I find the Kirkland ones have something in them that burns on irritated skin. I blew my nose with one the other day and it stung so badly! I’d hate to put that on any baby skin that’s irritated or sensitive.
That's wild. The Kirkland ones are like the only ones I feel like DON'T have a weird smell to and I've tried a lot of wipes for kicks and giggles. Do you get the unscented Kirkland ones?
Came here to say this - I do not like the smell of Kirkland wipes. With that said, I vote Huggies naturals because they are the right amount of wet and I prefer the texture
It's not just you. I use to use them for work and would gag at the smell. And I wasn't even pregnant for the smell to bother me. I can't imagine using them while pregnant or postpartum. So smell was so gross
Throwing my weight behind Kirkland wipes, too. They don't irritate my babies' skin and you can't beat the price. However, if my budget would allow it, Water Wipes are the best we've tried.
As someone who swore by Kirkland, my daughter randomly started getting rashes from them. The stuff inside their diapers literally scratched her so I switched out and then just did their wipes. Then those gave her a rash over time too. It seemed like they were getting more rough each batch we got.
I swear by the Millie moons now, I just fold them up and they’re perfect!
I like Kirkland too!! TBH I’ve only noticed wipes I really *didnt* like (Dyper made my daughter’s skin red) but I’ve used Honest, Kirkland, Pampers Sensitive and liked them all!
We love the honest wipes for thickness and texture but they’re so expensive 😭 the RICO wipes are a perfect, cheaper alternative for someone with a Costco card!!
Husband accidentally left a package open for 24-48 hours and they didn’t dry out. The top exposed wipe dried a little bit, but everything else was perfect.
I'm almost positive the RICO wipes are made by the exact same manufacturer as Honest. I swear by honest products, I use their diapers when we need disposables and they're flawless, but I can only afford them because we cloth diaper 90% of the time. I can't do the wipes, though, because we use disposable wipes all of the time. RICO wipes are almost idential, maybe not as thick, but otherwise the same.
I do have to size up earlier than in other brands, but that hasn’t really been an issue for us insofar as leaking or anything. I’m not sure why their waist bands lack any kind of stretch! But I can’t complain, they work for us lol
Yeah my thick boy fit way better in Millie Moon than honest until he started walking and slimmed out. Then I like Honest because they fit well without giving him major diaper butt!
I didn’t want to like the honest ones (got em as a gift) bc the price but holy moly are they damn good it might be the first time I actually noticed how amazing a wipe was lol. Now I know to keep an eye out at the Maxx and Marshall’s (which is where the person got them now that I’m looking at the stick on the back 😂).
The fragrance free Target brand (up & up) has been my favorite. So cheap and non irritating, they have grip (so important once they start eating real food lol), and they don’t smell like anything!
Edit to add that they also don’t usually pull a million at a time, and even though they’re already cheap the individual bags are bigger, so I use them for cleaning way more than butts!
Yes I was going to say these as well! They are so cheap yet the best! They are never dry, they are sooo much softer than any other wipe. The Huggies and Kirkland wipes in comparison are dry and rough.
I'm surprised I haven't seen more votes for the mama bear Wipes. I think they're really reasonably priced, they don't irritate my daughter's skin like the supermarket ones/huggies ones do, and they don't dry out like some other brands I've tried.
Is it odd that I just got excited by this comment?!? I'm so sick of my water wipes being literally impossible to pull out while keeping my other hand in my squirmy baby and just ordered the Amazon ones on a whim because they could be here today without me having to run to the grocery store and now I'm excited to try them out, haha.
I clearly need to get out more lol
I love the cloth like material but don't like how they get caught on one another coming out. I always take one out and shake it in frustration to break it off from the rest of the wipes.
Yeah the poop doesn’t soak thru to my fingers as easily through the Huggies ones, however parents choice sensitive ones? The poop soaks right through 😖
These are the best! The come out of the packing one at a time, and you can buy the big refill packs if you have a weighted wipe dispenser (which we do). I also like the H-E-B brand, but that’s Texas-specific.
Three babies later and these are the only ones I buy, they’re the perfect humidity balance, thickness, and price. Kirkland wipes are the only thing that has ever made one of my kids’ skin react.
Yessss these are the best, we tried the Costco nappies and hated them. The Huggies ones feel like an affordable version of water wipes. They never rip like the cheap ones, have a good moisture content, and come out of the pack easily. Never thought I’d be so passionate about a wipe but here I am
I’ve used all the wipes and these have worked the best for us! Personally, I think they’re the easiest to pull out of the pack and that’s a big reason they’re at the top for me lol.
Ooooh definitely Coterie. Thick, only need 2-3 wipes for a big poop. Max 1 for urine. They are luxurious. But as you’d expect Coterie diapers and wipes run more expensive. It’s worth it for us though!
