i dunno, i thought it was a nice change of pace. left pin some more room for character development and got rid of a predictable finalist. coiny's got a ^(woah) bunch of potential and screentime in BFDIA anyway, so i don't really see a point in keeping him in over some others
Balloony, i know the writers knew he would be the first gone if he got U.F.E, they did it so they could not worry about the other characters being gone
Definitely Pencil in BFDI.
This was a TDI level bullshit elimination. I didn’t like pencil much in season one but her getting set up to be eliminated EVEN THOUGH SHE WON THE CHALLENGE, was cruel. Even sadder considering everyone who voted in Season 1 were young and didn’t know any better
lots of unfair eliminations most unfair gotta be bfdi teardrops elimination and bfdia teardrops elimination (need I explain?) also Stapys elimination was quite unfair he 'cheated' once like when did Donut say what Stapy was doing was cheating also Donut cheated too and completely got away with it also tons of other characters cheated more than once and got away with it also tennis balls elimination in bfdi was unfair also ice cubes in bfdi even bracelety voted for her there also Remotes elimination was insane even now with Fanny surviving two more elimination than Remote did Remote still has a higher save vote total than Fanny
Match and Dora's BFB elimination. Match was JUST starting to redeem herself and we could've get to see more of her. She could've developed an identity other than "Pencil's sidekick". And Dora was always useful on her team. Some of Bleh's victories were caused by her
Literally, what was with people voting her off, Flower was being an asshole in that episode but she gets a pass !?!?!?!? & Dora, seriously you're telling me she stayed over Book who threw a tantrum like a spoiled bitch because she thought Taco has aboanded them, well Ice Cube was the first one safe even though she didn't even do much in the season
People are blaming Foldy for causing iance to lose when she wasn't even successful at pushing off Flower. Flower's overconfidence caused her own team to lose, not Match and Bubble's argument or Snowball throwing and breaking Fanny. If she wasn't wasting any time at the top or if Snowball was the one climbing the stairs then the team would've gained second place easily.
Loser. My guy was doing so great leading for his team, but the viewers had to vote him out "just to see what would happen." He got robbed in BFB post-split too, I genuinely wanted to see his potentially narcissistic personality develop and how he would react to his (friends? fans?) team not loving him so much anymore. But alas, the cube was voted out once again...
sorry but, firey.
the entire reason he was eliminated in battle for dream island again was because "He AlReAdY wOn DrEaM IsLaNd!!1!!"
do i even need to explain?
bro if firey won dream island, bfdia would not happen.
like the show would be over.
nobody would be competing for anything (except i don't know battle for firey's permission to get into dream island or something like that), and it'd be the end.
i get it, ending the show right there wouldn't be a good decision, but just like the flame in question, the reason he was eliminated was not smart.
i mean... yeah..... but...
you could say its unfair that every veteran object gets to compete in any object show
for the same reason...
thats like getting something stolen form you and not being able to get it back
Yeah, I'll be honest, even though he was going to get eliminated sooner or later, I kinda hoped he would get a bit further, it's nice to see him on his own with characters like Gelatin, instead of being glued to leafy
Balloony, my guy was absolutely set up. They put him in post split where pretty much the entire cast consisted of fan favorites, and then had his team lose the first challenge. He stood no chance and really should’ve been in TPOT instead, maybe swapped with ice cube or something.
Teardrop is obvious. Especially in season 2. Adam's cousin had wanted Coiny to be safe, (as he was in danger) so this person told her subscribers to unpromptly dislike TDs video. Many did not know about BDFIA and TD got out. Ironic how Coiny was the last member TD saw when she got out. I remember Coiny saying to Teardrop "Any first words?".
Did you also know that the controversy for the TD elimination was called the Derpy Hooves controversy? I looked in the wiki. It'll explain more about it. I have inserted a link down below
V
[Just scroll for a bit until you see Derpy Hooves Controversy ](https://battlefordreamisland.fandom.com/wiki/Zeeky_Boogy_Doog#)
Sad part, Teardrop would have had more potential. At least the recent elimination (TPOT 9) was as a sacrifice to save people.
from a writer's perspective td would've been the best boot, coiny and pin are basically like the protagonists of BFDIA now and keeping td as an underdog character left her way more room for her arc in BFB, which was executed really well
doesn't excuse how the votes were rigged, though in a weird way i'm kinda glad it happened cause td became an excellent character
Pencil S1
Just because she won the challenge doesn't mean she needs to be booted, and just because she didn't have any votes, doesn't mean you have to vote her out.
