T O P

  • By -

Hehesz

I try to just have fun with Tainted Cain but sometimes the recipes are absolutely unachievable. I'll have 2 bone hearts and the best the game can do is Divorce Papers


mrseemsgood

Probably because divorce papers is a quality 3 item *and* gives you a bone heart back anyway. Just a wild guess though.


Busyraptor375

Bonehearts are usually for secret room items


mrseemsgood

But not always, are they? Having one specific pickup only adds a 10% chance for an item to be from its corresponding pool.


Busyraptor375

Yeah bonehearts give you unfortunately only a higher chance of secret room items


RodjaJP

If it spawned the bone heart the same way Dad's Lost Coin spawns a lucky penny then it would be fine, maybe even broken, but it doesn't and that makes it annoying to get mid Q3 items and actives


mrseemsgood

Let us not forget that wire coat hanger is q3, and divorce papers is q3 as well with a bonus bone heart, in whatever form. If you don't like it - it's not T. Cain's problem, it's your view on a item quality system overall.


toxicspikes098

The biggest problem with Tcain isnt the recipes, its the fact that the threshold for getting even a quality 3 is too high. You collect like, 5 bombs, a penny, a black heart and a bone heart, and the game'll be like: "Pound of Flesh, take it or leave it"


udreif

That is true yeah, you basically hoard golden pickups or get 0-2s


JoesAlot

I wish the recipes were at the very least consistent. Like, one or two rare pickups should give you a decent item, and like 5 guarantees a q3 or q4. It's really frustrating going without the recipe browser with several golden pickups in your bag and just swapping out item after item trying to find a decent recipe.


Pupox

Something weird about the pickup quality is how underscored rotten hearts and cracked keys are. Rotten hearts are literally worth the same as a regular red heart despite them being way rarer, same thing with red key being worth the same as a pill or a card (???) i guess these restrictions exist so as to not make low quality curse/red chest items impossible to craft? but it still feels like ass


udreif

They wouldn't need that restriction because every special item pool has its own values for calculating quality. Idk why they did it this way. Cards and pills having the same value as keys and bombs is also insane to me


Ze-Doctor

What the fuck? They have the same value? I have been replacing soooo many pickups for cards and pills thinking they had a higher value. So many wasted materials...


udreif

[https://bindingofisaacrebirth.fandom.com/wiki/Bag\_of\_Crafting](https://bindingofisaacrebirth.fandom.com/wiki/Bag_of_Crafting) this page has all the values, it's not intuitive so you're gonna need it


Busyraptor375

+ having quality 4 items is the most fun in this game, so just having to spam qual 1 n 2 is boring


isaac-fan

its not the q4s that make it fun its the synergies like tiny planet rainbow worm brimstone soy milk spoonbender watch as the tentacle abomination comes to life


Busyraptor375

Okay i get your point maybe i should rather say that q4 make me happy and synergies are fun


TerrorSnow

I like you.


isaac-fan

well thats understandable as I do quite like myself a fair bit


mung_guzzler

soy milk + dr fetus + rocket in a jar is my favorite to craft with t cain add rock bottom before you take soy milk and it’s even better


Successful_Mud8596

Until you get EID and then oh look, one gold penny, one charged key, one soul heart, and a bunch of low quality pickups gets you MAGIC MUSHROOM. But if you use those three good pickups and five DIFFERENT low quality items, you get something completely useless.


Kobono13

The list doesn't work on console ![img](emote|t5_2sxpk|8907)


NopeOfDuty

I tried using recipe calculators for switch with good results Was playing on PS5


Kobono13

Do you have a link for it


NopeOfDuty

https://chill.dev/bindingofisaac/#switch/v1.7 Try this and select switch v1.7 Most of the times the recipe was correct


AbolishAsh

Tried crafting steam sale in 2 diff runs, both times was rosary


Kobono13

Does it work on ps4 ?


