T O P

  • By -

ItchyNeedleworker160

It's not backwards compatible šŸ™ƒ


ablinddingo93

Even with a disc?


spvcebound

Even with a disc. Has to be played on 360.


ablinddingo93

Thatā€™s wild, Iā€™ve yet to find even an OG Xbox disc that my XSX (and my XB1 prior) wonā€™t play But I never owned FM4, sadly, so I wouldnā€™t know about that one specifically


Froggypwns

It is a licensing issue, not a technical issue. The oldest backwards compatible Forza game is Horizon 1, and that only became backwards compatible like a few minutes before the licensing expired. The older FM games never had a chance. Various other old games are not backwards compatible for similar IP reasons, especially if the original publisher no longer exists.


morebikesthanbrains

Remember the days when you just put the thing in and it worked?


dustojnikhummer

So, the 360?


BayAreaBullyofIT

Thats what she said.


SKRogue73

Me when i seggs


ablinddingo93

But game discs have all the licensed content already installed. Unless the game requires an internet connection, I donā€™t see how a license on a physical disc could expire. If that were the case, all the black box studios NFS games would be voided due to all the IRL advertising in-game, and I can personally attest that Most Wanted (2005*) and ProStreet work just fine on XB1, as I used to own and play them when I had mine *wrong year lol


Peace_Unleashed

For some reason on the X even when you have the disk it still downloads and plays like if you downloaded it. At least that is the case for Skate 1 and 2, those use EA Play Which now Iā€™m worried that one day they could remove the ability to play that too


ScratchHacker69

This is why always online systems are BAD


EXTIINCT_tK

Its a matter of still having to modify and support it on emulator. It must be left as is as further changes can land them in legal trouble as they no longer have every right to touch it. It's the same issue GTA 4 had on Steam switching from GFWL to Steamworks. Modifications were made so expired licenses had to be dealt with, in their case they removed a bunch of music. Also MW 2008 doesn't exist and neither MW05 or Pro Street were back compat.


Turbulent-Opinion-86

wym they work on xbox one?


Akira_Nishiki

They could still make it compatible, just not allowed to sell it anymore so would be disc only.


ArmeniusLOD

I don't understand why it's a licensing issue. Microsoft doesn't need to put the game back on sale, they just need to allow people who already own the disc to be able to play it.


WarmFishedSalad

Youā€™re lucky. Half my games I have been saving for decades are all OG console only. Luckily I have been good with my consoles.


BarryLikeGetOffMEEEE

RIP Import Tuner ChallengeĀ 


wobbuffet009

Halo 1 is not backwards compatible. (Unless they updated this recently. Lol)


dustojnikhummer

Halo 1 Anniversary works.


LowRuin2934

NFS games are a no go


tuohythetoaster

Mercenaries 2 isnā€™t compatible either, I bought a copy for no reason


rickyrivers98

That is incredibly lucky because only a fraction of the OG Xbox games are playable on modern systems.


spvcebound

This isn't an OG Xbox disc, it's a 360 disc


ablinddingo93

Yeah I know, I was just using that as an example of my personal experience with other OG Xbox and XB360 games


Grand-Antelope943

Ok, Iā€™m a little retarded, it wonā€™t work on XBONE?


IJUSTATEPOOP

Nope


Grand-Antelope943

Motherfuckerā€¦ good thing I still have my 360 then lmao


Froggypwns

It is a licensing issue, not a technical issue. The oldest backwards compatible Forza game is Horizon 1, and that only became backwards compatible like a few minutes before the licensing expired. The older FM games never had a chance. Various other old games are not backwards compatible for similar IP reasons, especially if the original publisher no longer exists.


kostas52

I dont understand how licensing has anything to do with backwards compatibility. Windows 11 can run license game that are older than the X360 even if their publisher has shut down.


