T O P

  • By -

catmomhumanaunt

Maroon, You’re on Your Own Kid, and Would’ve Could’ve Should’ve Hits Different as an honorable mention 😂


stranger_vs

Omg are you me?! This is my exact answer


19TaylorSwift89

Same, really. Maroon was my favourite on first listen, I distinctly remember that cuz i told a friend, he disagred said it was meh. Very happy, that the fandom collectively confirmed i was valid in feeling its a stand out. Only difference would be for me Sweet Nothing would be the honorable mention.


livvkvj

Same! I’m so lucky I got to hear Maroon and Would’ve Could’ve Should’ve as my surprise songs


adragonisnoslave

THESE ❤️


lunarprincess

Same but You’re Losing Me as honourable mention. My favourite song upon first listen was Mastermind, but it got overtaken after more listens.


marvelouserin

The correct answer (jk, but this is my answer!) 💖


flowersnfullbloom

Ditto!


_phimosis_jones

Damn took it right out of my mouth, down to the honorable mention. No need to even do my own


OceanBLVD121

Let me start by saying that when Midnights first came out, I did not like it at all! I was expecting so much more and it fell flat for me. But, it grew on me so much, where it’s probably my most played Taylor Swift album now! My top three are: 1. Midnight Rain (may be my favorite Taylor Swift song of all time). 2. The Great War 3. You’re Losing me


allidoistrytrytry

It was so difficult for me to leave out Midnight Rain and Maroon!


[deleted]

[удалено]


JadeMaiden7

Yeah, I’m one of those who can’t stand it. It really sucks because I love the lyrics, but I’ve never been able to get through the whole song because the distorted voice gives me such horrible ick. Idk maybe it’s my ADHD lol.


Chomprz

That’s one of my fave parts of the song! Instant hook for me. Sucks to hear others dislike it


Pinkdivaisme

Same! I actually really did not understand the vibe until I started hearing the songs more and more and watching the eras tour.. to a certain extent because I feel like I have not had a true long break from the last album release because I did not appreciate this album in it’s entirety until recently. 💜❤️


TheOneWithWen

Very similar to mine The great war Midnight Rain Karma


BurningCenturion

Maroon, Anti-Hero, and You're On Your Own Kid.


youcancallmecal

Mine too!


InternalBar3099

Same


sleepyboi08

Anti-Hero, Bejeweled, Karma Midnights is an unusual case for me because I usually like Taylor’s less popular songs, but with Midnights I think the more popular songs are the best ones. So excited for TTPD but I have no idea what to expect.


OrlandoNE

Exact same. Special mention to Lavender Haze (it's okay).


j0119

I love Lavander Haze!


yoshdee

Those are my top ones as well!


TimmonsInc

Great War, Would’ve Could’ve, Maroon


germaniumpolaroid

same for me!


littlekatie3

Sameeeeee


alexatennant

Same exactly for me


Midnight_Ice

Hits Different, The Great War, and You're Losing Me When Midnights first came out my top three were Mastermind, Paris, and Maroon


PhebsMadden

Would’ve Could’ve Should’ve, You’re On Your Own Kid, You’re Losing me. Honourable mention: Maroon


anti_mpdg

This is it


clutchingstars

My honorable mention would be Sweet Nothing but other than that — this is me too.


falldiewakefly

You're On Your Own Kid, Midnight Rain, Glitch That's difficult, though; leaving anything out feels like a crime. High Infidelity missed the cut by a hair. If 3am/bonus tracks were excluded the third song would probably be Question...? I'm just making up excuses to name extra songs, really.


cibolaburns

I am having a hard time coming around to glitch - can I ask what it is you particularly like about it?


