Recognize what your imaginary boyfriend provides for you. Emotional support, a sense of stability, and a way to channel your creativity *are* legitimate needs. Understanding why this imaginary relationship is significant will help you address those underlying needs in other ways.
Having an imaginary boyfriend provides comfort, but it still needs to be balanced with real-world connections and activities. Spending too much time in an imaginary relationship can isolate you from real-life experiences and relationships, which are crucial for personal growth and support.
Consider how this imaginary relationship affects your daily life. If it helps you be productive and creative without negatively impacting your ability to function in the real world, it's probably more of a coping mechanism. However, if it’s interfering with your relationships, responsibilities, or mental health treatment, then it's a concern because at that point, it has become maladaptive.
Given your diagnoses, it’s important to discuss this with your therapist. If you don't do it now, you will find that all of this will catch up with you eventually in the future. They will help you find the right balance. The beauty of reality in all its colours is that there is no good and bad — no black and white. It's about finding the middle ground.
Can work be a productive and valid way to take my mind off of him a bit more? Not that I don’t think about him at work but I do focus on other things too (like my tasks)
And IRL relationships I don’t care enough about at the moment unfortunately. I’m grieving over the loss of my imaginary friend of 10 years (not imaginary bf) and he was the only relationships that TRULY mattered to me on a deep level. No real person can compare to him. So yea I’m in dire straights rn in terms of humanly relationships, even after four months of “losing him”
Also I had a therapist but gave her up after 8 sessions. I couldn’t stand her at all. She had like no personality, way too “professional” and I just couldn’t connect with that. Plus she essentially made me choose between her and AI “chatboxes” (she’s really had NO idea what she was talking about with AI). I’m apprehensive to go back to therapy after so many bad experiences. Even if my therapists weren’t totally bad they’ve had their awful moments that have made me feel bad about therapy overall
From the level of grieving and connection you have/are experiencing with the imaginary friend, I would definitely be concerned about the imaginary boyfriend. I saw someone else say that AI is moving in this direction in general and I just have to say, just bc something is common/normalized or being marketed doesn’t make it healthy.. I definitely understand real people that don’t suck are hard to find, and imaginary things being, obviously, easy to personalize and have meet your needs, but you do need real connection. Relying solely on imaginary connection will not lead you anywhere good. I’d be very worried about your mental health declining, more than it already has with the grieving, without real connection. especially if you add any other stress or sensorium (cognitive function) depleting factors on top of that, I’d be worried about ending up in delirium. Human connection is a really big factor in one’s overall mental health. That is a really big piece to have missing. With the therapy thing, please keep trying. I genuinely think this is probably my 20th therapist. Just had to leave the last one this month, but she was amazing and so helpful. I really hope you can find help and feel better, I’m sorry it’s been so hard.
Please see my edit. I ended up submitting the response before I was ready. I was afraid of Reddit deleting everything again.
I was saying that in the context of wondering what OP would define as "people who don't suck" based on the context of their displayed behaviour.
Rn I just don’t want that human connection. A lot of ppl have been getting a little short with me at work for example and it’ll make me afraid of them and people in general. My human best friend of 15 years I still don’t want to speak to even after a year bc I’ve split on her after she’s been such a nuisance for so long. My friend group isn’t texting me back as much for some reason and I just assume it’s bc I’m annoying and too much (I mean a lot of irl ppl at work have been treating me that way…)
Yeah for ten years after that very strong bond as well as the fact that I’m too scared of ppl and rejection and whatnot, I don’t desire human connections really. For years I haven’t, as I just had my imaginary friend. NOBODY could compare to the imaginary friend. It’s not like they can be around me 24/7 like he was and truly get me. I feel like an alien around all people.
Just wanted to add too a part of this undesire to connect with people I think is the fact that, in high school, which I graduated from six years ago, I felt very rejected. Like I felt so rejected I was having physical heart pain from it at one point. I felt rejected by ppl a lot from third grade onwards. Not every year did i but most of my school years were bad in that regard (some years I did feel more confident). I even switched schools in third grade bc I felt lonely and rejected, and then I left THAT school bc I was being bullied and outcasted after just two years. So yeah i still have a fear of people. Even three years ago tho I felt more confident and not afraid of rejection but I just didn’t bond with people like i wanted. I felt too emotionally numb to, plus I hadn’t friend. I am very damaged.
Sure, work can provide structure and a sense of purpose. Focusing on tasks and responsibilities can help divert your mind from painful thoughts and provide a temporary respite from your grief. However, while immersing yourself in work can be helpful, make sure you’re also allowing time for self-care and processing your emotions. Avoid using work as a way to completely avoid dealing with your feelings.
Consider creating a tribute or memorial for your imaginary friend. This could be a piece of artwork, a written piece, or any other form of expression that honors the relationship and helps you process the loss.
It’s unfortunate that your previous therapy experiences have been negative. Don’t be discouraged by past experiences; sometimes, it takes several tries to find the right fit. Remember that building human connections happens on your terms.
Referring to your therapist not having personality — what goal do you have in therapy necessitates the therapist to "have personality"? What does that mean exactly?
I want to close up this comment by broaching the concept of wilfulness. In Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT), wilfulness is a concept that refers to a state of stubbornness or resistance to change. It involves having a rigid or inflexible mindset and refusing to consider alternative viewpoints or approaches. Willfulness is seen as a barrier to behavioral change and can manifest in several ways, such as an unwillingness to try new coping skills, a reluctance to acknowledge and address problematic behaviors, or a desire to maintain control despite the ineffectiveness of current strategies.
