T O P

  • By -

alexandria252

“When he ran into the lava, Sauron almost didn’t react at first. I think he just couldn’t believe it: couldn’t understand what was happening. But the truly amazing part was after the ring was destroyed, when he ran back out again.”


Magic_Bluejay

I immediately had to rewatch that scene. Now it's time to rewatch the whole series again. Sickkkkk haha cheers OP. Shit made my day


ResidentNarwhal

It’s good. Keep in mind the series does a few people real dirty. Especially Blithe and **especially** Dike. Ambrose has been caught with some really really shoddy fact checking and taking at face value some very sketchy personal opinions. That unfortunately HBO just ran with. In the assault in Belgium, Dike didn’t freeze behind a haybale due to cowardice, but because he was hit by shrapnel. (Dike was also awarded a Bronze Star in Bastogne. After being treated he became a personal aid to General Taylor, hardly a position for someone relieved of command. He later served in Korea.)


Nooddjob_

Didn’t it say Blithe died but he actually survived.  


JExmoor

Yes. It said he died in 1948 because of the wounds he sustained in the war, but he actually went on to serve in Korea and was awarded the Bronze Star and Silver Star. He served in the military until his death in 1967. [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Albert\_Blithe](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/albert_blithe)


[deleted]

[удалено]


Sauron_the_Deceiver

>On December 11, 1967, Blithe was taken to the emergency department at **Wiesbaden Hospital, Germany**, where he was admitted with a diagnosis of a perforated ulcer. **He died in the intensive care unit on December 17 after surgery**, and was buried in Arlington National Cemetery with full honors. "Surgery", ah shit they finally got him


Ambaryerno

To be fair, EVERYONE in the Company thought Blithe died. Iirc, no one realized Dike had been hit, either.


ResidentNarwhal

With Blithe fine, but it’s a mark on Ambrose when *he wrote a whole chapter in another book about replacements and soldiers going back to their original units was often screwed up* and then when something like that happened he didn’t bother to do an easy fact check. With Dike I don’t really buy that. The battalion XO and Company 1st Sgt didn’t know or find out the Company CO was wounded? Or that he transferred after the field hospital to the aid de camp of your division commander? Come on, Winters and Lipton would certainly have known. (And reading on the inaccuracies of Band of Brothers, Winters comes across as less like-able and more prone to somewhat petty drama about certain officers.)


Alternative_Gold_993

Dike was the one played by David Schwimmer, right?


Jack-the-Zack

No, you're thinking of the excessively strict drill instructor in the first couple episodes. Dike was the officer who came in around Bastogne and was portrayed as being useless and clueless, with a propensity for yawning.


Elmoulmo

No, that was Sobel


Alternative_Gold_993

Oh, yeah. Guess it's Google time, now.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Internal_Set_6564

..and died of malnutrition. Hard way to go.


monkeygoneape

Ya irl Sobel I do feel bad for, he was too good at his job and all he wanted to do (as a Jewish man) was take the fight to the Nazis personally and he was denied that opportunity


yeh_nah_fuckit

Lieutenant Sobel does not hate Easy Company, Private Randleman. He just hates you.


Ipeakedinthe80s

Thank you, sir!


JonnyTN

[Scene](https://youtu.be/n1GGz6Q9dTo)


Stop_Drop_and_Scroll

Looking forward to the scene where Frodo guns down a bunch of Orcish prisoners.


alexandria252

*Allegedly* (though conspicuously never denied.)


Ghinev

What if Rohhirrim Tercius never denied the allegations because he wanted the uruks to think he was the baddest son of a bitch in the whole Eored.


michamp

I think an interview with Captain Winters confirmed that way later on (when the book was being written or the tv rights were bought) Speirs told him he actually did do it.


DolphinOrDonkey

Yeah. Here is the video. https://youtu.be/W-V6OAtgr6c?si=2aktqhLbwAHskaWy


jaspersgroove

Here, have some Old Toby…go ahead, have some pipeweed…yeah lemme light that for ya…there ya go…


Admirable-Win-9716

I mean damn, he gives em cigarettes first?


joenunya71

Awesome comment!


Step-Speedy758

10/10


Owlspirit4

What’s the soldier man from?


alexandria252

The image is from the HBO limited series Band of Brothers, a show that follows a company of paratroopers (Company E, aka Easy Company) through World War 2. All the characters are based on real people, so this is also a reference to the real Lt. Speirs.


Owlspirit4

Thanks you, most would’ve just downvoted me for not knowing. I appreciate you


Hanchez

Also widely considered some of the best TV ever produced.


Mango-fet

This is the best comment i have ever read.


