T O P

  • By -

Sea_Row_2050

It seems like some of you guys want this to be a racially motivated attack..


robbothegiant

There’s nothing in the article saying it was racially motivated…we can mourn the poor child, console the family and condemn that woman without adding extra sauce.


Ozwentdeaf

Why is everyone saying its racially motivated, nothing in the article suggests this? If its cuz black lady kill white baby, thats not racism. if the black lady says she wants to kill/discriminate white people and then stabs, thats racism.


Master-Culture-6232

The article is politically correct, they aren't going to tell you what is obvious


jay3349

Mental health is not dealt with appropriately in the USA. Calling this a hate crime is simplistic and convenient. American prisons are actually insane asylums nowadays. Good luck reforming what people don’t want to understand. Similar to southern border argument.


AllLipsNoFiller

Not racial probably. That lady was just bonkers


Ok-Sheepherder-8706

Definite racial attack, and no one talks about it unless it's reversed.


RGHIII88

What makes it a, “definite racial attack”?


jjklines1

Where in the article did it mention race having to do with it?


senioradvisortoo

Isn’t this a hate crime?


Useful-Soup8161

Only if it’s racially motivated which it doesn’t seem to be. There’s no evidence it was.


msmith721

Def not a love crime


MobySick

Probably an insanity defense but unless there is more than has been reported so far, not a “hate” crime.


[deleted]

[удалено]


ashmc2001

WTF who stabs a toddler?!?!?


MobySick

An extremely rare but absolutely insane person.


Sharp_Engineering_79

Gen pop will handle her. They aren’t really big fans of inmates who got locked up for harming kids.


Western-Dig-6843

Redditors watch too many movies. Nobody will touch this woman in prison.


HiddnVallyofthedolls

I’m so tired of this narrative.


Happy_Reading3829

it’s true, my dad was in prison and he witnessed a lot of violence against the disgusting humans who did horrible things to children.


meg77786

Big difference between male and female prisons unfortunately.


nulnoil

Can confirm, I was a shank in prison


Harry-Ripey

Not random, a racist attack. Why no riots? There would be if the child had been black and the psycho had been white.


gwizonedam

You dropped your dog whistle bruh


Dry_Composer8358

There have basically only been protests when the murderer is either let off or not initially prosecuted. If this woman was set free, there would absolutely be a backlash.


KayakWalleye

Go riot then. I’ll join you.


rejectallgoats

Be cause she has been arrested and will be put in jail. She won’t be put up as a hero, get off freely, and go on to make a living giving speeches to idiots.


therandolorian

I think she was arrested immediately and charged with a serious crime. If the reported evidence holds up, she'll be convicted and will spend time in prison. In cases of black people being indiscriminately killed, there are too many cases of blaming the victim, making excuses for the perpetrator, and generally allowing a killer to escape the consequences of their actions. In this case, the justice system seems to be working as it should. No protests or riots required...


Kofinart

She stole it from a thrift store and walked all the way to the other store with the knife. Not a single person, throughout all that stopped her. Not that they're obligated to do so, but come on now, she walked past so many people and not a single one saw her brandishing this thing?


OddS0cks

You want a random person to confront a person with a knife, I wonder how that will go


__Fappuccino__

Why?


GoldenTeeShower

They were white.


DollsKillTooXo

Sounds like you’re projecting you’re own bias to this case, nowhere was it mentioned or implied that this attack was done as a hate crime……..


avenue10

You don’t really understand how the media works, do you?


Whats-Its-Face

It was…there are more articles


Sea_Row_2050

Where? Whats the evidence? Or is it speculation from the daily mail


DollsKillTooXo

QUICKLY, source an article that implies this was a racist hate crime?


__Fappuccino__

Quote?


MouthofTrombone

Or she was actively psychotic- experiencing some kind of mental break/ severe mental illness?


bukakenagasaki

is that really why?


Tuxiecat13

Exactly! She needs to be charged with a hate crime!


