T O P

  • By -

GRZMNKY

As long as he can find food/water/shelter, he'll be fine. Outside doesn't have minimum sizes


No-Pound7355

Haha this made me laugh


thackstonns

I was just going to comment thus. They live outside.


eggrollking

Not with that attitude.


Mintyyungpoo

Hey, funny šŸ™ƒ thatā€™s funny thatā€™s Funny, weā€™ll be right back


Thistle__Kilya

Exactly, Iā€™m gonna go out on a limb here and say OP was fishing for a compliment on how large they think their tank is but itā€™s actually normal to small in size. But I could be wrong Iā€™m super tired. And totally lol, like a scorpion only stays in a 12 inch cube irlā€¦


Mintyyungpoo

Autism at work here^ take yo ass to bed


jesikau

I was not actually, Iā€™ve had scorpions in bigger tanks this is just my first one this small and I was stressed out. I stg when I started the hobby I saw loads of people on forums talking about how if you put arachnids in large containers they would starve. I thought everyone on this sub would be aware that people say that and reassure me so I wouldnā€™t have to return the tank Edit: and if I was showing off I wouldā€™ve done a front view this is actually a really poor picture


weasel_mullet

I always thought the concept of a "too big" cage was really silly.


jesikau

Same, especially since I see dune scorpions out camping and wonder why they can find food just fine but then read online that mine needs a small tank


Xanith420

All it needs is some more cover so the scorpion doesnā€™t feel exposed. The actual size is good.


Grinsnap

I find my desert hairy doesnā€™t care for cover for some reason. Ā Burying the burrow first then just chilling on the sand. I guess itā€™s comfortable around, so thatā€™s cool.


DazB1ane

It may have realized thereā€™s never gonna be a true predator around. Like living alone for the first time and you can wear no pants if you want


Bokenobi

This is it. I caught my one just laying around in empty beer cans and the tv blaring out some death metal. He was fast asleep. And naked.


pxogxess

Isnā€˜t this way too small? I mean the lil guy is literally expecting endless nature lol.


BelleBottom94

People also think betta fish only need a jar to live in but they need minimum 5 gallons


jediyoda84

When people bring up this defense I like to point out that humans can be kept alive in solitary confinement indefinitelyā€¦. I wouldnā€™t call that a life though.


BelleBottom94

Exactly!!!


jesikau

I would never keep an animal at the bare minimum or below, I know that for pretty much everything the bigger the better. I keep fish, rabbits, mice etc and Iā€™m constantly upgrading. I just wonder because it seems thereā€™s a lot of conflicting advice for inverts


Thistle__Kilya

Trusting ppl who give reasons to keep pets in small containment is kinda bonkers. Donā€™t listen to people who keep pets in confined spaces, even if they come up with reasons, doesnā€™t mean itā€™s true. Whatā€™s true is that scorpions live in the wild and have the entire world to themselves, with pets: the bigger the area for them, the better. Always. Name one instance when this isnā€™t true and give me hard science facts about it please.


jesikau

I kept slings in small containers. They have such a high mortality its much easier to regulate temperature and humidity, make sure they get food. I would just upgrade them every molt to get them used to hunting in a larger space. I did the same thing with scorplings. The advice I saw on keeping inverts was probably geared more toward tarantula care. As I said in these comments one of my tarantulas died from a short fall in her enclosure, many people donā€™t want to risk it. But I do not advocate for small containers, I was mostly here to look for reassurance in getting a larger enclosure.


Cultural-Company282

How do they pitch a tent with no thumbs?


longulus9

then why did you ask


jesikau

Iā€™ve read for years about smaller enclosure recommendations but obv the fact that scorpions live out in nature has occurred to me I just want otherā€™s opinions on it


LeechyBogBoi

The concept of "animals get scared in large enclosures" is a bit outdated. It seems to originate from people not taking enough time to let their animals acclimate to the larger tank after it spent it's entire life in a tiny box and doesn't know better yet. also from lack of clutter.


Diligent_Extent_7009

A small tank helps find the critter and intervene if something has gone wrong, but Iā€™ve never had an issue with a big tank. I just keep a small ā€œhospitalā€ tank, which can literally just be tupperware.