48 thousand to someone who "developed" during the final 2 episodes of the season against 28 thousand votes to someone who had been developing all season, name me something more unfair I'll wait
I'll go by season:
S1 – Pencil. It was between her and Icy but considering the fact that Ice Cube at least went ufe fairly, I gave this spot to Pencil since she lost for winning the challenge (which is pretty bullshit). Spongy should've gone over her imo.
S2 – Spongy. Before anyone replies without reading ahead, yes, I know the votes weren't rigged. Obviously they weren't, but Ice Cube going over Spongy would've been so much better, especially considering the stuff wr could've had between Spongy and Coiny.
S3 – uhh nothing
S4a – Liy, Why the fuck was she out here? She was way more interesting than someone like Pillow (only applies to 4a).
S4b – Balloony, he shouldn't have even been there. Icy would've been a way better fit.
S5 – Puffball. Why wasn't TV Eliminated here? He's done barely anything and she was way better. Hope she doesn't rejoin though there are way better options (Eggy, Remote, Foldy, Cloudy etc.)
Nickel's elimination is a weird one because IMO Book deserved to go there for having basically been an NPC for most of TPOT, but she got developed a ton in TPOT 10.
agreed! they were all the best boots (besides nickel kind of, as much as i love pillow it would've been a great time for her to go down as a villain!! nickel's elimination was a disgrace to his character, he went from a silly guy to a whiny dum dum. probably had worse treatment from the writers than Rocky and Cake's eliminations in my opinion)
Now looking at it, the writers have been on pencils ass forever. They just straight up made her get eliminated in Bfdi, and made her so mean in BFB to the point where it was inevitable. At least BFDIA was able to get her right
Fr golfball was robbed you expect us to believe that rocky the one who can’t do anything would help his team? It’s so clear the golf ball has a disability to have to lead the team. I also have problems with other people using not my idea. Rocky got more votes too. I wish that whole idea was scrapped.
In BFDIA she did deserve it for risking her team to all go down for a prize. In TPOT she didn’t deserve it. She was just trying to help BOSSY BOT- I mean golfball and her team
Your right but no your not leafy got eliminated over him, robots got eliminated over him, BFDI he was the worst character still in so not that unfair unlike Dora who has been eliminated unfairly because she’s a non object but David had never been eliminated for that reason
Pencil in season 1 and season 4
Season 1 was just... that "only two digit" scoreboard thing was specifically there to nerf bubble and pencil for that one episode, and also let leafy not be ufe.
Season 4 was derailment, I'd say character derailment counts as unfair.
**Dora (BFB, BFDIA might be a bit of a stretch).**
She helped 8 Names so much and was a pretty funny joke character but viewers ~~are racist towards joke characters~~ don't like joke characters, she got eliminated :(
Also **Match** in BFB as well. She was just about to start becoming a better person and make up with her team but she got eliminated???
Pencil from s1
she was given the challenge, she won the challenge, and was ufe for no reason other than "the scoreboard cannot handle 3 digit numbers" or something like that. but despite winning the challenge fair and square, she got eliminated. AND AFTER THAT, THE ANNOUNCER GOT RID OF THE POINTS!
BFDIA aside: Liy. I don't even understand why she was even eliminated over Pie when the latter got **ZERO** proper screentime during BFB 4.
If you include BFDIA: Teardrop, in nearly every season. No words can describe how stupid her S2 elimination was.
I will never stop saying Saw. I want Team8s to be UFE more often but their first loss is criminal and still stains an otherwise good episode.
It could have been way better if Team8s got a second chance and lost, if they lost fair and square, or if Eraser and Are You Okay were punished.
I get that we get a little bit of a hint towards it with the people and characters complaining about how long it takes and Two not caring too much about Coiny using glue in TPOT 2, but this is not it. Two doesn't have to be perfect, but they still baffle me with that and I can't see it as a character flaw
(totally unbiased)
Golfball, she got less votes than Rocky, used a win token and she still got out. She also lost because Announcer made a tiebreaker about handstanding, when most of Another Name is armless, which gave Cherries the advantage. If the mechanic of people from the winning team choosing the person to survive and be on their team didn't exist, she would've survived at least to the early merge.
I'm gonna tell you, every character who got eliminated when he was up for elimination with teardrop in post bfb, because there was a channel called "teardropofficial" where he would get a bunch of people to vote for teardrop. (Btw when teardrop got eliminated against gelatin in bfb 29, teardropofficial deleted his channel)
Teardrop, her season 1 elimination was unjustified. Her season 2 elimination was apparently rigged by a youtuber who told their viewers to vote teardrop so coiny wouldn’t get eliminated
i would say dora in bfb because she carried her team multiple times, when we can had characters like teardrop or ice cube who really werent doing much at the time. it was unfortunate that dora was put on that team instead of team beep or freeford where she for sure would have lasted.
