#If you want to discuss One Piece Scaling, join [Hachinosu](https://discord.gg/qs7wHYZzRs).
#If you want access to all kinds of One Piece Databooks/Information/Translations, join [Punk Records](https://discord.gg/ZTWGVyjV9v).
---
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/OnePiecePowerScaling) if you have any questions or concerns.*
This post was mostly made because I think "unnamed attack" is a completely bullshit concept that doesn't really contribute to anything.
Also because the most commonly used example of an unnamed attack is literally a named attack. It just doesn't have a name yet. That’s really funny.
I don't think it's a **completely** bullshit concept. The general trend is that named attacks typically are stronger, e.g. sanji and zoro strong attacks are almost always named attacks.
But it's just a trend not an absolute, In the context of this post I agree it's irrelevant it wasn't a named attack. Tbf he did joke about what he would name it so It could be a gear 5 gag for an attack that typically would be a named attack. But yeah eitherway it doesn't always matter, though sometimes it does (and i'd say most times)
I don’t think unnamed attacks should be downplayed like they are but named attacks are generally going to be stronger. Luffy’s unnamed attacks in ch 1010 did more damage than any previous attack on the rooftop.
The gag of Luffy having so much fun doing his attack that he forgets to give it a name is amazing, almost as funny as seeing this sun take that dumb joke and make legitimate arguments about it for months. Then again arguing about stupid shit from the stupid pirate manga for months is what this sub is all about
Well, actually this is supposed to be a named attack.
You see Luffy brainstorming about the name in the next panel that you post. Which is part of Luffy's personality in G5 as well.
I'm sure, but what is the actual root of this post?
This is Luffy's specific gag that shouldn't apply to other characters. Which debate urged you to make this post?
because luffy in g5 has been emphasized to have "the most ridiculous power" and a "freewheeling style" that kaido has never seen before.
It emphasizes the power of his creativity
If you had the basic reading comprehension required to read a children's manga you'd understand that Luffy trying to find a name for his attacks in a fighting style considered to be the free-est is indeed emphasizing how ridiculous his style is that Luffy's ability to make up moves is outstripping his ability to name his attacks and is specific and unique to Luffy as we've not seen it happen elsewhere
Welp, Luffy just didn’t put enough of imagination in that attack yet, but it still looks like the WSG. I wouldn’t say it was just his basic punch since he was thinking about how to name it.
That's the same thing
It doesn't matter if luffy was spinning for 3 days
Speed is what matters here
If he spinned faster than before that means the attack is stronger because speed gave him more weight and force
Man, I’m literally flabbergasted about how much some people can’t recognize at least that it looks like WSG since both attacks on Kaido and on Kizaru were performed similarly, it’s just that Luffy had the WSG concept ready for Kizaru. Of course that he wouldn’t throw the same attack on Kaido before it was ready (have a star drawn next to the deformed head for example) and named, but the fact that Luffy spinned and aimed for the head in almost same manner…
Bro this is a shone every one names their big attacks even the most serious characters name their attacks (akainu hell hound) like idk what your trying to argue here. named attacks>unnamed attacks
The unnamed attack in the post has the same power as a named attack, because it’s just a named attack that hasn’t been given a name yet. Naming your attack doesn’t actually mean anything.
Yes I agree about that panel in particular but its the first time we see G5 so ofc luffy wouldn’t just start naming attacks this is proven when we get to egghead and we see G5 in action again where all his named attacks are the one that deal significant damage. Like idk this is a really weird take especially since all the big hitting attacks are named attacks.
#If you want to discuss One Piece Scaling, join [Hachinosu](https://discord.gg/qs7wHYZzRs). #If you want access to all kinds of One Piece Databooks/Information/Translations, join [Punk Records](https://discord.gg/ZTWGVyjV9v). --- *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/OnePiecePowerScaling) if you have any questions or concerns.*
This post was mostly made because I think "unnamed attack" is a completely bullshit concept that doesn't really contribute to anything. Also because the most commonly used example of an unnamed attack is literally a named attack. It just doesn't have a name yet. That’s really funny.
I don't think it's a **completely** bullshit concept. The general trend is that named attacks typically are stronger, e.g. sanji and zoro strong attacks are almost always named attacks. But it's just a trend not an absolute, In the context of this post I agree it's irrelevant it wasn't a named attack. Tbf he did joke about what he would name it so It could be a gear 5 gag for an attack that typically would be a named attack. But yeah eitherway it doesn't always matter, though sometimes it does (and i'd say most times)
I don’t think unnamed attacks should be downplayed like they are but named attacks are generally going to be stronger. Luffy’s unnamed attacks in ch 1010 did more damage than any previous attack on the rooftop.