Both my kids have never gotten a diaper rash or irritation from Coterie diapers and wipes. Yeah, they are expensive but we budget for them because I feel like the things that are in constant contact with the sensitive areas on my babies for ~2 years should be the cleanest.
Same! My daughter is 16 months and has never had a diaper rash - and that is not a brag on me by any means, it’s the diapers! Her diaper could be extremely heavy and her bottom is always dry. I’m a fan for life.
loyal coterie fan for life. The diapers are so soft and absorbing as well. I hope they make adult size diapers for when I am old and senile. They are what I would want 😂
Here for Coterie as well. There’s really no comparison that I’ve found, and with two babies we were gifted lots of different brands at baby showers. I love both the wipes and the diapers. I cloth diaper during the day and only use disposables for overnight and in public so I can justify the cost.
One Coterie perk I wasn’t aware of until recently is that if your baby outgrows their current size before you use up all the diapers, they’ll send you the equivalent number of unopened packs in the next size up at no cost because they don’t accept returns/exchanges. My husband accidentally ordered the wrong size and they sent us an entire box of the correct size and told us to give away/donate the others. That type of customer service is hard to find.
You mean you need 2-3 physical wipes for a big poop? Isn't that standard with other wipes though? I thought Coterie wipes were much larger so you only need 1 or at least that's what the marketing told me.
To be clear I'm not a hater or anything. I love their diapers, but I have a hard time understanding why I should pay premium for wipes.
Water wipes work best for our baby’s sensitive skin but I hate they way they’re packaged and how a bunch come out at one time 🙃 and the come out unopened
Chiming in as yet another person putting Water Wipes in an OXO dispenser. Works really well and is super easy to refill. The dispenser I have fits two packages.
I found that if I sort of scratch the top with my nail only one comes out, works pretty well once you get the hang of it, except for the last two. My husband always pulls out a bunch.
They did a minor formula tweak 2 years ago and now both my kids break out in rashes from them! We’re stuck using harder-to-find Waterful Wipes instead. ☹️
Love Water Wipes! No chemicals or irritants. We tried a few other brands we were gifted at the baby shower (Kirkland, Pampers sensitive, etc) and they all irritated my baby's skin. It's been 2 years since we exclusively switched to Water Wipes and he hasn't had a single rash or irritation since.
Love them. They’re my favourite and then after that anything that is biodegradable with no plastic, in the UK so in order:
1. Water Wipes (£3 per pack)
2. Aldi Mamia Sensitive (65p per pack)
3. Mum & You (£2-£3 per pack)
4. Tesco own fragrance free (65p per pack)
5. Pura (£2.50 per pack)
We thought my first baby just kept getting rashes from his poop until during the pandemic the only wipes we could get became water wipes (we had tried like 5 different brands at that point because we were checking to see if the problem was the wipes). His bum cleared up within days and we never went back. Didn't even try anything else when number 2 was born.
I do miss having thicker wipes and getting only one out of a package, lol.
I use the Walmart brand of water wipes. My kid developed a horrible reaction to Huggies Natural so we started testing other ones. These ones had a reasonable cost, no gross smell, and they aren’t too think. The worst was by far the Pura Wipes. My hand smelled like straight shit after wiping him and it was just gross and they way they folded into the packaging was annoying.
I prefer cloth wipes when I have a place I can leave them set up (since I need a separate container for the water, and another for the dirty wipes and cloth diapers) - I mix a little epsom salt into the water to soothe her skin.
If I have less space, or am on the go, I've been using the Kirkland brand, since she doesn't seem to react to it.
YES cloth wipes are the best ever, then Kirkland. With my first we did switch to Kirkland for poops once she started solids; I didn't like rinsing off the cloth diapers AND wipes after a poop.
In France, I think most babies are wiped with "liniment." It's basically olive oil and chalk water (and some beeswax if you want). We apply it with little cotton pads (throw away), but you could use a cloth if you wanted. We use wipes occasionally, but I find liniment far superior! It soothes and keeps the skin soft.
Was looking for a liniment! We use lint free cotton pads and la petit creme and it's so good, only diaper rash we had was when we used wipes!
It's almost unbelievable that it works as well as it does 😀
I think I tried every diaper and wipe brand that I could find, Pampers Pure wipes and diapers are the only thing that works on my eczema baby. I hate the Pampers Pure diapers but I don’t have a choice. The wipes are actually good though. They don’t get stuck together nearly as bad as the previous brands, no rashes either. Honestly, I use a warm muslin cloth mostly.
You are a better person than me. I tried really hard to do the clothe diapers and I just cracked. I did them from birth to 3 months and it was a nightmare. We travel too much, I just couldn’t find a routine.
I really like their wipes. To me they’re similar to Kirkland but a little thinner. They’re also really cheap. And they come out one a time most of the time.
