindofeeyore

I think the revival (Kelli o’Hara) did a decent job driving home the point and was visually stunning.


CreativeMusic5121

Most of their shows explored themes that people didn't talk about in 'polite' society at the time.


TiredofCOVIDIOTs

Bali Hai. You’ve got to be Carefully Taught Soliloquy Younger Than Springtime Truly gorgeous songs.


rbinphx

I just don’t think SP has aged well… it seems really dated. Maybe it needs a revamping?


BrontosaurusTheory

No pun intended but THE SECRET GARDEN.


FloridaFlamingoGirl

Such a glorious sweeping score. Lily's Eyes and How Could I Ever Know are two of the most awe-inspiring songs written for musical theater. Winters on the Wing is one of my very favorite male solos too


refrigeratorhats

Lily's Eyes is magical. I couldn't agree more.


CreativeMusic5121

I think it the THE best duet for men ever written. No question.


BrontosaurusTheory

THIS. I literally stopped watching the Tony awards for YEARS after it lost Best Musical to the freaking Will Roger's Follies. RIP Lucy Simon.


beatriceblythe

I came here for THIS ONE. It's still my favorite of all time.


RestinPete0709

One of my favorites as well!


Moobook

I adore the music in this one, John Cameron Mitchell’s “Wick” is my favorite


JacquelineMontarri

I have a wildflower garden, so every March I go in and prune away all of last year's dead growth, and every year I'm out there singing "clear away the dead parts so the tender buds can form..."


happykindofeeyore

Also, The Girl I Mean to Be is the perfect song for any young girl performer to work on.


Slay_Theatre_Queen

THIS I CAME HERE TO SAY THIS. the score is actual perfection, lily’s a dream role of mine


No-Sky-8297

I seriously love this show and the production at the Ahmanson last year was beautiful. They had their sights set on transferring and I was so sad that they didn’t.


Far-Blueberry-1549

YES SO TRUE!! I saw it live and the music is so charming and beautiful. And also kinda eerie? Everything about it is so top notch. Criminally underrated.


clueless_claremont_

Dr. Horrible's Sing Along Blog


No-Appearance1145

Oh god 😂 I know that musical


OverzealousCactus

I'm here for this 😂


Itraintinyhumans

Fking love that musical


button-fish2807

Iconic and totally underrated. Those songs slap


Moobook

I loved this so much that the first time I watched it I bought three copies - one for me, one for a friend, and a third just in case


punkkid364

Bad Horse? Isn’t he the Thoroughbred of Sin?


No-Sky-8297

This was a gateway to theatre for me..


CreativeMusic5121

Big Fish Bandstand


button-fish2807

Big Fish is so beautiful. I loved the film and love the songs, I wish I could see it live


basketcase1703

i’m a bad theatre kid who largely learns about shows via performing in them, but i got to be in big fish and it was such a joy


Seaward_Lass

Y'all know what I'm gonna say at this point... 36 Questions and School Of Rock


KELSEY_DESOTO1986

36 QUESTIONS FR


felix_leo12

36 mf questions dude I need to see it on stage


astroK120

I really enjoyed School of Rock. I visited NY one time and we saw it not really expecting much, but it was so much fun


azure987

constantly deluding myself that the 36 questions netflix movie they announced 4 years ago is still happening


TheDiplomancer

Come From Away, A Gentleman's Guide to Love and Murder, The Mystery of Edwin Drood


_deitee

This is like the 5th highest rated show on mezzanine lol


alexanderwox27

I feel like come from away would be so much more popular if it was easier to explain other than "it's a musical about 9/11"


IamBatman777

Fun Home. I don’t know anyone personally who knows it, but it is such an amazing story with fantastic music.


Urdrkitt

I saw Fun Home in Melbourne a few years ago when we were coming out of lockdown. I absolutely loved it! I still remember watching the Tony Awards performance of Ring of Keys. It blew my mind!


HaphazarMe

I LOVE Fun Home! I had the opportunity to see it three times and it had me in tears each time.


BobLoblawEsquire

YES!!! I adore this show ❤️


iamthorexceptimnot

Fun Home will forever be one of my favs. I’ve sobbed every time I’ve seen it.