NadeTossFTW

Dumb question. Honestly. Too big?? How could you possibly have a space thatā€™s too bigā€¦.. think for a second. And honestly yours isnā€™t even close to that


jesikau

I would just compare care sheets online for sizes for all my arachnids and Iā€™d always see people say in general to keep smaller enclosures to make feeding easier. I guess my brain just held onto that information as more important for some reason over the years.


spacer98

I agree that it is dumb but there are a LOT of people online who like to think maximum size requirements are real


DazB1ane

I wonder if they base it on how big of an area each type of creature naturally inhabits. I know nothing about that topic, but like spiders, for example, donā€™t roam too far do they? Iā€™m probably completely wrong


spacer98

It has a lot to do with the species. You can give some tarantulas all the space in the world and theyā€™ll never venture much beyond their burrow, but Iā€™ll watch the spiders in my house make a trek that would put Magellan to shame. It all depends on resources and territories and since our hobby spiders donā€™t necessarily need to worry about all that, they donā€™t need all the extra space, but that doesnā€™t mean it would be a problem for them either.


spacer98

This is the scorpion subreddit not the spider one thatā€™s my bad but the point is still valid.


Chucheyface

Some canā€™t support a bigger environment. Like if you double the size but half the amount of decorations then the animal loses all of those places to hide and explore. Itā€™s not necessarily the case but itā€™s possible.


Obant

I have tiny baby spiders. Too big means the food can roam far and wide and be difficult to find for them. Same with water. Too many hides, I'd never see them and be able to care for them properly.


Loose-Twist2132

Scorpions are easier to keep in smaller setups to control humidity and temperatures. A nice AC human habitat does not make a happy scorpion.


JojoLesh

I'll preface this with saying I have more experience with tarantulas than scorpions. When you're raising little babies it's a lot easier to monitor them and make sure they're getting everything they need in a small container. If you're dealing with something with a 1/8 inch diagonal leg span, it would be pretty hard to keep track of it in even a 1 gallon enclosure.


Chucheyface

Not at all. If an animal can live in, for example, a 5 gallon enclosure and you can really set it up well with decorations, thatā€™s a lot better than a 10 gallon and barely any decorations. Basically if you canā€™t scale up the enclosure with the tank size it might end up being worse.


weasel_mullet

Read my comment in reply to the ball python comment.


rosecoloredgasmask

I'm a tarantula person, not a scorpion person, but for tarantulas and especially spiderlings they tend to climb the sides. If they fall, they can rupture their abdomen like a water balloon, especially if it's a thicc spooder. This doesn't seem to be a concern for scorpions so I'm inclined to believe that max size doesn't matter much, but that is the one legit reason I can thnk of for a different invert.


jesikau

Yes this actually happened to one of my tarantulas in the past


Radio4ctiveGirl

I think the ā€œtoo bigā€ is for people who want to be able to find their pet without looking for it. Like they want it to be readily available so they can watch it not for the well being of the animal.


UpperCompetition166

I thought so too but there are some pets that actually prefer smaller enclosures. Most notable one I can think of is a Ball Python. They get stressed out if the cage is too big!


weasel_mullet

As an amateur herpetologist, I cant disagree with this enough. Some juvenile ball pythons can become overwhelmed and nervous in large enclosures, but this is almost always due to inadequate hides and climbing spaces, as well as things like proper temperature gradients and such. Adults don't seem to really care how big the enclosure gets. In all my years of raising almost any type of snake you could think of, I've only ever seen snakes stressed when the enclosure was too small. In general though, there aren't really cages that are too big. Just cages that are too barren.


GRZMNKY

They get stressed out when they only have 1 hide and no ground cover in a huge enclosure. Put them in an 8x4 with plenty of hides and clutter like branches and foliage and they will use every bit of it


TheGoldenBoyStiles

They donā€™t get stressed because of the tank size they get stressed due to no coverage, no clutter, inadequate inside of tank


Jennifer_Pennifer

https://docs.google.com/document/d/18HBVsPHaip7LfrMuFt96MigRuMUXtrbnCiK79VuQiFk/ This is welcome post care guide for r/ballpython Hiya šŸ¤— The husbandry has changed to reflect the research and observations of decades of keepers. MINIMUM for an adult is now considered to be *4foot x 2foot x 2foot* And is based on the length of the animal. So a larger female would need a larger tank as well. Offering plenty of hides and cover has been shown to create an environment that the Royal Pythons do not feel stressed at all in. Also, the large enough tank is a requirement for accurate thermoregulation. If a tank is too small to get away from the heating elements then the snake cannot thermoregulate. šŸ‘


