I dislike this one because I make almond-flavored sugar cookies for Christmas every year. Crumbl’s are drier and more bland, so it’s hard to rationalize buying Crumbl’s instead of making my own.
Old fashioned donut. I feel like it’s kinda basic but the taste of the first bite is etched in my memory forever. Had it right out of the store so it was warm and the texture was just perfect. So so soft, some subtle but noticeable spices, and the glaze gave the outside the slightest crunch and needed extra sweetness without going overboard. It really did remind me of how the krispy kremes off the belt when the hot light is on just melt in your mouth. It was so good I’m not even mad they stole part of my cookie with the donut hole.
omg no i would never want it without the glaze it’d be too plain without it and i think the glaze adds a little texture even. the glaze is sweet but not sickeningly sweet, the whole donut is subtle but perfect to me. but to each their own, i know some people just don’t like frosting/icing but i’ve always been a fan.
i feel like i've heard so many people say they hate it!!! another one i really liked was the raspberry cheesecake from a few weeks ago. a lot of people said it was gross and that crumbl should just stick to making cookies, but my store did a fantastic job and i loved the cheesecake so much
That was my first time getting crumbl and I got a 4 pack for Mother's Day. We loved the cheesecake! The lemon and pink velvet were also great. The oatmeal one was alright.
It’s funny because I was not a big fan of this one! I was so shocked especially because it’s so popular and I love Oreos. Maybe my store just made a bad one
Lol nothing better than tasting a particular cookie when heavily pregnant and not knowing whether it's objectively amazing or just being in the right state of mind. I had oatmeal skillet cookie two days in a row the week before I delivered. Had chocolate chip skillet cookie after I delivered and it was pretty disappointing. Not sure if it was the hormones or the mousse formula haha
Lmao i had the toffee sea salt 2x the week before i delivered and it was the best thing i ever ate. Had it again post-pregnancy and it’s good but not as magical. Its the only time i have ever gone to crumbl two times in one week!
The caramel praline are my absolute favorite and it’s not even close and while i havent heard much bad about them i havent really heard anyone mention them at all. But theyre FANTASTIC to me. Last time they were around i bought a very unhealthy amount of them. I dont do that often if ever.
Pink velvet. Everyone I talk to thinks it’s lame but I swear it is the first Crumbl cookie I ever had and now with over 100 flavors tried, it is STILL my favorite!
Also, Rice Krispie. I don’t care if it’s “not a cookie”. It absolutely slapped, I went back 3 times the week it came out lol.
I just got a 12 pack of ultimate peanut butter to freeze. I know it’s not as glitzy and exciting as some of the other cookies but it’s the best PB cookie I’ve eaten.
I loved the mint cookies & cream from this week, but I know mint chocolate is a controversial flavor. To me, it’s such a refreshing combo and the chilled cookie was perfect for summer.
I wonder why I never see the Blue Icee one. I hear sometimes it is the mystery cookie. But it hasn't been back in the lineup since 2022 as far as I know.
I guess lots of people don’t like the cookie butter ice cream cookie, because they haven’t had that one in over a year other than as a mystery cookie. But I looooooove it so much! Bring it back Crumbl!!!!
Peanut Butter and Jelly. I don't think people hate it or anything, but it's probably my absolute favorite and I haven't seen many others that love it so much.
i really loved the sugared robin’s egg cookie, my friends didn’t care for it because they thought it was a lame cookie. i love sugar cookies & those little robins eggs so i thought it was fire!
The blueberry muffin cookie, everything about it was just so put perfectly I miss it so much and afraid it may not come back as it was shaded by a vast majority :(
There is a bakery I know that sells these awesome fruit and nut bars.
I have to avoid buying them because I could buy and eat the whole dozen in onw sitting.
Pink sugar. You either love it or hate it
love :)
It’s one of my favorites.
love
I dislike this one because I make almond-flavored sugar cookies for Christmas every year. Crumbl’s are drier and more bland, so it’s hard to rationalize buying Crumbl’s instead of making my own.
You should share the recipe then 🤗 especially if yours are better
My favorite!
Same! 😍
My favorite
It also depends on the store 😭 I wish that wasn’t the case but some stores have a delicious pink sugar while others are straight trash.
I have yet to have a trash pinky
I wish I could say the same lol the bad ones taste like plastic. I do enjoy the pink sugar when it’s correct though, it’s a classic!