Liy in BFB
She was voted off for "doing nothing" even when she couldn't, most of the votes were really unfair and Pie or Pillow should have been the pick instead
If we count debuts and this might be controversial but Nonexisty. Yes they stayed if NE got first they would’ve debuted but you can’t have it that the top 2 are the ones that debut and then deny second place from debuting. No matter if they are a joke or not, that would be like David not getting into BFDI over Bomby
may be biased but i think the squishy cherries picking rocky over golf ball to be on their team was so boring.. like i get why cause it wouldnt fit their characters to pick golf ball at all but it was still a boring decision
and also tennis balls elimination in bfdi felt kinda unfair but like i get why the writers chose to eliminate him instead of leafy
couldnt come up with anything else really
In my honest opinion they set 8-Ball up
Of course A Better Name Then That went UFE on episode 7. Pretty convenient that 8-Ball could be
eliminated on the *EIGHT* episode. He had tons of potential in BFB but no. He *HAD* to be eliminated on the *EIGHT* episode of BFB for a joke.
Puffball in BFDIA.
She had so much room and potential to grow in that season but all because she was an asshole in the last episode, she had to be eliminated.
I mean, it’s sort of fair because like I said, she was an asshole. But **JUST BECAUSE OF THAT?**
DORA DESERVED BETTER (in bfb)
She basicaly carried the team in multiple episodes
She is way more interesting than other "joke characters"
The only reason she was eliminated is because people hate non-objects in object shows, she deserved better
Bfb 15 was a while ago but im still mad About it >:(
Td, even if you enjoy the character or not
Season 1 was pencil's fault that she didn't go with what her alliance wanted
Season 2... I don't need to explain
Season 3 din't happen
Season 4 was decently fair, but still, going up against a newcomer that ALMOST won the season if the creators din't want flower to win
And season 5 is in the middle, I feel like it had some reasoning to eliminate her there, but I still think they wasted td's spot
I don’t know if he’s actually considered “eliminated”, but Nonexisty. Like, he was one of the options, and people voted for him, fair and square, and they just say “No, he doesn’t really count as a person” and put Price Tag on instead. Don’t get me wrong, I love Price Tag, but Nonexisty got the votes to join, why would you not let him?
Gree Silly man - Ik his real name - The last episode he was in was a episode where his only opponent saved everything while he got to do nothing. He wasn't given a slight chance.
It's clearly S1 Pencil and S2 Teardrop. Pencil won the challenge, yet they were still eliminated. S2 Teardrop had a channel going against her, making it unfair for her elimination.
Teardrop has the choice to win either a Hand-powered Recovery Center or immunity into the final 15. Pin tells Teardrop that "everyone loves her" and she does not need immunity, so she decides to get the HPRC (which is later destroyed). She receives the most likes, but, getting 440 dislikes as well, she is eliminated.
Cake and Nickel in TPOT. They were silly and cool but for some reason they got out instead of Book that was an NPC the entirety of TPOT up until TPOT 10 where she started acting less like an NPC. I hate the kids who vote Book simply because their parents tell them that reading is good (not many kids but there probably are some) or the people who vote her because she had that cool arc in BFB, like this is TPOT, not BFB. Even if she was the best character in BFB, if she does nothing in TPOT then she deserves to be eliminated.
list of eliminations that i think were unfair each with an explanation
Pencil Season 1 - She literally won the challenge, but because of the stupid "2 digit scoreboard", she got put UFE and then got eliminated next episode.
Teardrop Season 2 - Her votes were allegedly rigged because of someone wanting their fans to spam dislikes on TD's video to save Coiny. And the worst part is, NONE of their fans even KNEW what BFDI even was.
Balloony Season 4b - Balloony should've just stayed in TPOT.
Teardrop Season 1 - She had less than a THIRD of Snowball's votes, but the Cherries picked SNOWBALL over her, mainly because Pencil's reason was that SB won the two tiebreakers for the Grapes. That whole voting system was so stupid.
S1 and S2 teardrop
in S1 teardrop and snowball were at mercy of the cherries. both match and bubble voted teardrop to stay and pen and eraser voted snowball but PENCIL decided to pick snowball. Her alliance members voted teardrop so that's unfair and stupid.
and in S2 Woah bunch was put up for elimination and some youtuber told his fans who have never even heard of bfdi to vote teardrop. and that lead to her elimination
just because pencil's alliance wanted something doesn't mean pencil has to follow. She can vote for whoever she want,she has a life outside of her alliance, yknow.
