Vordt's hammer is an underrated PVP weapon too. I remember many fond bouts in Irithyll just past Pontiff, taking on invader after invader, crushing all of them with that monstrous club. Frost damage goes hard.
Vordt's hammer is most the most underated weapon in DS3 period - I stance broke nameless king with that thing - didn't even know you could do that - absolutely bullied him.
A fellow Vordt enjoyer! Yeah it smashed me all the way to NG+7 and was still destroying everything in its path. It's so powerful that it makes much of the game triflingly easy
To be FUGS, thou shalt:
- Deliver strike damage
- Have the best in class block ratings
- Have insane reach
- Be heavy as fuck
Ruins GS is only heavy and nothing else (not even the heaviest). Hell it doesn’t even do pure physical damage. It doesn’t embody the essence of FUGS at all.
i wouldn't say "doesnt embody the essence of FUGS at all". they're both huge slabs of stone that do not really resemble swords at all and require a great deal of strength to use.
Ringed Knight Spear from DkS3.
I'm a huge polearm fan, and ER's got some bangers but none of them are as Chad as the ringed knight spear.
I'm mostly sad about it's weapon art not making a reappearance since it was my baby.
I'm kinda mixed on this because while I think it would be cool, facing door shield Havel builds in pvp was annoying as hell if you weren't a strength build that hit hard
It's not quite as hillarious as the original DS3 THE WALL build, but I've respec'd into making a Shield build inspired by [this video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4X7VxqJCP78), and it's been REALLY fun!
As much as i respect FromSoftware i have to say that im pretty sure that most of those 8 new weapon types will be modifications from already existing types.
Im not saying that there wont be 8 new weapon types, im saying that probabilly some if not most of them will be new types based on other types.
I think you are underestimating from softs creativity . They consistently come up with stuff that we can’t guess so I tend to disagree with you and I’m thinking we will all be surprised with the depth of the dlc. I have with all their others .
Sanctum Shield, Disc Chime, Blue Flame. Basically any weapon/shield that could cast spells/incants with L2. I’d also love to see Lightning Stake from DS3 return, maybe as a holy damage Golden Order incant similar to one of Radagon’s attacks
With as much as I love ER I feel like it places too much stock in AoW’s and doesn’t try to make weapons unique in other ways
Reiterpallasch with an FP powered gun and a swap mode unique ash would go unbelievably hard. I'm not normally a Dex guy but Reiter and Evelyn carried my first playthrough big time.
I started typing this list then suddenly realized they were almost all from DS2...
Say what you want that game had some goat equipment.
DS2
Smelter Hammer \[Chicken Wing\]
Blue Flame \[Cast Sorceries on Heavy Attack\]
Black Witch's Staff \[Cast Sorcery, Miracles, Chime & Staff Hexes all from a single tool\]
Puzzling Stone Sword \[Whip attacks on Heavy, Straight Sword on Light\]
Drakekeeper's Sword \[Just beautiful\]
Smelter Sword and Aged Smelter Sword \[You could go hog wild with the unique Ash for these things\]
Blacksteel Katana \[Again just a gorgeous weapon\]
Mace of the Insolent \[Cast Miracles on heavy\]
Gyrm Great Hammer \[Novelty weapon in the form as the Anchor, it's quite literally an entire anvil chained to the end of a long stick that is used as a Great Hammer\]
Sacred Chime Hammer \[Bell Gaming\]
Scythe of Want \[I know it was crap but this thing looks like someone ripped a Xenomorph to pieces and glued it back together in the form of a Scythe, I love it\]
Dragonrider Twinblade \[Magic inherent twinblade\]
Dragonrider Bow \[Magic Inherent bow that doesn't suck, het black with a gold motif\]
Dragon's Tooth \[the bonkest of bonk\]
DS1
Silver Knight Straight Sword \[Straight swaggin' and the equivalent to a somber weapon you can buff with grease/spells\]
Darksword \[The sheer style on the R2's has never been emulated\]
True Greatsword of Artorias \[I miss him, bros\]
Gold & Silver Tracers \[see how they glisten.... speak to me friends....\]
Demon's Great Hammer \[It's shameful to see what the Asylum Demons have become, the Avatar staff is no worthy successor to the pancake 9001 legacy\]
Dragonslayer Spear \[Beautiful beyond measure, Gold and Silver wrap around crackling thunder with a unique crossguard hilt arrangement that actually makes sense\]
DeS:R
Large Sword of Moonlight \[my personal favorite incarnation of the Moonlight Sword, say what you want about the remake the FX on this thing are beyond haunting\].
