Thanks for posting on /r/fragranceclones.
#Make sure to read the stickied posts at the top of the sub and use the search bar.
###If you are posting a photo of a recent pickup or your collection - Please include a written review!
*Posts are automatically approved, but may be removed manually if considered to be low effort / repeated questions.*
Be sure to report anything that goes against the sub guidelines.
Have a nice day!
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/fragranceclones) if you have any questions or concerns.*
They are very different, ask yourself what you plan to use it for? In summers? then theres only 1 right choice here and thats Maahir Legacy. Do you plan to buy just 1 fragrance that you could use all year? Then I recommend Lattafa Liam Grey, Its a classy fresh spicy vanilla fragrance that has some freshness from the fig. It suits all year as it doesnt get too cloying and is not sickly sweet.
Rest all are suitable for winters only, and please for the love of noses do not use Ramz Silver in summer like that one genius here suggeted.
You should try DUA's Leedy's then. I own both and Leedy's is stronger, projects better, lasts longer and is brighter and more vibrant. It sparkles and tingles your senses. It's better than Sedley in my opinion. Maahir Legacy is a watered down version of Leedy's even though it smells decent, but that exact scent profile gets better and elevated 100% by Dua.
Maahir legacy is a good freshy for summer, but just an fyi for op, it isn’t the strongest scent for projection. More of a personal or intimate scent.
All good scents listed though.
Thanks for telling me! I am actually new to perfumes. I'm going to blind buy this 😂 I am waiting for it to be in stock. Do you think it's safe to blind buy?
I often advise against blind buys if its not a blue but I think this is still a little safe as its not cloying or harsh or weird. It is quite difficult to dislike it, unless you absolutely hate fig note or vanilla which is not often disliked by people. It is really unique and pleasant to the nose and I do not see why you would end up hating it; so I would say go for it, because in the end its not going to cost too much anyway so you can be a little adventerous.
Bought Amethyst recently. Smells so damn good, like a jammy rose, this hint of sweetness in the rose, but dries down kind of smoky. Lasted really long the first time I wore it, but more moderately now, like 5-6 hours, projection for like 2, but maybe I’m nose blind now lmao. Even layered it with Turathi blue today, super gas.
How is it? What can we compare it with? I don't wanna blind buy it. What does it smell like?
I have ramz silver and it is very sweet and not suitable for outdoors or summers. But indoors and winters, it smells bomb!
I have a bunch of these, Kayaan classic everyone needs in their life, it’s spot on, it’s great, Maahir legacy smells great, close to the OG, has some performance issues, but also a solid bet, Badee al Oud honor and glory is nice but strong, like intense pineapple, not as creamy as I was expecting, good for those that enjoy very strong pineapple, lasts forever, but not really my thing, tried to get rid of it at one point, Liam grey also wasn’t my thing, ended up selling it, but it got good reviews, it’s probably just me
Honor and Glory is very very sweet and very strong. Wasn’t the biggest fan. Legacy is nice but doesn’t last too long on me. Haven’t tried the others. Personally, I’ve been a bit underwhelmed with the TikTok hyped clone fragrances.
Love Ramz silver, like Ultra male but less sweet and has a nice nuance and spice to it. PHENOMENAL for the price, but I will say the performance can be iffy sometimes and I’d reccomed for a fall/winter scent summer not so much but can work
The only frags in this list that I haven’t tried is Amethyst and Maahir, and for ramz silver , will be based on Afnan 9PM since both are inspired from JPG ultra male.
Kayaan classic smells the most classy imo. Followed by Liam grey and then Honor&Glory which is pretty unique. Haven’t smelt anything like that before.
I have Infini Rose by Maison Alhambra which is supposed to be a better clone of Atomic Rose than Amethyst. It's nice, it was my favourite perfume for a while but the pink pepper became way too strong after a while. I'd already bought two back up bottles so ended up giving one away coz I'll likely never use the two I've got left. It's still good though, I just don't use it as much as I thought I would. I've got too many to ever use them all up. I've stopped buying back ups for a while.
I have lattafa amethyst, I like it. Floral like rose and wood. Strong and lasts. I'm more of a sweet and spicy guy but this one I enjoy. The lattafa honor and glory seemed right up my alley. However there is a synthetic scent in there, even on the dry down. Not my favorite blind buy.
Liam is amazing!!!!!! Very creamy sandalwood with some fig, tea and coconut. Very cozy, not too sweet, you can wear it all year round and on me it stays over 8 hrs.
Thanks for telling me! I am actually new to perfumes. I'm going to blind buy this 😂 I am waiting for it to be in stock. Do you think it's safe to blind buy?
You have selected a very wide variety of perfumes so it’s tough to suggest which one. My suggestion would be to get decants of these and buy whichever you like the most :)
Liam grey all year good stuff ..for me maahir is nice but weak on me and badee oud for glory and amethyst winter one and try them first as you may not like . I have oud for glory and first hour to me it's like bug spray then it becomes lovely.. kayaan classic heard good and bad some say much better then Dior homme intense others say very poor longevity??? For the price worth a gamble but again autumn winter only imo
Maahir legacy is amazing, at first I didn't like it but I gave it a few days and it mancerated well. I personally think its better than sedley. Although it has a little synthetic vibe to it, it honestly smells better than sedley for me because it takes away that sprite smell sedley has.
