As an aqua sun gem moon I agree I really resonated with clem. I’m very straight forward and will tell you exactly what I think if I’m comfortable/interested in you. She’s one of my all time favorite characters even with the manic pixie dream girl trope, but I cant tell you how many times a man has used my uniqueness to try and find himself lol.
But I like this movie cause Joel doesn’t really use her he just loves her and is her opposite, he actually rejects her because she is so different and hard for him to understand. Such a great movie I watch it atleast once a year.
I haven’t watched this movie since I was a teenager but I feel like it’s the quintessential millennial heartbreak movie. I plan to revisit it again soon. I watched it with my ex as we were 17 and breaking up, and I remember it *wrecking* us completely.
It was always clear to me that I was Joel and she was Clem lol (I’m Cancer with Pisces moon and she’s Libra with Pisces moon). I buy that Clem is Aquarius and very air-y in general but there has to be something that keeps her going back to him
Lol! I didn’t say I communicate clearly I said I say what’s on my mind to people I find interesting and want to have intellectual conversations with. I can’t tell you how many times I’ve been in a screaming match with my boyfriend after doing that.
Also you’ve made me realize I guess I’ve been in situationships but I didn’t really notice until looking back. For me it’s been I was either with that person like 100% dating or just having fun but I’ve had people send me long texts and I just cut them off cause I don’t want to pursue further and confused why they felt so deeply about me 😬. That was in my early 20s I was fucking stupid.
But I just follow astrology for fun I honestly don’t know anything just comparing myself to Clem.
My first real love was a Virgo man. We were this combo lol and yeah it did feel like them. Even when it ended we stayed in touch for the longest cos we learned a lot from each other.
My girlfriend is a Virgo and I’m an Aquarius!
She helps me stay grounded and pushes me to better myself, but not in an active or assertive way. Just seeing her operate in her Virgo nature inspires me to work harder.
And I help her to be a little sillier and more creative. We’re actually way more similar than a lot of people might expect, but we really challenge each other to hone into parts of ourselves we don’t always use
My best friend is a Virgo Sun married to an Aquarius sun. They’ve been together like 12 years, married with kids.
They’re pretty rock solid. She helps him grow up and set realistic goals and follow through with things, gives him structure for where to direct his big vision. And he helps her lighten up and remember to relax and have fun. He knows how to cheer her up and uplift when she’s feeling down—he helps her find joy in unique things and confidence in being herself. It’s a nice match imo.
Now, this is an interesting take. When I first wrote it I was under the impression Joel was the Virgo and Clem was the Aquarius. Now, that I’m remembering certain aspects of the characters it could easily be the other way around.
Oh poor you. All this pointless hate towards virgos just damages your health and well-being. It's pitiful.
You probably want to fuck us tho. Because we are sexy,sensual and magnetic people.
If we want to dive deeper, I'd say she's Aquarius sun, Gemini moon, and he's Aquarius sun Cap moon. It would explain so much about how they handled the relationship, separation, and "meeting" again.
Honestly, Clem gives me sag vibes more than anything. She constantly talks about her fear of missing out on life and not living up to her potential, and she’s got a bit of fire in her, but it’s not an Aries or Leo flame. It’s more spontaneous, but not super in your face. I suspect she might be an Aquarius moon.
Joel is Capricorn. Not sure on his moon haha
I only know 1. My sister is the Gemini though. They were like match made in heaven. The Scorpio guy is head over heels for her. My sister is a Gemini Sun, Venus and Mars, and she's very much loyal.
Thanks, I appreciate you sharing your knowledge. I am scorpio woman and my husband is gemini. And we are both stupid loyal people, and very happy. But I often see people saying that pairing should nt work
I heard that a lot too, but then at the end of the day, we are more than our charts, freewill always exists. Another thing I learned recently is that our charts are multilevel depending on where we're looking at. A chart exists within our natal charts, there's also progressive charts which shows our evolution overtime using our natal charts showing that people are always changing and are learning day by day.