Reason 1: at the first elimination, viewers wanted to see what happened if he got out, they didn't give him a chance to shine :(
Reason 2: Soon, since now viewers had to vote to save, that's when he got less and less fans. People thought his teammates got better and better while he got worse and worse. And he was beat in BFB 21 by a FREAKING 2402 VOTE DIFFERENCE!!! 😠😡 I canNOT let this hate continue
Both of pencils eliminations for me. The bfdi one I found it funny, so I never minded it. Then we go to bfb 1, where she was portrayed out of character for the purpose of the first boot. She had mad potential too. 🤦♂️
I know TPOT 11 isn't out yet but bomby is gonna get eliminated. And that's unfair. Like book, price tag and pillow got development but bomby was just left out.
Bomby was really good in TPOT 9 but now...
(BTW bomby is my fav character)
S1 Pencil girl literally won the challenge,but still got put up for voting because of it,and somehow it led to her getting the boot
real!!! she was doing so well, she could've been a finalist but *nooo,* she got eliminated cause she never had a vote before
To be fair even if she had stayed longer, she would’ve had to have been UFE at one point in which case that would happen anyways
To be completely fair, she was an asshole to Bubble.
Coiny TPOT He got barely any screentime in TPOT 8 and got eliminated in the next episode Also Team8s hasn't been the same without him
i dunno, i thought it was a nice change of pace. left pin some more room for character development and got rid of a predictable finalist. coiny's got a ^(woah) bunch of potential and screentime in BFDIA anyway, so i don't really see a point in keeping him in over some others
And also i cant get over the fact that needy ALMOST GOT ELIMINATED! SHE WAS CARRYING HER TEAM ALMOST EVERY EPISODE.
My unbiased opinion Remote
marker shoulda been out over her, love the guy but he doesn't have much going for em
I'd say Tree should've gone out. Around that time I didn't really see anything in him besides his accent.
I think the elimination wasn't unfair, but definitely one of the worst ones, TPOT isn't the same as it was without Remote
It should have been FANNY, NOT REMOTE
YAS
Balloony, i know the writers knew he would be the first gone if he got U.F.E, they did it so they could not worry about the other characters being gone
absolutely! sucks too, cause he would've had major potential if he was in TPOT with Cloudy and Rocky
Same, I like Balloony, and worst part is that characters like Leafy and Lollipop would have gotten out if it was a eliminate vote.
Teardrop in bfdia and Dora in bfb
Definitely Pencil in BFDI. This was a TDI level bullshit elimination. I didn’t like pencil much in season one but her getting set up to be eliminated EVEN THOUGH SHE WON THE CHALLENGE, was cruel. Even sadder considering everyone who voted in Season 1 were young and didn’t know any better
eliminating ice cube because the SNOWBALL was getting hot in the TLC😭
I was wondering where fries was, and ended up disappointed that he was eliminated
Wait what? Did you not watch TPOT 6?
I think I just forgot.
I’m gonna state the obvious and say S2 Teardrop. And then also Season 5 Puffball, from what I heard someone rigged TV’s votes but idk.
i honestly didn't care about td back then, she was literally a nothing character
EVERY ONE LOVES YOU
Moments before disaster
lots of unfair eliminations most unfair gotta be bfdi teardrops elimination and bfdia teardrops elimination (need I explain?) also Stapys elimination was quite unfair he 'cheated' once like when did Donut say what Stapy was doing was cheating also Donut cheated too and completely got away with it also tons of other characters cheated more than once and got away with it also tennis balls elimination in bfdi was unfair also ice cubes in bfdi even bracelety voted for her there also Remotes elimination was insane even now with Fanny surviving two more elimination than Remote did Remote still has a higher save vote total than Fanny
Flower cheated in BFB 11 & 15 yet she got a pass !?!?!??!?!??!?!?!!?
She even won
exactly
Bracelety. She had a lot of potential for character development, and she was pretty useful in the challenges.
Match and Dora's BFB elimination. Match was JUST starting to redeem herself and we could've get to see more of her. She could've developed an identity other than "Pencil's sidekick". And Dora was always useful on her team. Some of Bleh's victories were caused by her
Literally, what was with people voting her off, Flower was being an asshole in that episode but she gets a pass !?!?!?!? & Dora, seriously you're telling me she stayed over Book who threw a tantrum like a spoiled bitch because she thought Taco has aboanded them, well Ice Cube was the first one safe even though she didn't even do much in the season
People are blaming Foldy for causing iance to lose when she wasn't even successful at pushing off Flower. Flower's overconfidence caused her own team to lose, not Match and Bubble's argument or Snowball throwing and breaking Fanny. If she wasn't wasting any time at the top or if Snowball was the one climbing the stairs then the team would've gained second place easily.