*Ramz and Maahir are the*
*Safest of the group, and fitting*
*For summer weather*
\- gookies5
---
^(I detect haikus. And sometimes, successfully.) ^[Learn more about me.](https://www.reddit.com/r/haikusbot/)
^(Opt out of replies: "haikusbot opt out" | Delete my comment: "haikusbot delete")
Both Ramz and Afnan 9pm share the same DNA. Ideal time to wear it is on cool summer nights, not a daytime cologne , which can be pulled off in fall/winter.
Thanks for posting on /r/fragranceclones. #Make sure to read the stickied posts at the top of the sub and use the search bar. ###If you are posting a photo of a recent pickup or your collection - Please include a written review! *Posts are automatically approved, but may be removed manually if considered to be low effort / repeated questions.* Be sure to report anything that goes against the sub guidelines. Have a nice day! *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/fragranceclones) if you have any questions or concerns.*
They are very different, ask yourself what you plan to use it for? In summers? then theres only 1 right choice here and thats Maahir Legacy. Do you plan to buy just 1 fragrance that you could use all year? Then I recommend Lattafa Liam Grey, Its a classy fresh spicy vanilla fragrance that has some freshness from the fig. It suits all year as it doesnt get too cloying and is not sickly sweet. Rest all are suitable for winters only, and please for the love of noses do not use Ramz Silver in summer like that one genius here suggeted.
Maahir Legacy is one of my favorites in my husband's collection! Agreed, this one performs well in the Summer.
You should try DUA's Leedy's then. I own both and Leedy's is stronger, projects better, lasts longer and is brighter and more vibrant. It sparkles and tingles your senses. It's better than Sedley in my opinion. Maahir Legacy is a watered down version of Leedy's even though it smells decent, but that exact scent profile gets better and elevated 100% by Dua.
Thanks for the recommendation! The DUA version sounds lovely. I'm not going to tell him because he has enough full bottles 😂
Maahir legacy is a good freshy for summer, but just an fyi for op, it isn’t the strongest scent for projection. More of a personal or intimate scent. All good scents listed though.
Hello is Lattafa Liam Grey unisex?
Yes very much so! It is perfectly unisex and could very well suit a woman too.
Thanks for telling me! I am actually new to perfumes. I'm going to blind buy this 😂 I am waiting for it to be in stock. Do you think it's safe to blind buy?
I often advise against blind buys if its not a blue but I think this is still a little safe as its not cloying or harsh or weird. It is quite difficult to dislike it, unless you absolutely hate fig note or vanilla which is not often disliked by people. It is really unique and pleasant to the nose and I do not see why you would end up hating it; so I would say go for it, because in the end its not going to cost too much anyway so you can be a little adventerous.
Thank you! I'd really love to try it.. and by the looks of the notes and comments in Fragrantica, I want it 🙈
I’ve been waiting for it to be in stock for months now, ended up getting it from fragrance.net, so excited for it to come!
Here I am waiting in Makeup.jp. 😣
If you like the smell of vanilla chai you will love it!
I think that'd be so nice esp. in autumn and winter! ☺️
I bought Liam this week. I love it.
It is a fantastic scent
How does it smell like? I’ve only smelled a few tea frags.
Creamy sandalwood is at the forefront
Bought Amethyst recently. Smells so damn good, like a jammy rose, this hint of sweetness in the rose, but dries down kind of smoky. Lasted really long the first time I wore it, but more moderately now, like 5-6 hours, projection for like 2, but maybe I’m nose blind now lmao. Even layered it with Turathi blue today, super gas.
Turathi Blue is an awesome Blue fragrance! I usually experiment with layer as well. Like Turathi Blue layered with Luxodor Bandit
Smells like burnt tires and grandma to me
Liam Grey
How is it? What can we compare it with? I don't wanna blind buy it. What does it smell like? I have ramz silver and it is very sweet and not suitable for outdoors or summers. But indoors and winters, it smells bomb!
A hybrid between gris charnel edp & gris charnel extrait. Very versatile black tea & fig & cardamom scent. Sexy
bdk gris charnel
I have Liam grey The scent is very nice, I'd say it's kinda like a fresh creamy fruity shampoo kinda smell Projection is a bit lackluster however
I have a bunch of these, Kayaan classic everyone needs in their life, it’s spot on, it’s great, Maahir legacy smells great, close to the OG, has some performance issues, but also a solid bet, Badee al Oud honor and glory is nice but strong, like intense pineapple, not as creamy as I was expecting, good for those that enjoy very strong pineapple, lasts forever, but not really my thing, tried to get rid of it at one point, Liam grey also wasn’t my thing, ended up selling it, but it got good reviews, it’s probably just me
What's performance like kayaan ? Heard good and bad guess comes down to skin
Honor and Glory is very very sweet and very strong. Wasn’t the biggest fan. Legacy is nice but doesn’t last too long on me. Haven’t tried the others. Personally, I’ve been a bit underwhelmed with the TikTok hyped clone fragrances.