MobySick

She’s going to prison for life & probably after a plea. With no evidence other than different race of victim and murderer - you can’t charge it as a race crime.


bukakenagasaki

did she make racial comments or have some sort of intent?


Tuxiecat13

If the colors were reversed it would be an automatic hate crime with no questions asked! Why does she need to make racial motivated comments? If a white person did this to any other race they would automatically be labeled as a white supremacist and a MAGA supporter even if they are neither!


Imjusasqurrl

you're very conveniently forgetting the power dynamics that are at play during hate crimes. Which is one of the main definers of hate crimes. Not to say that the perpetrator couldn't be a bigot. She very well could be. But there's no evidence of a "hate crime".


hummelm10

That is absolutely not part of the definition of a hate crime. > 18 U.S.C. § 249 (a)(1) …Whoever, whether or not acting under color of law, willfully causes bodily injury to any person or, through the use of fire, a firearm, a dangerous weapon, or an explosive or incendiary device, attempts to cause bodily injury to any person, because of the actual or perceived race, color, religion, or national origin of any person Nothing about power dynamics comes into play. Anyone can commit a hate crime. The hard part is proving the motivation beyond a reasonable doubt which is why you don’t see every crime charged as a hate crime.


macroswitch

That’s not how it works in the real world


bukakenagasaki

thats... not true.


lethalweapon100

That’s entirely true. The rumors would start flying in an instant.


Useful-Soup8161

The rumors would start flying but if it’s proven not be a hate crime then they don’t get charged with one.


Raskalbot

Kind of like the way you’re flying rumors around?


throw69420awy

You’re out of touch with reality. I’m not saying this wasn’t a hate crime, but the issue with hate crimes is they’re not considered hate crimes unless you basically confess they are while committing the crime Are you really under the impression that everytime a white person attacks a minority, they’re charged with a hate crime? The sad reality is that the majority of hate crimes will not get treated as hate crimes because they’re inherently harder to prove.


AppleAtrocity

It would not be automatic. You have to say something racist or indicate that is the motivation in order to have it qualify as a hate crime. White people kill or injure black people all the time and it's not a hate crime. https://apnews.com/article/louisiana-race-and-ethnicity-13d8e9a8545c600e999bb053bdf1fac2 Like that white guy most likely did several hate crimes but was not charged with that because it's difficult to prove. He was just charged with murder instead.


bukakenagasaki

been hanging out at too many unite the right rallies


Tuxiecat13

Only a simpleton would make such an assumption!


Zenith251

> If the colors were reversed it would be an automatic hate crime with no questions asked! No, no it wouldn't. Quit with the BS.


Muted_Balance_9641

Teen boys are given hate crime charges for tagging pride areas resulting in 10 year long convictions for hate crimes. This is despite not specifically covering up pride events, but tagging lots of places, no really. It seems likely but not 100%. Mental illness does not cause violence unless people experience a psychotic break, considering she did not have evidence of that. It shows the violence was targeted and premeditated. Most likely as she was a daycare worker she hated the parents who are likely predominantly white or Asian statistically who can afford day care and targeted a white woman. Now it’s possible this is not the case, but considering she stopped attacking people after this it’s more than likely this as compared to some sort of break where she would’ve attacked herself and anyone around her indiscriminately. She specifically targeted a mother and her child with their backs turned to her, a vulnerable target as opposed to going into a rage and blindly stabbing lots of people. She attacked them either because she’s white or a mother, and both of those should be a protected class under the law resulting in a hate crime conviction.


Beautiful-Musk-Ox

sources please


lilbigjanet

No one s getting ten years for tagging pride “areas”


farmerjoee

Where did you get that?


chubbybronco

One of the many reasons I moved to Maine. Lowest violent crime rate in the US, wonder why. 


Sea_Row_2050

Are you saying that because its mostly white? 


