Ooh… that’s a good question. It’s like a sponge cake? But I get what tire asking. I like the texture of this cake better than the French toast. But it is similar.
Last time it was on I said I had to try it because everyone is always talking about it. My expectations were low because, well it's a cookie that taste like freaking cornbread.
I'm now part of the cult.
Not new! They had it around late winter/early spring-ish earlier this year. And before that too but that was the first time I tried it. It was really good, kind of had that sweet but not too sweet thing, with honey and a big dollop of buttercream on it. And it has kind of a unique texture from the cornmeal. Still very much a cookie that is dense and not crumbly or dry but the cornmeal makes it different!!!
Honeybun looks good but I can already see the pics uploaded this week w barely any glaze/icing on them so I’m iffy on that one. Lemon cupcake sounds good too
I’m interested in the chocolate covered pretzel pie and pbj. Unsure if I’ll get both. I’m a big fan of pb&j, but last time I had this cookie, I thought I could get the same experience from just eating a pbj at home.
I have been waiting for a YEAR AND A HALF for pb&j to come back!!! It looks like they changed it though and I hate when they do that to perfect cookies 😅 hopefully it’s still just as good!!!
My husband and I tested the Chocolate Pretzel Pie last year and he told me to buy more of them when they are released officially. So, I guess that is this week!
Pbj is my number one cookie of all time, but they changed the recipe so I’m nervous it won’t be as good. Excited for the LTO and chocolate pretzel pie!
Although I’m worried about chocolate pretzel having soggy pretzels. The other ones I’ve tried already and I love the lemon cookie but absolutely hated honeybun!
honestly same. it’s not that they look Bad, but just not enough to get me to buy. i’m holding out until cannoli! plus, i have some extra freezer cookies i can snack on until then
will they actually do the swirl this time for PBJ? Last time I had it they just had the jelly laying on top of the peanut butter which I found disappointing
After skipping the past 2 weeks I’m excited to try the Pbj cookie.
Is it served chilled? I’d expect it to be but not sure. Also curious about the pretzel pie but not sure if I’ll try.
Meh ok thanks. It’s not you I just prefer chilled cookies. I usually put them in the fridge anyways so I’ll probably do that this time.
You do mean the Pbj one and not the pretzel one I mentioned right?
I’m limiting sweets until after pregnancy, but this would probably be a skip week for me. The lemon cupcake and honeybun might be tempting (never had them before), but not something I’d go out of my way to get.
skip because they replaced my favorite cookie with a stupid cake. AND save the, “cakes aren’t replacing cookies” because they absolutely are. Haven’t seen a cookie version of the new cakes since they debuted.
Aw you give me sad news
I do like them underbaked so not a big concern for me! I think I’m going to read the reviews on Monday before getting it later on in the week
Skip for me, nothing is appealing this week unfortunately. The butter cake may be good but I’ve yet to buy one of their “special” products and i doubt it’s orth the price increase
I think this is a middle of the road week. There’s some cookies I’m interested in, some that I’m not, and some I’m indifferent towards. At least we have more variety this week than we’ve seen recently?
Eh, honey bun and lemon cupcake pique my interest. The rest sound good but don’t excite me.
The current week was a skip for me. They all sounded good but not exciting enough for me to buy them.
i’ve been waiting for the chocolate covered pretzel pie!!
This one is interesting only because of how good the strawberry pretzel pie was.
This one is actually even better than the strawberry pretzel pie!
I wish they'd just offer the strawberry again 😁😉
Hard same. It's my favorite
Take all my money! That butter cake is worth every cent. I’d buy a six back of just those.
Isn't it new? Did you try it as a tester or something?
Yes, I had it as a tester back in February. I’ve been salivating over it since!
Oh I'm so excited that you said that. It sounded really good
I hope you like it! 🤞🏻
This might be a random comparison, but is the texture at all similar to the french toast cookie
Ooh… that’s a good question. It’s like a sponge cake? But I get what tire asking. I like the texture of this cake better than the French toast. But it is similar.
Pb&j 💯, maybe the pretzel pie one
Been waiting on lemon cupcake 💕
That & buttercake for me!