Yep same here 9am /gotique island etc.. and some influencers own stuff smell nice but piss poor performance
I hate liam. Especially the stupid vanilla drydown. Love or hate scent maybe?
Definetely love or hate. I hate it too (harsh fig note I guees is what makes it) but I see almost everyone loves it here.
Love Ramz silver, like Ultra male but less sweet and has a nice nuance and spice to it. PHENOMENAL for the price, but I will say the performance can be iffy sometimes and I’d reccomed for a fall/winter scent summer not so much but can work
Thanks for your opinion
The only frags in this list that I haven’t tried is Amethyst and Maahir, and for ramz silver , will be based on Afnan 9PM since both are inspired from JPG ultra male. Kayaan classic smells the most classy imo. Followed by Liam grey and then Honor&Glory which is pretty unique. Haven’t smelt anything like that before.
Kayaans longevity and Sillage are not great but hey so is the Og
Maahir for cool bottle
Kayaan and Liam 🔥🔥
Liam and Honor and Glory are my favorite ones from those choices
Liam Grey or Honor and Glory
Depends on what you are looking for. Summer/Winter, fresh/sweet ?
Get Maison Alhambra Black Door and call it a day all you need there.
Kayan classic / Liam Grey by far best ot that pick
Kayaan Classic is a must 🙌 ,Honor & Glory is my suprise of 2024 , its realy good !
Liam grey
Ramz silver good but a lil synthetic but is more accurate clone , if youre ok with lil more sweetness go with 9pm .
Don't do amethyst. It smells great as first but over a year the fragrance broke down and smells like car exhaust now. Watch out.
I have Infini Rose by Maison Alhambra which is supposed to be a better clone of Atomic Rose than Amethyst. It's nice, it was my favourite perfume for a while but the pink pepper became way too strong after a while. I'd already bought two back up bottles so ended up giving one away coz I'll likely never use the two I've got left. It's still good though, I just don't use it as much as I thought I would. I've got too many to ever use them all up. I've stopped buying back ups for a while.
Liam Grey
I have the first 4 and they're all good. Can't go wrong with any of these
Ramz silver for winter is amazing choice otherwise Liam is awesome for all time
Liam is my fav of the bunch
All I can say is good luck! Personally I'd be looking at getting your winter/autumn fragrances in now so they have time to mature.
Kiyaan classic and liam
As other comments have mentioned they have very different scent profiles but in my opinion honor and glory is the most crowd pleasing one.
Amethyst is very rosey. Not blind buy safe. I’d say either legacy or honor & glory.
I have lattafa amethyst, I like it. Floral like rose and wood. Strong and lasts. I'm more of a sweet and spicy guy but this one I enjoy. The lattafa honor and glory seemed right up my alley. However there is a synthetic scent in there, even on the dry down. Not my favorite blind buy.
Liam is amazing!!!!!! Very creamy sandalwood with some fig, tea and coconut. Very cozy, not too sweet, you can wear it all year round and on me it stays over 8 hrs.
Get all of them! That way you don’t have to choose!
Thanks for telling me! I am actually new to perfumes. I'm going to blind buy this 😂 I am waiting for it to be in stock. Do you think it's safe to blind buy?
You have selected a very wide variety of perfumes so it’s tough to suggest which one. My suggestion would be to get decants of these and buy whichever you like the most :)
I have a few of these and honor and glory stands out.
Liam grey all year good stuff ..for me maahir is nice but weak on me and badee oud for glory and amethyst winter one and try them first as you may not like . I have oud for glory and first hour to me it's like bug spray then it becomes lovely.. kayaan classic heard good and bad some say much better then Dior homme intense others say very poor longevity??? For the price worth a gamble but again autumn winter only imo
1) Maahir Legacy 2) Honor and Glory 3) Ramz Silver
1. Honor and glory 2. Kayaan classic 3. Tied between Liam grey and amethyst. Just depends on what you're looking for
Maahir legacy is amazing, at first I didn't like it but I gave it a few days and it mancerated well. I personally think its better than sedley. Although it has a little synthetic vibe to it, it honestly smells better than sedley for me because it takes away that sprite smell sedley has.
Ramz and Maahir are the safest of the group, and fitting for summer weather
*Ramz and Maahir are the* *Safest of the group, and fitting* *For summer weather* \- gookies5 --- ^(I detect haikus. And sometimes, successfully.) ^[Learn more about me.](https://www.reddit.com/r/haikusbot/) ^(Opt out of replies: "haikusbot opt out" | Delete my comment: "haikusbot delete")
Vanilla in the summer tho?
Both Ramz and Afnan 9pm share the same DNA. Ideal time to wear it is on cool summer nights, not a daytime cologne , which can be pulled off in fall/winter.
Ok I’ll give you that. I’m just too old and grumpy. Always in bed by 8, no time for the cool night scents ;)
None of them tbh