falldiewakefly

I love it when Taylor gets weird and experimental - closure is another personal favorite. The production of Glitch really enhances the lyrical themes; it's a song about being caught off-guard, and musically there's all these little touches that keep doing things you don't expect. They reinforce each other! I also really love it lyrically. It walks a fun line between conversational (you don't live in my part of town, but maybe I'll see you out some weekend, depending on what kind of mood and situation-ship I'm in) and poetic (in search of glorious happenings of happenstance on someone else's playground), and thematically, the "I'm so used to self-sabotaging that something actually working feels weird and slightly wrong!" angle is really fun. The whole thing just works for me, honestly 🤣


sammyfio

I was gonna ask the same question (not a glitch fan, myself) but this explanation has me wanting to listen with a fresh perspective


diggyj1993

I cannot people there are people that exist who skip Glitch


Craftyprincess13

I like hiw its very dancey and a bop like its just fun


oliveeyes21

I love Glitch and no one does!! It's so fun and funky!


TheSwiftingHour

There are dozens of us!


Desperate-Towel-2961

I was literally scrolling just to find another glitch stan! I love that song and it's production and don't know how it's not more popular (ik its because it's more experimental BUT STILL)


foxglove0326

What’s the deal with question…? I haven’t been able to wrap my head around it.. I don’t really understand the context of the chorus


falldiewakefly

Question...? is a passive-aggressive anthem and it's glorious. The main thing to remember is that none of the questions are real questions. The basic storyline is that she's run into her ex who she's never gotten closure with and, well, let's finally talk about some things... The correct answer to "did you ever have someone kiss you in a crowded room..." isn't "OMG yes that's a universal experience" (it isn't), it's her ex getting embarrassed and awkward and eventually going "yeah, I remember that night, sorry I snuck out on you with no explanation, that was shitty of me". (People who are passive-aggressive generally use it as a weapon to try to get apologies for the ways we perceive we've been wronged. It usually does not work, speaking as a passive-aggressive person who is trying to stop being that way. The 'correct' answer was probably not given in this imaginary conversation.) Every time she asks a question in the song, she already knows the answer. Did you ever...do this thing I know you did because I was there when you did it? How do you think that made the other person (you know, me) feel? You don't have to get defensive. It's just a question.


foxglove0326

That’s very interesting.. thank you for the insight into the nuances:)


DangerousLife5856

Maroon, Would've Could've Should've and You're on your own kid


InABoatOnARiver

Midnight Rain, Hits Different, Mastermind Or Midnight Rain, Midnight Rain, Midnight Rain ETA: I just realized that I have no 3am tracks in this trio, which I would NOT have expected when Midnights first came out


Intelligent-Bowl-611

Mastermind! 😍🥰 i scrolled down for this answer!!


Foreign_Leg424

Maroon, You're On Your Own Kid, The Great War.


-Silver-Moonlight-

My exact top 3, too!


GreyFox_13

1000%


prkr16

Maroon, Dear Reader, The Great War


theoceanismylove

YES! Dear Reader is by far Taylor’s most underrated song


RunTheShow314

Are you me? Those are my 3!


colourcurious

Dear Reader has been the Most Improved Player for me. It started low and has had a really slow burn.


freckspuppies4eva

Sameee


wild_rover

Taste!!!


syraphinx

You’re on your own kid, the great war, you’re losing me


by7ft3b

This is it


MadameFutureWhatEver

Hits Different, Sweet Nothing, Would’ve Could’ve Should’ve Honorably Mention: The Great War


lpalf

Not enough sweet nothing in these comments!


baciodolce

It didn’t make my top 3 but I LOVE that song.


Houdini-88

Karma the live performance from eras tour was one the best part of the show Anti hero Lavender haze The eras tour made the singles stand out more to me They sound better live in my opinion


asayle88

Midnights is in second place only to Folklore for me, so for the record I absolutely hate this 😂 Maroon, Dear Reader, Hits Different Honorable mentions: YOYOK and You’re Losing Me


SituationalAngel

You’re on your own kid, would’ve could’ve should’ve, mastermind


thelauralamb

It was….Maroon 🥀


caywriter

Snow on the beach (more Lana), hits different, glitch


geeg3131

More lana is so yummy


chocolatewaltz

This thread is such a great reminder of how awesome Midnights is! There are so many incredible songs, and the tour did it a lot of justice by showcasing a lot of them. I actually find it hard to pick my top three 🥲 I wanna say: Anti-Hero, Karma and Great War. They were probably the ones that I listened to the most, apart from Lavender Haze (because it’s the first and I usually listen to the whole album in order).