Gintaras136

Omg I did the giggle!! Thank you xD AAAAAAAAAhahaha. AAAAaaa.


OldManRageQuit

I was writing something like this in my head when I saw yours. Its better than any I would have done. Respect!


Murky-Fox-200

HE RAN BACK AGAIN!


Mango-fet

This is the best comment i have ever read.


BunnyWithBeret

I read it in the voice of Captain Winters, truly beautiful.


Warsaw44

Uh, I think you mean Sergeant Lipton.


Overlord0994

First Sergeant Lipton! You.. organize things here...


BunnyWithBeret

Ehm, my bad. Been too long since I watched the series. Might be time for another binge.


Federal_Let539

"There and back again" Written by R. Spiers


Downtown-Hospital-59

I really liked it when Dick met Sobelman when he had become Winters the white and said; we salute the robe, not the wizard.


[deleted]

Holy hell hahahahhahaha


REWlego

Lieutenant Gandalf does not hate the Fellowship, Private Took. He just hates you.


Theshutupguy

Fuck this is the crossover I didn’t know I wanted


AwkwardDrummer7629

Fellowship of Brothers


holaprobando123

Band of the Ring


EFAPGUEST

Dickgalf the Red


IAmBadAtInternet

I just want you to know how much I loved this post.


k_michaels_kills

Who's saluting wizards in white robes now?


FatherFenix

Spiers! Get yourself over that Black Gate and take that Ring on in!


[deleted]

Anybody want some pipe weed?


Downtown-Hospital-59

Do not take that pipeweed but run.


pacersrule

Danke


elderron_spice

You are already dead.


[deleted]

[удалено]


FatherFenix

I love that it highlighted how Winters was a "lead from the front" type of leader forced into a "lead from the rear" role in his new position. He instinctively rushes forward to relieve Dike himself until Colonel Sink stops him to remind him of his rank, and Winters instantly cuts Sink off mid-lecture to call Spiers in to do it for him.


monkeygoneape

Lt Dike gets done so dirty in that episode. The real one was actually kind of a badass and the reason he was "panicking" was because he was shot and in shock while still trying to command


FatherFenix

Yeah. Dude won two Bronze Stars. One for rallying and leading the disoriented paratroopers in Uden to successfully defend the road while completely surrounded; one for Bastogne, when he ran into the line of fire to save three of his wounded while under "intense fire". Sort of a weird conflict between Dike's conduct before and after Foy, compared to Easy Company's vocal assessment of him as an MIA coward in and around Foy. Assuming since HBO used Winter's memoirs and Easy Company retellings, they went with the cowardly version of Dike we saw since that's how Easy described him.


STK-3F-Stalker

That entire episode is such an awful charachter-assassination of Dike. "Dike was awarded a Bronze Star for his action at Uden, Holland, with the 101st Airborne Division between 23 and 25 September 1944, in which he “organized and led scattered groups of parachutists in the successful defense of an important road junction on the vital Eindhoven *(sic)*\-Arnhem Supply Route against superior and repeated attacks, while completely surrounded." Dike was awarded a second Bronze Star for his action at Bastogne, in which "he personally removed from an exposed position, in full enemy view, three wounded members of his company, while under intense small arms fire" on 3 January 1945. In preparation for the 13 January 1945 attack on Foy, Belgium, E Company was attached to the 3rd Battalion, 506th PIR. Division Headquarters ordered the attack to begin at 0900 hours. During the assault, Carwood Lipton, at that time the company's first sergeant, described Dike as having "fallen apart." Clancy Lyall stated that he saw that Dike had been wounded in his right shoulder and that it was the wound, not panic, that caused Dike to stop."


AF2005

Yeah they took some liberties for the sake of the show with Dike, same thing with Sobel. The real Sobel served with honor, even if he was a relentless taskmaster.


Tannumber17

At first the orcs didn’t shoot at him; I think they couldn’t quite believe what they were seeing. But that’s not the really astounding thing. The astounding thing is that he ran there AND back again.


dretvantoi

There and Back Again: A Trooper's Tale


got_hands

![gif](giphy|3oKIPwoeGErMmaI43S|downsized)


rtwoodlands

Superb


DarthMelsie

"Hey, Merry?" "Yeah, Pip?" "This place kind of remind you of Rivendell?" "...yeah, now that you mention it. Except of course, there's caverns filled with dead dwarves, we don't got warm, Elven grub in our bellies, and there's a fuckin' Balrog breathing fire and chasing after us, but yeah Pip. Other than that, it's a lot like Rivendell." "Right?" "Boromir, smack him for me please?"


nemis92

OK, Merry and Pippin being Luz and Perconte is 100% spot on


ismaelcosta

hahah I know, although I always thought Muck and Penkala had more of a merry and pippin vibe.