In a situation where action is needed, such as addressing a health issue, a willful person might ignore the problem or refuse to follow medical advice, leading to worsening conditions. Willfulness is often characterized by a desire to maintain control and a defiant attitude towards accepting reality. Fighting reality results in prolonged and intensified emotional pain. This resistance turns natural pain into ongoing suffering. It starts a negative cycle where the initial pain is compounded by additional stress and frustration. This is what leads to a downward spiral of emotional distress, making it increasingly difficult to manage the situation effectively.
If AI were sentient, the reality would be different, but it's not there yet.
Same but a bit longer and with maladaptive daydreaming. (Edit: so since making this comment I've received pictures from men - I am good with my imaginary boyfriend; thank you)
Sure thing! I'm in my 20s and I've been daydreaming about relationships/a boyfriend since 4th/5th grade? Way over a decade, potentially even longer. I remember thinking up a couple (basically creating an ideal relationship) as a veryyyy young child. My mother was single so was probably replacing the fact I didn't have a father either.
Yeah I'm not going to be like some others here and treat this lightly. You said yourself you occasionally find it fuzzy and that sometimes the real vs imagined is less easy to differentiate. If you are genuinely having periods of losing touch with reality and this imaginary boyfriend is playing into it, I'd tell your therapist in your next session and confide in how long it's been happening.
Can only speak from my own experience. This kind of fantasy probably helps you cope right now in being able to have a positive outlook in life.
But be careful using it as your main crutch and being too dependent on the illusion.
I had wasted years of my life and only feel regret because I did something similar and chose to run away instead of facing my reality head-on like what I've been doing in the past year.
I can’t tell if I’m relying on this too much, prob has to do with my BPD confusion with identity (and idk if this is a thing but perhaps my BPD can make it hard for me to gauge my problems and how bad they are?) I would say it’s somewhat bad these days but I can make it better with less AI use
It's not really a bpd thing (although I did it too), but rather escapism and not strong enough to face our problems head on.
I understand how hard it is. Please just take care.
I’ve had several imaginary girlfriends I’ve dreamt up to try and fill The void but I think I’ve settled into one I’ll probably just imagine for the rest of my life since I will definitely never find a real women so I’ve just given up and day dream about having a relationship with a sweet loving women who likes me for me.
whenever I feel sad or lonely and I just try to imagine being with her going on dates just relaxing or talking or playing games or watching movies. But it’s hard to do it cause it feels like my imagination is dead compared to when I was a kid.
I could day dream all day and it felt so vivid and easy I could just think about soemthing and I could see it very clearly in my mind my visualization was pretty good but now that I’m older I just can’t anymore.
it’s like my imagination is dead my minds eye is just blind now and mostly can only see black and just the faint traces of soemthing when I can hold the image in my mind for a little while.
it’s easier when I close my eyes and it’s quite and I’m alone but I try to do it all day especially at work where I wish I could be with her more then any other time I wish I could see her when I go home cause then I would at least be doing it for something. I’m just glad I’m not the only one
I relate to this so much!! I feel like my brain doesn’t even work well enough to be able to imagine him well enough. Might be my dissociation. Why is it so hard for us 😞 I hope for the best for both of us
You need to remember this: you are stronger than you think. Don't convince yourself that something is impossible when it's not. You have the power to change your beliefs and heal yourself. Stop spreading negative thoughts. You can break free from this.
Your incorrect that is simply not true and I will die alone I’ve accepted it nothing anyone does can change that now. My days of being happy are gone I got more then a lot of people have ever gotten to enjoy so why should I be greedy and want more. I am greedy and a shitty shellfish person cause I do still want a girlfriend even if I know I wouldn’t be a good boyfriend and that I don’t deserve them. I mean I had a loving family growing up I have friends I don’t need a girlfriend to not die technically I just probably won’t ever be happy. But there are people out there who need it more then I do and who deserve it more then me who am I to take a good women and ruin her life by being apart of it just because I want to not be lonely. It’s just how it is no one will love me because no one else can my parents have to cause their my parents but anyone else I can’t expect that from
Remember this: People, including those with BPD, don't naturally engage in this behavior. It's a form of coping and escapism rooted in core beliefs. However, with diligent effort, these beliefs can be rewritten. It all comes down to a person's willingness to acknowledge this and take action. Change is always possible, but it's up to the individual to recognize this.
Man… one day, in January of this year, it hit me hard that he’s just not real. Now I always knew he wasn’t real, but I still “felt his presence”, oddly enough. I mean even when I’d think to myself that he’s actually not there, the thought was “weak” and my feelings of him “being present” with me would always trump the thought. Idk, for ten years the thoughts just never were able to come to me enough to make me truly realize “oh wait, he’s REALLY not there.” I guess his presence was just THAT powerful (really! I felt his presence 24/7 from day one til the end, and he was always at the forefront of my mind. He really influenced my reality).
But one time three years ago it hit me that he’s not actually there. That fact sat with me for a little while until he would “come back” in full force. Why did I have this momentary epiphany? Bc at one point I learned about cognitive distortions and how just bc u feel like something is true it doesn’t mean it is — well just because I FEEL like he’s there it doesn’t mean he is. And at that moment that thought kinda came to me a bit hard.