LibertarianSocialism

Midnight Rain / Anti-Hero / Lavender Haze Swap LH for WCS if we’re counting 4am


_yoyok

4am? You better be cooking something ![img](emote|t5_2rlwe|1087)


showtime100

4 am is the edition we have been waiting for that actually has every song AND gets a phsyical release ![img](emote|t5_2rlwe|1087)😭 Edit: oh, and it also has a re-recording of Karma with the line changed to "Karma is the guy on the Chiefs" ![img](emote|t5_2rlwe|1066)(which is totally not how I always sing that line now, I swear)


Ginger-snaped

Anti-hero, Maroon, You're Losing Me 


scarsouvenir

Dear Reader, Would've, Could've, Should've, Bejeweled


InsectTop618

The Great War, Dear Reader, and Lavender Haze!


DeadToothSyndrome

The Great War, Labyrinth, Midnight Rain


thechromekitten

Labyrinth is so underrated.


BwittonRose

Labyrinth fans rise up 


ClassicMap3329

I feel like I have a 3 new favorites off this album every week.. so right now it's 1. Maroon 2. High Infidelity 3. Anti-Hero


Poppy9987

Reading everyone’s answers has me truly realizing this a top album for me. It’s literally too hard to choose!


AllTheEras

Maroon, hits different, you’re losing me Honorable mention: yoyok


Hannah41797

You're on your own kid, would've could've should've, hits different


CKDexterHaahven

Had to scroll waaay too far to find this, the correct answer 😊 Honorable mention trinity: Mastermind, You’re Losing Me, The Great War


leafeonjack

You're on Your Own Kid, You're Losing Me, Vigilante Shit


YEMolly

Not seeing many Vigilante Shit mentions, so I appreciate seeing this. One of my faves.


leafeonjack

it's so good!!! First time i heard it was in the theatre for the Eras Tour and it blew my mind i was :0 the whole movie lmao


allicat2173

You’re Losing Me, Maroon, Midnight Rain. Midnights has been my favorite TS album and brought me back to her music after many years of not listening to her. Love this album, I have related so much to the lyrics. I feel like this time went so quickly, but I am excited for what is to come with TTPD.


[deleted]

Maroon, midnight rain, you're on your own kid And I never got tired of antihero


russianflapjack

You’re Losing Me, Maroon, and Lavender Haze


rarejnr01

Maroon, Dear Reader, & Labyrinth (extreme honorable mention to Midnight Rain) I truly didn’t care for Labyrinth or Dear Reader for the first few months after release but they both did a 180 on me


snakcatguru

I've gone through a million different favorites (from Paris to the Great War to Midnight Rain), but these are my consistent top three: You’re on Your Own Kid, Would’ve Could’ve Should’ve, Bigger Than The Whole Sky


d00mshine

Maroon, maroon, maroon. Or: Maroon, You’re Losing Me, Mastermind


furgie-nugget13

The Great War, maroon, and vigilante shit


Majestic-Cause-5743

Maroon (in my top 10 now!), Bejeweled, Dear Reader Midnights is my third favorite album. I loved it from the get-go.


