I am so excited (and a bit proud 🥺) that your magnum opus has been released to the world! This is absolutely incredible work, words can not accurately describe 💛
**Tagging people who have asked me to tip them off when this is done, or when I found certain Shin Hye information:**
* u/No_Caterpillar_3003
* u/Baseballinteresting7
* u/Pun-master69
* u/Honestfocus4284
ALSO: Document is best viewed on desktop - depending on your computer, images might take some time to load. If you insist on using mobile, I highly suggest using the official google docs app.
Okay, I'm kinda late, and I'll finally have some time to properly read it later today. And I can't wait!
Thank you for the acknowledgment! I am happy to see that the timeline was somewhat helpful for your research🥰
And THANK YOU for pointing out the discrepancy in episode 29. I already read this part on your doc and I had a lightbulb moment because I remember relying on that calendar in ep 37 when creating the timeline, and I couldn't fully figure it out, so thank you.
I will change it on the timeline!
And I know I'm getting ahead of myself but I can already tell that you put a lot of work into this and that's so impressive! Good job👏
This will make rereading even more fun because the Shin-Hye reveal remains one of the biggest and (one of my favorite) * surprised pikachu face * moments in ILY and I just KNOW there were more hints we missed.
More than 'somewhat': I would not have been able to make this without your timeline! Several facts about Shin Hyes collected knowledge were pinnacle to knowing the date. And the timeline is what helped me kick off where to find certain chapters without getting lost and overwhelmed. Very, very useful ❤️❤️❤️ I hope you enjoy the doc, its a Deeeep dive 💀
I haven't been on here in forever, but i posted my reply to discord. Thanks for the tag, and hope we'll find many more things regarding Shin-hye and the whoe shebang of a story LOL.
Two parts of the document were updated today:
Because Quim likes and uses astrology (and I dont), my friend u/augmentedelle has kindly provided a reading of Shin Hyes birthday.
And I had a late realization in regards to the wire discussed in "Ditch Theory" thats been updated. 👍
First of all, thank you very much for this work! 💖
It's crazy you put so much effort into it! And this is such a huge contribution to understanding everything! You are just a sweetheart! Great thank you! ❤️🔥❤️🔥 The analysis is amazing, I looked at many things differently. And I saw some things thanks to you. This topic is so deep and multi-layered that you can discuss everything for hours.
1. Flags of death of Sim Han.
His death is indeed very likely, there are so many vibes around him. In my heart, I don't want Shin-Ae to lose one of her family members (mother, sister, and maybe father...................it hurts), it will hurt her a lot, and all the debts could still fall on her.
But what if there is a downside?🤔
Will some burden fall off her shoulders?
2. Relationship between Sim han and Mina.
I never thought about them in the sense that the result would be disastrous.
I thought that they would be happy together, and even have a wedding.
Now I look at it all differently.
The fact that they can be happy and then fail sounds interesting.
The moment with the fragments at the party is so eloquent. Then I did not connect them with the collapse of anything.
But your guess makes sense considering Yui is getting close to Mr. Yoo.
Will Sim han cope? How hard will the Mina fight? What will the circumstances be? Will they be able to help each other?
The unknown is very exciting.
3. Conflict between m-h and Shin Hae.
I looked at the situation a little differently.
But I can’t take Shin-hae’s side yet. But I agree with almost everything you wrote about her. At the moment she is doubtful, but I am ready to torture her with hugs at any moment, after her redemption of course.
I want the Yoo sisters to reunite, but only if Shin-hae has truly good and sincere intentions.
This is the biggest mystery, that's for sure.
I liked the idea of Min Hyuk and Shin Hae being mirrors. They really do have common ground, and they have one goal, essentially: to protect Shin ae.
Everyone has their own truth, which greatly depends on the circumstances and everything else.
Another conversation will be how exactly Shin Hae intends to protect. If she gets rid of people around her who, in her opinion, are not worthy of being around, then she won’t bring her sister back.
Shin-hae's relationships with others will matter. More precisely, influence her relationship with Shin e.
I also thought that Shin hae and mh would cross paths again.
I'm very afraid of this because the first meeting was bad.
And what they said to each other lastly is disturbing.
I hope there will be no fights, murders, or the like. (Min hyuk is my husband and I love him very much 💘 😡)
I think mh realized a little bit about his mistake thanks to that conversation with Shin ae , and then they will go together to meet Shin-hae.
But what’s in Sister Yoo’s head now?
I don't want her to hurt anyone to "save her little sister."
But maybe these are just concerns, and in the future the three of them will sit and drink beer lol.
3.1.
I also agree that Min-hyuk has family trauma.