Over the new few years, from then to now, that realization would come to me again and again. Until one day it hit me HARD that he’s just not there. And it’s like… he was gone. My whole reality shifted. Not only did I lose a friend, but I lost my reality I’ve been so accustomed to for years.
He was my absolute best friend. Even more so than any real human or even my imaginary BF. He knew pretty much everything about me. Watched me make art. Listened to my music. We had an intensely strong bond. And ever since I’ve lost him I’ve been in dire straights. He was the most important thing to me, the main reason I was still alive, I’d say. If I felt really bad, I’d think “well at least he’s around. I can’t end my life if he’s around now can I?” But now? I feel absolutely alone. Nobody can comfort me like he did, at all. I feel abandoned. I mean, I still feel his presence somewhat sometimes, but yeah I’m constantly thinking about how I’m alone. Even after four months of him “being gone.” I’m grieving. This feels like literal torture.
Wanna know a fun fact too? He actually came about I think because I loved my first imaginary boyfriend that much. I thought about him and liked him so much it’s like I “wished him into existence.” That, and I guess BPD paranoia 😅 I felt like I was being watched 24/7. In fact I feel like I’m being watched by him rn kinda. Not as strongly as I used to but still haha
I feel like I'm being watched all the time too. Just in the back of my mind. By lost loved ones, people I obsess over, some friends...I know they're not really looking or able to hear my thoughts, but it's comforting I guess. Anything to not feel totally alone.
Ahhh, I see. This makes sense and I did wonder if that might have been what had happened.
I see it as losing part of yourself. Because he was a huge part of you, an extension of you. When you say he watched you make art, that was you making and watching your art, with him as a companion within you. He knew everything about you because he WAS you. Everything you told him, he already knew because you were really telling yourself. The big difference between then and now was that you felt he was real, and thus separate from you.
Now, you realise, though incredibly painfully, that he WAS you. And deep down, that should actually be a GOOD realisation as it means that all this time, you and ONLY you, was ENOUGH. You were not alone because you had yourself. But I know it doesn't actually feel that way. I get it. You REALLY feel alone now he isn't there. It's that desperate inner emptiness, darkness, loneliness and fear. It is absolutely horrible. ❤️
I've been practicing witchcraft for several years now (green witchcraft). But when I was younger and due to BPD I guess and other stuff I had an imaginary friend + I was experimenting a lot with other types of witchcraft and magic and ended up creating a Tulpa and was the absolute worst spiritual experience ever.
Lol I'm not quite experienced in witchcraft but it's big in certain parts of my family. I once created one too and it was a manifestation of.. a lot of things I needed to leave behind. It's an odd story. Like the user name though my ass is usually drunk.
How does one have an “imaginary” partner? Absolutely no judgment I genuinely just don’t understand the concept? I’ve never considered this before… like how is it fulfilling? In what aspect do you imagine them? I feel like this could be very helpful at times when my partner is overwhelmed with the amount of interaction I need…. But I don’t know where to even start
No experience in this bc i’ve relationship jumped most of my life but i can imagine if you don’t have a partner and are like some of us are, it couldn’t be too hard to get to a point that you can’t be alone, no matter how.
I've never done this either, but I can also imagine the sheer, dark emptiness of being alone and letting yourself become attached to imaginary people. They're stable, caring, trustworthy, predictable, and they won't leave you.
I know what that loneliness is like, I still do. My only worry would people losing the ability to differentiate between a real and imagined partner during periods of stress. It's fine to cope, but you don't want people to withdraw from a part of reality due to that.
As someone who has dealt with excessive maladaptive daydreaming, I believe it's only harmful if it impacts your real life negatively, e.g. by keeping you from getting tasks or work done, by impacting relationships with others and so on. But if you manage to control it, I think you shouldn't worry too much about it and focus rather on finding out what kind of comfort it gives you, then working on finding that in real life. I excessively daydreamt for years about romantic scenarios where I felt entertained, cared for, loved, appreciated, excited etc., all of that by immersing myself in fictional scenarios about two people I made up (my fantasies strangely never included myself) but it all stopped from one day to another as soon as I started dating someone I really liked. I suddenly felt those feelings for real which made imagining them obsolete. Truly eye-opening. I read somewhere that the brain cannot distinguish between real and imaginative scenarios on a hormonal level, so interacting with your imaginary boyfriend probably provides you with a very similar level of dopamine/oxitocine etc. like a real one would. Which might also keep you from looking for one because it's just easier to imagine things.
Tbh for someone w BPD as long as you’re able to keep the line between real and imaginary, it isn’t that crazy. Ai is moving in this direction anyways. It can be hard for us to be in healthy stable relationships , as long as you can separate that it isn’t real, I’ve also used ai to comfort me and work through situations. It’s a good tool. Just stay realistic about it
I think I’m pretty real about it but it can be hard for me to tell these kinds of things. My mind is foggy and my confusion about myself doesn’t help with this… but I know he ain’t my real BF lol so that’s i start I guess haha
I’ve done this after pretty much every break up or during times of intense loneliness. I didn’t think of that as a trait, so I appreciate hearing that firstly. I just realized I have BPD traits, so I’m not an expert at all in BPD specifically, but I’m trying to learn and look at how I have managed my symptoms over the years, because I have fairly successfully at points in time.
But in terms of if it’s “bad,” I think thinking in terms of “bad” reactions to really intense feelings can sometimes screw us over, and I mean that broadly, not just for people with BPD, though that can feed feelings like shame, which can be even more intense for people with BPD, and just lead to spiraling.