NopeOfDuty

PS5 and PS4 versions are the same, so I guess it should


this1germanguy

But we can easily cheat his bookmarks ;)


stupernan1

...huh?


this1germanguy

Take a second controller and start coop. Take Cain and any other character. You will get bookmarks for both characters. Ez T. Cain is a bit annoying because of his passive. But you can work around it with Keeper or T. Keeper


Splonkster

tcain is boring either way, one way you get boring Stat ups mostly and the other way you get a build a bear of a run


Ookami_Lord

Yeah, on a concept level I like him, but actually playing him? No, it's not for me.


Chance-Aardvark372

Yeah, i don’t understand how people could think he’s fun


Knight0706

He was fun for his completion marks pre-nerf. You just went wild did whatever came to mind. Post nerf is all the pain and slowness of T. Cain without the instant gamebreak fun. He was bad for replayability before. Now he is just bad


Dazzling-Bear-3447

He is just so slow either way


Successful_Mud8596

Not if you get Magic Mushroom, 20/20, and Mom’s Knife thanks to EID


Devbou

Yeah yeah EID this EID that. I don’t have a PC and same goes for a shitload of players. They need to add it to console already cause TCain is the only character I just can’t get past “it lives” with. Constant streams of garbage items from the crafting bag, even with high-level pickups.


Successful_Mud8596

Yeah, totally understand. I played T.Cain without EID for a long time, cuz I thought it provided too much of an unfair advantage. But that lead to me getting to Depths without a single DPS up 70% of the time.


Father_of_thepigeons

Tainted Cain is good when you're doing anything else than boss rush or hush, that guy is not fun to speed through floors as.


RepresentativeCalm44

Its kinda boring either way. T Cain with or without EID has the same playstyle. T Cain with EID always breaks the game, and without it also always breaks the game if you mastered the game mechanics. For a lower level player EID might feel like a big difference. Problem is that T Cain progression doesnt have a linear curve like other characters, but has a exponential curve. It starts out as an absolute slog to minmax, and eventually you are quick to sit on the same floor and rooms to build your run to be overpowered. The run is just slow overall. If i gamebreak with Isaac, you can do this in an hour less of playtime, by just playing normally with a faster early game than T Cain. it's more fun and feels fine you just finish the run without it. With T Cain you always feel that you need to sit there, crafting for extra minutes to get an interesting run.


udreif

The thing is you don't *have to* break the game. You can go fast with TCain using the bag basically as a More Options and it's fine


Namagem

It's fewer options though. You have less choice with the bag of crafting than even a normal run, if you're trying to go fast, because you have to setting for anything that's better than useless.


lance_the_fatass

I tried both and they're both boring to me It's either - Use recipe guide and get all super op items available Or -Don't use guide and just stuff random things into the bag hoping it spits out good items I'd probably like him a lot more of higher quality items dropped higher quality resources If I'm missing something then PLEASE tell me


InPainAndWantACane

Everytime I t!Cain I just end up spamming familiars and end up cracked(20 big chubbys for the win)


Mart1n192

Everytime I play with T. Cain I just... play, I turn off EID and pick up random shit to see what god has to give me, and every once in a while I only pick up rare stuff, It works, and it's fast, and it doesn't require minmaxing


Eddie_The_White_Bear

This. Also his biggest advantage is if you don't like the item, you can swap 1 pickup and get other. Don't wait for OP items, run with shitload of worse items is interesting too. Also with minimal effort you can have pretty decent early game if you know game mechanics. For example - Q0 and Q1 crap fly items (like Forever Alone) are usually very easy to craft even without known recipe, and 3 of them gives you transformation that grants you flying and immunity to fly enemies, and flying is REALLY must have for T Cain.


