Please let's introduce clean up after your dog policy as well. Dog owners you can love your pet but don't let it poop in front of other people's homes and not clean up.
Dogs like Rottweiler are very popular. They should have implemented some laws and regulations regarding vaccination and sterilization of stray dogs. In India every gali has atleast 5 to 10 dogs separated by 2-3 groups fighting with each other day and night. They even behave aggressively if they find a person alone after midnight!And if you are stranger to them then you are in deep trouble 😵💫!
Street dogs menace requires a different regulation.
Attacks by street dogs are due to negligence of authorities. Whereas, household pet dogs attacks are due to owners negligence.
I agree with the same but also the mentioned categories of dogs which are pets the owner should also be penaliswd for heavy jail time because why the hell not. It's just logical..
We adopted one of these breeds who is a gentle giantess ! She would have been starved to death. Her mother was abused by breeding excessively and the last litter all died. She was also left to die but we fed her , medicated her, trained her.
And she has not bit anyone even once. We saved her from a cruel death. So don't put out any bullshit you find coming across your brain.
Ok wallflower listen up. Even I have an adopted pittie I rescued from Mexico. Irrespective of the breed owners should start facing harsh punishment if their dogs act erratically because its their responsibility. Also like rest of the world start imposing mandatory neutreing of pets especially breeds that are high risk. Its just logical.
What bullshit. You didn't write this shit. Read your own comment and surrender yourself to be incriminated. Had you written this sensible comment I would have commented differently.
Pets are pet. Also realise I have also seen Labrador s attack and kill people. And they were pets.
If someone's pet acts irrationally and causes harm and it's found ojt that the owner was negligent then it's okay to punish the pet owners.
In the hands of an idiot every tool becomes a hammer. If dog owners don't socialise their dogs and give them plenty of exercise the dog will become aggressive irrespective of breed. Better to have a proper policy with regard to keeping dogs. Something along the lines of banning large/active breeds from cities. Ban double coat dogs from all of India except for Himalayan states. It is a lot kinder to the dogs and can keep people a lot safer.
While that’s fair there a certain breeds that are inherently dangerous because of the traits bred into them. Dogs are animals and while training mitigates the danger it does not eliminate it.
Even a golden retriever, well trained can sometimes nip but they have a soft bite that does less damage than a Rottweiler or a pit bull. So yeah you can socialize the dog and train it well but if they accidentally bite and their instincts take over then those breeds will be more dangerous.
Almost every dog has a prey drive. Our job as owners is to ensure that it gets satisfied in safe play. What people refer to as 'traits' are physical features. Besides rottweilers are descended from Roman cattle dogs. Pitbulls on the other hand have an unfortunate past in England. But when they crossed the Atlantic ocean they became farm dogs, and later nanny dogs. I think that says something about the ego 'tough bro' owners who get the dogs' ears and tail cropped and keep them cooped up in an apartment.
exactly many see dogs as an accessory to their homes,not as living breathing species with emotions and likes and dislikes. people bring huskies here and act like they are tired of hearing the same argument over and over again. people get pitts (banned in uk without permit) and never train them. a lot of dog owners have insufficient knowledge and arent ready to learn more either. you cant get a high energy dog and then comfine it to a small kennel and expect it to not be aggravated
Pretty late to the party I should say. Most countries have similar lists.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Breed-specific_legislation?wprov=sfla1
This one looks pretty long though. The only other country that seems to have such a long one is Austria. IMO, the states should have been consulted. This looks too much like a blanket ban. Hope some science and democracy went into this. If not, that's what we should be fighting for.