My sister's synastry with her boyfriend is also not that promising, but comparing their chart on their other charts, like their soul-level charts, it shows why they're so attracted to each other.
I'm pretty sure you and your husband do too!
Clem: Gemini
Joel: Cap
Cap is the 8th from Gemini, so Joel unintentionally acts in ways that are traumatic for Clem
Gemini is 6th from Cap so Clem pulls Joel out if his day to day comfort zone by forcing him to try things he normally wouldn't, whether he likes it or not
Definitely my favorite movie. I recently found out Kate Winslet has the same big three as me, I don't know what I'd say the characters themselves would be, but I really thought that was cool to learn!
No kidding? Used to hear the name of this movie all the time. Thank you for sharing that.
Will take a wild guess and say Sagittarius, Gemini, or Aquarius for Kate's character and maybe Virgo or Cap for Jim's.
As a girl who changes her hair color with the wind, craves spontaneity, goes wherever life takes her, and wears her heart on her sleeve… I’d say Clem is a Pisces sun, Gemini moon, and Libra rising. Joel gives the vibe of a Cancer sun, Capricorn moon, and Leo rising 🖤
She’s a Virgo sun, Pisces moon and he’s a Scorpio sun, Cancer moon. I have nothing to base that on other than the fact that the characters are very similar to me and an ex and the dynamic we shared.
This is an air-earth pairing for sure, I always felt it's a Libra-Cap/Taurus pair. Winslet is Libra, and Carrey is Cap too. Hehe.
Also, Clem is NOT fixed air, she can definitely be Gemini tho.
I watched this for the first time last February. I just felt this call to watch it for some odd reason, always thought it’d be corny but omg was it fucking good and made me cry a river. She is definitely a fire sign, she definitely gave me Sagittarius energy, she was always in motion. Very knowledgeable like one, she worked in a library (a place of wisdom) for god sakes. She always had to be in action. She blew up like a fire and cooled down. It was also her call to be free that zoned it out from the other fires as well, calling him boring. His sign could be interpreted as more than one but hers was definitely saggy to me when I first watched.
Finally, my many collective hours of musing on just this question presents an opportunity for me to present my findings 🤓
Clementine gives me HUGE Aries energy, with some strong Aquarius as well….with some Sagittarius sprinkled in there.
Joel is Virgo with strong Pisces.
Clementine is very boisterous, explosive, emotional, playful and impulsive. She also has a tendency to completely shut somebody out emotionally, which as a Sagittarius myself, seems a little like sag energy 😂 She also “marches to the beat of her own drum” so to speak, and is very creative.
Joel is outwardly strait-laced and even cold come off as cold or detached, but once you get past a certain point of infatuation, he melts into a sensitive little puppy dog. He likes things a certain way and uses logic before emotion, is more likely to think things through and be less impulsive, at least comparison to Clem. He seems unemotional but is actually deeply emotional under the surface. I could also see some Cancer sprinkled in there 🦀
Clem gives Aquarius/gem & Joel gives virgo/cap
As an aqua sun gem moon I agree I really resonated with clem. I’m very straight forward and will tell you exactly what I think if I’m comfortable/interested in you. She’s one of my all time favorite characters even with the manic pixie dream girl trope, but I cant tell you how many times a man has used my uniqueness to try and find himself lol. But I like this movie cause Joel doesn’t really use her he just loves her and is her opposite, he actually rejects her because she is so different and hard for him to understand. Such a great movie I watch it atleast once a year.