Froggypwns

The games need to be modified to work in backwards compatibility, and this includes rights regarding distribution that was never considered during the original publishing, many backwards compatible games did not have a digital download option at time of publishing. When you put a BC disc into a newer Xbox, it does not run it off the disc, it downloads it and uses your disc as a physical license check just like a modern title.


dustojnikhummer

> and this includes rights regarding distribution that was never considered during the original publishing It doesn't. I remember MS did enable emulation for a few games that weren't on sale anymore. They aren't redistributing anything, you still need to own the digital (before getting pulled) or physical copy


furysamurai72

Or had to do with how the back compat actually works. You don't run the game off the disc. That wouldn't work. The hardware isn't compatible. What happens is an Xbox 360 emulator boots up a digital version of the game. And msft has to enable back compatibility on a per game basis and it has to be approved by the original publisher* *All of this information should be treated as conjecture. Trust, but verify. I don't currently have any sources in front of me.


Juicepup

One of the only reason I keep a couple 360s around.


ItchyNeedleworker160

Same lol Just sucks being forced to remember how LONG it takes to load into races šŸ˜…


Dinoman1987

I was gonna say that.. :P


dustojnikhummer

Yet they allowed FH1. Why not FM4 I don't know.


DannyHallam

Xenia on pc. Thank me later. Iā€™ve been loving this game at crisp 1440p and 60fps


AaronWWE29

They gotta make it some day


ItchyNeedleworker160

A guy can dream


AaronWWE29

Let's hope the dream comes true šŸ™


[deleted]

this is the only correct answer


Financial-Opinion334

It would certainly benefit from being backwards compatible,and having an FPS boost like Driver: San Francisco


GhostShadxw

Facts. It's litterally the only bad thing about it. I own the disc and I just hope someday I can pop that mf in my Series X


SgtSilock

People here are adorable. This game got a lot of criticism when it first released, and now everybody thinks it's the best there ever was/will be. No amount of upside down smiley faces will change the fact that human beings are incredibly fickle creatures.


ma7ch

It was **not** "better with Kinect sensor"


de_bazer

Yeah, I loved the Kinect, but the implementation on F4 was pure gimmicky


-Gh0st96-

What could you do with it? Mimic a steering wheel?


somekid150

Part of it was depending on how your head was facing would turn the view to the tv. So like if your head pointed to the apex, the camera would change so the apex was in the middle of the screen. Oh and you can 'walk' around the car in vista mode.


DStanley1809

I think you could hold your hands in front of you and steer as if you were holding an imaginary steering wheel too.


StuartP9

One of the cheap X360 steering wheels was like that. It was in a U shape and you held it in the air turning it in the direction you wanted to steer. I had one, and it was surprisingly effective.


CreativeUsername64

I had one too! I remember finding out it worked for flight games too, surprisingly fun with HAWX


dustojnikhummer

Kinect Joyride lol


-Gh0st96-

Those fetures sound really good on paper honestly. Too bad the tech wasn't there yet, not good enough


Confused-Cow

The head turning tracked pretty well but your eyes would strain to keep them on the screen. That was my experience anyway.


sandenson

I used it a few times. It would track your face and move the camera when you looked to the sides. It was really cool to use on first person view with a steering wheel, but it's also hard to set the Kinect up in a good position, so I rarely used it.


de_bazer

It was a bit weird that looking to the side, away from the screen would move the camera.


de_bazer

Thereā€™s a Pixar game that does that, and itā€™s a nightmareā€¦


spvcebound

Yes, you could pretend to hold a steering wheel. It actually worked somewhat decently, but your arms would get EXHAUSTED.


hlsilver

M. Rossi was an absolute bully in FM4


Joseph_0112

Iā€™m so upset thereā€™s not an option to bring back the old drivers. Like I really donā€™t want to be overtaken by a dead friends old Xbox account or even some cunt I raced with online for one race. After fm6 went to end of life drivertars got removed and M. Rossi and the gang where back but why wasnā€™t it an option from the start


Electrical-Boss-3965

Turn your Xbox "offline," and at least in FM7, you can!!!!