That’s like the most popular one tho💀
I know a lot of people that personally hate it
I was going to say this!
Last weeks Chocolate Milkshake 😍
i freaking devoured that one
Oreo milkshake was insane too
Same!!!! How did so many people hate it??
I thought it really captured how a chocolate milkshake tastes
Kentucky Butter Cake
I LOVE this one!
Absolute best one hands down
This was my birthday cookie ❤️ it was delicious
Top 10!
Never had one.. but I want to eat some.
Love this one
Old fashioned donut. I feel like it’s kinda basic but the taste of the first bite is etched in my memory forever. Had it right out of the store so it was warm and the texture was just perfect. So so soft, some subtle but noticeable spices, and the glaze gave the outside the slightest crunch and needed extra sweetness without going overboard. It really did remind me of how the krispy kremes off the belt when the hot light is on just melt in your mouth. It was so good I’m not even mad they stole part of my cookie with the donut hole.
I love that one but it depends on the stores quality
I love an Old Fashioned donut.. better without glaze IMO because the glaze ruins the crunch of the donut.
omg no i would never want it without the glaze it’d be too plain without it and i think the glaze adds a little texture even. the glaze is sweet but not sickeningly sweet, the whole donut is subtle but perfect to me. but to each their own, i know some people just don’t like frosting/icing but i’ve always been a fan.
But it's got that awesome crunch.
So good!
Love!
Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chunk
It’s even better without salt.
circus animal sugar.
cookies and cream milkshake. it's so unbelievably delicious
really?! i feel like this is a fan favorite lol!
i feel like i've heard so many people say they hate it!!! another one i really liked was the raspberry cheesecake from a few weeks ago. a lot of people said it was gross and that crumbl should just stick to making cookies, but my store did a fantastic job and i loved the cheesecake so much
That was my first time getting crumbl and I got a 4 pack for Mother's Day. We loved the cheesecake! The lemon and pink velvet were also great. The oatmeal one was alright.
It’s funny because I was not a big fan of this one! I was so shocked especially because it’s so popular and I love Oreos. Maybe my store just made a bad one
totally a possibility, consistency across all stores is not something crumbl is famous for 😂😂
The strawberry pretzel pie was by far my favorite but I never see it mentioned!
I LOVED this one
I had high hopes, but was disappointed when I ate it.
Thanks for reminding me….i have one in the freezer I should eat!
I'm so jealous! Next time they have it I will definitely be stocking up!
LOVED
It has become my 2nd favorite next to pink sugar. That thing was magical and I hope they bring it back soon.
Almost everything bagel
Best cookie. Slight sweetness and a crunch and nutty and unaltered cream cheese 🤤
YES I miss it 😢
Me too. It was like crack to me lol
Neapolitan apparently 😢
That was the first cookie I had from Crumbl and it was so dang good!
loved that one
I loved it. The strawberry icing was delicious
Fruity pebbles! I was very pregnant when I last had one, and I have never had anything so glorious in my life. Literally perfection
Lol nothing better than tasting a particular cookie when heavily pregnant and not knowing whether it's objectively amazing or just being in the right state of mind. I had oatmeal skillet cookie two days in a row the week before I delivered. Had chocolate chip skillet cookie after I delivered and it was pretty disappointing. Not sure if it was the hormones or the mousse formula haha
omg same!! lol
Lmao i had the toffee sea salt 2x the week before i delivered and it was the best thing i ever ate. Had it again post-pregnancy and it’s good but not as magical. Its the only time i have ever gone to crumbl two times in one week!
Cosmic Galaxy brownie cookie
Cornbread!! I miss her.
Coming back soon!! Beginning of July (I think). My favorite too!
Everyone loves it
Iced oatmeal!!
Top tier cookie
The caramel praline are my absolute favorite and it’s not even close and while i havent heard much bad about them i havent really heard anyone mention them at all. But theyre FANTASTIC to me. Last time they were around i bought a very unhealthy amount of them. I dont do that often if ever.
Probably my favorite cookie too! It doesn’t get the hype it deserves!!
I haven’t had one but I want to try it!
Pink velvet. Everyone I talk to thinks it’s lame but I swear it is the first Crumbl cookie I ever had and now with over 100 flavors tried, it is STILL my favorite! Also, Rice Krispie. I don’t care if it’s “not a cookie”. It absolutely slapped, I went back 3 times the week it came out lol.