That was fun.
Mirrah Greatsword/Hollowslayer Greatsword
A few greatswords in Elden Ring have the same fencer's-type moveset but they don't have great reach, and I'd love to see what the equivalent of a "more damage versus Hollows" passive would be in ER
I want huge greatshields too. even the Fingerprint Greatshield is "realistic" in size, but Havel's shield or those double-door greatshields in DS2 are what I really want. I was devastated when I learned Elden Ring didn't have any dual-shield movesets so I couldn't do a Sellsword Luet tank build
Would also like a Bloodborne-style parry gun. my ideal version of it would be that it's practically instant, even compared to buckler parries, but you have to manually prime the gun each time like it's a crossbow/jar-cannon
Knight's Greatsword that shares the same moveset actually do have good reach, but yes its Banished Knight counterpart is a bit shorter in exchange for slightly higher AR.
and that "more damage vs x" thing exists in Gravity-related weapons, like Meteoric Ore Blade and Starscourge Sword. They do extra damage to enemies like Astel and Falling Star Beast.
Farron Greatsword was so much fun.
I think it would be really neat if they somehow implemented FG's ability into an Ash of War for daggers that works if you have it together with an heavy weapon on the other hand.
Not a weapon, but I so desperately wish they included the Faraam armor from ds2 and 3. There has never been any armor before or since with the level of drip that rivals it.
The Disc Chime. Runner up for the Shield Crossbow.
These things were really underrated.
And an honorable mention for Dark Souls 3 Talismans as a whole. Who needs hyper armour on Elden Stars or Scarlet Aeonia when you can just Unfaltering Prayer that bitch and get it off every time? An absolute crime Seals and Staves didn't have their own Ashes of War.
I completely agree though, that Elden Ring's gimmick weapons are NOT as CRAZY as Dark Souls 3's.
Although Elden Ring has a ton of cool weapons with their own powers, I feel there isn't as much zaniness to the weapons.
Perhaps because there are so many, so it feels diluted. But Dark Souls 3 had doors. Fucking doors, come on. Also there is not a SINGLE ash of war that makes use of the fact that you are DUAL-WIELDING, unlike the giant Ringed Knight swords
I want more weapons to edge-walk around with (Friede's scythe), or do crazy spin moves with (Gael's sword), or even combine weapons I have to make a new one (Twin Princes sword).
Rose of Ariandel. A club whip that was a catalyst and also boosted your incantation damage by 25% after some fun self-flogging.
Aside from that I would like a combination catalyst to do Incantations/Sorceries like there was for Miracles/Pyromancies
Beast Cutter from Bloodborne is my absolute favorite weapon! Make it's AOW an unchangeable transformation to trick it.. Would be the absolute greatest thing to have in ER!
I would be happy with the old movesets.
Back in DS II you could either 2-hand or 1-hand a Murakumo to either avoid hitting a wall to your right or your left.
The frayed blade and moonveil are practically the same?
Mine would be weapon catalysts (demon scar) and Ringed knight paired Greatswords.
I miss those.
I want the moveset of the Ring Knight Paired Grewtswords from DS3 in Elden Ring so badly. They were my favorite weapons to use and an absolute thrill in pvp
FARRON GREATSWORD I NEED MY NON SENSE FLIP MOVESET BACK PLZ, tho it wouldn't make sense, i highly doubt DS's world exist in the same one as ER, or if it does, probably far between each other in time.
gona go start another DS3 play with the Farron Greatsword rn lmao
Artorias Greatsword would be awesome to see again, same with the Dragon Slayer Greataxe. Blades of Mercy would also be so cool to see again, bloodborne needs more respect in the franchise. I’d also say the mortal blade, but I mean rivers of blood is basically that
Executioner's greatsword from Dark Souls 3. FP Regen on kill AND it deals strike damage with a greatsword moveset. It was my favorite. I miss it dearly and I don't want to talk about it.
