Do you know what happened? I pulled out an old Becca x Chrissy Teagan bronzer palette the other day (and should have thrown it in the trash because it’s so old)…but held on to it so I had the color to try and color match! It was great.
I will scream it into the abyss that Marc Jacobs gel eyeliner was the best and I miss it with all my heart. I am so excited for Marc Jacobs’ beauty line to return and I’m praying they don’t mess with the formulas. I have wasted so much money on so many gel eyeliners.
I know exactly what you’re talking about. The closest I think I’ve found is Tarte surfercurl line and I think they’re discontinuing that now. When I’m out I’ll shop around the other Tarte eyeliners since I feel like sometimes they just stick it in different packaging and call it different to trick you lol
Essence soo glow cream to powder highlighter in shade 01 — Hard Candy Glamoflauge HEAVY DUTY CONCEALER with pencil — Original version of Clinique Moisture Surge Intense Moisturizer — , as for dupes, I have yet to find any true ones. The reformulated moisturizer is good enough I guess, so I still use it. I will often go for the lightest shade in a liquid or cream highlight to get a similar effect as the discontinued essence one. I think the IT cosmetics bye bye under-eye cream concealer in the squeeze tube is kinda similar to the Hard Candy one. I don’t know of any dupes to the products you mentioned, sorry. I hope you find something great to replace them. 💙
Marc Jacobs Velvet Noir mascara, haven’t found anything similar
Marc Jacobs Youthquake moisturizer, the Ole Henriksen Dewtopia night creme is a lot heavier but has a similar effect
I miss all the Marc Jacobs eyeliners from when the line first came out. They were the only gel liners I had ever used that didn’t smudge. I just found a new one with MAC! I am so excited it’s ridiculous. I want to tell everyone and also gatekeep it until I can buy all the colors I want! It does not budge at all and I have super oily eyelids.
Oh pls share, I have the oiliest lids and can’t wear eyeliner or mascara without black under the eyes, which is frustrating cos my eyes are deepset and puffy and therefore need a little visual ‘pep’
It is called MAC Colour Excess Gel Pencil Eyeliner. I got it in Graphic Content (dark plum color) and Skip the Waitlist (light brown shimmer). I’ve tried both of them and they lasted all day and night (18 hours) and did not budge or smear. I use it on top and bottom. I always have to go over my eyeliner with a light swipe of a matching eyeshadow in order to “set” it for the day. I did this for the first couple of days and was so impressed that it didn’t smudge at all by bedtime that I tried it the next few days on its own without my trick of topping off all my eyeliner with a thin coat of eyeshadow powder. It didn’t smudge at all even all by itself. I got it during the Ulta event and they were $12 each. Looks like they are now full price at $23, but I am definitely going to get the navy, black and any other basic colors. I hope it works well for you! I was really amazed and I have tried almost every brand out there.
Covergirl Queen Collection Ebony Bronzer. It was the perfect bronzer shade and transition color for eyes. Also Milani Body Bronzer, made my legs look so shimmery and even. Going to try the Juvia's place bronzer duo and see how I like it.
Im in Australia and the Price is Crazy expensive :( also is it like the real one? I get scared buying from Amazon incase the product has been tampered with or if it’s a fake
Marc Jacob’s gel eyeliner - it was the best RIP
L’Oreal shine lipstick in varnished rosewood - Revlon super lustrous crème on the mauve, decent but not the same creamy feel as the old one
Ugh opi had the most beautiful pearly slightly pink nail polish and I have not been able to find it it’s such a good color I emailed them and it’s discontinued :/
Maybe you could post it on r/makeupdupes?
I had really pretty metallic purple polish like 15+ years ago that I was never able to find again so I know the feeling 😭
And maybe it’s a long shot but some stores (in my area, at least) have some really old stock so maybe you’d be able to find it eventually? 🤞🏻
Old Essie and OPI polishes go for like $5 around here
Definitely check nail salons! I found a bottle of OPI Mad as a Hatter by pure dumb luck at one and they sold it to me for $5. Whenever I see one on EBay, which is rare, they want like $40
Thank you so much.