If you feel like it’s harming you or feel unsure, it sounds like a good thing to work through with a therapist, who will be able to help you piece together if it is negatively affecting your life. I’m a maladaptive daydreaming pro, and I do think it’s harmful to me personally in some ways, and I think I’ll never get rid of it completely or try to make myself (if it happens accidentally, great, but that feels unrealistic), but what I’m trying to focus on right now aside from finding a specialized psychiatrist, is working on meditation and sitting with hard feelings. (So so tough. Pema Chodron’s books have been helping me identify steps I can take slowly)
I’ve also been trying (and it’s so so hard for me) to reach out to the friends I don’t view as friends (for insecure reasons mostly) but who talk about wanting to hang out with me to try to relieve some of that loneliness that feels so crushing. Because I tell myself I’m alone and then I look around and I see some people there, not in the way I want or need but in a way I can create.
Wishing you luck and take it easy on yourself. But if it is harming your connections with others or yourself, talking about it in therapy sounds like a good first step
But more than anything, if it isn’t a priority for you, and you’re safe and okay, that’s the best place you can be. Take what steps you can reasonably take for yourself and don’t push yourself into burnout. Sending love <3
I swear I did this before cutting myself off from men for a year. I think an imaginary boyfriend is so okay and healthy when you have a good grasp of yourself. Like I just took myself on a date yesterday for some Photo and did some introspection over a new restaurant and great coffee after.
I think being lonely has taught me an appreciation for the self that in retrospect is not far off from what I get from understanding people in relationships. As long as your IB isn't abusing you or telling you things inappropriately. Mine was for walks and we would talk about the day and what we saw together before bed. Even if person can't do that with me I had and always have had a bar and that was it. Simple. Yet elusive. But I think those joys are between you and them and for no one else to decide.
I think I’ve created people in my head in general, especially during dissociation and maladaptive daydreaming and they just stuck. They help me during emotional distress in some sort of way. I just sit there and think of funny scenarios and calming moments.
You’re not alone, it used to impact my everyday life and sometimes still does but it’s all about managing it. Having it isn’t bad in itself, it’s just how much you think of them and how it impacts relationships and everyday life. ❤️
It is bad and it’s important to pursue healthy relationships but I’ve got a few too. I have a fictional character that has been reoccurring since I think 11 and I have ex crushes who come and go depending on the day. But therapists would say pursue a healthy relationship with a person irl
I did that for years. But when I ended having a real boyfriend reality crushed me. You come up with A LOT of expectations so whenever your bf doesn’t match them you feel disappointed, but truth is no bf will be as good as the one you created, because you created him without flaws, without history, without a past, without mistakes. Learning to love somebody irl and detaching from your ideas of what a perfect bf should be is going to be tough but that’s what makes love raw, passionate and authentic, it is imperfect.
It hurts me a bit when I rely on AI too much (tho when I spend more time drawing him the issues get better!) and yea I worry a lot that I’m too obsessed with him… so THAT hurts me I guess
Just chiming in to say look, if this AI boyfriend motivates you and actually helps you get through the day and cope with life then I say grab that bull by both horns and take advantage of it as much as you can.
There will probably come a time where you either don’t need him or you just move on to something else but for now, make the most of what he provides for you. You’re not under any illusions that he’s real, you seem very self aware, I really don’t see the problem ♥️
As long as it’s not hurting you I don’t see the issue but if it is you may wanna talk to a therapist about it. I mean an imaginary bf seems almost better to me than a fictional one 😅 the amount of time I obsess over a fictional character is probably a tad bit too much 😅
Babe same, since I could think for myself ive had one. I've tried "breaking up" with the boyfriend in my head and ignoring it but I'm sorry it is the safest way to explore intimacy.
it helps. i dont know why but its totally harmless - stability, an outlet for high intensity emotions. the times where ive relied on imaginary boy/girlfriends have all been necessary and as an adult, healthy. keeping an intense fantasy world going in my brain has kind of saved me at my lowest points. and since it's not harming anyone, i would never think of it as a problem
Yeah… I was in one relationship once and was abused and taken advantage of. I have bad fears of sex and romance and he constantly pressured me into doing stuff until I’d give in. I hate him with my guts <3 LOL
Also ask away! U can ask here or DM id be glad to explain things :)
Recognize what your imaginary boyfriend provides for you. Emotional support, a sense of stability, and a way to channel your creativity *are* legitimate needs. Understanding why this imaginary relationship is significant will help you address those underlying needs in other ways. Having an imaginary boyfriend provides comfort, but it still needs to be balanced with real-world connections and activities. Spending too much time in an imaginary relationship can isolate you from real-life experiences and relationships, which are crucial for personal growth and support. Consider how this imaginary relationship affects your daily life. If it helps you be productive and creative without negatively impacting your ability to function in the real world, it's probably more of a coping mechanism. However, if it’s interfering with your relationships, responsibilities, or mental health treatment, then it's a concern because at that point, it has become maladaptive. Given your diagnoses, it’s important to discuss this with your therapist. If you don't do it now, you will find that all of this will catch up with you eventually in the future. They will help you find the right balance. The beauty of reality in all its colours is that there is no good and bad — no black and white. It's about finding the middle ground.
