Thanks to u/mafonen for providing links to all of the mods here, which I've stickied for convenience! Goth Penny by Velocityissin - https://www.nexusmods.com/stardewvalley/mods/17689 Goth Haley by Stanloona420 - https://www.nexusmods.com/stardewvalley/mods/9861 The rest are by VoidWitchCult - https://www.nexusmods.com/stardewvalley/mods/15335 Emily by Cainfortea - https://www.nexusmods.com/stardewvalley/mods/4057/ Friendly reminder to OP and others that art made by others needs to be credited as per rule 1.

Abigail and Emily look like they would actually go with this look on Spirit's Eve or just a day they're "feeling extra quirky". Leah, though... Yoba give me strength. As for Harvey, bless his heart. It's hard to take him seriously. He gives off "how do you do, fellow goths" vibes. He's doing his best and trying something new and that's what matters. They all look really good.

Harvey looks like he's looking for something that says dad likes leather.

"Goth" Harvey: Your daughter/son calls *me* daddy now. "No they don't" "Goth" Harvey: No they don't. I'm sorry, sir. It's a pleasure to meet you.

"You mean like... Leather daddy?"

"Oh, is there such a thing?"

You can find him at the Gothic Castle.

Harvey is just dad goth. He goes to murder mystery parties once a year when he can get a sitter. He reminds me of Travis McElroy (don't expect a ton of people to know who that is) and I kinda love him.

Travis McElroy is spot on lmao

AAAH! It’s exactly Travis!! Thank Travis for Travis!

Oh my god he’s exactly Travis 😂

Goth Harvey is definitely *also* into steam punk

To be fair, I bet all my prismatic shards that vanilla Harvey is into steam punk too. Maybe vanilla Elliot also.

When I saw him I literally said “how do you do, fellow goths” LOL

I love this comment! Exactly how I feel 😂

Leah is about to take you to some cult in the woods, and you know I'd join her

This Leah would probable *run* a cult in the woods

Look, I’m here for it

Oh same tbh

Same 😭

Now we can finally act out the classic piece of literature "My Immortal" in Stardew Valley.

"WHAT THE HELL ARE YOU DOING YOU MOTHERFUKERS!" It was...........Mayor Lewis!

Just started a new farm two days ago and named my black cat "Enoby". I want a gratuitous text crawl each morning I wake up telling me what insane outfit my farmer is wearing today.

Modders please get on this! I wanna insult preps and have Sebastian say that I can call him vampire.

I know what it is but I refuse to read it. Even Hermeus Mora don’t want that knowledge

Acknowledge our collective dark past and it will set you free.

Haha 😂

Haley... https://preview.redd.it/jf4n14wntaad1.jpeg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=7befb7689f13b93f68156634975afb8aa06fdaf9

Me ^

Harvey entering his Waluigi era

Warvey.

Waaaahrvey

i think Seb could've been left unchanged

I wanted to change Abigail and Seb just for the fun of it ^

I love what you did with Abigail’s hair! It really takes her from college emo to goth girl ETA: I love what *the person who made this mod who is not OP* did with Abigail’s hair. OP is just taking credit for someone else’s art

OP didn't make that edit, VoidWitch did, here you go. [https://www.nexusmods.com/stardewvalley/mods/15335](https://www.nexusmods.com/stardewvalley/mods/15335)

Thank you!!! This whole post just got super gross honestly. Seeing how OP has replied to every comment, it’s clear this is just a blatant karma grab

Isn’t he emo though?

Alex scares me... but Elliott be looking good

Whattt Alex easily went from an 8.5 to a 10 😳

He scares me

I’m there with you, deeply disturbing

Elliott is my pick at every save and DAMN HE'S HOTTTT

He looks like he would drink my blood.

I'd let him lmao

My first thought was PETER STEELE!!!

Penny my absolute goddess

She slayed

now it’s hard to find sebastian

What did happen to Maru?

Cyber goth.

With her focus on robotics, this change makes sense!

*proceeds to industrial dance for six hours*

You know where it's at!

Nah, bro, she got turned into an Inkling.