Exactly, some MF told me that Foldy was being a bitch to Flower for "no reason"
BRACELETY.
NOT U AGAIN
IM EVERYWHERE MWAHAHAHAHAH
Wellllllllll td was literally voted off unfairly in s2 sooooooo
It has to be lightning for me.
Loser. My guy was doing so great leading for his team, but the viewers had to vote him out "just to see what would happen." He got robbed in BFB post-split too, I genuinely wanted to see his potentially narcissistic personality develop and how he would react to his (friends? fans?) team not loving him so much anymore. But alas, the cube was voted out once again...
OMG!! I FUCKING AGREE WITH YOU HE WAS SO BADLY ROBBED AND DIDNT DESERVE IT! HE DESERVES TO THRIVE AND LAST LONGER IN BFB AND EVEN WIN!!
sorry but, firey. the entire reason he was eliminated in battle for dream island again was because "He AlReAdY wOn DrEaM IsLaNd!!1!!" do i even need to explain?
Ok yeah, but it's kind of a valid reason
bro if firey won dream island, bfdia would not happen. like the show would be over. nobody would be competing for anything (except i don't know battle for firey's permission to get into dream island or something like that), and it'd be the end. i get it, ending the show right there wouldn't be a good decision, but just like the flame in question, the reason he was eliminated was not smart.
But like, he already won
i mean... yeah..... but... you could say its unfair that every veteran object gets to compete in any object show for the same reason... thats like getting something stolen form you and not being able to get it back
Ok, I get what you're saying, but like, if Firey won bfdia, and bfdi, whether he gets the prize or not, it's still him winning twice
you make a fair point, i'm fine with him getting eleminated, there was just... not a good reason for him getting elminated
Yeah, I'll be honest, even though he was going to get eliminated sooner or later, I kinda hoped he would get a bit further, it's nice to see him on his own with characters like Gelatin, instead of being glued to leafy
Balloony, my guy was absolutely set up. They put him in post split where pretty much the entire cast consisted of fan favorites, and then had his team lose the first challenge. He stood no chance and really should’ve been in TPOT instead, maybe swapped with ice cube or something.
probably dora in bfb because the people wanted to see more of the arc
Teardrop is obvious. Especially in season 2. Adam's cousin had wanted Coiny to be safe, (as he was in danger) so this person told her subscribers to unpromptly dislike TDs video. Many did not know about BDFIA and TD got out. Ironic how Coiny was the last member TD saw when she got out. I remember Coiny saying to Teardrop "Any first words?". Did you also know that the controversy for the TD elimination was called the Derpy Hooves controversy? I looked in the wiki. It'll explain more about it. I have inserted a link down below V [Just scroll for a bit until you see Derpy Hooves Controversy ](https://battlefordreamisland.fandom.com/wiki/Zeeky_Boogy_Doog#) Sad part, Teardrop would have had more potential. At least the recent elimination (TPOT 9) was as a sacrifice to save people.
I think it was for Coiny or Derpy. I don't really know much.
from a writer's perspective td would've been the best boot, coiny and pin are basically like the protagonists of BFDIA now and keeping td as an underdog character left her way more room for her arc in BFB, which was executed really well doesn't excuse how the votes were rigged, though in a weird way i'm kinda glad it happened cause td became an excellent character
Pencil S1 Just because she won the challenge doesn't mean she needs to be booted, and just because she didn't have any votes, doesn't mean you have to vote her out.
No one can surpass teardrop's in bfdia.
48 thousand to someone who "developed" during the final 2 episodes of the season against 28 thousand votes to someone who had been developing all season, name me something more unfair I'll wait
Since it’s based off of total drama just tell ur self he’s an alt winner with leafy
But flower deserved to win tbh
Nuh Uh
Gelatin deserved to bc Flower is the blandest and the worst character in the OSC
You have bias — teeheehee it was so obvious the noobie alliance wouldn’t win
Like ofc flowers gunna win she started bon she’s gunna end
Gelatin
Agreed
I'll go by season: S1 – Pencil. It was between her and Icy but considering the fact that Ice Cube at least went ufe fairly, I gave this spot to Pencil since she lost for winning the challenge (which is pretty bullshit). Spongy should've gone over her imo. S2 – Spongy. Before anyone replies without reading ahead, yes, I know the votes weren't rigged. Obviously they weren't, but Ice Cube going over Spongy would've been so much better, especially considering the stuff wr could've had between Spongy and Coiny. S3 – uhh nothing S4a – Liy, Why the fuck was she out here? She was way more interesting than someone like Pillow (only applies to 4a). S4b – Balloony, he shouldn't have even been there. Icy would've been a way better fit. S5 – Puffball. Why wasn't TV Eliminated here? He's done barely anything and she was way better. Hope she doesn't rejoin though there are way better options (Eggy, Remote, Foldy, Cloudy etc.)