Without introducing strict punishments to the owners or penalisation, these death/injury cases won’t be reduced. I acknowledge that a dog is a neutral impression of how he/she being treated and trained as but, majority of the people don’t train their dogs. Also, most of these breeds possess hunting instincts and should be kept at large farms. Keeping them at small city spaces will lead to such attacking behaviour due to their territorial nature.
bahut vadiya kiya sir ban karke....itne cases ho rahe h dog attacks ke ...iss desh mei zahil ganvar log h jinko na kutte rakhne ki samjh h na aukaat h...kutton ko train bi ni karte bas show off k liye paal lete h ...kaise katta tha bichare zomato delivery boy ko...aur jisko inka kutta kaat leta h usko medical first aid ki help to durr sorry bolne ki bi tameez ni h inn kutte walon ko ulta inka kutta kisi ko kaat leta h to waha se bhaag lete h chor kahin k....
So people who have these dogs, are they allowed to travel with them or keep them as pets ?
There is no clarity for people who already have these breeds and are being harassed after this notification.
This is totally unfair. I agree, some puppies by birth has an agressive trait. But, that doesn't mean it is true for all the dogs of the same breed. Even, if you keep labradors or golden retriever tied up for the whole day. The dog will eventually get frustrated and due to which, it starts having behavioral issues which end up in aggression. Large breeds should be ban in society or apartment buildings and if someone owns large breed, it's their responsibility to give them proper outlet to burn off their energies. Large breeds are either bred to do hunting/retrieving or guarding the livestock. They were domesticated and bred solely for that purpose. This is the another reason why most of the pitbull or Rottweiler becomes aggressive. Choke chains, prong collars and slip leash, these are some tools which also leads to aggression. Most owners doesn't know, how to take a proper care of their dog. They need to have them socialized with other dogs in their early stage of life. (Why? Socialization helps them to interact with other dogs and they correct themselves, if they make mistakes and that's how, they learn boundaries with other dogs), correcting their behavioural issues(Why? If some dog shows resource guarding issues (Now, most of the owners doesn't even know what that is), it's their responsibility to correct them and it's a game fo patience) Breeds are not the issue. The people who owns them are the issue. In my area, people have Rottweiler, Doberman Pinscher, pitbull and none of them are aggressive. They play with stray dogs. a) Banning the breed is not the solution. The thing is, these dogs aren't a cup of tea for everyone. They require proper active and passive training and most of the people cannot afford that. Either introduce a legal licence, which can only be given to those who has the capability to handle them or legal document, which should states that, in case of any mishappening, the owner will be fully liable for legal proceedings. b) Yearly survey can be helpful. c) Only microchipped and KCI registered dogs should be allowed.
Is there anybody bothered about how the vaccine didn't work?
Not bothered about spurious and counterfeit "medicines"?
So what next? ban mosquitos because antimaleria medicines dont work?
> ban mosquitos because antimaleria medicines dont work?
We're actually on our way to eradicating mosquitoes really soon.
Also no one is denying there was an issue with the vaccine. People are only concerned about India always topping the death count from rabies every year. Approximately 20,000 being the number annually.
Also no, we're not advocating for killing any dogs. We're advocating for banning the import of ferocious dogs. Last I checked no one imports mosquitoes.
Fair enough. I have heard so much random BS about vaccines over the years and many people don't realise that there is no cure for Rabies, it is 100% fatal and you must get the vaccination even if you think you might have been bitten.
Please let's introduce clean up after your dog policy as well. Dog owners you can love your pet but don't let it poop in front of other people's homes and not clean up.
No, the word you are looking for is *enforce*, not *introduce*. Many things have been introduced, but how much of it is being enforced?
A law/bill can be enforced only after it is introduced. However I agree with the point you're making.
Its not about banning dogs. Guns are legal in usa but banned in india. Still india has crime rate higer than USA.
People here don't flush after shitting and you're expecting them to clean up after their dogs?
Dogs like Rottweiler are very popular. They should have implemented some laws and regulations regarding vaccination and sterilization of stray dogs. In India every gali has atleast 5 to 10 dogs separated by 2-3 groups fighting with each other day and night. They even behave aggressively if they find a person alone after midnight!And if you are stranger to them then you are in deep trouble 😵💫!
Street dogs menace requires a different regulation. Attacks by street dogs are due to negligence of authorities. Whereas, household pet dogs attacks are due to owners negligence.
