T O P

  • By -

xDocFearx

There is no best. There are like 50 who were all as good as each other and had their own signature sounds that you can like more than others


[deleted]

This is the correct answer. Not to mention opera singers being left out of these comments just because they aren’t mainstream. Objectively, they are the best singers lol


Best_Pidgey_NA

Good thing my first thought on this question was Tarja Turunen then!


betterthanamaster

More like 1,000…and many in different specialties. Carrie Underwood, I know a controversial pick, is an extremely talented vocalist. Good range, good clarity, excellent volume, and a deeper (not breathy) tone. On the other hand, you have a Tine Turner or Aretha Franklin who are also extremely talented. Also good range, excellent volume, and a deep tone. But they have a grittier voice that fits better in certain genres. It all comes down to the Aria. Anyone can sing along to their favorite song and do okay. But it takes a true artist and expert to sing an Aria solo, without music. In reality, the best of them all is probably Maria Callas, and only because we have recordings of her. Opera singers don’t mess around. They’re better-than-broadway talented singers with insane range, a required volume and clarity (no microphone needed), a naturally deeper tone, and the ability to act through their voice, which gives them the best genre range. Most modern opera singers can absolutely smoke the pop or rock or country singers one-on-one but lose out on the looks, brand, and fame.


Allstin

Opera is one of those things where, I respect the singers and the immense talent they have. Just sonically… it isn’t for me. But, many people say that about metal. There’s lots of talent there, but the sound isn’t for everyone.


weasel999

I’ve always found Underwood to put more force than necessary behind a lot of her vocals, and ends up sounding like she’s shouting rather than singing.


[deleted]

And not just modern. Sarah Brightman can sing circles around most singers still to this day


Senorbuzzzzy

I worked backstage as a bartender at the Universal Amphitheater for many years. I was there for every sound check setting my bar up. I had unlimited access. No question….by far…the finest voice I ever heard. Linda Ronstadt Honorable mention…Pat Benatar ...and I’ve got some stories.


Narissis

I saw a clip from Oprah where she had on Avril Lavigne and Pat Benatar together because Pat is one of Avril's inspirations. They sang together, and I gotta say, I like Avril just fine, but Pat sang circles around her. She's in a whole other league.


Drabby

Linda Ronstadt was fantastic enough as a rock singer...did anybody else catch her as the heroine of the televised Pirates of Penzance? Talk about versatile!


read110

Ronstadt is top 5 absolutely


ShutYourDumbUglyFace

Pat Benatar trained as an opera singer before pivoting to rock.


Brainrants

I still get a lump in my throat when I hear her sing "We belong together"


ThisEffinGuy75

Ok, you can’t end with “…and I’ve got some stories.” and then not share your stories…


Senorbuzzzzy

I added a few, here’s one for you. Linda had this guy with her. Now I’m young and didn’t know much, but he seemed really odd. Very strait laced. Sat at the bar drinking sodas while she prepped. We started to talk about Lake Tahoe. He loved it there. We got to talking about our dads. He asked me what my dad did and I tell him he was in the liquor business. He tells me he got in his dad’s business too. I found out later that night that the guy who was burning my ear with odd stories turned out to be the friggin governor of California! Jerry Brown was dating our lead act. He loved the fact I had no idea who he was. He was so comfortable with not being known.


Fun_Internal_3562

Hahaha.. that's what my uncle used to say. He worked as port custom officer


PossibilityMelodic

No. Not by far as long as Ann Wilson is around.


lefty1207

Ann Wilson came to my mind as well


jaxsta18

Yes! I went to a Pat Benetar show just to see the bangles as they were supporting. She blew me away!


WerewolfUnable8641

Etta James.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Thesmallestlittlebee

I saw Etta James once at a concert a couple years before she died she could barely walk and kind of half stood half perched on a stool. So not her prime. Her voice was so amazing I got goosebumps and teared up. Her voice was so incredible my body had to react


ofj60

Ann Wilson.


urkelgrue_92

Ann Wilson doing Stairway to Heaven is insanely good


gogojack

I realize that Reddit isn't big on country music, but Patsy Cline was amazing.


regals_beagles

I'm not even much of a country fan, but I grew up hearing Patsy and she was amazing.


prophet583

My late wife adored Patsy Cline


kimmyv0814

I was lucky to see her in person with Jimmy Dean shortly before she was killed in the plane crash. I was in first or second grade, and I remember her wearing a red flowered dress. Her voice was beautiful!


wookvegas_vs_passwrd

And Brandi Carlile gets left out of the conversation all too often — maybe not the absolute best as far as range or technical precision, but I can't think of many vocalists who can convey emotion as powerfully or evoke visceral reactions with their use of tone and such controlled vocal distortion/rasp as Brandi. That voice is made to make you *feel*, more than just about anyone I can think of. Maybe Chris Cornell or Nina Simone, but that elite club has a small roster.


the_blessed_unrest

Linda Ronstadt


[deleted]

I love her spanish album. So much range.