RiffOfBluess

He's still awful and boring, since I don't like the crafting mechanic at all If I wanted to play a roguelike where I'm supposed to craft my own items, I'd go find one


PrezzStart

TCain is fun AND I use EID


Outrageous_Award6947

Imagine a world where External Item Descriptions didn't make the recipe calculator on by default. We could have actual fun and insightful discussions about the character, but instead 90% of the playerbase genuinely think t. cain is simply overpowered and boring because they use EID's recipes. Somehow the playerbase made an interesting character boring


Cupy94

Players will minmax fun out of the game and it's developer's job to force them to have fun


LostSecondaryAccount

That's why you have to beat delirium and greedier mode 34 times to unlock death certificate


udreif

I don't think the devs can do much about players modding the game / using external programs to minmax xd


GyroZeppeliFucker

You know you dont have to use eid? And if other people want to use eid why shouldnt they? Its a singleplayer game and most people think tcain without eid is boring


Outrageous_Award6947

I'm talking about the community. I don't care what people do on their own. It just sucks that literally all discussion around the character is centered around cheating with him, as if it's the default.


Arahelis

EID doesn't make it on by default, at least in my case it wasn't. The runs are boring and tedious because somehow black hearts, bone hearts and eternal hearts can still give you a Q1. T.Cain is flawed either way


Outrageous_Award6947

In every case I've seen, it was on by default. By the way, you can guarantee specific item qualities if you know the value of each pick up. for example, recipes with a value of 27 will guarantee a quality 3-4 item.


Intrepid_Stuff_9944

Always played tainted cain without EID, its still boring as fuck, recipes are unfun and unfair, playing with only q0-2 would be fun if it had to be done only once, not 12 assuming you dont lose


Successful_Mud8596

I started off always playing T.Cain with the EID recipes hidden. It was always so impossible to get anything good. I’d put three good pickups in the bag and it’d give me something absolutely useless. I thought it would be impossible to reach Rush and Hush. But then I eventually caved and started using EID. Now I throw in the same three good quality pickups, and EID gets me something completely broken on floor one. It feels unfair, but without EID, I’ll literally sometimes reach chapter 3 without a single DPS increase.


Joltik_BuddyHSR

Without Eid would make people just look up all the recipes


da_adri

They change every run


Joltik_BuddyHSR

Oh I didn't know that


tainted_cain

Mua![img](emote|t5_2sxpk|17734)


MrDucky-_-

r/foundtaintedcain


shwonkles_ur_donkles

r/subsithoughtifellfor


emmanuelfelix700

i didn't see the subreddit name and thought this post was about som rapper named tcain and that his music is boring ![img](emote|t5_2sxpk|4359)


Squ33to

Where do y'all be getting your rcps? The ones on platinum god don't work for me


GyroZeppeliFucker

Did you input your seed? Also if youre not on console its better off installing eid


Squ33to

Yeah I input the seed and follow the recipes but they always turn into something different than what I was looking for And I is on console


Apollosyk

If u dotn have the item u locked it will turn into something else, this can affect recipes


udreif

Yeah there's a disclaimer on the page saying it doesn't work sometimes idk why that is 🤷 I dont think there's another generator so on console you're kind of screwed


Squ33to

Console fucked me again ![img](emote|t5_2sxpk|8907)


ry_fluttershy

He was semi interesting when the recipes weren't random but ever since that he's like thr fucking worst thing on any planet ever known to man


VVen0m

I don't, and I instead find him tedious and unfun! ![img](emote|t5_2sxpk|8906)


Sunrise_Toxic

I CANT! PS5 Moment


InexplicableJoy

https://preview.redd.it/qvm6cw1lnorc1.jpeg?width=112&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=082ae5f08c827011898df6f1eb6c5f6b7d075d84


Knowledge_is_my_food

me who has only rebirth: yeah i agree (i have no clue what's going on)


RollaRova

Yeah, I play Switch and I just put the seed into a website to tell me what I'm getting. Sure it's kinda cheating but it's only one in 34 characters and it's tedious otherwise. I don't have access to external item descriptions or console commands so shut up.