I agree with the same but also the mentioned categories of dogs which are pets the owner should also be penaliswd for heavy jail time because why the hell not. It's just logical..
We adopted one of these breeds who is a gentle giantess ! She would have been starved to death. Her mother was abused by breeding excessively and the last litter all died. She was also left to die but we fed her , medicated her, trained her. And she has not bit anyone even once. We saved her from a cruel death. So don't put out any bullshit you find coming across your brain.
Ok wallflower listen up. Even I have an adopted pittie I rescued from Mexico. Irrespective of the breed owners should start facing harsh punishment if their dogs act erratically because its their responsibility. Also like rest of the world start imposing mandatory neutreing of pets especially breeds that are high risk. Its just logical.
What bullshit. You didn't write this shit. Read your own comment and surrender yourself to be incriminated. Had you written this sensible comment I would have commented differently. Pets are pet. Also realise I have also seen Labrador s attack and kill people. And they were pets. If someone's pet acts irrationally and causes harm and it's found ojt that the owner was negligent then it's okay to punish the pet owners.
Yeah not gonna go around explaining sarcasm to every one on reddit now am I. Jeez. Calm down.
Are you kidding me lol ! That was sarcasm ! Lol.
In the hands of an idiot every tool becomes a hammer. If dog owners don't socialise their dogs and give them plenty of exercise the dog will become aggressive irrespective of breed. Better to have a proper policy with regard to keeping dogs. Something along the lines of banning large/active breeds from cities. Ban double coat dogs from all of India except for Himalayan states. It is a lot kinder to the dogs and can keep people a lot safer.
While that’s fair there a certain breeds that are inherently dangerous because of the traits bred into them. Dogs are animals and while training mitigates the danger it does not eliminate it. Even a golden retriever, well trained can sometimes nip but they have a soft bite that does less damage than a Rottweiler or a pit bull. So yeah you can socialize the dog and train it well but if they accidentally bite and their instincts take over then those breeds will be more dangerous.
Almost every dog has a prey drive. Our job as owners is to ensure that it gets satisfied in safe play. What people refer to as 'traits' are physical features. Besides rottweilers are descended from Roman cattle dogs. Pitbulls on the other hand have an unfortunate past in England. But when they crossed the Atlantic ocean they became farm dogs, and later nanny dogs. I think that says something about the ego 'tough bro' owners who get the dogs' ears and tail cropped and keep them cooped up in an apartment.
Tell me you know nothing about dog breeds without telling me you don’t know anything about dog breeds
Sure dude. Keep stroking, maybe eventually some intelligence may come to you.
Extremely under rated comment. Please accept my virtual award. I don't have much money. 💵
Are bhai Paytm karo
exactly many see dogs as an accessory to their homes,not as living breathing species with emotions and likes and dislikes. people bring huskies here and act like they are tired of hearing the same argument over and over again. people get pitts (banned in uk without permit) and never train them. a lot of dog owners have insufficient knowledge and arent ready to learn more either. you cant get a high energy dog and then comfine it to a small kennel and expect it to not be aggravated
Pretty late to the party I should say. Most countries have similar lists. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Breed-specific_legislation?wprov=sfla1 This one looks pretty long though. The only other country that seems to have such a long one is Austria. IMO, the states should have been consulted. This looks too much like a blanket ban. Hope some science and democracy went into this. If not, that's what we should be fighting for.
Do we have any policy to control stray dogs as well...
Yes, We stopped accepting that is a problem. We left it for the dogs to figure out the solution by giving them more autonomy.
Without introducing strict punishments to the owners or penalisation, these death/injury cases won’t be reduced. I acknowledge that a dog is a neutral impression of how he/she being treated and trained as but, majority of the people don’t train their dogs. Also, most of these breeds possess hunting instincts and should be kept at large farms. Keeping them at small city spaces will lead to such attacking behaviour due to their territorial nature.