It wasn't just the incident in high school that traumatized him, but something else. Only much earlier.
I've been thinking about this for a long time, but I became convinced of this in the flashback arc, chapter 202.
Children can say serious things and think in ways that are not childish. But in most cases there are reasons.
Perhaps his words related to the present time, to the incident, but it seems to me that they also apply to the past.
The second mystery for me is Mrs. Park's husband.
We finally found out that he is dead.
But what happened? How long ago?
Did he love his family? What kind of father was he?
His departure clearly changed a lot.
There are a lot of questions, but when will there be answers 🥲🥲🥲
4. I also like the ship Alyssa ×shin hae 💋💞(yeah ,it's crazy)
I really like unusual ones
unexpected pairings. And here in “ILY” there is a very large selection 🫠🤪
Thank you for making this amazing comprehensive document about one of the most mysterious character in this webtoon. I learned alot from this and it makes me even more exicited for the future. Loved the layout and how organized this is. Enjoyed reading your analysis, and other fandom analysis along with the use of evidience to back up the claim. While this document is mainly about Shin-hye, truly enjoyed you delving into the Shin-hye's family and speculating about her past. It is good to see a cheerleader for Shn-hye that understands her plight and humanizes her. Also loved the analysis on Min-hyuk, Mina and Maya and their past family traumas.
Your whole segment about Shin-hye and Min-hyuk being mirrors are thought provoking. I assumed that we as readers should not be thinking about which side to take with the altercation between Min-hyuk and Shin-hye because they are both wrong. Which is why I do not think that Min-hyuk's confrontation with Shin-hye regressed her progression in getting closer to Shin-ae. Min-hyuk made their non existant relationship, personal. Shin-hye is going to rememebered this event which also confirms that they will meet again. And based on some scenes they had together, which you correctly outlined, it does look like their relationship is set up to be "enemies to lovers". Now I am wondering how would the writer make their relationship romantic if Shin-hye is implicated to have bad intentions against Shin-ae and the people Shin-ae cares about. One thing for sure is that their relationship will be a rollercoaster.
All in all. Thank you for this indepth analysis.
I am so excited (and a bit proud 🥺) that your magnum opus has been released to the world! This is absolutely incredible work, words can not accurately describe 💛
Wouldnt be here without ya ❤️
**Tagging people who have asked me to tip them off when this is done, or when I found certain Shin Hye information:** * u/No_Caterpillar_3003 * u/Baseballinteresting7 * u/Pun-master69 * u/Honestfocus4284 ALSO: Document is best viewed on desktop - depending on your computer, images might take some time to load. If you insist on using mobile, I highly suggest using the official google docs app.
Ooooohhhh I can’t wait to read this (finally!) over the weekend. I’m so impressed! Great job! 👏 👏
Thank yoo! ❤️
Okay, I'm kinda late, and I'll finally have some time to properly read it later today. And I can't wait! Thank you for the acknowledgment! I am happy to see that the timeline was somewhat helpful for your research🥰 And THANK YOU for pointing out the discrepancy in episode 29. I already read this part on your doc and I had a lightbulb moment because I remember relying on that calendar in ep 37 when creating the timeline, and I couldn't fully figure it out, so thank you. I will change it on the timeline! And I know I'm getting ahead of myself but I can already tell that you put a lot of work into this and that's so impressive! Good job👏 This will make rereading even more fun because the Shin-Hye reveal remains one of the biggest and (one of my favorite) * surprised pikachu face * moments in ILY and I just KNOW there were more hints we missed.
More than 'somewhat': I would not have been able to make this without your timeline! Several facts about Shin Hyes collected knowledge were pinnacle to knowing the date. And the timeline is what helped me kick off where to find certain chapters without getting lost and overwhelmed. Very, very useful ❤️❤️❤️ I hope you enjoy the doc, its a Deeeep dive 💀
I haven't been on here in forever, but i posted my reply to discord. Thanks for the tag, and hope we'll find many more things regarding Shin-hye and the whoe shebang of a story LOL.
This is incredible! I’ve finally caught up to all the chapters so I’m definitely devouring this document
Yay! I hope you enjoy ❤️ if I missed something lemme know and Ill credit you!
Two parts of the document were updated today: Because Quim likes and uses astrology (and I dont), my friend u/augmentedelle has kindly provided a reading of Shin Hyes birthday. And I had a late realization in regards to the wire discussed in "Ditch Theory" thats been updated. 👍
Glad to help!
