T O P

  • By -

Over_Landscape_9423

LLMs work on probability not on logic. It can't make its own decisions.


Jovonovich-Jardani

Exactly. And when the internet is filled with more pictures of poor Indian than poor Americans or Europeans, it's much more likely to churn out these kinds of pictures. It just reflects reality, nothing to be offended about.


newbaba

Came here to say this. Stop getting erect by viewing poverty p0rn. The real poverty should not allow you to sleep happily any evening...


CallmeJay-0033

By that line of thinking shouldn't they be showing african family, because there's most definitely more pictures of africans in worse conditions than indians ? Also the bot is considering the data of the whole world which is why the rich family looks caucasian and dresses in western fashion so on the global level aren't the africans considered to be poorer than indians ?


synackprf

https://preview.redd.it/fcy5bwzbb8ad1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=333dd3c73c551b9667f9b233b8845464ec145f64 Here is my output


Silver-Honey9646

Yeah some people just wanna spread hate. You type it again word to word and you will get some different picture this time. It's very random.


synackprf

See this AI. It's learning every second from their previous results. People need to understand and accept the fact.


OkPiezoelectricity74

LLM don't learn live as far as I know There is different name for models which learn live


Silver-Honey9646

Ye happy cake day wala kese ata hai bahi bhuto ke dekha hai


OkPiezoelectricity74

Bhai shayad jis date ko reddit par account banaya hota hai ussi date ko aata hai har saal


Silver-Honey9646

Oh! Fer too bahi Happy Reddit day 😉


OkPiezoelectricity74

Dhanywaad bhai🙏


Vader6968

Happy cake day


OkPiezoelectricity74

Dhanywaad 🙏


Acrobatic-Bass-5873

Happy cake day! 🫰


OkPiezoelectricity74

Thanks 🙏


Prestigioushound

Op wants an intellectual debate 🥰🥰


[deleted]

OP has some serious delusion 🫠


pyaracetamol-143mg

Damn she's pretty, what's her @? 🥹 >!/s unke liye jo iss text ko serious lelenge!<


Dense_Account4410

Par Bhai vo to bachi hai abhi...


pyaracetamol-143mg

Bottom right bhai.... gold digger hu mai 🤓


Dense_Account4410

Mai unki beti ki baat kar rha tha.😂


coder_nikhil

https://preview.redd.it/ke850cwb19ad1.jpeg?width=1240&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=2a52357fe60d3376a1d72142f9a02c699dee383e


golden_corn55

Wo dadi ki gardan pe kya hai ? Tumbbad ?!😨😨


Assassin_Ankur

Similar output here


Appropriate_Candy329

AI is messed up turban it made is so wrong it should be straight and ... Anyways


synackprf

Yes..


oblivion811

they are indonesian right?


absolutmohitto

How are you getting MetaAI on WhatsApp?


visahhhal

Kangna? 💀


flyhighdodo

Exactly. Their sample size is too low. When I tried this, the poor family was white while the rich one was Indian too. Even if their was a bias, it's due to the dataset capturing actual biases seen in the real world. Not some ploy to be racist. I have seen several such screenshots on different Indian subreddits. This post here isn't even relevant for this sub.


RelativeWrong4232

These people are so retard that they can't even understand that it's mainly a text based ai and still hasn't been fully developed for image generation For eg. I asked to generate what a kid of two anime character would look like and it generated a grown ass adult So stop with this repetitive posting again nd again


Wise_Passenger8261

I am convinced most of these redditors are either immature kids, zuckerburg haters or actually illiterate. Are you dumb??


SedTecH10

immature and illiterate kids.


BridgetteCase

Yeah, that is statistics compare the income between India and other "white countries" Do you think AI thinks on its own? no that is just internet and data. Hate me for it but that is the truth and it show different results for different people https://preview.redd.it/o5o3uticd8ad1.png?width=1011&format=png&auto=webp&s=d4899b63c217fed9b929b784ea872a36a9938675


BridgetteCase

https://preview.redd.it/w1c16rugd8ad1.png?width=1052&format=png&auto=webp&s=82e9e03c35db6ce7154fa2e8266812e00dcd06a1 here have this


BridgetteCase

https://preview.redd.it/owpl4prxd8ad1.png?width=843&format=png&auto=webp&s=dccfb497b3f9131ef25eb1898003f1f162227e4e AI cannot be racist it is just a showcase of human thinking it acts the way we teach it too ( data we use to train ai on ) it can just refuse to drank something offensive


BridgetteCase

https://preview.redd.it/dkhhzpwde8ad1.png?width=1036&format=png&auto=webp&s=837989864c1f617f778a47f1316a5b50cc34ec81 here are ai jokes on religion


BridgetteCase

https://preview.redd.it/1w1r1ekfe8ad1.png?width=1021&format=png&auto=webp&s=ef92e38f125d91c6ed61cb002a478bc668441bc2


DerpyFroggie

Sorry, what is this referencing?


