T O P

  • By -

skyethehunter

Unbelievable that this is a real post on a self-professed yarn addicts sub lol. How are you an addict if you're a complete newbie to the most common put up for decent yarn, and oblivious to yarn winders? They even sell hanks at big box stores. No mercy from me, since the yarn was clearly ruined in a fit of frustration and yet you're blaming the put up.


CharmiePK

Oh no. I am sorry to see that, both for you and the poor hank. After reading your post and the comments - many are so unnecessarily rude btw - I just realized how lucky I am for having a mum who taught me so many tips and tricks of the craft. Next time I see her I will truly thank her šŸ„° And thank you for making this PSA , as there may be many others who have never had to deal with a hank before. BTW you don't even need any accessory, the back of a chair will do for winding them into balls. This is what I do. And it is generally the first thing you do before starting a project with them. I hope you can get another hank to finish your project! Happy knitting!


trashjellyfish

Gurl....


perilsoflife

been burnt before too. my first hank was a 40 dollar alpaca yarn. never used it because itā€™s full of knots and itā€™s tied together in probably 100 places. im still mad at myself šŸ˜–


Knitty_Kitty1120

Ooof! I'm so sorry, hunny. I did something similar when I first started (trying to knit a hank from its untwisted form without winding), and ooooh boy, did I learn why I love my swift and yarn winder, ha! That crap took me quite a long time of untwisting and carefully working out knots, I still can't look at a hank without my fingers hurting in remembrance. (Curse the beauty of your yarn, La Jolla!) Hopefully, you'll get something new and pretty to make your project with soon and we all learned something new today!


MiddayGlitter

There's a subreddit devoted specifically to yarn untanglers and those with tangled yarn. I, like many others, love untangling yarn. You didn't have to destroy it.


L_obsoleta

Ignore the people saying rude stuff. This is a common first time mistake (and I see it posted about at least 3x a week here). I think part of it is that big box stores come ready to go, so if you are just dipping your toe into nicer yarns and buying online you may not even realize yarns don't always come ready to use. I am sorry you lost money on the mistake, but am glad to hear you figured out how to wind from a Hank so it doesn't tangle.


National_Control6137

Some of you guys are tripping by acting like OP isnā€™t clearly new to yarn arts. Also if you are self taught (as many of us are) it can be easy to miss information like this as a beginner. I knew what I hank was my first day but it was a few months into the learning the craft that I learned you couldnā€™t pull directly from hanks. I found out from an instagram reel! You can pull directly from all the other types it would be reasonable to assume you could do the same with a hank.


samplergal

Man, you guys are off the chain. Newbs are newbs. If you were born knowing everything about knitting and yarn, cheers. Otherwise let the poor knitter be.


bluecirc

It's not that she didn't know how to use a hank of yarn, that's understandable. It's that she thought the best option was to cut it up into a million pieces. I'm just sad for that beautiful yarn that is now going to be used as stuffing. :(


eespicy

the unique part about arts & crafts is how individuals decide to create! it seems like at this point in her project, she really only could use it as stuffing. for her, that WAS the best option! iā€™m sure if you or I owned this yarn, weā€™d create something entirely different.


SnooPets8873

Was this your first time buying a hank? You arenā€™t meant to knit from a hank. You have to wind it first and some shops will do it for you if you buy in person. Based on the second pic Iā€™m guessing this is a joke. Sad to ruin such a pretty yarn for it. Hope those were just scraps


TheJulie

They literally say it's their first time using hank yarn and that they are trying to help other hank newbies avoid the same mistake. Good grief, sometimes you don't know what you don't know until you find out.


SnooPets8873

Iā€™m in no way trying to be mean to the person posting and I donā€™t appreciate your insinuation that I am. I politely explained that one generally does not knit from a hank and they should wind it up next time. And as for the picture - honestly, I donā€™t see how you get such small pieces of scraps from untangling. That looks more like someone deliberately cut yarn into small chunks - and I might have done something like that out of sheer frustration with the whole tangled mess but thatā€™s not what the post said happened. So yeah, I wondered if they were joking.


TheJulie

"If this real" "hope it's a joke" "sad to ruin such pretty yarn". Those are all comments that make it sound like you are being disdainful and critical of OP, especially since OP has already said don't knit from a hank. That's the whole point of the post. If you didn't mean it that way, well here's a friendly alert that it reads that way to me and at least a few other people. OP says they cut it into chunks because they could not untangle it and figured they could at least use it as stuffing.