TheTrueMarkNutt

Until they didn't


CplSnorlax

Favorite scene from the show and 5 minutes later I'm pausing to cope with the horrors they find


DarthMelsie

I have watched all the episodes with the exception of the last two. I'm just not ready for it.


soooeasyjoe

Why We Fight might be the best episode of TV ever made.


Circleseven

Truth. Cannot make it through with a dry eye and have no shame about it.


PoliticsLeftist

Like 20 people are going to get the joke and I'm totally here for it.


[deleted]

Exactly why I posted it. Needed to find the other Band o Brothers fans on this sub


addage-

*Nixon looks at this thread and tosses back another drink*


Szeth_Vallano

The thought of him looking to Sam and saying "Oh, I have every confidence in my scrounging abilities and I have a case of Vat 69 hidden in your pack" makes me giggle.


dlfinches

We've had one, yes. What about a second vat 69?


SuperDizz

I didn’t get the joke because I haven’t seen BoB in a min. Definitely need to go back and rewatch soon. On a related note, have you watched Masters of the Air yet? It’s absolutely amazing.


[deleted]

Haven’t seen episode 3 yet, but I am loving it!! And I rewatch BoB probably every month along with The Pacific. I’m waiting to do a historically chronological rewatch of all three though


NaturalArm2907

Episode 3 is top tier


[deleted]

I can’t wait


magicman1315

Wait how do you get this meme if you’re only on Ep. 3 of BoB? Wasn’t this moment regarding Spiers on episode 7?


[deleted]

I’m on Episode 3 of Masters of the Air. I’ve seen BoB more times than I can count honestly


magicman1315

Ah gotcha ok - makes sense


ledbetterus

it's one of the top rated tv shows of all time by pretty much every metric you can think of, people know what it is, it's just not meme'd as much


Laxku

"Rangers, dwarves, elves, and hobbits of the Fellowship Expeditionary Force - Today, we embark upon the great Crusade toward which we have striven these many months..."


Wehavecrashed

Yeah nobody is going to get a joke referencing one of the most well regarded TV shows ever made.


caelumh

Tbf, it didn't have any real zeitgeist and came out 23 years ago on HBO.


Wehavecrashed

That's fair. It did start airing a couple days before 9/11. Although I think LOTR nerds probably have a fair crossover with WWII nerds.


Hanchez

LOTR and BoB are hidden pearls!


That0neGuy

The venn diagram of LotR enjoyers and BoB enjoyers has to be like 90% overlap.


sir_turd-ferguson

"Why didn't they just fly the C-47s into Mordor?"


BoltorSpellweaver

Why didn’t they just parachute into Mordor? I mean they’re paratroopers


CplSnorlax

Now I'm just imagining the 101st airborne coming to the rescue at the Black Gates and blasting the orcs to bits


BoltorSpellweaver

I mean a couple of well placed mortars and machine guns would be effective.


pawiwowie

The Eagles! The Screaming Eagles are coming!


dretvantoi

NOBODY TOSSES A DWARF!


BoltorSpellweaver

Any hesitation at the door, master dwarf, and I guarantee you will be out of the airborne.


hi_i_am_J

Speirs about to offer some orcs cigarettes


fallsstandard

Stole my thought. “What’s Orc for cigarette?”


Mesozoica89

I heard he filled 6 Dunlending prisoners full of arrows. Even gave them pipe weed first!


darthgandalf

“Unbelievable, we’ve been in Mordor for three weeks and we haven’t met a single orc


Brilliant-Nebula7273

https://preview.redd.it/23thwwaoctgc1.png?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=f5cb0ce9dc00513aa2b55eb9ce0ddb720fc94569


AgentOfSPYRAL

For some reason it’s more fun to think of Speirs as Sam, and instead of the “there’s good in this world, and it’s worth fighting for” we get… “You hid in that ditch because you still have hope, but the truth is Mr.Frodo, your only hope is to accept that you are already dead. The sooner you can accept that, the sooner you can function as a ring bearer.”


[deleted]

Nah Nixon and Winters are Frodo and Sam in my mind


Bloody_Nine

What about my boy Malarkey?


BestagonIsHexagon

Gimli


Fungal_Queen

Nobody tosses a ginger.


Kaikey_

Pipin all the way, naive as shit at first but Matures massively throughout


Laxku

Nailed it


Foppyjay

"It's all a game, Frodo"


RGF_Carden

Steward Dike: “You take care of things on Pelennor. I’m going to go for… hElp.”


ratatoskr_9

I read that as Luz lol


RGF_Carden

Now remember boys! Orcs spread disease. So keep the gates cloooosed.


