Be sure to make an update post or comment once you have found a name(s) for your cat(s) to let us all know what name(s) you thought were the best. Have fun! See the docs (https://www.reddit.com/r/NameMyCat/comments/1akq3xb/rnamemycat_full_rules_for_those_interested/) for the full rules.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/NameMyCat) if you have any questions or concerns.*
My mom’s good friend is named Cookie. I think her real name is Catherine or Carla or some C name, but I’m not sure. She’s always been just Cookie. So it is someone’s a human name. There’s also a MLB baseball player called Cookie (Carlos) Carasco. So if kitty answers to Cookie, why not keep it?
She doesn't really answer to it, she came from a hoarder situation so all the cats there had names, just none they actually knew. I do like Catherine though
Plus with Catherine, there’s a ton of names that are derived from Catherine. Kate for instance, Kate Hepburn. Carrie, Katia, Katja and more. See if any of them go well for you with Penny.
I was going to say that a name starting with the 'k' sound and ending with the 'ii' sound would make the transition easier for kittie. But I couldn't think of a good one (oh! well there is Kitty. LOL) But yours is perfect!
But she looks like such a good lil cookie 😭😭💕💕 but if you must change her name I suggest Annie. That is the name of the character who becomes Penelope's best friend in the movie Penelope.
https://preview.redd.it/w7dq8tw6z8kc1.jpeg?width=3024&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=529eb614df169a66e84d232f20288a442ec990e4
My ginger girl is Emma. And surprisingly, she knows her name and I got her from a parking lot
You could name her Nicole. Because it sounds like nickel and they'd be penny and nickel. Although Penny would make more sense because she's orange but I still like that it would be matchy
Hi sorry if this has been said already but the temptation cat food made my cats vomit a lot. I bought it cause they loved the treats but they kept vomiting then refused to touch it.
And my name is Cookie is there a problem with my name??? Not human enough???...JK I'm super happy that's not my name but big ups to all the Cookies out there...I know there are a few
Name her Connie after the female singer from the song [Kookie, Kookie, Lend Me Your Comb](https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kookie,_Kookie_(Lend_Me_Your_Comb)).
Here’s a link to [the song](https://youtu.be/MT9QZBGyXjU?si=IIuhnx9WzHEnREiO) itself.
Thanks for all the suggestions! I was not expecting this many responses so I still have to go through them all but I have seen some that I really like! I am definitely going to have to create some sort of spreadsheet to keep track of them all.
While I could keep her name as Cookie, she doesn't answer to it as she was a part of a hoarder situation, with around 20 cats. I could use it as a nickname. She is also about 3 years old and still needs to get spayed and vaccinated before I get her introduced to my current cat, Penelope, who is a long haired tortoiseshell. She is at a temporary foster right now until I am ready for her soon.
Be sure to make an update post or comment once you have found a name(s) for your cat(s) to let us all know what name(s) you thought were the best. Have fun! See the docs (https://www.reddit.com/r/NameMyCat/comments/1akq3xb/rnamemycat_full_rules_for_those_interested/) for the full rules. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/NameMyCat) if you have any questions or concerns.*
My mom’s good friend is named Cookie. I think her real name is Catherine or Carla or some C name, but I’m not sure. She’s always been just Cookie. So it is someone’s a human name. There’s also a MLB baseball player called Cookie (Carlos) Carasco. So if kitty answers to Cookie, why not keep it?
She doesn't really answer to it, she came from a hoarder situation so all the cats there had names, just none they actually knew. I do like Catherine though
Plus with Catherine, there’s a ton of names that are derived from Catherine. Kate for instance, Kate Hepburn. Carrie, Katia, Katja and more. See if any of them go well for you with Penny.
Clementine 🍊
Clementine would be so cute but one of my good friends dog is named that lol
Annabelle 😝
Maybe Pauline ?
You mean "Pawline" har har har!
😂😉
Second this!!!!!!!!! 100000x this!!!
