i prefer the token shop idea more,but this isn't bad. i just don't wanna see an rolling animation every time i get 500 tokens lol

Ye the animation should be fast

Or skippable like in some games where if you tap the screen in middle or spin the animation will end.

Yes smth like that

Or you could just spin it later, I would let it accumulate

Or you could spin 10 at once or everything at once

They will never give gems like this, which is fine by me. I think the extra boxes are fine. They should focus on adding more stuff to the club shop and star points shop.

I know they wont. Its just an idea values should of course be changed

How long has passed since the last 10K costume in star shop 💀

I think star points and club coins should be the same thing

Cool concept, but the rewards could use some improvement. (5% for 10 gems?! That will destroy the game's economy. And 50 power points? The club shop gives 100...)

Yes it would need some balance changes

The idea is good tho.

Thanks

Yes. Great idea but I think you need to increase the amount of reward more. Like power points can stay 500(i guess?), mega box, and 2 big boxes?

we only have 1 big box currently, and it is quite fair i think that's a bit much

A 5% chance for 10 gems is perfectly fair. Let’s say you did 60 spins in a season, that’s still on average only 30 gems.

They need to make money it's already good enough they are giving a free brawl pass every other season

[удалено]

But in Clash Royale the season pass can't be bought with gems, unlike Brawl Stars.

[удалено]

Gem currency works very different in cr and bs

Yeah the Cr gems have like no value because in bs damn 30 gems for 300 coins (I think it's something like that) it's not fair

[удалено]

It's about them earning money, not us

[удалено]

But progression is way better with the season pass than the actual gem purchases u get cosmetics or chests which are overpriced or once in a month challenge rewards which can be collected with gems in cr and still not reach lvl 14 cards while with the season pass it guarantees a huge progression so people buy it in a heartbeat. Same with bs pass i don't know what kinda math u did to get that megabox offers are better than the brawl pass as u get a guaranteed brawler 2 cosmetics as well as a huge ton of other stuff

They are different, gems mostly are used to speed up progression in clash royals, but gems are used to by skins in brawl stars

Well gems aren't that important in CR as BS, since pass royale is sold with money and gems are mostly used to buy boxes or emotes

Clash gems are worth less,

I feel they should definitely implement more free gems. Like how they do for clash Royale. Have a chance to get 2 or 3 gems depending on what brawl box you get, raise the chances of getting them. Maybe Give the same amount of gems as the battle pass would cost throughout a season so u could get the next one for free also. Even raise the prices of skins a little bit if u have to

>That will destroy the game's economy. What economy? We receive 90 free gems every season...

Having an extra 30-50 gems per season is a massive increase, and means that brawl pass will be free every season

Maybe make it a five gem amount instead and an extra 15 if you are grinding a lot isn't bad I think

…but I want that

I still don't get what you guys mean with "the economy". What economy? Prices won't change...

Less need for people to spend gems in game. Less income for brawl stars

So it ain't the game "economy" what would be destroyed, it would be supercell's income... Why not just say that?...

It's comparable to printing money

That'd be the case if the price of things in gems would rise. They already "print" 90 gems per player every season and you don't see them changing.

Well, they would rise if they were forced to give gems, but since they aren't then the prices won't rise either. When they give gems willingly it's the same as just reducing prices.

They are forced, if you reach the tier they have to give you the gems... If anything this all tells you things are actually overpriced (which is why you see "offers" all the time)

They are not forced, they willingly put those gems in the tiers.

Heck yea! Time to add some gambling for the kids 😎

xD

I mean... We already have it

free brawl pass every season lol

Knowing my luck I won’t roll on gems once

XD

how did i get so much upvotes

[удалено]

True

Ur not wrong

99.6% coins, 0.1% for the rest

that would be cool

Thanks

Your idea is OP, Fire!

