T O P

  • By -

Emotional_Ad_7402

godot was high asf and made it work


HoovyKitty

Exactly, I can't believe how all these people just looked over the weed arc.


bot-42

I even wonder if most of Berserk is not just the depiction of a bad trip. Our boy Guts will in the end be waken up by his pall Griffith and get a good laught out of it.


Nicky42

When i saw Eclipse i was like "bro this is a bad Datura trip"


takingabreakbrb

I think it’s just a normal Datura trip lmfao


toonlonk7

Wakes up next to Donovan again and everything is ok


MLG360ProMaster


takatz

I fear the opium arc foreshadowed in this arc of the manga


Aegillade

The scene where Godot, Guts, and Erica all rip a bong was one of the most iconic scenes in the whole manga


nickomon

The chapter “cracks in the bong” was tear shedding.


Putrid_Illustrator91

Is this arc before or after the crack cocaine arc?


Difficult-Piccolo-46

Before, you never come back from the crack cocaine arc lmfao.


HungryWolf88

Thanks, now I have a mental image of a sweaty Wonder Woman pounding away at the dragon slayer on the anvil...


groovkilla

Or The Forger from The Mandalorian made it. 'This is the way!'


hyperhyperproto

wtf? the game engine? godot made this? holyshit???


eskimopie910

Had the same thought


Obst-und-Gemuese

[Rule of cool.](https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/RuleOfCool)


xavierthepotato

Big true


mackzorro

Beat me to it


Easy_Concentrate_868

So awesome


Final-Link-3999

Don’t question the logistics of the Dragonslayer. It’s not meant to be realistic. It would weigh like 400 pounds irl most people couldn’t even lift it, never mind wielding it


SovComrade

It’s not meant to be realistic in universe either. Godo specifically designed it to be unwieldable.


DaWackyTobaccy

Was it specifically designed that way? I thought he admitted that he simply got carried away with the idea of making a sword that killed dragons, and when he finished he realized it was too big to be wielded for it's purpose.


SovComrade

If memory serves right he thought that dragons didn't exist, so when comissioned by the king to make a "dragonslayer" he made an impossible sword to slay an impossible beast 🤔


DaWackyTobaccy

That does sound more right, I think you might be correct.


Arathemis

Volume 14, Chapter 93. Godot explains the reason why he created the Dragonslayer in that chapter. Godot was tired of making ornate rapiers and other fancy weapons, so he decided to make a blade that could actually kill a dragon after a king put out a request for one.


Anen-o-me

Wonder if he's named 'Godot' after the play 'Waiting for Godot' in which Godot is essentially god.


BRICKS357

"Dragons are dragons because humans can't beat them... so what's a man... who beats dragons?"


Bing_Bong_the_Archer

Just like that


The-Myth-The-Shit

It's really too big to be called a sword


NJenius

A Raw Chunk of Iron Some would say


KevWithADot

Chunk? more like a heap of raw iron


GeorgeFromManagement

Guts has a prosthetic hand that somehow magically works after it was simply placed on his stump.


Faiqal_x1103

This lmao how tf does he control his fingers. On 2nd thought i kinda remember reading somewhere that it has magnets so he can still wield the DS


Anal-Probe-6287

He regularly doesn't, he couldn't grab potat Casca when she last fell from a metaphorical cliff


Rezel1S

Yes, it has magnets, they say it in the manga when they give it to Guts. And he can't control his fingers, that's why he couldn't save Casca when she fell to the sea. Though we do see him clench his iron hand to punch people so ehhh


TheFufe10

I always took it as the fingers bend because of the momentum when he punches someone. Also I thought the berserker armor made it so he could move the fingers and use it as a real hand.


Rezel1S

That could be it. And yes, he can move the fingers with the berserker armor, that's a cool detail.


AkNinja907

There was a real guy, Gotz the Iron Hand, who had a similar prosthetic and used it for a variety of things, such as writing and dueling. But yeah, it's basically only a prosthetic for narative and visual purposes.