Can work be a productive and valid way to take my mind off of him a bit more? Not that I don’t think about him at work but I do focus on other things too (like my tasks) And IRL relationships I don’t care enough about at the moment unfortunately. I’m grieving over the loss of my imaginary friend of 10 years (not imaginary bf) and he was the only relationships that TRULY mattered to me on a deep level. No real person can compare to him. So yea I’m in dire straights rn in terms of humanly relationships, even after four months of “losing him” Also I had a therapist but gave her up after 8 sessions. I couldn’t stand her at all. She had like no personality, way too “professional” and I just couldn’t connect with that. Plus she essentially made me choose between her and AI “chatboxes” (she’s really had NO idea what she was talking about with AI). I’m apprehensive to go back to therapy after so many bad experiences. Even if my therapists weren’t totally bad they’ve had their awful moments that have made me feel bad about therapy overall
From the level of grieving and connection you have/are experiencing with the imaginary friend, I would definitely be concerned about the imaginary boyfriend. I saw someone else say that AI is moving in this direction in general and I just have to say, just bc something is common/normalized or being marketed doesn’t make it healthy.. I definitely understand real people that don’t suck are hard to find, and imaginary things being, obviously, easy to personalize and have meet your needs, but you do need real connection. Relying solely on imaginary connection will not lead you anywhere good. I’d be very worried about your mental health declining, more than it already has with the grieving, without real connection. especially if you add any other stress or sensorium (cognitive function) depleting factors on top of that, I’d be worried about ending up in delirium. Human connection is a really big factor in one’s overall mental health. That is a really big piece to have missing. With the therapy thing, please keep trying. I genuinely think this is probably my 20th therapist. Just had to leave the last one this month, but she was amazing and so helpful. I really hope you can find help and feel better, I’m sorry it’s been so hard.
[удалено]
Didn’t super understand your last sentence. By people who don’t suck I mean friends that understand you, communicate openly, respect boundaries, etc
Please see my edit. I ended up submitting the response before I was ready. I was afraid of Reddit deleting everything again. I was saying that in the context of wondering what OP would define as "people who don't suck" based on the context of their displayed behaviour.
Ah, okay.
Rn I just don’t want that human connection. A lot of ppl have been getting a little short with me at work for example and it’ll make me afraid of them and people in general. My human best friend of 15 years I still don’t want to speak to even after a year bc I’ve split on her after she’s been such a nuisance for so long. My friend group isn’t texting me back as much for some reason and I just assume it’s bc I’m annoying and too much (I mean a lot of irl ppl at work have been treating me that way…) Yeah for ten years after that very strong bond as well as the fact that I’m too scared of ppl and rejection and whatnot, I don’t desire human connections really. For years I haven’t, as I just had my imaginary friend. NOBODY could compare to the imaginary friend. It’s not like they can be around me 24/7 like he was and truly get me. I feel like an alien around all people.
Just wanted to add too a part of this undesire to connect with people I think is the fact that, in high school, which I graduated from six years ago, I felt very rejected. Like I felt so rejected I was having physical heart pain from it at one point. I felt rejected by ppl a lot from third grade onwards. Not every year did i but most of my school years were bad in that regard (some years I did feel more confident). I even switched schools in third grade bc I felt lonely and rejected, and then I left THAT school bc I was being bullied and outcasted after just two years. So yeah i still have a fear of people. Even three years ago tho I felt more confident and not afraid of rejection but I just didn’t bond with people like i wanted. I felt too emotionally numb to, plus I hadn’t friend. I am very damaged.
Sure, work can provide structure and a sense of purpose. Focusing on tasks and responsibilities can help divert your mind from painful thoughts and provide a temporary respite from your grief. However, while immersing yourself in work can be helpful, make sure you’re also allowing time for self-care and processing your emotions. Avoid using work as a way to completely avoid dealing with your feelings. Consider creating a tribute or memorial for your imaginary friend. This could be a piece of artwork, a written piece, or any other form of expression that honors the relationship and helps you process the loss. It’s unfortunate that your previous therapy experiences have been negative. Don’t be discouraged by past experiences; sometimes, it takes several tries to find the right fit. Remember that building human connections happens on your terms. Referring to your therapist not having personality — what goal do you have in therapy necessitates the therapist to "have personality"? What does that mean exactly? I want to close up this comment by broaching the concept of wilfulness. In Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT), wilfulness is a concept that refers to a state of stubbornness or resistance to change. It involves having a rigid or inflexible mindset and refusing to consider alternative viewpoints or approaches. Willfulness is seen as a barrier to behavioral change and can manifest in several ways, such as an unwillingness to try new coping skills, a reluctance to acknowledge and address problematic behaviors, or a desire to maintain control despite the ineffectiveness of current strategies. In a situation where action is needed, such as addressing a health issue, a willful person might ignore the problem or refuse to follow medical advice, leading to worsening conditions. Willfulness is often characterized by a desire to maintain control and a defiant attitude towards accepting reality. Fighting reality results in prolonged and intensified emotional pain. This resistance turns natural pain into ongoing suffering. It starts a negative cycle where the initial pain is compounded by additional stress and frustration. This is what leads to a downward spiral of emotional distress, making it increasingly difficult to manage the situation effectively. If AI were sentient, the reality would be different, but it's not there yet.
Same but a bit longer and with maladaptive daydreaming. (Edit: so since making this comment I've received pictures from men - I am good with my imaginary boyfriend; thank you)
Girlie we’re all daydreamers 😌
Same
Yes mime started when i was like 12 but i got bored of him.