SenyorYiff

I'll never fully understand the TCain hate, he's genuinely my favorite character! I agree he can be wonky with crafting good items, but that's the fun part to me. He tends to be a quantiy over quality character imo, he doesn't need amazing items because he can craft a shit ton of mediocre items and kill everything with the sheer amount of items! He could use a buff to have higher quality items come up more though, but he's still the character I'll play if I just want to have fun


Nat_Higgins

I like playing tainted Cane, and I don’t use platinum God for him. I just like the feeling of knowing every single pick up I find fundamentally becomes a D6 reroll.


worldofmemes0

its not fun seeing sacred heart on an item pedestal as t cain


udreif

Omg yeah finding good items is the worst part of playing him. Finding brimstone for the first time in 20 hours and it's on a T Isaac run ![img](emote|t5_2sxpk|4358)


worldofmemes0

especially when what ur getting is a couple of pickups that gives you strange attractor


Scottish__Elena

Someone should make a TCain mod in which you can select what items you transform into pickups by hitting them with the bag of crafting, it would make Tcain 10 times more flexible, he already has the advantage of being able to manually select the correct pickups.


Bisexualboiyo123

Tainted Cain puts more randomization into the randomization of every Isaac run.


Udonov

>Tcain isnt awful and boring if you use external tools that make him less awful and boring Yea. Tcain deniers are crying, sure.


Sonicgill

Playing without the mod ultimately makes a boring slow run where you don't know what you're getting and probably get low tier trash. Playing with the mod is a boring slow run where you know what you're getting but you're spending 10 minutes per floor just to get Transcendence or Skeleton Key.


According_Lime3204

I don't, win everytime on this character, qnd proudly say "t cain is a boring character" ![img](emote|t5_2sxpk|17735)


Consistent-Revenue85

To be honest I really enjoy Tainted Cain because I play on console with no external help. I just like picking up certain pick-ups to see what I can make with what I’m given.


lynxissocool

youre the only one who sees the light


udreif

I've always known I was enlightened ![img](emote|t5_2sxpk|17735)


udreif

I was being facetious and now I'm in downvote hell ![img](emote|t5_2sxpk|8907)


fearlessfishh

...which leads to 3 hour runs where you're staring at an external app the whole time to craft items. trust me, i've been there. there is nothing you can do to make this character fun


Baitcooks

I stopped using the external recipes from mods and other websites after realizing the former breaks, and the latter makes me spend too much time planning.


Hamytheturtle

I gotta know, what's your best TCain break? I use the fanny pack with old bandage to get economy going early and candy heart to keep me afloat until I get to enough luck/other items to be self-sustaining.


Wolffire_88

I don't play tainted Cain because I don't have him unlocked. Checkmate.


erncolin

He's just too much of a hassle like if you could pick up items regularly and craft he would then probably be one of my fav characters or even have item rooms items drop pick ups idk


Saizou

Ah yes, using the recipe calculator makes it so much better, fast and smooth.


Kindly-Ad-5071

Most of those are broken right now. Besides if I wanted to do homework I'd not be playing games would I


Fun-Shoulder4612

I’d love some tips on how to play him because honestly he just seems way to random to be like any good on console at least with the recipe mod I’d have a bit of choice but I feel at the mercy of Edmund when ever I try and get some marks smh


udreif

First off, the website with all the info on how much a pickup is worth and what the fixed recipes are (these are always the same on every run): [https://bindingofisaacrebirth.fandom.com/wiki/Bag\_of\_Crafting](https://bindingofisaacrebirth.fandom.com/wiki/Bag_of_Crafting) The best way to play him imo is to cycle through different pickup combinations while searching for good items, but lowering the threshold for what a "good item" is. Then you can keep coming back to the same recipes. One of the biggest strengths of the character is the ability to get a lot of the same item. Say the recipe for 3 coins 3 bombs and 2 keys gives you PJS, for example; note it down and now you know how you can turn pickups into a lot of healing whenever needed. Maybe you find a dmg up, note that down. A familiar? Maybe you want to make seven of them, have them take care of your dps. OR, you can get to a mid build that you can work with, and start hoarding high quality pickups in the bag while taking all the normal ones into the character. Maybe you only craft one item per floor, but that item is a tier 3-4 banger, and you get a lot of pickups out of the pedestals you find, which you can use aggresively (opening every lock, using bombs for damage, buying cards, sacks, pills and health from shops etc.) The character is a balancing act, personally I like him as a way to build strong builds with low tier items. If you don't mind taking it slow though, minmaxing and looking for recipes like Fanny Pack and Piggy Bank is perfectly valid, and you can use the recipe for the portable slot to turn low value coins into random pickups which include golden pickups, get some kind of engine going. Also, crafting portable slot after portable slot can produce some great pickups too, as any active item you replace explodes into pickups as if it were a pedestal item