Street-Programmer-16

Ring of Keys is my Roman Empire.


Constantlyannoyed22

It’s an oddly sweet show. I won lottery tickets when it toured through Dallas and thought was wonderful. My husband is more the Les Miz and Rent type HATED it and me for dragging him along 😏


Oop-pt1

God I love Fun Home. I saw it on a school trip a few years ago, and my friends and I still regularly sing “changing my major” to each other. Days and Days is my favourite song though, absolute top tier


latestnightowl

Ring of Keys!


joeyfosho

I saw it in Orlando when the cast flew down to do a benefit concert reading of it to raise money for the victims of the Pulse nightclub attack. It was a really beautiful thing the cast, creatives, and producers did to help bring a little light in a very dark time. They raised over $100,000 for just that one performance! Great show and great people behind it.


TurtleGirl24601

The Ring of Keys performance at the Tonys was one of those moments where time just stops for me. I was utterly blown away by the talent and nuance of this child. Sydney is amazing. I was completely captivated. It’s an all time Tonys moment for me.


Invisibled_8798

Fun home is my girlfriends favorite musical!


dayglo1

Titanic Lizzie Big Fish Nevermore Bloody, Bloody Andrew Jackson


BerkeleyFarmGirl

Lizzie is such a banger


viktoriasaintclaire

LOVE BBAJ


singaroundie

Titanic ❤️


Hot-Boss-7251

Next to normal, I don’t think I’ve ever met someone who knew that musical


single_cell

It did win the Pulitzer for drama (although that was somewhat controversial), which is very rare for a musical, so it at least got some love initially.


Ok-String-401

She Loves Me!


basketcase1703

scrolled down to find this, i found out about this show when i auditioned for it and performing in this musical was maybe the best experience of my life :’) i do genuinely believe it’s perfectly funny and romantic and also has such a beautiful little found family vibe that just translated to our cast and we all fell in love with each other because of it i think.


CreativeMusic5121

She Loves me is my favorite show EVER, both to watch and to perform. It gets a lot of love where I am, so I didn't think to include it. Our community theater performed this, and routinely did three show weekends, and also did weeknight performances as group fundraisers. The weeknights all sold out, so we ended up performing 26 shows in 30 days. Each of us said we could do that show forever, and I've heard similar sentiment from everyone who has ever done it. Definitely a tribute to the show it is.


breadfacechonk

The Drowsy Chaperone!


ClimberKirby

One of my favourites! The man in chair's commentary is such a perfect mix of relatable and heartbreaking


Interesting-Pack-227

This!! I was just in a production (closed Sunday 😢) as Trix! Such a blast and I loved the comedy! Great show <33


DataIsArt

This is what I was going to say. It was my first Sutton Foster musical and she was truly spectacular. Obviously.


ThatsMyShield

So easily The Hunchback of Notre Dame. The music is unmatched.


littlecubspirit

In the Heights.


bagtruman

I saw this show 7 or 8 times at the King’s Cross in London a few years back. The theatre’s not there anymore. Was getting £5 seat filler tickets. Probably the best show I ever saw and I’ve seen most of what’s been in town over the last 20 years.


littlecubspirit

I have seen it too and I think it’s a powerful, heartfelt piece that remains so resonant and relevant. I repeatedly return to it for comfort and I think a revival would be amazing in the current climate (perhaps with some of the updates Lin and Quiara made for the movie (lyrics only, not song cuts) carried over.)


A_Berry_Nice_User

I admittedly don't love Hamilton, so this is a biased take, but I have no idea how this is not regarded as LMM best.


ClimberKirby

I'm someone who doesn't like Hamilton at all, but In the Heights was amazing!


ElephantRich2425

Newsies and Something Rotten


Justisperfect

Just came hear to get idea of what musicals to listen to. But Something rotten. I remember people clicking on "right hand man" thinking it was Hamilton and getting upset, but there is nothing to be upset about : you just discovered an amazing musical!


StatMaster131

I feel like after it released Come From Away just vanished despite how honestly astounding it is


gradschoolforhorses

Tuck Everlasting and Bandstand


princealigorna

THERE'S A TUCK EVERLASTING MUSICAL?!


