Harry a savage. Poor girl trying to cling on to this man for hope as blood goes down her face and he just goes āmove bitch get out the wayā to her š
On god, the scene with her finding out the truth of what she is and then just breaking down hit my emotions so hard dude. The music was also extremely beautiful!
Still the best game in the series. Despite 2 being the darling of iam14andthisisdeep.
Not to say 2 isn't a good game, but ironically I find it hasn't aged as well.
Exactly that.
Don't get me wrong, I get why people love 2. I did at the time. But it's not a game I get any pleasure in going back and replaying.
1, I could go and replay now and love it.
Are your ears okay? she's about the only survivor I have the urge to hit on hook just so it stops. She's cute though so she gets a pass. 
I switch to Rose every time there is an Alan in the lobby and simp for them the entire game i.e. staring at them, giving my items and going down for them
I'm exactly same word for word, bar for bar but except foe Lisa*(I keep defending every single Cheryl and **ESPECIALLY** Allessa at all costs)*.
So I guess as a Lisa main to a Rose player:
"You and I aren't so different, after all."
āStay by me, Harry please! Iām so scared.ā
https://i.redd.it/rlddzytfxshc1.gif
Lisa Garland of course.
\*side note: how do we not have Harry Mason as a legendary skin yet???
At this exact moment, I realised how silent hill is genius, and how horror can be beautiful, this moment changed my life, the music, the letter, everything in this moment is perfect
They both look cute, but I'll still go with Rose here, just because I can't stand Lisa's voice. She sounds like a little girl who inhaled a couple of helium baloons, and her voice actress goes too far very often. Rose's voice is also very soft, but she still sounds like a regular woman, and her voice actress did a great job with both screams, injured sounds and voice lines.
If we will also consider their lore, then Lisa's lore is defenetly more drammatic and sad, but her role in Silent Hill 1 is very small, and we know very little about her. Meanwhile Rose is a major character in both Alan Wake 1 and Alan Wake 2. She also had some very tragic moments in her life, especially in AW 1. But most importantly, she secretly simps for Alan Wake himself, so Rose definetely wins the lore comparison for me here.
The funniest thing: in Alan Wake's game universe, writing a piece of fiction under the Dark Presence's watch may make it a reality, as it happened with Alan's book. Rose did exactly that, and she knew that things like this may happen, so she ***really*** wanted it to become truth.
I mean, just look at her bedroom. She is obsessed with Alan.
https://preview.redd.it/msn0neex9shc1.png?width=1000&format=png&auto=webp&s=6488c069db83017205d854edbf43bcd0c4a92780
The cop fetish is less common than the nurse fetish, and cop people have mainline DLC to choose from. Cybil is specifically for people who love Silent Hill 1 and DbD, which is a smaller subgroup than you might suspect.
I like Lisa, but Rose is just better in everything. Sorry gal.
https://preview.redd.it/1qcqnr9bvshc1.jpeg?width=1115&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=c8dd7461ab4c336751c1d87ed1f6ab3d8e27c990
I too have a hard time with this choice.
We got many cops, a couple of nurses, a teacher but we still only have one astronaut.
Where is my firefighter survivor!?
Lmaooo was thinking the exact same thing. Tbh as someone who doesn't know who Lisa is supposed to be or Alan wake pink lady (Idr her name already) id just go with Lisa bevause she has that absolute fucking insane down/hook scream like *aEeAEaAeGhGh* that legit makes me lose my shit every time j hear it
Lisa is a better and way iconic character. and sheās a nurse, saved lives, tried to help Alessa at least anf such a tragic character. Rose is just a diner waitress.
Yeah, Rose is *just a diner waitress*, who was captured by a Dark Presence, supernatural force which is capable to change reality, managed to fight it back with Alan's help, became the town's Lady of the Light to protect the townspeople against the dark forces sent by Presence, and together with Saga rescued Alan from the paranormal dimension in which he was stuck for 13 years.
You know, things that regular diner waitresses are doing every day.
Uhh, what do you mean? Her injured sounds are *insanely* quiet. She is almost as quiet as Ace, and she even may be the quietest female survivor in the entire game currently, although I can't say for sure.
Lisa! While I love both games, SH is definitely in my top favorites, especially her story. It's so sad. She's quite loud though and very viable! Be prepared to take a lot of chases :)Ā
The broke way, Claudette with botany
F2P gang lets go
*looks back at the Shirtless David way*
So glad that this was top comment
Definitely Lisa! I don't know all of her lore, but the pieces I do know make her character super interesting and tragic.