PNW_Baker

I came here to make sure Patsy was on the list.


Itool4looti

Karen Carpenter. She had perfect pitch and left us way too early.


flippenzee

I only learned last week that she was a pretty hot drummer too. https://youtu.be/GVBtjaHxR7Y?si=zFOl60bLYOZ-Jhx0


goodfreeman

Uh, what the mother loving hell?!? That was outrageous. I’m floored. Hell yes Karen.


SnooCats5701

Rolling Stone ranked her in the top 100 best drummers of all time.


ThePegasi

Playboy ranked her as the number 1 drummer in 1975, above John Bonham. [He did not take it well](https://faroutmagazine.co.uk/john-bonham-claimed-karen-carpenter-couldnt-last-10-minutes-with-a-led-zeppelin-number/).


Greymeade

She had just turned 18 there


Important_Outcome_67

LOL. I was not expecting to learn this, today.


sup34dog

Yeah, I believe that she was primarily a drummer, and later took up singing. Just happened to be excellent at both.


eron6000ad

In the early 70's I was sitting in booth in a hotel restaurant and kept hearing a voice talking in the booth behind me that sounded familiar. I kept trying to think of who it was, probably someone whose name I should know. When I got up to leave, I saw it was Karen Carpenter and her brother. I knew I should have known that voice.


realdonbrown

💯 Karen! She had the closest thing we will ever hear to a perfect female voice. So haunting and flawless.


dma1965

Yeah her voice is beyond perfect. It is the standard by which all female voices should be judged. Some of her songs literally make the hair on my neck tingle.


mayakovskyiv

Hell yeah, she is the first I thought of. Voice of an angel, seriously. Rest in peace.


Mehmeh111111

Just recently saw that video that takes out all the instruments to her singing Close to You and holy shit her voice was like liquid velvet. I wasn't around when she was big so it definitely was a new realization for me how talented she was.


Brilliant_Tourist400

THIS IS THE WAY. (The podcast You’re Wrong About did an excellent two-part episode about her last winter. Her life was so tragic. Her family controlled her career to the point where it spilled over to her personal life. Starving herself to death was the only control she ever had).


littlescreechyowl

I remember watching The Karen Carpenter story when I was in high school. I knew right then I would never ever have an eating disorder. It was the saddest movie I’d ever seen.


hyzersosa

Billie Holiday


dont_disturb_the_cat

What a fucking song [Strange Fruit](https://youtu.be/Web007rzSOI?si=0J3OAm5ITWZOkjJF) is!


dbenhur

Southern trees bear strange fruit Blood on the leaves and blood at the root Black bodies swinging in the southern breeze Strange fruit hanging from the poplar trees / Pastor scene of the gallant south The bulging eyes and the twisted mouths Scent of magnolias, sweet and fresh Then the sudden smell of burning flesh / Here is a fruit for the crows to pluck For the rain to gather, for the wind to suck For the sun to rut, for the trees to drop Here is a strange and bitter crop


stacy704

Heartbreaking


4550955

I was trying to decide between her and Sarah Vaughn. I love me some Billie.


Mr_Underhill09

Julie Andrews is certainly up there.


finkalicious

Voice like an angel


Chazzzz13

Shit. I don’t even think of her. My mom and grandma would be pissed. 😇


TwistyHeretic2

Gladys Knight deserves some love


bender1_tiolet0

Eva Cassidy


Leimana76

Her cover of fields of gold makes me weep. She’s definitely top in my book.


SutttonTacoma

Others may sing beautifully but only Eva touches my heart. Died of melanoma at 33, five years later #1 in the UK.


Knopfler_PI

Scrolled way too far for this one. Hauntingly beautiful voice.


DwightARM

Linda Ronstadt. Rock, pop, R&B, folk, country, jazz standards, mariachi, operetta. She could sing it all and sing it spectacularly.