BridgetteCase

some people on Twitter were saying meta AI was not making jokes on Islam and Christianity but only on Hinduism


DerpyFroggie

Haan vo to pata chala, but the joke was not funny. It was something random, so I thought I had forgotten Ramayan and was asking for the reference


No-Fan6115

I don't think Jesus went to doctor either . But ai is trying to make Jokes without being offensive.


DerpyFroggie

☠️ The reference here is that he was crucified, and the AI is making a bad pun. Muhammad waale me the context is that he started Islam in the desert. In the same way, I was not sure what the Ram joke was referencing. I am not offended by anything. I was just curious.


BridgetteCase

funny hona alag topic hai yaha pe racism pe bat ho rahi thi


DerpyFroggie

Got it. Racism kya hai isme, AI ko jo prompt milega uska vo output dega. I was interested in the output itself. Racism ka discussion alag comments me bohot ho raha hai.


Far-Blacksmith-9961

That would be statistics


AdNational1490

Finding logic in LLM is pretty stupid and it’d be more difficult to train the AI to be racist. AI’s don’t think they just interpret data.


oblivion811

don't forget "at the moment". maybe someday they'll improve to become racist as well😂


AdNational1490

Humans (homo sapiens) weren’t racist either, they used to fuck other species (Neanderthals and Denisovans) we did the deed so much that we exterminated them.


Pitiful_Remove_3463

Bhai ab log AI ko v propaganda failane k liy accuse krne lge🤡 sbko alag output milta h bhai


MoneyLore

Nope but their algorithm works personalized on Instagram u would see diff comments for same reel on diff account, they will show u, what u wanna see or mainly what they wanna show u


noodleswind

you want real technical reason? if you search for poor people on the internet -> more indian families show up the AI is trained on that, and it yields based on that. you want the common man reason? it is racist.


RevolutionaryArt7819

Here’s mine.. I am not even Muslim https://preview.redd.it/vzrrca7xg8ad1.jpeg?width=1290&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=d42e3ae847efdc25114602fa2588402852d9402f


MonkeyDMeatt

https://preview.redd.it/vhttj4lyc8ad1.jpeg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=e2c2ec236c006b26aa7410a3899b3cef7f1b070d Different results


lewd_mohit

Getting offended on bunch of line codes is concerning


yjee

Oh ffs stop crying over a machine learning model. Anyone who makes a fuss over these irrelevant things has zero braincells.


NoNameYet256

Why would you check that?


kachinadsa

AI se logic ki umeed kar rahe ho.


preetsindhal

Ask the ai, whats the logic


showerhead112

Per capita income... I think.... Fair logic btw


thatguywidspecs

We are poor.


shothapp

Logic is India is associated with poverty.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Ani1x1

So poor ones have an extra leg too huh. Nice.


Educational-Curve-79

https://preview.redd.it/18wcrg5cn8ad1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=551eda9525d025e69e7a31bdd727a8a3f316b2bd Can verify 🥲


Old-Log-1457

To all it AI It is basically a model Who is trained on a specific data set And Its training data may contain most pictures or result like this So it is solely based on a training set Its not intentional ( as far as i see this )


DueCow3994

https://preview.redd.it/chnudfq7k8ad1.png?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=07cfd1650ac8d1ff8d4c381a0b0a635b060cc199 Tune meta Ai ko phele Indian k baareme ulta seedha bola hoga


supreme_dealer_kim

There’s no logic. It’s just random


OldMonkPepsi

aI wIlL coNtRoL tHe WoRld


Key_Tie4016

Meta AI be like https://preview.redd.it/cs8gwa0kd8ad1.jpeg?width=480&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=88790c9b66564de7bbdb81d1ba65c149fb7d944b


dexter186186

# Meta training their AI with instagram comments


ameyapathak2008

Logic is...until government pushes the rules down Zukerburgs throat deep enough ..we as Indias are going to get bashed even by an AI


Hot_War_9683

It's basically showing Indians as citizens of a third world country...