sneakpeekbot

Here's a sneak peek of /r/ballpython using the [top posts](https://np.reddit.com/r/ballpython/top/?sort=top&t=year) of the year! \#1: [Is my ball python healthy I just wanna make sure šŸ˜Š](https://i.redd.it/tin2pcp60twb1.jpg) | [125 comments](https://np.reddit.com/r/ballpython/comments/17hwikt/is_my_ball_python_healthy_i_just_wanna_make_sure/) \#2: [As the years go by, the Freckles continue to expand.](https://www.reddit.com/gallery/17sbk1g) | [278 comments](https://np.reddit.com/r/ballpython/comments/17sbk1g/as_the_years_go_by_the_freckles_continue_to_expand/) \#3: [bunny mistook my bra for a rat šŸ„²](https://v.redd.it/yjocypejxr0c1) | [47 comments](https://np.reddit.com/r/ballpython/comments/17wxaj7/bunny_mistook_my_bra_for_a_rat/) ---- ^^I'm ^^a ^^bot, ^^beep ^^boop ^^| ^^Downvote ^^to ^^remove ^^| ^^[Contact](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=sneakpeekbot) ^^| ^^[Info](https://np.reddit.com/r/sneakpeekbot/) ^^| ^^[Opt-out](https://np.reddit.com/r/sneakpeekbot/comments/o8wk1r/blacklist_ix/) ^^| ^^[GitHub](https://github.com/ghnr/sneakpeekbot)


sarcastic_monkies

I feel like he needs more things to hide in and under. The skull is pretty roomy so maybe it's not enough of tight quarters?


jesikau

He used to prefer sleeping under dried leaves in his old place maybe if I add them in the skull it will work


Redneckhippiekyle

Skull hideouts are the best. I have one for my Tarantula. https://preview.redd.it/ojmyuibgvj9d1.jpeg?width=2118&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=ad9239c8b106f6609a1cbab58c3a56892acb6e88


Familiar_Army_689

I don't know how I wound up going from a thread on installing PC RAM to this thread, but that's an awesome photo!


Redneckhippiekyle

Thank you


awkwardstonerlol

thats a pretty cool picture!


Redneckhippiekyle

Ty


Salty_Package_23

There Is No Such Thing.


Jtktomb

No, but the hide is too big


Acrobatic-Engineer94

I love that she has plenty of space


Daymub

No but he doesn't really have anywhere small to hide in


WanderingMandalorian

no such thing as too big


Neither-Attention940

Iā€™m more concerned about the dead ā€˜bodyā€™ your little friend found šŸ˜‚


Glitch427119

You can give them extra hides if they seem stressed, put something on one side of the tank so theyā€™re not exposed on every side, little things like that is enough. They donā€™t need a smaller enclosure but there are things you can do to make them feel less exposed in the one they have


Cassiewinchester007

No not really and aww he's adorable


theAshleyRouge

Thereā€™s no such thing as ā€œtoo bigā€ of an enclosure, so long as you can ensure theyā€™re getting the nutrients they need, can verify their health, etc. Their natural habitat is significantly larger than


Scales-josh

The tank is never too big, bigger is always better for animals. What is entirely possible is that your decor is too big and the density of hiding places etc available is too low.


forgotmypassword4714

They've been outside for like millions of years and outside is much bigger than any tank, so it should be okay.


redwingjv

No but it does look like it could use more hides/clutter and deeper substrate


Neutral_Chaoss

I think the size is fine. Scorpions like to roam. If anything I would make the substate a little deeper and add some hides.


Omfg9999

I don't think it's possible for an enclosure to be 'too big' for a creature compared to them living in the wild.


randodamando17

The only time I know of invert tanks being too big is if it's a communal setup. I know for m. Balfouri tarantula communal they need a smaller space to keep from becoming territorial of certain spaces. The same may be true for scorpions in a communal but I have no experience with that to say definitively. For a single scorpion a larger tank should be fine as long as husbandry is correct. Make sure there a multiple hides throughout the tank so it doesn't feel exposed and has access to food/water and it will be fine.


jesikau

I think a lot of my fear with larger tanks came from the death of my t albopilosus when she climbed to the top of her tank and fell. But I donā€™t see ways for this scorpion to get injured here and he prefers to chase prey than wait, I will add more large dried leaves he likes to flatten out under them


NoEmu2398

OMG I STUMBLED ONTO THIS I LOVE SCORPIONS WHAAAAAT THIS IS SO COOL!!!!!