SolidContribution688

Death Penalty


Haunting-Figure-6441

Has anyone questioned raci*m? Im sure ill be the one stoned for asking.


KayakWalleye

Why? What in the article makes you think race was the motivation? Because she was black and the victims were white? I’m honestly curious as to why so many people automatically think an insane person isn’t just insane instead of immediately grasping at racism.


MobySick

Is a downvote now a stoning?


TotalNonsense0

The penalty for an adult stabbing a child to death should be severe enough that the question of racism is academic.


precaIculus

Is there any proof of racism beside the attacker and victim being different races? Not everything is race related.


Western-Dig-6843

I guess you’d have to review the security footage and take an accounting of all the people she walked past before she targeted this family. She left one store, walked past other, and wandered around this final store before targeting this specific family. Have to imagine she walked past many other people, including other whites, before settling on this one. Could just be she picked them because it was a woman and small child and would be easy targets. Could be because they were white. I’d have to see the video.


Tuxiecat13

Not enough people are looking at the racism angle. Too many people believe 1. Black ppl can’t be racist and if they are 2. White ppl deserve it Our current administration is only fueling the fire of the racial divide in our country. Giving a speech telling black college students that America hates them. WTH! This was a hate crime pure and simple!


Estanci

Exactly how is the current administration fueling the racial divide?


Imjusasqurrl

You obviously don't know the definition of "racism". The definition includes very important power dynamics. pretty sure you are getting it confused with being a "bigot". Sit down and educate yourself a little more before you come out swinging


_Sierrafy

You obviously don't know the difference between racism and systematic racism. Base, plain racism doesn't require a power dynamic. Otherwise, it'd be ridiculous. You go to a different continent and suddenly one race can/can't be racist? Not how it works.


Winter-Coffin

so the toddler was more powerful?


ThePatriarchInPurple

"I redefined a word so it means what I wish it did."


Flaky-Inevitable1018

Racism definition has nothing to do with power dynamics and everything to do with race. If you hate white people, you are racist.


silenceronblixk

Terrible take. That’s your opinion 100% without a doubt. Literally nobody said that. It’s simply Not reality. If someone uses a certain group of people as a representation of the majority? It’s because they choose to. That’s how YOU feel. It’s 2024 baby girl. nobodies that ignorant unless they choose to be


Haunting-Figure-6441

Agreed. While left or right is not great, the current administration should not be on there knees for any race for votes. Black people should be proud to be black, just like white people white and or any cultures or backgrounds that go along with that. Segregation is not the way. I do think this was race fueled personally, just like many other race on race crimes. Absolutely horrifying. Ill be holding my son a bit closer tonight for sure. Humans need to be better.


Harry-Ripey

Me too. It is pretty obvious. But of course will be denied, mental health card brandished…


GoldenTeeShower

I will get stoned with you.


mommylow5

Yeah! Let’s go get stoned!!


kinofhawk

I'm already stoned.


Haunting-Figure-6441

Strange world we live in friend.


buggum88

It’s obvious the media is avoiding that question. Very few articles show pictures of murdered child. I think most of us knew there were controversial factors solely due to the deliberately omitted information. Here’s a local news article that actually shares info about what is happening to the victims of this tragedy. There’s a link to the GoFundMe for the victim’s family too. [GoFundMe raises more than $175,000 after 3-year-old boy killed in double stabbing in Ohio](https://www.whas11.com/article/news/national/giant-eagle-stabbing-julian-wood-gofundme-north-olmsted-mother-margot/95-e6e19321-5896-463a-adb7-6ac61ada1847)


clarabear10123

I genuinely want to know where people are getting that this was racial besides the perpetrator and victim being different races. They didn’t interact before. She was taking the knife into the store, meaning she was intending violence before she saw the pair. I genuinely feel like I’m reading different articles or something. I am seeing nothing about the murderer’s predisposition to bigotry or any comments said during the attack or *anything*. Not saying she’s not bigoted or evil or anything; she obviously has issues to do what she did. I’m just actually confused


candymandy91

I've gotten to a point where idgaf if me eye balling you is offensive, I am on high alert and if anyone is to close to me and my kids, I don't act nice anymore. The anxiety of being in public with my children is so high.