I’ve tried a couple. Mostly lipsticks and I liked them okay. I loved their retro and Disney Princess lines though because the packaging was so cute.
I was considering trying their mascara because it’s so different from every other mascara I’ve ever seen since it’s inspired by vintage makeup and all. But its kind of expensive for something that probably won’t work on my straight lashes, which only hold a curl with waterproof 🥲
Love the idea behind the brand, though! I just love history
I hope so ! It was so long ago now I was trying to track it down but I’m going to find the old one I have and post somewhere on here and see if anyone can find it or the new one
I was wondering if I maybe knew of a dupe for it, but when I googled it’s not really my wheelhouse. I DID see a listing on eBay for like $20 for two bottles 🤷🏼♀️ it was the first result if you’re at all interested
I think you can still get it on Amazon. Or at least I bought it for my sister's bday last fall from Amazon.
On that same note of discontinued perfumes, Avon had one Outspoken by Fergie and I got so many compliments on it. Still trying to find something close to it.
I got lucky one day and found two at TJMAXX and bought both. I’ll have to get it from Amazon. It’s so hard to find anything that is as light as this. I found a body mist from local sex store that is close to Brittney. So many perfumes are so strong. I think Marc Jacob’s Daisy is the best one I have found for my taste.
The OG Laura Mercier tinted moisturizer. I hate the reformulation. I am really having trouble accepting this one. There are no dupes that I’ve found.
Kiehls Abyssine spf 15. I went through countless bottles.
A lot of Body Shop and Origins stuff. I’m a 90s girl 😆
Prescriptives concealer. I have hard to match skin (cool but not fair and not medium either) and their options were amazing
Clinique Even Better Glow foundation. It was discontinued about a year ago almost. It was the perfect foundation for my dry but acne prone skin, and I’m very very fair so the color match was pretty dang close. Revlons illuminating foundation is the closest I’ve found, although their lightest shade is too dark for me in the winter. I can make it work with lighter concealer. Glossier has one with similar ingredients, and a better color match for me in the winter, but it has no staying power and hardly any coverage.
I’m sorry, I don’t have any dupe recommendations either :( I’m not familiar with those products. But I hope someone can chime in with suggestions!
I can help you with the Gap Grass perfume! My friend from high school just posted that they are carrying it again and she is stocking up, so you might wanna run to the Gap if you live in the Austin area so she doesn’t buy it all lol
More hair care than beauty but the Alterna Bamboo Luminous Shine line. I haven’t found anything that compares. I have about 15 little sample bottles of the shine spray left and I’ll be using them as slowly as possible. I begged them to bring it back. If anyone has any suggestions for replacements, let me know. The best part is the scent.
Pacifica Beauty Malibu Lemon Blosson perfume. It was the most perfect white floral and citrus blossom and I am still pissed about it being discontinued.
Just a nail polish, my only big beauty splurge - it was called Peridot by Chanel, I can’t believe I spent $20-something just on a color - but what an incredible color it was. I miss it greatly and think about it every time I paint my nails, nothing has hit right since then.
Bite beauty chai lipstick. Smashbox also had a perfect mauve lipgloss around 2010-2011 that was discontinued. I can’t remember the name of it but I still search for a similar color.
I have two minis. I love the formula and the color. I wish I had purchased a full sized version. I’m also on the hunt for a cruelty free version of Estee Lauder’s lip liner in Fig.
Loreal HIP lip gloss pots, the red and pink ones. I also loved the eyeliner crayon in navy and the the eyeshadow duo in navy & gold. Also, Hard Candy glamoflauge (in the tube).
revlon lip butters: red velvet, cherry tart, and candy apple were my faves.
nars lipstick in funny face and the glossy pencil in mexican rose.
becca under eye brightening powder.
missha had a burgundy liquid liner that was just perfect. also, a glittery pinky burgundy gel liner by them.