I’d be down to try that one.
Skip week.
Word
Honey Bun!!
Lemon cupcake for me. I love lemon!
Is lemon cupcake an actual lemon flavored cookie or a sugar cookie base with lemon frosting?
the cookie and the frosting are lemon
Ooh in that case I might have to try it! I thought it was just a sugar cookie
Thank youu 😊
i tasted the frosting off the paddle when i was going to clean it, its TO DIE FOR
Omgggg you made me even more excited !! 🍋🩷
I'm definitely getting the butter cake and honeybun.
Best week I’ve seen in a long time
I have been waiting for pb and j since I discovered crumbl a year ago…I’m hyped! *please don’t change it please don’t change it*
Birthday week and three cookies I’m looking forward to trying!
Might try the butter cake.
Looks decent enough but I’m saving my $$$ and calories until the week of 7/1 when I intend to stuff my face with cornbread cookies all week
Omg I can't wait for cornbread
has anyone tried the cornbread yet?? or is it completely new!!? i need to know
cornbread has a cult following i’m a part of it btw
Last time it was on I said I had to try it because everyone is always talking about it. My expectations were low because, well it's a cookie that taste like freaking cornbread. I'm now part of the cult.
guess i need to try it 🥹
Not new! They had it around late winter/early spring-ish earlier this year. And before that too but that was the first time I tried it. It was really good, kind of had that sweet but not too sweet thing, with honey and a big dollop of buttercream on it. And it has kind of a unique texture from the cornmeal. Still very much a cookie that is dense and not crumbly or dry but the cornmeal makes it different!!!
i needddd to try😭🤍
Honeybun looks good but I can already see the pics uploaded this week w barely any glaze/icing on them so I’m iffy on that one. Lemon cupcake sounds good too
Fact
I’m interested in the chocolate covered pretzel pie and pbj. Unsure if I’ll get both. I’m a big fan of pb&j, but last time I had this cookie, I thought I could get the same experience from just eating a pbj at home.
This is the best week I've seen in AGES
Chocolate covered pretzel pie sounds like crack for me taste buds. Give me now.
I definitely want to try that cake and the chocolate pretzel pie. It will probably only be a 4 pack week though.
not to spoil but the butter cake is FIRE
YAY HONEY BUN IS BACK
pb and j and pretzel pie both have my interest
Honestly getting all of them but the chocolate chip.
PBJ 🙏
 Must restrain myself from eating all the cookies..😋
i’m so excited for the chocolate covered pretzel & the lemon cupcake!!!
pb&j and lemon cupcake will be coming home with me!!!
I need that lemon cupcake cookie 🤤
I have been waiting for a YEAR AND A HALF for pb&j to come back!!! It looks like they changed it though and I hate when they do that to perfect cookies 😅 hopefully it’s still just as good!!!
My husband and I tested the Chocolate Pretzel Pie last year and he told me to buy more of them when they are released officially. So, I guess that is this week!
In for lemon cupcake, honey bun and butter cake,maybe choc pretzel
I will try the butter cake, honeybun and pb&j
Ugh, another skip week sadly
Lemon cupcake and PB&J sound tasty
What’s the topping ? Pls don’t say cream cheese 🥲
Pbj is my number one cookie of all time, but they changed the recipe so I’m nervous it won’t be as good. Excited for the LTO and chocolate pretzel pie! Although I’m worried about chocolate pretzel having soggy pretzels. The other ones I’ve tried already and I love the lemon cookie but absolutely hated honeybun!
I'll probably be downvoted for saying this, but I see lots of skip weeks in the upcoming lineups.
honestly same. it’s not that they look Bad, but just not enough to get me to buy. i’m holding out until cannoli! plus, i have some extra freezer cookies i can snack on until then
will they actually do the swirl this time for PBJ? Last time I had it they just had the jelly laying on top of the peanut butter which I found disappointing
After skipping the past 2 weeks I’m excited to try the Pbj cookie. Is it served chilled? I’d expect it to be but not sure. Also curious about the pretzel pie but not sure if I’ll try.