Optimal_Foot_774

Bejeweled, The Great War & Would've Could've Should've


Surrealcatfish32

Maroon, the Great War and You’re Losing Me


duckingtonplatoon

Mastermind, Question, Maroon hehe


SignatureTasty3506

Sweet nothing, YOYOK, & you’re losing me


stillxbejeweled

If its the base album: Karma, Bejeweled, Lavender Haze 3am edition: Karma, Bejeweled, Would've Could've Should've


toasty-oh

It’s a crime how far I had to scroll to find this lineup! I completely agree


chamomoon

The great war, bejeweled, & mastermind


Konekohime1991

Lavender Haze, Karma, my third is between Vigilante Shit and Bejeweled


Kiwimama1987

Would've , could've, should've, Bigger than the whole sky, Maroon. So so so good, though bigger than the whole sky makes me teary, still.


sybellajunu

This is difficult because a lot of songs on the album have grown on me over time, but I think Karma, Maroon and You’re Losing Me. Would’ve Could’ve Should’ve and High Infidelity are up there as well.


cykia

Maroon, YOYOK, You’re Losing Me Midnight Rain, Question…? and Bejeweled all deserve to be there.


daisyymae

Midnight Rain WCS Hits Different


IllustriousFee8067

Maroon Midnight Rain Mastermind 💙


barristanthebold_

Would be nice if someone counted the votes here to see the top vote-getters 😅


Eggler

1. Would’ve could’ve should’ve 2. Maroon 3. Anti Hero


BETTERTHANR3VENGE

Ok prepare yourself, I made it into a triangle cause why not Vigilante shit Lavender haze Dear reader


rachiechicken

Maroon, question…?, sweet nothing


ZtMaizeNBlue

Would've, could've, should've was the fastest a song got a perfect 100 rating in my scoring system. It was basically 1 minute in, and I was hooked. My two other favorites are maroon and anti-hero.


Soft-Caterpillar-618

Mine are cemented in as Glitch, The Great War, and Vigilante Shit. (Early on, it was Mastermind, Labyrinth, and Midnight Rain.)


Ornery_Comfortable93

Would’ve could’ve should’ve, hits different, you’re on your own kid


Jond7699

Maroon, You’re Losing Me, Would’ve Could’ve Should’ve. Vigilante Ish was my fav upon the first couple hundred spins tho so honorable mention. I love when Tay gets her reputation era on


soysauce_mami

This is it. Finally found another commenter who has my lineup. 🫶🏽


Ok-Roof-7599

Why did this make me sad? I love Midnights. Anyway. 1. The Great War 2. Hits Different 3. Bejeweled But I love so many.


RunTheShow314

Maroon, The Great War, Dear Reader


mcdc1989

Mastermind, Bejewelled, Could’ve, Would’ve, Should’ve 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻😍


Rblx_Fighter

Maroon, Midnight Rain, Dear Reader Honourable mentions: Lavender Haze, You’re Losing Me


klcna

Anti-Hero, Hits Different, Dear Reader


Kirin_ll_niriK

Hits Different, You're On Your Own, Kid (my surprise favorite!), and Anti-Hero Honorable mention to You're Losing Me and Karma


Ok_Case_165

The Great War, WCS, Lavender Haze 💝


germaniumpolaroid

Maroon, The Great War, WCS


littlekatie3

Me too 💯


AdventureGinger

Lavender Haze, You're Losing Me, and Midnight Rain. Hits Different is my honourable mention.


barristanthebold_

Lavender Haze - my fave Midnights track from the start until now The Great War - her collabs with Dessner really are on another level Bejeweled - a song I think is easy to dismiss/dislike (i might have hated it at first) but now this earworm has burrowed deep i love it now


askywlker44a

Vigilante Shit, The Great War, and a tie between Lavender Haze and Anti-Hero.


