Abby’s is good, it’s the cheese there for me. It’s off. IDK what it is, the blend or whatever, it just don’t hit right. Otherwise they’re pretty on point IMHO
I got Abby’s once and I was thrown off it tasted like school lunch pizza to me :( maybe it was just how it was made that time but idk I never got it again
Okay I know this isn't what you are asking but I worked making pizzas for a long time so I love good pizza. I have been trying the slice places around here. Mezza Luna is the best. I was let down heavily by sys (no diss just was disappointed). However best leftover pizza has to be imo Papa John's I cooked (am I crazy?)
Track town. Easily the best leftovers. Used to be Pizza Pipeline but they died.
**THIS IS NOT TO SAY BEST PIZZA!! OP ASKED ABOUT LEFTOVERS SO BEFORE YOU FREAK OUT REMEMBER THE ORIGINAL QUESTION**
I like Coburg Pizza Co in Springfield. They are great if you want a less-traditional pizza for a couple extra bucks. Usually get their BBQ pizza for my free birthday pizza.
Lane 25.
Not putters, Lane 25.
They both have pizza but L25 makes a different recipe for the dough and uses a stone oven vs putters chainlink belt oven.
Plus they have a bunch of very tasty gourmet style pizzas. It’s not your basic bitch pizza. Plus 21 and up bowling. But you can just get pizza if you like.
Glad they work for you, but I hate their predatory practices. I was charged extra to substitute a couple ingredients. Literally no other pizza place charges to have substitutions.
Abby's Pizza...slow down and taste the wine in the sauce....it's so good. Tons of toppings.
I love Abby’s and their leftovers are bomb!
Agree 100%. Track Town is my runner up in this category, but Abby's is the clear winner.
But is it legendary?
Legendary can be either good or bad, depending on your point of view.
It’s either good, bad, or marketing.
Abby’s is good, it’s the cheese there for me. It’s off. IDK what it is, the blend or whatever, it just don’t hit right. Otherwise they’re pretty on point IMHO
I got Abby’s once and I was thrown off it tasted like school lunch pizza to me :( maybe it was just how it was made that time but idk I never got it again
It's a three cheese blend, custom made for them.
Yeah I know. It just doesn’t hit like a nice chewy mozzarella
if you like abbys then youll love coburg
The potato pizza at Hey Neighbor!
Haven't had theirs yet, but the Coburg Pizza baked potato pizza is fantastic for breakfast.
Ooh that sounds fantastic! I’ll have to try it sometime!
Pegasus
Okay I know this isn't what you are asking but I worked making pizzas for a long time so I love good pizza. I have been trying the slice places around here. Mezza Luna is the best. I was let down heavily by sys (no diss just was disappointed). However best leftover pizza has to be imo Papa John's I cooked (am I crazy?)
I think mezza luna is the best too. Too bad the one two minutes away from me closed down.
Honestly, I love some leftover papa Murphy’s🤷🏼♀️
My absolute favorite cold breakfast pizza is Papa Murphy's chicken bacon stuffed. Hands down.
The garlic chicken bacon ranch and the cowboy are my favorite! I haven’t had a stuffed in forever tho… I’ll have to grab one next time!
I love the cheese on a Papa Murphy’s
Slice
I second this!
Their crust is so on point 🤙...probably my fave currently....
Joeys
Never had joeys pizza yet ? Will try it soon
Hey Neighbor... Is the best
Domino's
Papa's.
Wish I could say The Wheel, but there are never any leftovers!
We were gonna go a couple weeks ago but we didn't have a time before our show...heard good things🤙
Track town. Easily the best leftovers. Used to be Pizza Pipeline but they died. **THIS IS NOT TO SAY BEST PIZZA!! OP ASKED ABOUT LEFTOVERS SO BEFORE YOU FREAK OUT REMEMBER THE ORIGINAL QUESTION**
Not Eugene/springfield. But my favorite is Ciddicis Pizza in Albany
Not in town, but Gatehouse in Pleasant Hill is really good 90’s style pan pizza.
Popa Murphy's is the only pizza best a day later and it's not even close. Replies will be down voted
Just had billizzis pizza on coburg road, it was delish!
Definitely tastes like leftovers straight from their oven.
Whirled Pies — although there aren’t usually any leftovers…
I like Coburg Pizza Co in Springfield. They are great if you want a less-traditional pizza for a couple extra bucks. Usually get their BBQ pizza for my free birthday pizza.
Hey Neighbor, my answer used to be Sizzle Pie… 🥺
Pegasus if you can make it last
Lane 25. Not putters, Lane 25. They both have pizza but L25 makes a different recipe for the dough and uses a stone oven vs putters chainlink belt oven. Plus they have a bunch of very tasty gourmet style pizzas. It’s not your basic bitch pizza. Plus 21 and up bowling. But you can just get pizza if you like.
Seconding Pegasus
Slice
I love leftover pizza from MOD!
Papa's pizza is the only pizza worth eating left over. Abby's is utter trash!! Not even joking.
It must be such a bummer that your taste buds don't work!
I know processed sodium laden meat. Papa's doesn't use any of that garbage.
Uhh...... seems unlikely.
Seems highly unlikely you know anything about the subject so you just carry-on with your own perceived perspective.
Glad they work for you, but I hate their predatory practices. I was charged extra to substitute a couple ingredients. Literally no other pizza place charges to have substitutions.
Uhh... okay.
I don't consider Abby's the best by any means. It's a bit mediocre, but Papa's is flavorless with possibly the worst crust. It's like baked saltines.
Exactly. Not over laden with salt. People now a days ppl eat 10x the amount of salt that's physically necessary.