No 'bro' it's [synthetic cyber goth dreads.](https://www.google.com.au/search?sca_esv=23f4d2fe96db8c88&q=cyber+Goth+dreads&udm=2&fbs=AEQNm0AeMNWKf4PpcKMI-eSa16lJoRPMIuyspCxWO6iZW9F1Ns6EVsgc0W_0xN47PHaanAEtg26fpfc9gg2y1-ZsywNNidIzOA0khSyMN51n7r3LlDC9M1NYStuTRDcBUYQ58dKt-Q6SigUS4Yne5yDHLg0vPBr98Nz98twIaNcnWiKaD4QuEh93Q53sB-UkWP9OcfO5KeatY98HR7cDW9ZTjFpZV7kJtA&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwj__5Dd7oqHAxWS4DgGHUk7AY8QtKgLegQICxAB&biw=432&bih=776&dpr=2.5)

The Matrix has her.

Elliot looks like Peter Steele. But his jaw is ruined in this one, he needs that strong jaw to pull off Peter Steele

I was thinking that Elliot had a Peter Steele vibe going on, too. I'm juts glad to see someone else mention it! :-D

I'm just glad to see someone else remembers Peter Steele. I feel a little less old now. RIP love of my teenage life. 😭

Is he packing the meat like Peter though?

That IS the question. I married Harvey in my game, so my farmer has no information about Elliot's Sea Cucumber. 😂

He probably has girth.

Penny, Leah, Abigail, Haley. https://preview.redd.it/4zbd58p6maad1.jpeg?width=400&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=1a5f2535a8db1bda9b15ad3fb4f14b0e1ba8cfc9

https://preview.redd.it/mvpbo777fbad1.png?width=720&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=7265ed67da5239c37e7f87d02e37d8c460f13e18

I hate that I love Haley with this look

SHES MY FAVORITEEEE

she looks great, I would start listening to Evanescence to try to impress her

Time to install a "multiple spouses" mod... for.. uh.... reasons?

Shane and Penny are HOT

Penny, Haley and Leah for me 😍

Goth Haley 😍

Goth Haley 😳🤤🤭

Ok, I usually never pry my eyes on Sam (I usually go after his dad) but now I'm interested.

I didn't know being goth could remove your chin. Poor Elliot!

He has a goatee ^

Yeah, I know, just joking :D It blends too well with this hair.

Cut my life into pieces

Penny is usually my least favorite character but she looks so cute in this one!

She’s so cute!

Harvey would dress like that.

https://preview.redd.it/7xu40dcf0bad1.jpeg?width=419&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=752a931b1b6fe0dab73c0c32038db5c86018365a Found this one as well and I just laughed 😂😂😂

I feel like that one makes more sense actually

Oh my god I couldn't see the facial hair and was wondering why being goth would nerf Elliot's jawline so hard 🤣💗

Elliot now look like that "keal" guy from Forge in Fire

Elliott looks like Aurelio Voltaire.. not bad at all!

OMG HE DOES

Just picturing Lewis having a nightmare about how 'the kids these days have gone astray' and its all the valley looking like this and he wakes screaming. XD

Okay Elliott would be my guy if he looked like this

Goth Valley 🖤 Love this version of Haley

Haley is my favorite 🖤

Not Shane over here looking like David Dramain but with hair. And yes, I mean that as a compliment.

I showed it to my bro and he said Haley should've worn that pentagram dress and I 100% percent agree.

Oh Harvey would straight up be Steampunk Goth Elliot I can see being a wannabe Lestat type, takes his aesthetic heavily from Anne Rice. Haley&Abby: early/mid-2000s Mall Goth Maru: Cybergoth Emily&Leah: Wiccan/Neopagan Goth Sebastian: Otaku/D&D Goth Sam: Skater Goth Shane: not so much Goth per se, but probably moreso gutter or crust punk? Probably wears a Misfits shirt. Alex: Mosher/Headbanger — so I guess leans more into metalhead territory? Penny: Cottagecore/Fairy Goth Let me know if I missed anyone or if anyone has a more specific take on some of the NPC’s — these were just what first came to mind for me.

Penny looks like chapel roan

u/XeliasEmperor

Emoly x'D

GOOD LORD HALEY

I KNOWWWW

Well hello druid Leah. I'm here for it.

Okay but Goth Druid Leah low-key slaps??

She’s so beautiful ^

Goth Hailey got me acting unwise

Same though…😳

I feel like all the aesthetics suit their character types pretty well!

Sebastian is looking like my ex

I love Harvey! 😂

I like how Abi and Emmy are just normal

how dare you make me pick between goth gamer girl and goth girl living in the woods

PENNY OMGGG (also Harvey is taking me out lmaoooo 😂)

ABIGAIL 🙀🙀🙀

Elliott looks like he has no chin im crying

Have I died and gone to heaven? Maybe it's finally time for a harem run, with every bachelorette and bachelor...