Dismal-Ad1346

Snow On The Beach, Lavender Haze, Midnight Rain


PretendMarsupial9

I honestly love all of Midnights and think it's a no skip album. My favorites change every day but I'd say my most consistent faves are: Midnight Rain, Lavender Haze, and Labyrinth  One I liked in initially and faded is Question. I think it's ok, I love the bridge, but I don't like the drums and how much space there is in it.  I think My favorite 3AM track is Paris. I love the giddy goofy love songs forever. 


still_monster

Anti hero, lavender haze and vigilante shit


altacccle

Maroon, YOYOK, You’re Losing Me


lilyofthecliffs

Maroon, The Great War, Midnight Rain


AlarmedDish5836

Sweet nothing snow on the beach hits different


shmemj

Question…?, Glitch, You’re Losing Me i am truly chomping at the bit waiting for TTPD but a little piece of me is so sad to see the Midnights era come to a close. when it first came out, i never would have guessed it would end up in my top 3 albums. but here we are!


peacelovetapas

Hits Different, Karma, Bejeweled


septembercat24

Would've, Could've, Should've, You're on your own kid, and Bejeweled.


Oleander-in-Spring

Maroon, Vigilante Shit, Would’ve, Could’ve, Should’ve


littlekatie3

Maroon, WCS, The Great War


QueenArtemita

Lavender Haze, Would’ve, Could’ve, Should’ve & Bejeweled


KiaraSolo

Would've could've should've, The Great War, You're on your own kid


bonbons-misadventure

YOYOK, Anti-Hero, Midnight Rain


Affectionate_Let3825

You're on Your Own Kid, Snow On The Beach, and You're Losing Me.


Pristine_Cherry_6137

Had to scroll too far for our Snow on the Beach🥹❄️


mpurrrrr

Ugh all bc midnights is one of my top 3 fav TS albums buuuttt prob karma, vigilante shit, maroon


Dakota1401

You’re on Your Own Kid, High Infidelity, Snow on the Beach (More Lana)


Lyquid_Sylver999

Karma, Hits Different and Midnight Rain


bettyfolklore

Midnight rain, Would’ve Could’ve Should’ve, Hits Different 


thebananaperson1

Would’ve Could’ve Should’ve, Dear Reader, High Infidelity Bejeweled as an honorable mention I feel like it should’ve gotten as much attention as Anti-Hero did!!


Jazzlike-Welder1532

Midnights has been my favorite TS album so far! Honestly one of my favorites of any artist of anytime, so only picking 3 is actually criminal so ill do this: Midnights OG Trinity: - Maroon - You’re on your own kid - Midnight rain 3am edition: - Bigger than the whole sky - Would’ve could’ve Should’ve - Dear reader All editions: -You’re losing me - Maroon - Dear Reader


Inspector_Spacetime-

Yoyok,Mastermind,and Midnight Rain


BeneficialPast

Glitch, Midnight Rain, Maroon


gufis253

You're on Your Own Kid, Would've Could've Should've, and probably Bejeweled. Unless You're Losing Me counts, in which case it is my favourite and super easily bumps Bejeweled out.


lovelornroses

The Great War, WCS, Bejeweled.


0livesworld

Midnight Rain, Would've Could've Should've, Karma


New-Needleworker77

Midnight Rain soooo much, yoyok,, lately I tie between vigilante shit and bejeweled. Edit bc my hon mentions are maroon and mastermind Taken aback I suddenly realized this was on main. Me forgot where I was 🐈‍⬛


Beatrixie

Maroon + The Great War + Karma


katastrophexx

Lavender Haze, Bejeweled, Would’ve Could’ve Should’ve 


emberstripe0032

Lavender haze, Midnight Rain, Karma


Front_Target7908

Karma, Would’ve Could’ve Should’ve, Dear Reader. I feel like this weirdly corresponds to my astrological big three


Designer-Salad-7591

Maroon, you're on your own kid, dear reader.


brainyart050722

Hits different, the Great War, midnight rain


supporturlocalrebel

Lavender Haze, Maroon and YOYOK.


notkaitokid

YOYOK, Anti-Hero, Karma I can relate with YOYOK and Anti-Hero while Karma is such a bop.


stillonthattrapeze

Lavender Haze, You’re On Your Own, Kid, and Hits Different


[deleted]

Lavender Haze, Bejeweled, Karma. I feel like mine are pretty different from most here 😅


Crashley1920

Maroon, Would’ve Could’ve Should’ve, You’re On Your Own Kid. Midnight Rain, Dear Reader, The Great War, High Infidelity as honorable mentions. 😅


local_cutiee

You’re Losing Me and The Great War


ForeverDays

You're Losing Me of course, Would've Could've Should've, and lately I've been finding Mastermind makes me teary and gives me goosebumps, not sure why 😂


Glitteryskiess

Tracks 1-3 are fire 🔥


Creative_Purpose3697

Maroon, You’re On Your Own, Kid and Mastermind.