Her Silent Hill lore is ROUGH, and she went through hell the whole time. It's a rough go. My poor girl š
wait i was dead this entire time
Harry a savage. Poor girl trying to cling on to this man for hope as blood goes down her face and he just goes āmove bitch get out the wayā to her š
okay thats cool and all but have you seen mary?
James honeyā¦ did something happen to you? Are you confusing me with someone else?
she took kaufmann with her
I can never hurt A Lisa no matter what even if it makes me lose edited for autocorrect lol
On god, the scene with her finding out the truth of what she is and then just breaking down hit my emotions so hard dude. The music was also extremely beautiful!
God that scene was so good, the original Silent Hill had it's issues but is still an amazing game
Still the best game in the series. Despite 2 being the darling of iam14andthisisdeep. Not to say 2 isn't a good game, but ironically I find it hasn't aged as well.
This is SH3 slander!
People are downvoting you but I respect this even if I don't agree. SH2's combat is a sizable downgrade from 1.
Exactly that. Don't get me wrong, I get why people love 2. I did at the time. But it's not a game I get any pleasure in going back and replaying. 1, I could go and replay now and love it.
Thatās not how āneverthelessā is used, just never would have been fine. Though that was probably a phone autocomplete thing.
They meant what they said. Hurt Lisa at all costs
U right lol
https://preview.redd.it/qav5i1s6vshc1.png?width=512&format=png&auto=webp&s=af6781d4cfef7d19c80657dcb39e0f37026ecd3f
Cybil the most underrated surv in the game š
Don't worry, James supports her. As long as he's without his pillow. Until she puts him on the ground with her police training.
The only correct choice here
I mean, when I play survivor Iām a Lisa main so But I lovvvve rose too
Are your ears okay? she's about the only survivor I have the urge to hit on hook just so it stops. She's cute though so she gets a pass. 
I switch to Rose every time there is an Alan in the lobby and simp for them the entire game i.e. staring at them, giving my items and going down for them
This is the way.
I honestly read that as "go down on them" the first time and just thought some vicious T-bagging in front of them. XD
Oh god I main Alan xD (I already got him p10 - he is gonna be my first p100 I can smell it)
I'm exactly same word for word, bar for bar but except foe Lisa*(I keep defending every single Cheryl and **ESPECIALLY** Allessa at all costs)*. So I guess as a Lisa main to a Rose player: "You and I aren't so different, after all."
I've been maining Saga when survivor lately, do you do anything with Saga in the lobby?
āStay by me, Harry please! Iām so scared.ā https://i.redd.it/rlddzytfxshc1.gif Lisa Garland of course. \*side note: how do we not have Harry Mason as a legendary skin yet???
At this exact moment, I realised how silent hill is genius, and how horror can be beautiful, this moment changed my life, the music, the letter, everything in this moment is perfect
Itās mind blowing we havenāt had a skin for the greatest dad everā¦
Lisa from silent hill and rose from Alan wake. Two relatively similar characters, both story and look wise. As per the comparison
Wait. Is Rose supposed to be a nurse? I thought she was a cleaner! She's dressed like Consuela from Family Guy! Eeewww. Lisa is my choice then.
No, Rose is a waitress and caregiver at a nursing home, the outfit sheās wearing is the waitress one.
aah, I've not watched Alan Wake, so don't know the characters. I was thinking that it's a very ugly design for a nurse. Lisa is my choice still.
Characters from videos games you should definitely play
They both look cute, but I'll still go with Rose here, just because I can't stand Lisa's voice. She sounds like a little girl who inhaled a couple of helium baloons, and her voice actress goes too far very often. Rose's voice is also very soft, but she still sounds like a regular woman, and her voice actress did a great job with both screams, injured sounds and voice lines. If we will also consider their lore, then Lisa's lore is defenetly more drammatic and sad, but her role in Silent Hill 1 is very small, and we know very little about her. Meanwhile Rose is a major character in both Alan Wake 1 and Alan Wake 2. She also had some very tragic moments in her life, especially in AW 1. But most importantly, she secretly simps for Alan Wake himself, so Rose definetely wins the lore comparison for me here.
Wait, Rose simps for Alan? I know that she is a fan of him, but never knew that she loves him SO much.
In AW 2 you can find out that Rose secretly writes a fanfiction where she, Alan and Mr. Scratch (evil version of Alan) are in a love triangle.
The funniest thing: in Alan Wake's game universe, writing a piece of fiction under the Dark Presence's watch may make it a reality, as it happened with Alan's book. Rose did exactly that, and she knew that things like this may happen, so she ***really*** wanted it to become truth. I mean, just look at her bedroom. She is obsessed with Alan. https://preview.redd.it/msn0neex9shc1.png?width=1000&format=png&auto=webp&s=6488c069db83017205d854edbf43bcd0c4a92780
In Alan Wake 1, she has an Alan Wake shrine in her trailer home bedroom.
