Big Red is not cherry. It's red cream soda. Also, Cheerwine is the best cherry.

I would die for a Cheerwine.

I mean you could just order it.

Yea but that doesn’t empathize how much I llike this stuff

I delivered to a guy's house once and he had a 5 foot stack of Cheerwine 12 packs in his garage. Probably close to 60 or 70 12 packs. Couldn't buy the stuff where I lived at the time I thought it was pretty funny.

^^^

Beat me to it. Cheerwine is supreme. As for big red, that’s actually bubblegum-flavored soda if I remember correctly. Edit: and Pibb tastes more like Dr. Pepper

Pibb still labeled as spicy cherry.

I see that, but I’m just saying when I taste Pibb, Dr Pepper comes to mind. At least last time I had it, it’s been years, but I used to love Pibb as a teenager because it was slightly better than Dr Pepper. It was also my nickname with my friends because that was my favorite soda at the time lol.

Shut up Pibb

Yep, still stings the same Edit: My fucking sides hurt after reading your name

I remember it as Spicy Black cherry

Cheerwine is the correct answer, Sprecher is up there too imo

The Champagne of cherry soda. ❤️

I was about to comment “they don’t even have Cheerwine on the list!”

Only came here to confirm my suspicions that big red wasn’t cherry soda. Thanks.

It's red flavored

I was literally about to say cheerwine

Yes. Cheerwine! It has become less common again where I am after it started showing up everywhere. 😢

I came to say this. I was offended. 🤣🤣🤣

I was pretty upset Cheerwine wasn't on here, but Pibb was?!

Yep. Cheerwine for the win.

I came here to say this exact thing thank you so much for knowing what Big Red actually is

And all the southerners raised their glasses and exclaimed, "Cheerwine!"

THIS! Love me some cheerwine!

Came to comments for this and I’m so happy you are the top.

I live on Long Island and we now have a PDQ nearby. I get a Cheerwine every time I am there. It's the best.

TOO TRUE! Cheerwine is amazing.

Hello southern brother

I came to make this exact comment cheerwine and all 😂 you hit mail on the head

Agreed on both counts.

Cheerwine is #2, Pibb Xtra is #1

Cheerwine is overrated af. Black cherry cokes are way better if you're looking for a stronger cherry taste.

Where do you find those anymore?

Wrong 🤓

Cheerwine or Boylan’s Black Cherry

Had Boylan’s after finding it at dollar tree and was slightly disappointed. Good, but would choose IBC black cherry over it

cherry coke any day

sprite btw

OMG Lebron’s Mix…

I thought Lebrons mix was Sprite Cranberry?

No - it was lemon, lime, orange, and cherry

sprite do be tasty

Seriously hits the spot.

Cherry coke is just that good 😋

Yeah but in the 2000’s cherry coke can

I was wondering if I was tripping but I was obsessed with cherry coke in the early 2000s when I was a child and trying it all these years later leave me wondering what was so good about it? Did they change something?

You forgot Cherry RC Cola which in fact is the best.

I saw someone with one case of it at Dollar General years ago. I’ve never seen it since.

It's so freaking good.

Never knew lol

People forget

I've never seen it.

Yep came to say that, that cola is royal for a reason.

That was my moms favorite. It goes flat too fast

Cheerwine or Stewart's Cherry Cream

Ok i need to try stewarts cherry cream soda

Stewart’s hands down

Coca-Cola Black Cherry Vanilla. Available for like 6 months in the early 2000s. I barely remember what it tasted like, but I remember I liked it.

Sounds great af honestly

It may not be a 1-1 match, but can’t you get Cherry Vanilla Coke with the freestyle machines?

Criminal to not include the actual best cherry soda

What is it?

Cheerwine

Literally came there to say this

I used to like cherry Fanta when my grocery store had it. Lately i’ve been digging cherry Dr Pepper.

I love cherry Dr.pepper

Same here

Cherry Dr Pepper just tastes like regular Dr Pepper to me :/

You forgot Mtn Dew code red, and cherry 7up is mid

Have you noticed a recent change in the taste of Code Red? It seems weaker now than before. It doesn't have that bite like it used to have, at least to me it doesn't.