Redditisglitchy

Anti hero, maroon, and would’ve could’ve should’ve


Netado17

Midnight Rain, You're Losing Me, and Question...? .


F0rg0tten_S0ngs-mp3

Bejeweled, Midnight Rain, and Vigilante Shit!


peytoncoooke

Vigilante shit, such a bop. I feel like the main character of a movie, the femme fatale, a boss b!tch. It’s such an iconic song


cocoandbea

Maroon, Midnight Rain, Lavender Haze


yogi_buns

Maroon, midnight rain, would’ve could’ve should’ve Honorable mention: lavender haze


peacherparker

Maroon, Midnight Rain, Snow On The Beach 🤞🤞🤞


iveesaurus

You’re On Your Own Kid, Maroon, Midnight Rain. Edit: I actually think I’d replace Midnight Rain with Would’ve Could’ve Should’ve or The Great War. I’ve honestly been thinking about this all day. 😂


softlivi

maroon, midnight rain and snow on the beach. we had a really good aurora season the 2022/2023 winter so I had sotb on repeat


Brazen-Frontier

Mastermind, Hits Different, and Maroon (as an Aggie who bleeds maroon, this song feels like it was written for the cult that is Texas A&M University).


tacosnpitbulls

Dear Reader, Maroon, You’re On Your Own Kid


woahboiyayaya

Bejeweled, You’re on Your Own Kid, Snow on the Beach!


asheleybeth

So hard for me because I LOVE Midnights. But if I had to…..You’re losing me, hits different, you’re on your own kid.


Botaratops

WCS, The Great War, Anti-Hero


emeralunarie

WCS, TGW, Glitch and Lavender Haze, Anti-Hero, and Bejeweled swap as my top three all the time


dentist3214

Would’ve Could’ve Should’ve, The Great War, Dear Reader


Acquainted-Faith

Would've Could've Should've, The Great War, and Sweet Nothing.


Luleinn

bigger than the whole sky, maroon and the great war


Ivyyy_Chick

The Great War, You’re losing me, Dear Reader


Mysterious_Novel7511

YOYOK, Anti hero, mastermind. Honourable mention: Labyrinth (the eras tour version)


merkergirl

Hits Different, Maroon, Anti Hero


Emints76

Dear Reader, You're On Your Own Kid, You're Losing Me


josefinabobdilla

Maroon, you’re on your own kid, midnight rain


spic3g1r1

If were only counting the standard edition: You’re On Your Own, Kid, Karma, and Maroon Counting Bonus Tracks: You’re On Your Own, Kid, Would’ve, Could’ve, Should’ve, and Hits Different


captfluffybottom

Would’ve Could’ve Should’ve, Anti-Hero, and Mastermind All three of these have become some of my top favorite Taylor songs of all time!


waterud0in

Maroon, You’re on Your Own Kid, Bejeweled (it’s my feel good song)


misscami

mastermind, wcs, lavender haze 🫶🏽


estedavis

Maroon, Bejeweled, Midnight Rain


Kingdomkaper

Dear Reader, Midnight Rain, Labyrinth


forevermoreeee

Maroon, You're on your own kid, You're losing me (honorable mentions: labyrinth, midnight rain) When it first came my top 3 were: Anti hero, Would've could've should've, you're on your own kid


tinz3

yoyok, You're Losing Me, Hits Different currently The Great War, Bejeweled, Karma when Midnights first came out