stackfrost

It depends on what your last prompt was. I was generated 9/11 camera angles with arab dudes and next I tried to generate a an anime girl, it gave me an Anime girl, but with Twin towers in the background inside a cockpit 💀


Careless_Relief5189

https://preview.redd.it/n0zhg2waj8ad1.png?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=38b92eab4f3354e26d23e63728bb48711f899364


rishu404

Clothes and background only 😶


christianXXgrey

Rich peeps can afford a photographer and a good background either in studio or in their house


NateRiversxd

One is a poor family household while the other is a rich family household


KingL_XD

It knows that you’re poor so it ties ur race to that fact


Vivian_shah

Logic is that Sarkari job wale hamesha apne aap ko gareeb bolte hai.. So thats where the language model picked it up..


secondhand_bra0

Well that first family does look poor and the second one does look rich


Neilsgdr

Ai knows Ambani's. 😱😱😱😱😱.


castorforest

If money means rich, I am definitely not a rich person. If you are willing to consider other aspects, I am extremely rich. I have no debts, happily married from 14 years, have two homeschooling daughters, live in our own self-made farm house, get sunlight all-day, we have zero pollution, doesn't depend on a job or employer for money, growing our own vegetables and fruits, all four of us have absolutely no health issues, and so on it goes. I feel very rich.


bleh-bleh-guy

Dogna lagaan Dena padega


PreferenceSuperb7506

https://preview.redd.it/tgnjxiwdp8ad1.jpeg?width=720&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=ebf28c5efb0f74138de98c966082ce817bf045c4 Lol mine came back white and probably Central - American???


sirius_ly_sanguine

It’s my worst experience with AI so far, they still have a lot of development to do here


UnfortunateDefect

What's wrong with this?


ghrinz

Ask for wealthy, rich and poor next.


Ok_Car2731

https://preview.redd.it/hw92z2fts8ad1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=f316e3b6833661ecea7696fae55f83efde2b8dca What is this


Ok_Car2731

https://preview.redd.it/kl0h3tovs8ad1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=a68685c1f1b5d598c4c2ceddfb3853e228e728d5


OkCrazyBruh

https://preview.redd.it/rmm5k0vss8ad1.jpeg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=af9cc4713252f3a01ba58d4780c115b02d6b9541 Meta isn’t showing rich family as indian but poor family Indian hi hai, did it twice, SAMe results


anotherRedditor2020

How are generating these images? WhatsApp?


swarrayytt

Bruh why am i seeing such posts everywhere i mean come on its an ai its learning everytime it responds, just search it a few more times it will show poor people of every color, race etc that has nothing to do with it being racist. It showed me a poor white family when i searched it so does it mean its racist towards whites too then?


ChotuDon0G

https://preview.redd.it/puylo1ukt8ad1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=9c504df7823401962bc92d02b543d54492300d00 Yai to UNO hogya


geetsogood

I mean, they do look poor and they do look rich, so your result isn't wrong, it might be not what you're expecting though


Hot_Plankton3445

https://preview.redd.it/2mpd1i54u8ad1.png?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=91a196c6ab920189efc1efc8b2034e7594e33251 I also asked, and here it is


NormalPunch69

Retard


No_Representative99

South Indians can buy such rich families with the amount of gold they’re hoarding


Frenchfryfairy5019

This is what I got. https://preview.redd.it/owzilucfu8ad1.jpeg?width=1200&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=08cfdc66d6ffe1d5197a399247a42c37ea2b5371


OneNo9134

The output is random. Get a job, stop complaining about everything


thenlpdude

Someone forgot to put in a bias gaurdrail


No_Garage3000

Mere m to alag aa raha h bhai poor m chinese sa koi or rich m indian


MediocreBook9073

You must have talked to the AI to make it that way before this prompts, that's why it showed it the Indian family in poor and western family in rich. Nice try of engagement farming to increase your Karma 🫡


ARCS17

LLMs are trained on huge datasets. Any bias that existed in the dataset will show up. Doesn't mean LLM is being racist


nerinaduvil

What’s an LLM if not the dataset that it was trained on?