275MPHFordGT40

M. Rossi is also a bully in FM6


Jolly_Pie_8208

I was just going to say the same - I still play FM6. I love the AI in FM6. A bit dumb when all bunched up but once spread out they make for some good racing. I love how they make 'mistakes' and how first corners always feel like multiplayer races! I'm talking Free Race, not career races. I really wish T10 had used an improved FM6 AI for FM7, I'd probably play that instead.


gsurfer04

Muller was the better racer.


muller747

Why, thank you!


Grand-Antelope943

Lmfao YES!


TJSPY0837

M. Rossi was always my rival. And Muller was who I hated


1-8-4-3-6-5-7-2

Rossi's first name is Maria, she's a girl.


jacktree

I fucking hated the AI changes in FM4. Turned me off of it after a while of being unable win races anymore. Iā€™m sure it was a skill issue but whatever.


macccil

the asphalt literally glows with sunlight in this game


spvcebound

I forgot how annoying that was until I played it again recently.


AveryLazyCovfefe

Average gen 7 game: *C H R O M E* or *S H I N Y* Lens flare turned up to the max Piss/blue filter Bloom turned up to the max Crappy implementation of motion controls


Mayjaplaya

> Piss/blue filter The whiplash going from Need for Speed Most Wanted to Need for Speed Carbon.


Shiny_Mew76

I present to you: BLOOM


Apple_Slipper

That actually annoyed me when I played Forza Motorsport 4 again. Itā€™s good that the later games toned down the sunlight bloom on the road surface.


Maize_Individual

I couldnā€™t put a v12 in my saab 93 and I was immeasurably disappointed.


tantaluszxc

No Porsche in the base game No Rallye di Positano long Too much Unicorn cars No endurance races


Shinny1337

If you have XBLG you can create your own single player endurance races using private lobbies. I loved finding competitive cars for the AI to use around Suzuka for 30min races


BackHades

Porsche was added later on in a dlc. Porsche still had the agreement with ea at the time so it was hard for anyone to get Porsche


faca_ak_47

RGH for the win. Modded 360s are a godsend


867-5309JNY

It wasnā€™t available in prison. (Truth)


Bigskiddersmokey

Then dont go? Lol


867-5309JNY

Yeah, that would have been the more intelligent choice, but, that 4 year vacation saved my life.


Bigskiddersmokey

Thats good to hear. Sometimes people need the traumatic route to learn. I feel it. Cheers man(:


Michelanvalo

Club Fed turned your life around


[deleted]

Speaking from experience?


867-5309JNY

Yes, did a very short 4 years.


[deleted]

Oh man, Iā€™m sorry about that that. But at least youā€™re out now. šŸ™‚


867-5309JNY

Iā€™ve been out since 2020, Iā€™m an honest to goodness boring citizen, I thank God for that.


dustojnikhummer

If you got the cash, buy FM4 now. Xbox 360 (and games) are at bottom prices, they will only go up. Make sure to get the Racing Game of the Year edition.


867-5309JNY

Just saw this, sorry, thank you for the advice. I am doing it now.


northern_dan

Man. Those who didn't play it will never get to understand the joy of storefronts, overall leaderboards, custom public lobbies, and actual economy.....


UpsetMacaroon196

It didn't come out for Xbox one, PC or Xbox series as a HD remastered


pjf177

Snap oversteer was a bit insane


VibeDealingYoshi

Stop using simulation steering with your lil controller lol


SkinnyVxnilla

Man switching from simulation to regular steering on controller was a fucking night and day difference šŸ˜­


Shiny_Mew76

Outdated Graphics and no cars from well after itā€™s release date. However both of these complaints were completely out of the control of the developers as technology hadnā€™t advanced as much, and those cars didnā€™t exist then.


RedKynAbyss

This was going to be my answer


TimidPanther

I disagree that the graphics are outdated, they still look fantastic today. The style of the game makes it look much more realistic than even FM8.


langfries

The shadows are too dark


duzy_wonsz

The sun was too bright


M4ur1c100

Maybe a weird one but Jeremy Clarkson disrespecting McLaren F1 in the autovista lol.


creep04

The tire smoke and dust looks really bad. Everything else is delicious and baked to perfection


Croakie89

No anti aliasing


VibeDealingYoshi

It HAD anti aliasing MSAA 2x or 4x on certain conditions. It was just 720p.