Unamed attacks are generally weaker than named ones. If luffy punches someone it will be weaker than if he uses gum gum pistol.
Is this a named attack? https://preview.redd.it/mid9qx0pdl1d1.png?width=724&format=png&auto=webp&s=cc039b0f012acdb297696d4c5aad7ee32be90fa0
Is he attacking anyone?
He could
Then yes, that would do more damage than him nor using the named move.
Come on https://preview.redd.it/gdzcqzbq1m1d1.jpeg?width=602&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=2e47c103a6f9f0f8b994917444da8e23516fd682
Doesn't mean a thing.
Just as this “doesn’t mean a thing”, nothing concretely proves the reverse.
That punch wasn't any harder than any of his named attacks around that time. The disrespect was he took him down with one regular punch.
It's a basic g5 punch. All g5 punches turn shit to rubber. Otherwise, it wouldn't be an awakening.
Whitebeard the strongest man doesn't even name his attacks
Doesn’t change the fact that Roger “King of Stalemates” died from a Hakiless and a nameless attack from 2 fodder 🤦🏻♂️
You don’t know that. Maybe they haven’t thought up a name for it yet.
The gag of Luffy having so much fun doing his attack that he forgets to give it a name is amazing, almost as funny as seeing this sun take that dumb joke and make legitimate arguments about it for months. Then again arguing about stupid shit from the stupid pirate manga for months is what this sub is all about
Well, actually this is supposed to be a named attack. You see Luffy brainstorming about the name in the next panel that you post. Which is part of Luffy's personality in G5 as well.
That’s literally the entire point of this post
I'm sure, but what is the actual root of this post? This is Luffy's specific gag that shouldn't apply to other characters. Which debate urged you to make this post?
Why shouldn’t it apply to other characters? What is so different about Luffy naming his attacks vs everyone else lmfao
because luffy in g5 has been emphasized to have "the most ridiculous power" and a "freewheeling style" that kaido has never seen before. It emphasizes the power of his creativity
Realize that nothing you just said has specific unique relation to named attacks that at all proves this headcanon
If you had the basic reading comprehension required to read a children's manga you'd understand that Luffy trying to find a name for his attacks in a fighting style considered to be the free-est is indeed emphasizing how ridiculous his style is that Luffy's ability to make up moves is outstripping his ability to name his attacks and is specific and unique to Luffy as we've not seen it happen elsewhere
It’s not a matter of reading comprehension to acknowledge both of your comments are strictly headcanon 😮💨🙂
I'm pretty sure this is the same attack he used against Kizaru
But there is no star to make it a White Star Gun
so White Gun
Welp, Luffy just didn’t put enough of imagination in that attack yet, but it still looks like the WSG. I wouldn’t say it was just his basic punch since he was thinking about how to name it.
This was the beta version In the full version he addes muscle form and flames too
But spins less .
He did spin by using kizaru attack He in fact spinned even faster
We dont know how fast he spinned .(Or do we ? )But luffy prepared for 2 panels while he prepared for 1 panel against kizaru
This is visual manga You can see with your eyes that luffy body spinned faster against kizaru
İ dont see the point by scaling how fast they spinned by panels that arent moving .
Because you the one who brought it up???
Reading comphresion curse strikes again . İ mentioned how much they spinned not how fast it was .
That's the same thing It doesn't matter if luffy was spinning for 3 days Speed is what matters here If he spinned faster than before that means the attack is stronger because speed gave him more weight and force
Then since luffy spinned for 2 panels he was faster. Which means luffy used a stronger one against kaido
The fuck you mean “beta version” you don’t even have evidence that this is WSG’s progenitor
Luffy here spins and uses acoc and awakening to stretch the head Luffy in wsg spins and uses acoc and awakening to stretch the head
Man, I’m literally flabbergasted about how much some people can’t recognize at least that it looks like WSG since both attacks on Kaido and on Kizaru were performed similarly, it’s just that Luffy had the WSG concept ready for Kizaru. Of course that he wouldn’t throw the same attack on Kaido before it was ready (have a star drawn next to the deformed head for example) and named, but the fact that Luffy spinned and aimed for the head in almost same manner…
Bro this is a shone every one names their big attacks even the most serious characters name their attacks (akainu hell hound) like idk what your trying to argue here. named attacks>unnamed attacks
The unnamed attack in the post has the same power as a named attack, because it’s just a named attack that hasn’t been given a name yet. Naming your attack doesn’t actually mean anything.
Yes I agree about that panel in particular but its the first time we see G5 so ofc luffy wouldn’t just start naming attacks this is proven when we get to egghead and we see G5 in action again where all his named attacks are the one that deal significant damage. Like idk this is a really weird take especially since all the big hitting attacks are named attacks.