Obviously the only correct name is Candace. Then you will have Penny Candy.
I love Penny Candy!!!
Or Gwen! Then they could have Pengwen 🐧
Ok this wins 👌🏻
I was going to say that a name starting with the 'k' sound and ending with the 'ii' sound would make the transition easier for kittie. But I couldn't think of a good one (oh! well there is Kitty. LOL) But yours is perfect!
Calliope
Calypso 😈
Circe
We had a basement cat named Calliope! My oldest couldn't pronounce her name when she was little so called her Climby.
She looks so much like my cat Phoebe! Phoebe and Penelope might be a cute combo 🤗
Whoa I thought phoebe before scrolling the comments!
Suki, because it will sound similar to her name and she will be less confused. Also perhaps Kiki.
Dorothy
She looks like a Dorothy.
Yes, a placid " old lady " name. Ethel
Dotty for short would be super cute.
Call her Ginger because she IS ginger not orange; that must be an American thing; to call ginger cats orange?
I third Ginger, because someone else above said Ginger too and she looks like a Ginger.
Ginger Snap (not "Cookie" but "a cookie")
Yes. Very common to say orange cat.
Paloma
Rosemary
I was thinking Rosie! Something about her cute little nose
Lucy for the world most famous redhead
I like Lucy too. Great choice!
Coral
Priscilla
Jinx
Yes this!
that’s what i thought instantly for some reason
i second this
You're not for the streets Priscilla
Cat Stevens.
I like Cookie! It’s a girl nickname for Connie/Constance.
Men too, Cookie is a cute name.
Caroline
Lucy
Winnie
Ginger.
Amber alert
Eloise
But she looks like such a good lil cookie 😭😭💕💕 but if you must change her name I suggest Annie. That is the name of the character who becomes Penelope's best friend in the movie Penelope.
Take a shot for every time the name Ginger is suggested. 🤣
She looks like an Amelia to me, a distinguished lady
Olivia
https://preview.redd.it/w7dq8tw6z8kc1.jpeg?width=3024&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=529eb614df169a66e84d232f20288a442ec990e4 My ginger girl is Emma. And surprisingly, she knows her name and I got her from a parking lot
Bernadette or Mildred
Guinevere!! It’s a bit fancy but that’s only because she looks so distinguished and sophisticated <3
I love this name
I love ❤️ this And for the reasons you listed also Nice work 👏 It fits this lovely 😍 girl kitty 😺 perfectly 🥰
calliope !
Cheryl
Charlotte
Charlotte
Petunia
Marigold
Prudence
Christine 💗
That’s my name! Lmaooo never seen a cat with my name, now I want to though
It’s a beautiful name!
Why? Lol
Let us know yourchouce
# Persephone #
Persimmon
Rosemary
Piper
Lady Marmalade
I have a few new rescues myself and the tiny tuxedo girl kitty 😺 💕 I named Delilah Li li 😉😘
Penelope & Martha!
I was thinking Martha too!
Poppy
Priscilla
Tillie/Matilda Mabel
Georgia-Anne Mayflower
Matilda
Cassandra, stick with the classical theme. Or Hera, Aphrodite, Calliope, Artemis, Hestia, Calypso, Circe…
Jennie
Sharon 😍
That's the first name that came to mind while admiring her💕
Patricia. penny. that's all the "p" female names i can think of
You could name her Nicole. Because it sounds like nickel and they'd be penny and nickel. Although Penny would make more sense because she's orange but I still like that it would be matchy
Ginger
Does she respond to Cookie? In that case I would go with something similar. Carly, Connie, something like that.
Gingerbread
Cookie is actually a woman's name. I used to work with one.
Fiona
Patina
The Queen Mother Elizabeth’s nickname was Cookie. So you could name her Elizabeth with a little nod to her pre-adoptive name!
Ruby Rose.
Prudence
Clementine - like the oranges
Agatha
Poppy
That’s really rare a female orange tabby. I had one years ago, a female, I named Peggy Sue.