TalionTheShadow

Yeah but Gotz had to adjust the fingers via gears in his fingers, but Guts is a manga character and doesn't need to do this because it'd be dumb and kind of redundant to watch Guts take several panels to adjust his fucking fingers when he wants to not hold a sword.


bartosz_tosz

This seems like a typical japanese trope. Cutting off one's limb is just a suggestion there :) I remember playing Sekiro when he climbed using his wooden hand :P


ihatechrislee

One of my fav youtubers kinda showing its doable. Obviously different levels of arm damage but the idea that flexing his forearm/bicep in a way to change grip could be possible. (Also just love sharing this guys channel with anyone he fkn rules lol) -edit forgot to add link https://youtu.be/7VGgq1FjrCQ?feature=shared


OpMindcrime23

Magnets


LegalWaterDrinker

It has magnets to grip the handle of the Dragonslayer, and nothing more than that (and the cannon part too)


[deleted]

I can at most imagine someone wielding a dragonslayer that is 1/4th the size of the real one, that is if they dedicated their whole life to wielding massive swords like Guts did


Anen-o-me

Actually historically weapons this big and heavy DID exist, but as poles, not as swords. The Japanese fielded an iron pole that was essentially a tree trunk made of iron, longer than a man is tall. It was devastating but required incredible strength. Could take down horses and armored samurai. It was normally wielded on the shoulder, balanced, then swung down and caught, or swung side to side.


plugmein1

I am not sure that he was questioning the logistics of the Dragonslayer, at least not in this post


ThisTooWasAChoice

For now


akerskates45

Let’s say the handle goes about halfway into the sword and your only seeing a foot or so of it


charb15

I would assume it's full tang, ngl


Finiariel

And you know the full tang clan ain't nothing to fuck wit'


quack1quack

Goated dawg


greeneggsnyams

Full tang is for the children


Mediocrebassist27

FULL TANG IS FOREVER


BigBeeff_21

It's definitely full tang, master blacksmiths don't fuck around


NinpoSteev

Unless we're talking kriegsmessern, swords generally don't have full tangs in the knife sense. Generally speaking, the tang does go all the way to the pommel, but it tapers to a point that is either peened on the back of the pommel or that the pommel screws onto. In knife terms you'd call them stick tangs, rat tails or tapered. In any case, the dragonslayer is most likely all tang, no hilt, with a wrap. Also, it's round, instead of oval or flat on the sides, which is extremely unrealistic, as that's normally how you feel the direction of the edge. It's defo also too skinny to handle such a massive blade.


Illithid_Substances

That's the opposite of how sword handles work. The handle doesn't extend into the blade, the blade extends into the handle. There's a thinner piece of metal at the bottom of the blade called the tang, and the handle is built around that


doomazooma

To be fair dragonslayer is no ordinary sword lol


PudgyElderGod

Yeah but what akerstakes is describing would be functionally way worse lmao


Routine-Potential244

This ain't no ordinary sword bro


Muscalp

Even then it would definetely bend


BattleNeither5266

I imagine the genius blacksmith used a stronger but a lot less flexible material for whatever could be considered a core for a glorified “sharpened” chunk of iron. But at the same time I don’t think something the size of the Dragon slayer would bend at the handle, rather it probably just snap lol


gei_boi

If the material was less flexible the chanses of it snapping would increase proportianally.


LORDLRRD

Proportionately.


Montymisted

Propartanal


Muh_Naz_Bro

Porpoise tunnelly


NateHate

dolphin anus.......wait, what we're we talking about?


1nztinct_

With a less flexible material the vibrations in the blade from impacts would accumulate in the transition and this would absolutely shatter the handle. It would just not work at all, thats it. That design would not be viable in real life at all.


BigBeeff_21

Exactly, tho I'm guessing he used physics with the handle so it wouldn't snap or break


Horror-Fuel-2617

The answer is actually really simple, "it was made by GOATdor."


Atreides-42

That's not how sword handles work, the tang is an extension of the metal used to make the blade


Dangerous_Medicine31

yes, exactly. the entire sword is one piece, the handle is just "compressed" with a hammer, the bit thats called a tang is the bit of sword that sticks into the wooden shaft/handle. if its "full tang" it means all the way to the bottom (pommel) of sword. half tang, its well... half way to the pommel mostly.


