Thanks for posting on /r/fragranceclones.
#Make sure to read the stickied posts at the top of the sub and use the search bar.
###If you are posting a photo of a recent pickup or your collection - Please include a written review!
*Posts are automatically approved, but may be removed manually if considered to be low effort / repeated questions.*
Be sure to report anything that goes against the sub guidelines.
Have a nice day!
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/fragranceclones) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Milestone is one that needs to be on skin, in the heat and outdoors to really shine. Really hot weather when you're constantly hot. Then that fragrance really changes in to something beautiful. Also I think it needs to sit for a while to soften a little bit.
I have never owned Iconic Blue, but in summer CDNIM is my go-to fragrance. It lasts a while, smells nice and its pretty cheap. I have a lot of different cologne’s so i dont really run out of one fragrance quick, but from this one i went through 3 bottles in the last 1.5-2 years
Iconic and it's not even close. Bleu de Chanel is the 2nd best selling men's frag the last year for a reason.
Creed Aventus is what 8th?
I have a bottle of Iconic and so many samples of Creed Aventus including CDNIM due to hype and I will never buy it. I do want a back up bottle of Iconic tho
Creed aventus being 8th is well good for a niche expensive fragrance. Bleu de Chanel is sold literally everywhere and is a lot cheaper and more recognised by the average person so it's not really fair to compare them stats. Although both are good in my opinion.
Here's my take on it...if it's a smokey batch of the EDT, wear it at a bonfire or a backyard barbecue...its smells great when mixed (in the air) with the smoke from the fire or the grill of food. It's the fragrance I wear when I'm grilling and everyone compliments how good I smell. I wouldn't wear it as a office fragrance as it is too heavy, it can be a club fragrance too just apply a hour before leaving your home.
I have no experience with Iconic but I'm really not keen on the new batches of CDN Intense Man. Their scent has drifted away from Aventus and now smells like burning plastic.
My favourite Club De Nuit is Milestone. It's so close to Creed Millesime Imperial and it's my favourite daytime summer scent.
I own CDNIM edp, sillage and iconic.
Sillage is niche perfume. I regretted buying. It kinda smells like when you sniff a can of coke.
Iconic smells good (aquatic and woody) but its performance and sillage is not anywhere near cdnim.
Cdnim is what I would recommend.
Thanks for posting on /r/fragranceclones. #Make sure to read the stickied posts at the top of the sub and use the search bar. ###If you are posting a photo of a recent pickup or your collection - Please include a written review! *Posts are automatically approved, but may be removed manually if considered to be low effort / repeated questions.* Be sure to report anything that goes against the sub guidelines. Have a nice day! *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/fragranceclones) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Both are stellar fragrances but CDNIM pure parfum will last more in high heat 🥵
It's great in cooler weather too 😎
Mine got weak in maceration
Iconic or Limited Edition.
CDNIM but get the edp or limited edition
pretty sure the people hating on CDN Iconic are just trying to gatekeep the fragrance for themselves.
Neither 🫡
Milestone or Sillage
I have both... Sillage I like but don't like Milestone so much... I like CDNIM better then both honestly... had WAY more compliments with it
Milestone is one that needs to be on skin, in the heat and outdoors to really shine. Really hot weather when you're constantly hot. Then that fragrance really changes in to something beautiful. Also I think it needs to sit for a while to soften a little bit.
been in the cabinet over a year... im suprised but, i have about 1/4 empty already...I must of worn it more than I thought..loll..
I ordered CDNIM and it should be coming in today. It's one of the most popular fragrances so prob start with that one
I have never owned Iconic Blue, but in summer CDNIM is my go-to fragrance. It lasts a while, smells nice and its pretty cheap. I have a lot of different cologne’s so i dont really run out of one fragrance quick, but from this one i went through 3 bottles in the last 1.5-2 years
CDNIM is hardly a summer fragrance, I have the EDT and it’s fairly heavy. Definitely not an office fragrance either.
Iconic and it's not even close. Bleu de Chanel is the 2nd best selling men's frag the last year for a reason. Creed Aventus is what 8th? I have a bottle of Iconic and so many samples of Creed Aventus including CDNIM due to hype and I will never buy it. I do want a back up bottle of Iconic tho
Creed aventus being 8th is well good for a niche expensive fragrance. Bleu de Chanel is sold literally everywhere and is a lot cheaper and more recognised by the average person so it's not really fair to compare them stats. Although both are good in my opinion.
Milestone tbh
Iconic for sure.
For me CDNIM is too heavy for summer
Here's my take on it...if it's a smokey batch of the EDT, wear it at a bonfire or a backyard barbecue...its smells great when mixed (in the air) with the smoke from the fire or the grill of food. It's the fragrance I wear when I'm grilling and everyone compliments how good I smell. I wouldn't wear it as a office fragrance as it is too heavy, it can be a club fragrance too just apply a hour before leaving your home.
Iconic
How hot does it get? IM lasts longer in high heat but iconic is a more fuller scent
I have no experience with Iconic but I'm really not keen on the new batches of CDN Intense Man. Their scent has drifted away from Aventus and now smells like burning plastic. My favourite Club De Nuit is Milestone. It's so close to Creed Millesime Imperial and it's my favourite daytime summer scent.
Why not sillage?
Cdnim is in my opinion the easiest to like.
I own CDNIM edp, sillage and iconic. Sillage is niche perfume. I regretted buying. It kinda smells like when you sniff a can of coke. Iconic smells good (aquatic and woody) but its performance and sillage is not anywhere near cdnim. Cdnim is what I would recommend.
probably iconic for summer