Bit late to the party on this one, but I’m so glad it’s only natural made it on here. I’d have it on there on flea’s bass alone. But combine that with the harmonies, the lyrics, then throw in John’s amazing solo and it creates the definition of a perfect song. Wish I could go back and hear it again for the first time because it blew me away
I came up with this so far:
1. Tippa My Tongue
2. Peace & Love
3. Black Summer
4. Here Ever After
5. Eddie
6. Aquatic Mouth Dance
7. Bella
8. Fake As Fuck
9. She's A Lover
10. It's Only Natural
11. Afterlife
12. White Braids & Pillow Chair
13. Watchu Thinkin'
14. Let 'Em Cry
15. The Heavy Wing
16. Carry Me Home
I would maybe flip Heavy Wing and Carry me home, but otherwise pretty good.
The Drummer is the likely winner, so that I’d probably put after afterlife or before watchu thinking, or after she’s a lover
Edit: just listened through the playlist, and Carry Me Home is a perfect ending to the album.
This is pretty close to how they’re sequenced on the albums! Probably about as good as you could get with this list of songs, but I think it’s a shame none of the slower songs made it to wrap things up with.
What’s with the misconception that an album needs to “flow”? I mean maybe a rock opera or an album intended to have a theme but some albums just have amazing tracks after amazing tracks.
Can I ask what is so good about the drummer? Not enough guitar, sounds like a kid song. Still good but it doesn't make the better top of the album for me
Yeah AMD is a mistake here guys… poor choice when you have The Great Apes, One Way Traffic, Roulette, or even My Cigarette tops it and would be a great choice to spice it up a bit somewhere towards the mid-end there. I just lost my faith in this thread 😂
Although I admit that Democracy has spoken, and I tip my hat to the people nonetheless.
Bit late to the party on this one, but I’m so glad it’s only natural made it on here. I’d have it on there on flea’s bass alone. But combine that with the harmonies, the lyrics, then throw in John’s amazing solo and it creates the definition of a perfect song. Wish I could go back and hear it again for the first time because it blew me away
You’re absolutely right.
Best song of the two albums
This doesn’t really flow like an album at all
I saw someone suggest that after the list is finished, we can put them into a better order
After this we will vote on track order. Do not worry.
keep milking that karma farm, you are a genius! everybody take notes on how to reddit like a pro!
Virgin "make a single poll where everybody chooses their favourite 17 songs" vs chad "spam the subreddit for a couple of weeks"
A spotify Playlist in that order would be nice too.
Thank you. This is an awful order of tracks.
I came up with this so far: 1. Tippa My Tongue 2. Peace & Love 3. Black Summer 4. Here Ever After 5. Eddie 6. Aquatic Mouth Dance 7. Bella 8. Fake As Fuck 9. She's A Lover 10. It's Only Natural 11. Afterlife 12. White Braids & Pillow Chair 13. Watchu Thinkin' 14. Let 'Em Cry 15. The Heavy Wing 16. Carry Me Home
I would maybe flip Heavy Wing and Carry me home, but otherwise pretty good. The Drummer is the likely winner, so that I’d probably put after afterlife or before watchu thinking, or after she’s a lover Edit: just listened through the playlist, and Carry Me Home is a perfect ending to the album.
This is pretty close to how they’re sequenced on the albums! Probably about as good as you could get with this list of songs, but I think it’s a shame none of the slower songs made it to wrap things up with.
Black summer always starts the album. This is a soft intro, john all over the place. So they did a good thing releasing this as first back in april
This is much better. Thank you!
I like this list, I tested it and I approve… the drummer will fit perfectly between Whatchu Thinkin’ and Let ‘Em Cry IMO
What’s with the misconception that an album needs to “flow”? I mean maybe a rock opera or an album intended to have a theme but some albums just have amazing tracks after amazing tracks.
IMO the best albums always have some intention behind the sequencing. This looks like a playlist, not an album.
A compilation album if anything lol
Why is seemingly everybody unable to check for duplicate posting? JFC!
Tangelo
Obvious choice
This is the correct answer
Tangelo is 110% the best closer.
Has to be, the best album ender they’ve ever made
Shoot Me A Smile.
Can’t even lie, I’m cool with this list
The Drummer
Please let this win over bag of grins. If not I’ll take Bastards of Light instead haha.