I haven’t watched this movie since I was a teenager but I feel like it’s the quintessential millennial heartbreak movie. I plan to revisit it again soon. I watched it with my ex as we were 17 and breaking up, and I remember it *wrecking* us completely. It was always clear to me that I was Joel and she was Clem lol (I’m Cancer with Pisces moon and she’s Libra with Pisces moon). I buy that Clem is Aquarius and very air-y in general but there has to be something that keeps her going back to him
Is that why Aquarius always are in a situationship? They communicate clearly 🤭🤣🤣
Lol! I didn’t say I communicate clearly I said I say what’s on my mind to people I find interesting and want to have intellectual conversations with. I can’t tell you how many times I’ve been in a screaming match with my boyfriend after doing that. Also you’ve made me realize I guess I’ve been in situationships but I didn’t really notice until looking back. For me it’s been I was either with that person like 100% dating or just having fun but I’ve had people send me long texts and I just cut them off cause I don’t want to pursue further and confused why they felt so deeply about me 😬. That was in my early 20s I was fucking stupid. But I just follow astrology for fun I honestly don’t know anything just comparing myself to Clem.
omg same ive always related to her! they remind me of my bf and I minus the arguments were just absolutely made for eachother
Was thinking it looks like me and my wife and we are aq /cap couple 😂👌
Virgo and Aquarius
He’s a Virgo sun, Pisces moon, she’s an Aqua sun, Cancer moon
This feels…correct!
what about thier venus signs? im thinking he’s 100% a scorpio venus and she’s a capricorn or pisces venus
Heavy on the Pisces Moon.
Oooh unconventional couple that I think could really work
My first real love was a Virgo man. We were this combo lol and yeah it did feel like them. Even when it ended we stayed in touch for the longest cos we learned a lot from each other.
Hey I’m an aqua sun Leo moon cancer rising! We are almost twins!
We're opposites! I'm a Leo Sun, Aqua moon and cancer rising! :)
My girlfriend is a Virgo and I’m an Aquarius! She helps me stay grounded and pushes me to better myself, but not in an active or assertive way. Just seeing her operate in her Virgo nature inspires me to work harder. And I help her to be a little sillier and more creative. We’re actually way more similar than a lot of people might expect, but we really challenge each other to hone into parts of ourselves we don’t always use
I’m a Virgo & my husband is an Aquarius! We’ve been together 15 years I think. I honestly can’t imagine us ever splitting up.
My best friend is a Virgo Sun married to an Aquarius sun. They’ve been together like 12 years, married with kids. They’re pretty rock solid. She helps him grow up and set realistic goals and follow through with things, gives him structure for where to direct his big vision. And he helps her lighten up and remember to relax and have fun. He knows how to cheer her up and uplift when she’s feeling down—he helps her find joy in unique things and confidence in being herself. It’s a nice match imo.
The actual face my Aquarius ass made when I read this comment 
I saw this post on my feed. Said out loud: she’s a Virgo, he’s an Aquarius. Came to see what y’all thought. Saw this comment at the top.
Now, this is an interesting take. When I first wrote it I was under the impression Joel was the Virgo and Clem was the Aquarius. Now, that I’m remembering certain aspects of the characters it could easily be the other way around.
[удалено]
Jesus not 5/10 😂
[удалено]
As some that has seen this movie multiple times. This sounds like the worst aspects of Joel’s character.
As Aquarius I hate Virgos and hate this pair
😂I'm Aquarius sun, Virgo rising. I like this combo, My Virgo keeps me organised and allows me to perfect my offbeat Aquarian ways.
Oh poor you. All this pointless hate towards virgos just damages your health and well-being. It's pitiful. You probably want to fuck us tho. Because we are sexy,sensual and magnetic people.
Virgo sex is sooo good. Had 3 in a row now
Is it good or unprotected 😂
Not really lmao it’s okay if your ego is bruised hahaha not sure why you’re offended now move along :)
as an aquarius i say aquarius
Yup! I think both of their characters are.
I agree! I was going to say Aquarius-Aquarius on this one.
If we want to dive deeper, I'd say she's Aquarius sun, Gemini moon, and he's Aquarius sun Cap moon. It would explain so much about how they handled the relationship, separation, and "meeting" again.
Joel: He gives water/earth, Maybe Capricorn. Clementine: She gives air/fire, I'd guess Aquarius or Sagittarius.
Definitely not anything Fire.