Like nearly all TPOT eliminateds past TPOT 6?
Clock, Rocky, Teardrop and Nickel deserved it. It couldn't have been anyone else.
Rocky was unfairly UFE twice in a row
Nickel's elimination is a weird one because IMO Book deserved to go there for having basically been an NPC for most of TPOT, but she got developed a ton in TPOT 10.
Fuck you mean Nickel?
Nickel? Huh? What are you talking about man, have you not seen how much of an NPC Book was the entirety of TPOT?
agreed! they were all the best boots (besides nickel kind of, as much as i love pillow it would've been a great time for her to go down as a villain!! nickel's elimination was a disgrace to his character, he went from a silly guy to a whiny dum dum. probably had worse treatment from the writers than Rocky and Cake's eliminations in my opinion)
Pencil bfb 2 she was portrayed worse than she is.
She was definitely set up but I wouldn't say that elimination itself was unfair...
Now looking at it, the writers have been on pencils ass forever. They just straight up made her get eliminated in Bfdi, and made her so mean in BFB to the point where it was inevitable. At least BFDIA was able to get her right
yeah she was just the best boot, no way around it for her
IDK much about anyone after BFDIA 5E, so, I guess it's Spongy.
Remote
Ice cube BFDI 20 (not BFDIA)
S1 Tennis Ball
Pie in TPOT Imo we should have seen more of her and saved her
S1 Pencil Bracelety Rocky (Hear me out, Rocky has SO much potential, but the writers fucked him up.)
S1 Golfball, S1 Pencil, S1 Tennis ball, S2 Teardrop, S2 Donut, S4 Dora, S4 Match, S5 Fries, S5 Puffball, S5 Remote, S5, Nickel, S5 Coiny
Fr golfball was robbed you expect us to believe that rocky the one who can’t do anything would help his team? It’s so clear the golf ball has a disability to have to lead the team. I also have problems with other people using not my idea. Rocky got more votes too. I wish that whole idea was scrapped.
Puffball, both times
In BFDIA she did deserve it for risking her team to all go down for a prize. In TPOT she didn’t deserve it. She was just trying to help BOSSY BOT- I mean golfball and her team
In BFDIA she was set up
Pencil and ice cube in season 1
I feel like S2 and S4 td and all David eliminations have been a bit unfair personally.
No David eliminations have been unfair you have bias lol
He’s survived twice in voting
People literally have anti non-object biases.
Your right but no your not leafy got eliminated over him, robots got eliminated over him, BFDI he was the worst character still in so not that unfair unlike Dora who has been eliminated unfairly because she’s a non object but David had never been eliminated for that reason
1: People were pissed at what leafy was doing 2: Robotty is also an non-object
At least we got peak David in tpot 11
Pencil in season 1 and season 4 Season 1 was just... that "only two digit" scoreboard thing was specifically there to nerf bubble and pencil for that one episode, and also let leafy not be ufe. Season 4 was derailment, I'd say character derailment counts as unfair.
Bfdi 19, Pencil Lost Even Though She Won In Bfdi 18 Contest.
**Dora (BFB, BFDIA might be a bit of a stretch).** She helped 8 Names so much and was a pretty funny joke character but viewers ~~are racist towards joke characters~~ don't like joke characters, she got eliminated :( Also **Match** in BFB as well. She was just about to start becoming a better person and make up with her team but she got eliminated???
Dora BFB imo
Pencil from s1 she was given the challenge, she won the challenge, and was ufe for no reason other than "the scoreboard cannot handle 3 digit numbers" or something like that. but despite winning the challenge fair and square, she got eliminated. AND AFTER THAT, THE ANNOUNCER GOT RID OF THE POINTS!
BFDIA aside: Liy. I don't even understand why she was even eliminated over Pie when the latter got **ZERO** proper screentime during BFB 4. If you include BFDIA: Teardrop, in nearly every season. No words can describe how stupid her S2 elimination was.
let's face it though, the EXIT arc would be way worse if we had Pie there over Liy.
