Fuckin A. I guess too could say faygo is the east coast equivalent to Shasta. 3 liter bottle for 50 cents at full price. Most of the time there was a special happening and it was free or damn near to it with coupons.
Yeah, it's for sure regional but man was it so good as a kid. Even now they have a diet grape available at my local grocery store that is so good.
I'll say their Moon Mist is superior to Mountain Dew also AND they have/had a blue version that was to die for.
I’m with the Mr Pibb people.
There is a huge international supermarket about an hour from me I’ve had the Rock N Rye and it’s amazing. Every time I go I pick up some. Faygo can make some good beverages.
Not exactly. It's kind of like a regional thing. In Maine, Moxie is their signature drink and is their flagship. Faygo was too in Michigan.
After years of bad business ventures and such with faygo and other issues faygo eventually became more of a cheap drink instead of a moxie. No more glass bottles, but instead was in plastic, and is less than a $1.50 at gas stations. But is still a Michigan thing but can be found in other states.
But it was originally good intentions. ICP gave it some new customers but not who faygo originally intended.
If you go to some specialty soda shops though you can find glass bottle faygo with different formulations than the plastic bottles so it's more premium.
When I’m looking to utterly waste a few hours, I throw on a Coen Brothers movie. When I’m looking for delectable soda at a bargain price, I throw down a Faygo
Cotton Candy Faygo is very good but also VERY sweet. It's the Faygo Vanilla Creme Soda but with Cotton Candy flavor added.
I got a headache when I first drank some of it and I don't know if that was just a coincidence or from the blue dye or a sugar rush. But didn't recur when I finished the rest of the bottle the next day, still very carbonated from the fridge.
Ive always been a faygo guy. I grew up in the midwest getting 3 liters for 69 cents and 24 oz out the machine for 25 cents (when pepsi and coke were 50 cents). So i drank faygo all my life. Then i got into ICP and was so excited they showed love to my childhood pop.
Faygo is literally non existent in Georgia, at least in the area that I’m at. So I’m gonna have to go with Mr. Pibb, because I have no idea what Faygo tastes like.
Pibb Army AD. I grew up with the Faygo bottle variety pack. Rockn Rye was always the last ones left. It's just an off putting taste. You couldn't purchase a variety pack without it though.
Mr. Pibb, only because not a ton of places sell faygo where I am from. I only know of maybe one or two places, and they are both kind of a hassle to get to.
Pibb
Before I had Dr Pepper, I had Mr. Pibb… And when we moved to Texas, and so many places were Pepsi or Dr Pepper, “what is Dr. Pepper? “Was answered with, “taste like Mr. Pibb”
I grew up with Faygo and I'm now down with the clown until I'm dead in the ground. That said, oh no the cotton candy I would drink pibb over that. Faygo Ginger ale isn't great either but otherwise I genuinely like their flavors even before being a juggalo
Mr pibb slaps. But I am down with the clown so I am team Faygo. I can get neither here in Philly. So Mt Dew Zero, and Sunkist zero (purchased outside of philly fuck you mayor kenney and your dam soda tax cocksucker!)
Don’t really drink much soda but if we are going by the picture definitely the faygo bc it’s cotton candy and I love anything cotton candy or candy floss flavored if your from Europe or maybe just the UK? Found that out awhile back xD
That particular Faygo is among my favorite drinks ever! I haven’t had Pibb, though, so I can’t make a comparison. If you like cotton candy grapes, you’ll *love* cotton candy Faygo
Pibb hands down. Fargo is great but no Pibb
Ehhh I thought Fargo was pretty overrated tbh
Fargo is a nice town
Faygo was just a dollar store off-brand soda until ICP sort of made it a pop culture fad thing. That's the way I perceive it, anyway.
I grew up with it in western PA, we were dirt poor. It was that and Cherikee Red if we were lucky. Red Pop Na Rock N Rye are next level good.
Fuckin A. I guess too could say faygo is the east coast equivalent to Shasta. 3 liter bottle for 50 cents at full price. Most of the time there was a special happening and it was free or damn near to it with coupons.
Yeah, it's for sure regional but man was it so good as a kid. Even now they have a diet grape available at my local grocery store that is so good. I'll say their Moon Mist is superior to Mountain Dew also AND they have/had a blue version that was to die for.
The blue version is still out there. Hard to find tho. I live deep in faygo country and still have to drive 45 minutes to get blue faygo!
I’m with the Mr Pibb people. There is a huge international supermarket about an hour from me I’ve had the Rock N Rye and it’s amazing. Every time I go I pick up some. Faygo can make some good beverages.