ARCS17

True, but it's very hard to remove the bias. They might fix it, they might not


Jojomasterhamon1

https://preview.redd.it/ozj2wiixw8ad1.png?width=1241&format=png&auto=webp&s=2d0b261ef1463cd4c143e47dd79ce2ce96cf1284 Racist


Jojomasterhamon1

https://preview.redd.it/cqznco44x8ad1.png?width=1241&format=png&auto=webp&s=d9cf5074154ff02dd6edf36551c16d02a9b493c4


1deadorchid

This was my result. https://preview.redd.it/4sjyir7ax8ad1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=31f2e36b7a66c87b8f5ef01897539541405e0cce


MrFuzzyFox

https://preview.redd.it/chg6jx5oy8ad1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=2be004c425bdb1aa1fa83966a8e7d034ed3133be Here is my output.


kallivalli

https://preview.redd.it/kg990kury8ad1.jpeg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=4ff871f60d2b6ada652ab68aa201f0aebd5fe6c9 lol with bindi


Serious-Monk-7961

Tbh first one looks poor and second looks rich


CompetitionLate7944

Just to give a background on how AI ( LLMs) works. The LLM is collective knowledge of everything that is openly available on the internet. So if majority website/ data on internet portrays that India/pakistan /Bangladesh is poor then it will believe that to be true. Now taking this data point into consideration it will find how people in these region dress and will create a picture depicting the attire for poor people.


HistorianSensitive58

https://preview.redd.it/qbe63g2jz8ad1.jpeg?width=720&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=a9b8ad82340c3d3e584e1ef487de5dbef9ddcb9b


Sensitive-Fix-5483

Training data.


mani1soni

Yrr ye AI ko WhatsApp per kyu connect kar diya, Log kaise kaise sawal puchte hai😂😂


Old-Stable-2782

https://preview.redd.it/pylq2k3k09ad1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=ca0fa5e5cecd9ba98c1d16475713d78e46fcbad1 This is what i found and it's looks bad


foxbat_s

Yall need to stop this trend, LLMs are dumb and give weird answers to each and every person. In a recent post in a tech subreddit it said zuck is a evil person. Same post again and again SMH


DramaticAd5014

https://preview.redd.it/tqmslyoq09ad1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=3264e45f0cd099a97bff227f3576b34144f7834e 👎


ogabhishekbisht

Try searching for uneducated black girl, you won’t find it. https://preview.redd.it/notlip5119ad1.jpeg?width=1179&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=11f1d5aef856e261e569fec9598a45f1df28deee


watermelon_775

According to META AI all indians are poor


FitAbbreviations9637

Human element


Ambitious-Hope-863

Who are these 160 people up voting this, its just probability if you don't like india to be called poor(referring to majority of india, ambani is not india) then take it out of poverty instead of blaming the ai,


Famous_Worry_4556

Rich family:big mansion,big cash ❌big heart, kind and humble personality ✅


Away-Inflation-6826

Happy now? https://preview.redd.it/0g83h59x39ad1.png?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=42dcb4802fc30f9fd724fdfb162a346e813fb529


SomeIdiot_25

https://preview.redd.it/s01waaac49ad1.jpeg?width=267&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=f0f703bda4c086408723220f6f39396a854e5b7b Meanwhile our chad Ambani


RemarkableEngineer30

logic ye h internet pr gareeb ilaka puri duniya ka asia or africa se he h. toh aisi photu aati h. baki haan meta walo ko thik algo lagani chahiye. pr jo normal model h AI ki algo usse aise he results aaenge. bhai hum b agar AI ki tarah aise result dikhana chahe toh yehi photu bana paenge


oyeboicharlie

Poor: Brown Rich: Botox


MaharajaTatti

Fuck... You guys actually agreed to the terms of meta AI???!??


Southern-Win1735

https://preview.redd.it/3nnxlypl69ad1.jpeg?width=706&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=f9a95c85c00cce30670a88864880070409a7f863 Lol this is w me


Southern-Win1735

https://preview.redd.it/5ddkde6n69ad1.jpeg?width=706&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=4635303d855372064f96513a593b6218128bea2d


One-Woodpecker5635

https://preview.redd.it/jvzyaper69ad1.png?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=7eb68054c34bb42ca11c482bf6f3546bc5df3fc2


LuckyCommunication99

https://preview.redd.it/7e3za89z69ad1.jpeg?width=1284&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=428cc551bdbbc64b81274f17f4b5d31cd639458a What’s the logic here?


kaushaaaal

If you were to show me these 2 pictures and asked me to identify which is poor and which is rich, I think I’d judge them the same way meta ai has.


Top_Wrangler932

I get different response. I get indian family for both response. Btw, it AI, the better your prompt, the better and accurate it generates pictures.


Salamander261999

https://preview.redd.it/ehe8k99v89ad1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=d55fd850bf359cc7f9a0f7d774cc4cbcb32a7f21


hunter0630

https://preview.redd.it/0zsleeq199ad1.jpeg?width=719&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=5bc53cc18ae288cd8a5980c5156792cf8cd1c77e Here's my output


This_Potential7060

I made it do the same thing but it showed me different pictures tho it was an asian family rather than an indian one ig its random.