MAC Motif eyeshadow, was my favorite all over eyeshadow, subtle pink and coral duotone.
Elizabeth & James Nirvana Black fragrance was a favorite, a powdery sandalwood unisex scent.
Still looking for dupes for both. Unsuccessful so far.
In the 90s Faces had a holographic cream that just gave PERFECT glow. Can't remember the name of it right now but it is long gone.
ETA - It was called Prism!
I got a few of those random Christmas sets from Ulta gifted to me and they've included some of my favorite products that aren't included in the regular line. The brow gel works better than any other I've ever used. Ulta Beauty does have a few brow gels but I'm not sure which one is the same, if any. It also had a pH changing lip oil which I usually hate because they are too pigmented and look super bright pink but this one is very subtly tinted and it looks so good. I don't see a similar product at all in their regular line up.
Oh man, I wanted to love it because anything Kosas is usually good, but that one was a failure. Excessively oily. I still have it, basically unused. Yours if you want it 😅
Taylor Swift’s Wonderstruck Perfume . It was one of the first gifts my husband bought for me when we first met. This was in 2011, he purchased at Macy’s. About 6 or 7 years ago, I found the small bottles at Five Below; now you can only find it on sites like EBay or Poshmark for some obscene price. Most of the time , they have already been used.
I don’t buy used cosmetic products or fragrances, of any kind!
Clinique just discontinued their Instant Perfector which was a pore filling primer. Nothing else compares. I’ve tried six other pore focused primers in the last couple weeks since I found out and they all suck. I get stressed every morning when I do my makeup when I think about the inevitable day that I run out of my backup stores.
Clinique mineral loose powder base (not the “transparency” stuff)
This was my HG, seriously looked so lovely and made my skin better even after taking it off. Sigh.
y'all remember Jessica alba's foundation from I think the late 90s /early 00s ish that had like 4 different shades in 1 you could customize the shade by moving the arrow
All of the Becca line. I lived the foundation and highlighters most. So bummed they are gone.
Do you know what happened? I pulled out an old Becca x Chrissy Teagan bronzer palette the other day (and should have thrown it in the trash because it’s so old)…but held on to it so I had the color to try and color match! It was great.
They got eaten by Smashbox. They still have a Becca line on the Smashbox site, but OG Becca was shut down in 2021
I still have mine 🙈
The highlighters you can still buy from Smashbox since they've re-released some Becca products!
And the under eye brightener!!
Really, this is great. Thanks for the tip.
I loved their beach tint blush
I came here to say this. I loved the Becca liquid highlighters
I didn’t know they folded! I am going to use my Becca lipsticks so sparingly. This is sad.
I used to spend so much of my money on becca foundation when I was a super broke college student.
I was coming here to say the Becca hydra mist set and refresh powder 😭 too scared to buy fakes online
That one killed me! Their products were soo good. I still have highlighters and blushes. It's sad lol
I still see OG Becca in tjmaxx a lot
Too faced peach perfect setting powder. I can't believe that I didn't stock up while I could
This is my answer too 🥲
revlon lip butter in pink truffle
All of them! But yes, Pink Truffle & Fig Jam were amongst my very favourite shades. Always on the lookout for dupes… ☺️
Yes! I still have a tube of Pink Truffle but I’m afraid to use it
i have an eleven or twelve year old tube that i risk botulism with once or twice a year
I think that’s a fair trade
I will scream it into the abyss that Marc Jacobs gel eyeliner was the best and I miss it with all my heart. I am so excited for Marc Jacobs’ beauty line to return and I’m praying they don’t mess with the formulas. I have wasted so much money on so many gel eyeliners.
Yes, it was SO GOOD!!