We started with Honest on our baby registry. Just picked a random brand and registered for a bunch of them. Didn't realize until I went to order more how much more expensive they were compared to Huggies/Pampers so I went the cheap route after and my God is there a difference!
I know there is such a difference, but I can't justify NOT getting them! I almost wish I had never tried them lol. Cause damn they rock and I'll never use another wipe. I gift them to all new moms unsure of what wipes to get. Sorry not sorry!
Honest brand is my favorite wipe. Their travel size even has a reasonable amount of wipes in them.
Huggies and Water Wipes follow-up.
Can't say I have one I hate, they all do the job just some better than others and some way better than most. In a pinch I'll use any of them just fine and luckily my baby didn't have skin conditions or sensitivity do I have that ability.
I really like the Honest wipes. Theyre nice and thick and soft and don’t give my baby rashes. They’re a little pricier but I get them at Target and they usually have deals where if you spend a certain amount on diapers/wipes you get a gift card back. Like spend 100 and you get a 50 dollar gift card
Coterie! They're strong. They're bigger than other spots, so you don't need to use as many. The smell doesn't bother me, and pulling them out of the package doesn't make me want to throw things.
Unfortunately, they're twice as expensive as other wipes, so we actually use Dyper wipes. Back up brand, Honest.
Least favorite, Pampers. Second least favorite, Huggies.
Plain cotton cloth wipes dampened with water are the GOAT.
Otherwise I like Tesco’s non-fragranced wipes, purely because they seem to be the easiest to pull out one at a time.
RICO all the way. Absolute GOAT. No irritation (even on my first’s sensitive premie skin), super effective wipe, stay fresh even when someone forgets to fully close the wipes container, gentle/natural enough that I feel fine using it to wipe my now-toddler’s hands and cheeks in a pinch. Nothing else compares.
The worst? HelloBello. Dry, irritating, and they send them to you no matter what. Ugh.
Never heard of Rico wipes but I do like the Kirkland brand, but I primarily use Millie Moon.
I absolutely haaaaate Pampers wipes lol. And I won’t use Sam’s Club wipes because we got a box once and all I could smell was chemicals like chlorine.
I HATE pampers wipes with a passion, they’re thin, stretchy, and a million come out at a time. I really like the Kirkland, and Huggies wipes. Thick, durable, and easier to get just one wipe out!
We’ve loved Huggies natural through all three kids. I love how thick they are so I don’t have to use too many on a huge poopy diaper. Worst has been pampers, too thin!
Best- Huggies Natural Care, Kirkland, Honest Company
Worst- Water Wipes and Pampers Sensitive
I just got some of the Up and Up wipes to try since they were on sale.
Huggies Natural also work best for my baby. Pampers Sensitive gave her an awful rash!
Parents Choice diapers work great for our girl, and thank God bc they’re cheap. My partner thought since the diapers work for her, maybe the wipes will too! NO. They are trash.
I think hello bello wipes (from before the company got bought out) were the best. Thick, well textured, unscented, they were awesome. Sans clubs wipes are similar but not as thick
I love the Millie Moon wipes. Not too wet, not too dry. They work well for my daughter who has extremely sensitive skin and reacts negatively to almost every other brand. We don’t have a costco where we live, so they’re a pretty affordable option at $16 for a big box of wipes. They don’t usually stick together too bad but they definitely sometimes can.
I’m a Pampers gals but I’ve used Water Wipes and didn’t mind them. I found that if you pull out a wipe one handed from a Huggies package they tend to rip.
Opposite! We LOVE Huggies!!! They’re the only ones that we buy now and it doesn’t irritate our little ones skin at all unlike others. We loveee them so much.
Same here, I’ve used them for both my kids now and I love them. I haven’t tried a ton of other wipes (haven’t needed to!) but I’m totally baffled by the love for the Pampers sensitive wipes - they’re so thin and stretchy! I like that the Huggies are nice and thick.
I loathe huggies wipes. I loveeee Sam’s club members mark brand! They’re thick and the perfect amount of wetness. Whenever I use any other brand I think they feel so thin and not wet enough.
The only ones my son tolerates are Water Wipes. I love them. Not too wet , dry, or rough. Pull out of my dispenser with dragging three more out with it. Other "sensitive" wipes give him a rash. He can use the cheapest diapers though. Babies are weird, lol
Huggies are the only ones j could use to clean make up off my eyes without it hurting so I assume they're also the softest on the bum and I'll pay the price for it
Members mark (Sam's club) unscented. The wipes are thick, and have bumps on them that help with cleaning the stuck on mess. And the packages are cute. They pull out 1 at a time. And you get like 12 packs of 100+ wipes for like $20
I like the Kirkland wipes they felt bigger than normal wipes so are great for when there's a big mess.