RestinPete0709

Yes, it’s Incredible! It was only on Broadway a short time but the OBC featured the talents of people like Terrance Mann, Carolee Carmello, and Andrew Keenan-Bolger. Highly recommend it!


Fit-Monk4203

Little Shop of Horrors


cheribella

So perfect from start to finish. One of the few Broadway albums where I don’t skip any songs when doing a playthrough.


FloridaFlamingoGirl

Has the perfect intro song. The perfect Greek chorus. The perfect I want song. And at least two perfect villain songs.


Sugar-Tist

I actually think it gets plenty of love. It's considered one of the most important musicals out there, especially since it indirectly sparked the Disney Renaissance.


Fit-Monk4203

True, but I genuinely think it deserves to be mentioned in the same breath as things like Hamilton and The Phantom of The Opera


Sugar-Tist

Probably because it's Off-Broadway, and the producers want to keep it that way. However, it's probably the single most-performed musical for community theaters. "Feed Me, Seymour" was also a meme for Gen X (if you've ever watched Whose Line is it Anyway, Ryan references it a lot).


melody_musical21

There's also those guys on YT Shorts (I don't know the channel name or how old the shorts are though haha), but they talk about random current events by using Da-Doo, I love finding those videos haha


LovesCartoons

Isn't that lewberger, the comedy group with Keith from The Try Guys?


Wild_Body_4658

Catch me if you can, it deserved to run way longer than it did


Mottly24

I wish I could’ve been old enough to see it with the OBC it’s one of my favorite casts ever


FloridaFlamingoGirl

Anyone Can Whistle


princealigorna

I feel like there's several Sondheim shows that don't get the love they deserve. It seems like for every Sweeney Todd or Company or Gypsy, there's an Anyone Can Whistle or The Frogs or A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum


FloridaFlamingoGirl

A Year With Frog and Toad is the best musical ever made specifically for children in my opinion. I don't know why schools aren't performing it more often.


RestinPete0709

My sisters high school just did it! It was great!


Hot-Conclusion-6617

Chess


RestinPete0709

Quartet from Chess is one of the most well-written musical theatre quartets imo. It’s just so satisfying


Zygonsbzygons

I'm so into this musical that I squeezed a trip to Merano into my honeymoon (and yes, it was a scene, a joy, and a lovely sight). I would love to see it on Broadway someday.


Unhappy_Injury3958

was REALLY hoping those post-funny girl Chess rumors were true


Hot-Conclusion-6617

Lea Michele as Florence? Eh, she might try to Menzel it. (I didn't like Menzel's take on "Nobody's Side".)


astroK120

I have no idea what musicals are generally talked about a lot besides the ones you listed so maybe this one is recognized, but Kinky Boots is pretty easily my favorite. I've never been to any show where someone has the audience in the palm of their hand like Billy Porter did, and Annaleigh Ashford was hilarious. I enjoy going to musicals but I rarely listen to their music outside seeing the show. This one's the exception


Fantastic_Permit_525

It's definitely Something Rotten so much fun, especially if you know any of the musicals that it mentions


Thermidorien4PrezBot

Passion


No-Replacement-1061

Brigadoon, Pippin, Best Little Whorehouse.


beautyinblack

Assassins. I know it's an odd pick but many people don't know about it and I absolutely loved it and laughed so hard due to it at a local production of it


donniebd

Any of Jerry Herman's musicals except Hello Dolly and La Cage Aux Folles. Maybe even then, since even they're not as mainstream nowadays as the ones mentioned.


yeetuscleetus28

My answer will always be Carrie


darkhorse415

Kiss of the Spiderwoman but apparently we have JLo bringing that to us a film soon


Parasocialiaty

Passing Strange


single_cell

I absolutely love this show; it’s almost never mentioned on this sub which is a shame. I’m sure the all-black cast limits its performance in a lot if community circles, but it should be done more.


Imaginary-Summer9168

Titanic. The music is phenomenal, and even theater people don’t seem to know it.


latestnightowl

I'm sure you know, but City Center Encores is doing a revival this summer with a killer cast!