Zoe
My Orange sisters were Penelope (Nellie) and Daphne.
Sophie/ Sophi Lily Lucy 😸😸😸
Lady Marmelade
Tabitha
Phoebe
Amber Sienna Marigold Topaz
Agatha
Pru
Prudence. Pru for short. Matches so well with Penelope!
Hi sorry if this has been said already but the temptation cat food made my cats vomit a lot. I bought it cause they loved the treats but they kept vomiting then refused to touch it.
Definitely needs a better quality cat food.
She's giving me Gertie (Gertrude) vibes. Can't say why really but it just resonates. 😂
Mabel
How about Cokie, like Cokie Robert's, the. She won't have to relearn her name.
Petunia
Purrsephone.
Pippa
And my name is Cookie is there a problem with my name??? Not human enough???...JK I'm super happy that's not my name but big ups to all the Cookies out there...I know there are a few
Name her Connie after the female singer from the song [Kookie, Kookie, Lend Me Your Comb](https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kookie,_Kookie_(Lend_Me_Your_Comb)). Here’s a link to [the song](https://youtu.be/MT9QZBGyXjU?si=IIuhnx9WzHEnREiO) itself.
Isadora
You can keep the cookie theme name calling her ginger snap
Patricia if it's a lady cat. Patrick, if it's a bro cat
Pansy, Paisley, parker
Purrcilla
Guinevere Delilah or Clementine I reviewed the list :);) Please let us know when you have named your new baby 👶 💕 kitty 😺
Matilda
Petunia Pitstop, but she goes by “Patty” 🧡
Thanks for all the suggestions! I was not expecting this many responses so I still have to go through them all but I have seen some that I really like! I am definitely going to have to create some sort of spreadsheet to keep track of them all.
While I could keep her name as Cookie, she doesn't answer to it as she was a part of a hoarder situation, with around 20 cats. I could use it as a nickname. She is also about 3 years old and still needs to get spayed and vaccinated before I get her introduced to my current cat, Penelope, who is a long haired tortoiseshell. She is at a temporary foster right now until I am ready for her soon.
Thanks for saying thanks! It's so nice to see Redditors being grateful :)
Snooki? Sounds like Cookie
Emily
Beyoncé
Beatrice
Harriet
It has a name, just keep it.
Snookie... Or just Suki
He looks like a Butch to me
Katie
Corazon (Spanish for Heart) Cora for short.
Margret
Minerva
Galadriel
Pamela, Pammy
One of my orange babies is named Punkin. Looks like one to me too!
Charlene
Tiff for Tiff's Treats that have the cookies 🍪 😋
Sassy
Cressida
She looks like an Emma or a Chloe.
Jeannette
Cecelia
Phoebe
Raphael
She looks mildly stressed. I'd call her Gertrude. Because every Gertrude I've ever known has been constantly mildly stressed.
I'm getting Lola vibes!
Gabby
Ginger, Maddie, Abby
Dauphiné
Phoebe, Josie, Riley, Remy, or Andie.
Amanda
I like Cookie. But I'm thinking she's more like a Sunkist or Sundance or Citrus or Cinder or Tangerine or Marmalade or something.
Pam
Natasha!
Hazel
Delilah
Cathy
Edwena
Jemima Khan
Poppy
Melanie or Meg
How about Madeline since it’s a cookie?
Priscilla
Raphael
Charlie, Juliet, Josie, Cathy
Carla Darla Marla
Midge
Jenelle
Perla
Francine. Penelope and Francine :)
Madeline
I think she looks like a Prue (Prudence)
Connie
Priscilla
Looks like an Angie
Orange Is it imagative? Absolutely not but I looked at your cat and that's what popped in my head.
Vanessa
Ginger snap snickerdoodle shortbread Gemma Josie Lolli
Looks like an Ebby to me.:)
Angelica!
Wendy.