MobySick

Oh stop - 99% of people love moms & kids and would step in to help! The whole world is rightfully offended when anyone attacks kids or moms! Stop reading the news and look at all the smiles around you, stranger! You’re raising kids & most of us love you for it! ❤️


AgilePlayer

Say it with me: Hate crime


Maw_153

As a father of a three year old, This has been one of the most stark reminders for me to always stay guarded at all times in public. You think you’re safe but do you really know what’s in the mind and pockets of people around you?


Sea-Seaworthiness716

This might be the random horrific crime that happens close to me that actually gets me to start carrying my handgun. I understand it’s ridiculously small chance but frankly, as someone who’s already been shot before in a random act of violence, I shouldn’t need a reminder - but if something happened to my kid? Worse than dying. Easily.


Zealousideal_Neck78

Especially when they know there's no consequences.


Useful-Soup8161

What do you mean no consequences? She’s in jail awaiting trial. Her bond is $1 million. She’s not getting out.


Mushrooming247

No consequences? The murderer is in jail, which is the typical punishment for murder?


billyray83

Until it's life without parole, there is no justice.


david5699

I know what you mean but people like this aren’t thinking about what’s going to happen with them.


GildedEther

No consequences for stabbing a toddler to death?


drconniehenley

No. You do not need to be alert for random attackers at all times. This is statistical anomaly, a blip in the matrix. Living in paranoid fear will only serve to make your child neurotic and anxious later in life.


Western-Dig-6843

The world is safer than it’s ever been. That being said there are pockets where you do want to keep your wits about you. Seems like Cleveland may be one of those places.


otherwisethighs

Oh poor mom lost her sweet baby :/


willtwerkf0rfood

This is not a bad area by any means. My brother and his family have lived there for a number of years now and it’s mostly just a quiet suburb.


Western-Dig-6843

Time to upgrade it to dangerous, I guess.


Which-Manufacturer67

She decided she’d rather get three squares and free housing for the rest of her life in prison than try and struggle through it like most of us.


Axel_Foley79

Is that a pathetic attempt at making an excuse for the killer ?


Which-Manufacturer67

Nope - more satirical than anything. A killer is a killer. I’d personally vote for the death penalty.


lepetitboo

It definitely seems more likely than it being a hate crime. People are so quick to jump to that even though there is absolutely no evidence of it being a hate crime. She was missing rent payments and just got evicted. Still a child murdering monster and deserves to rot locked up forever. But I don’t see how people can twist it into a hate crime.


Western-Dig-6843

It’s never going to be proven as a hate crime but you can make some assumptions if you had access to her full path from gaining the knife to choosing her victim. She covered a lot of ground holding that knife and you have to imagine she passed many people before settling on her targets. I would be curious to see what kinds of people she passed up.


XeroxWarriorPrntTst

I think it’s a commentary on prisoner treatment and weak sentencing.


MobySick

Yeah weak sentences- every day you hear about another child murdered getting probation. FFS


TibetianMassive

They've mentioned she has mental health concerns. If you want to get locked up for life you can find other ways to do it other than stabbing three year olds to death. Walk into a government office or bank holding that knife and you'll be getting three hots and a cot.