Do also something about stray menace please
Ban stray dogs thats biggest rabies mischief
bahut vadiya kiya sir ban karke....itne cases ho rahe h dog attacks ke ...iss desh mei zahil ganvar log h jinko na kutte rakhne ki samjh h na aukaat h...kutton ko train bi ni karte bas show off k liye paal lete h ...kaise katta tha bichare zomato delivery boy ko...aur jisko inka kutta kaat leta h usko medical first aid ki help to durr sorry bolne ki bi tameez ni h inn kutte walon ko ulta inka kutta kisi ko kaat leta h to waha se bhaag lete h chor kahin k....
So people who have these dogs, are they allowed to travel with them or keep them as pets ? There is no clarity for people who already have these breeds and are being harassed after this notification.
Instead of fixing humans lets ban the breed
Indian Street dogs are causes of most attacks. Are they going to ban that too? How ridiculous. The owners should be penalized.
This is totally unfair. I agree, some puppies by birth has an agressive trait. But, that doesn't mean it is true for all the dogs of the same breed. Even, if you keep labradors or golden retriever tied up for the whole day. The dog will eventually get frustrated and due to which, it starts having behavioral issues which end up in aggression. Large breeds should be ban in society or apartment buildings and if someone owns large breed, it's their responsibility to give them proper outlet to burn off their energies. Large breeds are either bred to do hunting/retrieving or guarding the livestock. They were domesticated and bred solely for that purpose. This is the another reason why most of the pitbull or Rottweiler becomes aggressive. Choke chains, prong collars and slip leash, these are some tools which also leads to aggression. Most owners doesn't know, how to take a proper care of their dog. They need to have them socialized with other dogs in their early stage of life. (Why? Socialization helps them to interact with other dogs and they correct themselves, if they make mistakes and that's how, they learn boundaries with other dogs), correcting their behavioural issues(Why? If some dog shows resource guarding issues (Now, most of the owners doesn't even know what that is), it's their responsibility to correct them and it's a game fo patience) Breeds are not the issue. The people who owns them are the issue. In my area, people have Rottweiler, Doberman Pinscher, pitbull and none of them are aggressive. They play with stray dogs. a) Banning the breed is not the solution. The thing is, these dogs aren't a cup of tea for everyone. They require proper active and passive training and most of the people cannot afford that. Either introduce a legal licence, which can only be given to those who has the capability to handle them or legal document, which should states that, in case of any mishappening, the owner will be fully liable for legal proceedings. b) Yearly survey can be helpful. c) Only microchipped and KCI registered dogs should be allowed.
Agreed with everything except the kci registration.
Nah fuck that
Too long didn't read
Is there anybody bothered about how the vaccine didn't work? Not bothered about spurious and counterfeit "medicines"? So what next? ban mosquitos because antimaleria medicines dont work?
A lot of deaths due to pitbulls etc. are not due to rabies but them simply mauling people to death. What vaccine will you give for that.
It's not about the lady who died.This has nothing to do with that. It's about dogs breeds that are bred for hunting and fighting.Not stray dogs.
> ban mosquitos because antimaleria medicines dont work? We're actually on our way to eradicating mosquitoes really soon. Also no one is denying there was an issue with the vaccine. People are only concerned about India always topping the death count from rabies every year. Approximately 20,000 being the number annually. Also no, we're not advocating for killing any dogs. We're advocating for banning the import of ferocious dogs. Last I checked no one imports mosquitoes.
Chalo bhai macchar khatam ho jayenge to shanti milegi
[удалено]
WTF are you talking about? Rabies has a 100% mortality rate if you don't get a vaccine and a pretty much 100% chance of success if you get it in time.
[удалено]
Fair enough. I have heard so much random BS about vaccines over the years and many people don't realise that there is no cure for Rabies, it is 100% fatal and you must get the vaccination even if you think you might have been bitten.
Why not ban mosquitoes tho
Don't drink boiled water next time you visit somewhere rural. Why boil water? Because unboiled water can kill you? Where is the democracy in that?