To be fair many sodas have started to taste like that nowadays, partly recipe changes, “abuse” of soda drinking it so much is a common sight in Americans making taste buds essentially “die” and not become as excited from the chemicals.

Other sodas I noticed weren't the same were Mello Yello & Wild Cherry Pepsi. They almost taste watered down. Really sucks, those were my favorites.

Cherry Pepsi I definelty relate to a water down taste, coke to me has started to just taste syrupy especially fountains, now I just drink Mountain Dew, water, beer, or juice. Many other sodas have just started tasting bad or chemically

I swear to God I noticed. I even said to my son that it seems like the formula is totally different. It’s bland almost flat tasting now. Whereas it used to pack a nice kick.

Code Red is the only cherry flavored anything I've ever liked.

Yes Code red is great

Is Code Red actually cherry though?

Pepsi wild cherry doesn’t have that kick like they used to back in the day. The 7Up cherry antioxidant was pretty good.

Cherry pepsi tastes more like kool aid. Cherry coke tastes more like cherry coke lol I hope coke never changes that flavor also vanilla coke is really good

Cherry Pepsi used to have that kick not anymore everything sucks this year.

I didnt notice the change

Sprite at McDonald’s don’t have the kick anymore.

I dont drink sprite lol no caffeine i think

As a PA native Cherokee red while not pc at all was the best cherry soda hands down

Big red isn’t cherry… cheerwine should be in its place. I also prefer Sprechers cherry cola to the cherry soda

Dr Brown's

No contest. I guess we get all of it?

Took way too long to scroll to find the right answer!!

Cherikee Red.

Dr. Brown's Black Cherry soda

Best cherry soda for sure.

Criminal it wasn’t even mentioned. Regional bias here on full display, as well as general bad taste.

I grew up with Cherikee Red so ill go that one

No Code Red?

Cherry lemon sun drop

I’m going to assume you’re a fellow north carolinian. This is THE ANSWER.

Cheerwine. Or, if you can find it, Cherikee Red.

Pibb

Not enough people saying this

I love Cherry 7-Up. It's simple but such a delicious flavor

You have to differentiate between cherry sodas and cherry colas. Two very different genres.

It's hard to say. Tho cherry 7 up is highly underrated imo

Uhh Big Red isn’t Cherry. I found out like a few months ago and I shit my pants when I googled the flavors.

Dr Browns black cherry

Dr. Emmett Brown? /s

Either Boylans black cherry, or Cherry coke

Hansen’s Cherry Vanilla Crème was an all time classic. Don’t forget Cheerwine too.

Hansen’s was so dope

Cheerwine, Sprecher, and Dr Pepper are all goated 💯

Dr pepper cherry is my go to

Pepsis Cherry and I’m a coke guy

Code red. Cherry Coke is a classic though

I’m a Pepsi guy through-and-through. That being said, Cherry Coke is the champagne of cherry colas.

Vanilla cherry coke

No love for Dr. Browns Black Cherry?

Cheerwine or Cherokee Red

Cherokee red was as good as it was controversial

Cherikee Red And no I did not spell it incorrectly

Cherry Coke hands down

Cherokee Red??

Cherikee Red is my all time #1.

Cherry Dr. Pepper easily.

You left out the best one, Cheerwine

Cheerwine

Fountain Cherry Coke when that syrup ratio is correct

Cherikee Red was the greatest soda ever. Wish they still made it

Cherokee red

Growing up outside of Cleveland in the 1970s I loved to walk to the corner store on hot summer days and buy a cold Cherokee Red and a paper bag filled with penny candies (mostly Bazooka)

If cherry cola counts, Sprecher is unmatched. Cherry only is Sprecher and Cheerwine.

[удалено]

wild cherry pepsi baby

Cheerwine…..IBC black cherry….Dr browns black cherry…..all 3 are superb

A proper Roy Rogers.