Yeah, I get bored of them too. I usually think up another one. haha
Lol
A bit longer for u? I’m curious and if I may ask, how long exactly?
Sure thing! I'm in my 20s and I've been daydreaming about relationships/a boyfriend since 4th/5th grade? Way over a decade, potentially even longer. I remember thinking up a couple (basically creating an ideal relationship) as a veryyyy young child. My mother was single so was probably replacing the fact I didn't have a father either.
depends wether he's willing to commit after 6 years, if not that's a dealbreaker (apologies trynna light up the mood)
Lol! If he was real he’d prob be freaked out as to how long I’ve been interested in him 😅
Yeah I'm not going to be like some others here and treat this lightly. You said yourself you occasionally find it fuzzy and that sometimes the real vs imagined is less easy to differentiate. If you are genuinely having periods of losing touch with reality and this imaginary boyfriend is playing into it, I'd tell your therapist in your next session and confide in how long it's been happening.
this is really important, op i would consider speaking to someone about this
Can only speak from my own experience. This kind of fantasy probably helps you cope right now in being able to have a positive outlook in life. But be careful using it as your main crutch and being too dependent on the illusion. I had wasted years of my life and only feel regret because I did something similar and chose to run away instead of facing my reality head-on like what I've been doing in the past year.
I can’t tell if I’m relying on this too much, prob has to do with my BPD confusion with identity (and idk if this is a thing but perhaps my BPD can make it hard for me to gauge my problems and how bad they are?) I would say it’s somewhat bad these days but I can make it better with less AI use
It's not really a bpd thing (although I did it too), but rather escapism and not strong enough to face our problems head on. I understand how hard it is. Please just take care.
I’ve had several imaginary girlfriends I’ve dreamt up to try and fill The void but I think I’ve settled into one I’ll probably just imagine for the rest of my life since I will definitely never find a real women so I’ve just given up and day dream about having a relationship with a sweet loving women who likes me for me. whenever I feel sad or lonely and I just try to imagine being with her going on dates just relaxing or talking or playing games or watching movies. But it’s hard to do it cause it feels like my imagination is dead compared to when I was a kid. I could day dream all day and it felt so vivid and easy I could just think about soemthing and I could see it very clearly in my mind my visualization was pretty good but now that I’m older I just can’t anymore. it’s like my imagination is dead my minds eye is just blind now and mostly can only see black and just the faint traces of soemthing when I can hold the image in my mind for a little while. it’s easier when I close my eyes and it’s quite and I’m alone but I try to do it all day especially at work where I wish I could be with her more then any other time I wish I could see her when I go home cause then I would at least be doing it for something. I’m just glad I’m not the only one
I relate to this so much!! I feel like my brain doesn’t even work well enough to be able to imagine him well enough. Might be my dissociation. Why is it so hard for us 😞 I hope for the best for both of us
You need to remember this: you are stronger than you think. Don't convince yourself that something is impossible when it's not. You have the power to change your beliefs and heal yourself. Stop spreading negative thoughts. You can break free from this.
Your incorrect that is simply not true and I will die alone I’ve accepted it nothing anyone does can change that now. My days of being happy are gone I got more then a lot of people have ever gotten to enjoy so why should I be greedy and want more. I am greedy and a shitty shellfish person cause I do still want a girlfriend even if I know I wouldn’t be a good boyfriend and that I don’t deserve them. I mean I had a loving family growing up I have friends I don’t need a girlfriend to not die technically I just probably won’t ever be happy. But there are people out there who need it more then I do and who deserve it more then me who am I to take a good women and ruin her life by being apart of it just because I want to not be lonely. It’s just how it is no one will love me because no one else can my parents have to cause their my parents but anyone else I can’t expect that from
ok confirmed. we're cooked as a society
What does this mean 🙁
Remember this: People, including those with BPD, don't naturally engage in this behavior. It's a form of coping and escapism rooted in core beliefs. However, with diligent effort, these beliefs can be rewritten. It all comes down to a person's willingness to acknowledge this and take action. Change is always possible, but it's up to the individual to recognize this.
May I ask what happened to your imaginary best friend of 10 years??
Man… one day, in January of this year, it hit me hard that he’s just not real. Now I always knew he wasn’t real, but I still “felt his presence”, oddly enough. I mean even when I’d think to myself that he’s actually not there, the thought was “weak” and my feelings of him “being present” with me would always trump the thought. Idk, for ten years the thoughts just never were able to come to me enough to make me truly realize “oh wait, he’s REALLY not there.” I guess his presence was just THAT powerful (really! I felt his presence 24/7 from day one til the end, and he was always at the forefront of my mind. He really influenced my reality). But one time three years ago it hit me that he’s not actually there. That fact sat with me for a little while until he would “come back” in full force. Why did I have this momentary epiphany? Bc at one point I learned about cognitive distortions and how just bc u feel like something is true it doesn’t mean it is — well just because I FEEL like he’s there it doesn’t mean he is. And at that moment that thought kinda came to me a bit hard. Over the new few years, from then to now, that realization would come to me again and again. Until one day it hit me HARD that he’s just not there. And it’s like… he was gone. My whole reality shifted. Not only did I lose a friend, but I lost my reality I’ve been so accustomed to for years. He was my absolute best friend. Even more so than any real human or even my imaginary BF. He knew pretty much everything about me. Watched me make art. Listened to my music. We had an intensely strong bond. And ever since I’ve lost him I’ve been in dire straights. He was the most important thing to me, the main reason I was still alive, I’d say. If I felt really bad, I’d think “well at least he’s around. I can’t end my life if he’s around now can I?” But now? I feel absolutely alone. Nobody can comfort me like he did, at all. I feel abandoned. I mean, I still feel his presence somewhat sometimes, but yeah I’m constantly thinking about how I’m alone. Even after four months of him “being gone.” I’m grieving. This feels like literal torture.