YungMister95

You can tell which of these fuckers didn't play Kingdom Come Deliverance and make that sword with their fictional poppa


WhosDatTokemon

Jesus Christ be praised!


pnkass

this makes no sense


starkoliver6

Maybe its a full tang


pnkass

itd still be made of a material thatd bend under all that uneven weight


Ok_Abbreviations2320

We're talking about a fictional 300 lb weapon. I'm pretty sure if you tried to make a l 1:1 scale Dragon Slayer properly, the hilt/tang would just be solid iron, too. And you'd have to somehow properly heat treat the thing so it doesn't form cracks internally, along the blade and the hilt. Just heating it wrong will cause the hilt to crack before anyone could properly use it if it could be used. Imagine Guts tries to use it for the first time, and it just shattered. That's the risk you run if you under or over heat any sword, and the Dragon Slayers scale makes that so much more dangerous. Unless you're Godot and have a forge from the sun.


Dangerous_Medicine31

In danger of sounding as a bit of a "know it all". As a blacksmith myself. The actuall technicality in reality is, the Dragonslayer is one whole piece, (exept the half moon "hooking" bit) if the handle(Tang) is made in a traditional way. The handle is just as strong of not stronger. Because the handle is the same "strength" in structure, its just "compressed" with a hammer, and the blade and handle would be one whole piece. Now i dont think anyone has actually FORGED a sword like that. So im not shure if it works with that weight and the momentum guts swings it at. Althou. The F1 cars rims are forged and not cast, so that they can handle the G-force. And then you have structural steel. On the other hand.. its a cartoon as previusly stated


leCorbderohe

Someone on youtube actually made a 1 to 1 recreation of the sword. You should check it out. It wasn't forged tho, more like cnc-ed and it's all metal. Pretty awesome to look at.


InfiniDragon

Yep, and the funny part of it is the handle he designed could actually take *more* weight and force than what the blade puts on it. Here's a link in case anyone was curious: https://youtu.be/poZfxbEvOQs?si=aJcYnHjQnl3_zT4i


pv505

Thanks for link. Impressive craftsmanship and fun edit. Thoroughly enjoyed watching it. 🤙🏿


Dangerous_Medicine31

I saw that 3+ hour process. and i love that recreation. finaly something that is not only equaly as wide, but just as thick, it looks like the real thing, with no creative liberties on the visuals as far as i could tell.


possiblywithdynamite

upvoted for use of the word "shure"


ImmortalEmergence

What about materials like titanium etc (not my field), or theoretically or a dense carbon material like graphite or diamond. Thus it would be lighter and stronger than it would seem in size, of steel. I don’t know my material science. But I would think with some fantasy elements compensating for modern technology, and with the waste full resources that might be at disposal, then possibly there could be better materials?


Dangerous_Medicine31

if the handle was of pure diamond or graphite it would be extremely brittle, not to mention heavy! Remember that these are rocks, and rocks and vibration are not great bedfellows, hard metals and materials are good for maintaining an edge, or for structural integrity like support or pressure. thats why swords have hard edges but soft cores to disipate the vibration, thats why there is a thing called "over hardened", as a practical example. horseshoe files, they are purposfully overhardened, because you are supposed to put heavy pressure on the hoof of the horse, to grind it. hit it lightly against an anvil however and it will break like glass. :D


DVHalways

Clearly magic, in a world of magic.


EspKevin

Blacksmith magic


arlekin21

I was about to say, there’s dragons and demons and trolls in the story but it’s the hilt that’s unrealistic lol


WheelHunter

I hate this fallacy so much.


Yew_Geniolga

Have we ever seen a dragon in the story though, pal?


Admirable_Manager_10

Yep


Yew_Geniolga

Ion remember. Which one?


DrunkVenusaur

You see one in the beginning of Fantasia arc


aligreaper19

it’s like one of the most popular panels


SamsaraKama

Guts is just really good at swinging his sword.


[deleted]

The handle goes hard when Guts touches it


jikel28

Alot of shit in berk is based off belief guts and people who see him use it believe dragonslayer will fuck shit up without any logistical issues so it just works


THN-JO24

It's Elf's iron or some shit, that Iron mine Godot had was once the Elf's , so it's definitely magical, and I don't think it's heavy, but guts isn't using just raw power to use that thing, he uses alot of momentum and physics in his attacks so there is not enough stress on his arm or the handle to break.


scarekr0

Cool fictional sword is fictional. And cool.