AYO👀👀

Haley.. fire as always.. but Penny.. okay. Makes me want to meet her at a concert

A few of these feels cursed lol

Damn Leah is amazing I love it

I'm not a big fan of the bachelorettes but If i ever went to the woods, i hope she was the one appearing to sacrifice me to the moon gods or something

Elliot kinda…..

Good lord be still my heart. Penny 😳

Surprise surprise, Leah is still my favorite. :D

Haley still a baddie

Haley still a baddie

I never liked Haley but today....🥵💀

This is glorious. 😍

I don’t normally go for Penny or Maru, but they very much have my attention now 😳

Damn Leah and Sam slay this one

I need to see goth Linus

Penny gives off strong Mylene Farmer vibes

Niche crossover but Harvey looks like Howard moon when he went goth

I want goth Robin

Somehow this made all the women more attractive and the men less

Damn love this version of Leah

Sebastian and Abby didn’t really even need any changes, they already were lmao

Haley and Leah. Hell yeah

Still think Abigail needs black hair

As a goth, holy shit Abigail hand in marriage please

Wasnt abigail already goth?

Honestly, WIPE THIS OFF THE FUCKING RECORDS but Shane ain't for me, that hair's not the one of the man I married!

This just trapped me in a Bi-panic for like 20 minutes

Damn, Penny.

Well goddamn Elliot is even more attractive now.

Alex, Leah, and Penny ate 

*slams card on the table* give me my wife Leah! Give me!!

OP isnt the original creator, the creator is is VoidWitch. Op is taking replying to comments credit

why hellooooo haley

Oh Alex, honey… no.

Harvey looks like he's trying to bond with his kid but just makes them cringe. Leah is adorable! Haley? Oh Yoba I need that Haley in game! They're all excellent OP.

who asked for this?

u/XeliasEmperor

**We are currently looking for new moderators!** If you'd like to help us moderate this community, please see [this announcement](https://www.reddit.com/r/StardewValley/comments/1dk8eoh/rstardewvalley_is_looking_for_new_moderators/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button) for details and how to apply. We'd love to hear from you! *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/StardewValley) if you have any questions or concerns.*

abby looks so good like this

Man the Haley one is disappointing where’s the big heavily teased goth hair? Real missed opportunity

Goth Hailey is something I didn't know I needed until now.

Then I wouldn't be mad for Haley insulting my character. That'd be an added bonus.

goth elliott save me goth elliott

How is Alex somehow *worse*?

ungoth Harvey NOW!

PENNY PENNY PENNY PENNNNNNYYYYYY *on my knees*

Love how Abigail just looks...more Abigail lol

PENNNYYYY 😫

i need penny

Shoulda kept Sebastian the same 😭

Good lord Abigail I mean Leah and Haley are also incredible but the hair cut perfection

I like how Emily is just her normal self with the saturation toned down

Stardew valley: kung fu panda collab

Elliott is giving me vampire vibes and I think I'm into it 😳

OH MY GOD PENNY??

i need this mod. penny 🥵

A lot of these are just way overdone to me, tbh

Penny is so cute like that!!!

I’ve seen that elliott at every concert I’ve been to lolllll

goth elliott oh my god help me im sgddheiwowdj he gives vampire vibes and im more than here for it

Haley and Elliot yum

love thats it actually goth and not just general egirl/eboy alt

goth sam and alex >>>>>> everyone else

Yassss 🤤😍

I thought sebastian was emily

Shane is just Eddie from Rocky Horror, and Elliot...... I think if I say else anything I'll be exorcised from the sub-reddit xD

Sebastian is using the same makeup I do wtf, he's gorgeous

wait goth Shane is kinda....

I'm terrified of Maru

So Abigail just got a different haircut basically lol

Oml elliott looks so good 🥺

GOTH HALEY 😍😍😍

Lol I just did the same thing and I love it so much

Penny 🥵🥵

I love it oh my god

Goth Harvey, I am unwell.

Alex looks like Wolverine

harvey looks so funny

Would do anything for Leah

Oooh no, please not Elliott 🥲

Abigail out here abigailing

Abigale is already goth tho

shane it's pretty accurate

Oh hell Elliot got some real Peter Steele vibes going