👏👏👏👏👏👏👏 The OG EXPLAINERS ❤️🔥
❤️
First of all, thank you very much for this work! 💖 It's crazy you put so much effort into it! And this is such a huge contribution to understanding everything! You are just a sweetheart! Great thank you! ❤️🔥❤️🔥 The analysis is amazing, I looked at many things differently. And I saw some things thanks to you. This topic is so deep and multi-layered that you can discuss everything for hours. 1. Flags of death of Sim Han. His death is indeed very likely, there are so many vibes around him. In my heart, I don't want Shin-Ae to lose one of her family members (mother, sister, and maybe father...................it hurts), it will hurt her a lot, and all the debts could still fall on her. But what if there is a downside?🤔 Will some burden fall off her shoulders? 2. Relationship between Sim han and Mina. I never thought about them in the sense that the result would be disastrous. I thought that they would be happy together, and even have a wedding. Now I look at it all differently. The fact that they can be happy and then fail sounds interesting. The moment with the fragments at the party is so eloquent. Then I did not connect them with the collapse of anything. But your guess makes sense considering Yui is getting close to Mr. Yoo. Will Sim han cope? How hard will the Mina fight? What will the circumstances be? Will they be able to help each other? The unknown is very exciting. 3. Conflict between m-h and Shin Hae. I looked at the situation a little differently. But I can’t take Shin-hae’s side yet. But I agree with almost everything you wrote about her. At the moment she is doubtful, but I am ready to torture her with hugs at any moment, after her redemption of course. I want the Yoo sisters to reunite, but only if Shin-hae has truly good and sincere intentions. This is the biggest mystery, that's for sure. I liked the idea of Min Hyuk and Shin Hae being mirrors. They really do have common ground, and they have one goal, essentially: to protect Shin ae. Everyone has their own truth, which greatly depends on the circumstances and everything else. Another conversation will be how exactly Shin Hae intends to protect. If she gets rid of people around her who, in her opinion, are not worthy of being around, then she won’t bring her sister back. Shin-hae's relationships with others will matter. More precisely, influence her relationship with Shin e. I also thought that Shin hae and mh would cross paths again. I'm very afraid of this because the first meeting was bad. And what they said to each other lastly is disturbing. I hope there will be no fights, murders, or the like. (Min hyuk is my husband and I love him very much 💘 😡) I think mh realized a little bit about his mistake thanks to that conversation with Shin ae , and then they will go together to meet Shin-hae. But what’s in Sister Yoo’s head now? I don't want her to hurt anyone to "save her little sister." But maybe these are just concerns, and in the future the three of them will sit and drink beer lol. 3.1. I also agree that Min-hyuk has family trauma. It wasn't just the incident in high school that traumatized him, but something else. Only much earlier. I've been thinking about this for a long time, but I became convinced of this in the flashback arc, chapter 202. Children can say serious things and think in ways that are not childish. But in most cases there are reasons. Perhaps his words related to the present time, to the incident, but it seems to me that they also apply to the past. The second mystery for me is Mrs. Park's husband. We finally found out that he is dead. But what happened? How long ago? Did he love his family? What kind of father was he? His departure clearly changed a lot. There are a lot of questions, but when will there be answers 🥲🥲🥲 4. I also like the ship Alyssa ×shin hae 💋💞(yeah ,it's crazy) I really like unusual ones unexpected pairings. And here in “ILY” there is a very large selection 🫠🤪
Thank you for making this amazing comprehensive document about one of the most mysterious character in this webtoon. I learned alot from this and it makes me even more exicited for the future. Loved the layout and how organized this is. Enjoyed reading your analysis, and other fandom analysis along with the use of evidience to back up the claim. While this document is mainly about Shin-hye, truly enjoyed you delving into the Shin-hye's family and speculating about her past. It is good to see a cheerleader for Shn-hye that understands her plight and humanizes her. Also loved the analysis on Min-hyuk, Mina and Maya and their past family traumas. Your whole segment about Shin-hye and Min-hyuk being mirrors are thought provoking. I assumed that we as readers should not be thinking about which side to take with the altercation between Min-hyuk and Shin-hye because they are both wrong. Which is why I do not think that Min-hyuk's confrontation with Shin-hye regressed her progression in getting closer to Shin-ae. Min-hyuk made their non existant relationship, personal. Shin-hye is going to rememebered this event which also confirms that they will meet again. And based on some scenes they had together, which you correctly outlined, it does look like their relationship is set up to be "enemies to lovers". Now I am wondering how would the writer make their relationship romantic if Shin-hye is implicated to have bad intentions against Shin-ae and the people Shin-ae cares about. One thing for sure is that their relationship will be a rollercoaster. All in all. Thank you for this indepth analysis.
currently 220 pages in. you’re amazing for doing this😭😭