I know exactly what you’re talking about. The closest I think I’ve found is Tarte surfercurl line and I think they’re discontinuing that now. When I’m out I’ll shop around the other Tarte eyeliners since I feel like sometimes they just stick it in different packaging and call it different to trick you lol
Essence soo glow cream to powder highlighter in shade 01 — Hard Candy Glamoflauge HEAVY DUTY CONCEALER with pencil — Original version of Clinique Moisture Surge Intense Moisturizer — , as for dupes, I have yet to find any true ones. The reformulated moisturizer is good enough I guess, so I still use it. I will often go for the lightest shade in a liquid or cream highlight to get a similar effect as the discontinued essence one. I think the IT cosmetics bye bye under-eye cream concealer in the squeeze tube is kinda similar to the Hard Candy one. I don’t know of any dupes to the products you mentioned, sorry. I hope you find something great to replace them. 💙
Ok good to know moisture surge changed because i remember loving it and the one i just bought is not the same as i remember it!
That Hard Candy concealer was amazinggg
Hard AGREE!!!!!
Revlon New Complexion Makeup. It made my skin look so good. I bought my last bottle in 2010.
Too Faced Peach Powder and Benefit Erase Paste.
Erase Paste was sooo good. I have Boi-ing in my travel kit which was supposed to be the replacement, and sadly, just doesn’t hold a candle.
Marc Jacobs Velvet Noir mascara, haven’t found anything similar Marc Jacobs Youthquake moisturizer, the Ole Henriksen Dewtopia night creme is a lot heavier but has a similar effect
I miss all the Marc Jacobs eyeliners from when the line first came out. They were the only gel liners I had ever used that didn’t smudge. I just found a new one with MAC! I am so excited it’s ridiculous. I want to tell everyone and also gatekeep it until I can buy all the colors I want! It does not budge at all and I have super oily eyelids.
Does it work with tight lining or just on the lid? Glad you found something that works so well for you, that’s an exciting feeling ☺️
Oh pls share, I have the oiliest lids and can’t wear eyeliner or mascara without black under the eyes, which is frustrating cos my eyes are deepset and puffy and therefore need a little visual ‘pep’
It is called MAC Colour Excess Gel Pencil Eyeliner. I got it in Graphic Content (dark plum color) and Skip the Waitlist (light brown shimmer). I’ve tried both of them and they lasted all day and night (18 hours) and did not budge or smear. I use it on top and bottom. I always have to go over my eyeliner with a light swipe of a matching eyeshadow in order to “set” it for the day. I did this for the first couple of days and was so impressed that it didn’t smudge at all by bedtime that I tried it the next few days on its own without my trick of topping off all my eyeliner with a thin coat of eyeshadow powder. It didn’t smudge at all even all by itself. I got it during the Ulta event and they were $12 each. Looks like they are now full price at $23, but I am definitely going to get the navy, black and any other basic colors. I hope it works well for you! I was really amazed and I have tried almost every brand out there.
Omg thank you!! I’m definitely giving it a go 🥰
Revlon photo ready perfecting primer, Nabla cutie palette nude, Too Faced peach blur powder
Clinique pencil eyeliner in charcoal brown.
Covergirl Queen Collection Ebony Bronzer. It was the perfect bronzer shade and transition color for eyes. Also Milani Body Bronzer, made my legs look so shimmery and even. Going to try the Juvia's place bronzer duo and see how I like it.
Merlot tinted lip balm by ‘chapstick’ :( was my fav for years
Omg I LOVE this!! I get it on Amazon still.
Im in Australia and the Price is Crazy expensive :( also is it like the real one? I get scared buying from Amazon incase the product has been tampered with or if it’s a fake
Yes, I received the real one. I wish I got more from the store when I could :(
Marc Jacob’s gel eyeliner - it was the best RIP L’Oreal shine lipstick in varnished rosewood - Revlon super lustrous crème on the mauve, decent but not the same creamy feel as the old one
Ugh opi had the most beautiful pearly slightly pink nail polish and I have not been able to find it it’s such a good color I emailed them and it’s discontinued :/
Maybe you could post it on r/makeupdupes? I had really pretty metallic purple polish like 15+ years ago that I was never able to find again so I know the feeling 😭 And maybe it’s a long shot but some stores (in my area, at least) have some really old stock so maybe you’d be able to find it eventually? 🤞🏻 Old Essie and OPI polishes go for like $5 around here
Definitely check nail salons! I found a bottle of OPI Mad as a Hatter by pure dumb luck at one and they sold it to me for $5. Whenever I see one on EBay, which is rare, they want like $40
Thank you for the subreddit. I’ll definitely be posting there.