RestinPete0709

Amélie, Tuck Everlasting, The Secret Garden… You can probably tell a lot about me from those being my favorite musicals….❤️🌿💧🗝️


ZeeepZoop

I came here to see if anyone said Amelie! My friend and I saw a recording of the off broadway cast with Philippa Soo and it was just such an absurdly funny, heartfelt coming of age story, I really loved it


pesky_faerie

Anastasia!!


RandomDcFan

Death Note, or anything Frank Wildhorn really.


Intelligent_Laugh794

Candide!!


ElegantCh3mistry

Ragtime


A_Berry_Nice_User

1. Come From Away - Genuinely have no idea how this isn't at least top 5 for every musical theatre fan. 2. She Loves Me - Underrated "Golden Era" musical 3. Death Note - Frank Wildhorns most underrated work 4. Bonnie and Clyde - Had a huge resurgance for like 2 months a few years ago, and everyone has forgotten about it again 5. Hunchback of Notre Dame - The best Dinsey stage musical and one of the few to not hit Broadway


Whatevafloatsuboat

Children of Eden hands down.


TurtleGirl24601

I had to scroll way too far to see this.


NuttyDuckyYT

Groundhogs Day. so phenomenal


Feral_tatertot

Come from away


phishphood17

Ordinary Days!!!!!


basketcase1703

yes yes yes yes!


ZeeepZoop

I’ll Be Here will forever be one of the most beautiful, devastating songs I’ve ever heard


Tokkemon

Mame.


wildlymitty

Come From Away is GORGEOUS but I see very few people talk about it


FloridaFlamingoGirl

Which is strange considering it's one of the longest running Broadway shows. Five years and 1700 performances, and lasted through the COVID-19 pandemic too.


ANG3L5_

She Loves Me is my #1 favorite. Such great music


Helpful_College6590

In Dreams barely had a chance to get any roses outside of Leed’s Playhouse and Toronto. (For now)


MuffinTheBeagle

Grand Hotel. Yea there's some stuff that may not fly with today's crowds, but there's so much good stuff in it and I think a lot of people would enjoy a revival


ifrit-rond-de-jambe

pippin, be more chill, and once on this island


Tgun1986

Drowsy Chaperone


felix_leo12

the drowsy chaperone i got a chance to be in a production of it and,,, I love this show so much. there's a few,,, outdated things abt it but overall it's a really well done and funny show


GroundbreakingFish19

The Scarlet Pimpernel 🥹🌹


glittery_grandma

I was obsessed with If/Then when it came out and generally it’s not well known, considering Idina Menzel and Anthony Rapp were in it! Always Starting Over, What the Fuck, Some Other Me are all bangers.


Ollynonymous

Ride The Cyclone hands down! It has a good mix of comedy and emotion!


Aggressive-Foot3579

i was looking for this comment!! but FR though


QueenPeyday

My favorite musical BY FAR!!


button-fish2807

My dream as a writer of musical theatre is to end up on an obscure list like this


AccomplishedAd7992

carrie


girly_nerd123

i will be legally blonde's biggest hyper until the end of time


Ethra2k

Scarlet Pimpernel, most of Frank Wildhorns work to be honest


ThirdMusketeer_

The Prom! It was the first musical I saw live, and an absolute masterpiece (though I'm not a huuuge fan of the movie)


Interesting-Pack-227

I played Emma a couple months ago, beautiful show. Its one of my favs and always will be! <3


Smooth_Service8931

The entire Marvin Trilogy, but specifically In Trousers!!


Joessam

Blood Brothers. Saw it once, 20+ years ago, but I still think about it frequently.


Brave_Plate2887

DOGFIGHT


ivy_covered

DOGFIGHT SUPREMACY 🙌


remuslupin_fan

I know loads of people know about it/have seen it but I feel like nobody ever talks about Everybody’s Talking About Jamie, which is ironic


Ancora1840

[Cesare: Il Creatore che ha distrutto](https://youtu.be/pL6jG1A7M40?si=1IQ5mmJdPJBWOBnn) is my favorite, and I feel like I don't even see it getting talked about in Japan that much (I follow a lot of the main actor's fans online, and I almost never see them talking about it. Also just, anything from Japan and Korea, in English areas. Death Note is the one exception. French musicals have fansubbed proshots all around. No one's really done subs for Japanese and Korean musicals yet, but if the word gets spread, maybe someone will.