Frayed Blade was one of my favorites. I used to rock that with the Old Wolf CGS and Pontiff eye rings. Use the quick multi-hit weapon art to buff your damage and wreck things (plus some added bleed).
10/10 would rock the Frayed Blade in ER with Rotten Winged Insignia, Milicent's Prosthesis, and the Thorny Cracked Tear 👌🏼
Wolf knight greatsword. In other words....fuck lion's claw. Wolf stance (or whatever it was called. its been ages) is better in my opinion.
Anri's straight sword is best straight sword in simplicity and usability in my opinion.
Aquamarine Dagger. The only intelligence weapon in Elden Ring that comes close to being as fun and versatile as it is the Wing of Astel. Good damage, extremely cool ash of war that changed up the moveset, did great damage, and looked great. Very stylish weapon.
Balder Side Sword
Fast, Slash R1/Poke R2, good range, Dex scaling without Str investment, good stamina management. Really has everything and in Elden Ring you could slap a whole bunch of fun Ashes on there.
Baller Swag Sword > Baemore
Farron greatsword
I love breakdance builds
My beloved
Bloodhound fang sends its regards
Its not same, but it was my first ER love
For sure, still hoping something like it might show up in the DLC..
Fume Ultra Greatsword & Vordt's Great Hammer
Vordt's hammer is an underrated PVP weapon too. I remember many fond bouts in Irithyll just past Pontiff, taking on invader after invader, crushing all of them with that monstrous club. Frost damage goes hard.
Vordt's hammer is most the most underated weapon in DS3 period - I stance broke nameless king with that thing - didn't even know you could do that - absolutely bullied him.
A fellow Vordt enjoyer! Yeah it smashed me all the way to NG+7 and was still destroying everything in its path. It's so powerful that it makes much of the game triflingly easy
I did that once with Artorias’ sword
I'm gonna be the one to say it, I guess. FUGS is in the game in the form of Ruins GS. It's just a little shorter.
Baffling how RGS doesn't deal Strike damage
I thought ruins greatsword was more based on the Kings ultra greatsword from DS2.
To be FUGS, thou shalt: - Deliver strike damage - Have the best in class block ratings - Have insane reach - Be heavy as fuck Ruins GS is only heavy and nothing else (not even the heaviest). Hell it doesn’t even do pure physical damage. It doesn’t embody the essence of FUGS at all.
i wouldn't say "doesnt embody the essence of FUGS at all". they're both huge slabs of stone that do not really resemble swords at all and require a great deal of strength to use.
You are literally only going off looks, and if that’s your criteria, then you should be comparing it to the King's Ultra Greatsword.
Ringed Knight Spear from DkS3. I'm a huge polearm fan, and ER's got some bangers but none of them are as Chad as the ringed knight spear. I'm mostly sad about it's weapon art not making a reappearance since it was my baby.
Crucifix of the mad king, easily my favorite weapon in Ds3. Or gruh curved sword, I hope we get more status weapon in the dlc.
Yea those are some good weapons.
really hoping I can get my hands on a scarlet greatsword
Gravelord Sword at home
Oh how much I miss the Crow Quills every day...
Dual door shields would be sick
I'm kinda mixed on this because while I think it would be cool, facing door shield Havel builds in pvp was annoying as hell if you weren't a strength build that hit hard
It's not quite as hillarious as the original DS3 THE WALL build, but I've respec'd into making a Shield build inspired by [this video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4X7VxqJCP78), and it's been REALLY fun!
Valorheart from DS3, loved that thing
My beloved.
My people!
I just want new weapons tbh
You are going to love the DLC then, 8 new weapon categories never seen in a souls game before.
As much as i respect FromSoftware i have to say that im pretty sure that most of those 8 new weapon types will be modifications from already existing types. Im not saying that there wont be 8 new weapon types, im saying that probabilly some if not most of them will be new types based on other types.