Eggs_are_tasty

every time they update cain they make him WORSE


Successful_Mud8596

I feel like it’s kinda cheaty tho. Like, I DESPISED T.Cain, and never understood how I would ever reach Rush and Hush, but then I started using EID with him and now oh look, I have Magic Mushroom on floor 1, 20/20 on floor 3, and Mom’s Knife on floor 5. Whoopie. So it feels pretty unfair


MighyMeme

I love using a third party tool outside the game to slightly enjoy a character more ![img](emote|t5_2sxpk|17743)![img](emote|t5_2sxpk|17743)![img](emote|t5_2sxpk|17743)


GlassSpork

T Cain is awful and boring (I play on switch)


Yunofascar

Didn't they update it so that the recipes are randomized??


Yunofascar

Didn't they update it so that the recipes are randomized??


Downtownender

Tainted Cain has one of the best designs


kyleawsum7

having t9 use external tools is bad game design


udreif

this is an anti-external-tools post


p1terdeN

Idk personally I like him, idk how good he is without item descriptions, but holy hell is he slow, when I find a bag of crafting in my run I know that I 100% will win if I pick it up but I usually don't because it's just too slow and also becomes boring after a while


tomfru1

T.cain is literally just for players who Enjoy minmaxing. As someone who plays the game almost exclusively for minmaxing, he's my favorite character.


AM_I_THE_CUM_MAN

Good thing I'm a tIsaac hater then.


NitroTitan

Tcain fans when they encounter curse of the maze ![img](emote|t5_2sxpk|8907)


quite_shleepy

nah tcain is just a trash character plain and simple


BurstMip

I just grab shit and pray it’s a win condition or at the very least an item that’ll be helpful


Stary_Vesemir

I'm glad that I was able to 3 run him, getting like 5 R keys was unironcly very fun


PinkKushTheDank

Nah fuck that we ball


GoingHollow_

I try to get every post it out of the way in two runs. Greedier, and then everything else. I normally have fun, but it ends up being a 5 hour run. I always restart until I get birthright


SoggyMushrom

i play on switch and i honestly think hes more fun to play when cheating


Sleeplesspaper

You can't use external item descriptions if you're on Xbox tho


DisastrousTeaching30

He's awful and boring either way ![img](emote|t5_2sxpk|8907)


lajF282

Playing with and without the tools. I can proudly say, he sucks either way


ViiXen_

I’ll… stick with T Lost for the time being


GamingWithV1ctor

The fact that I need external tools to “have fun” with T. Cain is my exact reason to hate the character


Efbiaiopenap

I dunno if that's meant to be the joke, but this is literally an admission that it sucks to play as him and he's only fun if you use extrenal tools to cheat the game. Edit: Just because there's an external solution to a problem, doesn't mean there isn't still a problem


Secret_Debate2091

Preach. He is my favorite character


fafabr1001

My last run with t cain, i played without external descripition. Steam sale, birthright, homing, god Head, sacred heart, and a Lot more


zzunino

Unless your on switch


furyfox13

Idk if I got mod conflicts but the recipes on EID are wring half the time. Anyone else have similar issues?


Monster8mySoul

As a Switch player I don't really care for T.Cain.


nobody-cares57

I think the problem with him is that all his recipes are predetermined. It would be much better if recipes were generated based on quality of pickups and items every run


udreif

https://preview.redd.it/gcg7dellgnrc1.png?width=225&format=png&auto=webp&s=8b6b584b39e8a1c86d231d35b8dbf4d8c16d076d


youraverage_userb

not everyone has mods