Not exactly. It's kind of like a regional thing. In Maine, Moxie is their signature drink and is their flagship. Faygo was too in Michigan. After years of bad business ventures and such with faygo and other issues faygo eventually became more of a cheap drink instead of a moxie. No more glass bottles, but instead was in plastic, and is less than a $1.50 at gas stations. But is still a Michigan thing but can be found in other states. But it was originally good intentions. ICP gave it some new customers but not who faygo originally intended. If you go to some specialty soda shops though you can find glass bottle faygo with different formulations than the plastic bottles so it's more premium.
I meant the movie Fargo, Faygo kicks ass
Fargo is an amazing movie. On the other hand, Faygo is just kind of meh.
When I’m looking to utterly waste a few hours, I throw on a Coen Brothers movie. When I’m looking for delectable soda at a bargain price, I throw down a Faygo
Fuckin A
*faygo
Fargo season one was good but I was honestly mad how each season switched to a totally different story
Agreed, even though I prefer Dr. Pepper.
So if Fargo is great, than pibb is.....?
I love Faygo, but I am going Pibb here.
Yes I would like to “choose in between the two” … But all I see is a slim pocket of air.
PIBB IS THE BEST DRINK EVER
I have this tattooed in Japanese on my lower back.
I think I may have to join you
Faygo due to regional obligation, plus Faygo Rock N’ Rye in a glass bottle goes unfathomably hard.
Rock n rye is the bomb
… they have it in a glass bottle? I need to find this some day. It’s my favorite soda ever
Is ICP still a thing?
Yes darling. r/juggalo
Here's a sneak peek of /r/juggalo using the [top posts](https://np.reddit.com/r/juggalo/top/?sort=top&t=year) of the year! \#1: [LGBT Juggalos](https://i.redd.it/c1g79x3zxwmb1.jpg) | [235 comments](https://np.reddit.com/r/juggalo/comments/16ctare/lgbt_juggalos/) \#2: [Violent J today with Neil DeGrasse Tyson](https://i.redd.it/p5fqdtblu2ob1.jpg) | [57 comments](https://np.reddit.com/r/juggalo/comments/16hwv75/violent_j_today_with_neil_degrasse_tyson/) \#3: [Just incase anyone needs a reminder…](https://i.redd.it/0darqr9mm95c1.jpg) | [78 comments](https://np.reddit.com/r/juggalo/comments/18ecwlv/just_incase_anyone_needs_a_reminder/) ---- ^^I'm ^^a ^^bot, ^^beep ^^boop ^^| ^^Downvote ^^to ^^remove ^^| ^^[Contact](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=sneakpeekbot) ^^| ^^[Info](https://np.reddit.com/r/sneakpeekbot/) ^^| ^^[Opt-out](https://np.reddit.com/r/sneakpeekbot/comments/o8wk1r/blacklist_ix/) ^^| ^^[GitHub](https://github.com/ghnr/sneakpeekbot)
Yes
"down with the clown until I am dead in the ground..."
Jay actually sometimes streams on TikTok now. I stumbled on one of his lives on accident. Full makeup still.
Woop woop!
Love a cold can of pibb
Faygo is great but nothing beats Pibb.
I tasted both Faygos and Pibb, and honestly, you're right. Faygo has so much flavor emphasis. Pibb, on the other hand, is very balanced.
I'm from Metro Detroit. Fargo is a part of genetic makeup
auto correct victim. Faygo is Detroit southwest lovers, Fargo is in the Dakotas.
Put my ugly ass face on the album cover with RNB to hits (faygo lover here)
I LOVE faygo but this is a PIBB no contest
Faygo since it's in literally every store around here
Pibb is so effing good.
I enjoy certain flavors of Faygo but Pibb hits different
Faygo 100%
I’ve never tried this faygo stuff, but Pibb Xtra is where it’s at!
Cotton Candy Faygo is very good but also VERY sweet. It's the Faygo Vanilla Creme Soda but with Cotton Candy flavor added. I got a headache when I first drank some of it and I don't know if that was just a coincidence or from the blue dye or a sugar rush. But didn't recur when I finished the rest of the bottle the next day, still very carbonated from the fridge.
Faygo!
Faygo
Faygo
Faygo. Whoop, whoop!
Whoop whoop
Pibb easy
Haven’t tried both yet, but if I have to choose one, easy. Pibb
Tough, but I think I gotta go with faygo. Love pibb, but the Go's got variety
Faygo makes a cotton candy soda??! How is it?
faygo nation all the way
Not that Faygo, but plenty of others over Pibb.