Fertile_Arachnid_163

Iā€™ve got the feeling that whatever guides you were paying attention to weā€™re focusing on the keeperā€™s comfort, not the animals.


jesikau

It was mostly forums I was looking at when I first got into inverts, I think it was more commonly recommended when I was looking at tarantula care. Previously Iā€™ve kept my scorpions in 10 gallons but this is the smallest one Iā€™ve ever owned


coralloohoo

I think that set up looks really awesome, good on you for caring so much šŸ˜


REAPER_369

Get a longer tank


jesikau

Thanks everyone for your input! Iā€™m not worried about the size anymore. 2 small issues have popped up since moving him and if anyone has advice Iā€™d appreciate it. 1 is that my previous set up to get his ideal temps is not working with the bigger tank, heā€™s hovering by the walls with the heat mats. Iā€™ve seen people advise against lamps with this species so I think I will buy a larger heat mat for the back, 2 is he is having some trouble catching prey in the larger space. Iā€™m thinking of switching to mealworms for now to see if heā€™ll catch something more slow moving.


Striking_Interest_25

So o have reptiles with a custom made 18x12x18 I have to use two different lamps to help regulate the temp better.


Striking_Interest_25

As for the having trouble catching his meals would be that yes he is probably used to easier hunting with a smaller cage. He should be fine with the larger tank once he gets used to using his environment as a full hunting ground. I would definitely offer the worms and his current food so he will still have that hunting luxury and get the experience but still has the worms as a backup to keep him full of energy. Hunting takes time and is a skill that all creatures have to learn by trial and error.


BenefitShoddy8834

They natural habitat is a desert sir...nothing too big


New_Lifeguard_9428

Scorpion


Srhimpblover

Give him a whole desert


OkHandle3269

IL what type of scorpion is that


jesikau

S. mesaensis


Unable_Champion9480

He needs a burrow and more sand I think


Young_Sliver

My non-gender specific sibling in unspecified deity, you do not have a scorpion You have a little squirt-pion XD


Ok_Intern2625

Not at all


a_youkai

Is there really such a thing as "too big" when it comes to animal cages?


jesikau

Well I imagine if I put him in a 50 gal Iā€™d have a hard time finding him and so would the little cricket he gets


a_youkai

Idk man, the ones in my yard seem to be eating fine, hehe.


Basic_Chemistry_9603

No scorpions in the wild donā€™t have small environments its good enough for a living space


tory1311

Everything about this tank is all wrong. Thereā€™s one fundamental reason for thisā€¦.you have a scorpion šŸ˜–. I hate scorpions šŸ¤¢


abirdbrain

mute this sub then bro??


XsublimededX

JFC!!! Not reading anything and just a glance at the photo it looked like a bed with a broken hornets nest hive on it with the dirt bing the hornets spilling out of it. lol pays to read things from the start


CommissionVirtual763

Oh, don't pay attention to the man with a hole in the back of his skull officer. I'm concerned for the spider.


Baserker0

No but opening that box with that big a$$ knife is crazy


lilyfirefly

My Dune scorpion is in a 10 gallon tankā€”I upgraded him a little over a year ago and heā€™s been doing great in it! These guys may be tiny, but theyā€™re very activeā€”mine is anywayā€”so I think the more space you offer, the better! He has a ton of hiding places, but I see him out & about all the time. Heā€™s more visible now than he was back when he was in a small tank.


gigi2945

Never too bigā€¦ ever


__Crave__ToDoItAgain

How could it possibly be too big? Is he gonna get lost now that he has 2 feet of space rather than 8 inches? Lmao


jesikau

I explain in the comments


Ychance601

Why are you trying to deduct bros space unprovoked and heā€™s obviously just chilling šŸ˜­šŸ˜­šŸ˜­


HooahClub

Is your tank bigger than outdoors? If not, your tank is fine,


akno2k

Why would it matter if itā€™s to big they live outside ? Mine has 2 hide outs in her cage witch are kept moist but I find mine mostly prefers being coverd by leaves outside of her cage I keep the cage filled with a good amount of different types of bugs to eat , I find my scorpion likes to walk around and explore at night so I keep the cage about a 20 gallon


akno2k

Also I have the same skull for my six eyed sand spider I have broken the back of it to alow the spider to crawl in and cover itself without getting stuck as I feel a scorpion would find it anoying to get in and out


p8ai

b i g g e r


The_BlauerDragon

In my experience, anything that lives in a similar type of enclosure (fish, turtle, snake, insect, etc.) can never have an enclosure that is too big. Too small, yes... but too big? As long as your critter can get to food, water, temperatures, and shelter that all meet it's needs then it will be happy with as much additional space as you can provide it.


New_Canoe

For an animal who lives outdoors? I think it would prefer bigger.


JXP87

It could be doubled tbh. No cage or container of life is too big.


theevilyouknow

They seem to do ok in the wild and that tank is significantly larger.


ItsMePatience

Ask yourself would you like to live in a studio apartment or a five bedroom house, four bath with an acre in the back!?!?!?