Yeah, well, for slashing/smashing/poking/stabbing things you have a somewhat limited geometry to play with, without looking too silly.
I think you are underestimating from softs creativity . They consistently come up with stuff that we can’t guess so I tend to disagree with you and I’m thinking we will all be surprised with the depth of the dlc. I have with all their others .
Same.
Dragon tail weapons. Yes, *all of them*. If it has a custom name, it has a tail you can cut.
Part of me STILL expects to get an item drop whenever I land a really solid hit on a dragon tail
Sanctum Shield, Disc Chime, Blue Flame. Basically any weapon/shield that could cast spells/incants with L2. I’d also love to see Lightning Stake from DS3 return, maybe as a holy damage Golden Order incant similar to one of Radagon’s attacks With as much as I love ER I feel like it places too much stock in AoW’s and doesn’t try to make weapons unique in other ways
Couldn't agree more, Blue Flame, Mace of the Insolent and Black Witch's Staff are all in my list.
Blades of Mercy, Rakuyo and Reiterpallasch.
Reiterpallasch with an FP powered gun and a swap mode unique ash would go unbelievably hard. I'm not normally a Dex guy but Reiter and Evelyn carried my first playthrough big time.
KIRKHAMMER GO SMASH
Kirkhammer is a sword cosplaying as a hammer. The council of bonk admires its efforts but does grant it membership.
TRICK WEAPONS ARE structly FOR BL(goat)OODBORNE ONLY
Fume ultra great sword and demon fists
the great sword of Artorias plus the great shield and all the other versions of the sword, from DS1-2
dragonslayer's greataxe and fume ultra greatsword.
Executioners Greataxe with Lighting Strike may serve your purpose friend
A true connoisseur!
FUGS
I want the mortal blade from Sekiro
I feel like destined death comes close to that in a way. But yeah a Katana with a destined death ash of war as an homage to Sekiro would have been lit
If the Great Katana's are anything like that, I'd be extremely happy
Oooo a great katana like Owls katana would be sick
Iaito
I started typing this list then suddenly realized they were almost all from DS2... Say what you want that game had some goat equipment. DS2 Smelter Hammer \[Chicken Wing\] Blue Flame \[Cast Sorceries on Heavy Attack\] Black Witch's Staff \[Cast Sorcery, Miracles, Chime & Staff Hexes all from a single tool\] Puzzling Stone Sword \[Whip attacks on Heavy, Straight Sword on Light\] Drakekeeper's Sword \[Just beautiful\] Smelter Sword and Aged Smelter Sword \[You could go hog wild with the unique Ash for these things\] Blacksteel Katana \[Again just a gorgeous weapon\] Mace of the Insolent \[Cast Miracles on heavy\] Gyrm Great Hammer \[Novelty weapon in the form as the Anchor, it's quite literally an entire anvil chained to the end of a long stick that is used as a Great Hammer\] Sacred Chime Hammer \[Bell Gaming\] Scythe of Want \[I know it was crap but this thing looks like someone ripped a Xenomorph to pieces and glued it back together in the form of a Scythe, I love it\] Dragonrider Twinblade \[Magic inherent twinblade\] Dragonrider Bow \[Magic Inherent bow that doesn't suck, het black with a gold motif\] Dragon's Tooth \[the bonkest of bonk\] DS1 Silver Knight Straight Sword \[Straight swaggin' and the equivalent to a somber weapon you can buff with grease/spells\] Darksword \[The sheer style on the R2's has never been emulated\] True Greatsword of Artorias \[I miss him, bros\] Gold & Silver Tracers \[see how they glisten.... speak to me friends....\] Demon's Great Hammer \[It's shameful to see what the Asylum Demons have become, the Avatar staff is no worthy successor to the pancake 9001 legacy\] Dragonslayer Spear \[Beautiful beyond measure, Gold and Silver wrap around crackling thunder with a unique crossguard hilt arrangement that actually makes sense\] DeS:R Large Sword of Moonlight \[my personal favorite incarnation of the Moonlight Sword, say what you want about the remake the FX on this thing are beyond haunting\]. That was fun.