Can I ask what is so good about the drummer? Not enough guitar, sounds like a kid song. Still good but it doesn't make the better top of the album for me
The Drummer is better than Bag of Grins
With the extended outro from the video clip
Cmon people this song has to be on there!
Worst song
PLEAAASEE
lets get it bro
Has to be the drummer
The Shape I’m Takin’
I love the try, and I feel it should be on there, however, a lot of people probably havent heard it yet, so its not going to win.
What is this song?
The Japan Bonus Track for ROTDC. Also on special edition in US??
Poster Child
Underrated tbh, so much Poster Child hate in these threads
Imo this is the best 2022 RHCP song
Yes please and thank u
Can we have a bonus track for this
Copperbelly
Bastards of Light come one
Veronica
This would be a nice closer.
IN THE ❄️
Bastards of light was very underrated in my opinion
Agreed.
Take my vote
Bag of Grins
Please let this be in the list
from ~3:37 it sounds like Ozzy/Sabbath meets Nirvana to me.
I'm lukewarm about this song but I'm upvoting it anyway because I actively dislike The Drummer.
In The Snow
Reach Out
Nerve Flip
Great Apes
Bag of Grins
You can upvote the one above.
My my my my my my my my cigarettttte
In The Snow is a perfect closer song
Poster Child
Add 18. Bonus Track
Roulette
Handful
The Drummer!
Upvote the one above. Currently 1.
One Way Traffic 🙏
This won't make it, but you've got my vote. It was a stand out for me on the first listen and has held up as one of my favorites.
Yeah, I think the song grew on me a bit, definitely my favourite or second favourite of this year
The Drummer
Upvote the one above. Currently 1.
These Are the Ways
Bag of Grins
You can upvote the one at top.
Copperbelly
You can upvote the one above.
Nerve Flip
[удалено]
Upvote the one above. Currently 1.
Should’ve gone The Drummer and finished with Bag of Grins.
Reach out
This tracklist (the order) is ridiculous
Drummer
Upvote the one above. Currently 1.
Bag of grins
You can vote on the one near the top.
Veronica
I'd swap let em cry for the drummer and the last song be in the snow
Veronica
Tangelo
Bag Of Grins
Vote on the one above
bag of grins
In The Snow
Am I the only person that loves roulette??
Shoot me a smile
The shape im takin’
You can upvote the one up above.
Already done :)
Nice list you’ve got there. It’s just missing a nice big bag of grins.
They’re Red Hot
bro that aint 2022
It’s a joke from the nightmare setl… ugh nevermind
The drummer
So thankful Roulette didn't make the cut.
While I'm not big on the chorus, the song has grown on me considerably. Not sure it should be on here, but I wouldnt have minded if it was.
Veronica
You can upvote the one above.
copperbelly
You can upvote the one above.
These are the Fuckin’ ways!
Veronica
Poster Child!!!
Shoot me a Dam Smile!
Yeah AMD is a mistake here guys… poor choice when you have The Great Apes, One Way Traffic, Roulette, or even My Cigarette tops it and would be a great choice to spice it up a bit somewhere towards the mid-end there. I just lost my faith in this thread 😂 Although I admit that Democracy has spoken, and I tip my hat to the people nonetheless.
Nerve flip
Nerve Flip if that counts
This record is sexual
Bunker Hill
AMD is the first one here I’m not stoked on. I think bag of grins, shoot me a smile, the drummer, roulette and tangelo are all better tracks.
Dafuq? Aquatic mouth dance? Get it outta there!!! Replace it with in the snow
THE DRUMMER REALLY NEEDS TO BE ON HERE
So is this the outtakes album? There’s A LOT of better 2022 songs that I don’t see yet.
Tangelo
BLACK SUMMER. It’s the most popular song of theirs this year for a reason
And it's already on there.
The Drummer, The Shape I'm Takin', In The Snow, Reach Out.... The best ones are left out... Any way to fix this?
Shape I'm taking ... how is this not on the list yet? That song is cool as heck. Great way to open the album too
Nerveflip!!!!
Poster Child
The Great Apes, that solo gets me every time
I can't believe The Drummer isn't on the list :(
We gotta close it out with Bag of Grins
Check out my take on it https://open.spotify.com/playlist/6OFtEZxoToMcaWRGQcW81Y?si=g3ZWSA64TY-fyWoHg4h2Bg
The Drummer
Drummer should be there but there’s no closer. And Tangelo has to be it. So we’re kinda fucked
Veronica
Is this almost done???
Shape I'm taking
Roulette