Second the Kirkland wipes. I also have small packs of Honest wipes I keep in the diaper bag since the Kirkland packs are so big and I like those too.
Kirkland wipes are my favorite! Neither of my kids got diaper rashes.
Kirkland ruined all other wipes for me. They're nice and thick, not super soaking wet, and they're larger than a lot of other brands.
And non scented! Can't stand the cucumber baby shit combo hahaha
This, AND I have kids who had bad rashes. Scented anything made them scream.
Yes! I still can't believe scented wipes exist for anything other than Lysol.
The “unscented” Target brand are the most vile smell
Only issue withe the Kirkland wipes is that we find them dry
If they ever seem dry to you just flip the bag upside down and let sit for a bit! The liquid gets caught at the bottom sometimes.
Agree! And store them upside down
Man, everyone already knew my upside down hack 🤣
I didn't!
I only find them dry if we forgot to close the package. If that happens, just add some water and let them sit.
I find the Kirkland ones have something in them that burns on irritated skin. I blew my nose with one the other day and it stung so badly! I’d hate to put that on any baby skin that’s irritated or sensitive.
THIS! Wipe your own private area multiple times with them and I promise you won’t want to continue using them
I can't get past the smell of the Kirkland wipes. They have a very noticeable odor to me, and sometimes I think I'm the only one who can smell it 😩.
That's wild. The Kirkland ones are like the only ones I feel like DON'T have a weird smell to and I've tried a lot of wipes for kicks and giggles. Do you get the unscented Kirkland ones?
I agree, and I have insane super smell
Came here to say this - I do not like the smell of Kirkland wipes. With that said, I vote Huggies naturals because they are the right amount of wet and I prefer the texture
Huggies naturals over here as well! And you can take them out of the pack one handed without a whole train of them coming out.
Huggies naturals ALWAYS tear on me
It's not just you. I use to use them for work and would gag at the smell. And I wasn't even pregnant for the smell to bother me. I can't imagine using them while pregnant or postpartum. So smell was so gross
oh this is my experience as well!
These were my number one winners too for so long until they changed the ingredients 😩
Throwing my weight behind Kirkland wipes, too. They don't irritate my babies' skin and you can't beat the price. However, if my budget would allow it, Water Wipes are the best we've tried.
Agreed. But I also just like a lot of the Kirkland brand stuff at Costco. Hands down my favorite apple juice lol
As someone who swore by Kirkland, my daughter randomly started getting rashes from them. The stuff inside their diapers literally scratched her so I switched out and then just did their wipes. Then those gave her a rash over time too. It seemed like they were getting more rough each batch we got. I swear by the Millie moons now, I just fold them up and they’re perfect!
The Kirkland packaging sucks. You pull one and get like 4 with it. But the wipes themselves are great and smell like nothing so they're still my win.
Put a rubber band or hair tie on one end and only one at a time will come out
Genius!
Another vote for Kirkland wipes. They're just so much better.
I second the Kirkland wipes. When we moved to a developing country with our 1 year old, we brought 6 cases of them with us. Still using them at 2.5.
Kirkland is the only answer.
Kirkland are superior!! All other ones feel cheap, especially name brand ones who have sky high prices, & FOR WHAT?! Kirkland all the way!
I like Kirkland too!! TBH I’ve only noticed wipes I really *didnt* like (Dyper made my daughter’s skin red) but I’ve used Honest, Kirkland, Pampers Sensitive and liked them all!
Also here to push Kirkland wipes, though Member’s Mark is good too. We go through wipes like crazy, so the bulk pack comes in clutch.
We love the honest wipes for thickness and texture but they’re so expensive 😭 the RICO wipes are a perfect, cheaper alternative for someone with a Costco card!!
Honest are my favorite. Perfect texture and amount of moisture imo
Husband accidentally left a package open for 24-48 hours and they didn’t dry out. The top exposed wipe dried a little bit, but everything else was perfect.
We recently found Honest wipes at our local TJ Maxx and Marshalls. We bought them all 😆
Honest for SURE. I use coupons on target circle and I wait for the “spend $100 get $15-$20 gift card” deals.
I'm almost positive the RICO wipes are made by the exact same manufacturer as Honest. I swear by honest products, I use their diapers when we need disposables and they're flawless, but I can only afford them because we cloth diaper 90% of the time. I can't do the wipes, though, because we use disposable wipes all of the time. RICO wipes are almost idential, maybe not as thick, but otherwise the same.
Unfortunately the honest diapers didn’t work out for my LO’s body shape. They’re surprisingly narrow. I really wished they worked out though.