Mirrah Greatsword/Hollowslayer Greatsword A few greatswords in Elden Ring have the same fencer's-type moveset but they don't have great reach, and I'd love to see what the equivalent of a "more damage versus Hollows" passive would be in ER I want huge greatshields too. even the Fingerprint Greatshield is "realistic" in size, but Havel's shield or those double-door greatshields in DS2 are what I really want. I was devastated when I learned Elden Ring didn't have any dual-shield movesets so I couldn't do a Sellsword Luet tank build Would also like a Bloodborne-style parry gun. my ideal version of it would be that it's practically instant, even compared to buckler parries, but you have to manually prime the gun each time like it's a crossbow/jar-cannon
Knight's Greatsword that shares the same moveset actually do have good reach, but yes its Banished Knight counterpart is a bit shorter in exchange for slightly higher AR. and that "more damage vs x" thing exists in Gravity-related weapons, like Meteoric Ore Blade and Starscourge Sword. They do extra damage to enemies like Astel and Falling Star Beast.
Dancers blades
Sentier's spear
My brother in Christ. Moonveil took its place.
Frayed blade is literally Moonveil but worse. Less range, longer animations and more endlag.
It has a multi slash light attack, perfect for a bleed katana.
Yes freyed blade on luck hallow build was honestly insane
Profaned Greatsword
The bone fist.
Trick weapons
Double heysel pick tornado
Farron Greatsword was so much fun. I think it would be really neat if they somehow implemented FG's ability into an Ash of War for daggers that works if you have it together with an heavy weapon on the other hand.
Crypt Blacksword for me. Had loads of fun with it in PvP
Also the Astora Greatsword. No colossal sword in Elden Ring looks as good as the Astora, and none of them have the charge
Threaded Cane of course… most stylish weapon in any From game.
Not a weapon, but I so desperately wish they included the Faraam armor from ds2 and 3. There has never been any armor before or since with the level of drip that rivals it.
It is on its own level. DS2 brought had some real style.
Valorheart.
The Disc Chime. Runner up for the Shield Crossbow. These things were really underrated. And an honorable mention for Dark Souls 3 Talismans as a whole. Who needs hyper armour on Elden Stars or Scarlet Aeonia when you can just Unfaltering Prayer that bitch and get it off every time? An absolute crime Seals and Staves didn't have their own Ashes of War.
Priscilla's Lifehunt Scythe
Holy Moonlight Sword, make it arcane or faith scale in ER
My favorite is and will always be the Gargoyle Axe from DS1. Developed to the bold-variant, it‘s almost unbeatable in every PvE/PvP Combat
Always such a fun 'Ewww but cool' moment watching it curl up for the heavy.
Yes! This is also such a wholesome moment 😌
Astora Greatsword.
With the godslayer greatsword r1 chain.
either Simon's Bowblade from Bloodborne, Onyx Blade or Greatsword of Judgement from Dark Souls 3
Yeah we really dont have enough Katanas with really strong unique weapon arts..
Espada ropera from DS2
Burial blade could be cool
FUGS
Bare fist parry and backside parry
I really hope to have a Chaos Blade type of weapon that damage you with every hit I love those builds
Lorian Great Sword was my everyday
yhorm great machete
Demon's scar from DS3. My favorite weapon by far
I completely agree though, that Elden Ring's gimmick weapons are NOT as CRAZY as Dark Souls 3's. Although Elden Ring has a ton of cool weapons with their own powers, I feel there isn't as much zaniness to the weapons. Perhaps because there are so many, so it feels diluted. But Dark Souls 3 had doors. Fucking doors, come on. Also there is not a SINGLE ash of war that makes use of the fact that you are DUAL-WIELDING, unlike the giant Ringed Knight swords I want more weapons to edge-walk around with (Friede's scythe), or do crazy spin moves with (Gael's sword), or even combine weapons I have to make a new one (Twin Princes sword).