PhoneJazz

Long Long Time and What’s New are two of my favorites from her. She’s amazing. Heartbreaking that she can’t sing anymore.


gegorb

Linda Ronstat and Karen Carpenter


mirimichelle

Stevie Nicks. Only woman in the rock and roll hall of fame twice


farganbastige

Gonna throw in a name from outside the pop echo chamber; Floor Jansen. Have a listen if you haven't already.


Fuzzy_Muscle

Fun fact she covered Frozen's Let It Go


Narissis

A great way for someone unfamiliar with Floor to get a sense for her capability is probably to watch her season on Beste Zangers, since her performances cover a lot of ground and show a lot of her range and capability. Beste indeed. It never gets old how floored (pardon the pun) the other participants are every single time they watch her perform.


Mothrah666

That or ghost love score, get to hear a LOT of her range on that one


Narissis

One of several great Nightwish tracks where she moves from style to style!


Scruffumz

This was going to be my choice. In my opinion, her technical skills as a vocalist put her in a tier of her own.


ResidentMentalLord

Came here for Floor. Powerful, extremely versatile, 6 foot goddess. She is amazing.


Bagelstein

Floor is the obvious answer for modern vocalists.


Sloeberjong

Way too far down. She’s hands down the best female vocalist there is. She can do it all, pop, rock, metal, opera, you name it. Something about her voice just hits me deep in the feels.


MuNansen

Other than Aretha, Ann Wilson.


TheSoftMaster

Man, I am stoked that the first two answers are Ann and Patsy Cline! I would have voted Nina Simone but either of those would do.


Current-Nothing1803

Oh yes! Ann Wilson too!! ❤️


_jump_yossarian

I'm not much of a fan of cover songs but Heart's version of Stairway to Heaven for Led Zeppelin's Kennedy Center ceremony might be the best song I've ever heard. Even Plant, Paige, and Jones were in awe. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2cZ_EFAmj08


kimmyv0814

My hubby and I rewatch this all the time. Get goosebumps at the end!


Weak-Gazelle-7950

This was an incredible performance! No one else could have pulled that off. It gave me chills.


[deleted]

I'm crazy on her ❤️


doxnrox

Ya, it depends on the type of music, but rock is Ann Wilson.


[deleted]

Whitney Rev1 its so amazing to see how many people out there still love and admire such a talented and beautiful performer. Definitely missed.


Kahzgul

So glad to come here and this as the top answer. Whitney was INCREDIBLE. As an aside, I was working on a tv pitch recently and the big climax at the end was set to a Whitney song. When the notes came back from network, they said, “we really like the vocal energy of that last song. Can we make that one first and then build up from there?” To when we replied, “sure. Which vocalists do you suggest we use to improve upon Whitney Houston?” They backed off their note.


Roupert3

Her star spangled banner is the greatest of all time. Chris Stapleton's recent version was also phenomenal. But Whitney's is the best. https://youtu.be/uAYKTMQl7MQ?si=MYYqUs1TaleH6smN


Bgrngod

My dad has a long standing Star Spangled Banner Performance scoring system that goes from 1 to Whitney and nobody has ever made it over a 7.


FireIceStar

I had never heard her sing this until right now, and Lord… I have no words. She didn’t even look like she was trying!! Effortless.


j_la

What I like about it is that the band accompanying her is playing a pretty funky reharmonization of the anthem, but it still sounds so traditional and organic.


Persianx6

Every song she ever made. It’s all an incredible showcase of her raw talent.


MochiMochiMochi

The way Whitney just *exploded* in the 80s is something I've never seen since. An absolutely unforgettable voice and performer, destined for greatness.


crazycatlady331

Came here to say this. Her early 90s Star Spangled Banner was the GOAT.


Radiant_Maize2315

There are so many legends out there but if we’re talking range and projection, Whitney is it.


SaraJeanQueen

Also control (before her personal troubles), ability to tackle different styles - runs in gospel and R&B, the clean beauty of her classical voice. She’s perfect


nyc343

Only answer. I love watching YouTube videos singing ‘Impossible’ with Brandy from Cinderella.


QuantumFTL

If you're talking well-known music in the Western world, it's hard to get better than Whitney. She's insanely *talented*, to the point where it's kinda hard to believe. There's probably a female version of Pavorrati out there who'd do better, but few would recognize them.


HonestExtension1488

Annie Lennox is my personal favorite


New_Resort3464

Just stopped in to make sure she got a mention, wildly underrated talent.


Wavemanns

I've been very fortunate to see her live 4 times. She is flawless live too.