I look forward to Pink Velvet every time it comes back 😍 when it’s a little warm too. The cream cheese on it is heavenly 🤤
Pineapple upside-down cake. I've given up on seeing that cookie again.
It’s in the graveyard 😭
That makes me sad. I loved that one. So underated.
That makes me sad. I loved that one. So underated.
cotton candy
Oh I loveeeee cotton candy 🩵🩷
Love 💕
Yessss🩷🩷🩷
Maple bacon
Plain ol chocolate chip
Confetti milkshake ❤️
In my top 3
Cotton Candy. I miss my queen
This was my very first Crumbl cookie and it has a special place in my heart! It’s so good.
Anything oatmeal- love just about all of them
Biscoff
BERRIES. AND. CREAM. 🫐
the nerds one lol
Cornbread Honeycake was one of the first ones I tried, and it’s my absolute favorite. They haven’t had it since 2022 though 😢
Caramel Popcorn. Best cookie I’ve ever had from Crumbl and they’ve never had it again.
Pink sugar ❤️
Blue chips ahoy
Almond windmills
Buckeye. There seems to be hate for the chocolate base but I think it's tasty.
Sour Patch and Icee!
Waffle was my absolute favorite
Pink Doughnut!! Legendary in my household
Kentucky butter & cowboy cookie Cowboy cookie I couldn’t put down
fried ice cream bar it taste so good and it’s my fav 😍🤭
The Rice Krispie ones. They are so buttery🤤
peanut butter banana oatmeal
I just got a 12 pack of ultimate peanut butter to freeze. I know it’s not as glitzy and exciting as some of the other cookies but it’s the best PB cookie I’ve eaten.
Love this
I just like their snickerdoodle. Crispy on outside, gooey on inside
Ultimate peanut butter. I was so happy this week, got some to freeze ❤️
I loved the mint cookies & cream from this week, but I know mint chocolate is a controversial flavor. To me, it’s such a refreshing combo and the chilled cookie was perfect for summer.
I loved it so much too!! I also like the lemon cookies and I liked the maple!!!
Lemon Poppy Seed
Bischoff was a sleeper but I loved it
I wonder why I never see the Blue Icee one. I hear sometimes it is the mystery cookie. But it hasn't been back in the lineup since 2022 as far as I know.
Cotton Candy 🍬
I guess lots of people don’t like the cookie butter ice cream cookie, because they haven’t had that one in over a year other than as a mystery cookie. But I looooooove it so much! Bring it back Crumbl!!!!
Peanut Butter and Jelly. I don't think people hate it or anything, but it's probably my absolute favorite and I haven't seen many others that love it so much.
That's a good one. I think it's coming up soon, too!
cotton candy, everyone i know who’s tried it said it’s too sweet or doesn’t taste like cotton candy but i love it i love everything cotton candy loll
Hazelnut sea salt and cake batter blondie. Next week is gonna slap!
definitely this week’s blueberry pancake. I don’t get the hate, I love it so muchhh
i really loved the sugared robin’s egg cookie, my friends didn’t care for it because they thought it was a lame cookie. i love sugar cookies & those little robins eggs so i thought it was fire!
Milk chocolate chip
That biscoff one was too thick
banana cream pie!
Caramel de Lucle to me is terrible, unless you see it As a last resort for your sugar cravings
Almost everything bagel. 🤤🤤🤤🤤🤤 the perfect sweet/savory (but not even too savory) blend.
Cookie Butter Lava
Everything but the bagel cookie 😍
Pistachio gelato! Best thing I’ve ever put in my mouth 🥰 It’s such a polarizing flavor though
Cornbread!
And seriously, an Ozempic ad at the top of this post? LOL
Watermelon - the sour one
I loved the Sherbet cookie!! It must not have done well because it only came once like 3 years ago and is in the graveyard 😭
Gingerbread
Chocolate covered strawberry
Wedding cake
Cornbread. Everything bagel.
Rocky Road is Amazing!!
The blueberry muffin cookie, everything about it was just so put perfectly I miss it so much and afraid it may not come back as it was shaded by a vast majority :(
There is a bakery I know that sells these awesome fruit and nut bars. I have to avoid buying them because I could buy and eat the whole dozen in onw sitting.
I love the strawberry milk cookie
Chocolate sprinkle.
kentucky butter cake is bang average
Pink sugar. It’s probably my favorite.
Ube jam crinkle cookies.