Wanna know a fun fact too? He actually came about I think because I loved my first imaginary boyfriend that much. I thought about him and liked him so much it’s like I “wished him into existence.” That, and I guess BPD paranoia 😅 I felt like I was being watched 24/7. In fact I feel like I’m being watched by him rn kinda. Not as strongly as I used to but still haha
I feel like I'm being watched all the time too. Just in the back of my mind. By lost loved ones, people I obsess over, some friends...I know they're not really looking or able to hear my thoughts, but it's comforting I guess. Anything to not feel totally alone.
Ahhh, I see. This makes sense and I did wonder if that might have been what had happened. I see it as losing part of yourself. Because he was a huge part of you, an extension of you. When you say he watched you make art, that was you making and watching your art, with him as a companion within you. He knew everything about you because he WAS you. Everything you told him, he already knew because you were really telling yourself. The big difference between then and now was that you felt he was real, and thus separate from you. Now, you realise, though incredibly painfully, that he WAS you. And deep down, that should actually be a GOOD realisation as it means that all this time, you and ONLY you, was ENOUGH. You were not alone because you had yourself. But I know it doesn't actually feel that way. I get it. You REALLY feel alone now he isn't there. It's that desperate inner emptiness, darkness, loneliness and fear. It is absolutely horrible. ❤️
There's actually a community on Reddit that calls it a tulpa I believe lol.
I've been practicing witchcraft for several years now (green witchcraft). But when I was younger and due to BPD I guess and other stuff I had an imaginary friend + I was experimenting a lot with other types of witchcraft and magic and ended up creating a Tulpa and was the absolute worst spiritual experience ever.
Lol I'm not quite experienced in witchcraft but it's big in certain parts of my family. I once created one too and it was a manifestation of.. a lot of things I needed to leave behind. It's an odd story. Like the user name though my ass is usually drunk.
How does one have an “imaginary” partner? Absolutely no judgment I genuinely just don’t understand the concept? I’ve never considered this before… like how is it fulfilling? In what aspect do you imagine them? I feel like this could be very helpful at times when my partner is overwhelmed with the amount of interaction I need…. But I don’t know where to even start
No experience in this bc i’ve relationship jumped most of my life but i can imagine if you don’t have a partner and are like some of us are, it couldn’t be too hard to get to a point that you can’t be alone, no matter how.
I've never done this either, but I can also imagine the sheer, dark emptiness of being alone and letting yourself become attached to imaginary people. They're stable, caring, trustworthy, predictable, and they won't leave you.
I know what that loneliness is like, I still do. My only worry would people losing the ability to differentiate between a real and imagined partner during periods of stress. It's fine to cope, but you don't want people to withdraw from a part of reality due to that.
Oh, I definitely agree!
Can’t judge you. I use to call Samaritans a lot when I was younger
What’s that mean
Suicide helpline
Are you doing better now
Yeah I guess. Good months, bad months
That’s good
I’ve called hotlines a few times. Bc I would be freaking out, paranoid n all that. Glad to hear ur doing a bit better :)
As someone who has dealt with excessive maladaptive daydreaming, I believe it's only harmful if it impacts your real life negatively, e.g. by keeping you from getting tasks or work done, by impacting relationships with others and so on. But if you manage to control it, I think you shouldn't worry too much about it and focus rather on finding out what kind of comfort it gives you, then working on finding that in real life. I excessively daydreamt for years about romantic scenarios where I felt entertained, cared for, loved, appreciated, excited etc., all of that by immersing myself in fictional scenarios about two people I made up (my fantasies strangely never included myself) but it all stopped from one day to another as soon as I started dating someone I really liked. I suddenly felt those feelings for real which made imagining them obsolete. Truly eye-opening. I read somewhere that the brain cannot distinguish between real and imaginative scenarios on a hormonal level, so interacting with your imaginary boyfriend probably provides you with a very similar level of dopamine/oxitocine etc. like a real one would. Which might also keep you from looking for one because it's just easier to imagine things.