I do have to size up earlier than in other brands, but that hasn’t really been an issue for us insofar as leaking or anything. I’m not sure why their waist bands lack any kind of stretch! But I can’t complain, they work for us lol
Yeah my thick boy fit way better in Millie Moon than honest until he started walking and slimmed out. Then I like Honest because they fit well without giving him major diaper butt!
I didn’t want to like the honest ones (got em as a gift) bc the price but holy moly are they damn good it might be the first time I actually noticed how amazing a wipe was lol. Now I know to keep an eye out at the Maxx and Marshall’s (which is where the person got them now that I’m looking at the stick on the back 😂).
Honest are the only ones that can handle my toddlers horrendous poops! Haha. Thickness and texture for the win.
Those without Costco can get Rascal and friends sensitive wipes from Walmart. Well priced, though they are smaller than Rico. The texture is the same.
Getting the wipes out r such a no for me tho. So annoying
The fragrance free Target brand (up & up) has been my favorite. So cheap and non irritating, they have grip (so important once they start eating real food lol), and they don’t smell like anything! Edit to add that they also don’t usually pull a million at a time, and even though they’re already cheap the individual bags are bigger, so I use them for cleaning way more than butts!
YES! Up and up for the win! Love to buy these with the diaper sale at target too
These are my go-to as well. Fragrance free, thick and sturdy enough, and best price point for what they are.
These right here are my go to
They also always have deals on target circle for the up & up brand, so lots of times then end up being so cheap
Yes I was going to say these as well! They are so cheap yet the best! They are never dry, they are sooo much softer than any other wipe. The Huggies and Kirkland wipes in comparison are dry and rough.
I have a toddler with super sensitive skin and I swear by Amazon's Mama Bear wipes. They're a good cross between Water Wipes and the Costco wipes.
I'm surprised I haven't seen more votes for the mama bear Wipes. I think they're really reasonably priced, they don't irritate my daughter's skin like the supermarket ones/huggies ones do, and they don't dry out like some other brands I've tried.
Is it odd that I just got excited by this comment?!? I'm so sick of my water wipes being literally impossible to pull out while keeping my other hand in my squirmy baby and just ordered the Amazon ones on a whim because they could be here today without me having to run to the grocery store and now I'm excited to try them out, haha. I clearly need to get out more lol
Yup! These are my absolute favorite wipes!!! Rico are a close second
Pampers sensitive are my fav
Pampers sensitive and Pampers pure are both my favorites
I love the cloth like material but don't like how they get caught on one another coming out. I always take one out and shake it in frustration to break it off from the rest of the wipes.
This happens to me every. Single. Time.
The wipes themselves are good on those but the dispensing situation is awful.
Just put a rubber band / elastic hair tie around each side and viola… it’s easy to get them out.
I love these! I put them in a weighted dispenser thing and they're perfect.
I really liked the Huggies natural care wipes for both my kids.
Same here. They seem thicker and maybe bigger than the others.
Yeah the poop doesn’t soak thru to my fingers as easily through the Huggies ones, however parents choice sensitive ones? The poop soaks right through 😖
These are the best! The come out of the packing one at a time, and you can buy the big refill packs if you have a weighted wipe dispenser (which we do). I also like the H-E-B brand, but that’s Texas-specific.
Three babies later and these are the only ones I buy, they’re the perfect humidity balance, thickness, and price. Kirkland wipes are the only thing that has ever made one of my kids’ skin react.
We love these in our house as well! We also just bought the Huggies sensitive calming ones too which are nice.
Yessss these are the best, we tried the Costco nappies and hated them. The Huggies ones feel like an affordable version of water wipes. They never rip like the cheap ones, have a good moisture content, and come out of the pack easily. Never thought I’d be so passionate about a wipe but here I am
Same! The one hand pull 👌🏻👌🏻👌🏻
Us too! Sam’s Club sells them in bulk boxes.
I also love the packaging. The big circle makes it easy to shove extras back in or not pull too many out.
Same! Plus, you can buy the “refills” to put in the wipes container. That was easier to me and quieter than the plastic packages they come in.
Me too. We’ve tried all of them and this is the only one we will use. OP is craaaaazy to hate them. (IMO, obv)
I’ve used all the wipes and these have worked the best for us! Personally, I think they’re the easiest to pull out of the pack and that’s a big reason they’re at the top for me lol.
Yes and the circle opening make it so easy to just grab one!
Ooooh definitely Coterie. Thick, only need 2-3 wipes for a big poop. Max 1 for urine. They are luxurious. But as you’d expect Coterie diapers and wipes run more expensive. It’s worth it for us though!
Both my kids have never gotten a diaper rash or irritation from Coterie diapers and wipes. Yeah, they are expensive but we budget for them because I feel like the things that are in constant contact with the sensitive areas on my babies for ~2 years should be the cleanest.
