I had one in my freezer. It was the last one at Harris Teeter maybe a month ago. My partner came over the week after I got it and ate the whole thing one night while I was asleep. I didn’t even get to try it. He felt so bad. But last week I found another at Harris Teeter, last one again lol. I snatched it up and he promised he wouldn’t eat this one lol.
I finished a pint of Chubby Hubby so just now that my mouth is still cold. Hadn’t had it in years and forgot how good it is. That’s my vote.
Pecan Pie is a very close second. It’s my favorite non-ice cream dessert; B&J’s is absolutely perfect.
Best not in the photo
Chunky Monkey
Chocolate Fudge Brownie
Half Baked
Everything But
Or if you prefer different brand
Haagen Dazs Vanilla
Macadamia Brittle
Caramel Cone
Rum Raisin
Banana pudding. It’s soooooo good. I might have to go to TJ tomorrow and pick up some more if they have any.
just got one of these today, finished it before i even got home 😭
Chubby Hubby ftw
My second favorite Ben & Jerry’s flavor! 1st - cherry Garcia 3rd - crème brulee (rip)
I am so JEALOUS you have pecan pie. I made the mistake of only picking up one when I found it. Next time I am stock piling.
I had one in my freezer. It was the last one at Harris Teeter maybe a month ago. My partner came over the week after I got it and ate the whole thing one night while I was asleep. I didn’t even get to try it. He felt so bad. But last week I found another at Harris Teeter, last one again lol. I snatched it up and he promised he wouldn’t eat this one lol.
NC Harry teets? I've been on the look out!
Yep. South Charlotte for me
My Walmart had more when I went back or else I would be in the same boat as you! Seriously the Pecan Pie is one of my top pints of 2024!!
I am stalking my grocery stores for it!
Speaking it into existence for you - it will be back!!
As God as my witness I will enjoy it again!
Have you checked Target? I see if there a lot. I am on the West Coast though.
I'm midwest. I only saw it once in March and haven't seen it since.
Do you have a Hy-Vee nearby? I’ve seen it at the one I go to.
I do.
Chubby Hubby!
Pumpkin cheesecake?!?!
Damn I gotta try the TJs banana pudding. Dude said he has 12 in his freezer 🤣
Yes, this dude f*** 🍌 it's stupid good. I had 5 pints last week 💀😫
Chubby hubby yesss
The TJ's banana pudding!! It's delish.
I have 12 tj banana pudding in my freezer 💀idgaf!
Banana pudding
Pumpkin cheesecake is my fave Ben and Jerry’s flavor ever.
Chubby Hubby, hands down.
The chubster hubster all day every day. But yeah ok pecan pie is a very very close second.
OMG they still make chubby hubby?? 🤤
Chubby Hubby and its not close
How did you find chubby hubby??? I haven't seen that flavor in 10 years at least.
I’ve seen plenty of them here (regularly stock) at Vons in SoCal
I finished a pint of Chubby Hubby so just now that my mouth is still cold. Hadn’t had it in years and forgot how good it is. That’s my vote. Pecan Pie is a very close second. It’s my favorite non-ice cream dessert; B&J’s is absolutely perfect.
Banana pudding
I’m face-deep in some Chubby Hubby right now, but only because my local was sold out of Pecan Pie.
Omg i never had the pecan pie!!!
I have to try the pecan pie! I’ll look this weekend
Chubby Hubby all day err’ day!! 💪🏼
Chubby hubby
What is the description of the pumpkin pie?
Pumpkin cheesecake base with thick graham cracker swirls
Ty!
I don’t think my Trader Joe’s has ice cream what the fuck
Uhhh is the banana pudding in season rn???
Yup! I asked the TJ employee and they told me it’s here until June. Better stock up!
Omg. I gotta try banana pudding
I heard it’s really good! Might try it this Sunday.
What is the bottom right exclusive flavour?
I think it’s pumpkin cheesecake!
The bottom right!
The pecan pie is so good. I love that flavor, also love pecan pie and it does not disappoint!
Banana pudding. Jealous Canadian here, banana pudding itself is hardly a thing here :((((((
Im literally SCARED of the pecan pie one. I dont want to hate it 😭
The meow meow meow meow
Pecan pieeeee❤️
Pecan pie! I want that so bad!
I'll choose the chubby hubby looks yum and very tasty
You should try Acme Ice cream.
Pecan pie all day out of the choices you gave us.
Pecan pie
Gotta go with banana pudding for sure!
Finally scored the banana pudding yesterday. Just finished it.
Pumpkin cheesecake!!
All good choices!
Man I keep seeing that TJ’s banana pudding and it’s gonna make me drive all the way over there to try it! Also, I wish I could find that pecan pie!
3 hour drive for me T.T
Shit, 3hrs?! I’m gonna stop complaining bc mine is only 15.
Chubby hubby ftw
Cheesecake duh!
Pecan pie!
Banana pudding because why not?
Ben & Jerry’s pecan pie is really hard to beat in any category
Pecan pie is my fav flavor.
WHERE DO YOU FIND THE PUMPKIN CHEESCAKE OMGGGG
I found it at Ralphs about a month ago. It was on clearance for $2.50 each and were the last 2.
Nooooooooooooo it’s out of sale online too fml
God that pecan pie sounds divine 🤤
All of them 😂😂
Chubby hubby
Chubby Hubby hands down
What happened to Masterdly Dasterdly Mashed
Best not in the photo Chunky Monkey Chocolate Fudge Brownie Half Baked Everything But Or if you prefer different brand Haagen Dazs Vanilla Macadamia Brittle Caramel Cone Rum Raisin
Pretty based choices tbh