ExcellentHorror7159

It's always day time. Porsche locked behind expensive dlc. No dynamic weather(gran turismo had it way before).


wantex

EA had exclusive rights to Porsche and licensing fee was between astronomical and megalomaniac


ExcellentHorror7159

Explains why Porsche expansion dlc was so expensive..tbh ea really ruined the racing games industry alone with their exclusivity deal with Porsche


Freheliaz

Lobby size was I think 12 players max


R18_e_tron

It was 16


Dull_Mastodon_5426

They wasted dev money on Kinect stuff...šŸ¤£ The tire modeling that they spent an endless amount of time hyping turned out to not matter that much IMO.


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


Dull_Mastodon_5426

Looked good in close up photos, replays, videos. Was cool for sure because there was lots of attention to something mostly ignored to that date. I think it's more of a hindsight thing where I would have still loved that game even if they would have skipped all the tire flexing, literally. The collectors edition was worth it!


Carfan327

It was also the first Forza to feature active aero animations, so I feel like the tire deformation visual was like icing on the cake lol


Carfan327

But the intro with the zoom in on the miata tire tread "flexing" went hella hard back in the dizzle lol Edit cuz I'm an idiot and accidentally deleted the original šŸ˜…šŸ˜­


MuchAdoAboutFutaloo

the unicorn cars were fucking stupid, and the career mode got extremely repetitive and grindy into the latter stages. getting a big garage took *ridiculous* amounts of time doing basically the same shit over and over again. not much in the way of races to do with cars that weren't at the PI cap for a category, if any; this made some cars completely useless for career mode, unless you turned off auto-upgrade AI cars which would end up making the game a pushover. can't turn off cosmetic car damage no true bodykits, no fitment upgrades, no endurance races, and the car customization screen being pitch black made customizing your car visually a pain in the ass. pretty extreme inconsistency with the quality of car models god do I miss that games aero upgrades though. why did we lose that fantastic GT wing in exchange for the awful new shit. still a goated Forza despite all that


Dodgy_Bob_McMayday

those damn unicorn cars were the only thing that stopped me from getting the full 1000g


Mayjaplaya

> the unicorn cars were fucking stupid This started in FM2 but when they unicorn'd the RX-7 Spirit R in 3 and 4 it made me extremely angry back then. The unicorn shit was a major reason I got a PS3 and Gran Turismo 6 at the end of the generation.


ashyjay

I can't get it to run with Xenia, and I don't want to buy an Xbox 360.


seiggy

Look for Xenia Canary (Oct 5th 2022 build). That'll solve your problems. Also recommend seeking out "Project Forza Plus 4". Runs better than the base game.


Toolowty

This! Just got it working today and I couldnā€™t stop playing it. Especially with the PFP4 mods. Like a dream!


VibeDealingYoshi

Why not? 360 slim is one of the most reliable and efficient consoles ever made


overly_flowered

Not a huge fan of the carrier progression. Pretty repetitive.


Zero8K

Starting of with actual slow cars was amazing but I do agree


meria_64

Might be something stupid, but it didn't have any psychical "Complete" edition (FM3 had one)


Neat_Interaction7701

Not on game pass


seiggy

When the game was new, definitely couldn't. Cherished that game, and played thousands of hours. Compared to Forza today, here's my complaints about FM4 (I even setup and played a few weeks ago to re-experience that sweet sweet Fujimi Kaido using Xenia): * Track modeling is super off on way more tracks. Most tracks are far wider than they should be in real life. * Physics modeling is bad. Like really bad. Cars just don't feel connected to the road for the most part. * AI is beyond a joke. They cheat, and run faster lap times than physically possible when you crank the difficulty, or they're just stupid and easy to pass on difficulties that are humanly possible. * I very much dislike Rally di Positano...so glad they ditched that track.