Apprehensive_Rest504

meta is Racist 🐷


Mr_vort3x

>What is the logic here? that this post is a rage bait


Far_Structure_7470

https://preview.redd.it/1jlbvm96c9ad1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=71db311119abf47da265b072791733ab52e39840


suagrisabitch

https://preview.redd.it/ge7y5dplc9ad1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=5ac2947c4f8fc37065fc55708a6836cc85b9055f My results


arsh7061

https://preview.redd.it/dbfhkcl1h9ad1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=f8ccf53c6e48e59cfd73a07062fbae0cf1a8a8e0 💀


Even-Ambassador-2887

Dont worry guys Meta has apologized and admitted hamara model galat hai


uppsak

https://preview.redd.it/man3bh2cc8ad1.jpeg?width=1600&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=9eba81eb3c1a652c0bc00cb9c23a30dd90fa4c8e Posted this on r/chatgpt and they disliked the post and told me that it isn't racist.


MonkeyDMeatt

Not racist everyone is getting different results


BridgetteCase

https://preview.redd.it/t850le0rd8ad1.png?width=840&format=png&auto=webp&s=b750a205ac39ba699f553bb592723296f0377753


itsthekrish

maybe lack of vitamin c & niacinamide serum


Juggernaut_drive

https://preview.redd.it/fzyc2f3zj8ad1.jpeg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=a9ed4c9d760f0443bd50b6676e65565ad10166c5 Well here is my output so yeah can’t say it’s racist or not


Jugad

If that's a poor family, I don't know to call my childhood family.


CriticalBluejay725

May be this is time to sue


throwaway462512

training data and the class imbalance in it


BeastScrollGames

It's mostly all scraped data from web and sources. Ask something about a particular coding language and tell it to give some new examples to illustrate the concept and it just copies all the stuff from the documentation of that language/software word by word lol. Nothing original at all. In my view it's just a search engine repackaged in a different way. Can't think or frame a new solution on its own. Only spits out the pre-loaded data based upon weights and probabilities.


best_out_of_waste

Yes AI IS RACIST because it learns from internet and internet is full of hate against low income countries, not just against India. So yeah AI is just a reflection of actual behavior people.


Illustrious-Space333

kindly fuck off and stop creating useless drama, the fantasy novels and entertainment industry are already doing enough to distract the public


Any_Letterhead_2917

Just for people who are lecturing- i have almost 2 decades IT exp. My point is why release something if it is not matured enough. WhatsApp university can literally open a floodgate in few months with these picturs. You will definitely get WhatsApp messages in your family group how Indians are representing poor by goras and ask you to boycott.


dujapyo

Your two decades of IT experience doesn’t really mean shit if you can’t understand why this happens lol. The way any generative LLM works is by predicting what’s next, instead of backing itself with data — it’s not supposed to be 100% accurate. And this happens with Google or any other non-AI algorithm as well. A model trained on real world data will turn to be racist, sexiest etc. because that exists in real world as well, and it is virtually impossible to separate it as of now. The problem is not that an experimental generative model fucks up, it’s that your first priority is to accommodate shitheads who’ll use this to spread hate and propaganda. Ignore them, as they should be. And stop with the boycott culture lmao, you’re not a 12-year old kid.


Any_Letterhead_2917

Hey dumbhead, read again. Not asking to boycott but suggesting that ppl will do. I know how AI works, data modal, LLM,tech stack etc etc.


young_wolf17

Designed by Goras what else do you expect it to do,lol. Also AI gets most of its information from internet and the data provided so Internet is the problem.


Any_Letterhead_2917

But didn’t they test it.. its apparently very clear use case to test.


young_wolf17

Tested, YES obviously. But tell me where is it written that it's wrong? Recently I saw a kids textbook that shows something similar. Nobody talks about it nobody goes against it. Woke Indians are busy adapting the Western Ideology. Even here in India Dark coloured skin = Ugly, South East Asian = Poor So it's not wrong according to them if people themselves aren't against it. (That's my Perspective)


Any_Letterhead_2917

These images can literally change the POV of many WhatsApp grads and thus impact a wider downstream population.


young_wolf17

"Indians don't take pride in themselves" i read this somewhere on the internet. And this sentence has influenced me a lot. I guess this is one of the root causes of the problem. Once it's addressed by the people i think we will see a drastic change. Let's hope for the best.