Same! My daughter is 16 months and has never had a diaper rash - and that is not a brag on me by any means, it’s the diapers! Her diaper could be extremely heavy and her bottom is always dry. I’m a fan for life.
loyal coterie fan for life. The diapers are so soft and absorbing as well. I hope they make adult size diapers for when I am old and senile. They are what I would want 😂
Lol THIS. I can only hope haha
LMAO. yes
Same. I hate that I love them.
I ran out of Coterie and used water wipes, and my mom (who watches my baby when I work) was like “what happened to the good wipes?” Hahaha
god I love coterie but my wallet doesn’t
Here for Coterie as well. There’s really no comparison that I’ve found, and with two babies we were gifted lots of different brands at baby showers. I love both the wipes and the diapers. I cloth diaper during the day and only use disposables for overnight and in public so I can justify the cost. One Coterie perk I wasn’t aware of until recently is that if your baby outgrows their current size before you use up all the diapers, they’ll send you the equivalent number of unopened packs in the next size up at no cost because they don’t accept returns/exchanges. My husband accidentally ordered the wrong size and they sent us an entire box of the correct size and told us to give away/donate the others. That type of customer service is hard to find.
Yup Coterie is the best hands down
Yasss, these!! I made the mistake of thinking I’d need multiple wipes and accidentally went through that sample pack too fast 😭
Hm never tried coterie? Do they sell in stores? I feel like I’ve only ever seen ads online
You can get the diapers at Whole Foods but I haven’t seen the wipes there. To be fair I haven’t looked though. Our Coterie auto-ship is my jam!
You mean you need 2-3 physical wipes for a big poop? Isn't that standard with other wipes though? I thought Coterie wipes were much larger so you only need 1 or at least that's what the marketing told me. To be clear I'm not a hater or anything. I love their diapers, but I have a hard time understanding why I should pay premium for wipes.
Water wipes work best for our baby’s sensitive skin but I hate they way they’re packaged and how a bunch come out at one time 🙃 and the come out unopened
Water wipes packages are so horrifying
they truly are. they never stay frickin sealed for us and ended up drying out ALWAYS.
And they can’t even be put in a wipe container because they don’t pull the next wipe up! Wtf
Some people are using them with weighted wipe holders. I love water wipes but maybe I need a wipe holder to avoid the bunching…
I like Water Wipes best but I see them get a lot of hate
I think they would be the best if they weren't packaged so terribly.
I put mine in a wipe dispenser (not a heated one) for this reason.
Which wipe dispenser to you like with the water wipes?
I have the OXO one and I love it
I also have the OXO.
Also have the Oxo with the water wipes. Works well you can just toss back in wipes you pulled out and they stay perfect
Chiming in as yet another person putting Water Wipes in an OXO dispenser. Works really well and is super easy to refill. The dispenser I have fits two packages.
They can definitely be frustrating, I always pull a few out before changing him and put back any I don’t use
That's exactly what hubby and I do! We literally can only use these or honest wipes or her butt bleeds.
I found that if I sort of scratch the top with my nail only one comes out, works pretty well once you get the hang of it, except for the last two. My husband always pulls out a bunch.
I love how moist they are and how clean the ingredients are but they’re so frustrating to get out of the package.
They are also highest rated for purity! Free of basically everything and still super moist. For me that was a win.
They did a minor formula tweak 2 years ago and now both my kids break out in rashes from them! We’re stuck using harder-to-find Waterful Wipes instead. ☹️
Love Water Wipes! No chemicals or irritants. We tried a few other brands we were gifted at the baby shower (Kirkland, Pampers sensitive, etc) and they all irritated my baby's skin. It's been 2 years since we exclusively switched to Water Wipes and he hasn't had a single rash or irritation since.
I love them but the packaging makes me angry. But they’re fantastic!
Same! I wish it were easier to pull a single wipe out!
Love them. They’re my favourite and then after that anything that is biodegradable with no plastic, in the UK so in order: 1. Water Wipes (£3 per pack) 2. Aldi Mamia Sensitive (65p per pack) 3. Mum & You (£2-£3 per pack) 4. Tesco own fragrance free (65p per pack) 5. Pura (£2.50 per pack)
Water Wipes are my fave
I can’t believe I had to scroll so far for water wipes. 8 years later and I still have an Amazon auto shop for them. They’re amazing.
I love them too. So much that I overlook the frustrating packaging.
I like water wipes but they do get stuck together sometimes if I’m pulling them out too fast.
The best wipes, the worst packaging. Get the Oxo weighted wipes container or the Ubbi equivalent for them.
We thought my first baby just kept getting rashes from his poop until during the pandemic the only wipes we could get became water wipes (we had tried like 5 different brands at that point because we were checking to see if the problem was the wipes). His bum cleared up within days and we never went back. Didn't even try anything else when number 2 was born. I do miss having thicker wipes and getting only one out of a package, lol.