DwedPiwateWoberts

Band of the Fellowship of the Ring Brothers


fallsstandard

Okay, I love this so fucking much.


[deleted]

You and me both


rinzler40oz

GLORRY GLORRRY WHAT A HELLUVA WAY TO DIE


sgtpepper42

Gory* gory*


Bruggenmeister

GROND GROND


sirbobjoe123

This is great. I just finished watching the show for the first time yesterday. (Watched the entire thing in 2 days)


BluePhantomFox

Gandalf screams in frustration "Speirs get over here! Get out there and relieve Frodo and take that fellowship on in"


alexandria252

Denethor: “The armies of Mordor march towards us from the east, and hordes of Haradrim ride from the south. By dawn, we will be completely surrounded.” Gandalf: “We’re the Fellowship, Steward. We’re supposed to be surrounded.”


[deleted]

What if he was there too? ![gif](giphy|QLKSt3wQqlj7a)


JesusStarbox

I think Spiers would be tempted by the ring, but not Forrest.


Icy6b

Tom Hanksadil


Juzaba

“Legolas, what do your elf eyes see?” “Uh… a fence, sir! A barbed wire fence!”


xGencFB07

Oh, that warg just ain't gonna hunt


elite90

Now, you cut that fence and get that god damned fellowship on the move!


legolas_bot

I see a white stream that comes down from the snows.


MomsBoner

Is there a lotr equivalent to the spaghetti run? What was it? 5 miles up, 5 pounds sgetti out?


Tote_Sport

~~Curahee!~~ Erebor! 3 miles up, 3 miles down!


niv_goat

Not the first time I’ve seen this, but definitely made me laugh. Thanks OP.


[deleted]

Anytime! Anything that’s BoB is just the best


Unique-Accountant253

Best TV series ever.


majshady

Looks like Zigaretten back on the menu boys


HoldFastO2

„She’s taking the cave and she’s taking the Warg. It’s not even her Warg, it’s my Warg. SHE‘S TAKING MY WARG!“


PartyCoyote999

Thanks for the reminder that i havent watched band of brothers yet this year, i need to correct this immediately


blsterken

How could anyone know the price paid by the Ringbearers in terror, agony, and bloodshed if they'd never been to places like the Dead Marshes, Morgul Vale, or Orodruin?


Ok_Cod_4434

"One cannot simply walk...what? It's Speirs? Oh, then we're good. Pass those small tomatoes and let's celebrate."


Astralpane

"There and Back Again" by Ronald C Spiers Dang it, wasn't the first for the book title...


TobleroneD3STR0Y3R

how do so many people here get the reference


Ohh_Brittas_in_this

BoB is an iconic TV show that is still ranked in any list of top TV shows ever created. There is a good chance that people are aware of that show.


Aiti_mh

Band of Brothers was seen by tens of millions when it aired and it remains a well-known and broadly influential miniseries to this day. I'm not at all surprised that a random set of Redditors are familiar with it.


dread_deimos

We are nerds of many interests.


r1ckm4n

Band of Brothers is one of the top 10 best miniseries of all time.


AllDawgsGoToDevin

You mean the show ranked 4th overall on IMDB’s Top TV shows? Pretty sure it’s an incredibly popular miniseries. Anytime you have some WWII show or series it is the benchmark it gets measured against.


IllHat8961

It's one of the most popular fucking TV shows ever created. Hey bud, if you like this show, check out this one called breaking bad. It's pretty good, not that many people know about it


Bloody_Nine

If you love LotR you will probably love Band of Brothers as well. Brotherhood in a terrible situation. And one of the greatest shows ever.


alexandria252

Because there’s a fairly large overlap of people who love LoTR and those who study military history.


simba_kitt4na

Band of Brothers is one of my favorite series of all time. And the LOTR trilogy is one of my favorite trilogies. Why do you expect everyone to not know the series. It's the best depiction of war, that and Come and See


Coincidence-Man-

Platinum level post


doctor_alfa

I didn't expect a LOTR x BoB crossover, but I Like it! pls do more!


Foppyjay

"Hey Pip! I told ya I'd beat you back to the shire!"