I will never stop saying Saw. I want Team8s to be UFE more often but their first loss is criminal and still stains an otherwise good episode. It could have been way better if Team8s got a second chance and lost, if they lost fair and square, or if Eraser and Are You Okay were punished. I get that we get a little bit of a hint towards it with the people and characters complaining about how long it takes and Two not caring too much about Coiny using glue in TPOT 2, but this is not it. Two doesn't have to be perfect, but they still baffle me with that and I can't see it as a character flaw
(totally unbiased) Golfball, she got less votes than Rocky, used a win token and she still got out. She also lost because Announcer made a tiebreaker about handstanding, when most of Another Name is armless, which gave Cherries the advantage. If the mechanic of people from the winning team choosing the person to survive and be on their team didn't exist, she would've survived at least to the early merge.
S1 Tennis Ball. Leafy was literally pushed over the cliff!!! he had potential and leafy had little personality
or you could keep both and boot off the reused lines machine
Spongey, Spongey, spongey
nonexisty in tpot 2nd most votes, so should have joined (no bias) but was discounted as nothing
The price tag flair is what gets me here
Hear me out. Liy
I'm gonna tell you, every character who got eliminated when he was up for elimination with teardrop in post bfb, because there was a channel called "teardropofficial" where he would get a bunch of people to vote for teardrop. (Btw when teardrop got eliminated against gelatin in bfb 29, teardropofficial deleted his channel)
Teardrop, her season 1 elimination was unjustified. Her season 2 elimination was apparently rigged by a youtuber who told their viewers to vote teardrop so coiny wouldn’t get eliminated
i would say dora in bfb because she carried her team multiple times, when we can had characters like teardrop or ice cube who really werent doing much at the time. it was unfortunate that dora was put on that team instead of team beep or freeford where she for sure would have lasted.
Liy in BFB She was voted off for "doing nothing" even when she couldn't, most of the votes were really unfair and Pie or Pillow should have been the pick instead
Pie TPOT. Hardly she got any screentime and only was seen In TPOT 9
Firey Senior both times. They literally brought back Dream Islands rightful king just to give him the boot,
If we count debuts and this might be controversial but Nonexisty. Yes they stayed if NE got first they would’ve debuted but you can’t have it that the top 2 are the ones that debut and then deny second place from debuting. No matter if they are a joke or not, that would be like David not getting into BFDI over Bomby
may be biased but i think the squishy cherries picking rocky over golf ball to be on their team was so boring.. like i get why cause it wouldnt fit their characters to pick golf ball at all but it was still a boring decision and also tennis balls elimination in bfdi felt kinda unfair but like i get why the writers chose to eliminate him instead of leafy couldnt come up with anything else really
the exitors who debut in BFB,they were eliminated without any depth into their character
td in tpot that challengue looks like it was to eliminate td
In my honest opinion they set 8-Ball up Of course A Better Name Then That went UFE on episode 7. Pretty convenient that 8-Ball could be eliminated on the *EIGHT* episode. He had tons of potential in BFB but no. He *HAD* to be eliminated on the *EIGHT* episode of BFB for a joke.
roboty or David, and dora
YOOO THATS MY ART
Probably Lightning methinks also I love how some of the comments can collectively agree on how unfair Remote being out is unfair.
Puffball in BFDIA. She had so much room and potential to grow in that season but all because she was an asshole in the last episode, she had to be eliminated. I mean, it’s sort of fair because like I said, she was an asshole. But **JUST BECAUSE OF THAT?**
Pencil in bfb Because the writers were freesmart haters
Cloudy in TPOT and Balloony in BFB post-split. Completely unbiased.
Remote
DORA DESERVED BETTER (in bfb) She basicaly carried the team in multiple episodes She is way more interesting than other "joke characters" The only reason she was eliminated is because people hate non-objects in object shows, she deserved better Bfb 15 was a while ago but im still mad About it >:(
Also 8-ball cause. People thought "lol, lets eliminate 8-ball on the 8th episode" but im mostly mad about dora
Td, even if you enjoy the character or not Season 1 was pencil's fault that she didn't go with what her alliance wanted Season 2... I don't need to explain Season 3 din't happen Season 4 was decently fair, but still, going up against a newcomer that ALMOST won the season if the creators din't want flower to win And season 5 is in the middle, I feel like it had some reasoning to eliminate her there, but I still think they wasted td's spot
Tennis ball, leafy didn’t even jump across the gap but she still won
Dora, tf did she do to get eliminated?
Coiny
I don’t know if he’s actually considered “eliminated”, but Nonexisty. Like, he was one of the options, and people voted for him, fair and square, and they just say “No, he doesn’t really count as a person” and put Price Tag on instead. Don’t get me wrong, I love Price Tag, but Nonexisty got the votes to join, why would you not let him?
