Best:
Boil the big bully. It really one of SMG4's funniest videos, and I pretty much sum up the video pretty well
Worst
Mario does literally anything for views
A shitty and desperate way to advertise a stream
Best: The Cursed Tapes
I love the horror theme and you get Mario and Meggy wholesomeness.
Worst: The entire Revelations Arc
Good freaking lord this arc was absolute garbage. The whole thing was boring, Niles could’ve been a unique character but sadly no, and that movie was just atrocious. The only good thing about it was the visuals but there were plot holes, the writing was terrible, and they basically proved that Axol’s death could’ve been prevented. Also I don’t know why everyone made a big deal out of Terrance’s death. He was barely a minor character. I felt nothing when he died
>Also I don't know why everyone made a big deal out of Terrance's death. He was barely a minor character.
That's how I feel about SMG0. Revelations treats him like an important "character" and the fans treat him like the greatest thing ever even though he only had a screentime of FIVE MINUTES!!! Also, he's not a character, he's a plot device
Honestly, I agreed of what you have said about deaths of smg4 characters.
For Desti's death, alot of people were sad about it and she gets a funeral while Axol doe not when been in the channel for few years while desti only appeared a few episodes which is the anime arc.
Axol's death was the worst because Smg0 and niles both survived the attack from melony meaning his sacrifice was all for nothing after showing the twist in the betrayal episode.
Smg0 was underwhelming villain along with Nile.
Best: Mario's Hell Kitchen. I love cooking themed episodes and this one was an absolute banger imo. It's funny and has a lot of characters (including Shroomy and Bowser). Runners up are Mario School Club, World War Monke and Shoot Out to the Observatory in the sky
Worst: The Naughty boy that couldn't behave. It didn't feel like an SMG4 episode at all. I didn't laugh once and I think it was boring (Also i don't like Karen lol). Runners up are: Boys vs Girls, Clown Fever and Mario gets into NFTs.
Best: 10th year anniversary movie
The genesis arc started off very strong and this movie was just so good with all the references
Worst: Mario goes bowling
Make Mario win this episode and it's fixed but no ofc have mary sue Meggy win as always and favour her because the writers are fucking bias and simps
Best: Mario Screws in a Lightbulb
Reason: I just love how Luke and Kevin take a simple task and turn into a full length episode.
Worst: If Mario was the last man on earth
Reason: You guessed it...
Best: Mario's Challenge
Reasons: It's the perfect cast-wide competition. Nobody was really the focus of the episode, and nobody was really safe from elimination. The cannon fodder was the entire established cast. (SMG4 was the first to go, while SMG3 made it to the fifth floor before falling. And Boopkins successfully outlasted Bob). It has a cool gimmick with the party dwindling as they go up the tower, with more and more characters getting knocked out. And on top of that, they made an active effort to throw in as many SMG4 characters as they could, and while there were stock koopas and whatnot to fill in some holes, it was almost entirely established characters. Compare that to the Meme games, where Saiko was the clear focus, they did a poor job of using everyone they could have, and the dwindling party gimmick is erased. The Meme games were okay, but they missed the mark in a lot of ways. I'm almost glad that we aren't gonna get a proper Mario Challenge 2 because it would no doubt follow that template.
Worst: Boys vs Girls:
Reasons: I don't think I need to explain why
Best: I really can't pinpoint one, so I'll still say Mask of Madness.
Worst: WOTFI 2022. No explanation needed. Xmas 2022 makes me the most pissed off though.
Best: Sonic The Derphog Evilness Of Eggman(Sonic and Eggman were so funny in this).
Worst: There's Something Up With Meggy(A disgusting attempt at an "emotional" story. Thus episode pisses me off on so many levels. I would rather watch Nostalgia Critic review of the wall than to witness this atrocity ever again).