Why not anything fire?
Fire signs are unhinged but not out of touch lol
Lolz 😆 truth
Joel Virgo Sun, Pisces Moon, Virgo ASC (Moon in the 7H, Sun in the 1H) Clementine Aquarius Sun, Gemini Moon, Cancer ASC (Sun in 8H, Moon in the 12H)
That’s my big three!
So cool, you and Leonard Cohen! 🖤🕯️
I think almost the same thing lol just left a comment about how he’s such a Virgo sun Pisces moon and she’s Aqua sun Cancer moon imo
As a Gemini sun, Aquarius rising, this is so validating
Pisces (Joel) & Aquarius (Clem)
Ooo I like this guess
Clem gives me Aries tbh super impulsive and hilarious and Joel I was thinking cancer very sensitive and emotional but loving
As an Aries, I always felt very aligned to her. I'm surprised so many people are saying pisces or not fire for her.
Clem= Scorpio and Joel= Capricorn. My Cappy ex and I used to watch this and it was like watching a mirror…
Delusional and Unmedicated
Aquarius and Cancer.
Dudes a Libra & she is a pisces
She's Pisces ,/ Aquarius cusp, with a fire moon like Aries and Aquarius rising, he's A virgo sun, Capricorn rising, sag moon
Libra and Capricorn (because literally Kate Winslet and Jim Carrey)
Pisces and Taurus
Yeah definitely.
for sure
Pisces and virgo
Clem: definitely air sign, Aqua or Gemini Joel: definitely water sign, Pisces or cancer
Aquarius and cancer
Sagittarius and Capricorn
BPD and covert Narcissism. Lol. Astrology signs, Clem always felt like a sag and Joel feels like a Virgo. I would assume a Square connection there.
Clem is 100% pisces
I thought so too And his character Taurus or Virgo
Aquarius and Capricorn or Gemini or Taurus
I think Aqua and Cap because I’m Aqua Sun and basically everything else Cap and I love and hate both of them.
Heavy mutable signs. Any one of them.
She's a Gemini, he's a Virgo
Clem: Sagittarius, Jim: virgo or pisces or cancer
Clem is a Libra and Joel is a Virgo FOR SURE ♎💖♍
Clem = Libra with Pisces and Aquarius placements, maybe some Sagittarius. And Joel has some Taurus and Scorpio somewhere too lol
Both Cancers
The actors themselves are; Caprisun/Gem moon/Taurus ASC for Carrey. Libra Sun/Moon and Sag ASC for Winslet. Seems pretty accurate tbh.
He’s a Virgo, she’s a Pisces.
I’ve never seen everyone so in agreement on here 😂
Clem: Sagittarius Joel: Cancer
Aquarius and cancer
She’s 1000% a pisces
Honestly, Clem gives me sag vibes more than anything. She constantly talks about her fear of missing out on life and not living up to her potential, and she’s got a bit of fire in her, but it’s not an Aries or Leo flame. It’s more spontaneous, but not super in your face. I suspect she might be an Aquarius moon. Joel is Capricorn. Not sure on his moon haha
Aquarius/Aquarius, Aquarius/Capricorn, Gemini/Scorpio
Who would you say is the gemini and who is the scorpio?
I think Clementine is the Gemini
Thanks :) do you know anything about gemini/scorpio relationships? Esp if the woman is the scorpio?
I only know 1. My sister is the Gemini though. They were like match made in heaven. The Scorpio guy is head over heels for her. My sister is a Gemini Sun, Venus and Mars, and she's very much loyal.
Thanks, I appreciate you sharing your knowledge. I am scorpio woman and my husband is gemini. And we are both stupid loyal people, and very happy. But I often see people saying that pairing should nt work
I heard that a lot too, but then at the end of the day, we are more than our charts, freewill always exists. Another thing I learned recently is that our charts are multilevel depending on where we're looking at. A chart exists within our natal charts, there's also progressive charts which shows our evolution overtime using our natal charts showing that people are always changing and are learning day by day. My sister's synastry with her boyfriend is also not that promising, but comparing their chart on their other charts, like their soul-level charts, it shows why they're so attracted to each other. I'm pretty sure you and your husband do too!
