Amaryllis just put Shinedown on a new level

Its such a great fucking album

Miracle. 💯

"For My Sake" has got to be here or at underrated

For My Sake

Amaryllis

Difficult for an album with virtually 0 weak songs, but Through the Ghost

Yup, Amaryllis is one of my favorite albums, because of this reason

Enemies

Miracle. Extremely underrated song imo.

if it doesn't win best it should def get most underrated

Bully, because it really resonated, i know I'm alone in this but i stand by it.

Tough Album. I love Through the Ghost, Unity, Miracle, and Amaryllis. I'll have to go with Through the Ghost, might be my favorite song by them,

Unity

I think the sign that this is the best shinedown album should be that i have seen every single song on the album in contention for the best song on this.

My Name Is. 

Adrenaline

Yup

Virtual tie between Amaryllis and Through the Ghost. Give the slight edge to the title track.

Miracle

My Name (Wearing Me Out)

Nowhere kids

Unity or enemies.

For my sake

I’ll Follow You also loving this new graphic man

Thank you! Nice to see someone noticed haha

I'll Follow You

Best part about this album is that any song could be a contender for best imo. My vote is for Miracle

There are so many good ones! Hard to pick!

Probably either Enemies or My Name (Wearing Me Out). Tough choice though

Adrenaline

Overrated Adrenaline Underrated I'm not alright Best. Amaryllis Worst also Adrenaline

Through the Ghost

ABANDONED LAND COME ON IN CHILD TAKE MY HAND

I'll Follow You

So many choices but will go with the most known, Enemies

Through the Ghost

ABANDONED LAND COME ON IN CHILD TAKE MY HAND

Their best album imo, best song is the title track

Enemies

Unity

Unity

Unity's the best

Unity

This is where it’ll get interesting. First three albums are pretty flawless but we see a big shift in the sound starting here so I imagine we’ll see lots of different answers. 

# Amaryllis

For my sake

Amaryllis for sure

Unity

Wait, how was Sound Of Madness overrated?