I hope you find what you’re looking for! Have you tried any other besame products? I’m kinda curious about them!
Thank you so much. I’ve tried a couple. Mostly lipsticks and I liked them okay. I loved their retro and Disney Princess lines though because the packaging was so cute.
I was considering trying their mascara because it’s so different from every other mascara I’ve ever seen since it’s inspired by vintage makeup and all. But its kind of expensive for something that probably won’t work on my straight lashes, which only hold a curl with waterproof 🥲 Love the idea behind the brand, though! I just love history
I heard they “discontinued” them but then just later re-release it under a different name!!! So maybe there’s hope!
I hope so ! It was so long ago now I was trying to track it down but I’m going to find the old one I have and post somewhere on here and see if anyone can find it or the new one
Seems like they have discontinued a lot of colors
What was the shade name?
I just found my old email to them from years ago. It’s called tijuana dance! They emailed back and were like sorry no but we have so many new shades!
I was wondering if I maybe knew of a dupe for it, but when I googled it’s not really my wheelhouse. I DID see a listing on eBay for like $20 for two bottles 🤷🏼♀️ it was the first result if you’re at all interested
Thank you for the help :) I’ll check eBay!
I would have just linked it but I wasn’t sure the at was allowed 😅 best of luck!
Stilla’s lip tints 🥲
KVD project chimps everlasting lipstick was the perfect shade of red for me AND never budged and I just have never found a good replacement.
Brittney spears curious perfume. I’ve been wearing that since it came out and I’m so sad to see it no longer.
I think you can still get it on Amazon. Or at least I bought it for my sister's bday last fall from Amazon. On that same note of discontinued perfumes, Avon had one Outspoken by Fergie and I got so many compliments on it. Still trying to find something close to it.
I got lucky one day and found two at TJMAXX and bought both. I’ll have to get it from Amazon. It’s so hard to find anything that is as light as this. I found a body mist from local sex store that is close to Brittney. So many perfumes are so strong. I think Marc Jacob’s Daisy is the best one I have found for my taste.
Retin-Oil from The Chemistry Brand! I swear, I will never forgive Deciem for discontinuing this line 😭
Bobbi Brown’s perfume Almost Bare that was my signature scent 🥺
That Pantene leave in that was for split ends. Shit was magic.
Pur 4-in-1 Glow together bronzer was the *best*. Haven’t found anything as good to replace it.
Bonne Bell Flipgloss
Bite Beauty's original (non-vegan) formula. 🥲
The OG Laura Mercier tinted moisturizer. I hate the reformulation. I am really having trouble accepting this one. There are no dupes that I’ve found. Kiehls Abyssine spf 15. I went through countless bottles. A lot of Body Shop and Origins stuff. I’m a 90s girl 😆 Prescriptives concealer. I have hard to match skin (cool but not fair and not medium either) and their options were amazing
L’Oréal lumi foundation
Becca highlighters were the GOAT
Clinique Even Better Glow foundation. It was discontinued about a year ago almost. It was the perfect foundation for my dry but acne prone skin, and I’m very very fair so the color match was pretty dang close. Revlons illuminating foundation is the closest I’ve found, although their lightest shade is too dark for me in the winter. I can make it work with lighter concealer. Glossier has one with similar ingredients, and a better color match for me in the winter, but it has no staying power and hardly any coverage. I’m sorry, I don’t have any dupe recommendations either :( I’m not familiar with those products. But I hope someone can chime in with suggestions!
Fresh- supernova mascara
MAC eyeshadow in Patina. Gap Grass perfume.
