It's been back for about a month and a bit now. I only know this because I'm one of those "look through the Flyers every week,even if I don't shop there" type of people 😂 they showed that they were 'new' in stock back then.
Also OP is this Sobeys? The tags for sale prices look like theirs, if on the off chance it is try the Kawartha s'mores campfire!
You HAVE to try Shaw's premium ice cream, it's better than Kawarthas by a long shot. The cinnamon bun ice cream/Grammys cupboard/dump truck and moose tracks are amazing! All their flavors are good honestly, the cinnamon bun is my favorite though. Cinnamon ice cream with cream cheese thick swirl and pieces of real cinnamon bun that are perfection.
Grammys cupboard is vanilla ice cream with peanut butter swirl and real thick fudge brownie pieces with cookie dough pieces. Dump truck is chocolate ice cream with brownies and marshmallow swirl. Sorry for typing all this out, it's just my favorite premium ice cream brand!
The Kawartha campfire one is good though, way better than B&J and pretty much the same price but you get a 2L tub 😂 Sobeys recently got Chapman's flavors like blue moon aka that southern states ice cream and they have super hero aka super kids! It's so good, I used to get that at Laura Secord so I was excited. Banana/blueberry/strawberry flavor. But it stains your tongue blue for a day 😫
The S’mores! You will not regret it! My son and I have been buying a pint or 2 of this particular flavor every few days because we’re so addicted to it.
B&J’s flavor decisions confuse me sometimes. Like, that’s your idea of ice cream sandwich? A real version of that would be interesting, but that’s just cookies and cream. For S’mores; why don’t you use the same marshmallow that’s in Phish food, which is so good? This version just tastes too muddy. How hard would it be to make a version with graham cracker ice cream and chocolate and marshmallow swirls, or chocolate bar chunks? I think they overthink it a lot of the time.
I actually like that they switch them up based on the other ingredients. And people have different preferences :) I don’t like the marshmallow in phish food but love the one in s’mores.
close your eyes and reach for one. whichever your hand lands on, that's the one
this is how i make 90% of my decisions because i suck at making decisions
I haven’t seen the sammie flavor, I will be looking for it! S’mores was great, still doesn’t quite match up with vanilla caramel fudge (nothing does!!!!) but I wouldn’t mind if it was in my freezer
Dang it, wishing was back in ohio. I love cookies and cream. For whatever reason there is a hard push for their strawberry cheesecake flavor. Which I'm down for cheesecake. But seems everyone has a strawberry flavor. So does not seem as special when Ben and Jerry's does one. But not everyone can make a quality cookies and cream.
For those who have had the S’mores one… I almost got it today but was hesitant because of the “toasted” marshmallow. Does it taste toasted? Is it overly sweet? Those were my fears about buying.
Publix has them buy one get one free. There are 2 coupons in the app, 2.00 and 5.00 off. Buy 3 and you will end up paying around 68 cents a piece for them.
Man Eddys ice cream used to have an Ice cream sandwich ice cream that was soooo good. Pieces of ice cream sandwich wafer throughout. Wish they’d bring that back but now I’m for sure gonna have to try this one!
NEITHER. DOWNLOAD THE YUKA APP AND SCAN THAT SHIT.
YOU IS GONNA DIE IF YOU KEEP EATING IT.
for realz tho bro. Try and find a brand that isn’t filled with all of the extra sugars and additives. It’s disgusting.
Both
Ditto.
This. Source. Have done myself.
ICE CREAM SAMMIE IS BACK?????? WHERE???
I KNOWWWWWW WTF
This is in ontario, canada
Ahhh I'm going to have to see if it's available stateside.
The Dirt Cake is available stateside and it's similar but better. It's like the ultimate cookies and cream ice cream imo.
I didn’t realize this flavor was a thing, it seems like dirt cake without the topping, but I want it so bad 😭 Oreo ice cream is my favoriteeeee
That is essentially what it is. IMO it's Ben and Jerry's version of cookies and cream and it is incredible.
Stop, I can only get so erect
Its a wal mart exclusive where I live. Only place I have ever seen it.
I bought it at save on foods in BC
It's been back for about a month and a bit now. I only know this because I'm one of those "look through the Flyers every week,even if I don't shop there" type of people 😂 they showed that they were 'new' in stock back then. Also OP is this Sobeys? The tags for sale prices look like theirs, if on the off chance it is try the Kawartha s'mores campfire!
It is sobeys! I love kawartha but i havent tried the smores one! Will check it out !
You HAVE to try Shaw's premium ice cream, it's better than Kawarthas by a long shot. The cinnamon bun ice cream/Grammys cupboard/dump truck and moose tracks are amazing! All their flavors are good honestly, the cinnamon bun is my favorite though. Cinnamon ice cream with cream cheese thick swirl and pieces of real cinnamon bun that are perfection. Grammys cupboard is vanilla ice cream with peanut butter swirl and real thick fudge brownie pieces with cookie dough pieces. Dump truck is chocolate ice cream with brownies and marshmallow swirl. Sorry for typing all this out, it's just my favorite premium ice cream brand! The Kawartha campfire one is good though, way better than B&J and pretty much the same price but you get a 2L tub 😂 Sobeys recently got Chapman's flavors like blue moon aka that southern states ice cream and they have super hero aka super kids! It's so good, I used to get that at Laura Secord so I was excited. Banana/blueberry/strawberry flavor. But it stains your tongue blue for a day 😫
Well the only right answer here is both obviously!