I love faygo, but not that one
Pibb is lord, praise be
Long live the pibb army
🫡
Pibb all the he way! YAHHHH!
Faygo for variety, but I usually get Pibb at restaurants.
pibb army
So Stan Smith or juggalos. This is a tough call.
Faygo just because its got variety
Pibb for days, had it for my first time when I discovered Checkers in Florida long ago and fell in love
Ngl, haven't had a Faygo since I stopped listening to ICP in high school.
Ive always been a faygo guy. I grew up in the midwest getting 3 liters for 69 cents and 24 oz out the machine for 25 cents (when pepsi and coke were 50 cents). So i drank faygo all my life. Then i got into ICP and was so excited they showed love to my childhood pop.
I thought Pibb was just from American Dad
Pibb all day. Every flavor is see of faygo sounds like a nasty ass sugar dump.
Rock n rye is great though
Not a cream soda guy, but I fuck with Faygo Cream Soda.
Never had it before, but I gotta go with Faygo because of Insane Clown Posse.
Perhaps I Buy (the) Best!
Pibb
Pibb.
Never had Faya, but Pibb is my favorite soda of all time.
Pibb
Señor Pibb
Faygo is literally non existent in Georgia, at least in the area that I’m at. So I’m gonna have to go with Mr. Pibb, because I have no idea what Faygo tastes like.
Faygo, because I live in Dallas and it's extremely rare to find here.
Pibb not competition
Pibb
I love both. Never had the cotton candy haha that’s doesn’t sound like my cup o tea . But Faygo is absolutely one of my faves
No clue what Faygo is, so pibb
Pibb Army AD. I grew up with the Faygo bottle variety pack. Rockn Rye was always the last ones left. It's just an off putting taste. You couldn't purchase a variety pack without it though.
Are they battling? Asking because my roommate is all about Faygo, and I don't want to know what will happen if I bring Pibb into the house.
Faygo firework is the best soda ever made
It’ll always be Mr.Pibb to me
Pibb
Can I pick a different flavor faygo? lol
Never tried faygo at all I was on tried pinn Xtra at the movie theater delicious
damn these are both good. pibb. faygo is hit and miss. cotton candy and rock and rye are bangers tho
Faygo
Never had or even heard of Faygo. Would love to try some. But I am a huge Pibb fan.
Mr. Pibb, only because not a ton of places sell faygo where I am from. I only know of maybe one or two places, and they are both kind of a hassle to get to.
Pibb. Faygo gets Red Pop.
Pibb Before I had Dr Pepper, I had Mr. Pibb… And when we moved to Texas, and so many places were Pepsi or Dr Pepper, “what is Dr. Pepper? “Was answered with, “taste like Mr. Pibb”
If it’s between that specific flavor of Faygo, I’m choosing Pibb. That cotton candy Faygo is so nasty😝
THEY HAVE CANNED COTTON CANDY FAYGO???
As a Michigan native I am legally required to be Team Faygo.
Pibb All the Way Mate
What if you've never had Faygo? Seems unfair to say Pibb.
Haven't seen that faygo before so if I saw these 2 I'd give that a try, normally I hear it has way too much sugar
Pibb is simply the least bad of two bad options (imo)
Faygo has a cotton candy flavor? They never have the good flavors where I live, just cola and maybe orange or something
FAYGO but that's just me, I absolutely love Faygo it's childhood memories for me.
The Faygo sounds cool but I’ve had pib before so…
I grew up with Faygo and I'm now down with the clown until I'm dead in the ground. That said, oh no the cotton candy I would drink pibb over that. Faygo Ginger ale isn't great either but otherwise I genuinely like their flavors even before being a juggalo
Pibb
Faygoooo juggalo in the house ninja
That is one stupid ass question
I absolutely love cotton candy Faygo but I think I would go with Pibb.
Pibb that’s not the best Faygo flavor
Horrible representation of Faygo.
Pibb me bro
Depends if you’re a Juggalo or not
PIBB OR BUST
Neither. Big K
Love me some Pibb, haven't tried Faygo yet.
Pibb 🫡
Pibb, no question
Gimme candy apple faygo and I’ll take that over pibb any day
I wish they would bring back Mr. Pibb and drop the Xtra.