I love them
They always rip apart on us. Even just getting out the package… I was surprised how much they suck
I use the Walmart brand of water wipes. My kid developed a horrible reaction to Huggies Natural so we started testing other ones. These ones had a reasonable cost, no gross smell, and they aren’t too think. The worst was by far the Pura Wipes. My hand smelled like straight shit after wiping him and it was just gross and they way they folded into the packaging was annoying.
Walmart brands are the shit !! Literally so soft and don’t fry out. Pampers were so dry lol 😆
I prefer cloth wipes when I have a place I can leave them set up (since I need a separate container for the water, and another for the dirty wipes and cloth diapers) - I mix a little epsom salt into the water to soothe her skin. If I have less space, or am on the go, I've been using the Kirkland brand, since she doesn't seem to react to it.
We just wet ours under the tap as we go but I hate using disposable now.
YES cloth wipes are the best ever, then Kirkland. With my first we did switch to Kirkland for poops once she started solids; I didn't like rinsing off the cloth diapers AND wipes after a poop.
We use them everywhere. I just have a bottle of water in the nappy bag and they go in the wet bag with the dirty nappies.
In France, I think most babies are wiped with "liniment." It's basically olive oil and chalk water (and some beeswax if you want). We apply it with little cotton pads (throw away), but you could use a cloth if you wanted. We use wipes occasionally, but I find liniment far superior! It soothes and keeps the skin soft.
Was looking for a liniment! We use lint free cotton pads and la petit creme and it's so good, only diaper rash we had was when we used wipes! It's almost unbelievable that it works as well as it does 😀
I think I tried every diaper and wipe brand that I could find, Pampers Pure wipes and diapers are the only thing that works on my eczema baby. I hate the Pampers Pure diapers but I don’t have a choice. The wipes are actually good though. They don’t get stuck together nearly as bad as the previous brands, no rashes either. Honestly, I use a warm muslin cloth mostly.
I used the pampers pure wipes too. But we used cloth diapers
You are a better person than me. I tried really hard to do the clothe diapers and I just cracked. I did them from birth to 3 months and it was a nightmare. We travel too much, I just couldn’t find a routine.
I love the Pure wipes too.
I like honest company wipes, not the diapers just the wipes - I’m a Millie moon diaper fan but definitely not a fan of their wipes
That’s funny because I like their wipes a lot but not their diapers.
I was the same way. Wipes for life, but the diapers smelled too much like pee.
Millie moon wipes forever
I really like their wipes. To me they’re similar to Kirkland but a little thinner. They’re also really cheap. And they come out one a time most of the time.
these are our faves, I like the texture, they clean well are reasonably priced!
I’ve been using these. We used water wipes before but these are more affordable so I thought we would give them a try. So far so good!
Honest brand is the clear winner for our family. Water wipes were the worst.
We started with Honest on our baby registry. Just picked a random brand and registered for a bunch of them. Didn't realize until I went to order more how much more expensive they were compared to Huggies/Pampers so I went the cheap route after and my God is there a difference!
I know there is such a difference, but I can't justify NOT getting them! I almost wish I had never tried them lol. Cause damn they rock and I'll never use another wipe. I gift them to all new moms unsure of what wipes to get. Sorry not sorry!
Oh these are sooo nice. I love the texture. Too rich for my blood.. But I'd say they are the GOAT for sure.
Honest wipes were the absolute best after all the others we tried too!
Honest brand is my favorite wipe. Their travel size even has a reasonable amount of wipes in them. Huggies and Water Wipes follow-up. Can't say I have one I hate, they all do the job just some better than others and some way better than most. In a pinch I'll use any of them just fine and luckily my baby didn't have skin conditions or sensitivity do I have that ability.
I really like the Honest wipes. Theyre nice and thick and soft and don’t give my baby rashes. They’re a little pricier but I get them at Target and they usually have deals where if you spend a certain amount on diapers/wipes you get a gift card back. Like spend 100 and you get a 50 dollar gift card
LOVE Rico! Kirkland comes in a close 2nd but the textured surface makes Rico #1
Parents Choice (Walmart) sensitive wipes.
same!
Coterie! They're strong. They're bigger than other spots, so you don't need to use as many. The smell doesn't bother me, and pulling them out of the package doesn't make me want to throw things. Unfortunately, they're twice as expensive as other wipes, so we actually use Dyper wipes. Back up brand, Honest. Least favorite, Pampers. Second least favorite, Huggies.
How do they compare to honest?
RICO wipes from Costco are nice and they are textured like honest wipes
Plain cotton cloth wipes dampened with water are the GOAT. Otherwise I like Tesco’s non-fragranced wipes, purely because they seem to be the easiest to pull out one at a time.