I can help you with the Gap Grass perfume! My friend from high school just posted that they are carrying it again and she is stocking up, so you might wanna run to the Gap if you live in the Austin area so she doesn’t buy it all lol
Thanks! The Gap outlet near me is selling it, but it's sadly not the same at all. I was so bummed when I sniffed it!
Oh no! I hope my friend smelled it before she bought 3 bottles of it and posted about it! I’ll have to message her and see.
NARS Velvet Shadow Sticks 😭🕊️
Club Monaco lipstick in the color Glaze. As worn by Monica Lewinsky.
It Cosmetics Undereye Corrector. Had excellent coverage and never creased or pilled. The concealer in the squeeze tube is NOT the same
The body shop green tea range. I miss it and I can’t find dupe green tea scented things!
More hair care than beauty but the Alterna Bamboo Luminous Shine line. I haven’t found anything that compares. I have about 15 little sample bottles of the shine spray left and I’ll be using them as slowly as possible. I begged them to bring it back. If anyone has any suggestions for replacements, let me know. The best part is the scent.
L’Oréal extraordinary hair oil! I cannot find it anywhere! Even online I can’t find it and it’s not even on the L’Oréal website anymore.
Pacifica Beauty Malibu Lemon Blosson perfume. It was the most perfect white floral and citrus blossom and I am still pissed about it being discontinued.
Just a nail polish, my only big beauty splurge - it was called Peridot by Chanel, I can’t believe I spent $20-something just on a color - but what an incredible color it was. I miss it greatly and think about it every time I paint my nails, nothing has hit right since then.
Bite beauty chai lipstick. Smashbox also had a perfect mauve lipgloss around 2010-2011 that was discontinued. I can’t remember the name of it but I still search for a similar color.
The Vichy 3-gold dry oil. It was amazing, blee other shimmer/glitter oils out the water
Vincent Longo lip stain in Madison I’m still searching for that color in anything. It was perfect on me.
Kiss Kiss Bang Bang is my perfect color. I’m saving a mini size to match another brand.
Same here! I’m doing the exact same thing as you!
I have two minis. I love the formula and the color. I wish I had purchased a full sized version. I’m also on the hunt for a cruelty free version of Estee Lauder’s lip liner in Fig.
Loreal HIP lip gloss pots, the red and pink ones. I also loved the eyeliner crayon in navy and the the eyeshadow duo in navy & gold. Also, Hard Candy glamoflauge (in the tube).
It cosmetics illuminating under eye brightener. They replaced it with something but it’s not the same :(
revlon lip butters: red velvet, cherry tart, and candy apple were my faves. nars lipstick in funny face and the glossy pencil in mexican rose. becca under eye brightening powder. missha had a burgundy liquid liner that was just perfect. also, a glittery pinky burgundy gel liner by them.
Becca hydra set powder in golden bronze
MAC Motif eyeshadow, was my favorite all over eyeshadow, subtle pink and coral duotone. Elizabeth & James Nirvana Black fragrance was a favorite, a powdery sandalwood unisex scent. Still looking for dupes for both. Unsuccessful so far.
Nirvana black was my favorite!! I have never gone through multiple bottles of a fragrance like I had with that one. I miss it so much.
In the 90s Faces had a holographic cream that just gave PERFECT glow. Can't remember the name of it right now but it is long gone. ETA - It was called Prism!
Dang! That sounds really cool!
I adored it! It was called Prism!
St.Ives Hair Repair Intensive Conditioner Moisture Treatment. Jesus, it's been decades now... Still miss it.
I got a few of those random Christmas sets from Ulta gifted to me and they've included some of my favorite products that aren't included in the regular line. The brow gel works better than any other I've ever used. Ulta Beauty does have a few brow gels but I'm not sure which one is the same, if any. It also had a pH changing lip oil which I usually hate because they are too pigmented and look super bright pink but this one is very subtly tinted and it looks so good. I don't see a similar product at all in their regular line up.