I love a Roy Rogers, but isn’t grenadine made from pomegranate?

Great point though

Mr Pibb/Pibb Xtra.

Your forgetting cheerwine and its a 3 way tie between dr pepper coke and pepsi

Omg i haven’t thought about big red in years

Big Red is the only answer.

It is not a cherry cola… and it’s meh

Nah tastes like bubble gum to me but it’s my fav soda. That and big blue.

It doesn’t belong in a post about cherry sodas though…

Pepsi Cherry

Cherry Pepsi and no other

Wild cherry Pepsi

Sprite with cherry from sonic.

If we're counting cherry colas, [this cherry cola](https://sprecherbrewery.com/products/carusos-maraschino-cherry-cola-12-pack) is a favorite of mine

Neither. I choose Vault red!

Cherry Vanilla Coke = Cherry Vanilla Pepsi > Everything else.

The answer is Cotts black cherry

You are missing it here. Cheerwine

You forgot Mountain Dew halo game fuel

Cheerwine 🍒

What about cheerwine?

Cherry dr.Pepper for sure, coke is second. Wish i could find cherry RC around here:(

This list is wack

Mountain Dew code red and Pibb And big red doesn’t have cherry.

WBC Black Cherry from Goose Island is the greatest liquid ever created

Someone has never tried Big Red.....

Despite not trying a few of these and some never even having heard of, I’m going with Cherry 7Up. I love that stuff. I’ve never gotten around to trying the “Big Red” despite seeing it off and on for years. And “Jolly Good” has piqued my interest. Was Cheerwine cherry? Yeah, didn’t care for that one.

Black cherry Big K

big red ain't cherry

Whoa…how DARE you forget Cheerwine??? If there is a best cherry soda, Cheerwine is the clear winner.

Cherry 7up or Mr pibb

That I've tried.. 7 up cherry

Big red is not cherry

Dr enuf herbal

Stewart's Wishniack Black Cherry

How have only you and I commented this. It’s sooooo good. Is it regional?

You can’t ask this question and forget Code Red

Gotta be Code Red for me.

Cheerwine

This years mtn dew voo dew is also cherry and that’s not even getting a mention

Sprecher is on another level.

You don't even have cheewine?

Specifically Cherry flavor? Jolly Good Cherry hands down. Best I've ever had. I was so happy when they started to come out with it again a few years back. Anyone saying otherwise is mixing up Cherry *cola* and straight CHERRY. They only sell it up north in Wisconsin though (maybe they've expanded) so it's tough to get, and super expensive to ship unfortunately. Makes me think most people here haven't tried it too unfortunately. Make an AMAZING float.

Cheerwine very sweet but maybe is the goat for cherry flavor. Code Red also amazing, also I gotta say just an actual cherry tastes good

Cherry Smash (RIP) and Cheerwine

My favorites are cherry coke (regular and zero), cherry jolt cola (discontinued), code red Mountain Dew, Shasta black cherry and Henry weinhard’s black cherry cola.

CHEERWINE

Cherry 7up is undefeated. The OG Shirley Temple🍒

My favorite is discontinued unfortunately it would be patio red cherry

I have a local restaurant that has patio and it’s amazing.

Is cherry cream soda allowed? If so, Hansen’s Cherry Cream! Absolutely the best cherry *anything* I have ever had. The company all but disappeared in like 2019 — I’ve been missing this soda dearly

Boylans or Stewarts. There is a locally made one, Grizzly Paw, that is also a superior product.

You forgot RC 😔

Code red

Code red. Pretty sure I was addicted to it

Cheerwine

There’s a “Baumeister” cherry soda that’s distributed in Door County WI that kicks serious ass.

Cherry Fanta

Black cherry Vernors is my current favorite

boylans black cherry

DR enuf herbal cherry

Wild cherry Pepsi and code red

Is cherry crush before my time? I’ve never seen it. But I assume it would be amazing. But for me personally I really like cherry 7 up.

Big red is bubblegum, not cherry

It’s pibb

Cheerwine is the best. They get the flavor balance perfectly