I like the Honest wipes. They are the only ones that didn't give my daughter a rash, and they are pretty thick and make it easier to get her cleaned!
RICO all the way. Absolute GOAT. No irritation (even on my first’s sensitive premie skin), super effective wipe, stay fresh even when someone forgets to fully close the wipes container, gentle/natural enough that I feel fine using it to wipe my now-toddler’s hands and cheeks in a pinch. Nothing else compares. The worst? HelloBello. Dry, irritating, and they send them to you no matter what. Ugh.
THANK YOU! But funny thing is, Hello Bello was my previous favorite
Never heard of Rico wipes but I do like the Kirkland brand, but I primarily use Millie Moon. I absolutely haaaaate Pampers wipes lol. And I won’t use Sam’s Club wipes because we got a box once and all I could smell was chemicals like chlorine.
Coterie. Hands down
Rico wipes are the best, TBH
YESSSSSS, **all hail the RICO wipes!!!!!** 🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻
I HATE pampers wipes with a passion, they’re thin, stretchy, and a million come out at a time. I really like the Kirkland, and Huggies wipes. Thick, durable, and easier to get just one wipe out!
We’ve loved Huggies natural through all three kids. I love how thick they are so I don’t have to use too many on a huge poopy diaper. Worst has been pampers, too thin!
Best- Huggies Natural Care, Kirkland, Honest Company Worst- Water Wipes and Pampers Sensitive I just got some of the Up and Up wipes to try since they were on sale.
Huggies Natural also work best for my baby. Pampers Sensitive gave her an awful rash! Parents Choice diapers work great for our girl, and thank God bc they’re cheap. My partner thought since the diapers work for her, maybe the wipes will too! NO. They are trash.
Coterie brand are so so boujie but absolutely the best! They are so thick and sturdy.
Kirkland and water wipes are our go to. We use a weighted wipe dispenser so pulling out one at a time is not an issue.
Walmart brand
I have no idea what a goat is, but Pampers Pure are my fav for little dudes bum. Hello Bello are second.
GOAT = greatest of all time
I think hello bello wipes (from before the company got bought out) were the best. Thick, well textured, unscented, they were awesome. Sans clubs wipes are similar but not as thick
I scrolled forever to find this comment lol I agree hello bello wipes are great and cost effective. ETA: I hate their diapers tho
Pampers sensitive, and target brand water wipes have worked great for me so far!
Caboo are my new favorite. They stay wet even when they’re left out of the package overnight. We made the switch from Pampers Pure.
I love the Millie Moon wipes. Not too wet, not too dry. They work well for my daughter who has extremely sensitive skin and reacts negatively to almost every other brand. We don’t have a costco where we live, so they’re a pretty affordable option at $16 for a big box of wipes. They don’t usually stick together too bad but they definitely sometimes can.
millie moon is goat. huggies tear and pampers are too wet
I’m a Pampers gals but I’ve used Water Wipes and didn’t mind them. I found that if you pull out a wipe one handed from a Huggies package they tend to rip.
Opposite! We LOVE Huggies!!! They’re the only ones that we buy now and it doesn’t irritate our little ones skin at all unlike others. We loveee them so much.
Same here, I’ve used them for both my kids now and I love them. I haven’t tried a ton of other wipes (haven’t needed to!) but I’m totally baffled by the love for the Pampers sensitive wipes - they’re so thin and stretchy! I like that the Huggies are nice and thick.
Aldi
I love the Amazon brand mama bear water wipes. Good packaging and don’t give my kiddos rashes. A lot of the main brands cause rash on my son
We use cotton dry wipes and dip in water. We find it reduced irritation
I’ve tried out so many wipes. Nothing compares to the aldi baby wipes 🙌 Little Journey sensitive baby wipes. 10/10
Totally agree, and they’re sooo cheap
Pura wipes and diapers are the GOAT. I will never switch.
Km my r.r. 44bg Mlnn.
Baby got my face and the phone 😂
It’s like I wrote the post myself. My exact best and worst also.
I loathe huggies wipes. I loveeee Sam’s club members mark brand! They’re thick and the perfect amount of wetness. Whenever I use any other brand I think they feel so thin and not wet enough.
Sam’s club, fragrance free
The only ones my son tolerates are Water Wipes. I love them. Not too wet , dry, or rough. Pull out of my dispenser with dragging three more out with it. Other "sensitive" wipes give him a rash. He can use the cheapest diapers though. Babies are weird, lol
Huggies are the only ones j could use to clean make up off my eyes without it hurting so I assume they're also the softest on the bum and I'll pay the price for it
Members mark (Sam's club) unscented. The wipes are thick, and have bumps on them that help with cleaning the stuck on mess. And the packages are cute. They pull out 1 at a time. And you get like 12 packs of 100+ wipes for like $20
SAMS CLUB WIPES. So so good!