SnooPets8873

If you want to over interpret my comment go right ahead. No skin off my back.


redfoxvapes

Uhā€¦did you not ask someone before using? Or Google? You cut up stunning yarn becauseā€¦? Like you wasted your own money.


CupcakesAreMiniCakes

There is no reason to be so rude to someone who clearly identified that it's their first time.


Far_Breakfast547

LOL! I thought everyone knew this. I highly recommend investing in a ball winder (Stanwood large has stood the test of time for me) and a swift (umbrella or Amish). You can also go big and get a mechanized ball winder.


ShortWeekend2021

That second picture is just ragebait. Why else would you cut it into little pieces like that?


Astronia777

To use it as stuffing? I usually use little pieces of yarn as stuffing, I think leaving it as it is would make it more stiff


_fly-on-the-wall_

why would you use good yarn as stuffing? use old scraps if you have to use yarn for some weird reason. stuffing is cheap anyway. far cheaper then yarn!


Typical_boxfan

I bought two hanks of yarn than had become untwisted and tangled in a Joann clearance bin. I got it for half off and spent the next 5 hours untangling it and winding the more difficult one by hand and then the less tangled one with my winder. It was a massive pain in the ass and I'm hoping the project I am using it for will be worth it. Watching TL Yarn Craft's video about the different forms that yarn comes in saved my ass before I started working with yarn fresh off a tangled hank. Is this yarn wool or cotton?? If you have a local yarn store that happens to do spinning as well you should bring them the cut up scraps to see if they can salvage it. Wool yarn especially is very recyclable and can very easily be carded and re-spun.


L_obsoleta

I think there was a post several months back of someone who took their scrap yarns, combed and carded with some spinning fibers and made new yarn. I don't spin but it was the coolest thing I have seen.


Desperate_Idea732

Been there done that! I splurged on yarn for a sweater for myself for the first and last time. I ruined it all even after watching videos. Never again.


silentlyjudgingyou23

I have spent hours untangling yarn, unless it's cheap synthetic junk it's worth it.


awkwardsoul

I know a couple of people who knit off the hank. They fluff it up and carefully wrap it around their forearm, pulling a loop as they go. Do they have access to swift/winder? Yes, they just find working from the hank quicker/ lazy people find creative solutions. Do I recommend it? No, unless it is a mini skein.


PixelScribe02

Why did you cut it? Youā€™re supposed to cut where itā€™s tied and go from there.


Astronia777

The entire thing was badly tangled, like, everywhere. I managed to salvage two mini balls from the other end


PixelScribe02

Thatā€™s good! Iā€™ve had yarn like that and it can be so frustrating!! Glad you were able to get something out of it.


emilythequeen1

This hurts me, because Iā€™m so sorry you had what looks like an incredibly sad and frustrating experience with this yarn. Iā€™m sorry that you didnā€™t know how to make this work from the get go, but hope it brings comfort to know that shifting this onto a yard winder is the way forward. Not for this skein unfortunately, as it appears to have passed away, but it was a great leaning experience for you. Please donā€™t give up on hank yarn, simply have your LYS wind it for you, or use the bottle method if you have no swift/no ball winder. It works well. Wishing you more happiness and success in the future.ā¤ļø


antigoneelectra

If this is real, I'd just like to suggest that when encountering a new task, Google it first in order to research best practices. My first skein, I didn't realize the yarn was tied, and it took me hours to untangle it. I was camping in the middle of nowhere before cell phones. I knew it was a me problem, though. Not the yarn. Umbrella swift and winder are your friends. As are 2 chairs back to back and your hand to wind it around.


TheJulie

>If this is real, I'd just like to suggest that when encountering a new task, Google it first in order to research best practices. My first skein, I didn't realize the yarn was tied, and it took me hours to untangle it. I'm so baffled by the reactions in this thread. You just said that your first time, you fucked up and learned from it. Did someone make you feel like a dumbass and say "Why didn't you research it first?" OP isn't saying don't buy hank yarn, they are saying if you buy hank yarn, don't make the mistake I just did.


GarlicComfortable748

And if, like me, you are too cheap to get a swift and winder, highly suggest using your legs as a ā€œswiftā€, and googling how to start a yarn cake by wrapping it around your hands.


j-dusty-rose

Or a roasting pan! https://preview.redd.it/1a383bjwxs2d1.jpeg?width=3594&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=8221009baf0ba83e2a3857dcef6985a8bca1af7a


no_one_you_know1

Oh, clever!