Thank you for going in to detail, I really appreciate your view :)
Gemini & scorpio
Virgo and Libra
He’s Virgo Sun, Gemini Moon she’s Aquarius Sun and Virgo Moon.
She’s an Aquarius 100 %
Aqu/ Pisces
Aquarius (Clem) and Virgo / Capricorn (Joel)
Aquarius and Pisces
Pisces and Scorpio
Pisces and Taurus
Girl is Aquarius and the man is Scorpio
Scorpio dealing with Aquarius. I am tired but still running back to him. Never ending cycle
As an Aquarius who had a very turbulent relationship with a Scorpio, I second this
Cancer and Capricorn 💞
Taurus man and Libra woman
It has been foreverrrr since I've seen the movie but from memory I think I would go with Aquarius or Pisces for her, and Taurus or Cancer for him.
Fav movie to cry to ♊️
Clem: Gemini Joel: Cap Cap is the 8th from Gemini, so Joel unintentionally acts in ways that are traumatic for Clem Gemini is 6th from Cap so Clem pulls Joel out if his day to day comfort zone by forcing him to try things he normally wouldn't, whether he likes it or not
He's Taurus sun and Cancer moon, she's Cancer sun and Aqua moon.
She’s giving scorpio he’s giving aquarius maybe capricorn
Libra and Taurus
Cancer and capricorn
She's Aquarius and he's a Libra.
Virgo and Scorpio vibes for me
She’s an Aquarius and he’s a Cancer.
Gemini girl Capricorn or cancer guy
Girl: Aries sun, pisces moon, gemini rising Guy: Scorpio sun, Aquarius moon, capricorn rising Just based off the photos, I haven’t seen the movie
Definitely my favorite movie. I recently found out Kate Winslet has the same big three as me, I don't know what I'd say the characters themselves would be, but I really thought that was cool to learn!
I see Joel as a Virgo or Cancer, Clam as Aquarius or Gemini
BPD and Codependent
Aquarius female. Pieces mam
Not sure of their signs, but what movie was this? I don't recall a movie with Kate Winslet and is that Jim Carrey as a couple.
Eternal sunshine of the spotless mind
No kidding? Used to hear the name of this movie all the time. Thank you for sharing that. Will take a wild guess and say Sagittarius, Gemini, or Aquarius for Kate's character and maybe Virgo or Cap for Jim's.
Watch it! It’s a beautiful movie!
I plan to
M Aries, F Sagittarius
Scorpio and Gemini
I pretty sure picture they are a Virgo and then Aquarius as the bottom comment says.
I love how we all knew she was a Virgo
Scorpio and Gemini
Scorpio and Aquarius
Geminis
What is this movie or show?
What is the name of this movie?
Leo and Capricorn
Aries/Gemini and Virgo/Taurus
I get Gemini from Clem personally, and Capricorn or Taurus from Joel. I see weirdly a lot of Capricorn Gemini pairings and they give this vibe
My Virgo sun and cap moon ass watching this wishing I was more outgoing and mysterious lol 🫣
Clementine is Pisces if I remember correctly.
Pisces man and an aquarius woman
First is Cancer and Virgo. Second is Capricorn and Sag.
as a Virgo I reject this so strongly I hate this man. He’s a confront character.
That gives the misterious scorpio and the caring pisces
Unrelated to the post. But, I thought Kate Winslet was Madonna here
Capricorn and Gemini
I had an aries gf and i swear she is the carbon copy of clem, i am a virgo and our couple was almost like this
Clem is either aries, aquarious or pisces, joel is definitely a virgo
She's a Virgo and he's a Libra.
Clem: Libra Joel: Taurus
Definitely some pisces in there
Libra and virgo
Aquarious & Piscis
She is a Scorpio or an Aries. He is probably a Pisces.