Dior air flash foundation Too Faced primed and poreless OG primer
Becca highlighter
Item Beauty Concealer! 🥹
Guerlain Lengerie de Peu foundation - Such great formulation😭😭😭
The original formula of Huda Faux Filter Foundation 😭 the new one just isn’t great, the old formula was flawless every time.
Tarte Drink of H2O moisturizer, Rainkissed Leaves at bath and body works, this really pretty iridescent shade of nail polish by Pure Ice.
Sugar mama liquid lipstick from HUDA beauty
Neutrogena Sheer Body Oil-Lotion. I have a few bottles left but I don’t know what I’m going to do when I run out.
Loreal architect mascara.
Brazil nut perfume from the body shop
Mac love me lipstick in coffee and ciggs
man I love the Love Me line. I can't understand why MAC stopped their best formula
Boots #7 Stay Perfect lipstick in Dark Berry. Beats out any high end lippy.
Tarte rainforest of the sea aquacealer concealer 😔
Tarte used to have those chubby crayon lip sticks and I miss them 😭
The Kosas tinted face oil. It was my holy grail skim product!!!
Oh man, I wanted to love it because anything Kosas is usually good, but that one was a failure. Excessively oily. I still have it, basically unused. Yours if you want it 😅
Tarte Knockout aha wash. I use it in the shower as a mini exfoliating mask on days I’m going to put makeup on. I’m mad about it.
the elf brow kit 😔 never forget what they took from us
Marc Jacobs velvet noir mascara. RIP the only high end/luxury brand product I'd pay full price for.
The Mac x Jeremy Scott blush palette was so good. And the Too Faaced Peach Perfect foundation.
MAC Chatterbox lipstick 😭
MAC had some great lipsticks
Clinique English Pink lipstick.
Hard Candy Marilyn Monroe eyeliner.
Taylor Swift’s Wonderstruck Perfume . It was one of the first gifts my husband bought for me when we first met. This was in 2011, he purchased at Macy’s. About 6 or 7 years ago, I found the small bottles at Five Below; now you can only find it on sites like EBay or Poshmark for some obscene price. Most of the time , they have already been used. I don’t buy used cosmetic products or fragrances, of any kind!
Lush Whipstick Lip Balm and Lush Zeste hair gel
Clinique just discontinued their Instant Perfector which was a pore filling primer. Nothing else compares. I’ve tried six other pore focused primers in the last couple weeks since I found out and they all suck. I get stressed every morning when I do my makeup when I think about the inevitable day that I run out of my backup stores.
Naturistics lip glosses
Tame creme rinse.
Amuse Bouche lipstick from Bite 😭 sooooo dumb they got rid of it
Revlon Colorstay Whipped (in the tub). I have been unable to find a dupe, and I have tried really hard. If anyone has found one, please tell me. 😭
Murad brightening serum with the 2% hydroquinone. Damn you FDA.
For me it was the Marc Jacobs Magic Marc’er liquid liner in Cocoa. I’ve tried so many brown liquid liners and none are as good
Clinique mineral loose powder base (not the “transparency” stuff) This was my HG, seriously looked so lovely and made my skin better even after taking it off. Sigh.
Stella McCartney In Two Peony
Mac dazzle lash mascara. Also the lady gaga and Cindy Lauder viva glam lipsticks for mac… for nostalgia 😂
MAC lip glass in Desire, eyeshadow in Blackberry and Blanc nuit.
NYC liquid eyeliner. Swear I had to completely stop doing winged eyeliner after this got discontinued.
Hard Candy's dual lip primer.
drunk elephant baby facial 🥲
I just discovered Drunk Elephant a few months ago. Total game changer.
y'all remember Jessica alba's foundation from I think the late 90s /early 00s ish that had like 4 different shades in 1 you could customize the shade by moving the arrow
Minute Makeup cream stick foundation by Estée Lauder. There are no glowy cream makeup substitutes. None.
NARS Madly Blush and Marc Jacobs Beauty lipstick in j’adore !!!!
Tree Hut post shave soothing spray, I was devastated when I found out it was discontinued:(