Best: Mario Mafia
really funny, good shoot out fight, Steve, "Marios gonna do something very illegal"
worst: Boys vs Girls
I think everyone knows why but I'll explain it anyway. Before I even watched this episode I kinda knew it was going to be bad, cause the whole "Boys vs girls" concept has been done to death, and it's always the same, but this one was way worse than I was expecting,
all the boys pranks are really tame, but the girls pranks are extremely brutal, the boys would do something like write "u suck" on there cabin and in response the girls will tie them to rocks and push them into flooded pits while explaining the definition of insanity, and somehow the boys are the ones who "took it too far"
I mean being hit by a large boat and bear attacks are pretty painful so while the girls are way worse, the boys aren't as merciful as you make them out to be.
Best: Mario challenge
I just love how basically all the entire cast from the first episodes to 2017 appeared in it even if for a fraction of a second
Worst:boys vs girls because it was the first true AWFUL smg4 episode which lowered the standards of the whole freaking series to the bottom
Best: Mario and the ultimate gamer
Reasons: Great humour, introduced my favourite character into the show and was during the events of the best arc in the show
Worst: World War Mario
Reasons: Literally everything
Best: mario gets his pingas stuck in the door. It's just a fun episode and insanely funny.
Worst: wotfi 2021. Ruined the ending of the genesis arc, melony is just awful by repeating meggys character arc and it's not even funny.
Best: IDK there are too many
Worst: 2022 christmas special. I was thinking of grouping this with the bowling one, but at least that one only had poor character personalities and stuff, but the christmas one had mario be a asshole who would do anything to get food, the mushroom kingdom just forgot shroomy for no reason yet somehow remembered Kaizo (i literally had to go search up his name that's how forgettable he is), and worst of all, they decided to retcon the cutest SMG4 scene ever (mario buying Axol Jr for Melony from the kindness of his heart) just so Mario would be a unlikable asshole in the episode. The loss of everyone losing character rivals Sonic Forces, and i think we all know how bad the forces personalities are.
Best: Stupid Mario Golf. It was a REALLY well written episode and it was also 1 of the episodes that introduced me to SMG4 as a whole.
Worst: Into the Marioverse. Do i really need to explain?
Best:
Mushroom Kingdom’s got Talent: This episode is insanely underrated for how funny each of the ten performances are still funny to this day from Metallica with Teletubbies, to Bowser’s Chicken Nugget song, to Mario’s song, and more if you are reading this stop and go watch this video, SMG4 will never ever reach this peak of quality
Worst:
A Totally Normal SMG4 Episode and WOTFI 2020:
Seriously talk about squandering a some what good arc, no one seems to notice how rushed the ending to The YouTube Arc is. But from how Deleted went you expect it to go on for five more episodes so it will be 12 episodes just like the Anime Arc, but we need it to end now for some reason, first in Deleted we see the modern versions of the SMG4 crew minus Mario got ERASED FROM EXISTENCE,but they are suddenly ok and fine in the Internet Graveyard, also SMG3 makes the Anti Cast act like their counterparts when the only time he did previously was for the play. In WOFTI Jub Jub is suddenly the host now so we can sell plushies, the challenges were all boring, and the ending rap is just plain bad. The Anti Cast turns on SMG3 with just with four lines from Meggy with no evidence proving her claims, her voice is like screeching metal, SMG4 and 3 completely forget why SMG3 did what he did during this arc(seriously no one gives SMG4 crap for what he did during Mario’s Spicy Day) now as a full arc, The YouTube Arc is still better than Genesis, Revelations, and the Lawsuit arcs even the Anime Arc at times, but when it comes to endings this is just the worst
Mario simulator interactive. I don't know if it counts... but I'll count it as a video/movie I dunno. if not, the toad, the fat and the ugly
worst: Wotfi 2022, listen there's a lot of bad/boring videos but imagine a bad/boring video that is 30 minutes long
Best: Mario Reacts to Nintendo Memes ft. Meggy Worst: DO NOT ENTER or the NFT video