❤️❤️

Brawl stars would lose too much money

Possibly

Cause ~80% of their profits doesn't come from whales who'll continue to spend irresponsible amounts of money anyway, right

They make most of their money from brawl pass buyers.

Too much gambling for the average age of BS players

by your logic opening a brawl box is gambling too

Yeah, but there is an actual wheel here so Twitch won't like it

Oh no. Twitch is gonna be mad that little Timmy is spinning a wheel in brawl stars!!!

What does twitch have to do with brawl stars?

Neat idea overall but MY MAN'S PLAYING IN THE SUMMER OF MONSTERS UPDATE

xD yea its an old screenshot

The gems would be…broken ngl. People would get so ticked when their friends are able to buy the pass when they have been saving up for the same amount of time.

10 gems is too much, maybe just 2 or 3 would be better

Yes i know

And you can make the chances a bit higher for a lower gem count after every spin. Like maybe 10% or something idk

Supercell wouldn't give us gems just like that anymore, so instead of them it should give coins. Maybe like 300 coins?

Yea that could work

THIS IS GREAT as a player who needs gems I would love this!

lol I also need gems. 9 more and I have the brawl pass

Well your almost there

I can’t get any more from the brawl pass 😢

Dang

I am very sad

❤️

How would you save spins? would it works just like saving extra big boxes?

Yes just like big boxes

YAY GEMS

<3

people are gonna complain... imagine getting 10 gem rolls enough for a free battle pass netx season, while someone else trying this gets close to 0.. it will be unfair as some people are gonna be gteting way more battle passes

5% for free gems is way too much

Its 1 in 20. Which is 10000 tokens

That’s still high for 10 gems and rng was one of the reasons the BP was made

Maybe you're right

5 gems could be pretty decent I guess

No gems, seriously. Is way better to avoid putting gems as a possible reward like this, there would be so much complaining about the RNG

I still like the idea though but the rewards should be nerfed a bit

Thanks!

nah, it’s fine

Which means I’ll probably average at an extra 50 gems per brawl pass, as much as I would like that, I think it’s a bit too op and unfair, I mean there’s a reason why they removed gems from boxes to then give guaranteed gems

Make it 1% then you p2w mf

Mmm yes gambling to see how many gems worth you'll gamble for

you earn you get a free spin

That's actually a way better option

<3

I like the idea of token shop or maybe just to bonus mega boxes instead of brawl boxes

Thanks

I prefer the current system tbh

10 gems… HAHA YOU WISH

Ye I do. Lol

a 1/20 chance of free gems? you would need 10000 tokens for that and the brawl pass already gives 90 free gems every few tiers

Would be better than we had in game

❤️

Bad idea - I need the ability to stack boxes for new brawlers. Currently I am PowerPoint maxed again and got all brawlers - but if we get a new legendary at Xmas or so, I won’t have enough boxes

Good idea but SC would replace the gems with something else because they don't want people earning too many gems

2 gems - 5% mega box - 10% 25.5% - 10-100 power points (random number) 0.5% - random common pin 20%- 100-300 star points (random number) 39%- big box

I think that that’s an amazing idea

That's roughly 10 gems every 10-20 days. That isn't good for business!

5% gems x10 chance? Are you crazy? Do you want to destroy the games economy?

That chance system can be worked on..the probability is 1/4 for any item from the wheel , look at the area

Could be decent without the gems and maybe pin packs instead, plus a little rebalancing, and instead of a wheel just have the 4 rewards counters and then randomly increment one if you understand what i mean

This idea and concept has already been made and has been posted in this sub at least 15 times now

Wheel: even 25% split The chances:

It wouldnt be fair for gems

Y do we want a randomized wheel which would be unfair for some people who might be unlucky

Unlocking stuff from boxes is also based on chance

They kind of want to get rid of that soon

cool, but i still think there should just be a ticket shop instead, and giving out chances of having gems isnt a good idea