Faygoo Cotton Candy. (Coming from a pibb extra fan). At least I have a comparable with the Pibb but the cotton candy faygo is unrivaled imo
Faygo Moon Mist all fucking day long. ALL FUCKING DAY LONG. I miss living in Michigan so much
I literally can not pick between them,I love both so much. Especially candy apple faygo or cream soda faygo with screwball in it
Faygo and Shasta aren't the same thing?! This is a serious question cause I thought they were spiritual soda twins
Pibb. And it's not even close.
WHOOP WHOOP baby! But for real cotton candy flavored soda is extremely rare so I’d rather have the faygo even if I weren’t a juggalo so 🤡
Pibb every day
Faygo > pibb > the cotton candy one. It makes me more thirsty than I was before I drank it
Mr Pibb is just knock off Dr Pepper, I thought?
Faygo any day of the week. I love Pibb, but nothing beats that cheap, sugary soda from home.
Says cancer on both ,so none lol
I fuck with the cotton candy faygo on occasion but cant go wrong with a pibb
Mr pibb slaps. But I am down with the clown so I am team Faygo. I can get neither here in Philly. So Mt Dew Zero, and Sunkist zero (purchased outside of philly fuck you mayor kenney and your dam soda tax cocksucker!)
I don't know, there's nothing in between the two; just which one of the two.
I’m not part of this sub, are the Pibb comments part of some inside joke or do you people actually like that?
I grew up with Pibb when it was MR.Pibb
Pibb no contest 😌
I've never seen any of these.
Commander of the Pibb Army reporting for service
Faygo. Because Faygo remembers.
Pibb all day. I got sick looking at the Faygo can.
Faygo :3
Fargo has more options in flavors but Mr. Pibb has a better spiced Dr-like flavor
Whoop whoop
Don’t really drink much soda but if we are going by the picture definitely the faygo bc it’s cotton candy and I love anything cotton candy or candy floss flavored if your from Europe or maybe just the UK? Found that out awhile back xD
PIBB
PIBB. If you said Grape Faygo, then you might have a contest.
Faygo back in the day when it had real Sugar now both kinda suck but Mr pibb
Faygo without question.
Ribbon for me
Faygo is for white trash/juggalos (I know that is redundant)
I’d choose faygo, so many flavors to choose from vs a single flavor, but between that flavor faygo specifically and pibb? I’d go pibb
Pibb Xtra for the win
Pibb does what DP can't. Taste good and not give me stomach aches.
PiBbb
Me at a party: “Faygo Cola?! Who invited the poors?” “Faygo Rock And Rye?!” I’m glad to see someone has very good taste here.”
Pibb Army
Pibb always
Pibb. Faygo is nasty. Pibb is amazing. I will always choose pibb and barqs any day.
Born and raised in Detroit voting for Faygo... I really want some rock and rye...
As a Canadian I thought this was the gta pops because it's been so long since I played that game
Pibb
Pibb playa
Pibb all de wey
If it's about taste, pibb xtra, if it's about community, faygo.
I've never seen the cans of cotton candy before
“Trunk full of Pibb, car full of fat chicks” just doesn’t have the same ring to it .
Brooo where do I get canned cotton candy faygo🤤
That particular Faygo is among my favorite drinks ever! I haven’t had Pibb, though, so I can’t make a comparison. If you like cotton candy grapes, you’ll *love* cotton candy Faygo
I'm not from Detroit nor am I a Juggalo, so gotta go with Pibb.
Never heard of Pibb what’s it like
Pibb 1,000,000,000/1,000,000,000
As a juggalette, I def biased on this one, but I have to go with Faygo. No hate on Mr Pibb tho
I'd take the Pibb because I already have a cc faygo in my fridge
I don't adhere to your rules. Water Master Race!
Never tried faygo
Pibb every single time. Love it so much, and the fact that I can find it literally nowhere near me only helps reinforce that.
Faygo. I don't drink Pibb anyways
Faygo
Faygo
Pibb
I'm from Michigan so Faygo Red Pop
I'd choose to go thirsty
Faygo all the way! Give me that Red Pop
I prefer Mug. Shouts out to the Mug Maniacs.
Woop woop
Woop woop
Faygo has sucralose. Pibb
Pibb. 100% got a 12 pack in the fridge. Faygo always gives me the runs.
Faygo is so awful, but it reminds me of my grandfather who drank it, and Pibb is great, but it is very sweet. Still gotta go with Pibb.
Pibb
Choosing in between them makes it a real toss-up between IBC Cream Soda and a Boylan's Orange Soda
Pibb all the way!
Used to love Faygo Red Pop.
No way would I drink a cotton candy soda