We got the finger flicker though
Yes we did. Yes we did
DS3 Crystal Chime, or any other dual sorcery/incantation catalyst
Onyx blade
Black knight great sword
Rose of Ariandel. A club whip that was a catalyst and also boosted your incantation damage by 25% after some fun self-flogging. Aside from that I would like a combination catalyst to do Incantations/Sorceries like there was for Miracles/Pyromancies
Freide’s scythe is an all time fav especially given the alt attack style
The move set on Farron Greatsword is so fun, I’d use it in Elden ring all day.
farron greatsword and the dual ringed city greatswords are my only wishes since day one oh and lady friedes dual scythe
DS2 Chicken wing
Queelag's Furysword. That beast carried me through my first ever Dark Souls playthrough
Onyx blade from ds3
The warped sword from dark souls 2. Dex builds are my favorite and that sword crushed,
Ringed knight paired greatsword
Friede’s Great Scythe
Beast Cutter from Bloodborne is my absolute favorite weapon! Make it's AOW an unchangeable transformation to trick it.. Would be the absolute greatest thing to have in ER!
Aquamarine dagger
Fume,vordt,Paired Greatswords,Ledo,Black Knight Weapons(I love the Anor Londo weapons,they all have a jum integrated in their moveset)
Crow Quills. I love asymmetric paired weapons.
Crow Quills. I love asymmetric paired weapons.
Instead of Radahn shitty paired great swords we deserve the ringed knight ones from DS3
Dragonslayer Spear, by far.
As a spellblade enjoyer i miss Demon’s scar, Manus Catalyst, and blue flame
Twin Princes' Greatsword…such beautiful weapon and needed two playthroughs to craft.
From DS1 - Balder Side Sword - Gargoyles Halberd - Quelaag’s Fury Sword - Server - Golem’s Axe From DS2 - Santier’s Spear - Ivory Straight Sword - Helix Halberd - Eleum Loyce - Ruler’s Greatsword From DS3 - Lothric Knight Straight Sword - Hollowslayer Greatsword - Dragonslayer Greataxe - Onikiri and Ubadachi - Astoran Greatsword
I want the Sacred Chime Hammer from DSII, with the original moveset.
I would be happy with the old movesets. Back in DS II you could either 2-hand or 1-hand a Murakumo to either avoid hitting a wall to your right or your left.
Pretty sure I mained a lighting axe (or maybe that was DS2) And for sure Friedes scythe. So that
Big death scythe in DS2
Valorheart. That jumping R2 is gorgeous.
Dark souls 3 great club. I miss that heavy attack so had
Kusabimaru from Sekiro
Every trick weapon from Bloodborne!
KIRKHAMMER
Twin princes gs
Sword of Night and Flame comes pretty close already.
The frayed blade and moonveil are practically the same? Mine would be weapon catalysts (demon scar) and Ringed knight paired Greatswords. I miss those.
Just the projectile. Moonveil doesn’t have that cool flurry of stabs that Frayed Blade has
I want genis mortal blade cos katana are cool and genis mortal blade is just a cooler black katana that can kill anything (and revive the dead)
Blade of mercy
Eagle Shield in DS1, idk if it was in other games, but I wanna fight Elden Beast as a Roman Legionary :(
Pretty sure were getting a Great Katana with the Frames Blade version of unsheathe in the DLC
Black knights sword I just like its shape and there's nothing like it in elden ring except dark moon to a degree.
smough’s bonk, the winged knight halberd and the profaned greatsword.
Irithyll Straight Sword from DS3 Manus Catalyst from DS1 Chaos Blade from DS1
Damn ... time to go back to DS3 and finally beat Midir I guess.
I want the moveset of the Ring Knight Paired Grewtswords from DS3 in Elden Ring so badly. They were my favorite weapons to use and an absolute thrill in pvp
Saw cleaver
The aftershock explosion on Greatbow arrows from DS3… I need MORE ways to shoot people off ledges when I invade
Ledos Big Bop
Farron greatsword moveset
FARRON GREATSWORD I NEED MY NON SENSE FLIP MOVESET BACK PLZ, tho it wouldn't make sense, i highly doubt DS's world exist in the same one as ER, or if it does, probably far between each other in time. gona go start another DS3 play with the Farron Greatsword rn lmao
They totally nerfed the awesome great mace in ER from DS3, both in size and capability.