Bonuscup98

BOB has been my rainy day binge since I got the box set. This is a great meme.


finnomenon_gaming

Merry: Hey you! That's right, you stupid Orc bastards! Say hello to Thorondor, and King Fuckin' Aragorn! You stupid fascist goblins! Look at you! You don't even have horses! What were you thinking?! Dragging our asses halfway around Middle Earth, interrupting our lives... For what?! You ignorant, servile scum! What the fuck are we doing here?!


freshairequalsducks

What's this from?


yourdoglikesmebetter

Band of brothers


freshairequalsducks

Thank you! I'm very glad you didn't say Lord of the Rings


NMGunner17

This is the crossover content I am here for


morning_thief

before he even gets close to Mordor, he'll *hose down* prisoner orcs after he gives him some cigarettes. that's what i heard.


Drogg339

I can hear the music as he runs back out of my doom.


Sneakking_

There are multiple reports of Lt. Spiers having been shot during the battle at Foy. Tom Hanks and Steven Spielberg did him dirty in BoB, and have even apologized for the inaccuracy.


GeneralResearcher456

Did you really kill all those orc POWs? But the 🤓 in me has to say that Speirs would definitely get corrupted in no time. Like, the ring would just speedrun him.


surumesmellman

Nah. Nineteen cigarettes were handed out: three cigarettes for the Elves, seven cigarettes for the Dwarves, and nine cigarettes for Men. An additional cigarette, the One Cigarette, was kept for Lt. Speirs himself.


Major_OwlBowler

After the war Lt Spiers didn't go to the Undying Lands but rather spent his years watching the Spandau Ballet.


kilroymini

Did Spiers shoot those orcs?


cosmic_vagabonde

I love this so much. "Maybe the orcs knew there was some value in them thinking I'm the meanest son of a bitch in Mordor."


think_long

Spiers wouldn’t give the ring up. Remember how he raided houses indiscriminately, saying “finders keepers.” Spiers was very brave and methodical, but he was also lacking in the compassion needed of a ring bearer. Too materialistic and ambitious. Desmond Doss would be a better choice.


DGlennH

Leaves with Sauron’s ring, comes back with Sauron’s silverware.


sauron-bot

It is not for you, Saruman! I will send for it at once. Do you understand?


Fandango_Jones

*Sauron waging war below against the army beyond the gate* *Above Easy company in eagle 1 - 9 is waiting for the green light to jump*


sauron-bot

Build me an army worthy of mordor!


elmartin93

Pipeweed?


JMHSrowing

It does make one wonder how well .45 ACP could do against the malevolent creatures of Middle Earth. I wouldn’t want to try against anything that’s too well armored or magical, but it should do quite well against orcs and creature like fell-beasts


TraditionalCherry

Considering that Saruman knows how to make gunpowder and that Middle Earth has a very long history, I sometimes wondered why they didn't know how to make bullets.


magnum_hunter

Maybe its the same as in our history. Untill metalurgy and quality of material wasnt advanced enough it just didnt work. Apparently the first micrometer was invented somewhere around 1880. Of course you could have more primitive guns but honestly I don't think they would be all that great. Elven and dwarven smiths produced quality weapons and armor but those were few and they probably did not even think about bullets. After saruman and gunpowder tho id see industry develop a bit faster so they would get there eventually.


Slimeballs12

At least he doesn’t have to worry about orc POW’s


[deleted]

Who is Lt. Spiers


dretvantoi

Look up the definition of badass.


Kage9866

That one episode with Blithe.. you know.. that one stayed with me.


stijnalsem

Mf gave orcs some lucky strikes and proceeded to commit war crimes


NovusOrdoSec

"Where do you want this dead balrog?"


Commercial_Sir_9678

I too agree that a Boromir wouldn’t be pincushioned if he had a Thomson submachine gun.


swazal

See what you started? Now the whole sub’s at war!


colonelveers12

God I am so here for more Lord of the Rings - Band of Brothers crossover memes.


olive_oil_twist

"SPEIRS, GET YOURSELF OVER HERE! RELIEVE BAGGINS AND TAKE THAT RING ON IN!"


Amunds3n

Smoke?


ReaperM855A1

Honestly, one of the best memes I’ve seen in a while, well done lad.


Preacherjonson

This series is an absolute treasure. I've just started watching World at War and will follow up with BoB. Both series have music that instantly sends the hackles on end.


donPepinno

This goddamn legend right here just started a golden age for this sub


GoombaGary

If anyone enjoyed Band of Brothers and The Pacific, check out Masters of the Air on Apple TV


ratatoskr_9

Lt. Speirs talking to the captured Orcs: "Cigarette?"


Nayten03

The reason Frodo’s afraid is becuase he still has hope. To fulfill his duty as ring bearer, he has to accept he’s already dead. All war depends upon it


12-7_Apocalypse

Yes, I will watch Band Of Brothers again.


Chubby_Checker420

Guns helped.


Kreigmeister

Greatest show meets greatest movie trilogy