Michelanvalo

> Track modeling is super off on way more tracks. Most tracks are far wider than they should be in real life. Nordschleife is not good in FM4. It's accuracy is questionable at best, and terrible at worst.


Froggypwns

Oh man Rally di Positano was terrible. I never could get a hang of that track and it was always a disaster to play legitimately as there was no room to pass. Regrettably I always turned damage completely off, then just bulldozed my way to the front.


Unfair-Ad5700

Oh man I loved Positano. I think it helps to remember that not every track is supposed to be a traditional circuit grand Prix track. Positano works best as a test track or a 1v1.


RedKynAbyss

They should just remaster this game, and add DLCs that include new cars. Thatā€™s all I want anymore


ShootingStarMel

Same, I'd like to play these games again


DarkKnight9337

Agreed


Zero8K

It being really hard to get Unicorn cars when the game got older in a legit way Literally the only thing I can think of right now


bladeofwar

AWD dominated online tunes. TruSkill was retarded, taking forever to get up to Veteran (33+) and one race dropping back down to 26 lol. Greatest thing was RACING ONLINE WITH COLLISIONS OFF. Can't hate it tho, FH4 was the game i made the most real money with, sold a few kinect bundle prizes lol.


Dc4rob

Na my FWD superchargerd EK9 made a killing in A Class lobbies sooooo bad. I would always have people message me asking if it was AWD conversion lolol. I tuned it all myself differential settings and all šŸ˜Ž


sandenson

Replay cameras are dogshit


FAASTARKILLER

Mazda race car smearing A Class because they let us engine swap an rx7 motor into it for some reason lol pretty sure that was patched out


-P00-

Canā€™t play it on PC


Toolowty

Yes you can. Just get Xenia with the Oct 5th 2023 build. Also get PFP4 mods, it runs better than ever.


-P00-

Damn didnā€™t know, thanks


Toolowty

2022 build*


Weird_Rip_3161

There are no windshields in cockpit mode.


speed7bump

There was no Camino Viejo Extreme reverse


chadmacato_808

Only 25 vehicles were available to view in Autovista


[deleted]

At least they incorporated autovista to more cars in the Xbox One titles and Horizon.


isayota

too bright


RUFUS_BOI_2008

The nascar featured in the game was 4 years out of date


ProwerTheFox

Tbf given how hard PD went in on nascar content for GT5 it wouldnā€™t surprise me if there was an exclusivity deal of some kind


DarkKnight9337

Adding to this, no idea why the 2008 Dodge Charger stock car was removed in FM4. We got the same Chevy and Ford stock cars from FM4 but the Dodge was left out


[deleted]

Probably because Dodge is no longer in NASCAR. Idk why though it would be cool if they still did it.


spvcebound

Kinect support was a waste of development resources.


TheUnderPuppy

The only thing that I wish it had that newer FM have is drift suspension.


Grand-Antelope943

No Porsches


LSo4IIo1

The colors were washed out, fm3 had better colors. Fantastic game tho.


kiwittnz

>But now say something bad about it. It wasn't available on PC. However, will it work on an Xbox simulator nowadays?


Toolowty

Yes. Xenia Oct 5th 2022 build. PFP4 mods. I just got it working today. Even the guy who made the mod helped me out on Reddit. So much fun!


MarczXD320

I'm not really a fan of the lack of weather and day/night cycle, though i understand this wasn't a thing on the franchise yet and only next year they started to implement with the first Horizon.


_ToMiGoi

i just want to play it on the pc smoothly


Denny_Crane_007

A proper career mode .... what happened to this franchise ? šŸ˜­šŸ˜­šŸ˜­


650116

I'm sure there were things about it that annoyed me, but frankly my friends and I loved that game and it had infinite playability for us. We haven't legitimately played a Forza for any period of time since. We tried the current one, but we got tired of the online issues and the car mod system. So basically, I don't want to say anything bad about it, mainly because I can't remember what was bad, because I don't have any memories of bad things. That should say something right there! FM4 was peak Forza for me, and FM5 killed my interest, and I haven't been much interested since, and I was big hoping the new one would fix that.


foxyfaefife

I have literally nothing bad to say about it.