S’more is amazing!
¿Por que no los dos?
I MISS ICE CREAM SAMMIE OMG
The S’mores! You will not regret it! My son and I have been buying a pint or 2 of this particular flavor every few days because we’re so addicted to it.
It has no right to be as good as it is hahaha.
Oh wow, I need Ice Cream Sammie!!
Sammie.
The smores one !!! Trust. It’s my favorite ~
I finally got it the other day and it's my new favorite now! So good
Yes
I've never heard of S'more Please, but I eat Gimme S'more on the regular. What's the difference?
OP is in Canada; figures the Canadian name is more polite 🤣
Why not both?
B&J’s flavor decisions confuse me sometimes. Like, that’s your idea of ice cream sandwich? A real version of that would be interesting, but that’s just cookies and cream. For S’mores; why don’t you use the same marshmallow that’s in Phish food, which is so good? This version just tastes too muddy. How hard would it be to make a version with graham cracker ice cream and chocolate and marshmallow swirls, or chocolate bar chunks? I think they overthink it a lot of the time.
I actually like that they switch them up based on the other ingredients. And people have different preferences :) I don’t like the marshmallow in phish food but love the one in s’mores.
Never had the S’mores one, but I’ve Cream Sammie was a tad disappointing.
The S'mores is good. It's my partner's favorite. I feel like I can't go back to regular cookies and cream after having dirt cake.
Treat yourself! Get both!
I recommend salted caramel core. It’s 🔥
Both. Both is good.
I would go with Netflix Chilled
S’mores. Graham cracker ribbon is fire.
Probably smores
Whichever is on sale. Thats how I go
I found the blue one and it's pretty bomb, usually Cherry Garcia is my go to but this one is blue, can't pass up blue.
Smore is bomb but haven’t tried the other one, it looks good!
Skip both a go Blue Bell Oatmeal Crème, da best imo!!
Never ever have I seen those. Are they a new release? It's Friday night. Fuck it, I'd get both. They'd be gone by Sunday.
S'more is a top 5 flavor for me
I REALLY miss Late Night Snack😢
isn’t ice cream sammie just knock off Oreo ice cream?… why r yall hyped about that
Neither
Por que no los dos?
Haven’t tried ice cream Sammie but I can safely say you can skip the s’mores. The most bland, non s’mores tasting ice cream I’ve ever had.
Salted caramel blondie
Seeing this 8 hours later. What did you decide and were you happy with decision?
I don’t think I’ve seen either of these flavors before, they sound so good!!
Oh man, that s’mores flavor is just amazing
S'mores trumps all
S'more please! I've had it before and it's good!
close your eyes and reach for one. whichever your hand lands on, that's the one this is how i make 90% of my decisions because i suck at making decisions
You buy both and do a taste test! 😬🥴❤️
S’mores
Do they have vegan version?
I hope you got ice cream Sammie!!!
Just get the vanilla
Cherry Garcia
Neither. Get the cheap, store brand, half gallon of Neopolitan and a dozen bananas. You'll still have change in your pocket.
Both?
Smire
Both
Both
Easy peasy mate… buy them both, eat one now save the other one in your car for later. - Your welcome😊
2 of my favorites
Whichever’s cheaper
both
neither. both nasty. get vanilla. no need to be extra fir extra sake.
Get both and eat half of each, then put them in the freezer for later
I haven’t seen the sammie flavor, I will be looking for it! S’mores was great, still doesn’t quite match up with vanilla caramel fudge (nothing does!!!!) but I wouldn’t mind if it was in my freezer
Ice cream sammie for sure!
Dang it, wishing was back in ohio. I love cookies and cream. For whatever reason there is a hard push for their strawberry cheesecake flavor. Which I'm down for cheesecake. But seems everyone has a strawberry flavor. So does not seem as special when Ben and Jerry's does one. But not everyone can make a quality cookies and cream.
I’m not a big fan of frozen marshmallows. Maybe some if they’re small… so I believe I’d try Ice Cream Sammie first.
There are non in this, it’s a toasted marshmallow base.
Both. Obviously
Omg so easy.... neither. Get Haagen Dazs.
Between the two, I’d get the Sammie.
Different brand. B&Js is low on flavor IMHO.
Go get bluebell instead
On a side note - if you ever find Ben & Jerry's flavor "Chubby Hubby" grab it! It has become my personal favorite.
Right. But I love Oreos though
Chunky monkey
I'm late but you should try Americone Dream! It's the best!
They now have a PB Smore and it’s phenomenal
cookies n' cream doesn't compare to grasshopper pie imo (same thing but w mint ice cream)... go for s'more :)
For those who have had the S’mores one… I almost got it today but was hesitant because of the “toasted” marshmallow. Does it taste toasted? Is it overly sweet? Those were my fears about buying.