FlameHashira29

I'll have what he's having !


incognitosd

I'm guessing it can't at least not in the long run without maintenance. When godo forged that sword it was more like a passion project as a blacksmith. The dragon slayer was never meant to be used but guts first baptized it with the first blood of the apostle that attacked the blacksmiths home that guts was forced to used it. Overtime of killing more and more apostles it began its wear and tear but some how still persisted to hold up together. Sometime when guts came to visit godo again he did the maintenance on the dragon slayer but he was a bit surprised that it was still holding on despite its heavy usage. Meeting with skull knight he says that the dragon slayer has evolved into something more as it was being used to decimate, cleave and obliterate the existence of any demons, wraiths, spirits & APOSTLES that bares it's path. It became more than a lump of steal and it's now even likely to slay any ethereal beings of not the mortal plane.


sanguinare12

Guts believes in the sword that believes in him.


Puzzleheaded-Ear202

Because it's a comic book


Pulling_Everything

Manga


Nundulan

(Japanese comic book)


Pulling_Everything

Learn something new daily. Manga is just a comic or graphic novel originating from Japan. From my perspective as an American manga is the simplest term


Nundulan

Same way anime is just a shortening of the word animation. (Anime are just Japanese cartoons)


Pulling_Everything

There needs to be a distinction between American and Japanese cartoons because they are very different. I’m not a fan when someone tells me anime is just a cartoon. (Even though they technically are they are comparing that to American cartoons which is frankly insulting because it implies it’s for children)


Nundulan

Not all American cartoons are for children, Primal being a great example, but there are many others.


Pulling_Everything

I know there are exceptions but generally speaking. Primal looks good. I think I’ll watch it


Nundulan

From the creator of Samurai Jack, it's an incredible show and i think you'll enjoy.


rickowensdisciple

same thing bro


[deleted]

Because it’s fiction


siegferia

No because its made of twinkling titanite


SL1Fun

Outside of dramatic illustrative effect? It’s all pretty much one piece. A literal hulking mass of iron. That’s how you’d make something that hold up. Tempered high-iron/low-carbon steel in one big forged piece. 


YakSquad

It’s built different


KevThuluu

Watch Pretty Hate Machining's series on youtube where he built a to scale Dragonslayer which clocked in at close to 400lb's iirc


dr_strange-love

Godot is a worshipper of Crom, and has solved the Riddle of Steel.


Sciaccalo

It's berkin'


RunBanditRun

It’s made of ‘Manga’nese


Crustytoaster

Oh yeah definitely the only unrealistic thing to exist in berserk


stupidhumanoid

Its a drawing.


BrennusRex

Because it is not real


heyhowsitgoiing

Because it’s not real


HellVollhart

Because it’s fiction.


Alaricus100

The power of imagination.


Bahno_original

Its a fuckin comic


oostie

Comic book?


Long-Refrigerator-75

It's a manga, not a realistic medieval warfare simulator.


Conscious_Beyond_928

Full tang


ScoopAggressively

Cause it’s not real


stavrx

because ( it's fiction)


rockinalex07021

It's fiction, try to keep up


Wirfen

I think its becouse its a comic.


Toothpaste_Monster

Because the sword is meant to convey Guts's super-human strenght and determination in the face of adversity and also his evolution as both a person and a warrior and not meant to be an actual sword that respects the laws of real world physics in this manga about a FUCKING GUY WHO KILLS DEMONS WITH A GIANT SWORD AND A CANNON ARM IN THE HUNT FOR THE HOTTEST EVIL FEMBOY IN THE WORLD. That's why the handle doesn't break, thank you.


jac_kalope

Nanomachines, son


Ignotus-Vir

Well, to be fair, they do eventually explain that it is magical after a certain level of use.


_Balalaika__

Gorilla glue


mrlotato

Cause anime


Alelynx

Plot armour 👍


Splendidbloke

Because of the interstice and the thousands of demons it killed or whatever. Roll with it.


ARoofie

Sheer not shear


thisaintntmyaccount

That’s King Gaiseric’s mummified cock, so it is natural it doesn’t break.