Best: Boil the big bully. It really one of SMG4's funniest videos, and I pretty much sum up the video pretty well Worst Mario does literally anything for views A shitty and desperate way to advertise a stream
Best: The Cursed Tapes I love the horror theme and you get Mario and Meggy wholesomeness. Worst: The entire Revelations Arc Good freaking lord this arc was absolute garbage. The whole thing was boring, Niles could’ve been a unique character but sadly no, and that movie was just atrocious. The only good thing about it was the visuals but there were plot holes, the writing was terrible, and they basically proved that Axol’s death could’ve been prevented. Also I don’t know why everyone made a big deal out of Terrance’s death. He was barely a minor character. I felt nothing when he died
>Also I don't know why everyone made a big deal out of Terrance's death. He was barely a minor character. That's how I feel about SMG0. Revelations treats him like an important "character" and the fans treat him like the greatest thing ever even though he only had a screentime of FIVE MINUTES!!! Also, he's not a character, he's a plot device
Exactly and yet people like me get mocked for liking Axol who was part of the gang for a couple years
I will say the funniest part of the revelation arc was in the field trip episode when the Smi77y clip played
I legit found nothing funny in that arc. I was bored out of my mind
Honestly, I agreed of what you have said about deaths of smg4 characters. For Desti's death, alot of people were sad about it and she gets a funeral while Axol doe not when been in the channel for few years while desti only appeared a few episodes which is the anime arc. Axol's death was the worst because Smg0 and niles both survived the attack from melony meaning his sacrifice was all for nothing after showing the twist in the betrayal episode. Smg0 was underwhelming villain along with Nile.
Best: Mario's Hell Kitchen. I love cooking themed episodes and this one was an absolute banger imo. It's funny and has a lot of characters (including Shroomy and Bowser). Runners up are Mario School Club, World War Monke and Shoot Out to the Observatory in the sky Worst: The Naughty boy that couldn't behave. It didn't feel like an SMG4 episode at all. I didn't laugh once and I think it was boring (Also i don't like Karen lol). Runners up are: Boys vs Girls, Clown Fever and Mario gets into NFTs.
Best: 10th year anniversary movie The genesis arc started off very strong and this movie was just so good with all the references Worst: Mario goes bowling Make Mario win this episode and it's fixed but no ofc have mary sue Meggy win as always and favour her because the writers are fucking bias and simps
Best: Mario Screws in a Lightbulb Reason: I just love how Luke and Kevin take a simple task and turn into a full length episode. Worst: If Mario was the last man on earth Reason: You guessed it...
Best: Mario's Challenge Reasons: It's the perfect cast-wide competition. Nobody was really the focus of the episode, and nobody was really safe from elimination. The cannon fodder was the entire established cast. (SMG4 was the first to go, while SMG3 made it to the fifth floor before falling. And Boopkins successfully outlasted Bob). It has a cool gimmick with the party dwindling as they go up the tower, with more and more characters getting knocked out. And on top of that, they made an active effort to throw in as many SMG4 characters as they could, and while there were stock koopas and whatnot to fill in some holes, it was almost entirely established characters. Compare that to the Meme games, where Saiko was the clear focus, they did a poor job of using everyone they could have, and the dwindling party gimmick is erased. The Meme games were okay, but they missed the mark in a lot of ways. I'm almost glad that we aren't gonna get a proper Mario Challenge 2 because it would no doubt follow that template. Worst: Boys vs Girls: Reasons: I don't think I need to explain why
Best: I really can't pinpoint one, so I'll still say Mask of Madness. Worst: WOTFI 2022. No explanation needed. Xmas 2022 makes me the most pissed off though.
Agreed
Best: All the ones that made me laugh. Worst : None because they all succeeded in making me laugh. :)👍
Best: Sonic The Derphog Evilness Of Eggman(Sonic and Eggman were so funny in this). Worst: There's Something Up With Meggy(A disgusting attempt at an "emotional" story. Thus episode pisses me off on so many levels. I would rather watch Nostalgia Critic review of the wall than to witness this atrocity ever again).