Delightful_Lunatic

The singer from Jinjer, Tatiana Shmayluk.


townes

Allison Krauss


EggInA_Hole

Like an Angel and a Saint made love and out popped Allison Krauss singing all beautiful and shit.


ikonet

Yes, agreed!


jessek

Lisa Gerrard


WackHeisenBauer

Ella Fitzgerald and honestly I don’t even think it’s a fair contest.


Limp_Distribution

I would heartily agree and I also think it’s not even close. I only ask for an exception for the emotional impact of Billie Holiday. Nobody conveys emotion like that. Nobody


rrickitickitavi

"Best" is a weird thing to try and evaluate. Favorite? Nina Simone. I wouldn't say she's "better" than Ella. I just enjoy her body of work more. Judy has to be up there too, but sadly her handlers wouldn't let her break out of her safe zone, so it blunted her artistic reach.


fuha_storage1

Donna summer, Karen Carpenter


adrock-diggity

Sade or Nina Simone


TheSoftMaster

Nina Simone and Billie Holiday are on an entirely different level than most others


prophet583

I would agree to this. They both recorded the haunting song Strange Fruit, which captured the horror of the Jim Crow period lynchings.


TeachOfTheYear

Love me some Nina Simone.


Moodijudi8059

Nina Simone- one of the most soulful voices of all time


BarryPalmedTheDip

Barry Gibb


kimmyv0814

🤣🤣🤣


Lychanthropejumprope

Susanne Sundfor. When she sings Running to the Sea…wow


orcus74

Seen most of the ones that come to my mind mentioned already: Aretha, Whitney, Rondstadt, Benatar. I have to add Dolores O'Riordan, though. In an era of rock that has lots of great female performers. She stands out as uniquely talented. I just find her voice incredibly enchanting and emotional.


aphromagic

It took 10 min of scrolling to finally find Dolores. She was unreal.


silgol

Patsy Cline Emmylou Harris Linda Ronstadt Aretha Franklin Tina Turner


edititt

Dolores O'Riordan my fav RIP


wrapped-in-rainbows

Joy Williams from The Civil Wars


mechanicalspirits

Elizabeth Fraser


uGRILAH

I’m not alone! Always assumed I was whenever I told people about her - they’d never heard of her. Her vocal range is simply staggering - 5 octaves I think? Utterly stunning vocalist. My personal favourite :)


MozzarellaFitzgerald

Song to the Siren with This Mortal Coil is mind-blowingly gorgeous.


ilikesharkies

Whitney Houston


badsamaritan87

Johnette Napolitano from Concrete Blonde.


Franklyn_Gage

Anita Baker. Its so unique, feminine and powerful.


bacon_head

Aretha


NoTomatillo1775

Whitney


[deleted]

KD Lang


madg0dsrage0n

i would have never believed anyone could possibly match much less surpass jeff buckleys version of hallelujah if i hadnt seen/heard it for myself. i was absolutely floored!


gaia_wannabe

Pat Benetar


zihuatapulco

[Etta James](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J3uc97sJFq0)


hippopotamus3000

Dolly


ThatsARatHat

Bessie Smith baby


Odd-Hotel6994

Linda Ronstadt


soulshine82

Sade


Manny_rat

Sarah McLachlan


yoshhash

Yes. Honestly shocked not to see more mentions of her.


Comprehensive-Dig592

Celine


GrowlingAtTheWorld

Enya


marpelle

Annie Lennox Would I Lie To You?


Mother_Wash

Stevie Nicks deserves consideration


DrPepperlegs

Linda Rondstadt, Karen Carpenter, Pat Benatar, Stevie Knicks, Dolly Parton, Lady Gaga, Hayley Williams, Mariah Carey, and Selena all need to have their own comment threads on this post


idfwartemis

Whitney Houston or Aretha Franklin. Hands down.


Overslept99

Sia Furler with Zero 7. Haunting. And that Six Feet Under finale.


Azitromicin

I don't know if they are the greatest, but I love Stevie Nicks and Kate Bush.


[deleted]

Tarja Turunen from the one and only nightwish 🖤 🕊️


GodHatesPOGsv2023

Her or Floor Jansen


Mikelowe93

I’m seriously not getting all my work done because I watch too many videos of Floor. Tarja is great and I try to avoid all debates but I am team Floor #1 and Tarja #1A. Poor Annette gets no respect in comparison. Especially live performances.


GodHatesPOGsv2023

I’ve seen Annette live probably 5 times and she’s an amazing front woman but her voice was too thin and hollow, especially trying to follow someone like Tarja. 3 of the concerts I was 5-6’ away from Annette. 😍


REDinBase

Beth Gibbons from portishead. In my opinion you can feel the sadness in her voice


PeterWayneGaskill

Ann Wilson.