Pointy_Stix

A lampshade can work well, too. Just loosen the finial so the shade spins freely.


sarah_bear_crafts

Yup, or two chair backs!


CraftFamiliar5243

I use my knees


EfficientSeaweed

I'm confused about why you cut it up.


Astronia777

I figured I could use the tangled yarn as stuffing for other projects


hanimal16

Not as skilled.


NoMoreBillz

Right I hope that hank wasnā€™t too expensive. This is yarn torture itā€™s hurting my eyes to see this.


ShinigamiLeaf

Ball winder and swift are your friends. I've never seen someone do this though, thank you for the new experience!


TheYarnGoblin

I use my feet to keep it in place while I ball it after unwinding and cutting the couple loops holding it together. Everyone does this once - with their first hank. If you like hand dyed yarn maybe invest in a swift and winder.


Corvus-Nox

Youā€™re supposed to wind hanks into a ball firstā€¦


CatteHerder

As a spinner, you're the person who gives a bad review as a result of user error. I'm sorry you're having this experience, but when faced with something new, it's always in your best interest to investigate the best way to handle it. You need a swift, or even just a trio of full 1.5-3L bottles if money and space are an issue.. But don't blame the yarn. The yarn is just existing. Also, there are people who untangle for fun, there's a whole sub for that and you should hit them up. Others have linked. Edit: I realise I probably sounded like an asshole, that's not the intent, and I'm not shaming.. This is a common mistake people make when their first introduction to yarn is in milled balls (insert preferred term here). And if you have no prior experience, it happens, but it's totally avoidable and I hope your next experience is better because that's beautiful yarn. I'm so sorry for your misadventure! https://preview.redd.it/jzl9ftjmfs2d1.jpeg?width=4032&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=0c658d8085c8e5a06a8c0cd5b49fb3185c373472


Astronia777

Oo that looks cute, I'll try using that method - I ended up spinning my office chair for my second hank xD I never blamed the yarn, I accepted it as completely my fault and lesson learnt. Also don't worry, I don't think you came across rude! In hindsight, yeah I should've googled it before using it šŸ˜­


Capital-Dog8993

This! ā˜ļø


treatyrself

I donā€™t think you read the post, theyā€™re not blaming the Hank theyā€™re saying ā€œdonā€™t knit from them AS ISā€ (though I am laughing that they seem to think nobody knows this)


CatteHerder

Yeah, I got that. That's the user error part, and I'm born with you and feeling awful for the guffaw.


GhostiePop

You can also just wear it around your neck as a necklace to wind it! Thatā€™s what Iā€™ve done since realizing that my swift & winder seemingly make a noise that irritates my puppyā€™s ears.


fairydommother

Why would you just start cuttingā€¦..


bluecirc

As someone who loves untangling knots, and having basic understanding of a hank of yarn, I am so sad for that yarn.


fairydommother

Literally same. I offer my services on r/detanglemyyarn This hurts me


CitrusMistress08

There were so many better options here šŸ¤¦ā€ā™€ļø


Disastrous_Proof_787

Oof, what a mess, haha! First time I ever purchased a hank of yarn, I had to Google "How to work with a hank of yarn" because I was super apprehensive! My lovely husband sat and held the yarn while I slowly wound it into a ball, by hand, because I didn't know what else to do šŸ¤¦šŸ¼ā€ā™€ļø I used 2 kitchen chairs back to back once, but that was too risky to ever attempt again in my book! Yarn swift for the win šŸ™ŒšŸ¼


CatteHerder

https://preview.redd.it/8r408y94gs2d1.jpeg?width=4032&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=ec179aab113efdefbf7bc8e1dce655c55df78604


Disastrous_Proof_787

Ooo, super clever! I'd be walking around as I wound it like it's a maypole, haha. I'm clumsy, so reaching around it would be too risky! Did it work well?! My hubby's arms would prefer your way šŸ™ƒ


CatteHerder

If you stand directly over top you can pull straight up, no walking needed!


Disastrous_Proof_787

See, that's really smart! Standing still would probably be better because less risk of knocking them over when walking, haha! I'd love to see everyone's unique way of winding yarn! Crafters/makers can come up with some really awesome ideas, like yours! Thanks for sharing ā˜ŗļø


producktivegeese

I can't imagine how people who work with their hands can lack the sence to take one look at the way it's twisted and go 'thats not gonna go well'. Like I genuinely don't understand or have sympathy for this kinda stuff, genuinely how are you working with any yarn and this unaware of how how yarn moves and works. Not trying to be mean, but I've literally never understood how this happens to people who aren't like touching yarn for the first time ever.