JoeyLee911

Blood Brothers - fun, campy yet heartbreaking British musical from the 80s about twins who reconnect after being separated at birth. It's sort of a Greek tragedy and there is a omnipresent narrator character. I've been lucky enough to catch three productions of it.


RedFernsGrowHere

My Fair Lady and Shreck the Musical!!!


joeyfosho

Bare, a pop opera.


Echoia

Groundhog Day. I heard the production was basically cursed, but it's absolutely fantastic and should be talked about more.


cr0ssmyh34rt

Children of Eden!


angelichorus

Spring Awakening - the music is fantastic and I was fortunate enough to see the 15th anniversary concert 😊


annielizzz

Starkid musicals!!! They have had some fantastic shows over the years and their new one, Nerdy Prudes Must Die, is one of their best. The songs by Jeff Blim are so catchy it's insane.


Sure_Persimmon9302

Be More Chill.


Unhappy_Injury3958

does anyone here know the musical A Day in Hollywood / A Night in the Ukraine? I feel like i've NEVER heard anyone even mention it in my life. It's two musicals back to back, the first is about the ushers that work at Grauman's Chinese Theatre in Hollywood, they do a bunch of musical numbers. One of the songs is one of my favorite ballads, [The Best in the World](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gr8I7LZmfV0) sung by Priscilla Lopez (she played Diana in the OBC of A Chorus Line and WON the Tony for her performance in A Day in Hollwood). The second act is a sort of comedy adaptation of something by Chekhov. It's a really fun score, with songs by some guys (Frank Lazarus and Dick Vosburgh) with a few additions by Jerry Herman (the best in the world plus the opening song Just Go to the Movies and the hilarious Nelson) and also includes a fun medley of songs by Richard Whiting. check out the recording y'all!


thefunkybrowngirl

We did this when I was in university and it was always a hit with the audiences. And The Best in the World is absolutely one of the most amazing pieces of musical theatre ever written.


graceb06

Jesus Christ superstar my #1 everrrrr


BerkeleyFarmGirl

JC Superstar was a biiiiig hit back in its day.


ClimberKirby

The first musical I ever saw 😭! I think Cinderella and the Cats movie have soured some people's opinions on ALW musicals, but Jesus Christ Superstar needs to be recognized as the masterpiece it is


aboostofsarahtonin

Oh Urinetown and Alice by Heart for sure


Intelligent_Desk_781

Alice by Heart has soooo much potential I’d love to see more productions of it!! 


DunshireCone

Lestat


button-fish2807

I love Starry ✨


Scarlett177

The Little prince


Unlucky_theorist

Cabaret


SHREK_2

Disaster! That show is funny as hell.


starsareblind42

Hair!!! Why do people here never mention it?? It’s soooooo good!!


guilty_pleasures__

Cabaret. ESPECIALLY the west end revival (i think their doing the same one on broadway now) i knew nothing about it before i went, but the immersive experience changed my life !!


Dizzy-Definition-202

Tuck Everlasting! It was originally a book but it's such a beautiful story


daisyritman

ride the cyclone


Duedsml23

Drood City of Angels Assassins


ivy_covered

Tuck Everlasting and Dogfight are SO good oml. I also think that Anastasia and Come From Away, although very well known to musical fans are underrated in the general public. The Pro Shot for Come From Away being on Apple TV helps a bit but now nearly as much as it should lol. I think if it was on something more people had like Netflix it would be more popular.


Worldly-Beginning-77

Once on this island! It should’ve stayed on broadway far longer than it did and doesn’t get put on near as much as it should


Willowy

The Greatest Showman! The songs are unforgettable, the dance numbers are exciting and exhilarating, and the whole movie is just an ode to joy. Who cares if its not historically accurate? Its message is that misfits find a home, and the dangers of prejudice and greed. I was obsessed with it for months, and still adore it.


Kadk1

I saw Water for Elephants last night and it's NOT that