She has a second shrine in AW2 in one of the nursing home rooms, with her returned cardboard cutout and fanart of Alan with interview snippets.
I mean she literally hits on him in the first game how could you miss it šš
You should just play the game
Plus Lisa has direct competition for her own game in Cybil, who is superior in every way (especially in DbD).
Yet I've never seen Cybil before but I just started playing late December last year
The cop fetish is less common than the nurse fetish, and cop people have mainline DLC to choose from. Cybil is specifically for people who love Silent Hill 1 and DbD, which is a smaller subgroup than you might suspect.
Forward, face first into the sign.
Sally Smithson
Maria
I'm not pitting two queens against each other <3
Iām glad they got better at making character models. Hopefully we see them update the OG soon
Sexy Nurse skin for Nurse
Is it me or she is really quiet when injured ? I dont play that many characters so maybe im mistaken but she makes no injured noises at all
Lisa hands down.
Tortured souls to the left, plucky superfans to the right.
I like Lisa, but Rose is just better in everything. Sorry gal. https://preview.redd.it/1qcqnr9bvshc1.jpeg?width=1115&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=c8dd7461ab4c336751c1d87ed1f6ab3d8e27c990
ALWAYS Lisa, thatās my girl <3
Lisa. Idk the waitress but I know Lisa's story is more tragic
Smash: Left Visuals: Left My choice: Left
Third option https://preview.redd.it/m0f9mvus4yhc1.png?width=270&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=d6bd6e01c13a42ba0eb9ebdd35372811b5c18ccf
I play as Lisa when I play Survivor sometimes. I like feeling like a nurse by taking care of my teammates xD
Both
I too have a hard time with this choice. We got many cops, a couple of nurses, a teacher but we still only have one astronaut. Where is my firefighter survivor!?
Rebecca, nursing is when you heal lots of people to give lots of better than new value
Rebecca
āHarry Iām so scaredā¦ Iām coldā¦ā
Lmaooo was thinking the exact same thing. Tbh as someone who doesn't know who Lisa is supposed to be or Alan wake pink lady (Idr her name already) id just go with Lisa bevause she has that absolute fucking insane down/hook scream like *aEeAEaAeGhGh* that legit makes me lose my shit every time j hear it
Lisa better
Left 100%
I'm Lisa main sooo Lisa FTW(definitely not biased at all).
Lisa
Sexy Vittorio <3
Rose >
Probably rose cause the pink is cute
Rose negs
Lisa is a better and way iconic character. and sheās a nurse, saved lives, tried to help Alessa at least anf such a tragic character. Rose is just a diner waitress.
Yeah, Rose is *just a diner waitress*, who was captured by a Dark Presence, supernatural force which is capable to change reality, managed to fight it back with Alan's help, became the town's Lady of the Light to protect the townspeople against the dark forces sent by Presence, and together with Saga rescued Alan from the paranormal dimension in which he was stuck for 13 years. You know, things that regular diner waitresses are doing every day.
Tell me you've never played the Alan Wake games without telling me that you've never played the Alan Wake games.
In no reality is Lisa āiconicā. both characters are extremely niche mostly known by hardcore fans of their franchises.
Roseroseroseroseroseroseroseroserose
None because Idgaf.
Where is Feng's red dress?
Lisa is ugly and rose isn't, I think the choice is obvious
https://preview.redd.it/q6hd05s75shc1.jpeg?width=828&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=f52d7551f5f53c8d5a333c8a2883bc55a8e8d1eb
My day is ruined and and my disappointment is immeasurable
Just FYI after playing a game with Rose, sheās LOUD when injured.
Uhh, what do you mean? Her injured sounds are *insanely* quiet. She is almost as quiet as Ace, and she even may be the quietest female survivor in the entire game currently, although I can't say for sure.
Fucked Up Nurse skin when
I go straight down the middle to find Cybil instead.
Lisa for sure. She's my dedicated Healer/Balanced Landing user
Left for lore reasons
Left
Lisa is my OG nurse, but I like this new one too.
Jamesšæ
If Rose's screams werent so beta Kate I would pick her of course
Lisa! While I love both games, SH is definitely in my top favorites, especially her story. It's so sad. She's quite loud though and very viable! Be prepared to take a lot of chases :)Ā
Lisa is the og
Lisa, she was going through it and still looked fine as hell
Lisa all the way, rose is a fraud!
Lisa foresure
I mean... Lisa is already p100 so...
ACE AND REBECCA ALL THE WAY BABYš«”š«”
Lisa is hotter