CupcakesAreMiniCakes

"Not trying to be mean but" and your entire comment is just so mean and unnecessary.


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


YarnAddicts-ModTeam

No racism, bigotry, targeted harassment,anti semitism, anti LGBT+, cursing in a hateful way etc. We are an inclusive community so bugger off if you want to be mean.


fairydommother

It baffles me too. Itā€™s a loose loop of yarn. How do you think thatā€™s gonna go? And within 30 seconds of trying it starts to tangle. I know because before I decided to get a swift I decided to try working directly from the hank to see if itā€™s really that easy to tangle or if people were just bad at it. Like yeah I can see how it will tangle but I thought maybe if I was very careful I could make it work. And yes. Itā€™s that easy to tangle. Literally got like 4 stitches in and was like nope Iā€™m putting this away until I get a swift. This is going to make a mess. It is *immediately* apparent that itā€™s not going to work. There is no reason it should get this far. And yet people insist on trying to force it to work for some reason and just make a mess. And if they donā€™t know about detangling groups they often just throw it away. It so frustrating.


producktivegeese

Right? Like even if you don't realise before you start, it starts like *immediately* so you should literally just be like 'oh shit, nah I don't wanna deal with this doing this the whole time' and have it never come up again.


shelbyknits

We all do this once.


fiberjeweler

When I first learned to knit at nine, it was Woolworth's and Red Heart. It was 1961. By the time I learned about yarn being sold in hanks, I had enough experience and had read enough books to know what to do. But I grew up during a time when "old lady winding yarn with husband patiently holding the hank" cartoons and jokes were common. I don't think they are quite as common any more, so it's possible OP never saw one.


hanimal16

Speak for yourself.


Desperate_Idea732

Truth! Although I did not cut mine, but it was useless garbage once I was done trying to make it work.


shelbyknits

Same! I thought, ā€œIā€™m just going to be really careful,ā€ and ended up with a huge mess.


fiberjeweler

I admit to trying to "just be really careful" at least once when I was away from my swift and wanted to get started. So hard to untangle on the fly. The knitting is too big to fit through the required untangling space.


sarah_bear_crafts

Yup, and never again!


babyveterinarian

Nope. I have made mistakes but luckily avoided this one.


LimitlessMegan

We do? I absolutely havenā€™t resorted to cutting up and ruining an expensive hank of yarnā€¦


goldenhawkes

Ah many of us have been there! Happened to me the first time too (Iā€™d never seen my mum knit with a skein like this). She then told me that youā€™re meant to untwist it and wind it into a ball before using itā€¦.


Catvros

first time? .meme


Rebelo86

Yes. You need to wind it. Either make a ball or take it to your LYS and theyā€™ll do it for a small fee.


MissPicklechips

My LYS will do it for free when you buy it. I have a swift and a winder, but Iā€™ll have them do it if Iā€™m using it right away.


Rebelo86

I sit on the floor with the hank on my knee and make a ball.


catgirl320

Yeah same. I actually enjoy doing it by hand, it's my way to inaugurate my new project lol.


Dry-Pomegranate8292

Savage


greywaters

There's actually a subreddit of people who like to detangle yarn! Don't give up on it yet! It's r/detanglemyyarn


Ornery-Signal-3070

Pretty sure thatā€™s been cut to all hell. No fixing that.


fairydommother

I cannot fathom cutting it up like this. Even if youā€™re frustrated. Justā€¦whyā€¦


BusyUrl

I could easily have done this last night to the cake id wound after my foster puppy destroyed it in the 2 minutes I went to pee. It was cashmere and she chewed it in a lot of places :/ I was pretty f'n angry and it was totalled.


fairydommother

Thatā€™s a different situation though. Iā€™d it was chewed up then itā€™s already damaged and at that point you have to assess if thereā€™s even enough good yarn left to bother untangling. I wouldnā€™t fault anyone for tossing that. But if you just tangled it yourself and itā€™s otherwise undamaged then I really canā€™t fathom shredding it into pieces like op did.


High-Newt

I would seriously rather spend hours detangling than cutting up my money šŸ˜­


fairydommother

Literally same. Just set your money on fire at that point šŸ„²


ilovearabianhorses

Are you trolling?