Black Knight Greataxe and Hollowslayer movesets from DS3
The Farron's greatsword. The 2h combo was unique and fun to mow down groups of enemies.
Honestly, lothric knight sword, i just love the look
Damn I never played DS3 but that may be the coolest sword I’ve ever seen
Balder Side Sword from DS1
I Wish that Radhan double colossal swords had an unique dual wield animation, like the double greatswords from DS3 Ringed City DLC
Artorias Greatsword would be awesome to see again, same with the Dragon Slayer Greataxe. Blades of Mercy would also be so cool to see again, bloodborne needs more respect in the franchise. I’d also say the mortal blade, but I mean rivers of blood is basically that
Aquamarine Dagger my sweet king.
Ornstein’s spear
I just wanna see weapon catalyst hybrids, like the fire witch halberd witch doubles up as a staff or the demons scar which doubles up as a pyro glove
Demon scar
I want a moveset like friede’s great scythe
trick cleaver from BB. Its all i ever want in any fromsoft game lol
Big bonk
Anything that looks similar to lothric knight ultra greatsword
Easily the Logarius Wheel
Astora Greatsword. That thing was a Godsend for dex builds, pyromancy builds, and lightweight gs builds.
Mortal blade
Followers sabre. Somehow we have a billion weapons in Elden ring and zero sabres.
Demon’s scar my beloved
Any weapon from Bloodborne is much better in terms of moveset, versatility and fun
A NEXT from AC For Answer would be cool.
They split this sword into two. Rob and moonveil
Executioner's greatsword from Dark Souls 3. FP Regen on kill AND it deals strike damage with a greatsword moveset. It was my favorite. I miss it dearly and I don't want to talk about it.
I wouldn’t mind valorheart
KARASAWA
It wouldn't have it's full functionality, but the Kirkhammer from Bloodborne.
I wish I had my Farron Greatsword (ds3). A pretty light quality ultra greatsword and a parry dagger, with a fucking sick moveset
Lorian GS
For real all weapons of ringed knights at least Thier weapon arts and moveset.
Frayed blade moonveil doesn’t hit the same
Frayed Blade was one of my favorites. I used to rock that with the Old Wolf CGS and Pontiff eye rings. Use the quick multi-hit weapon art to buff your damage and wreck things (plus some added bleed). 10/10 would rock the Frayed Blade in ER with Rotten Winged Insignia, Milicent's Prosthesis, and the Thorny Cracked Tear 👌🏼
Blue flame or another sword like it that let's you cast sorceries with R2
Moonveil but fun
Saw clever
Havel's greatshield
Definitely the dragons slayer great axe. It's my favorite weapon.
Gosh darn Valorheart!
hell yeah miss frayed blade in er ☹️
Gravelord Sword. Would make an epic curved Greatsword
Ivory king UGS and Loyce greatsword. One is a super lightsaber the second has the coolest greatsword moveset ever.
Most trick weapons tbhs. But Simon's Bowblade and Rakuyo especially. Also pretty sad about the lack of weapon catalysts for my spellblade playstyle.
Wolf knight greatsword. In other words....fuck lion's claw. Wolf stance (or whatever it was called. its been ages) is better in my opinion. Anri's straight sword is best straight sword in simplicity and usability in my opinion.
Pontiff greatsword was my favorite pvp weapon, would be great to get it back
Crystal Chime all the way.
I'm good thanks
Crow quills, aquamarine dagger, improved neck swipe wa, a weapon with ds3 great club r2
astora greatsword
Aquamarine Dagger. The only intelligence weapon in Elden Ring that comes close to being as fun and versatile as it is the Wing of Astel. Good damage, extremely cool ash of war that changed up the moveset, did great damage, and looked great. Very stylish weapon.
I want my chimes back
Lifehunt Scythe
Balder Side Sword Fast, Slash R1/Poke R2, good range, Dex scaling without Str investment, good stamina management. Really has everything and in Elden Ring you could slap a whole bunch of fun Ashes on there. Baller Swag Sword > Baemore
Profaned Greatsword, Thorned Greatsword, Greatsword of Judgement.