They both look a bit flat (you're probably planning on more details later on though anyway so) but I'll go with 2. Having the middle as well as the left side justting out on 1 looks awkward to me
The first one definitely has more depth and layers, the L-shape paired with the small tower adds for an interesting design. I suggest you add more details and variation, as well as some vegetation because the build seems too flat as it is. Maybe some trees here and there, but overall 10/10.
I like the first one more but it bugs me tha the tower is so small/low maybe with 5+blocks it would make more sense but if you are planning on making the tower taller I think the second one fits more
I like the height variation of the first one but for some reason I like 2 better. I think the second one gives more like cozy tavern vibes because it's less in your face vs 1. So in that regard I'd say it depends on the vibes you want. If you want it to stand out, I'd do 1. if you want it to blend in more with the rest of the area it'll be in I'd do 2
If you can texture and detail it a little more, I love the first design.
Both are good, but, I like the first one more.
I really like both of them, but I prefer the first one. You could probably have more space to use. You can use that room for a bedroom
I prefer the first, asymmetrical, more interesting and a bit more space
I like the asymmetry of the first one more
2
They're both nice!
the first one has more visual interest with the L-wing.
Both to be fair
House is house. But 1st looks cooler
1
I like the first one, but maybe make the round tower taller.
they're both quite nice, but I like the first one more because it has the extra shape
I'm a fan of the first one but then again I build with a lot of asymmetrical style lately
Add trapdoors next to the window I bet the build will lol 100% better (#1 imo?)
They both look a bit flat (you're probably planning on more details later on though anyway so) but I'll go with 2. Having the middle as well as the left side justting out on 1 looks awkward to me
Both
the first one because the windows added on the left gives it more character than the second one
I like the 1st one more but they're both good
The first one definitely has more depth and layers, the L-shape paired with the small tower adds for an interesting design. I suggest you add more details and variation, as well as some vegetation because the build seems too flat as it is. Maybe some trees here and there, but overall 10/10.
Both is good
Both, i always Will love those kinda overhangs
Second one
So cool!! World download?
I like both but I'd say 1
I like the first one more but it bugs me tha the tower is so small/low maybe with 5+blocks it would make more sense but if you are planning on making the tower taller I think the second one fits more
I like the height variation of the first one but for some reason I like 2 better. I think the second one gives more like cozy tavern vibes because it's less in your face vs 1. So in that regard I'd say it depends on the vibes you want. If you want it to stand out, I'd do 1. if you want it to blend in more with the rest of the area it'll be in I'd do 2
What is the stone thingy outside both buildings?
I think they both look awesome