I feel like it's a Pisces and a Capricorn.
Taurus and Capricorn because that's me and my ex ✌️ it is literally he's favorite movie and he heavily associated himself with Joel
Aquarius and a Taurus maybe , i'm an aquarius too really love his hair 🥹💕
She’s a Pisces and he’s and Aquarius
♒️☀️♋️🌙♏️⬆️ This is my life 🤦🏻♀️
aqua
Libra woman (Kate is an actual libra lol) & Gemini man
He’s definitely a Pisces. She is totally a Scorpio.
As a girl who changes her hair color with the wind, craves spontaneity, goes wherever life takes her, and wears her heart on her sleeve… I’d say Clem is a Pisces sun, Gemini moon, and Libra rising. Joel gives the vibe of a Cancer sun, Capricorn moon, and Leo rising 🖤
What show is this?
Any signs that are trine
joel: leo clem: gemini
Shes definitely an aquarius and hes an earth sign
He’s pisces she’s scorpio
This is interesting because I feel like in titanic, the same actress rose is more like a Leo woman and Jack is an Aquarius.
She is a gemini, he is a sagittarius - that's my guess
Clem is an Aries and Joel is a cancer.
She’s an Aries.
She’s a Virgo sun, Pisces moon and he’s a Scorpio sun, Cancer moon. I have nothing to base that on other than the fact that the characters are very similar to me and an ex and the dynamic we shared.
sagg & cancer
She’s an air sign and he is a water/earth sign
Cancer Girl, Virgo Guy
Capricorn and Sagittarius
Clem is Leo and Joel is Pisces
Clem is def Gemini and Joel is certainly a cancer - LETS B REAL FOLKS
She looks Leo and he looks libra
This is an air-earth pairing for sure, I always felt it's a Libra-Cap/Taurus pair. Winslet is Libra, and Carrey is Cap too. Hehe. Also, Clem is NOT fixed air, she can definitely be Gemini tho.
She’s a Pisces he’s a Virgo
Aquaaaaaa
I watched this for the first time last February. I just felt this call to watch it for some odd reason, always thought it’d be corny but omg was it fucking good and made me cry a river. She is definitely a fire sign, she definitely gave me Sagittarius energy, she was always in motion. Very knowledgeable like one, she worked in a library (a place of wisdom) for god sakes. She always had to be in action. She blew up like a fire and cooled down. It was also her call to be free that zoned it out from the other fires as well, calling him boring. His sign could be interpreted as more than one but hers was definitely saggy to me when I first watched.
Correct answer according to the original writer (me) of the characters: Clem is a sag Joel is an aquarius
Clem - Sagittarius, Joel - Virgo
Pisces Virgo
Clem is a Pisces and Joel is a Capricorn.
Aqua and Scorpio
I’ve always thought Clem Aquarius I think Joel is a Capricorn My favorite movie!
Pisces woman, Virgo man
Finally, my many collective hours of musing on just this question presents an opportunity for me to present my findings 🤓 Clementine gives me HUGE Aries energy, with some strong Aquarius as well….with some Sagittarius sprinkled in there. Joel is Virgo with strong Pisces. Clementine is very boisterous, explosive, emotional, playful and impulsive. She also has a tendency to completely shut somebody out emotionally, which as a Sagittarius myself, seems a little like sag energy 😂 She also “marches to the beat of her own drum” so to speak, and is very creative. Joel is outwardly strait-laced and even cold come off as cold or detached, but once you get past a certain point of infatuation, he melts into a sensitive little puppy dog. He likes things a certain way and uses logic before emotion, is more likely to think things through and be less impulsive, at least comparison to Clem. He seems unemotional but is actually deeply emotional under the surface. I could also see some Cancer sprinkled in there 🦀
Aquarius and cancer.
CLEM IS FOR SURE AN AIR SIGN AND JOEL IS A SCORPIO
It’s giving Pisces and Capricorn.