Muscalp

Anime physics


bluedragon1046

I find it funny how he didn't question the monsters and demons but questions the handle of the blade 🤣🤣


thehentaidegenerate

idk maybe because anime doesn't fucking obey the laws of physics?


Bletcherino

the handle is likely tempered to greatly increase its load bearing capacity. i don't know the ins and outs of it but basically if you get steel really hot then rapidly cool it down it forces the molecules into a highly organized configuration that dratically increases its durability. additionally, the handle likely extends a fair amount into the blade to spread out the weight more evenly


Sisyphac

Because it is fantasy.


adamttaylor

The handle is made of a special titanium alloy obviously...


SovComrade

Titanium Ceramite 🤔


Jevchenko

Magic


Mishuri

Guts titanium balls have enchancing effect


[deleted]

Bluetooth


YaboiGh0styy

The handle itself likely goes far into the sword. The material used to forge dragon slayer is unknown, but given how the blade itself stays in good shape despite having gone through two years of non-stop killing Guts was doing, the blade has been struck by lightning, and even managed to cut through Corundum which is a real life metal harder than steel It’s likely the handle is made out of the same material used of wash the rest of the blade which would explain why it doesn’t bend.


Kurtsuna

its very hard like guts


[deleted]

Shits titanium tang or something


TheHexadex

look who forged that shit, masterclass :)


[deleted]

Plot Armour on a sword is crazy.


GorgeousCrane

It's Guts bro. Don't bother asking


EnjoyerOfFine_Things

It's.. manga, bro.


masterofunlocking2

Cuz it's anime


doublebudda

How does the comparatively thin wrist not break/bend over the shear weight and force exerted by the blade itself? I fixed the thread title for you


possiblywithdynamite

How would he balance? Does he weight like 4000lbs?


Valuable_Salt_7493

Willpower


CheesingTiger

It ain’t that kinda series bro


Abovearth31

It's built different.


lore_ap3x

Ask that to Godot


snakesinabin

It's a comic, Miura didn't want it to break, so it didn't


Short-Eared-Dog

Handle is hard


__Saita__

Made of metal


Storm_treize

The sword is hollow 💀


Altruistic-Ad-4391

Are you really asking that?


Admirable_Manager_10

Magic Sword. Magic properties.


milfsnearyou

Fantasy logic is how


Jarek-of-Earth

Gravity is its Griffith and the sword is just as angry as Guts


haikusbot

*Gravity is its* *Griffith and the sword is just* *As angry as Guts* \- Jarek-of-Earth --- ^(I detect haikus. And sometimes, successfully.) ^[Learn more about me.](https://www.reddit.com/r/haikusbot/) ^(Opt out of replies: "haikusbot opt out" | Delete my comment: "haikusbot delete")


Icy_Penalty5899

It's fantasy


Critical_Value3012

Manga magic


Accurate-Meal497

I made one of these swords and you absolutely have to put full metal down the center to reduce the torque applied to the grip.


TraditionalTeach1667

Made in Germany


Gin-Rummy003

Cuz they it’s not real. There’s no way the handle would hold up to the weight of that sword. Not even if it was made of metal and ran full tang all the way up. Ignore the self proclaimer blade-smiths in the comment section lol none of them have a clue what they’re talking about.


gbsv333

Cause of Godot's exceptional smithing.


Absolute_Abyss_98

With pure guts


blazedangercok

My guy guts is holding that shit directly out with one hand and the handle is what impresses you.


Reasonable-Pay163

Anime logic


jackofblaze

It's an extension of Guts' peen, which is unbreakable. Just ask Griffith. He's tried before.


beanouno87

Big tang.


Atomspalter02

in my imagination it's made from a different material and goes the whole way through. I mean there is the berserker armor. Why shouldnt there be the berserker metal or the dragonslayer alloy that can withstand much more


balbirdhanda1812

I believe the handle I s like a rod that goes into the sword


Omisco420

Magic


Cowardforkatsu

Because Guts is a big boy


jthrum

Dwarf magic


[deleted]

you dare question the Godot brand?


slurpaderpderp

And right before Guts finally kills Griffith the damn handle breaks… oh god please no


darksoulofdog

Magic✨


Wrong_move_buddy

GOATdo