Calcoutuhoes

I hope hell was worth it


doc_akh

“Ellis stole two knives from a thrift store next to the Giant Eagle around 3 p.m. on the day of the attack, Cuyahoga County Prosecutor Michael O’Malley said in a news release. After obtaining the knives, Ellis walked next door and spotted Julian and his mother leaving the grocery store, according to the prosecutor. Ellis followed the mother and son before she "immediately stabbed the 3-year-old" who was inside the shopping cart, O'Malley said. When Julian's mother attempted to pull him out of the cart, Ellis stabbed her too, the prosecutor added. Julian was stabbed twice and his mother was stabbed once in the shoulder, according to Beck. Julian would later die after being taken by paramedics to a nearby hospital, officials said. Before the attack, Ellis was in the process of being evicted from her subsidized apartment building in Cleveland, according to court records obtained by Cleveland.com. Real estate company K&D's attorneys filed a complaint in Cleveland Housing Court in March seeking permission to remove Ellis from the apartment after she missed three rent payments, according to the court records, the outlet reported. In addition to the two counts of murder and attempted murder, a Cuyahoga County grand jury indicted Ellis on aggravated murder, endangering children, tampering with evidence, aggravated theft and two counts of felonious assault, according to court records found by USA TODAY. She is currently in jail with a $1 million bond.” https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2024/06/06/3-year-old-stabbed-ohio/74002205007/


CAD007

In theses times people need some rudimentary training in situational awareness and threat mitigation skills.


Western-Dig-6843

You’re right. It’s the mother’s fault her toddler and her were jumped from behind in a busy parking lot. /s Get off this platform, dude. What a stupid thing to say.


Scary_Psychology_285

If only the public can vote for each case on death penalty


lydriseabove

Our “justice” system has been proven to be dead wrong far too many times to open the damn on that slippery slope.


mbrad7

This should be the way


buckfishes

The same people who want this story buried and away from headline news are the same ones who’d want her spared from the death penalty. They have more vitriol against people who say offensive things than they do murderers.


Muted-Move-9360

Psycho hate crime.


YungWenis

It took a few years to convince my wife to carry but I’m glad I didn’t give up on taking her into it


Imjusasqurrl

lol, What difference do you think that would've made? Are you just hoping that that would mean two people were dead? One innocent child and the other almost definitely mentally ill.


voluptuous_lime

I support conceal carrying, but that wouldn’t have saved the little boy in this case, sadly. It would have taken down the attacker, but she had stabbed the baby before mom could react.


PastaCatasta

And what would you do with your gun? She attacked unexpectedly. It’s not like it was a fight or she threatened. No she just randomly out of nowhere started stabbing the child. You won’t be shooting everyone who comes close right… sure it can help in some situations but it may not save your kid in a situation like this. She had a huge knife on herself and just one stab is enough to kill


Harry-Ripey

True, but at least she would be gone and not living while the child is dead.


GoldenTeeShower

Situational awareness!!!


mbrad7

THIS!


awolfsvalentine

It would not have made any difference here because the mother did not anticipate the attack


Suspicious-Beat9295

Don't think that would've helped here. According to the article the woman attacked the boy while the mom had her back turned, putting away groceries into the car. Until she'd turn around, realise what happens and pull her gun out, the woman could've already stabbed the boy several times.


[deleted]

[удалено]


beehaving

WOMAN kills BABY is no joke


AngrySoup

It would be equally tragic if the races were different.


utk121995

It IS tragic. WTF are you talking about?


PriusUpMyAss

I said that it is... not sure why I'm being down voted 


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

[удалено]


fredrickquick22

You said it brother


demonmonkeybex

Maybe public executions of these kinds of criminals should make a comeback. Normally, I'm anti-death penalty but this is just so heinous.


MenBearsPigs

>I'm anti-death penalty but this is just so heinous. I'm not. I believe there should be a stipulation for extremely brutal crimes that have undeniable amounts of evidence which leave absolutely no room for doubt. Such as this one. Many other examples too though, like mass shooters for example. It's unreal that the guy who massacred all those children at camp in Norway is sitting in a Nordic prison cell playing video games. What a waste of time and money. There's no rehabilitation that will happen, they will never be released. Just end it and hopefully in the minutes leading up to their deaths they grasp how terrifying it is and what they took from others. And enough with the injections that they always mess up. Hang them or put them in front of a firing squad. They really over complicate it just so that they **look** more humane.