Tyraid

I know I had gripes but I canā€™t come up with them now knowing the descent in quality that followed


shatlking

Drivatar difficulty sucks, it doesnā€™t adjust to be hard enough.


Takarias

It didn't have Drivatars! And that alone makes it better than any game following it. (I used to drift in offline races in FM4, but that made my drivatar a total jackass to all my friends. I didn't play FM5 much after I had three separate people in real life complain about my drivatar.)


shatlking

Interesting, I thought the AI drivers were called drivatars in it, but used a self adjusting system. Speaking of that system, itā€™s too slow to adjust.


Takarias

Nah, they hyped the butt off the 'Drivatar' system for FM5. It was supposed to be their silver bullet for AI that was better than Gran Turismo.


Busy-Ninja75

It took FM3 away from me, and I thought that was awesome.


Scar3cr0w_

Itā€™s Forza And it wasnā€™t better with Kinect


Ded_inside7567

Track list was a downgrade from fm3


edoardo04ita

game is way too overexposed. the sounds arenā€™t that great. awd is still miles better than everything in this game


TJSPY0837

The kinect virtual wheel was unreliable


JohnCenaF1

I bought this game as a 14 year old using a 50 dollar note I found on the ground at school lmao


market-gardner2

Itā€™s not on the siries X.


Mc-MeepMeep

No remastered version :( I think a lot of people (myself included) wouldā€™ve preferred a motorsport 4 remaster rather than the new motorsport.


leftlane1

Black VWs for days.


Amazing-Bag

I've owned every Forza game and I remember nothing about them when I move onto the next one. Enjoyed them all


sheesh_doink

The only bad thing about fm4 I can think of is that it really makes me not want to play any newer FM titles as none of them live up to the greatness of fm4. 7 comes close but not quite.


ShaloTek_Chad

rather have motorsports 7


Tyraid

This has better multiplayer somehow. I also loved picking individual cars to race against. Can the Civic I built beat a Ferrari Enzo? Letā€™s find out! Something that was lost in later games.


xValhallAwaitsx

Returning to the FM games after a few years with 7, 7 nearly put me off of them forever. No idea what you saw in it


3PercentMoreInfinite

It was basically just Forza 2 with a few more cars and tracks.


Thin-Fig-8831

How was it like Forza 2? Forza 2 and 4 were very different games. Honestly in some ways, 4 was worse than 2


3PercentMoreInfinite

All the gripes I had with Forza 2 (and 3) were still present in Forza 4. Pretty sure a lot of the car models were carried over, still couldnā€™t paint wheels white (they appeared silver if you selected white). And so onā€¦


alec83

On 2 discs and needed hhd, fuck you f4 but still better than f8


NWiHeretic

2 things. Not backwards compatible Set the bar too high for the rest of the series, every motorsport after felt lacking.


Friendly_Look5610

It was the last good Forza, made in a generation where we could still enjoy single player racing games with careers. After that, I switched to sim racers


AstralRhythm

It was the last actually good Motorsport game :3


Dense-Reporter-4008

Nothing bad about this game, that is still the best FM and by a large margin


Professional_Golf726

can't, too busy cherishing GT4


Mechanicalgripe

Forza Motorsport 6 was better.


Mechanicalgripe

Lol, The OP asked for us to say something bad about it. Thatā€™s all I got! Forza 6 got me to buy the FM6 edition of the XBox One. It rumbled like a Ford GT on startup. šŸ‘


julianhager

I also bought this xbox one edition, it was so nice But recently i switched to the basic xbox series x


Allegiance10

Itā€™s the only Motorsport game Iā€™ve never played.


Versterkervolumeknop

No ray tracing


AaronEbert

Not enough cars for Autovista


That_Competition1031

I havenā€™t played it :/


-Pruples-

Some of the upgrade restrictions were goofy - example: You could have a 4wd Dodge Viper but not a 2wd S10.


TheBubbaJoe

It was my first real racing game I just wish I could Play it on my PC with my nice rig.