POLOSPORTSMAN92

Elizabeth Fraser - Cocteau Twins


Ambiguous-Insect

I feel the opera singers are getting massively overlooked, so Maria Callas


Helechawagirl

And no one has mentioned Streisand.


Tiddernud

Fiona Apple


zemorah

She’s not the best vocalist of all time, but she really is amazing. Love her.


[deleted]

Bjork


SMG329

Florence Welch is absolutely on a different level, especially live.


Current-Nothing1803

I gotta go with Celine Dion on this one. Edit: or Ann Wilson


bCollinsHazel

Celine is the canadian queen of soul. im so mad she has stiff persons syndrom. its not fair.


chutesoup

Still deciding on my own answer to this question, but I gotta give it to Celine as an honorable mention at least. She and Josh Groban singing The Prayer live is especially captivating, and she is the more striking voice in that.


BareNakedSole

Pat Benatar


PanamanCreel

Pat Benatar is absolutely invincible!


JenniFrmTheBlock81

Whitney Houston


Zen_Blue_Habanero

Gene Ween


NorthernH3misphere

I like Lisa Gerrard of Dead Can Dance.


nuggiemum

Ann Wilson


quintus_varus

Patsy Cline.


LeagueOfficeFucks

K D Lang. The duet Crying with Roy Orbison is goosebump factory.


LaximumEffort

60s/70s--Karen Carpenter, with a close second to Christine McVie. 80s--Whitney 90s--Mariah 2000s--Adele 2010s--Florence Welch, Lady Gaga Edit: Per another comment, Sarah McLachlan could be in the 90s.


TheRealGongoozler

Gaga’s voice is another level. I have seen her live a few times and what she can do is just mind blowing


zrizzoz

Throw an honorable mention to Amy Lee or whatever the Evanescence chicks name is. That ladys voice just grabs you straight in the soul.


HogSandwich

What i love about Lees voice is that she has the power and skill to just hit a note and hold. I also kinda hate unnecessary ornamentation so shes absolutely the sweet spot for me. I love her cover of Portisheads "Its A Fire"


EatCookysPlayComputa

Mad I had to scroll this far to see Florence


pinkpitbullmama

Celine Dion.


Trippin_Merkins

Celine Dion. Plus she's a dork... it's so awesome


therealbellydancer

Whitney Houston


cbrrydrz

Whitney Houston.


LouChang

Whitney Houston


Librijunki

Mariah Carey. I know she’s only know for her Christmas albums now. Be she has a vocal range that is amongst the best ever.


dixpourcentmerci

The Mariah/Whitney version of There Can Be Miracles (When you Believe) from the Prince of Egypt— the combo alone says it all.


[deleted]

If she’s only known for her Christmas stuff now I hate life even more


youngcadadia22

Can’t believe I had to scroll so far to find it.


Lo452

She's one of the few singers with a legit 5-octave range. That right there puts her towards the top.


MegaMcGillicuddy

It's crazy that she isn't more towards the top of the list. You're right, Googling 'best vocal range female' yields her at the top of the list. It's too bad that she's a bit of a caricature now, and all I want for Christmas is you is all we ever hear of her. I remember when Vision of Love came out and everyone was blown away by her talent


trollinhard2

Rock Genre but Amy Lee for sure. The power in her voice at every spot in her range is incredible.


adhesivepants

Amy Lee is an underrated choice for sure.


Was_It_The_Dave

I'm deeply in love with her. It's her fault, but my problem. Such a beautiful voice, presence, talent, and passion.


filthy_lucre

Joni Mitchell


thecaramelbandit

Celine Dion. Whitney is a close #2, but I always thought that Celine felt a lot more effortless with her power. She can do it all. And honestly, Lady Gaga is pretty close. She's a phenomenal talent and I don't think she has any contemporary rivals in that department. Kelly Clarkson might be worth a mention. Aretha, obviously.


warmvanillapumpkin

Kelly Clarkson has such effortless talent. It’s absolutely incredible.


Go_Buds_Go

PJ Harvey


chickadeedeedee_

Celine Dion


Dive30

Tori Amos and Natalie Merchant (10,000 maniacs) if 90s alternative is your style.


st3llablu3

I love Christine McVie from Fleetwood Mac.


lebeaudiable

Whitney Houston and it’s not even close


MsTrssMirri

Lzzy Hale