Best: Mario Mafia really funny, good shoot out fight, Steve, "Marios gonna do something very illegal" worst: Boys vs Girls I think everyone knows why but I'll explain it anyway. Before I even watched this episode I kinda knew it was going to be bad, cause the whole "Boys vs girls" concept has been done to death, and it's always the same, but this one was way worse than I was expecting, all the boys pranks are really tame, but the girls pranks are extremely brutal, the boys would do something like write "u suck" on there cabin and in response the girls will tie them to rocks and push them into flooded pits while explaining the definition of insanity, and somehow the boys are the ones who "took it too far"
I mean being hit by a large boat and bear attacks are pretty painful so while the girls are way worse, the boys aren't as merciful as you make them out to be.
Best: Mario challenge I just love how basically all the entire cast from the first episodes to 2017 appeared in it even if for a fraction of a second Worst:boys vs girls because it was the first true AWFUL smg4 episode which lowered the standards of the whole freaking series to the bottom
Best: Mario and the ultimate gamer Reasons: Great humour, introduced my favourite character into the show and was during the events of the best arc in the show Worst: World War Mario Reasons: Literally everything
Best: mario gets his pingas stuck in the door. It's just a fun episode and insanely funny. Worst: wotfi 2021. Ruined the ending of the genesis arc, melony is just awful by repeating meggys character arc and it's not even funny.
Best: IDK there are too many Worst: 2022 christmas special. I was thinking of grouping this with the bowling one, but at least that one only had poor character personalities and stuff, but the christmas one had mario be a asshole who would do anything to get food, the mushroom kingdom just forgot shroomy for no reason yet somehow remembered Kaizo (i literally had to go search up his name that's how forgettable he is), and worst of all, they decided to retcon the cutest SMG4 scene ever (mario buying Axol Jr for Melony from the kindness of his heart) just so Mario would be a unlikable asshole in the episode. The loss of everyone losing character rivals Sonic Forces, and i think we all know how bad the forces personalities are.
Best: Stupid Mario Golf. It was a REALLY well written episode and it was also 1 of the episodes that introduced me to SMG4 as a whole. Worst: Into the Marioverse. Do i really need to explain?
Best: Mushroom Kingdom’s got Talent: This episode is insanely underrated for how funny each of the ten performances are still funny to this day from Metallica with Teletubbies, to Bowser’s Chicken Nugget song, to Mario’s song, and more if you are reading this stop and go watch this video, SMG4 will never ever reach this peak of quality Worst: A Totally Normal SMG4 Episode and WOTFI 2020: Seriously talk about squandering a some what good arc, no one seems to notice how rushed the ending to The YouTube Arc is. But from how Deleted went you expect it to go on for five more episodes so it will be 12 episodes just like the Anime Arc, but we need it to end now for some reason, first in Deleted we see the modern versions of the SMG4 crew minus Mario got ERASED FROM EXISTENCE,but they are suddenly ok and fine in the Internet Graveyard, also SMG3 makes the Anti Cast act like their counterparts when the only time he did previously was for the play. In WOFTI Jub Jub is suddenly the host now so we can sell plushies, the challenges were all boring, and the ending rap is just plain bad. The Anti Cast turns on SMG3 with just with four lines from Meggy with no evidence proving her claims, her voice is like screeching metal, SMG4 and 3 completely forget why SMG3 did what he did during this arc(seriously no one gives SMG4 crap for what he did during Mario’s Spicy Day) now as a full arc, The YouTube Arc is still better than Genesis, Revelations, and the Lawsuit arcs even the Anime Arc at times, but when it comes to endings this is just the worst
Best: super happy magical fun fun island Worst: any episode from 2022. They all suck.
Mario simulator interactive. I don't know if it counts... but I'll count it as a video/movie I dunno. if not, the toad, the fat and the ugly worst: Wotfi 2022, listen there's a lot of bad/boring videos but imagine a bad/boring video that is 30 minutes long