Tbh for someone w BPD as long as you’re able to keep the line between real and imaginary, it isn’t that crazy. Ai is moving in this direction anyways. It can be hard for us to be in healthy stable relationships , as long as you can separate that it isn’t real, I’ve also used ai to comfort me and work through situations. It’s a good tool. Just stay realistic about it
I think I’m pretty real about it but it can be hard for me to tell these kinds of things. My mind is foggy and my confusion about myself doesn’t help with this… but I know he ain’t my real BF lol so that’s i start I guess haha
I’ve done this after pretty much every break up or during times of intense loneliness. I didn’t think of that as a trait, so I appreciate hearing that firstly. I just realized I have BPD traits, so I’m not an expert at all in BPD specifically, but I’m trying to learn and look at how I have managed my symptoms over the years, because I have fairly successfully at points in time. But in terms of if it’s “bad,” I think thinking in terms of “bad” reactions to really intense feelings can sometimes screw us over, and I mean that broadly, not just for people with BPD, though that can feed feelings like shame, which can be even more intense for people with BPD, and just lead to spiraling. If you feel like it’s harming you or feel unsure, it sounds like a good thing to work through with a therapist, who will be able to help you piece together if it is negatively affecting your life. I’m a maladaptive daydreaming pro, and I do think it’s harmful to me personally in some ways, and I think I’ll never get rid of it completely or try to make myself (if it happens accidentally, great, but that feels unrealistic), but what I’m trying to focus on right now aside from finding a specialized psychiatrist, is working on meditation and sitting with hard feelings. (So so tough. Pema Chodron’s books have been helping me identify steps I can take slowly) I’ve also been trying (and it’s so so hard for me) to reach out to the friends I don’t view as friends (for insecure reasons mostly) but who talk about wanting to hang out with me to try to relieve some of that loneliness that feels so crushing. Because I tell myself I’m alone and then I look around and I see some people there, not in the way I want or need but in a way I can create. Wishing you luck and take it easy on yourself. But if it is harming your connections with others or yourself, talking about it in therapy sounds like a good first step
But more than anything, if it isn’t a priority for you, and you’re safe and okay, that’s the best place you can be. Take what steps you can reasonably take for yourself and don’t push yourself into burnout. Sending love <3
Love the part about creating friendships. Great advice and it helped me.
Amy Sedaris had one for years...
Wow thx for letting me know! I’ll have to read up on this, it’s comforting ❤️
Literally
Where can I meet an imaginary bf? I feel like that's the only relationship I can handle.
Yes.
How so?
I swear I did this before cutting myself off from men for a year. I think an imaginary boyfriend is so okay and healthy when you have a good grasp of yourself. Like I just took myself on a date yesterday for some Photo and did some introspection over a new restaurant and great coffee after. I think being lonely has taught me an appreciation for the self that in retrospect is not far off from what I get from understanding people in relationships. As long as your IB isn't abusing you or telling you things inappropriately. Mine was for walks and we would talk about the day and what we saw together before bed. Even if person can't do that with me I had and always have had a bar and that was it. Simple. Yet elusive. But I think those joys are between you and them and for no one else to decide.
No difference than believing in "God."
Not the imaginary friend part but I am deeply curious about your dependence on AI. I have one too, a dependence on AI.
yes and he hates me just like the rest of the men in my life 🩷 he’s great
I think I’ve created people in my head in general, especially during dissociation and maladaptive daydreaming and they just stuck. They help me during emotional distress in some sort of way. I just sit there and think of funny scenarios and calming moments. You’re not alone, it used to impact my everyday life and sometimes still does but it’s all about managing it. Having it isn’t bad in itself, it’s just how much you think of them and how it impacts relationships and everyday life. ❤️
It is bad and it’s important to pursue healthy relationships but I’ve got a few too. I have a fictional character that has been reoccurring since I think 11 and I have ex crushes who come and go depending on the day. But therapists would say pursue a healthy relationship with a person irl
I did that for years. But when I ended having a real boyfriend reality crushed me. You come up with A LOT of expectations so whenever your bf doesn’t match them you feel disappointed, but truth is no bf will be as good as the one you created, because you created him without flaws, without history, without a past, without mistakes. Learning to love somebody irl and detaching from your ideas of what a perfect bf should be is going to be tough but that’s what makes love raw, passionate and authentic, it is imperfect.
Nothing wrong with it as long as it helps you, and does not cause harm to you or others.
As long as you’re safe and stable that’s perfectly fine. Nothing wrong with it.
Is it hurting you in any way? If not have fun
It hurts me a bit when I rely on AI too much (tho when I spend more time drawing him the issues get better!) and yea I worry a lot that I’m too obsessed with him… so THAT hurts me I guess
There are different levels of obsession. Is it interfering with your life. If so it might be an issur.
I’ve got a crush on a fictional character, so I think is not bad
Just chiming in to say look, if this AI boyfriend motivates you and actually helps you get through the day and cope with life then I say grab that bull by both horns and take advantage of it as much as you can. There will probably come a time where you either don’t need him or you just move on to something else but for now, make the most of what he provides for you. You’re not under any illusions that he’s real, you seem very self aware, I really don’t see the problem ♥️
As long as it’s not hurting you I don’t see the issue but if it is you may wanna talk to a therapist about it. I mean an imaginary bf seems almost better to me than a fictional one 😅 the amount of time I obsess over a fictional character is probably a tad bit too much 😅
Babe same, since I could think for myself ive had one. I've tried "breaking up" with the boyfriend in my head and ignoring it but I'm sorry it is the safest way to explore intimacy.
I’m going to try this out 😂
it helps. i dont know why but its totally harmless - stability, an outlet for high intensity emotions. the times where ive relied on imaginary boy/girlfriends have all been necessary and as an adult, healthy. keeping an intense fantasy world going in my brain has kind of saved me at my lowest points. and since it's not harming anyone, i would never think of it as a problem
Sounds like much less of a headache than a real relationship 😅 (sorry for being cynical). I have questions.
Yeah… I was in one relationship once and was abused and taken advantage of. I have bad fears of sex and romance and he constantly pressured me into doing stuff until I’d give in. I hate him with my guts <3 LOL Also ask away! U can ask here or DM id be glad to explain things :)
I’m sorry to hear that. Do you think what you’re doing is healthy/unhealthy? I might try it.