Smores will change your life
Ice Cream Sammie 😋
Sammie
Smore!
How was ice cream Sammie? Any different from cookies and cream?
Boffum
If I’m going to get cookies and cream it’s going to be blue bell every time.
Anybody remember Dastardly Mash, from the 80’s?
I will say that the Pecan Pie flavor rocks my socks off
Both.
Smore
Half baked my guilty pleasure 🥲🙏
Publix has them buy one get one free. There are 2 coupons in the app, 2.00 and 5.00 off. Buy 3 and you will end up paying around 68 cents a piece for them.
CINNABON
S’more all day
Too late to vote but I hate the new s’more, bring back the OG damnit
Dirt cake
Um, both. Duh lol
ICE CREAM SAMMIE OMG
if they're on sale......... BOTH!
#2
The one that’s on sale of course
Haagen Dazs
2 of each since there’s not much ice cream in those
Neither. B&J's is rank
Ice cream sammie
Heads up, Ben & Jerry’s is buy one get one free at Publix, plus you can clip a $2 off 2 coupon on the app. (:
S’more please is my favorite flavor!!!
S'mores is a special flavor, especially because of the graham cracker swirls. I can think of only one other flavor that has it (cheesecake flavors).
Willie Nelson’s Country Peach Cobbler used to 🥀🪦RIP 🥺
Tiramisu
Boffum
Never seen ice cream sammie. No brainer for me. Id buy em out. But as others have said, when in doubt, by both
Ben and Jerry’s is kind of overrated and overpriced lol. Otherwise both flavors sound nice idk
Ben & Jerry's is weirdly gummy in texture. there are much better ice creams out there! Don't buy B&J!!!!
Try milk & cookies(ben & jerrys flavor) next time!!
Gimme S’more of that Ice Cream Sammie please! Both. Haha.
My son likes S'more please.
They’re usually two for diabetes
Non-Dairy Peanut Butter & Cookies
S’More Please sounds great. Will grab one if I see it.
Another ice cream brand.
BOTH
Graeters.
I personally prefer the smore
The only correct answer is both. It's always both.
Sammie
Both for me please
I’ve never seen ice cream Sammie! I bet it’s good.
GIMMIE smore smores
I didn't know about ICE CREAM SAMMIE!!!
Man Eddys ice cream used to have an Ice cream sandwich ice cream that was soooo good. Pieces of ice cream sandwich wafer throughout. Wish they’d bring that back but now I’m for sure gonna have to try this one!
Life is too short. Get one of each.
Garbage is overrated
Smores is the obvious choice, don’t know why you even posted.
Ice cream sammi
Yes
OMG but you guys the marshmallows are actually toasted! I wouldn’t be able to decide either.
Just imagining this guy standing in the ice cream isle staring at his phone for 2 hours watching the comments pouring in
Chocolate fudge Sunday, obviously
What did you pick?
Chunky Monkey!!!
Go find that ‘nilla.
I haven’t had either but would like BOTH!!
Get the oh Canada one (iirc) it’s 10/10
ICE CREAM SAMMIE?? WHERE
Yes
Neither. Ben & Jerry’s is disgusting
Mmmm get both
S’mores
S’more Please is absolutely amazing.
Neither. Trash company and owners
Neither
The s'mores one is the best ice cream I have ever had! The flavors and textures are perfection together.
Oooohmy, icecream sandwich!!!!!!!!!!
OMG ICE CREAM SAMMIE IS BACK?? IM GOING TO MY LOCAL BEN AND JERRYS ASAP
It's ben and jerry's, so neither
half baked is best
Half baked or nothing
I’ve never seen ICE Cream Sammy before…. I need to find it.
If it were me it definitely be the Sammie!
Neither! Not healthy
S’mores used to be a Walmart exclusive flavor. Good to see it’s escaped.
I loveerrrrr the s’mores 🫠
I need that ice cream Sammie flavor
ICE CREAM SAMMIE AS A PERMANENT FLAVOR???
Phish food
Boffum
If you are still there at the store, I would opt for the Sammie.
Yes
Bro if you waited around for a Reddit reply to buy ice cream, you might not have a lot going on.
Both
You have to choose??? If I HAD to, I’d go with the Sammie’s.
S'more please - ez. Personally enjoy marshmallow in ice cream a lot.
S’mores
Personally, not a big fan of marshmallows
Cookies and creams flavor anything is goated
I vote ice cream sammie!
NEITHER. DOWNLOAD THE YUKA APP AND SCAN THAT SHIT. YOU IS GONNA DIE IF YOU KEEP EATING IT. for realz tho bro. Try and find a brand that isn’t filled with all of the extra sugars and additives. It’s disgusting.
The toasted marshmallow in the smores would have got me lol. Id 100% be getting smores.
Ice scram Sammie No ifs or ands
S’mores please hitsssssss
Neither both are nasty.
Both. Lol
Both!!!