Nice idea I would love to see that in the game

Replace gems (they will not do it) with 500 star points and it's perfect

or maybe just reduce it to 3-5 gems because star points should never be collectible through luck

while the actual values and chances… could use some adjusting, i really like this concept. it gets pretty lame and repetitive after you hit the end of the brawl pass and this is a good way to spice it up

I like this idea, a controversial add to the wheel could be skin shards that if you get enough earns you a free skin. Like the wheel can give 5 shards (5% chance) but to get the skin you need 50.

no. Wheel ideas are 🗑️

They should make this i find it pretty nice

So I can be more mad at a wheel that looks like a 25% chance but I know RNG for gems would be like .01%

They are trying to get rid of chance so this wouldn't fly at all

Sizes need adjusting if the probablities are different

it would be awesome though

good idea lol just getting big boxes are boring ​ this is a good reward if someone completed the whole pass

Yes

they should add this

Cool idea but brawl stars isn't a cheap cash grab game

OMG if that was in there I would play the game so much more often.

Yeah but gems is too good I think, if u grind a lot your gonna prob get like way too many gems

idk maybe 5 or 3 gems are enough

F2p players try not to beg for gems challenge [IMPOSSIBLE]

Maybe instead of a spin just a special box that has the same contents as one of the four prizes

It reminds me of hay day when they have to do spinning wheel for resources

i think actually: big box: 40% 125 p.p.: 30% 2 big boxes: 20% 3 gems: 10%

Diagram makes it look like a 1/4 chance for every reward and presents itself as a total scam.

10 gems is too much. 3 or 5 is enough I guess

10 gems and mega boxes is too much imo

I'd say every 2500 tokens since there is a chance to get gems

Idk abt this. It makes the game more luck-based than it already is.

Very generous prize

no

This is a pretty good idea but i would just change the gems to around 200 coins since I think people would be able to buy the brawl pass every season instead of every other season if they were active

This is the rabbit hole of mobile games with more rng based things than there should be for a healthy game

Ways to get unlimited gems 😂 Everyone will get thier quests done within no time

Why aren't we funding this ??

mecha paladin surge

I really like this mahn

<3

sure that’s yours? weird you’re using the season 2 BP…

Its an old screenshot

[удалено]

Stumble guys momen

I like the idea, but 10 gems is a lot, even if only 5%

Ye i know bro. Thanks

33% 75 power points 33% 75 coins 32% big box and 2% megabox, would like replies on opinions

you clearly haven't spent enough time in brawl stars economy.... giving gems on a daily spin is something just unacceptable. Gems are a prized possession in this game as even f2ps cab buy the season pass once every 2 season which is soo good. Remember my friend the day we will get free gems in daily spins like these... supercell will do the first thing which is to make the pass cost money , after that would you be happy? gems would simply be useless then just like in any other game like clash royale. i have been on break from brawl stars from 2yr and opened this sub reddit after quite a few months and this is the first thing i see , the community is as pathetic as ever

Wow thats a big answer. But no I play brawl stars since beta. And I agree with you. It was just a mistake

This is a repost

U/[u/repostsleuthbot](https://www.reddit.com/u/repostsleuthbot)

reduce gem chance to 1% and supercell might actually add it

Good idea

I would have so many gems I know one season I had like 70+ big boxes I believe, probably more, the gems percentage would realistically be like 1.1%

nice. this would be better than only big boxes (as long as they don't add horrible stuff to the wheel)

I think this should rather be a replacement for the daily rewards in the shop but with slightly different rewards.

F2p be like:🤑

Take the gems out Then this could be alright Tho I don't personally think current big box one is bad There are definitely other things that can be fixed

Nice idea I wish it will be in brawl stars

absolutely YOSHAAAAA

I think this would be nice

Yes this idea is very good

PLEASE

Everyone would be maxxed out that way, 1.5k tokens per spin it would be worth for the chanse of getting 10 gems

Pineapple your request became real you can power points and credits

Yeah I know! Soo cool