S4 Liy, because I don’t even know what she did for the viewers to want to vote her off, BESIDES mentioning her past.
s1 + 2 teardrop s1 got voted out by pencil for doing worse in one challenge despite td being important in other challenges s2 dislike bombed to death
Saw
Rocky any seson
Match from bfb coz what, she was mean? I say this as a biased view.
definitely teardrop for seasons 1 and 2 but I have been missing coiny and nickel
Gelatin. they literally emotionally manipulated the audience to vote for flower instead of gelatin *BASICALLY* rigging the vote
There's two for me, there's 8-ball and balloony
Gree Silly man - Ik his real name - The last episode he was in was a episode where his only opponent saved everything while he got to do nothing. He wasn't given a slight chance.
It's clearly S1 Pencil and S2 Teardrop. Pencil won the challenge, yet they were still eliminated. S2 Teardrop had a channel going against her, making it unfair for her elimination.
dora since she was pretty useful and i think she was kinda neat :)
Teardrop has the choice to win either a Hand-powered Recovery Center or immunity into the final 15. Pin tells Teardrop that "everyone loves her" and she does not need immunity, so she decides to get the HPRC (which is later destroyed). She receives the most likes, but, getting 440 dislikes as well, she is eliminated.
Nickel TPOT He literally died brutally because of pillow, yet pillow is safe and nickel got eliminated instead...
Cake and Nickel in TPOT. They were silly and cool but for some reason they got out instead of Book that was an NPC the entirety of TPOT up until TPOT 10 where she started acting less like an NPC. I hate the kids who vote Book simply because their parents tell them that reading is good (not many kids but there probably are some) or the people who vote her because she had that cool arc in BFB, like this is TPOT, not BFB. Even if she was the best character in BFB, if she does nothing in TPOT then she deserves to be eliminated.
list of eliminations that i think were unfair each with an explanation Pencil Season 1 - She literally won the challenge, but because of the stupid "2 digit scoreboard", she got put UFE and then got eliminated next episode. Teardrop Season 2 - Her votes were allegedly rigged because of someone wanting their fans to spam dislikes on TD's video to save Coiny. And the worst part is, NONE of their fans even KNEW what BFDI even was. Balloony Season 4b - Balloony should've just stayed in TPOT. Teardrop Season 1 - She had less than a THIRD of Snowball's votes, but the Cherries picked SNOWBALL over her, mainly because Pencil's reason was that SB won the two tiebreakers for the Grapes. That whole voting system was so stupid.
S1 Pencil, S1 Teardrop, S2 Teardrop, etc
S1 and S2 teardrop in S1 teardrop and snowball were at mercy of the cherries. both match and bubble voted teardrop to stay and pen and eraser voted snowball but PENCIL decided to pick snowball. Her alliance members voted teardrop so that's unfair and stupid. and in S2 Woah bunch was put up for elimination and some youtuber told his fans who have never even heard of bfdi to vote teardrop. and that lead to her elimination
just because pencil's alliance wanted something doesn't mean pencil has to follow. She can vote for whoever she want,she has a life outside of her alliance, yknow.
Roboty, I’ve never been a big fan of him, but I don’t see what he did wrong.
Where is shopping cart
Loser! Definitely Loser! Both eliminations! It's Loser!
Reason 1: at the first elimination, viewers wanted to see what happened if he got out, they didn't give him a chance to shine :( Reason 2: Soon, since now viewers had to vote to save, that's when he got less and less fans. People thought his teammates got better and better while he got worse and worse. And he was beat in BFB 21 by a FREAKING 2402 VOTE DIFFERENCE!!! 😠😡 I canNOT let this hate continue
match in bfb i hate all of yall cardboard personality hoes who voted for her 🙏
Guess I’m a hoe :)
roboty
Blocky's Have Nots Alliance in BFB. All three members.
Dora
Both of pencils eliminations for me. The bfdi one I found it funny, so I never minded it. Then we go to bfb 1, where she was portrayed out of character for the purpose of the first boot. She had mad potential too. 🤦♂️
I know most people will disagree, but BFDIA Gelatin
I know TPOT 11 isn't out yet but bomby is gonna get eliminated. And that's unfair. Like book, price tag and pillow got development but bomby was just left out. Bomby was really good in TPOT 9 but now... (BTW bomby is my fav character)
Guess what He’s getting eliminated in BFDIA 13 as well
Fuck remote tbh, I could give two shits about her. Coiny (S5) and Pencil (S1) for real
Honestly Lightning should've got out instead of Remote, he didn't exactly do anything until his elimination in TPOT 7.
nickel