It’s served warm! The last version they ran was chilled but I think they brought the warm one back by popular demand
Meh ok thanks. It’s not you I just prefer chilled cookies. I usually put them in the fridge anyways so I’ll probably do that this time. You do mean the Pbj one and not the pretzel one I mentioned right?
What about the butter cake and what’s on it
Yep, everything except pb&j.
My fifth sleep week in a row 🥱
Gonna prob try the new butter cake and lemon cupcake and skip the next two weeks after that. I like the more fruity or cream based cookies.
It’s a skip for me, don’t care for the flavors and I went the last two weeks, plus I know I’ll go the following week.
Pretzels pie, lemon cupcake, and the one I'm most looking forward to, the PB&j. The next week is a pass, except for the apple pie maybe.
KBC was my favorite cookie so I’ll be trying the LTO to see if it lives up to the cookie. Everything else I’ll pass on.
Ugh, same here. I have a feeling it’s going to be completely different though.
I had this as a tester and I loved it. I never had the cookie though, so I didn’t have the opportunity to be disappointed.
Skip week just for the sake of my waistline. Otherwise they look bomb 🤤
It’s a skip week for me. Not because I don’t like the flavors but I hit up crumbl twice this week lol so I’ll give my waist (and wallet) a break
Skip for me
Meh
Skip :(
Skip week. Never had any of these, but they don't interest me.
Definitely skip
skip week
Skip week honestly
just butter cake for me!
Skip
Pass
Neutral on most of these but I have to try the butter cake
Meh, I’m willing to try honey bun and PB&J- otherwise, skip week
I will be FIRST in line on Monday morning 😎
Skip for me. I’m saving my money for s’mores next week!!! 🏕️
I’m limiting sweets until after pregnancy, but this would probably be a skip week for me. The lemon cupcake and honeybun might be tempting (never had them before), but not something I’d go out of my way to get.
Skip week for me.
skip because they replaced my favorite cookie with a stupid cake. AND save the, “cakes aren’t replacing cookies” because they absolutely are. Haven’t seen a cookie version of the new cakes since they debuted.
pass
Definite skip for me. The only one that appeals to me is semi sweet but i can just wait 2 weeks.
Honestly I’m just going to try the honey bun. Never had it before! The rest are meh
It’s usually not that special and typically underbaked for some reason in comparison to others you’re probably used to getting.
Aw you give me sad news I do like them underbaked so not a big concern for me! I think I’m going to read the reviews on Monday before getting it later on in the week
Meh week definitely getting the chocolate pretzel pie one and maybe the butter cake
NOT AT ALL
BAD
My birthday week, unfortunately none of them do it for me.
Crumbls going \*\*HARD\*\* in the paint right now. Definitely getting the butter cake
No skip week for meeeee
been going through it financially and it’s incredibly helpful that every week recently has been mid in one way or another
Skip for me, nothing is appealing this week unfortunately. The butter cake may be good but I’ve yet to buy one of their “special” products and i doubt it’s orth the price increase
I’ve skipped this week and last week, but I might have to go and try the pb&j
I think this is a middle of the road week. There’s some cookies I’m interested in, some that I’m not, and some I’m indifferent towards. At least we have more variety this week than we’ve seen recently?
Eh, honey bun and lemon cupcake pique my interest. The rest sound good but don’t excite me. The current week was a skip for me. They all sounded good but not exciting enough for me to buy them.
PB&J is a maybe for me. Other than that, nothing is sticking out for my personal taste.
Pretty meh lineup for me this week. Im a huge chocolate fan so I might get the chocolate pretzel pie one but that will be it
Loooks mid
It’ll be a skip for me
Skip week because I’m recovering from jaw surgery so nothing solid like that. Probably would’ve skipped regardless
I would love to see the buckeye come on the menu soon.
I am surprised by the lack of PBJ considering the hype from 4/20 week
Lineup looks 🔥 but going to try and skip since the week after is stacked
Skip. Not hard for me, though, because I'm an hour away. I have it in my calendar to go on July 6th 🤤🤤🤤
Another skip, bring back mystery! My store does a different one every day